Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1216

MOTION Samsung's Motion for Relief from Nondispositive Pretrial Order of Magistrate Judge re #1144 Order Granting-in-Part and Denying-in-Part Motionis to Strike Expert Reports filed by Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.. Responses due by 7/25/2012. Replies due by 8/1/2012. (Attachments: #1 Martin Decl., #2 Ex. 1, #3 Ex. 2, #4 Ex. 3, #5 Ex. 4, #6 Ex. 5, #7 Ex. 6, #8 Ex. 7, #9 Ex. 8, #10 Ex. 9, #11 Ex. 10, #12 Ex. 11, #13 Ex. 12, #14 Ex. 13, #15 Ex. 14, #16 Ex. 15, #17 Ex. 16, #18 Ex. 17, #19 Ex. 18, #20 Proposed Order)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/11/2012)

EXHIBIT 2

Disclosure of References Cited in the Expert Reports of Itay Sherman and Robert Anders
STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY

1988 U. of Illinois Apple
design contest Tablet



March 5, 2012 Deposition of Robert Brunner, Tr. 53:1-55:19,
Exhibit 2; Tr. 55:20-59:18, Exhibit 3;

(Sherman Report)



April 16, 2012 Rebuttal Report of Expert Peter Bressler
(―Bressler Rebuttal Report‖) at 50-51.

Apple “Brain Box” design



Letter from Zeller to Bartlett, dated November 1, 2011;

(Sherman Report)



November 8, 2011 Deposition of Douglas Satzger (―Satzger
Deposition‖), Tr. at 76:2-79:21, Exhibit 1175;



Samsung's Motion to Compel Production of Documents and
Things, Dkt. No. 487 at 18-19;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00354743—SAMNDCA00354746);



March 5, 2012 Deposition of Robert Brunner, Tr. 75:7-76:13,
Exhibit 1 at 144;



March 15, 2012 Deposition of Evans Hankey, Tr. 88:22-92:9,
Exhibit 2505 at 144;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 47.

KR 30-0304213



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00021593);

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



November 3, 2011 Corrected Notice of Prior Art, In Re Certain
Electronic Digital Media Devices and Components Thereof, Inv.
No. 337-TA-796 (―ITC 796 NOPA‖), Ex. F at 12, Ex. G at 12;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00021593).

U.S. D412,157



April 20, 2012 Deposition of Itay Sherman, Tr. 240:5-244:1,
Exhibit 17;

(Sherman Report)



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 16-18.

U.S. D500,037



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00027716-22);

(Sherman Report)



Samsung’s Eighth Set of Supplemental Responses to
Complainant’s First Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 33-38), In Re
Certain Electronic Digital Media Devices and Components
Thereof, (―February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36‖)
1

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY
at 149, 179;


March 7, 2012 Deposition of Sean Roarty, Tr. 20:2-36:18;
83:22-86:6; 141:10-153:9, Exhibit 2;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 13-16.



October 13, 2011 Declaration of Mark Tung in Support of
Samsung's Notice of Lodging of Materials in Opposition to
Apple's Motion For Preliminary Injunction (―Tung PI
Declaration‖), Dkt. No. 456, Ex. E;



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00019932-33);



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 149, 179;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 50-51.

D464,344



March 27, 2012 Deposition of David Bungo (―Bungo
Deposition‖), Tr. at 199:24-201:15;

(Sherman Report)



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 50-51.

D463,797



Bungo Deposition, Tr. 216:15-221:14.

(Sherman Report)



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 50-51.

Q72 iBook



October 18, 2011 Deposition of Brian Huppi, Tr. 15:17-9;

(Sherman Report)



Bungo Deposition, Tr. 202:15-210:14.

Tablet shown in “2001: A
Space Odyssey”



August 23, 2011 Declaration of Sara Jenkins in Support of
Samsung’s Opposition to Apple's Motion For Preliminary
Injunction (―Jenkins PI Declaration‖), Ex. D (Dkt. No. 179-4);

(Sherman Report)



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 14
(SAMNDCA00020130-32);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 50-51.



Jenkins PI Declaration, Ex. E (Dkt. No. 179-5);



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 14
(SAMNDCA00022514-16);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 50-51.



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 12;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 145-146,
176;

EU registered design
000048061-0001
(Sherman Report)

Tablet shown in “Tomorrow
People”
(Sherman Report)
JP D1204221
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

2

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY


Bressler Rebuttal Report at 25-27, 51-52.

D514,590



October 7, 2011 Deposition of Tracy-Gene Durkin, Tr. 333:19336:23, Exhibit 426

(Sherman Report)



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00023918-21);



February 15, 2012 Deposition of Christopher Stringer, Tr. 204:1212:1;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 3-4;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00023918-21);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 57-59.

iRiver U10



February 29, 2012 Deposition of Owen Kwon (iRiver, Inc.), Tr.
16:6-26:4, Exhibit 3; passim;

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



March 7, 2012 Deposition of Dong Hoon Chang, Tr. 29:9-30:10;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 142-143,
151, 173, 181;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 59-61.

KR30-0394921



October 7, 2011 Deposition of Tracy-Gene Durkin, Tr. 333:19336:23, Exhibit 426;

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 8;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00255305-11);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 69.



March 6, 2012 Deposition of Amy Leslie (Olympus Imaging),
Tr. 24:10-27:2, Exhibit 12;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 144-145,
151, 174-175, 181;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 69.

Nokia Fingerprint concept
phones images



Tung PI Declaration, Ex. J (Dkt. No 456-13);



(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

March 16, 2012 Deposition of Ricardo Vilas-Boas, Tr. 10:1120:23;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 146-147,

Olympus MR500i
multimedia device
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

3

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY
176-177;


Bressler Rebuttal Report at 54-57.

U.S. D497,364



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 141-142,
151, 169-170, 179;

(Sherman Report)



March 7, 2012 Deposition of Sean Roarty, Tr. 34:25-36:16,
Exhibit 1;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 69.



August 23, 2011 Declaration of Itay Sherman in Support of
Samsung's Opposition to Apple's Motion For Preliminary
Injunction ("Sherman PI Declaration"), Ex. EE (Dkt. No. 17231);



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 8;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00255357-65);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 62, 76.

Samsung F700 Handset



Apple’s Amended Complaint, Dkt. No. 75 at ¶ 80;

(Sherman Report)



Samsung's Opposition to Apple's Motion For Preliminary
Injunction (Dkt. No. 181a at 4, 14, 18, 45);



Jenkins PI Declaration, Ex. H (Dkt. No. 179-10);



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00198325-26);



February 23, 2012 Deposition of Greg Joswiak, Tr. 186:11189:5.



February 29, 2012 Deposition of Hyoung Shin Park, Tr. 8:216:15; passim



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 13, 16;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00198325-26);



March 2, 2012 Deposition of Min-Hyouk Lee, Tr. 68:15-73:1,
Exhibit 2114;



April 20, 2012 Deposition of Itay Sherman, Tr. 207:16-213:6;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 62.



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 12;

KR30-0452985
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

U.S. D560,192

4

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 62.

Documents labeled as
SAMNDCA00321457-656



April 20, 2012 Deposition of Expert Itay Sherman, Tr. 207:16213:6 (SAMNDCA00321552);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 62.



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00021315-19);



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 10;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 152, 182
(SAMNDCA00021315-19);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 65-66.



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 149, 179;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 66-68.

Samsung K3 MP3



March 7, 2012 Deposition of Dong Hoon Chang, Tr. 29:1930:10;

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 151, 181;



April 26, 2012 Deposition of Robert Anders, Tr. 84:18-22;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 68;

JP D1295003



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 10;

(Sherman Report)



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00256150-68);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 53, 68, 71-74.



March 15, 2012 Deposition of Evans Hankey, Tr. 167:20-170:9,
Exhibits 10 & 11;



April 15, 2012 Deposition of Steve Zadesky, Tr. 87:15-122:3;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 30;



May 2, 2012 Deposition of Shin Nishibori, Tr. 44:14-46:3.



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 30.

