Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1322

TRIAL BRIEF Samsung's Unsealed Trial Brief and Exhibits Thereto by Samsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC(a Delaware limited liability company). (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Joby Martin, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Exhibit 8, # 10 Exhibit 9, # 11 Exhibit 10, # 12 Exhibit 11, # 13 Exhibit 12, # 14 Exhibit 13, # 15 Exhibit 14, # 16 Exhibit 15, # 17 Exhibit 16, # 18 Exhibit 17, # 19 Exhibit 18)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/25/2012) Modified on 8/7/2012 EXHIBIT 5, 6, 8 AND 11 HAVE NOT BEEN MANUALLY SUBMITTED TO THE CLERK'S OFFICE FOR FILING (dhm, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT 15

Subject: Fwd: Tablet Competitive Update July 7th, 2011
Date: Thu, 07 Jul 2011 23:24:27 +0000
From: "evans hankey" <[e-mail]>
To: "Eugene Whang" <[e-mail]>, "Shin Nishibori" <[e-mail]>, "Jody
Akana" <[e-mail]>, "Duncan Kerr" <[e-mail]>, "Danny Coster"
<[e-mail]>, "Rico Zorkendorfer" <[e-mail]>, "Daniele De Iuliis"
<[e-mail]>, "Peter Russell-Clarke" <[e-mail]>, "Bart Andre"
<[e-mail]>, "Jeremy Bataillou" <[e-mail]>, "Christopher Stringer"
<[e-mail]>, "Matt Rohrbach" <[e-mail]>, "Richard Howarth"
<[e-mail]>, "Jony Ive" <[e-mail]>, "Julian Hönig" <[e-mail]>
Message-ID: <[e-mail]>

Begin forwarded message:
From: Paul Meade <[e-mail]>
Date: July 7, 2011 4:15:20 PM PDT
Subject: Tablet Competitive Update July 7th, 2011
Quick competitive update:
- Most of the summers competitive devices are now available, see chart below for details.
(Samsung Galaxy 10 clearly the closest in reviewers minds).
- The HP TouchPad launched on July 1st to less than stellar reviews.
- The Toshiba Thrive will be available on July 10th.
- Attached the latest version of the Competitive Tracker.

HP TouchPad Highlights:
- 9.7" IPS display (very similar display module to K48), 1024x768
- Snapdragon APQ8060 dual core 1.2Ghz
- WebOS 3.0
- Front facing camera only 1.3MP
- Size = 240mm x 189mm x 14mm
- weight = 740g (1.6Ibs)
- 22.2Whr battery
- Has inductive charging coil built in to be used with optional TouchStone dock ($80)
- Initial reviews have been pretty harsh with weight (1.6Ibs) and sluggish OS being major
complaints. In our own testing, the display seems "dull" even compared to K48 and the
accelerometer/orientation control seems extremely "twitchy". In our video playback tests we
achieved 6hrs of playback (65% brightness).
- The SW itself is intuitive and easy to use but the glitches and sluggishness are hard to overcome
and the product feels it was shipped before it was ready.
- In the take apart it was clear there are provisions for a cellular model soon with plenty of space
for the cellular components.

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509486

- Available July 1st.

- the HP roadmap found on the web shows the 64GB and 4G Touchpad's coming next month
along with the 7" Opal in the Fall.

Toshiba Thrive Highlights:
- Available on July 10th.
- Comes in a 8GB configuration for $429
- Also has removable colored back covers for personalization
- 10.1" display, 1280x800
- Android 3.1
- Tegra2 with 1GB RAM
- 2MP F/F and 5MP R/F
- User replaceable battery
- Full sized SD and HDMI

Amazon Tablet Coming Soon?
- Probably the last of the summers competitive threats will be from Amazon. Its no secret that
they have been staffing up their local Lab126 development center and its likely to ship a tablet (or
tablets) in August/Sept.
- Amazon it likely one of the few potential competitors that have enough of the platform pieces to
mount an interesting offensive on the tablet front considering their brand loyalty, cloud services,
video streaming service, Android App store and its MP3 store.

