Campbell et al v. Facebook Inc.

Filing 162

Exhibits in Support of 147 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal and Documents in Support of Facebooks Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class Certification (Dkt. 149) filed by Facebook Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Replacement for Dkt. 147-1 (Declaration of Nikki Stitt Sokol In Support Of Defendant Facebook, Inc.s Administrative Motion to File Documents in Support of its Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class Certification Under Seal), # 2 Replacement for Dkt. 147-2 ([Proposed] Order Authorizing the Filing of Documents Under Seal), # 3 Replacement for Dkt. 147-5 ((Exhibit 3) Unredacted Chorba Declaration Motion to Seal), # 4 Replacement for Dkt. 147-6 ((Exhibit 4) Redacted Chorba Declaration Motion to Seal), # 5 Replacement for Dkt. 149-1 (Redacted Chorba Declaration Opposition to Class Certification), # 6 Replacement for Dkt. 149-7 (Redacted Expert Report of Dr. Catherine Tucker Opposition to Class Certification), # 7 Replacement for Dkt. 154-11 ((Exhibit 66) Unredacted Tucker Expert Report Motion to Seal), # 8 Replacement for Dkt. 154-12 ((Exhibit 67) Redacted Tucker Expert Report Motion to Seal), # 9 Replacement for Dkt. 155-1 (Unredacted Appendix of Evidence (Part 1 of 19) Motion to Seal), # 10 Replacement for Dkt. 156-9 (Unredacted Appendix of Evidence (Part 19 of 19) Motion to Seal), # 11 Replacement for Dkt. 157-1 (Redacted Appendix of Evidence (Part 1 of 13) Opposition to Class Certification), # 12 Replacement for Dkt. 157-13 (Unredacted Appendix of Evidence (Part 13 of 13)) Motion to Seal))(Chorba, Christopher) (Filed on 1/22/2016) Modified on 1/22/2016 (vlkS, COURT STAFF).

Replacement for
Dkt. 147-2

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13

GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
JOSHUA A. JESSEN, SBN 222831
[e-mail]
JEANA BISNAR MAUTE, SBN 290573
[e-mail]
PRIYANKA RAJAGOPALAN, SBN 278504
[e-mail]
ASHLEY M. ROGERS, SBN 286252
[e-mail]
1881 Page Mill Road
Palo Alto, California 94304
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
CHRISTOPHER CHORBA, SBN 216692
[e-mail]
333 South Grand Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90071
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
Attorneys for Defendant
FACEBOOK, INC.

14

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

16

OAKLAND DIVISON

17
18
19
20
21
22
23

MATTHEW CAMPBELL and MICHAEL
HURLEY,
Plaintiffs,
v.
FACEBOOK, INC.,
Defendant.

Case No. C 13-05996 PJH
PUTATIVE CLASS ACTION
[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING
THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER
SEAL (CIV. L.R. 79-5(B))
HEARING:
Date:
March 16, 2016
Time:
9:00 a.m.
Location: Courtroom 3, Third Floor
The Honorable Phyllis J. Hamilton

24
25
26
27
28
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP

[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
Case No. C 13-05996 PJH

1

On January 15, 2016, Defendant Facebook, Inc. filed an administrative motion to file under

2

seal documents related to Defendant’s opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification.

3

Facebook also submitted a declaration in support of that administrative motion on January 15, 2016.

4

Having considered Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s administrative motion to file under seal, all materials

5

submitted in support thereof, and other records on file, the Court hereby GRANTS the administrative

6

motion to file under seal. Therefore, the following documents may be filed under seal:

7

The Court authorizes the filing under seal of the following documents in their entirety:

8

Exhibits A, B, C, D, L, M, N, O, P, Q, S, T, U, V, FF, GG, HH, KK, and LL to the Declaration of

9

Christopher Chorba In Support of Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for

10

Class Certification; and Exhibits PP, QQ, RR, SS, TT, UU, VV, WW, XX, YY, ZZ, and AAA to the

