Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1236

Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Samsung's Objections to Apple's Exhibit List, Proposed Joint Exhibit List and Deposition Designations filed by Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.. (Attachments: #1 Trac Declaration, #2 Proposed Order, #3 Samsung's Objections, #4 Ex. A, #5 Ex. B, #6 Ex. C, #7 Ex. D)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/13/2012) Modified on 7/16/2012 Pursuant to General Order No. 62 attachment #1 Sealed (dhm, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT B

Exhibit B - Samsung's General Objections to Apple’s Proposed “Joint” Exhibit List

1


Samsung generally objects to Apple’s Exhibit List for all the reasons discussed in

 Samsung’s motions in limine, filed on July 5, 2012. Samsung also reserves the right to raise
 additional objections during the proceedings, depending on the manner in which an exhibit is
 offered into evidence.


Samsung’s Objection To Apple’s Failure To Submit A True Joint Exhibit List



The July 9, 2012 Minute Order and Case Management Order recognizes that the parties

 “agree to joint stipulated exhibits, such as accused devices and file histories, that shall not exceed
 60 exhibits total.” Despite this directive, Apple served a proposed joint exhibit list that contains
 physical exhibits selected by Apple (7 Apple products and 32 accused Samsung products),
 certified copies of Apple’s asserted patents and file histories for Apple’s asserted patents, but does
 not include any of Samsung’s asserted patents or the file histories for those patents. Even though
 the Court stated at the June 29, 2012 hearing that prior art could be placed on the joint list, Apple’s
 proposed joint exhibit list also does not include a single one of the prior art references that
 Samsung asked Apple to include on the joint exhibit list. Apple’s inclusion in its “joint” list of
 only exhibits it wishes to use at trial and its refusal to include exhibits requested by Samsung is
 contrary to the Court’s intent that the joint exhibit list contain stipulated exhibits and benefit both
 parties equally. In contrast to Samsung’s proposed joint exhibit list, there is nothing joint about
 Apple’s list and it should be stricken for this reason.











Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-1SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND
DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

Joint Trial Exhibit List
TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1000
1001
1002
1003
1004
1005
1006
1007
1008
1009
1010
1011
1012
1013
1014
1015
1016
1017

DEPO. EX.
NO.

DATE

1018
1019
1020

12/7/2010
2/2/2011
1/21/2011

iPhone
iPhone 3G
iPhone 3GS
iPhone 4
iPad
iPad 2
iPad 3G
Galaxy S (i9000)
Acclaim
Intercept
Galaxy S Vibrant
Galaxy S Captivate
Galaxy S Epic 4G
Galaxy S Fascinate
Transform
Galaxy S Mesmerize
Galaxy S Continuum
Galaxy S Showcase
500
Nexus S
Galaxy S 4G
Gem

1021
1022
1023
1024
1025
1026
1027
1028
1029
1030
1031

3/15/2011
4/5/2011
3/21/2011
4/15/2011
1/6/2011
2/1/2011
1/5/2011
6/2/2011
6/2/2011
1/26/2011
8/30/2011

Sidekick 4G
Galaxy Prevail
Nexus S 4G
Replenish
Droid Charge
Indulge
Infuse 4G
Exhibit 4G
Gravity Smart
Galaxy Ace
Galaxy S II (AT&T)

02198.51855/4858220.1

6/29/2007
7/11/2008
6/19/2009
6/24/2010
4/3/2010
3/11/2011
4/30/2010
3/23/2010
6/9/2010
7/7/2010
6/22/2010
6/17/2010
6/28/2012
6/28/2012
10/6/2010
11/6/2010
11/8/2010
10/6/2010

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

AS237
N/A
AS420
AS423
AS426
AS425
N/A
AS18
AS357
AS28
AS42
AS319
AS6
AS145
AS41
AS316
AS315
AS313

AS237
N/A
AS420
AS423
AS426
AS425
N/A
AS18
AS357
AS28
AS42
AS319
AS6
AS145
AS41
AS316
AS315
AS313

AS32
AS16
AS314

AS32
AS16
AS314

AS38
AS320
AS151
AS35
AS97
AS221
AS310
AS9
AS23
AS12
AS341

AS38
AS320
AS151
AS35
AS97
AS221
AS310
AS9
AS23
AS12
AS341

MARKED

ADMITTED

OBJECTIONS

402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3

402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3

MIL 3, not
disclosed as an
accused device for
the ‘381 patent

402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3

402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3
402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-2SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1032

DEPO. EX.
NO.

DATE

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

2/1/2011

Galaxy S II (i9100)

AS359

AS359

1033

10/12/2011

Galaxy S II (TMobile)

AS88

AS88

1034

6/8/2011

Galaxy S II (Epic 4G
Touch)

AS123

AS123

1035

11/6/2011

Galaxy S II
(Skyrocket)

AS117

AS117

1036
1037

9/17/2010
2/13/2011

AS192
203

AS192
203

1038

7/28/2011

Galaxy Tab 7.0
Galaxy Tab 10.1
(WiFi)
Galaxy Tab 10.1 (4G
LTE)

AS236

AS236

1039

7/22/2008

US Trademark Reg
for iPhone
Certified copy of US
D504,889, issued
May 10, 2005

APLNDCY0000182281
APLNDC00032467

MARKED

ADMITTED

OBJECTIONS

APLNDCY0000182283
APLNDC00032472

1040

Ex. 8;
Ex. 880;
Ex. 1036;
Ex. 1132;
Ex. 1174;
Ex. 203;
Ex. 430;
Anders Ex.
8;
Bressler
Ex. 3510;
Musika Ex.
7;
Sherman
Ex. 2"