Motorola Xoom
- Currently been discounted by $100 at BestBuy (32GB for $499)
- Also the original Xoom launch was 3G with the promise of a 4G upgrade by the end of June.
The latest word from Motorola is now the upgrade will be available by the end of Summer. This
must be infuriating for current shoppers especially with the 4G of the latest Samsung Galaxy 10.1"
now up for pre-order.

Samsung Galaxy 10.1"
- Now available for pre-order with 4G on Verizon, available mid to late August.

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509487

iPad makes up 1% of global web browsing:
- Report from NetMarketShare shows iPad is now responsible for 1% of WW web browsing.

Tablet App Stores:
- This week it was reported that the number of tablet apps in the Apple App store crossed the 100,000 mark.
- In comparison, CNNMoney reported that the number of Android Apps optimized for tablets was 1,345.
- WebOS on their launch day (July 1st) had a total of 300 (8,000 apps available for the Palm Pre but only
70% of them work and there is no magnify feature so you are stuck with the phone sized app on the tablet)

------ end message ------

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509488

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509489

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509490

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509491

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509492

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509493

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509494

K48/K48M

OS
Processor

K93/K94

Galaxy Tab

Toshiba Thrive

Vizio

iOS

iOS

Android 2.2

Android 2.2

Android 3.0

QNX

Android 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 2.3
(Gingerbread)

Android 3.0

WebOS 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 2.3

Android 3.0

WebOS 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 3.0

Android 3.0

H3P: A8 @ 1Ghz

H4P: dual core A9 @
1Ghz

Samsung
Hummingbird A8 @
1Ghz (1.2Ghz in v2)

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

Dell Streak 7

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

TI OMAP 4330
dual core 1Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz or 3D
version?

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz or 3D
version?

Snapdragon
Hummingbird
@1.5Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

APQ8060 1.2Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

1Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

APQ8060 1.2Ghz

Tegra T25

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

Nvidia Tegra2, dual
core @ 1Ghz

Moto Xoom

Playbook

LG G-Slate

Acer Iconia Tab
A500

ASUS Eee Pad

HTC Flyer

Galaxy Tab 10.1

HP “Touchpad”

Galaxy 8.9”

HP - “Opal”

Streak Pro

Sony S1

Sony S2

Lenovo ThinkPad

Fujitsu Q550

ViewSonic ViewPad
10 Pro

Windows 7 Pro

Windows 7 Pro

Intel Oak Trail 1.5Ghz Intel Oak Trail 1.5Ghz

ViewPad 7x

Dell Latitude ST

Android 3.0

Windows 7

Nvidia Tegra2

Intel Oak Trail 1.5Ghz

1GB?

1GB DDR2

2GB DDR2

2GB DDR2

9.7”

9.7”

7.0”

7”

10.1”

7.0”

8.9”

10.1”

10.1” IPS

7”

10.1”

9.7” XGA w/IPS

10.1

8”

8.9”

7”

10”

9.4”

pair of 5.5”

10.1”

10.1”

10.1”

1024x768 (4:3)

1024x768 (4:3)

1024x600 (10:6)

WVGA 800x480

1280x800 (16:10)

1024x600 (10:6)

1280x768 (15:9)

1280x800 (16:10)

1280x800 (16:10)

1024 x 600 (10:6)

1280 x 800 (16:10)

1024x768 (4:3)

1280x800 (16:10)

1024x768 (4:3)

1280 x 800 (16:10)

1024x768 (4:3)

1280 x 800

1280 x 800 (16:10)

1024 x 480 (21:9)

1280 x 800 (16:10)

1280x800 (16:10)

LCD PPI

132

132

169

133

149

169

167

149

149

169

149

132

149

169

182?

160

205

149

160

R/F Camera

None

HD, 720p 1MP

3MP (5MP in v2)

5MP AF

5MP

dual R/F 5MP
Stereoscopic

5MP

5MP AF

5MP AF

3MP AF

none

5MP

none

3MP AF

none?

yes

yes

yes

3MP

F/F Camera

None

VGA

1.3MP

1.3MP

2MP

3MP

2MP

2MP

1.2MP

1.3MP

2MP

1.3MP

2MP

VGA

2MP

yes

yes

yes

yes

1.3MP

Camera Flash

None

None

Led flash

no

dual LED flash

None

yes, LED

No

no

LED

no

None

LED

no

Video Recording

None

720p

720p

yes

720p

1080p

1080p, 720p 3D

?