11

Declaration of Dan Fechete In Support of Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’

12
13
14

Motion for Class Certification.
The Court also authorizes the filing under seal of portions of Facebook’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification, as designated below:

15
16
17

Document
Facebook’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification

Sealable Portions
2:17-18, 24-2; 3:3-4; 3:16-17; 4:9-17; 5:23-24;
6:1-3, 17-21; 7:1-16; 7:20-22; 8:4-14, 20-22;
9:10-14, 19, 22, 26; 11-1, 3-8, 8-9, 9-12, 1618,19-22, 23-28; 12:1-1, 18-22, 26, 28; 13:1-10,
26-28; 14:4, 11-12, 18-19; 14:21-23; 15:15-16,
24-25; 16:1-4, 14-24, 26; 18:14-15, 19; 20:5-6,
12-13, 17-20; 21:7-9, 15-19, 23-28; 23:7-10, 2526; 25:3-4; 26:10-12, 12; 27:21; 29:3-14; 30:2-3,
5-6
2:12; 2:17; 2:22; 3:2-11; 3:17-18; 3:18-19; 3:2021; 4:1-2; 4:3-7; 4:24-28; 5:1-2; 5:2-4; 5:16-20;
5:23-25; 12:14, 12:16; 12:18
Page 1, text between “response contained” and
“detailed entries”

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP

Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Exhibit R - April 10, 2015 Letter from David
Rudolph to Joshua Jessen
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

Page 2, text between “Interrogatory No. 5 as
follows” and “Plaintiffs’ Responses to
Facebook’s Contention”
1

[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
Case No. C 13-05996 PJH

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Document

Sealable Portions

Exhibit W – July 24, 2015 Letter from David
Rudolph to Joshua Jessen
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

84:3; 84:5; 84:6-10; 107:1-2; Errata 9:23; Errata
94:21; Errata 94:23; Errata 94:25; Errata 197:7;
Errata 197:10; Errata 254:1-5

Exhibit BB – Excerpts from June 30, 2015
Deposition of Jiakai Liu
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

56:1-18; 56:20-21; 77:4; 77:6; 77:9-25; 78:1-8;
78:11; 78:13-14; 78:16; 78:18-23; 91:1-4; 91:8-9;
91:12-15; 91:18-20; 91:22-25; 92:2; 92:5-15;
156:1; 156:6-12; 156:18-19; 156:21-25; 157:3-8;
157:10-13; 157:15-18; 157:21-22; 190:4; 190:910; 190:12-13; 190:17-19; 190:23-24; 252:3-6;
252:12-14; 252:17; Errata 28:12; Errata 29:5;
Errata 30:7; Errata 32:7; Errata 52:25; Errata
53:1; Errata 65:19; Errata 79:19; Errata 92:16;
Errata 97:17; Errata 101:8; Errata 102:2; Errata
128:21; Errata 129:11; Errata “throughout”;
Errata 163:4; Errata 178:23; Errata 179:12; Errata
197:14; Errata 212:3; Errata 223:9; Errata
251:2,4; Errata 262:23
290:15-17; 290:19-21

Exhibit CC – Excerpts from September 25, 2015
Deposition of Ray He

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Exhibit DD – Excerpts from December 18, 2015
Deposition of Fernando Torres
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

105:3-355:6

Exhibit EE - Excerpts from December 16, 2015
Deposition of Jennifer Golbeck
Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

43:6-7; 43:10-11; 43:14; 43:17-22; 43:24-25;
44:1-4; 44:10-16; 44:19-25; 83:5; 83:8-22; 106:12; 106:6-11; 106:15; 106:17-18; 106:21-23;
106:25; Errata 28:14-16; Errata 28:17-24; Errata
28:25; Errata 29:4; Errata 29:9; Errata 30:17;
Errata 31:24; Errata 32:7; Errata 32:10; Errata
32:14; Errata 36:34; Errata 37:13; Errata 38:4, 6;
Errata 38:12, 14, 15; Errata 39:3; Errata 40:20;
Errata 41:5; Errata 41:7; Errata 41:12, 14; Errata
41:19; Errata 42:7; Errata 43:10; Errata 43:18;
Errata 44:22; Errata 46:25; Errata 48:13; Errata

