Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 672

*** EXHIBIT 4 FILED IN ERROR WITH CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION . DOCUMENT LOCKED. DOCUMENT TO BE REFILED LATER.. *** EXHIBITS re #667 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal re Samsung's Motion to Supplement Invalidity Contentions (Briggs Declaration in Support of Samsung's Motion to Supplement Invalidity Contentions) filed bySamsung Electronics Co. Ltd.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10, #11 Exhibit 11)(Related document(s) #667 ) (Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 1/27/2012) Modified on 1/27/2012 (feriab, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT 5

EXHIBIT D-8
SAMSUNG’S INVALIDITY CLAIM CHARTS FOR SUPERCLOCK! VERSION 4.0.4 FOR THE
SYSTEM 7 OPERATING SYSTEM ON A MACINTOSH POWERBOOK ("SuperClock! for System 7")
SuperClock! 4.0.4 is an application written by Steven Christensen for the Macintosh System 6 and System 7 operating systems. It is
further described in the SuperClock! 4.0.4 ReadMe file, as discussed in the Deposition of Steven Christensen, October 26, 2011,
Exhibit 984 ("ReadMe File"). For demonstrative purposes, this chart uses a Macintosh PowerBook 165c (first released on February
10, 1993) running Mac OS System 7.1 (first released in August, 1992); however, other portable computers using System 6 or 7 and
running SuperClock! are also included as prior art to the '002 patent.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

[1A] An interactive computercontrolled display system
comprising:

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses an interactive computer-controlled display system comprising
a processor and a data display screen coupled to the processor.

a processor;

For example, the Mac PowerBook 165c, which was sold with System 7 installed, is a laptop
computer including one or more processors and a display screen coupled to the processors.

a data display screen coupled to
the processor;

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

[1B] a cursor control device
coupled to said processor for
positioning a cursor on said data
display screen;

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a cursor control device (e.g. trackball) coupled to said
processor for positioning a cursor on said data display screen.

[1C] a window generation and
control logic coupled to the
processor and data display screen
to create an operating
environment for a plurality of
individual programming modules
associated with different
application programs that provide
status and/or control functions,

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a window generation and control logic coupled to the
processor and data display screen to create an operating environment for a plurality of individual
programming modules (e.g. a clock module and a battery status module) associated with different
application programs (a clock program and a battery program) that provide status (the time and
the battery status) and/or control functions.

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

[1D] wherein the window
generation and control logic
generates and displays a first
window region having a plurality
of display areas on said data
display screen,

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the window generation and control logic generates and
displays a first window region (e.g. menu bar) having a plurality of display areas (e.g. the clock
area and the battery status area) on said data display screen.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

[1E] wherein the first window
region is independently displayed
and independently active of any
application program, and

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the first window region (e.g. menu bar) is independently
displayed and independently active of any application program.

02198.51855/4429789.1

For example, System 7 includes a single, universal menu bar that remains present across all
programs.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

[1F] wherein each of the plurality SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that each of the plurality of display areas (e.g. the clock area
of display areas is associated with and battery status area) is associated with one of the plurality of individual programming modules
one of the plurality of individual
(e.g. the clock module and the battery status module).
programming modules,
For example, "SuperClock! displays the time and date near the right end of the menu bar. If you're
using a portable Macintosh, it will also display the battery level; the battery icon will include a
little lightning bolt when the battery is charging." ReadMe File at ¶1.

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

[1G] the first window region and
the plurality of independent
display areas implemented in a
window layer that appears on top
of application programming
windows that may be generated;
and

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that first window region (e.g. the menu bar) and the plurality
of independent display areas (e.g. the clock are and the battery status area) are implemented in a
window layer that appears on top of application programming windows (e.g. Microsoft Word)
that may be generated.