(Sherman Report)
EU Registration 0005691570005
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

U.S. D534,516
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

Sony Ericsson W950
Walkman phone
(Sherman Report)

Sony K800i
(Sherman Report)

5

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY

035 Proto



October 21, 2011 Deposition of Rico Zorkendorfer, Tr. 65:2369:22;

(Sherman Report)



October 21, 2011 Deposition of Daniele DeIuliis, Tr. 188:9 –
194:7;



October 24, 2011 Deposition of Matthew Rohrbach, Tr. 50:2467:10;



October 25, 2011 Deposition of Quin Hoellwarth, Tr. 136:22144:12; 157:11-167:20; 176:1-183:7;



October 27, 2011 Deposition of Daniel Coster, Tr. 30:22-33:3;
45:18-48:21;



October 31, 2011 Deposition of Richard Howarth, Tr. 107:20133:20;



November 4, 2004 Deposition of Christopher Stringer, Tr. 95:5100:18;



November 8, 2004 Deposition of Douglas Satzger, 36:24-40:5;



Letter from Zeller to Mazza, dated November 8, 2011;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 19 n.2.

U.S. Patent No. 504,889



September 15, 2011 Deposition of Itay Sherman, Tr. 214:15217:11;

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00200769-73)



July 26, 2011 Deposition of Richard Lutton, Tr. 95:10-96:15;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 4;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 129-130,
159-160;



April 26, 2012 Deposition of Robert Anders, Tr. 162:14-174:11;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 27-30, 52.



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 53.

KR30-0398307



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 127-128,
157-158;

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



April 26, 2012 Deposition of Robert Anders, Tr. 149:23-152:16;

Sharp Aquos Fulltouch
(Sherman Report)

6

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY


Bressler Rebuttal Report at 74-76.

Bluebird Pidion BM-200



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 126-127,
150, 156-157, 181;

(Sherman Report)



March 8, 2012 Deposition of Sungyub Lee (Bluebird), Tr. 12:2527:25, Exhibit 2208 (―Bluebird Pidion BM-200 Specifications‖);



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 146.



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 11.



Sherman PI Decl., Exs. J-K, Dkt. No. 172-10, 172-11;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 11;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 140-141,
168-169;



Bressler Rebuttal Report at 45-47.

JP D1250487



October 7, 2011 Deposition of Tracy-Gene Durkin, Tr. 333:19336:23, Exhibit 426

(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 11;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00255132-46).



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 150, 180.



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 5;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 1;

JP D1178470



Tung PI Declaration, Ex. I (Dkt. No. 456-12);

(Anders Report)



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 8;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 153, 183
(SAMNDCA00027686).

JP D128057
(Anders Report)
JP D1142127
(Sherman Report)
(Anders Report)

JP D1104685
(Anders Report)
U.S. Patent D532,791
(Anders Report)
U.S. Patent D333,574
(Anders Report)

7

STRICKEN REFERENCE

DISCLOSURES DURING DISCOVERY

JP 1241638



Sherman PI Declaration, Exs. P-Q (Dkt. No. 172-16; Dkt. No.
172-17);.

(Anders Report)



October 13, 2011 Preliminary Injunction Hearing, Tr. 39:11-15;
40:12-13; 41:21-15; 53:15-17;



December 19, 2011 Response to Interrogatory No. 12 at 11-12,
14 (SAMNDCA00255247);



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 11;



February 15 Response to ITC Interrogatory No. 36 at 133-134,
161-162;



April 6, 2012 Preliminary Injunction Appeal Hearing, Tr. 43:2044:17;



April 24, 2012 Deposition of Peter Bressler, Tr. 182:23-183:24;



April 26, 2012 Deposition of Robert Anders, Tr. 149:23-152:16.



Declaration of Roger Fidler in Support of Samsung's Opposition
to Apple's Motion For Preliminary Injunction, Dkt. No. 166 at ¶¶
13-15, Exs. I-L;



Sherman PI Declaration at ¶ 25, Ex. D;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 15;



September 23, 2011 Deposition of Roger Fidler, Tr. 26:14-40:18;



April 20, 2012 Deposition of Itay Sherman, Tr. 233:6-240:4.

HP Compaq TC1000



August 3, 2011 Deposition of Christopher Stringer, Tr. 266:18300:4, Exhibit 56

(Anders Report)



Sherman PI Declaration at ¶ 30, Exs. L-M;



ITC 796 NOPA, Exs. F-G at 15.

1994 Fidler Tablets
(Anders Report)

8