Exhibit II – Excerpts from October 28, 2015
Deposition of Ray He

26
27
28
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP

2
[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
Case No. C 13-05996 PJH

1

Document

Sealable Portions
48:21; Errata 49:11-14; Errata 49:15, 16; Errata
51:15, 16; Errata 52:16; Errata 54:4, 6; Errata
54:9, 11; Errata 59:19; Errata 58:25; Errata 60:22;
Errata 62:10; Errata 62:22; Errata 65:7; Errata
65:9-10; Errata 65:16; Errata 66:18; Errata 67:14; Errata 68:25; Errata 72:4; Errata 74:7; Errata
75:2; Errata 76:15; Errata 78:7; Errata 78:8;
Errata 78:19; Errata 79:15; Errata 79:20; Errata
80:2; Errata 80:5; Errata 80:21; Errata 81:19;
Errata 83:5; Errata 83:10; Errata 84:5; Errata
88:20; Errata 90:18; Errata 93:23; Errata 96:4;
Errata 96:9l Errata 100:24; Errata 102:20; Errata
102:25; Errata 103:14; Errata 106:1; Errata 106:9;
Errata 107:7; Errata 107:17; Errata 109:5; Errata
110:7; Errata 110:9
45:17-18; 45:24-25; 54:1-17; 75:1; 75:3-25; 76:111; 76:18-25; 77:1-6; 77:11-14; 77:16-19; 77:21;
77:24-25; 118:2-8; 118:11; 118:13-20; 118:2325; 119:1-4; 119:6-25; Errata, Global; Errata,
Global; Errata, Global; Errata, 47:21; Errata,
48:20-23; Errata, 76:24
ToC, II; ToC, II.B; ToC, II.C; ToC, III ToC,
III.B; ToC, V; ToC, V.B; ToC, V.C; ToC, VI;
ToC, VI.B; ToC, VI.C; ToC, VIII; ToC, VIII.B;
ToC, VIII.C; 1:8-10; 1:12; 1:24-27; 2:1-2; 2:11;
2:13-14; 2:17-27; 3:1-11; 3:24-25; 3:27; 4:8-10;
4:13; 4:16-27; 5:1-27; 6:1-5; 6:8-9; 6:11-27; 7:114; 7:16-27; 8:1-27; 9:1-27; 10:1-5; 10:8-16;
11:14-23; 11:25-27; 12:1-4; 12:9-19; 12:21-27;
13:1-6; 13:8-9; 13:11-25; 13:27; 14:3-27; 15:1-2;
15:4-5; 15:7-27; 16:1-21; 16:23-27; 17:1-11;
18:1-2; 18:4-15; 18:17-27; 19:1-9; 19:11-12;
19:14-27; 20:1-5; 20:13-27; 21:1-20; 21:22-27;
22:1-10; 22:12-24; 22:27; 23:1-6
10:21-18:16

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15

Declaration of Christopher Chorba In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Exhibit JJ – Excerpts from October 28, 2015
Deposition of Michael Adkins
Declaration of Alex Himel In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP

Declaration of Alex Himel In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Exhibit MM – Facebook’s Second Supplemental
Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs’
Narrowed Second Set of Interrogatories
Declaration of Alex Himel In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

3:23-24; 5:24 (the text following “defenses in this
action”)-27; 8:9-25; 9:18-11:24; 12:26-16:13;
17:9-20:24; 21:24-25:11; 26:7-29:22; 30:23-33:4;
33:27-36:15; 37:15-38:18; 39:15-40:18; 41:1542:18; 43:13-44:16; 45:16-21; and 46:18-23

Exhibit NN –Facebook’s Supplemental
3

[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
Case No. C 13-05996 PJH

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

Document
Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs’ First Set
of Interrogatories