720p

1080p

?

720p

1080p

?

1080p

1080p

Adobe Flash

None

None

Yes, 10.1

yes

Yes, 10.1

10.1

probably, 10.1?

10.2 after upgrade

10.1

10.2

yes

yes, 10.1

10.2

yes

32 GB

8/16/32/64 GB

16/32 GB

unknown

RAM
LCD Size
LCD Resolution

Internal Storage
Memory Slot
WiFi

256MB

512MB

16/32/64 GB

512MB

16/32/64 GB

16/32 GB

1GB

5MP

16GB

1GB

1GB

32GB

1GB

16 GB

None

None

uSD

uSD

uSD

None

none

802.11a/b/g/n

802.11a/b/g/n

802.11b/g/n

802.11b/g/n

802.11a/b/g/n

802.11 b/g/n/l

802.11 b/g/n

2.1

2.1 + EDR

3.0

2.1 + EDR

2.1 + EDR

2.1 + EDR

2.1

Sensors

Accel, Compass, ALS

Accel, Gyro,
Compass, ALS

Accel, Gyro,
compass, ALS

Accel, Compass,
GPS, Prox, ALS

Accel, Gyro,
Compass,
Barometer, Prox,
ALS

Accel

Accel, ALS, Gyro

Speakers

mono

mono

Stereo

Stereo speakers

Stereo Speakers

3 speakers

Bluetooth

1GB

16GB + web storage

?

802.11 b/g/n

16GB

16/32/64GB

uSD (up to 32GB)

uSD

802.11a/b/g/n

1GB

uSD (up to 32GB)

?

SD

802.11 b/g/n

802.11a/b/g/n

802.11b/g/n

802.11

2.1 + EDR
Accel, ALS, Gyro,
Compass, GPS

Stereo Speakers

512MB

3.0

2.1 + EDR

2.1 + EDR

Accel, Gyro,
Compass, Proximity

Accel, Gyro,
Compass, ALS

Accel, ALS, ?

stereo, SRS WOW
HD

Stereo (surround)

Stereo

?

30/62GB SSD
?

ALS, Accel

Stereo + SRS

3.0
GPS, Accel

Stereo

30 pin

30 pin

30 pin (HDMI, USB,
charging)

30 pin, SD

uUSB, HDMI

USB2.0 port, HDMI

mini HDMI, micro
USB

microUSB

30 pin (HDMI, USB,
charging)

microUSB

241.27 x 185.77 x
8.80mm

190 x 120 x
11.98mm

199.9 x 119.8 x
12.4mm

249.1 x 167.8 x
12.9mm

193 x 130 x
10.0mm

243.8 x 149.8 x
12.7mm

14mm

269 x 175 x 12.95

195.5 x 112.5 x13.2

256.6 x 172.9 x
8.6mm

241 x 190 x 13mm

?

167 x 205 x 12.2

680g (730g K48M)

612g (K94)

380g

450g

730g

400g

620g

725g

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

?

3G (HSDPA)

3G (HSPA or EVDO)

10h

10h

?

230.9 x 157.8 x
8.6mm

180 x 144x 13mm

USB, mini USB,
HDMI, SD

242.8 x 189.7 x
13.4mm

GPS
Cellular Options
Battery life claim
(Whrs)
Other

Apps

3G (HSPA or EVDO)
WiFi in Q1(?)
4G maybe in Q2?
7h

4G HSPA+
?

3G (EVDO); free HW 4G (WiMAx) in Q2
upgrade to LTE (VzW) LTE/HSPA+ in 2H11
10h

8h (20Whr)

>350,000 apps;
>60,000 iPad apps

>350,000 apps;
>60,000 iPad apps

WiFi only

9h

pair of 3260mAh
batteries, 8hrs

3D capture but
needs glasses for
playback

Getting a 5MP R/F
cam bump, new
processor & LTE in
v2 (Q2?)

Q2/2010 3G/WiFi

Q2/2011 - 3G/WiFi

Q4 2010 - 3G
Q2 2011(?) - 4G

Pricing

$499 - $829

-

$599

Feb 2nd, 2011
Mobile
$450

T- Feb 24th US - 3G
April 19th - WiFi
Q2 2011 - 4G (LTE) Q2 11-4G (WiMax)
March 27th -WiFi only 2H 11 - LTE/HSPA+
$799 (32GB 3G/4G)
$599 Wifi Only

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

$499 (16GB)
$599 (32GB)
$699 (64GB)

675g

421g

565g

725g

?

