Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 822

Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Proposed Order, #2 [Redacted Public Version] Apple's Reply Brief, #3 [Redacted Public Version] Olson Reply Declaration, #4 Exhibit C to [Redacted Public Version] Olson Reply Declaration, #5 Exhibit E to [Redacted Public Version] Olson Reply Declaration, #6 Exhibit G to [Redacted Public Version] Olson Reply Declaration, *** DOCUMENT LOCKED [822-7] AT FILER'S REQUEST. *** #7 Exhibit I to [Redacted Public Version] Olson Reply Declaration, #8 [Redacted Public Version] Roberts Reply Declaration, #9 [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #10 Exhibit 1 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #11 Exhibit 2 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #12 Exhibit 3 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #13 Exhibit 4 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #14 Exhibit 5 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #15 Exhibit 6 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #16 Exhibit 7 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #17 Exhibit 8 Part 1 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #18 Exhibit 8 Part 2 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #19 Exhibit 11 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #20 Exhibit 12 to [Redacted Public Version] Kim Reply Declaration, #21 Certificate/Proof of Service)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 3/20/2012) Modified on 3/21/2012 (wv, COURT STAFF). Modified on 3/21/2012 (wv, COURT STAFF).

AnandTech - Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 4G LTE Review

Page 5 of 7

REPLY

RE: nice review by webmastir on Monday, August 15, 2011

wondering same thing =/
webmastir
REPLY

RE: nice review by dendysutrisna on Monday, August 29, 2011

dendysutris
na

Yes thanks for tablet comparison table.
And i agreed, How expensive Verizon's data plan , though someone took a 10GB quota, with
a speed 10X 3G, it does not mean anything if its use is not wise. Anyway remains its an
internet connection will run only no more than half a day.

REPLY

Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon by Mugur on Monday, August 15, 2011

The 16GB 3G European version (21.6 Mbps) is 400 euros plus taxes, less than iPad 2 3G...
Mugur

Too bad it is removed from the shelves by that Apple patent dispute. Anand, did you really feel that it
is an iPad clone by "looks and feel"? :-)

REPLY

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon by TypeS on Monday,
August 15, 2011
TypeS
REPLY

While I don't agree with the patents granted to Apple or the legitimacy of its numerous suits
against Samsung/Motorola/HTC, you can clearly tell by looking at the front fascia that
Samsung can't claim innocence and ignorance as to just how much it looks like the iPad.
And before someone replies saying "Well there's only so many ways to design a tablet!", take
a look ASUS EEE Transformer. Do you see Apple firing snide remarks or starting suits with
ASUS?
The Samsung Galaxy S II's aesthetics also mimic the iPhone's look to an extent (did they
really need to exaggerate the home button against the other two beside it; which are almost
non visible). Motorola won acclaim with its' Droid and it's successors and you don't see Apple
suing them over how similar the phone looks at least.
While I have high respect for Samsung and the innovations they've brought to the LCD
market, they're a Korean company and Korean companies often like to mimic (rip off) highly
successive models. Look no further than Hyundai's cars and their outward styling, they look
like premium Japanese or German luxury cars.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4605/samsung-galaxy-tab-101-4g-lte-review

AnandTech - Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 4G LTE Review

Page 6 of 7

Where Toyota and Mercedes may not care that their car styles are mimiced, Samsung caught
the eye of Silicon Valley's "magic making" CEO, and they did quite brazen and stupidly.

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon by Mugur on
Monday, August 15, 2011
Mugur

Well, I had both of them in my hands and the only thing common to both and
uncommon for the others is the great quality of the materials. I also checked on the net

REPLY

the European patent Apple is hanging on and it'a 2 page sketch of "handheld
computer" from 2004 that looks like every tablet from Star Trek to ... any tablet. Just a
rectangular surface with round edges. In my opinion, Apple just wanted to bury its best
competitor...

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon by
robinthakur on Monday, August 15, 2011

No, it looks like a White iPad 2 unless you look very closely. Having seen a

robinthakur

Galxy S 2 over the weekend up close, it does bear a very close similarity to an
iPhone 4, and the Galaxy S 1 looked like a 3GS. These occurences are not

REPLY

accidental, they are designed to fool the honest consumer! Samsung should not
be able to get away with this, however you slice it.

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon by
MonkeyPaw on Monday, August 15, 2011
MonkeyPa
w
REPLY

And when you say "very closely", do you mean reading the labels or using
the OS? Those are pretty big differences, IMO. There's no giant Apple on
the back, there's no home button on the front, one runs iOS, the other
Android. Logos aside, the back even has different details, and the charge
port, while similar, is not the same, and isn't even found on the same side
as iPad. Will the Tab even work with Apple's extras, like cases and
adapters?
To me, the Tab 10.1 just might be more magical than iPad2, and THAT is
why Apple is firing back at it. Good thing Apple doesn't make cars, or we'd
all be screwed.

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore soon
by kmmatney on Monday, August 15, 2011
kmmatney
REPLY

I checked out my co-workers Samsung phone, and I have to say
even the general software layout looks like an iPhone clone. You
can see for yourself in this image:
http://mos.futurenet.com/techradar/Review%20images...

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4605/samsung-galaxy-tab-101-4g-lte-review

AnandTech - Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 4G LTE Review

Page 7 of 7

pretty much a complete iOS ripoff...

RE: Great tablet... too bad you won't be able to buy it anymore
soon by medi01 on Monday, August 15, 2011

Claiming that Android is a iOS ripoff, wow...

medi01
REPLY

1

2

3

4

5

Next »
VIEW ALL COMMENTS

POST A COMMENT

Copyright © 1997-2012 AnandTech, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms, Conditions and Privacy
Click Here for Advertising Information

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4605/samsung-galaxy-tab-101-4g-lte-review