Sealable Portions

Declaration of Alex Himel In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

1:19-24; 2:6; 2:25-26; 3:17-27; 4:1; 4:6-13; 4:1627; 5:1-5:4; 5:9-14; 5:23-27; 6:1-26; 7:1-2; 7:4-5;
7:8-27; 8:1-19

Exhibit OO – June 1, 2015 Declaration of Alex
Himel on Behalf of Defendant Facebook, Inc.
Declaration of Dan Fechete In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
Declaration of Michael Adkins In Support of
Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification

2:1-25; 4:11-23; 4:26-27; 5:1-10:15; 10:18-12:27;
13:14-14:17
1:7; 1:11; 1:14-17; 1:19; 1:20; 1:21; 1:24; 1:27;
2:3-5; 2:6; 2:11; 2:15; 2:16; 2:17-22; 2:23-27;
3:2-3; 3:4-7; 3:7-8; 3:8-9; 3:9; 3:10; 3:11-12;
3:12-13; 3:14-15; 3:16; 3:18-19; 3:20-22; 3:2427; 4:1-2; 4:3-6; 4:6-7; 4:7; 4:8-9; 4:10-11; 4:1314; 4:16-18; 4:19; 4:20; 4:21-27; 5:1-3; 5:3-5;
5:13-14; 5:15-17; 5:18; 5:19-22; 5:22-23; 5:2527; 6:1; 6:9-12; 6:13-16; 6:18-19; 6:21-27; 7:1;
7:2; 7:3; 7:4; 7:5-6; 7:7-8; 7:9-11; 7:14-16; 7:1719; 7:23-24; 7:24-26; 8:8-10; 8:11-15; 8:17-21
ToC, VII. A; ToC, VII. B; ToC, VIII. A.1; ToC,
VIII. A.2; ToC, VIII. A.3; ¶¶ 8-11; 13; 14; 14 fn.
1; 15; 16; 28-30; VII.A; 31; 32; 33-36; 37-38;
39; 40-41; 42; VII.B; 49; 49 n.3; 50; 50 n.4; 51;
52; 53; 54; VII.B.2; 55; 56; 57; VII.B.3; 58; 60;
61; 62; 63; 66; 68; 68 n.6; 69; 71; 72; 73; 75; 79;
80-80; VIII.F; 88; 93; 96-99; 101; 102; 103-104

10
11
12
13
14

Expert Report of Dr. Benjamin Goldberg

15
16
17
18

4, n.3; 5, n.4; 6, n.5; 6, n.6; 11, ¶ 32; 12 (figure); 12, ¶ 33;
13 (figure); 14, ¶ 34, lines 3-6; 14, n.26, 14, n.27; 14, ¶ 34,
lines 1-2; 14, n.25; 14, ¶ 35; 16, n.33; 16, n.32; 17, ¶ 40; 18,
¶ 45-19, line 2; 19, line 4; 19, n.39; 19, n.40; 20, ¶ 48- 21,
line 4; 21, n.43; 22, ¶ 51; 22, ¶ 52; 23, figure; 22, ¶ 53; 23, ¶
54; 23, n.46; 24, ¶ 56; 24, ¶ 57; 24, n.54; 24, n.55; 24, n.56;
25, n.57; 25, ¶ 59; 29, ¶ 70; 29 ¶ 71; 30, figure; 31, figure;
32, ¶ 72; 31, n.64; 31, n.65; 36, lines 2-3; 45, lines 6-7; 45,
n. 119; 45, lines 7-10; 53, ¶ 121; 52, n. 144
Index 2:16-19

Expert Report of Dr. Catherine Tucker

19
20
21
22
23

Appendix of Evidence in Support of Defendant Facebook,
Inc.’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class
Certification

24
25
26

IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated:
THE HONORABLE PHYLLIS J. HAMILTON
United States District Court Judge

27
28
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP

4
[PROPOSED] ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FILING OF DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
Case No. C 13-05996 PJH