544g

470g

Yes (cellular)

yes w/WWAN

?

Yes

Yes (cellular)

yes

3G cellular options
available

WiMax

HSPA+ (21Mbps)

Summer (WiFi only);
3G & 4G models later

?

HSPA+ (21Mbps)

?

10h (22.2Whr)

USB, HDMI, SD/
SDHC. dock
?

?

Yes

8h

9.5hrs (24.4Whr)
- includes ASUS
webstorage
- Keyboard dock
accessory- DLNA

200,000 scaled
200,000 scaled
200,000 phone apps; Adobe AIR & Web 200,000 phone apps;
phone apps; handful phone apps; handful unknown 3.0 apps at Apps. Also supports unknown 3.0 apps at
of tablet apps
of tablet apps
launch
Android 2.3 apps
launch

Availability

USB2.0, uUSB, 3in1
SD card, uHDMI

yes (incl wifi)

4G w/T-Mobile
(HSPA+)

4h (14.8Whr)
- HTC Scribe (sold
sep) HTC Sense
- Includes Onlive
gaming
- dual mics for NC

10h (25.3Whr)

- Exchange
Activesync
- Quickoffice HD

8h
- “Touchstone”
inductive charging
- cloud storage
- Touch to share

?

10h

- replaceable battery - 4GB (2GB user
- 5 colors (rear)
avail)
- built in IR blaster
- multiple speakers
(x3)

200,000 phone apps;
200,000 scaled
200,000 phone apps; <10,000 phone apps; 200,000 phone apps;
unknown 3.0 apps at phone apps; handful unknown 3.0 apps at unknown Tablet apps unknown 3.0 apps at
launch
of tablet apps
launch
at launch
launch

- TouchWiz UI skin
- Exchange
Activesync
- Quickoffice HD

771g (30GB ver)

380g
3G

?

HSPA+

3G
8h
- 2 mics, 2 video chat - “quick and smooth
windows
UI”
- Dell “stage 1.5” UI - “swift” browser
- IR remote
- DLNA

19Whr ($729)
43Whr ($849)

- Playstation certified

- pen and digitizer
optional

Announced Apr,
available Fall 2011

Announced Apr,
available Fall 2011

?

preorder May 9th,
2011, ships June

- $599?

-$699

16GB, 32GB, 64GB

3500mAh (4.5hrs)

8h

- fingerprint sensor
- dual NC mics

- active pen support

$729 (30GB)
$849 (62GB)

200,000 phone apps; <10,000 phone apps;
unknown 3.0 apps at unknown Tablet apps
launch
at launch

20 Apr, 2011 (US TMobile)

April 24th, 2011

April via Best Buy

- WiFi only in April
WiFi - June 8th
- Summer with Sprint 5k given out at
- 3G in Europe
Google IO on 5/10

7/1 for (WiFi)
3G/4G later

Jun 13, 2011

pre-order 7/1,
shipping 7/18

“early summer”

Sept 2011?

$529.99 (with 2yr
contract and $100
rebate) $750 no
contract
Shipping

$449 (WiFi)

$399 (16GB)

(32GB)

$499 (16GB)
$599 (32GB)

8 GB
$429 
16GB $479
32GB $579

$379 (4GB)

$469 (16GB)
$569 (32GB)

?

$499 (16GB)
$599 (32GB)

up to 128GB SSD

802.11a/b/g/n

3.0

Dimensions
Weight

32GB

Accel, Gyro,
Compass, Proximity

Connectors

microUSB. miniHDMI,
microUSB,
charging port and microHDMI, charging
contacts
contacts

10”
1366 x 768

?

802.11a/b/g/n

2GB RAM
7”
1024x600

?

16/32/64GB
uSD (up to 32GB)
802.11b/g/n

yes, version ?

Accel, Gyro.
Compass, ALS

1GB?

?

Announced at
Computex

Oct 1, 2011

Announced

APLNDC0001509495

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509496

Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only

APLNDC0001509497