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Showing that the menu bar is on top of the word programming application.)
[1H] an indicia generation logic
coupled to the data display screen
to execute at least one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules to
generate information for display
in one of the plurality of display
areas in the first window region,

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses an indicia generation logic coupled to the data display screen
to execute at least one of the plurality of individual programming modules to generate information
for display in one of the plurality of display areas in the first window region.
For example, "SuperClock! displays the time and date near the right end of the menu bar. If you're
using a portable Macintosh, it will also display the battery level; the battery icon will include a
little lightning bolt when the battery is charging." ReadMe File at ¶1.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

[1I] wherein at least one of the
plurality of display areas and its
associated programming module
is sensitive to user input, and

SuperClock! for System 7

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that at least one of the plurality of display areas and its
associated programming module is sensitive to user input.
For example, "If you want to hide the clock for awhile (for instance, if you're doing a presentation
in MacroMind Director ), hold down the option key and click on the clock." ReadMe File at ¶3.
"If you're running on a portable Macintosh, hold down the control key and click on the battery

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

indicator to put the computer to sleep." ReadMe File at ¶4.
"Clicking on the clock (with no keys held down) toggles between the time, date, and a count
down/count up timer (clicking on the little timer icon will start or stop the timer)." ReadMe File
at ¶5.

(Clicking on the clock area twice changes the clock into a timer. Clicking on the timer icon then
starts and stops the timer.)

[1J] further wherein the window
generation and control logic and
the indicia generation logic use
message-based communication to
exchange information to
coordinate activities of the indicia

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the window generation and control logic and the indicia
generation logic use message-based communication to exchange information to coordinate
activities of the indicia generation logic to enable interactive display activity.
For example, SuperClock! communicates with other programs: "Starting with version 4.0,
SuperClock! uses a new method of determining when a screen saver is running that essentially

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

generation logic to enable
interactive display activity.

asks the screen saver itself. Support for this feature was developed by Berkeley Systems for After
Dark. It's also supported in recent versions of Pyro! and DarkSide. What this means is that
SuperClock! will not hide for older screen savers (Moire comes to mind), and some presentation
applications in full screen mode. If you run into one of these cases and can get in touch with the
author, please feel free to point him/her to me and I can let 'em know about a really easy change
that needs to be made." ReadMe File at ¶7.

[2] The display system defined in
claim 1 wherein the first window
region comprises a control strip.

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the first window region comprises a control strip.
For example, to the extent that this claim is more limited than Claim 1, the menu bar permits
control of the clock:
"If you want to hide the clock for awhile (for instance, if you're doing a presentation in
MacroMind Director ), hold down the option key and click on the clock." ReadMe File at ¶3.
"If you're running on a portable Macintosh, hold down the control key and click on the battery
indicator to put the computer to sleep." ReadMe File at ¶4.
Clicking on the clock (with no keys held down) toggles between the time, date, and a count
down/count up timer (clicking on the little timer icon will start or stop the timer). ReadMe File
at ¶5.
Furthermore, the menu bar allows for the selection of menu options from a given application.

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Ctrl-clicking on the battery puts the computer to sleep.)

(The menu bar allows for control of computer functions.)
[3] The display system defined in
claim 1 wherein said at least one
display area is variably sized.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that at least one display area is variably sized.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(SuperClock! showing that the clock area is variably sized depending on the number of characters
in the time.)
[4] The display system defined in
claim 1 wherein size of the first
window region is variable.

The size of the first window region (e.g. menu bar) is variable.

(Compare Apple's Infringement Contentions at Ex. 1-3.)
Furthermore, it would have been obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art of user
interface design to combine the menu bar with the well-known principals of image and window

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

re-sizing. Other windows of System 7 are fully re-sizeable.
Moreover, the asserted '002 patent itself states: "Adjustments to the size of the window may
comprise either an increase in the height of the window, the width of the window, or both. . . . The
definition and use of windows is well-known in the art." U.S. Patent No. 6,439,002 (Christensen)
at 7:6-10 (emphasis added).
[6] The display system defined in
claim 4 wherein the first window
region is sized such that all of the
plurality of display areas are
visible.

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses the first window region sized such that all of the plurality of
display areas are visible.

[7] The display system defined in
claim 4 wherein the first window
region is sized such that a portion
of the plurality of display areas is
visible.

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses the first window region sized such that a portion of the
plurality of display areas is visible.

For example, all menu options are typically visible. "Once it's installed, it [SuperClock!] will
display the time on the menu bar as long as there's room for it." ReadMe File at ¶3.

For example, "Once it's installed, it will display the time on the menu bar as long as there's room
for it; various combinations of small screen sizes, large number of menus, or a large clock font
could cause the clock to be hidden. If you want to hide the clock for awhile (for instance, if you're
doing a presentation in MacroMind Director ), hold down the option key and click on the clock."
ReadMe File at ¶3.
Furthermore, it would have been obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art of user
interface design to combine the menu bar with the well-known principals of image and window
re-sizing. Other windows of System 7 are fully re-sizeable.
Moreover, the asserted '002 patent itself states: "Adjustments to the size of the window may
comprise either an increase in the height of the window, the width of the window, or both. . . . The
definition and use of windows is well-known in the art." U.S. Patent No. 6,439,002 (Christensen)
at 7:6-10 (emphasis added).

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
[9] The display system defined in
claim 1 wherein at least one of
the display areas acts to provide
access to control information
when selected.

SuperClock! for System 7

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that at least one of the display areas acts to provide access to
control information when selected.
For example, the System 7 menu bar includes an Apple Icon, which provides access to system
controls.

(The Apple Icon provides access to Control Panels and application controls.)

[10] The display system of claim
9 wherein said at least one of the
plurality of display areas displays
an additional display element.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that at least one of the plurality of display areas displays an
additional display element.
For example, the System 7 menu bar includes a clock that will display a timer when selected.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Clicking on the clock area twice changes the clock into a timer.)
Furthermore, the System 7 Apple Icon displays additional menu options when selected.

(Touching the Apple Icon on the menu bar displays a control menu tab.)
Moreover, the Control Panels option brings up a Control Panel when selected.

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Compare Apple's Infringement Contentions at Ex. 1-3, e.g. Claim 4.)

(Selecting "Control Panels" brings up a control panel allowing system control.)
[11] The display system defined
in claim 1 wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
individually and variably sized.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that each of the plurality of display areas (e.g. the clock area
and battery status area) is individually and variably sized.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

[12] The display system defined
in claim 1 wherein the first
window region always appears in
front of application windows.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the first window region always appears in front of
application windows.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Showing that the menu bar is on top of the word programming application.)
[13] The display system defined
in claim 1 wherein the first
window region is implemented in
a private window layer that
appears in front of windows for
all applications layers.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the first window region is implemented in a private
window layer that appears in front of windows for all applications layers.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Showing that the menu bar is on top of the word programming application.)
[14A] An interactive computercontrolled display system
comprising:

See [1A].

a processor;
a data display screen coupled to
the processor;
[14B] a cursor control device
coupled to said processor for
positioning a cursor on said data
display screen;
[14C] window generation and
control logic coupled to the
processor and data display screen
to create an operating
environment for a plurality of
individual programming modules

02198.51855/4429789.1

See [1B].

See [1C].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
associated with different
application programs that provide
status and/or control functions,
[14D] wherein the window
generation and control logic
generates and displays a first
window-region having a plurality
of display areas on said data
display screen,
[14E] wherein the first window
region is independently displayed
and independently active of any
application program, and
[14F] wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
associated with one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules,
[14G] the first window region
and the plurality of independent
display areas implemented in a
window layer that appears on top
of
application programming
windows that may be generated;
and
[14H] at least one indicia
graphics generation logic coupled
to the processor and the window
generation and control logic,

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1D].

See [1E].

See [1F].

See [1G].

See [1H] and [1I].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
wherein said at least one indicia
graphics generation logic
generates user sensitive graphics
for display in at least one data
display area by executing at least
one of the plurality of individual
programming modules;
[14I] wherein the window
generation and control logic
determines when said at least one
data display area has been
selected by the user and signals
said at least one indicia graphics
generation logic in response to
user selection, and further
wherein said at least one indicia
graphics generation logic initiates
a response from said at least one
of the plurality of programming
modules.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the window generation and control logic determines
when at least one data display area (e.g., clock area) has been selected by the user and signals at
least one indicia graphics generation logic in response to the user selection, where the indicia
graphics generation logic initiates a response from at least one of the plurality of programming
modules (e.g., clock module).
For example, "If you want to hide the clock for awhile (for instance, if you're doing a presentation
in MacroMind Director ), hold down the option key and click on the clock." ReadMe File at ¶3.
"If you're running on a portable Macintosh, hold down the control key and click on the battery
indicator to put the computer to sleep." ReadMe File at ¶4.
"Clicking on the clock (with no keys held down) toggles between the time, date, and a count
down/count up timer (clicking on the little timer icon will start or stop the timer)." ReadMe File
at ¶5.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Clicking on the clock area twice changes the clock into a timer. Clicking on the timer icon then
starts and stops the timer.)
See also [1J].
[15] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein the first
window region is always visible
to the user.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7 discloses that the first window region is always visible to the user.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

(Showing that the menu bar is on top of the word programming application.)
[16] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein the first
window region comprises a
control strip.
[17] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein said at least
one display area is variably sized.
[18] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
individually and variably sized.
[19] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein the first
window region always appears in
front of application windows.
[20] The display system defined
in claim 14 wherein the first
window region is implemented in

02198.51855/4429789.1

See [2].

See also [11].

See [11].

See [12].

See [13].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
a private window layer that
appears in front of windows for
all applications layers.
[25A] A system comprising:
a window generation and control
logic to create an operating
environment for a plurality of
individual programming modules
associated with different
application programs that provide
status and/or control functions,
[25B] wherein the window
generation and control logic
generates and displays a first
window region having a plurality
of display areas,
[25C] wherein the first window
region is independently displayed
and independently active of any
application program, and
[25D] wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
associated with one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules,
[25E] an indicia generation logic
coupled to the data display screen
to execute at least one of the
plurality of individual

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1C].

See [1D].

See [1E].

See [1F].

See [1H].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
programming modules to
generate information for display
in one of the plurality of display
areas in the first window region,
[25F] wherein at least one of the
plurality of display areas and its
associated programming module
is sensitive to user input, and
[25G] further wherein the
window generation and control
logic and the indicia generation
logic use message-based
communication to exchange
information to coordinate
activities of the indicia generation
logic to enable interactive display
activity.
[26A] An interactive computercontrolled display system
comprising:
a means for positioning a cursor
on a data display screen;
[26B] a means for creating an
operating environment for a
plurality of individual
programming modules associated
with different application
programs that provide status
and/or control functions,

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1I].

See [1J].

See [1B]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.
See [1C]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
[26C] wherein a first window
region is displayed having a
plurality of display areas on said
data display screen,
[26D] wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
associated with one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules,
[26E] the first window region and
the plurality of independent
display areas implemented in a
window layer that appears on top
of application programming
windows that may be generated;
and
[26F] a means for executing at
least one of the plurality of
individual programming modules
to generate information for
display in one of the plurality of
display areas in the first window
region,
[26G] wherein at least one of the
plurality of display areas and its
associated programming module
is-sensitive to user input, wherein
an interactive display activity is
enabled.
[27] The display system defined

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1D].

See [1F].

See [1G].

See [1H]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

See [1I] and [1J].

See [2].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
in claim 26 wherein the first
window region comprises a
control strip.
[28] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein said at least
one of the plurality of display
areas is variably sized.
[29] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein size of the
first window region is variable.
[31] The display system defined
in claim 29 wherein the first
window regions is sized such that
all of the plurality of display
areas are visible.
[32] The display system defined
in claim 29 wherein the first
window regions is sized such that
a portion of the plurality of
display areas is visible.
[34] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein said at least
one of the plurality of display
areas acts to provide access to
control information when
selected.
[35] The display system defined
in claim 34 wherein said at least
one of the data areas display an
additional display element.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [3].

See [4].

See [6].

See [7].

See [9].

See [10].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
[36] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
individually and variably sized.
[37] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein the first
window region always appears in
front of application windows.
[38] The display system defined
in claim 26 wherein the first
window region is implemented in
a private window layer that
appears in front of windows for
all application layers.
[39A] An interactive computercontrolled display system
comprising:
a means for positioning a cursor
on said data display screen;
[39B] a means for creating an
operating environment for a
plurality of individual
programming modules associated
with different application
programs that provide status
and/or control functions,
[39C] wherein a first window
region is displayed having a
plurality of display areas on said

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [11].

See [12].

See [13].

See [1B]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.
See [1C]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

See [1D].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
data display screen,
[39D] wherein the first window
region is independently displayed
and independently active of any
application program, and
[39E] wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
associated with one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules,
[39F] the first window region and
the plurality of independent
display areas implemented in a
window layer that appears on top
of application programming
windows that may be generated;
[39G] a means for generating
user sensitive graphics for display
in at least one data display area;

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1E].

See [1F].

See [1G].

See also [1H] and [1I]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor
executing computer instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7
discloses a “processor executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple
failed to identify a corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a
corresponding algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the
prior art.

[39H] a means for determining
when said at least one data
display area has been selected by
the user; and

See [1I]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

[39I] a means for initiating a

See also [1J]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002

SuperClock! for System 7

response from said at least one of
the plurality of programming
modules.

computer instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a
“processor executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to
identify a corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a
corresponding algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the
prior art.

[40] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein the first
window region is always visible
to the user.
[41] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein the first
window region comprises a
control strip.
[42] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein said at least
one data display area is variably
sized.
[43] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein each of the
plurality of display areas is
individually and variably sized.
[44] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein the first
window region always appears in
front of application windows.
[45] The display system defined
in claim 39 wherein the first
window region is implemented in
a private window layer that

See [15].

02198.51855/4429789.1

See [2].

See [3].

See [11].

See [12].

See [13].

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
appears in front of windows for
all applications layers.
[50A] A system comprising:
a means for window generation
and control to create an operating
environment for a plurality of
individual programming modules
associated with different
application programs that provide
status and/or control functions,
[50B] wherein the means for
window generation and control
generates and displays a first
window region having a plurality
of display areas,

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1C]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

See [1D]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

[50C] wherein the first window
See [1E].
region is independently displayed
and independently active of any
application program, and
[50D] wherein each of the
See [1F].
plurality of display areas is
associated with one of the
plurality of individual
programming modules,
[50E] the first window region and See [1G].
the plurality of independent
display areas implemented in a
window layer that appears on top

02198.51855/4429789.1

Asserted Claims From
U.S. Patent No. 6,493,002
of application programming
windows that may be generated;
[50F] a means for indicia
generation coupled to the data
display screen to execute at least
one of the plurality of individual
programming modules to
generate information for display
in one of the plurality of display
areas in the first window region,
[50G] wherein at least one of the
plurality of display areas and its
associated programming module
is sensitive to user input, and
[50H] further wherein the means
for window generation and
control and the means for indicia
generation use message-based
communication to exchange
information to coordinate
activities of the means for indicia
generation to enable interactive
display activity.

02198.51855/4429789.1

SuperClock! for System 7

See [1H]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.

See [1I].

See [1J]. In its infringement contentions, Apple only identified a “processor executing computer
instructions” as the corresponding structure. SuperClock! for System 7 discloses a “processor
executing computer instructions.” In its infringement contentions, Apple failed to identify a
corresponding algorithm. To the extent Apple is allowed and able to identify a corresponding
algorithm, Samsung reserves the right to identify a corresponding algorithm in the prior art.