02198.51855/4858220.1

5/10/2005

402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device
402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device
402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device
402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device
402, 403, U, MIL 3

402, 403, U, MIL 3,
not disclosed as an
accused device

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-3SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1041

1042

1043

1044

1045

DEPO. EX.
NO.
Ex.6;
Ex. 874;
Ex. 1790;
Ex. 205;
Ex. 426;
Anders Ex.
3;
Bressler
Ex. 3511;
Charmicha
el Ex. 16;
Godici Ex.
3;
Musika Ex.
6;
Sherman
Ex. 4
Ex. 577;
Ex. 415;
Kare Ex. 3
Ex. 1790;
Ex. 204;
Ex. 425;
Sherman
Ex. 3;
Bressler
Ex. 3512"
Ex. 1856;
Ex. 362;
Ex. 328;
Gray Ex.
12"
Ex. 109;
Ex. 120;
Ex. 2;
Balakrishna
n Ex. 2"

02198.51855/4858220.1

DATE

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

5/26/2009

Certified copy of US
D593,087, issued
May 26, 2009

APLNDC00030426

Certified copy of US
D604,305, issued
November 17, 2009
Certified copy of
D618,677, issued
June 29, 2010

APLNDC00030421

APLNDC00032478

11/30/2010

Certified copy of US
7,844,915, issued
November 30, 2010

APLNDC00025380

APLNDC00025432

12/23/2008

Certified copy of US
7,469,381, issued
December 23, 2008

APLNDC00022467

OBJECTIONS

APLNDC00030425

APLNDC00032473

ADMITTED

APLNDC00030441

11/17/2009

MARKED

APLNDC00022527

6/29/2010

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-4SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1046

DEPO. EX.
NO.

DATE

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

Ex. 572;
Ex. 611;
Ex. 741;
Gray Ex.
15;
Ex. 1006"
Ex. 93;
Ex. 405;

1/4/2011

Certified copy of US
7,864,163, issued
January 4, 2011

APLNDC00027870

APLNDC00024705

Ex. 330

11/30/2010

APLNDC00027081

APLNDC00027869

1049

Ex. 537;
Ex. 612;
Ex. 613

1/4/2011

APLNDC00022528

OBJECTIONS

APLNDC00025379

1048

Certified file history of
US 7,469,381, issued
December 23, 2008
Certified file history of
US 7,844,915, issued
November 30, 2010
Certified file history of
US 7,864,163, issued
January 4, 2011

ADMITTED

APLNDC00027921

12/23/2008

MARKED

APLNDC00024334

1047

Apple would agree to include the following exhibits requested by Samsung if the Court accepts over 60 exhibits on the joint exhibit list.
1050
1051
1052
1053
1054
1055
1056
1057

02198.51855/4858220.1

Apple iPad 2 3G (iOS
4.x) - AT&T version
Apple iPad 2 3G (iOS
5.x) - AT&T version
Apple iPad 3G
Apple iPhone 3G
(iOS 4.x)
Apple iPhone 3GS
(iOS 4.x or iOS 5.x)
Apple iPhone 4 (iOS
4.x) - AT&T version
Apple iPhone 4 (iOS
5.x) - AT&T version
Apple iPod Touch
(4th Gen.) (iOS 4.x or
iOS 5.x)

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-5SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1058

DEPO. EX.
NO.

1059

1060

1061
1062
1063
1064

02198.51855/4858220.1

DATE

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

MARKED

ADMITTED

OBJECTIONS

"File wrapper for
6,928,604 (including
file histories of U.S.
Patent App. No.
10/393,784,
09/282,851, Korean
Patent App. 199811380)
File wrapper for
7,447,516 (including
file histories of U.S.
Patent App. No.
11/148,181, Korean
Patent App. 10-20050037774)
"File wrapper for
7,675,941 (including
file histories of U.S.
Patent App. No.
11/417,219, Korean
Patent App. 10-20040042300, Korean
Patent App. 10-20040062190, Korean
Patent App. 10-20040073552, Korean
Patent App. 10-20040093947, Korean
Patent App. 10-20050029192)
File wrapper for U.S.
D504,889
File wrapper for U.S.
D593,087
File wrapper for U.S.
D604,305
File history for U.S.
D618,677

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-6SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

TRIAL
EXHIBIT
NO.
1065

DEPO. EX.
NO.

1066

1067

1068
1069
1070
1071
1072
1073
1074
1075

02198.51855/4858220.1

DATE

DESCRIPTION

BEGBATES

ENDBATES

MARKED

ADMITTED

OBJECTIONS

"File History for U.S.
Patent No. 7,456,893
(including U.S. App.
No. 11/167,851 and
KR App. No. 102005-0021335)"
"File wrapper for U.S.
Patent No. 7,577,460
(including U.S. App.
Nos. 11/493,754,
11/003,222, and
09/540,830 and KR
App. No. 199911179)"
File wrapper for U.S.
Patent No. 7,698,711
(including U.S. App.
Nos. 11/778,466,
11/390,338 and KR
App. No. 10-20050079921)
U.S. Patent No.
7,456,893
U.S. Patent No.
7,577,460
U.S. Patent No.
7,675,941
U.S. Patent No.
7,698,711
U.S. Patent No.
6,928,604
U.S. Patent No.
7,447,516
HP Compaq TC 1000
Fidler 1994 Tablet

Case No. Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
-7SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, PROPOSED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS