Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1387

Objections and Counter Designations to Apple's Corrected Notice of Amended Deposition Designations by Samsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC(a Delaware limited liability company) re 1294 Samsung's Objections and Counter Designations to Apple's Corrected Notice of Amended Deposition Designations (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A to Samsung's Objections and Counter Designations to Apple's Corrected Notice of Amended Deposition Designations, # 2 Exhibit B to Samsung's Objections and Counter Designations to Apple's Corrected Notice of Amended Deposition Designations)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/26/2012) Modified text on 7/27/2012 (dhm, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT A

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

7:10-13
23:25-24:4
31:24-32:23
44:17-20
44:22-24
45:1-5
45:8-10
50:17-51:8
51:23-52:4
56:19-57:1
57:3-4
58:4-7
62:3-6
62:9-10
62:17-18
62:20
81:15-82:7
82:10-17
82:20-83:15
93:20-94:4
94:6-11
94:14
95:18-96:2
96:5-13
97:12-13
97:15-17
98:6-8
98:10
100:20-22
100:24-101:4
101:7-8
101:18-21
101:23-24
104:8-105:12
109:22-110:1
110:3-6
116:9-14
116:17-19
117:21-118:2
118:11-20
118:22

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion

101:10-16
102:1-9

110:7-11
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
117:6-19

1

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Ahn, Seung-Ho
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)

3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
3/15/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

119:5-15
119:17-25
120:2-3
120:6-14
120:16-20
120:22-24
120:25-121:7
121:9-13
121:15-16
121:17-122.2
122:4-9
122:11-13
122:14-123:5
123:6-22
123:23-124:14
124:15-125:5
125:6-23
125:24-126:16
126:17-127:5
127:6-128:3
128:5-18
130:10-16
130:19-21
131:9-22
132:6-10
8:15-17
14:5-7
14:9-11
30:13-17

Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)

2/22/2012

30:21-25

Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

37:24-38:2
38:4-7
44:25-45:12
46:7-16
56:4-5
56:10-14
56:24-57:4
57:7-9

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

130:22-131:8

Narrative, compound,
ambiguous
errata 30:24 (should read:
"across all consumers because
it varies")
ambiguous

ambiguous, mischaracterization
errata 57:7 (should read:
2

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

59:10-14
60:1-61:4
61:13-16
61:24-25
62:2-4
63:6-8
63:11-13
64:2-3
64:11-15
65:6-8
65:23-66:1
71:1-6
73:20-74:2
102:13-117:10

Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Benner, Timothy 30(b)(6)

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

127:14-128:1
128:5-7
142:22-23
144:8-146:1

Chang, Dong
Chang, Dong
Chang, Dong
Chang, Dong

3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

8:15-16
11:3-13:14
40:21-41:7
46:14-104:9

Hoon
Hoon
Hoon
Hoon

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
"There are no numeric titles")

ambiguous

ambiguous

64:19-25
68:3-18

lacks foundation, legal
conclusion, ambiguous, beyond
scope of 30(b)(6), narrative,
vague as to time, speculation,
MIL 2

errata 104:3-4 (should read: "It
is my understanding that this
document is a SEC document
that included some input from
our product planning team at
STA"); 111:11 (should read "It
does explore options"); errata
113:19 (should read "it's a high
level document").
128:8; 128-10-11

MIL 2

errata 144:18 (should read
"Those who saw--is it a photo
array that"); errata 145:12
(should read "What they
thought, they said, was that it
was")

Incomplete

10:4-13:14

Asked and answered; Lacks
foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Assumes facts;
Misstates testimony;
Translation; Compound;
Argumentative;
Mischaracterization;
3

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

3/7/2012

147:6-165:22

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

167:3-177:5

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

177:9-179:3

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

179:5-181:8

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

184:8-188:4

Chang, Dong Hoon

3/7/2012

191:6-193:4

Chang, Dong Hoon
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin

3/7/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012

5:22-25
6:2-7
10:20-25
11:2-6
13:4-10
14:2-15
18:19-25
48:6-20

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Overbroad; 402; 602; 403;
beyond scope of designations;
Narrative
Asked and answered; Lacks
foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Assumes facts;
Misstates testimony;
Translation; Compound;
Argumentative;
Mischaracterization;
Overbroad; 402; 602; 403;
beyond scope of designations;
Narrative
Translation; Ambiguous; Asked
and answered; Compound;
Mischaracterization;
Overbroad; Privilege; 402;
Lacks foundation; Misleading;
Argumentative
Ambiguous; Lacks foundation;
Overbroad; Incomplete
hypothetical; Translation;
Mischaracterization; 402; 403
Translation;
Mischaracterization;
Ambiguous; Misleading; Lacks
Foundation; 402; 403
Lacks foundation; Ambiguous;
Translation
Translation; 403; 402;
Misleading
802; Lacks foundation;
Mischaracterization; 402; 403

104:17-139:9

Chang, Dong Hoon

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

193:10-194:8

602; hypothetical; speculation
4

48:21-23; 48:25-25

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cheung, Benjamin
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young

3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
3/28/2012
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011

58:5-25
59:2-25
60:2-5
68:8-15
75:4-25
76:2-25
77:2
77:5-9
77:11-17
78:9-25
79:2-3
80:2-10
82:18-25
83:2-3
84:2-19
85:20-25
86:2-25
87:2-25
88:2-4
91:24-25
92:2-18
92:20-25
93:13-25
94:2-25
95:2-25
96:2
14:9-13
14:15-16
16:17-19
24:16-25:6
25:8-17
31:6-25
33:3-5
33:12-20
94:19-22

Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young

11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

94:25-95:2
95:11-14
95:16-96:3
96:10-97:8
103:20-21

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
60:6-15

79:4-25
80:11-81:22

Ambiguous

25:7, 25:20-26:8
32:3-6

Misstates Testimony; Asked
and Answered

33:22-34:5
94:23-24

Ambiguous
Legal Conclusion
Ambiguous; Legal Conclusion
5

95:15

103:22, 104:9-17

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Joon-Young
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
11/30/2011
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012

103:23-104:8
118: 4-10
118:13-14
119: 2-6
119:15-120:8
125:10-15
125:17-21
134:9-18
134:21-135:6
136:18-23
136:25-137:9
6:20-10:2
22:20-24:14
25:22-27:1
27:21-28:8

Cho, Nara

1/14/2012

28:19-29:5

Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

1/14/2012
1/14/2012

30:11-31:3
33:11-36:25

Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

1/14/2012
1/14/2012

37:19-38:6
40:6-43:19

Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012

46:8-19
47:11-21
51:25-56:10
57:6-58:2
59:3-60:9
60:21-61:18

Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
1/14/2012

70:17-23
72:5-73:7
74:2-76:11
80:11-83:12

Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara

1/14/2012
1/14/2012

80:4-9
84:10-85:15

Cho, Nara

1/14/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

87:5-25

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Speculation; 701; Ambiguous

118:11-12

Ambiguous

125:16, 125:23-126:2, 126:5-7

Ambiguous; Legal Conclusion

134:19-20
135:8-14

10:7-9

Lacks foundation; assumes
facts
Lacks foundation; assumes
facts
Lacks foundation; assumes
facts; misleading; 602; 802;
1002; not testimony
lacks foundation; 602;
Speculation; 602; lacks
foundation

37:2-10

38:7-17

58:3-8
lacks foundation; 602;
lacks foundation; 602;
speculation; 802

61:22-62:6
70:25-72:3
73:8-9

assumes facts; speculation;
lacks foundation; 602
802; assumes facts;
speculation; ambiguous

6

85:16-86:16

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Cho, Nara
Cho, Nara
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
1/14/2012
1/14/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

89:11-90:10
91:21-92:15
11:11-13
13:1-6
27:15-22
28:1-29:3
29:22-30:19
31:7-15
32:4-9
32:12-18
35:2-3
35:6-15
35:18-19
38:18-24
39:7-8
39:10-15
40:6-15
40:20-25
41:16-20
41:23-25
43:13-17
43:20-21
47:11-12
47:14-19
52:9-15
53:4-14
53:17-22
54:16-18
54:21-55:5
55:8-14
55:17-24
56:2-5
56:18-19
56:22-57:8
57:11-12
58:3-14
58:17-20
58:23-24
60:19-21
64:9-10
64:12-16

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

29:4-11
30:25-31:6

incomplete

42:1-18
42:22-43:12
43:22-44:2
45:20-47:10
52:16-20

speculation; ambiguous
speculation; ambiguous

57:17-58:2
speculation

81:25-82:8
7

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

82:23-25
83:3-15
83:17-21
84:5-7
84:12-15
84:17-21
85:1
104:16-22
104:24-105:18
115:11-12
115:14-20
117:5-7
117:11-15
117:23-118:11
120:6-9
120:11-15
120:18-22
120:25-121:3
121:6-8
121:11-17
121:20-23
122:1-3
122:6-11
122:14-24
123:1-7
123:9-11
123:13-15
123:17-24
124:1-13
125:4-8
125:10-19
126:2-19
127:1-2
127:5-19
127:22-128:3
128:7-19
128:22-129:7
129:16-19
129:25-130:2
131:3-16
131:19-132:8

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

83:22-84:4

98:25-99:4
105:19-23

speculation; ambiguous
124:17-125:2

lacks foundation, speculation
lacks foundation, speculation

8

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho
Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012
2/19/2012

132:23-133:1
133:4-16
133:20-134:1
138:13-15
138:18-139:5
140:3-15
142:10-15
142:18-24
143:4
143:7-11
143:14-17
144:18-19
144:23-145:4
147:12-148:2
148:6-12
148:15-17
148:20-149:5
152:25-153:4

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

153:9-153-15

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

154:7-8

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

154:11-22

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

154:25-155:1

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

156:18-19

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

156:22

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

157:18-19

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

157:22-24

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

158:7-19

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

160:20-23

Choi, Sung Ho

2/19/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

161:2-9

02198.51855/4877234.1

speculation
speculation
speculation
speculation
speculation
speculation
speculation
legal conclusion

401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
legal conclusion; 401/402
(patent no longer asserted)
401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
401/402 (patent no longer
asserted)
speculation; 401/402 (patent
no longer asserted)
speculation; 401/402 (patent
no longer asserted)
speculation; 401/402 (patent
no longer asserted)
speculation; 401/402 (patent
no longer asserted)
speculation; 401/402 (patent
no longer asserted)
9

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

145:5-9

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Choi, Sung Ho
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung

2/19/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012

143-20-22
6:10-13
29:20-25
35:12-36:1
37:22-24
38:1
38:12-40:10
40:13-18
40:22-41:3
41:5-17
41:21-42:3

Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung

3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012

45:9-12
45:15-19
56:18-25

Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Chung, Minhyung
Conley, Cira
Conley, Cira
Conley, Cira
Conley, Cira

3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
4/13/2012
4/13/2012
4/13/2012
4/13/2012

86:14-25
98:11-19
99:5-7
99:9-100:5
100:7-15
101:21-23
102:1-8
106:15-25
107:9-15
107:18-108:3
108:6
109:18-110:15
110:17-24
111:1-9
112:6-11
112:14
112:16-19
8:5-12:19
13:1-9
13:16-14:14
21:3-26:11

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

28:15-31:11

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

33:17-34:3
36:9-37:4
legal conclusion
legal conclusion

42:12-20, 43:6-8, 43:10-13,
43:23-44:12
45:21-46:1
54:11-19, 55:8-13, 55:22-56:5,
58:6-15, 59:16-24, 60:11-14,
63:19-22, 64:6-10, 64:21-65:1

ambiguous
103:5-104:2, 104:9-105:1
mischaracterization

602, ambiguous, speculation
ambiguous
602, ambiguous, speculation
602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading, lacks foundation
602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading
10

12:24-25
12:24-25
12:24-25, 38:4-12, 55:24-56:7,
65:22-66:1, 72:9-18,
12:24-25, 38:4-12, 55:24-56:7,
65:22-66:1, 72:9-18,

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

32:23-38:3

602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading, lacks foundation

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

38:13-41:5

602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading, not testimony

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

41:14-43:15

602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

44:1-49:7

602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading

Conley, Cira

4/13/2012

50:3-52:19

602, ambiguous, speculation,
misleading

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012

9:21-10:24
11:3-13
12:16-23
13:7-10
13:24-14:7
14:13-15:10
15:16-22
17:10-20
18:8-19:17
22:5-22
23:10-24:9
24:24-25:3
25:14-21
28:15-29:1
29:8-13
40:23-41:1

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012

40:3-6
40:12-15

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

45:9-46:8

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
12:24-25, 27:17-28:1, 38:4-12,
46:12-17, 49:8-11, 53:2-7,
55:24-56:7, 65:22-66:1, 72:918,
12:24-25, 27:17-28:1, 38:4-12,
46:12-17, 49:8-11, 53:2-7,
55:24-56:7, 65:22-66:1, 72:918,
12:24-25, 27:17-28:1, 38:4-12,
46:12-17, 53:2-7, 55:24-56:7,
65:22-66:1, 72:9-18,
12:24-25, 27:17-28:1, 38:4-12,
46:12-17, 49:8-11, 53:2-7,
55:24-56:7, 65:22-66:1, 72:918,
12:24-25, 27:17-28:1, 38:4-12,
46:12-17, 49:8-11, 53:2-7,
55:24-56:7, 65:22-66:1, 72:918,
11:24-12:1

402
lacks foundation
lacks foundation; 402
402
lacks foundation; 402
lacks foundation; 402
lacks foundation
lacks foundation; 402
lacks foundation; 402
lacks foundation
lacks foundation
lacks foundation; ambiguous

14:8-12

17:21-24
24:10-14
25:22-24
29:2

lacks foundation, 402, 602,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
1002, ambiguous, asked and
answered
11

40:16-22
45:1-6

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

52:5-54:9

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

54:12-16

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

55:10-24

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

57:6-58:5

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

58:25-59:23

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

63:15-24

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012
1/25/2012

68:7-14
72:17-21
73:1-10
74:9-11
78:3-9

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

83:1-7

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

83:10-13

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

95:1-4

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

96:15-23

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

96:8-11

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

98:18-99:24

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

102:2-103:12

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

103:24-105:8

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

108:19-109:1

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, speculation,
asked and answered
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, speculation,
asked and answered
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, speculation,
asked and answered
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602
lacks foundation, 402, 602
lacks foundation, 402, 802 1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, mischaracterization,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, assumes facts,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
12

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

54:17-21
55:5-9
55:25-56:10

58:19-24
59:25-60:4
62:8-13
68:17-20

73:14-24
74:15-24

83:20-21
95:25
96:5-7

100:15-21

103:13-15
103:18-23
105:9-13

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

1/25/2012

113:4-13

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

114:9-115:1

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

119:18-120:2

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

120:23-121:2

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

120:4-15

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

121:24-122:12

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

137:13-18

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

140:22-141:21

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

142:25-143:20

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

142:4-22

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

146:18-19

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

147:1-4

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

148:22-150:24

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

151:18-152:16

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, misstates
testimony
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization, misstates
testimony, asked and answered
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous,
mischaracterization, misstates
testimony , asked and
answered
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, compound

108:7-14

Denison, Justin

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

155:22-156:5

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
13

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

113:17-25
114:1-8

121:7-10

137:11
140:17-21

143:24-144:4

146:21-23

147:13-15
148:6-15
151:8-11
147:12-17
152:23-153:4
155: 6-11

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012

157:1-6

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

159:23-177:12

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012

177:20-24
178:8-22

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

179:9-18

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

182:3-24

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012

184:22-185:3
187:2-6

Denison, Justin
Denison, Justin

1/25/2012
1/25/2012

187:8-12
202:3-25

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

203:8-17

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

210:8-16

Denison, Justin

1/25/2012

213:17-214:3

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

6:10-18
13:5-34:23

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

38:5-39:10
39:21-40:7
42:4-46:10
46:22-47:1

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous, assumes
facts, compound, asked and
answered, mischaracterizes

157:11-18

Denison, Justin

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

46:15-20
46:12-13

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation, 402, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, ambiguous
lacks foundation
lacks foundation, 402, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, assumes facts,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 602,
ambiguous, speculation

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
155:12-19
157:7-10
157:24-158:2

178:25 - 179:5
180:11-13
182:25-183:3
187:24-188:4

210:17-19
210:21-23
211:14-21

Ambiguous; Assumes Facts;
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Compound; Asked and
Answered
Assumes facts
Ambiguous
Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered
Ambiguous
Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered
14

47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12
47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12
47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12
47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

47:4-10

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

47:13-14

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

49:13-51:17

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

51:20-25
52:22-53:3
56:22-24
57:2-7
62:25-63:3

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

62:20-22

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

71:2-73:2

Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered; Incomplete
Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered
Ambiguous; Misstates
Testimony; Asked and
Answered; Beyond Scope of
30(B)(6)
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6)
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous; beyond Scope of
30(B)(6); Lacks Foundation
Ambiguous; beyond Scope of
30(B)(6); Lacks Foundation
Ambiguous; Compound

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

75:24-76:22

Ambiguous; Compound

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

77:1-3

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

77:8-10

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

77:13-15

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

77:5-6

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

78:2-12

Ambiguous; Assumes Facts

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

80:19-86:17

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

88:12-90:6
91:3-8

Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered; Incomplete;
Speculation
Ambiguous; Assumes Facts

02198.51855/4877234.1

15

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12
47:16-48:17; 48:20-49:12

63:5; 63:8-16; 63:19-22; 65:911; 65:14-22
63:5; 63:8-16; 63:19-22; 65:911; 65:14-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22
73:21-25; 74:3-4; 74:17-20;
74:23; 75:3-6; 75:9-11; 75:1316; 75:19-22

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

92:1-16
93:1-9
96:8-106:24

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

110:22-111:1

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

110:7-19

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

115:20-24

Translation
Translation; Speculation
Translation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; beyond Scope of
30(B)(6); Misstates Testimony;
Mischaracterization; Assumes
Facts; Asked and Answered;
611c; Argumentative
Misstates Testimony;
Misleading; Asked and
Answered
Misstates Testimony;
Misleading; Asked and
Answered
Translation; Misleading; 611c

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

115:10-13

Translation; Misleading; 611c

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

115:16-17

Translation; Misleading; 611c

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

120:9-25

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

120:4-7

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

120:1-2

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

121:2-8

Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

122:2-19
128:22-129:13

Asked and Answered
Ambiguous; Assumes Facts;
Mischaracterization; Misleading

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

129:16-130:7

Ambiguous; Assumes Facts;

02198.51855/4877234.1

16

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
93:10-14; 94:12-96:6
93:10-14; 94:12-96:6; 106:25107-25

106:25-107-25

106:25-107-25

111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
111:3-115:5; 115:8; 115:25116:4; 116:7-19; 116:22117:10; 117:13-119:5
122:21-124:8; 124:10-124:22;
125:4-10; 125:13-22; 125:25126:17; 126:20-127:7; 127:10128:10; 128:14-128:21; 151:524
122:21-124:8; 124:10-124:22;

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS
Misstates Testimony;
Mischaracterization; Misleading

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

130:9-14

Ambiguous; Misstates
Testimony; Mischaracterizes;
Misleading

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

135:2-137:19

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

137:24-25
139:19-143:3

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

146:24-149:19
187:5-191:14

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

195:4-198:13

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

198:22-199:1
199:10-19

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

199:3-6
199:22-24

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

200:14-202:16
204:21-205:2
205:25-206:7
205:5-15
205:17-22
206:9-207:7
208:24-209:1

Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Ambiguous; Asked and
Answered; Misstates Testimony
Misstates Testimony
611c; Misstates Testimony;
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Compound; Ambiguous;
Incomplete
611c; Ambiguous
Ambiguous; Speculation;
Assumes Facts
Ambiguous; Compound;
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6)
Ambiguous; Incomplete
Ambiguous; Beyond Scope of
30(B)(6)
Ambiguous; Incomplete
Ambiguous; Beyond Scope of
30(B)(6)
Ambiguous; Lacks Foundation
Asked and Answered
Asked and Answered
Assumes Facts
Assumes Facts

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

208:12-22
208:6-10
209:3-16

02198.51855/4877234.1

Ambiguous

Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous

17

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
125:4-10; 125:13-22; 125:25126:17; 126:20-127:7; 127:10128:10; 128:14-128:21; 151:524
122:21-124:8; 124:10-124:22;
125:4-10; 125:13-22; 125:25126:17; 126:20-127:7; 127:10128:10; 128:14-128:21; 151:524
137:20-23; 138:2-12

137:20-23; 138:2-12
143:10-144:2

193:10-194:3; 194:8-22;
198:15-21
199:9

199:9

207:8-13; 207:15-208:5;
209:18-23; 208:25-209:24;
210:2-13
207:8-13; 207:15-208:5
207:8-13; 207:15-208:5
207:8-13; 207:15-208:5;
209:18-23; 208:25-209:24;
210:2-13

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

218:24-219:4
221:8-14

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

221:3-5

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011

221:17-19
224:19-225:8

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

224:13-16
225:11-15
225:21-23
238:11-24
239:3-10

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

239:14-19

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

239:23-25

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

240:24-241:2

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

240:19-21

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

248:12-15
248:18-20
255:12-24

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

256:10-257:13
284:25-285:2
284:20-23
284:17-18
285:4-10
285:13-16
285:19-22
286:25-287:5
286:10-14

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

286:18-21

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

287:20-25
287:15-17
288:25-289:17

02198.51855/4877234.1

Not Testimony
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Ambiguous
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Ambiguous; Misleading; 701
Misleading; 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701;
Ambiguous
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Incomplete; Misleading; 701
Not Testimony
Not Testimony; Ambiguous;
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Ambiguous; Beyond Scope of
30(B)(6); 701; Misleading
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701;
Misleading
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Ambiguous; 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6);
Ambiguous; 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701

Asked and Answered
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Incomplete; Misleading
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701;
Hypothetical
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701;
Hypothetical
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701

18

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

240:1-18
240:1-18

248:22-249:5; 249:8-17
248:22-249:5; 249:8-17
250:20-251:6; 252:23-253:9;
253:12-17

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

288:2-3
303:23-304:1
303:19-21
304:11-306:5
307:12-308:6

Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6); 701
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

310:24-311:14

Asked and Answered

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

310:3-17

Asked and Answered

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

310:20-22

Asked and Answered

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

311:17-21

Asked and Answered

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
9/21/2011

317:17-24
318:2-6
321:13-17

Assumes Facts
Assumes Facts
Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6)

Denison, Justin 9-21-11

9/21/2011

321:20-24

Beyond Scope of 30(B)(6)

Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin 9-21-11
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796

9/21/2011
9/21/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011

331:14-18
331:21-25
5:12-15
8:21-10:10
13:7-15:19
16:13-19:2
19:24-20:13
20:21-23
25:12-18
62:4-13
63:16-64:9
65:10-66:21
74:19-25
80:16-81:9
80:7-11
81:17-82:6
83:14-20
84:4-9
86:4-18
91:16-21
105:4-15

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Asked and Answered
Asked and Answered

02198.51855/4877234.1

308:7-9; 308:12-18; 308:20310:2; 312:23-25; 312:3-24
308:7-9; 308:12-18; 308:20310:2; 312:23-25; 312:3-24
308:7-9; 308:12-18; 308:20310:2; 312:23-25; 312:3-24
308:7-9; 308:12-18; 308:20310:2; 312:23-25; 312:3-24
308:7-9; 308:12-18; 308:20310:2; 312:23-25; 312:3-24
318:8-12; 318:14-19
318:8-12; 318:14-19
318:21-319:3; 319:6-20;
319:22-19; 320:23-11
318:21-319:3; 319:6-20;
319:22-19; 320:23-11

Outside the Scope of 30(B)(6)
Outside the Scope of 30(B)(6)
25:24-26:7
62:14-16; 63:8-15
62:14-16; 63:8-15
65:5-9

79:7-25; 80:2-6; 80:12-15
79:7-25; 80:2-6; 80:12-15
83:8-13
83:21-25; 84:2-3

19

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Denison, Justin ITC-796
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho

12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
12/16/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011

106:14-107:7
115:9-16
135:22-136:5
135:16-20
157:22-158:12
177:16-24
178:22-179:17
180:8-181:6
182:2-6
183:15-184:24
185:19-186:9
187:11-188:8
190:8-13
204:18-25
205:6-16
6:2-7
10:6-19
18:4-8
20:14-22
33:17-25
35:8-10
35:12-16

Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011

35:19-20

Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011

36:4-7
36:10-12
37:4-6

Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011

37:9-13

Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011

37:16

Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011

38:2-4

Eun, Sung-Ho

11/18/2011

38:7

Eun, Sung-Ho
Eun, Sung-Ho
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo

11/18/2011
11/18/2011
4/19/2012
4/19/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

42:14-17
42:19-20
8:16-23
10:14-20

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Legal Conclusion
115:17-23

179:18-180:7
701
Speculation

611c

182:7-20
184:25-186:18
184:25-186:18
188:9-190:3
190:6

6:8-16

ambiguous
ambiguous, compound, legal
conclusion
ambiguous, compound, legal
conclusion
ambiguous, legal conclusion
ambiguous, legal conclusion
ambiguous, legal conclusion,
701
ambiguous, legal conclusion,
701
ambiguous, legal conclusion,
701
ambiguous, legal conclusion,
701
ambiguous, legal conclusion,
701
ambiguous
ambiguous

20

errata

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012

12:23-13:7
13:16-18
14:12-15
14:24-16:22
24:5-25:5

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

30:3-45:5

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

45:13-62:12

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

71:7-74:8

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

76:12-80:4

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

80:14-96:6

Hong, Won-Pyo

4/19/2012

99:6-112:17

Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Translation; Lacks foundation;
402
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Translation;
Assumes facts;
Mischaracterization; 402
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Translation;
Assumes facts;
Mischaracterization; Misstates
testimony
Assumes facts; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Lacks foundation;
Compound
Translation; Lacks foundation;
402; Ambiguous; Misstates
testimony; Overbroad
Lacks foundation; Overbroad;
Ambiguous; Translation;
Mischaracterization; Assumes
facts; Misstates testimony;
Asked and answered;
Speculation; Hypothetical; 402
Mischaracterization; Lacks
foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Overbroad;
Translation; Misstates
testimony; Assumes facts;
Hearsay; Argumentative; 403;
402
115:13-17
115:19-116:8
116:10-116:10
116:13-18
116:20-22
116:24-117:3
117:5-6
117:10-15
21

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Hong, Won-Pyo
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang

4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
4/19/2012
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011

7:4-8
10:1-9
11:11-18
12:1-9
12:11-19
14:5-7
14:10-16
14:21-15:6
24:6-9

Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang
Jeong Moon-Sang

11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011
11/17/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

24:12-15
24:17-21
29:4-5
29:7-11
29:18-19
29:21-22
51:23-52:1
52:4-13

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
117:17-19
117:21-23
117:25-118:3
118:5-119:17
119:19-120:4
120:6-121:5
121:7-10
121:12-14
121:16-122:14
122:16-17
122:19-123:1
123:4-7
123:9-21
123:23-24
124:1-6
124:8-16
124:18-125:13
125:15-126:2
126:4-6
126:8-127:4
127:6-9
127:11-13
127:15-25

Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Translation
Translation
Speculation, Legal Conclusion,
Translation,
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Incomplete, Ambiguous
Ambiguous
Incomplete
Asked and Answered

22

29:12-13; 29:15-17
29:23-24; 30:2-4; 30:7-14

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 1
Kho, Wookyun Vol 2
Kho, Wookyun Vol 2
Kho, Wookyun Vol 2
Kho, Wookyun Vol 2
Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
1/12/2012
3/4/2012
3/4/2012
3/4/2012
3/4/2012
3/4/2012

5:20-6:7
10:4-16:22
38:22-39:1
38:2-11
39:15-41:3
41:13-25
42:4-11
43:20-44:15
45:17-46:7
48:9-51:21
57:13-58:1
59:3-8
67:12-69:1
69:24-70:14
71:4-7
75:15-76:4
77:23-79:22
80:16-19
81:12-83:2
84:21-96:18
103:12-104:14
105:12-108:6
111:10-16
124:16-125:8
124:11-14
126:3-19
127:4-21
128:8-20
129:3-130:7
142:11-12
143:5-12
151:20-23
157:15-19
157:22-25

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

158:4-20

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

159:4-8

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

161:5-11

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

402

lacks foundation
lacks foundation
69:2-69:23
70:15-23

lacks foundation; Speculation
lacks foundation; 1002

112:15-22

lacks foundation

130:14-17

Ambiguous, beyond scope of
designations, asked and
answered
Ambiguous, beyond scope of
designations
Ambiguous, lacks foundation,
beyond scope of designations
Ambiguous, beyond scope of
23

159:9-15

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012
3/4/2012

162:2-13

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

163:21-164:4

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

168:4-20

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

206:20-207:17

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

3/4/2012

211:20-212:14

Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12

2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012

designations, lacks foundation
Ambiguous, lacks foundation,
beyond scope of designations
Ambiguous, lacks foundation,
beyond scope of designations
Ambiguous; beyond scope of
designations
Ambiguous, Overbroad,
compound, beyond scope of
designations
Beyond scope of designations;
Ambiguous; assumes facts;
hypothetical; lacks foundation;
Misleading as to the phrase
"bounce effect"
Ambiguous, beyond scope of
designations; lacks foundation

162:21-163:8

Kho, Wookyun Vol 2

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

8:15-20
24:25-25:4
30:8-9
30:16-20
38:3-39:13
65:17-66:12
67:9-68:8
68:25-69:20
69:22-70:1
70:9-17
82:18-20
82:23-83:5
134:18-135:7
138:5-139:9
139:11-17
139:19-140:22
141:22-142:13
142:18-24
143:5-7
143:13-21
143:23-25
144:4-13
144:15-145:2
145:8-146:1

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

161:13-18

202:10-24; 204:16-205:9;
207:18-19

212:16-213:12

72:24-73:5

135:8-137:2

140:23-141:16

24

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 2-13-12
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Seongwoo 3-19-12 ITC-794
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
2/13/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
3/19/2012
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

146:3-11
146:14-24
168:13-169:1
169:3-11
169:14-17
169:19-22
169:24-170:4
170:7-16
170:19-171:3
171:5-172:19
172:22-173:8
173:11-175:3
175:14-17
176:3-13
176:16-22
177:1-6
177:9-10
9:24-10:14
12:13-17
17:19-18:24
53:12-20
54:20-55:3
56:6-7
57:8-16
57:18-23
70:4-71:20
73:11-14
74:9-17
75:20-76:8
78:21-80:1
80:7-12
93:3-18
93:20-22
93:24-94:8
98:5-99:6
110:17-111:11
146:12-147:1
156:7-157:7
157:9-16
6:1
8:12-15

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403

97:13-20
110:1-14
112:1-14
161:9-162:6

25

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

26:20-23
26:25-27:2
27:25-28:2
28:5-10
48:11-21
50:22-51:5
51:15-18
51:20-23
58:8-59:20

Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

62:3-5
62:7-14
70:4-17
70:21-71:1

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

71:19-73:4

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

73:17-23

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

74:18-24

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

75:1-11

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

75:13-76:16

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

76:18-20

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

80:23-81:11

Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

85:5-19
88:21-89:2
91:25-92:6
93:20-94:16
94:19-95:9
95:15-21
95:23-25
101:21-102:1
102:8-103:23
107:21-25

misstates testimony
602; 403; 402; lacks foundation
602; 403; 402; lacks foundation
602; 403; 402; lacks foundation

Kim, Soeng Hun

11/11/2011

108:2-7

lacks foundation; 602

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

28:11-21
48:7-10; 48:22 - 50:6
49:23 - 50:21; 51:24 - 53:21
49:23 - 50:21; 51:24 - 53:21
21:3 - 22:4; 23:4 - 23:8; 23:14 18; 84:23 - 85:4
62:15 - 63:5; 61:2 - 62:2

602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation
602; lacks foundation;
speculation

lacks foundation; 602

26

71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17; 76:21 78:16
71:2 - 18; 73:24 - 74:17; 76:21 78:16

90:4 - 91:24; 92:7 - 93:3
90:4 - 91:24; 92:7 - 93:3
90:4 - 91:24; 92:7 - 93:3
90:4 - 91:24; 92:7 - 93:3
90:4 - 91:24; 92:7 - 93:3

108:12 - 109:23; 112:2 - 15;
113:25 - 114:25; 132:8 - 133:17
108:12 - 109:23; 112:2 - 15;

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Soeng Hun
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

118:10-12
118:19-119:22
120:6-17
120:20-22
121:2-7
123:5-124:7
124:16-125:1
9:13-18
10:11-13
10:15-25
12:10-18
25:10-11
25:13-14
32:18-19
32:22-33:9
33:11-13
59:1-5
59:12-20
60:20-23
60:25-61:1
63:8-9
63:22-25
64:1-4
64:7-11
64:14-20
64:23-65:6
65:9-10
67:22-24
68:3
69:17-23
70:4
70:10-11
70:14-15
72:20-22
72:24-73:3
73:5-8
73:11-13
84:9-11
84:14-16
84:22-85:7

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
113:25 - 114:25; 132:8 - 133:17
118:13 - 18
118:13 - 18
120:23 - 121 - 1
120:23 - 121 - 1
124:8 - 15
125:2 - 22; 132:8 - 133:17

20:5-8, 22:6-23:7
legal conclusion
legal conclusion

legal conclusion
legal conclusion; Ambiguous
legal conclusion; Ambiguous

27

32:20-21
33:10

63:3-4, 63:6-7, 64:12-13
64:21-22
65:7-8
65:11-15, 65:18-20
71:8-9, 72:6-9, 72:12-14

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

Kim, Young-Bum
Kim, Young-Bum
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Kwak, Yong Jun
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi

11/11/2011
11/11/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
11/23/2011
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

104:19-20
104:23
8:6-25
15:21-16:6
37:17-38:4
44:23-25
45:3-5
94:12-14
12-22-13:8
94-17-21
6:5-8
6:12-13
7:17-20
8:12-19
14:9-25
17:2-8
17:21-18:6

02198.51855/4877234.1

96:8-9
96:18
96:25-97:1, 97:7-9, 79:12-18

Ambiguous

97:2-6
103:14-16
103:18-104:3
104:5-13

91:25-92:1, 92:5-7, 92:10-13

Speculation; Ambiguous
Speculation; Ambiguous
Speculation; Ambiguous; Legal
Conclusion; 701

85:10-16
85:19-21
89:6-7
89:10-13
89:18-21
90:25-91:2
91:4-7
91:10-24
92:2-4
92:21-22
92:24
93:17-20
94:21-22
94:25-95:11
95:14-19
96:5-7
96:10-17
96:19-24

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

legal conclusion; Ambiguous

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

104:4
104:14-18, 114:20-24, 115:2116:3, 118:12-16, 118:18-24
104:21-22

Speculation

7:21-22, 8:1-5
15:17-20
44:17-22
mischaracterization

94:15-16

6:9-11
6:14-19
7:21-8:11
8:20-23
13:1-14:8
lacks foundation; Speculation
28

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

18:15-19:12
23:8-24:16
27:12-21
28:7-29:15
33:20-34:4
37:3-18
42:6-23
43:6-44:2
49:8-14
50:13-51:6
53:22-54:8
55:1-56:4
69:13-25
71:23-72:24
71:16-20
73:11-76:4

Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lam, Ioi (ITC)
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
3/29/2012
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

76:15-23
101:22-103:16
104:12-108:24
109:12-110:16
113:20-25
113:11-15
114:13-115:1
123:14-124:18
125:9-23
5:11-14
9:1-15
9:22-24
52:24-53:24
54:18-55:22
90:22-91:15
118:11-119:15
130:5-131:16
6:5-9
10:13-11:1
14:23-15-13
21:12-14
21:16-22
23:17-19
23:22-24:4

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
19:13-20:6

lacks foundation

29:16-24

Speculation

37:19-38:1

Ambiguous

Ambiguous
Ambiguous; lacks foundation

71:21-22

Ambiguous; lacks foundation;
legal conclusion

lacks foundation

113:16-19

1002

Ambiguous; hypothetical
Misleading
lacks foundation; Speculation
hypothetical

55:23-57:10
93:15-94:9
119:16-25
129:20-130:4
10:8-12, 11:2-6

Mischaracterizes
Incomplete
29

23:20-21
24:5-9

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, JuHo
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won

12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
12/3/2011
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012

54:4-6
54:9-12
69:15-17
69:20-24
70:9-19
111:1-3
111:8-23
112:3-12
112:14-17
113:10-11
113:16-20
120:19-122:5
122:7-9
124:6-8
124:10-125:2
125:8-12
125:14-24
7:2-6
7:11-22
8:10-11
8:14-16
8:21-9:9
11:7-:12:11
12:13-16
13:6-7
13:9-12
22:3-5

Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012

22:8-11

Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

23:1-5
23:7
23:9-12
23:14
23:16-20
23:24
24:20-22
25:1
28:4-6
28:9-10
28:12-14

02198.51855/4877234.1

Incomplete
Legal Conclusion
Incomplete
Legal Conclusion
Ambiguous

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
54:13-55:10
69:18-19
70:1-8, 68:2-69:10
111:1-7

Speculation
Speculation

113:12-15

Ambiguous

122:24-123:4
123:18-21, 123:23-124:4, 124:9

beyond scope of 30b6, lacks
foundation
beyond scope of 30b6, lacks
foundation
compound

22:13-24

24:1-18
26:10-14, 27:7-18
beyond scope of 30b6
beyond scope of 30b6
beyond scope of 30b6
30

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012

28:17
28:19-21
28:25-29:4
29:6-10
29:23-30:1
30:3-8
34:22-35:10
35:12-13
36:4-8
36:12-14
36:16-20
36:22-37:7
37:10-11
37:22-23
38:2-7
38:9-10
38:13-20
39:6-7
39:11-12
39:14-16
39:18-21
41:21-24
42:2-6
43:10-12
43:15-16
46:12-14

Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012

46:19-22

Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

46:24
47:1-4
51:25-52:2
52:4
52:6-8
52:11
52:13-15
52:17-20
52:22
53:1
53:3-6
53:8

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

beyond scope of 30b6

29:12-21

35:15-36:3

40:1-41:19

43:18-25, 45:12-46:10
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30b6, legal conclusion
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30b6, legal conclusion

54:8-20
31

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012

57:8-10
57:14-20
62:13-18
62:23-63:2
63:4-6

Lee, Jun Won

3/26/2012

63:10-15

Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/26/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012

71:5-7
71:9-14
71:17-18
72:5-7
72:10-11
72:21-23
73:1-2
7:25
9:1-19
43:20-23

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

43:25-44:1

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

105:17-107:22
108:6-23
108:25
109:2-4
109:6
109:8-9
109:11-15
112:19-113:4
113:6-8
113:10-22
113:24-25
114:2-10
114:14-23
115:1-2
115:4-7
115:10

02198.51855/4877234.1

hypothetical, lacks foundation,
speculation
hypothetical, lacks foundation,
speculation

lacks foundation, beyond scope
of 30b6
lacks foundation, beyond scope
of 30b6

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

64:13-19

28:2-7
44:3-44:9, 45:2-15, 46:3-12,
63:12-19, 64:10-16, 65:21-25,
66:5-9, 67:17-24, 68:1869:7,81:4-15, 100:9-16, 101:911, 101:19-20, 101:23-102:6,
102:9-14

ambiguous, speculation, MIL 9
ambiguous, speculation, MIL 9
speculation
speculation
110:21-111:16

32

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

115:12-15

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

115:17-117:3

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

117:7-15

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

117:17-18

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

122:4-7

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

122:11-12

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

133:21-134:12

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

134:15-24

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

135:1-4

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

142:11-13

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

142:16-22

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

142:24-143:2

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

143:5-7

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

143:9-11

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

143:14-16

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012

146:21-24
147:1
151:3-5

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012

151:8

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1

3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

8:16-10:2
16:14-15
16:17-17:7
17:9-18:4
18:7-19
18:21-20:25

02198.51855/4877234.1

beyond scope of 30b6, lacks
foundation
beyond scope of 30b6, legal
conclusion, lacks foundation
beyond scope of 30b6, legal
conclusion, lacks foundation
beyond scope of 30b6, legal
conclusion, lacks foundation
lacks foundation, beyond scope
of 30b6
lacks foundation, beyond scope
of 30b6
legal conclusion, beyond scope
of 30b6, foundation
legal conclusion, beyond scope
of 30b6, foundation
legal conclusion, beyond scope
of 30b6, foundation
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6
701, lacks foundation, beyond
scope of 30b6

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

118:12-119:4; 119:20-120:1
123:6-12

140:9-14

146:13-19
147:3-9
beyond scope of 30b6, calls for
speculation, lacks foundation
beyond scope of 30b6, calls for
speculation, lacks foundation

33

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-5-12 Vol 1
Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2

3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/5/2012
3/6/2012

21:18-22:3
22:10-14
22:5-8
24:8-11
24:13-15
27:21-23
27:18-19
27:25
30:10-13
31:18-23
31:15-16
33:21-24
37:21-25
37:8-9
38:2-5
53:24-54:11
53:11-15
53:17-21
56:21-24
56:16-18
58:16-59:3
58:12-14
59:5-15
59:18-21
149:17-150:10
150:13
174:24-175:11

Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2
Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2

3/6/2012
3/6/2012

174:3-7
175:21-176:4

Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2

3/6/2012

175:14-19

Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2
Lee, Jun Won 3-6-12 Vol 2
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/26/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

176:9-13
7:2-6
6:24-25
7:10-8:10
10:3-6
11:14-16
11:20-12:1
12:3-12

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

beyond scope of 30b6
beyond scope of 30b6

incomplete
legal conclusion
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30b6, lacks foundation
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30b6
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30b6, lacks foundation
incomplete

incomplete

34

184:3-10, 199:3-16

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

12:15-19
12:21-23
12:25
14:25-15:2
15:4-6
15:9-14
15:17-21
15:23-16:2
16:4-8
16:10-13
16:16-21
16:24-17:17
19:12-13
20:4-6
20:10-11
20:13
21:19
21:21
21:23
21:25
22:2-4
22:7
23:1-3
23:6-10
23:12
43:21-24
44:2-12

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012

44:14-20

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012

44:24-45:2
48:9-11

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012

48:14-15

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

51:22-24
52:2-4
59:4-5
59:8-11
59:13-16
59:18

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

13:2-11; 13:14-18

20:25, 21:8-17

legal conclusion
legal conclusion

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6
speculation, beyond scope of
30b6

35

24:25-25:11, 25:24-26:10
30:16-23; 31:2-14
34:14-23; 35:2-3; 35:5-7; 35:913; 35:14-18; 35:20-23
38:4-5; 38:9-18; 38:22-1; 39:1619; 39:22-40:6
45:4-13, 46:24-47:12

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

59:20-21
59:24-60:7
61:2-6

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012

61:10-13

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

61:15-17
61:19
62:4-6
62:9
62:11-13
62:16-24
63:2
64:9-11
64:13-14
64:16-17
64:21-23
64:25-65:1
65:4-10
65:12-14
69:6-7
69:11-16
69:18
69:20-21
69:23-70:3
70:5-11
70:15-20
70:22-23
71:1-2
108:2-5

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

108:8-13
108:15-16
108:18
108:20-21
108:23-109:4
109:6
110:5-6

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

110:8-15
110:17-20

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6
speculation, beyond scope of
30b6
61:21-25

63:4-23

legal conclusion
legal conclusion
speculation
speculation
65:16-23

85:13-19, 99:21-100:10
105:19-23, 106:10-19, 107:2025

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6

36

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

110:22
110:24
111:1-4
111:6-12
111:14
111:16-18
111:20-21
111:24-112:3
112:5-8
112:11-15
112:17-20

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

112:22
112:24-25
113:2-3
113:5-7

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

113:9-15
113:17:18
113:20-24
114:9-11
114:13-15
114:17-20
114:22-24
115:1
115:3-5
123:25-124:9
124:12-17
124:19-25
125:3-13
125:15-18
129:8-11
129:13-14
129:16
129:18
131:3-6
131:9
131:13-15
131:17-18
131:20-21
131:23

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6

ambiguous, speculation

legal conclusion
128:5-11

129:20-130:8

37

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

131:25-132:2
132:5-6
132:8-9
132:12-14
132:16-17
133:3
133:6-7
133:20-23
134:1
134:3-6
134:9-10
136:3-17
136:19-23
137:12-14
137:16-21
141:3-12
141:15-17
141:19-22

Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794
Lee, Jun Won ITC-794

3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012
3/6/2012

141:24-142:1
142:12-14
142:17-18
142:20-22
142:24
143:1-3
143:5

Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

5:17-18
5:22-25
7:13-15
7:25-8:3
8:8-13
9:6-25
10:10-11:12
16:15-21

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

21:7-11

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

21:24-22:20

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion

speculation, beyond scope of
30b6

143:15-144:9, 146:5-9, 146:1116

compound, ambiguous
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, 402
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence
ambiguous, beyond scope of
38

13:16-14:18
15:3-15:13

19:18-19:22

24:9-24:17

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

3/8/2012

25:16-23

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

26:4-23

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

34:20-35:6

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

34:9-13

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

41:10-15

Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012
3/8/2012

47:15-19
48:4-15

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

49:19-50:2

Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012
3/8/2012

49:6-11
50:17-51:6

Lee, Kiwon

3/8/2012

30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, calls for a legal
conclusion
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, calls for a legal
conclusion
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, translation
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, 402
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence
ambiguous, beyond scope of
30(b)(6), assumes facts not in
evidence, calls for a legal
conclusion
ambiguous, assumes facts not
in evidence
beyond scope of 30(b)(6), 402
calls for speculation, beyond
scope of 30(b)(6), 402, 602
calls for speculation, beyond
scope of 30(b)(6), calls for a
legal conclusion, 402, 602
calls for speculation
calls for speculation,
ambiguous, outside scope of
30(b)(6)
lacks foundation, calls for
speculation, outside scope of
30(b)(6), 402, 602, 802

23:13-17

Lee, Kiwon

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

55:18-56:18

Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Kiwon
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

24:22-25:1

34:14-34:19

38:17-38:22

39:10-39:18

40:16-41:9

41:16-41:21
47:20-47:25
49:6-49:18

42:18-42:22
44:1-44:6
3/2/2012
3/2/2012
3/2/2012
3/2/2012
3/2/2012

6:17-13:21
20:16-22:25
26:10-29:11
34:21-40:19
41:11-42:19

ambiguous; lacks foundation;

23:1-3
40:20-41:9

39

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk
Lee, Min-Hyouk

3/2/2012
3/2/2012
3/2/2012
3/2/2012

52:21-53:18
67:1-74:1
81:2-23
82:19-85:2

Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796

3/3/2012

20:20-22:13

Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796
Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796
Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796

3/3/2012

54:10-25

3/3/2012

56:10-61:2

Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796
Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796
Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796
Lee, Min-Hyouk 30(b)(6) ITC796

3/3/2012

118:3-7

3/3/2012

121:14-125:8

3/3/2012

136:6-17

3/3/2012

157:21-167:8

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

9:19-13:10

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

14:18-15:8

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

15:22-19:9

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

19:25-22:25

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

25:2-29:1

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

33:22-38:21

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

35:6-14

3/3/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation; calls for
speculation; assumes facts;
misleading; 602
ambiguous; calls for
speculation; lacks foundation;
602; incomplete hypothetical

55:1-56:7
compound; ambiguous; calls for
speculation; incomplete
hypothetical; lacks foundation
118:9-20

lacks foundation; 602; calls for
speculation; 802; misleading;
assumes facts
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
602, 802, lacks foundation,
assumes facts
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation,
mischaracterization
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
40

32:14-33:7

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Lee, Sangeun
Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012
2/24/2012

2/24/2012

46:1-49:3

Lee, Sangeun

2/24/2012

50:9-51:25

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

5:16-20

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

6:1-3

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

9:16-23

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

speculation,
mischaracterization
402, 403, 802, 1002
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
Samsung objects to the
designation of tesitmony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that

42:12-15
43:1-44:12

Lee, Sangeun

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

12:20-21

02198.51855/4877234.1

41

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

2/1/2012

37:19-38:5

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

41:6-42:4

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Incomplete
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Incomplete
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.

24:11-20

Ling, Qi

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

45:19-46:6

02198.51855/4877234.1

42

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

24:25-25:18

38:5-41:5

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

45:9-11

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

48:14-50:14

Ling, Qi

2/1/2012

52:7-58:22

Nam, Ki Hyung
Nam, Ki Hyung
Nam, Ki Hyung
Nam, Ki Hyung

2/10/2012
2/10/2012
2/10/2012
2/10/2012

5:16-17
6:14-17
39:2-40:8
52:4-21

Nam, Ki Hyung ITC-794
Nam, Ki Hyung ITC-794
Oh, Jeong-Seok
Oh, Jeong-Seok

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
11/11/2011
11/11/2011

19:8-20:23
21:8-22:11
6:25
7:1-15

Oh, Jeong-Seok
Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011
11/11/2011

19:2-8
28:6-7

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

28:10-13

02198.51855/4877234.1

Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; lacks foundation
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Ling on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Incomplete

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

58:23-61:25

40:10-13
Lacks foundation; speculation;
602; Misleading;
Ambiguous; compound
Ambiguous; compound
translation, incomplete,
Ambiguous
Misleading, Legal Conclusion,
702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
43

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

28:19-22

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

28:25

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

29:16-17

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

29:20-22

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

30:1-3

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

30:6

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

30:21-22

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

30:25

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

44:19-24

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

45:2

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

45:8-9

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

45:11-13

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

45:16-19

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

48:4-5

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

48:9

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

48:21-24

Oh, Jeong-Seok

11/11/2011

49:2-3

Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

7:12-18
12:19-21
21:20-22
21:24-25

02198.51855/4877234.1

Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
702/703
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
702/703
Incomplete, Misleading,
702/703
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703, asked and
answered
Incomplete, Misleading, Legal
Conclusion, 702/703

44

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

21:11-22:12; 46:21-47:13
21:11-22:12; 46:21-47:13
21:11-22:12; 46:21-47:13

21:11-22:12; 46:21-47:13

21:11-22:12; 46:21-47:13

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012

22:2-6

Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

134:18-21
134:23-135:8
135:10-136:18
136:20-22
143:20-25

Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012

144:3-22

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

7:16-20

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

7:9

Park, Hyoung Shin
Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012
2/29/2012

10:11-13
48:19-49:10

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

48:10-14

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

50:25-51:3

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

50:7-16

Park, Hyoung Shin

2/29/2012

55:3-57:16

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794
Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794
Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012
3/1/2012
3/1/2012

5:22-23
6:1-21
13:8-14

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

28:10-29:13

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

30:2-5

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794
Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012
3/1/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

34:5-6
61:19-62:5

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
18:25-19:10; 19:17-18; 19:2024; 20:3-7

136:24-137:18; 137:20-20
speculation; hypothetical; 602

Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Translation; MIL 6
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Translation
Ambiguous; Overbroad
402; 403; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Translation; MIL 1
403; Ambiguous; Overbroad;
Translation; MIL 1
Speculation; 602; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Lacks foundation
Ambiguous; Overbroad

Speculation; lacks foundation;
701; Ambiguous; Legal
Conclusion; Overbroad; 602;
Translation
402; Not Testimony
Incomplete
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
602; Ambiguous; Overbroad;
402
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
602; Ambiguous; Overbroad;
402
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
602; Ambiguous; Overbroad;
402
45

89:23-90:1; 90:3-8; 90:11-17;
96:10-16; 96:18-18
110:10-110:17; 112:12-112:17;
112:19-113:20
7:21-8:10

10:14-11:2; 11:19-20
49:11-50:5; 50:18-23
48:15-17

32:21-23; 33:1; 33:16-24;
40:12-41:3; 50:1-2; 50:5; 50:1823; 54:16-55:2

29:22-30:1
34:7-13
62:7-63:6

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

81:24-25

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

82:3-6

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

86:18-21

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

87:3-13

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012

89:8-15

Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794
Park, Hyoung Shin ITC-794

3/1/2012
3/1/2012

89:17-90:5
115:2-11

Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2

3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

101:10-14
103:22-104:5
111:14-21
117:18-118:3
118:23-119:4
118:8-18
119:9-12
120:3-7
128:10-129:7
128:2-6
131:20-133:1
135:15-136:18
135:6-8
137:2-12
137:24-25
138:18-139:5
138:6-14
138:1
139:17-20
140:14-141:2
140:4-10
142:15-143:2

02198.51855/4877234.1

Lacks foundation; Incomplete;
Speculation; 602; Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Lacks foundation; Incomplete;
Speculation; 602; Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Lacks foundation; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; 402
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
701; Ambiguous; Legal
Conclusion; Overbroad; 602
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Overbroad;
Incomplete
Ambiguous
Lacks foundation; Incomplete;
Speculation; 602; 802;
Ambiguous; 402; 403

translation
translation

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

86:22-23; 87:1

114:7-21; 115:13-21

11:22-25
118:4-7

ambiguous, lacks foundation

128:7-9
128:7-9
402, ambiguous
ambiguous, compound
402, 501, not testimony
402, 501, not testimony
402, 501, not testimony
402, 501, not testimony

139:6-9; 139:21-140:3
138:15-17
139:6-9; 139:21-140:3

402, 501, not testimony
402, 501, not testimony
mischaracterization; assumes
facts
46

141:12-14; 142:2-3; 142:6-7

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Junho Vol 2
02198.51855/4877234.1

DATE
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

143:20-144:8
143:8-10
144:15-23
145:3-7
146:11-16
148:3-16
148:22-25
149:8-19
164:25-165:25
166:17-167:5
167:15-168:8
168:11-25
169:3-10
169:17
169:20
170:2-171:5
171:22-172:24
171:15-18
173:19-174:5
173:4-16
174:22-175:19
175:22-176:14
176:21-177:17
184:7-24
186:12-16
186:19-23
187:2-15
188:19-190:5
190:11-192:14
193:7-19
194:16-195:9
196:11-197:18
198:14-199:6
199:24-200:5
199:12-17
199:20-22
200:9-17
201:4-14
202:22-203:6
202:3-10
203:19-204:9

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
141:12-14; 142:2-3; 142:6-7

402
402, lacks foundation

lacks foundation
translation

148:17-21
148:17-21
149:1-7; 149:20-150:2
166:1-3; 166:11-16
166:11-16

translation

171:7-11

translation

174:6-8

asked and answered
lacks foundation

175:20-21
175:20-21
175:18-21
186:17-18; 186:24-187:1
186:17-18; 186:24-187:1
187:16-19; 187:22-25
187:5-6
187:5-6

402
402
402
402
402
402
402
402
402
402
402
402
47

199:7-11
199:7-11

203:7-8
203:7-8

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Park, Junho Vol 2
Park, Sang-Ryul
Park, Sang-Ryul
Park, Sang-Ryul

3/30/2012
11/18/2011
11/18/2011
11/18/2011

203:9-17
8:12-18
10:22-25
19:10-12

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

19:14-15

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

20:4-5

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

20:8-11

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

20:14-16

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

41:11-16

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

41:19-21

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

41:24

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

46:7-8

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

46:12-13

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

49:3-4

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

49:7

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

50:17

02198.51855/4877234.1

402
n/a
n/a
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
48

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
203:7-8

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

50:20-23

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

51:2-3

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

52:4-6

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

52:9-10

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

54:15

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

54:19-22

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

54:25-55:2

Park, Sang-Ryul

11/18/2011

55:6

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

5:14-18
7:9-12
16:7-20
19:22-20:7
21:20-21
21:23-24
22:1-6
22:12-20
23:24-25

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

24:11
24:13-14
24:17-21

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

24:24-25
25:12-13
25:16-26:20
28:16-24

02198.51855/4877234.1

Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701
Incomplete, Misleading,
Ambiguous, Legal Conclusion,
701

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

22:3-22:25

22:3-22:25

16:21-23
20:16-25

22:21-23:18
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation

legal conclusion, lacks
foundation

26:21-24
29:8-20
49

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

30:18-22
33:10-15
33:19
34:1-10
34:12
38:4-5
38:8
38:10-18
38:21-39:2
39:6-14
39:18-24
40:2
40:15-17
40:20
41:7-12
41:14
44:17-45:10
45:13
47:8-11
47:14
48:1-2

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

48:5-6
48:8-10
48:13-19
49:1-3
49:6-7
49:15-50:3
51:14-18
55:11-14
55:24-56:1

Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012

56:4

Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012

56:5-18

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

56:20-22
56:24-57:1
57:3
57:5-15
60:7-61:6

02198.51855/4877234.1

legal conclusion, speculation

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
31:7-32:1
32:6-33:8

37:6-12

legal conclusion, speculation
legal conclusion, speculation

40:4-13
40:22-41:6
44:8-9

legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion

52:3-10
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
ambiguous

lacks foundation
50

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

61:9-62:8
62:11-13
66:6-13

Park, Seung Gun

3/21/2012

66:16-67:6

Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Park, Seung Gun
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

67:18-68:2
68:6
68:16-19
68:22
68:24-69:1
69:4-5
69:7-12
69:15-16
74:14-21
74:25-75:22
76:16-19
77:18-78:9
94:2-21
96:11-14
98:7-19
99:12-15
7:13-16
8:20-9:2
9:5-10:11

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

9:15-10:1
10:14-19

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

13:8-14:10

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

14:20-15:19

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

15:22-23
15:25-17:10
20:19-23

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

20:14-16

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

20:25-21:6

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

lacks foundation
lacks foundation
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation
lacks foundation
lacks foundation

lacks foundation
lacks foundation

75:23-76:15

lacks foundation
95:18-96:9
98:21-99:11

Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Lacks foundation; Speculation;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Speculation; Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Ambiguous; Overbroad;
Compound
Ambiguous; Speculation; 602;
Overbroad; Compound
Incomplete; Speculation; 602;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
51

9:3-4
10:12-13

15:24
17:20-18:11; 18:16-25
20:17-18; 21:7-10
20:17-18; 21:7-10
20:24; 21:7-10

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

21:11-16

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

23:14-24:5

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

31:18-24

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

33:1-22

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

34:4-36:3

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

36:24-37:8

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

36:18-22

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

37:10-16

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

38:6-39:19

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

38:1-3

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

40:10-21

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

40:24-41:11

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

40:2-6

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

41:13-23

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

41:25

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

42:20-23
43:19-44:6

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

43:16-17

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

44:10-46:19

02198.51855/4877234.1

Ambiguous; Speculation; 602;
Overbroad;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Incomplete; Compound;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Speculation; Lacks foundation;
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Mischaracterization; Misstates
testimony
Speculation; Lacks foundation;
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Mischaracterization; Misstates
testimony
Speculation; Lacks foundation;
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Mischaracterization
Incomplete; Lacks foundation;
Ambiguous
Incomplete; asked and
answered; Speculation;
Ambiguous
Incomplete; asked and
answered; Ambiguous
Incomplete; asked and
answered; Ambiguous
Incomplete; asked and
answered; Ambiguous
Asked and answered;
ambiguous
Incomplete; Asked and
answered; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Asked and
answered; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Speculation; 602
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
Speculation; 602
Incomplete; Ambiguous;
52

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
21:17-19
22:18-23:13; 24:17-25:2; 25:1420
25:14-20
30:15-31:17; 32:23-25
33:23-34:3

36:4-23

36:4-17

37:09:00
38:4-5

38:4-5
39:20-40:1; 40:7-9
41:12-14
39:20-40:1; 40:7-9
41:12:00
41:24; 42:1-19

43:18; 42:24-43:15
43:18; 42:24-43:15; 44:7-9
42:24-43:15; 44:7-9; 46:20

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

47:11-48:2

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

48:17-23
48:25-49:21
51:9-52:3

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

54:12-14

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

55:3-24

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

56:10-13
60:20-25

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

60:5-7
60:9-11
115:25-116:10

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

115:18-23

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

116:23-117:1

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

116:12-16

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

116:19-21

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

151:8-12

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

151:15-18

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

151:21-152:1

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

152:4-152:8

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

Speculation; 602
Incomplete; Lacks foundation;
Ambiguous; Speculation; 602
Incomplete; Lacks foundation;
Ambiguous; Speculation; 602
Incomplete; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Compound;
Ambiguous; Overbroad
Incomplete; Ambiguous; Asked
and answered
Ambiguous; Asked and
answered

46:21-47:9

Pendleton, Todd

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

152:17-22

02198.51855/4877234.1

Speculation; 602; Ambiguous;
Overbroad; Incomplete
Incomplete; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Overbroad
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Overbroad
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Ambiguous;
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Ambiguous;
Overbroad
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Ambiguous;
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Lacks foundation;
Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Lacks foundation;
Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Hypothetical; Lacks
foundation; Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Hypothetical; Lacks
foundation; Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
53

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
42:24-43:15; 44:7-9; 46:20;
47:10
42:24-43:15; 44:7-9; 46:20;
47:10
48:24; 50:5-51:8
52:04:00
53:13-18
54:15-24; 55:25-56:9
57:7-10
60:12-19
60:8; 60:12-19
60:17-19; 67:10-13
115:24; Errata 116:1
115:24:00
116:22; 117:2-6
116:11; 116:17-18

116:11; 116:17-18; 116:22
151:13-14

151:13-14; 151:19-20

151:19-20; 152:2-3

152:2-3

152:23-25

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

3/21/2012

153:8-15

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

153:18-22

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

154:1-6

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012
3/21/2012

167:17-22
167:13-15
173:4-11

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

173:21-174:6

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

188:17-19
190:13-17

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

190:20-21

Pendleton, Todd
Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012
3/21/2012

191:18-22
194:20-195:6

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

195:25-196:10

Pendleton, Todd

3/21/2012

30(b)(6); Lacks foundation;
Ambiguous; Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Hypothetical; Lacks
foundation; Ambiguous;
Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Hypothetical; Lacks
foundation; Ambiguous;
Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Lacks foundation;
Hypothetical; Ambiguous;
Speculation
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); Lacks foundation;
Hypothetical; Ambiguous;
Speculation
Incomplete; Ambiguous; 611c
402; Incomplete; Ambiguous
Incomplete; Compound;
Assumes facts; 1002;
Mischaracterization
Incomplete; Compound;
Assumes facts; 1002;
Mischaracterization
Incomplete; not testimony
Argumentative; Asked and
answered; Ambiguous; 611c
Incomplete; Argumentative;
Asked and answered;
Ambiguous; 611c
Incomplete; not testimony
Beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 1002;
Mischaracterization;
ambiguous; assumes facts
Incomplete; Beyond scope of
30(b)(6); 1002;
Mischaracterization;
ambiguous; assumes facts;
lacks foundation; Speculation
Beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 1002;

153:1-5

Pendleton, Todd

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

195:9-22

02198.51855/4877234.1

54

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

153:6-7

153:6-7; Errata 153:11; 153:1617

153:16-17; 153:23-25

153:23-25; Errata 154:2

167:3-12
167:3-12
173:12-13; 173:15-16

173:18-20; 174:7-12; 174:25175:5

190:18-19
190:18-19

195:7-8

195:23-24

195:7-8; 195:23-24

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

Mischaracterization;
ambiguous; assumes facts;
lacks foundation; Speculation
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean
Roarty, Sean

3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012
3/7/2012

7:21-22
9:14-12:14
14:11-15:20
18:2-19:9
59:9-22
139:14-140:4
141:10-16
143:17-146:1
146:21-148:8
151:23-153:9

Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012
1/27/2012

8:7-9:23
11:3-11
12:10-14:9
15:3-16
16:4-6
16:16-17:17
17:21-18:21
22:17-23:6
24:6-9
25:9-27:9
29:3-16
29:20-24
30:16-24
40:12-41:1
42:21-43:13

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

43:19-44:9

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

44:11-18

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

46:22-47:24

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

49:9-24

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

51:18-52:1

02198.51855/4877234.1

30:23-32:6; 54:19-55:3;
141:24-142:2

misstates; lacks foundation;
ambiguous; calls for
speculation; 602

146:10-15
151:10-22

7:21-8:2
lacks foundation (14:8-9)
lacks foundation (15:3-7)
Incomplete
lacks foundation (18:19-21)
402; 403
402; 403
402; 403
402; 403
402; 403
402; 403; speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; incomplete
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802; 1002
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
55

17:18-20
18:22-19:3
19:22-20:2; 20:21-21:16

29:25-30:15
41:2-3
43:14-17

49:25-50:2

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

52:4-12

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

54:20-55:3

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

55:14-56:8

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

55:10-12

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

72:22-75:1

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

72:12-20

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

75:11-77:23

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

87:9-18

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

89:21-90:8

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

90:23-92:15

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

92:17-18

Rosenberg, Brian

1/27/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

101:22-104:3

Rosenberg, Brian
Rosenbrock, Karl

1/27/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

402; 403; Speculation; lacks
foundation (remainder); 803
402; 403; 701
Standing objection to entire
depo designation

105:14-106:7
7:2-3

Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl

402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; assumes facts; 701
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
incomplete; not testimony;
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 701; 802
Incomplete; 402; 403; lacks
foundation; speculation; 602;
701; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 701; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 802
402; 403; lacks foundation;
speculation; 602; 701; 802
misleading; 402; 403,
Speculation; lacks foundation;
701 (101:22-102:15)

8:4-5
8:18-20
13:9-14:2
15:4-19
15:24-16:23
17:15-18
18:12-19:18
20:21-21:19
25:16-18

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
52:2-3

56:9-10; 56:17-19; 56:23-57:2

85:12-86:9
89:17-20

106:8-12

17:19-18:5
20:20-23, 22:1-23:9
27:20-23
56

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

25:22
26:20-27:4
41:4-8

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

41:13-23

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

42:9-18

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

43:2-4

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

78:10-79:8

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

79:13-21

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

79:24-80:2

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

80:4-7

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

80:10-21

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

81:1-5

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

81:8-9

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

83:8-9

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

83:14-84:14

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

84:22-24

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

200:11-202:1-7

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

209:8-20

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
30:17-23

402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence),
speculation
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
402, 403, not testimony (expert
report not in evidence)
speculation, legal conclusion,
lacks foundation, 802, 702/703
speculation, legal conclusion,
lacks foundation, 802, 702/703
speculation, legal conclusion,
lacks foundation, 802, 702/703
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
57

44:11-17
57:8-25 (only if objection is
overruled)
59:7-60:11 (only if objection is
overruled)
66:10-18, 68:19-69:5
72:1-73:20

87:24-88:2
106:21-107:3, 107:16-108:25

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

4/20/2012

210:21-211:24

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

212:1-213:14

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

213:16-17

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

213:19-22

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

213:25-214:9

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (testimony on legal
issue of availability of
injunctions not appropriate for
jury and improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
speculation, 702/703 (improper
questioning about expert
reported prepared by an expert
who is not testifying) from a
2007 UK case involving
application of UK law, 402, 403,
802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning

210:11-20

Rosenbrock, Karl

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

214:12-20

02198.51855/4877234.1

58

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

4/20/2012

222:14-223:20

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

223:24

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

224:4-225-5

Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012

225:9-227:18

Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

231:8-9
231:12-15
232:22-233:12

Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl
Rosenbrock, Karl

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation, 702/703
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation, 702/703
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation, 702/703
legal conclusion, lacks
foundation, 702/703
speculation, lacks foundation
speculation, lacks foundation
702/703 (improper questioning
about expert reported
prepared by an expert who is
not testifying) from a 2007 UK
case involving application of UK
law, 402, 403, 802
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection
same objection

214:22-24

Rosenbrock, Karl

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

233:14-236:4
236:7-8
236:10-12
236:15-19
236:21-237:5
237:7-8
237:10-24
238:7-20
238:25-239:7
239:12
242:5-244:13
246:4-247-14

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

220:1-11

224:1-3

231:17-23

247:15-20, 248:12-21, 253:13,
only if testimony re: Walker
chart comes in, then: 272:6274:4, 275:25-277:6
59

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

5:15-22
7:19-10:19
12:22-13:14
14:2-17
16:19-17:25
19:6-20:20

Ryu, Dongseok
Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012
2/29/2012

21:10-18
27:20-33:6

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

33:21-34:9

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

35:23-42:14

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

43:9-44:21

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

45:24-46:17

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

53:13-54:20

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

55:15-21

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

56:4-10

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

57:16-23

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

59:5-22

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

60:18-61:13

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

63:12-66:7

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

72:25-75:6

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

77:6-16

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
10:25-11:7

lacks foundation, assumes facts
lacks foundation, assumes facts
lacks foundation, assumes facts
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts
lacks foundation, assumes facts
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation,
mischaracterization
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation, misleading,
hypothetical
lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation, hypothetical
lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation
602, 701, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation
602, lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation
602, lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation
602, 701, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation
602, 701, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation
402, 403, 602, 1002, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
60

33:10-19

34:11-17

42:16-43:7

51:17-52:1
54:22-55:13

56:12-23
57:25-58:18
59:24-60:16
62:13-20

75:7-11

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Ryu, Dongseok

2/29/2012

2/29/2012

83:9-20

Schin, Mincheol
Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012
3/2/2012

6:12-7:10
31:12-14

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

32:7-15

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

35:11-37:24

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

40:6-13

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

40:22-23

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

41:14-17

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

42:8-10

Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012

43:3-16

Schin, Mincheol
Schin, Mincheol

3/2/2012
3/2/2012

43:18-22
44:7-45:7

Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy

1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012

assumes facts
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation

79:9-81:16

Ryu, Dongseok

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

7:11-15
7:1-3
7:20-22
8:4-7
8:15-9:10
9:20-10:9
21:14-22:1
27:14-28:10
51:11-24
55:12-15
56:12-17

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 403, 602,
802, 1002, mischaracterization,
calls for legal conclusion,
incomplete
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002
lacks foundation, 402, 602, 802,
1002, mischaracterization,
incomplete
lacks foundation, ambiguous
lacks foundation, 402, 403, 602,
802, 1002, mischaracterization,
incomplete

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

85:15-21

32:16-18
34:23-35:10
38:2

40:14
41:2-12
41:18-20

41:22-42:4

45:9-21

8:1-3

61

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Sheppard, Timothy

1/24/2012

61:17-63:18

Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy

1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
1/24/2012
3/30/2012

67:9-14
69:20-70:2
115:11-20
116:9-11
117:7-11
117:5
26:9-25

Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy
Sheppard, Timothy

3/30/2012
3/30/2012
3/30/2012

27:3-12
27:14-18
28:16-29:13

Sheppard, Timothy

3/30/2012

29:15-17

Sheppard, Timothy

3/30/2012

39:14-40:1

Sheppard, Timothy

3/30/2012

39:8-10

Sheppard, Timothy

3/30/2012

40:4

Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy 30(b)(6)
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

7:11-17
8:20-9:6
13:5-9
44:11-17
44:4-8
60:5-12
123:9-124:17
123:5-6
125:20-126:13
125:12-17
129:6-10
6:12-14
11:5-11
19:23-20:4
24:14-19
25:2-4

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

63:2-8 MIL 9; 63:9-18
speculation lacks foundation

26:16-19 not testimony

Misleading mischaracterization
assumes facts
beyond scope of 30(B)(6);
mischaracterization of 30(B)(6)
topic; 64:5-6, 64:12, 64:17-21,
65:1-2; 65:12 not testimony
Misleading mischaracterization
assumes facts
Argumentative misleading
mischaracterization assumes
facts
Misleading mischaracterization
assumes facts

24:19-21; 24:24-25:12; 25:1418; 25:20-26:8
150:10-153:1
153:9-154:7
47:11-49:2

47:11-49:2
47:11-49:2

47:11-49:2

402 403 not testimony
speculation lacks foundation
assumes facts hypothetical
assumes facts hypothetical
129:11-17

402
402
62

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796

12/21/2011

64:2-65:14

Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Sheppard, Timothy ITC-796
Shin, Jaegwan

12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
12/21/2011
1/27/2012

187:22-188:2
188:23-189:18
188:15-19
188:9-10
188:12-13
188:21
190:11-22
190:25-2
191:4-5
5:18-23

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

7:7-11

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

7:14-18

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

8:13-15

02198.51855/4877234.1

beyond scope of 30(B)(6);
mischaracterization of 30(B)(6)
topic; 64:5-6, 64:12, 64:17-21,
65:1-2; 65:12 not testimony

Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
63

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

1/27/2012

11:1-8

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

12:1-14

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Ambiguous
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Ambiguous
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.

10:23-24

Shin, Jaegwan

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

16:11-14

02198.51855/4877234.1

64

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

12:15-16:6

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

17:10-18

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

18:15-25

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

19:1-19

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

20:5-22:11

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

23:10-25:8

02198.51855/4877234.1

Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Assumes facts
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Assumes facts
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Assumes facts
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; Assumes facts
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
65

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
17:19-18:14

19:20-20:4

22:12-23:9

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

1/27/2012

27:5-9

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

27:16-19

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

38:13-49:18

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

testimony is properly
admissible; misleading
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; lacks foundation
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated

26:2-25

Shin, Jaegwan

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

65:18-66:8

02198.51855/4877234.1

66

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

1/27/2012

68:12-71:23

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

72:8-19

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; mischaracterizes
testimony
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible; mischaracterizes
testimony
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.

66:24-67:8

Shin, Jaegwan

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

73:25-74:15

02198.51855/4877234.1

67

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

71:24-72:7

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

76:1-14

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

78:11-80:1

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

81:4-82:8

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

83:7-21

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

85:22-86:10

02198.51855/4877234.1

Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
68

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

1/27/2012

89:11-22

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

90:8-94:2

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

95:18-25

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated

88:1-25

Shin, Jaegwan

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

96:1-4

02198.51855/4877234.1

69

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

89:23-90:7

94:10-95:17

96:5-97:23

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

1/27/2012

102:24-104:4

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

106:21-22

Shin, Jaegwan

1/27/2012

108:7-109:17

Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012

that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.
Samsung objects to the
designation of testimony from
Mr. Shin on the grounds that
Apple has not demonstrated
that he is unavailable pursuant
to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 32(a)(4) or that his
testimony is properly
admissible.

97:24-98:18

Shin, Jaegwan

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

7:21-8:13

02198.51855/4877234.1

70

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

104:5-105:18

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

8:23-25
14:8-22
16:18-17:3
18:19-21
30:23-31:9
32:1-9

Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

32:16-19
33:14-34:6
44:8-50:19

Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il
Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012
4/20/2012

51:3-52:1
71:7-22
72:8-13
74:17-75:5
75:6-78:8

Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012

86:22-87:5

Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012

95:4-19

Sohn, Dae Il

4/20/2012

104:1-16

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

5:15-19
23:21-24:2
24:5-8
24:10
25:22-26:1
26:3-7
26:10-21
26:24-27:5
27:8-11
28:14-17
28:19-21
31:6-24
39:17-40:19
40:22-41:5
41:8-12
41:14-18
41:21-42:3

02198.51855/4877234.1

lacks foundation; calls for
speculation;

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

31:10-25
32:10-15; 32:20-33:13
34:7-36:13

lacks foundation; calls for
speculation; 602; 802;
lacks foundation; 602

ambiguous; overbroad; legal
conclusion; lacks foundation
ambiguous; lacks foundation;
assumes facts;
ambiguous; overbroad; legal
conclusion; lacks foundation
lacks foundation; ambiguous;
overbroad; calls for
speculation; 602

29:18-30:1; 30:4-15; 30:17-31:1

speculation, hypothetical, 602
speculation, hypothetical, 602
speculation, hypothetical, 602

71

39:6-9; 39:12-16

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

42:5-19
42:21-43:8
46:13-47:4
54:24-56:10
58:3-15
58:18-59:2
65:15-66:5
67:5-13
68:11-18

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

68:21-69:6
69:17-70:1
78:23-79:2

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

79:5-7
79:23-80:4
80:11-19

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011

80:22-81:3
82:20-83:9

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011

83:12-14
84:11-15

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011

84:18-20
91:4-9

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

91:12-13
91:18-23
92:8-10
92:12-13
94:20-95:2
95:22-96:6
96:12-21
98:5-10
98:15-23
99:1
99:3-6
101:19-102:6

Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

104:19-105:2

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS
43:21-23; 43:24-45:4; 45:16-22

speculation, hypothetical, 602
speculation, lacks foundation,
602, legal conclusion

speculation, lacks foundation,
602, legal conclusion

speculation, lacks foundation,
602, legal conclusion
speculation, lacks foundation,
602, legal conclusion
speculation, lacks foundation,
602, legal conclusion
lacks foundation, speculation,
602

lacks foundation, speculation,
602

72

68:2-5; 68:8-10

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011

105:4-19

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011

105:22-107:2
107:5-13
107:17-108:3
111:24-112:18
112:20-113:19

Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Der Velde, Himke
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/2/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

115:21-116:5
117:10-17
118:9-13
120:1-7
120:10-11
121:6-10
122:15-123:6
4:8-10
5:6-18
6:2-10
9:21-10:7
18:10-17
18:19-21
20:2-21:22
29:18-24

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

30:3-6

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

30:18-31:4
31:6-11
32:20-33:12

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

33:15-24

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

40:5-41:1
41:8-42:4
42:7-8
50:9-14
50:23
84:7-18
85:2-86:2
101:20-24
102:1

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS
lacks foundation, speculation,
602

lacks foundation, speculation,
602

ambiguous; compound
ambiguous; compound
lacks foundation, speculation,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, speculation,
ambiguous
ambiguous
lacks foundation, speculation,
ambiguous
lacks foundation, speculation,
ambiguous
602

ambiguous
ambiguous
73

21:23 - 22:3
25:15 - 29:17
25:15 - 29:17
32:1-5
32:1-5

602
38:10-11, 18-19; 48:11-18
21:23-22:3
42:9 - 43:4
51:8-10, 18 - 53:4
51:8-10, 18 - 53:4
84:19 - 85:1
86:3 - 86:24

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

102:3-5
102:9-10
102:13-17
104:24-106:17
131:4-24
132:1-8
132:11-15
132:17-24
133:1-7
133:9-14
133:17-19
134:3-12
134:15-18
135:24
136:1-2
136:5-10
136:13-16
136:19
137:4-21

ambiguous

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

138:20-142:1

incomplete; interrupted
witness

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

147:10-149:2
161:20-22
162:1-17
162:20-24
163: 3-14
163:17-164:1
164:8-14
164:17-165:3
169:19-21
169:24-170:3
170:10-22
171:2-16
171:23-172:3
172:6-7
173:13-23
174:2-16
174:18-20
184:24-185:18
195:4-8

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

02198.51855/4877234.1

102:18-103:13

legal conclusion; ambiguous
legal conclusion; ambiguous

legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
legal conclusion; ambiguous
legal conclusion; ambiguous
legal conclusion; ambiguous
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
145:4 - 146:7; 148:8 - 21;
215:22 - 217:8
145:4 - 146:7; 148:8 - 21;
215:22 - 217:8
149:3 - 150:22

speculation
speculation
speculation
speculation; compound
asked and answered
speculation
speculation

speculation

188:18 - 189:21
ambiguous; incomplete
74

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

195:10-18
195:21-24
196:2-197:5
197:8-20
197:23-198:4
198:6-18

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

198:20-21

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

198:24-199:6

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

199:9-10

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

199:22-200:22
201:1-5
201:8-17
201:19-23
202:3-10
202:13-22
203:1-11
203:14-19
203:22-204:10

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011

204:13-24
205:3-5
205:7-10

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

205:17-206:3

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

206:7-15

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

206:18-23

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

207:2

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

207:5-6

02198.51855/4877234.1

compound; hypothetical
hypothetical
hypothetical
hypothetical
hypothetical
hypothetical; ambiguous;
compound; speculation
hypothetical; ambiguous;
compound; speculation
hypothetical; ambiguous;
compound; speculation
hypothetical; ambiguous;
compound; speculation

legal conclusion; compound;
402; 602
legal conclusion; 402; 602
legal conclusion; 402; 602
legal conclusion; ambiguous;
402; 602
asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
75

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS

Samsung Objections/Counter ‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

APPLE'S DESIGNATIONS

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan

11/4/2011

207:8-10

Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Van Lieshout, Gert Jan
Yeo, Jungmin
Yeo, Jungmin

11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
11/4/2011
2/2/2012
2/2/2012

212:2-16
212:20:213:4
213:7-12
213:15-21
213:24-214:13
214:23-215:5
215:8
231:1-11
231:14-20
231:22-232:5
6:5
12:9-13:17

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

28:1-21

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

29:18-21

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

30:21-24

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

34:13-21

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

34:24-38:20

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

66:21-68:21

Yeo, Jungmin
Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012
2/2/2012

71:23-72:5
73:20-23

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

77:24-78:17

Yeo, Jungmin

2/2/2012

SAMSUNG'S OBJECTIONS

82:2-21

02198.51855/4877234.1

SAMSUNG'S COUNTERDESIGNATIONS

asked and answered; legal
conclusion; compound;
ambiguous; 402; 602
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8
215:9 - 217:8

20:22-21:2
403, 602, 802, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation
402, lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation
402, lacks foundation, assumes
facts, speculation
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation,
narrative, ambiguous
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation,
narrative, ambiguous
402, 403, 602, 802,. lacks
foundation, assumes facts,
speculation, ambiguous
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, speculation,
ambiguous
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts, ambiguous
402, 403, 602, 802, lacks
foundation
402, 403, 602, lacks foundation,
assumes facts

76

31:1-10

46:4-48:3; 48:20-49:4

68:23-69:12

APPLE'S OBJECTIONS