Palantir Technologies Inc. v. Abramowitz et al

Filing 1

NOTICE OF REMOVAL OF CIVIL ACTION UNDER 28 U.S.C. 1441(A) from Santa Clara County Court. Their case number is 16cv299476. (Filing fee $400 receipt number 0971-13816085). Filed byMarc Abramowitz Charitable Trust No. 2, KT4 Partners LLC, Marc L. Abramowitz. (Attachments: #1 Civil Cover Sheet, #2 Exhibit 1, Filing Error see dkt #23 , #24 for corrected#3 Exhibit 2, part 1)(DiCanio, Jack) (Filed on 10/22/2019) Modified on 10/29/2019 (sfbS, COURT STAFF).

Download PDF
?H&75C8 -- #GSd' )0(*2$ /5C58 /<C1? @411A IVS ?H&75C8 -- QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb O\R bVS W\T]`[ObW]\ Q]\bOW\SR VS`SW\ \SWbVS` `S^ZOQS \]` ac^^ZS[S\b bVS TWZW\U O\R aS`dWQS ]T ^ZSORW\Ua ]` ]bVS` ^O^S`a Oa `S_cW`SR Pg ZOe% SfQS^b Oa ^`]dWRSR Pg Z]QOZ `cZSa ]T Q]c`b' IVWa T]`[% O^^`]dSR W\ Wba ]`WUW\OZ T]`[ Pg bVS ?cRWQWOZ 7]\TS`S\QS ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa W\ HS^bS[PS` *20-% Wa `S_cW`SR T]` bVS 7ZS`Y ]T 7]c`b b] W\WbWObS bVS QWdWZ R]QYSb aVSSb' "7++!/37869)8/437!43!3+;8!5'-+!4,!8./7!,462%# 5' #G$ =8-5;A522@ 0121;0-;A@ Marc L. Abramowitz; the Marc Abramowitz Charitable Trust No. 2; and KT4 Partners LLC Palantir Technologies Inc. #H$ 7]c\bg ]T GSaWRS\QS ]T ;W`ab AWabSR EZOW\bWTT ! 7]c\bg ]T GSaWRS\QS ]T ;W`ab AWabSR 8STS\RO\b Santa Clara "/3!9%7%!51'/38/,,!)'7+7!431<# !"+;)+58!/3!9%7%!51'/38/,,!)'7+7# CDI93 #I$ Jack DiCanio, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP 525 University Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94301 650-470-4500 .-@5@ <2 6B?5@05/A5<; "5E=?A!=G!S;T!DG!4GA!(HP!4GEQ# * J'H' <]dS`\[S\b EZOW\bWTT J'H' <]dS`\[S\b 8STS\RO\b + ! , - ! 5C' ;-AB?1 <2 @B5A /<;A?-/A **) >\ac`O\QS *+) BO`W\S *,) BWZZS` 5Qb *-) CSU]bWOPZS >\ab`c[S\b *.) GSQ]dS`g ]T DdS`^Og[S\b DT KSbS`O\ma 6S\STWba *.* BSRWQO`S 5Qb *.+ GSQ]dS`g ]T 8STOcZbSR HbcRS\b A]O\a #9fQZcRSa KSbS`O\a$ *., GSQ]dS`g ]T DdS`^Og[S\b ]T KSbS`O\ma 6S\STWba */) Hb]QYV]ZRS`am HcWba *2) DbVS` 7]\b`OQb *2. 7]\b`OQb E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg *2/ ;`O\QVWaS ?1-8 =?<=1?AE +*) AO\R 7]\RS[\ObW]\ ++) ;]`SQZ]ac`S +,) GS\b ASOaS " 9XSQb[S\b +-) I]`ba b] AO\R +-. I]`b E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg +2) 5ZZ DbVS` GSOZ E`]^S`bg C' * C5' >C A5C8 7DC89BC5I>DC 75H9H% JH9 I=9 AD75I>DC D; I=9 IG57I D; A5C8 >CKDAK98' 5bb]`\Sga "/B!0GHOG# 5bb]`\Sga ",DJF!3=FA$!'@@JAKK$!=G@!8AEAICHGA!3MF>AJ# John C. Hueston, Hueston Hennigan LLP 523 West 6th Street, Suite 400, Los Angeles, CA 90014 213-788-4340 55' Santa Clara 555' /5A5F1;@45= <2 =?5;/5=-8 =-?A51@!"5E=?A!=G!S;T!DG!4GA!(HP!BHJ!5E=DGLDBB !",HJ!*DNAJKDLQ!)=KAK!4GEQ#!! ;SRS`OZ FcSabW]\ "9%7%!-HNAJGFAGL!3HL!=!5=JLQ#! =A2 * 7WbWhS\ ]T IVWa HbObS 012 * 7WbWhS\ ]T 5\]bVS` HbObS + + 7WbWhS\ ]` HcPXSQb ]T O ;]`SWU\ 7]c\b`g 8WdS`aWbg "/G@D?=LA!)DLDRAGKCDI!HB!5=JLDAK!DG!/LAF!///#! , , =G@!4GA!(HP!BHJ!*ABAG@=GL#! =A2 >\Q]`^]`ObSR HJ E`W\QW^OZ EZOQS ]T 6caW\Saa >\ IVWa HbObS >\Q]`^]`ObSR =G@ E`W\QW^OZ EZOQS . ]T 6caW\Saa >\ 5\]bVS` HbObS ;]`SWU\ CObW]\ / 012 . / "5E=?A!=G!S;T!DG!4GA!(HP!4GEQ# A<?A@ =1?@<;-8 5;6B?E ,*) 5W`^ZO\S ,*. 5W`^ZO\S E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg ,+) 5aaOcZb% AWPSZ " HZO\RS` ,,) ;SRS`OZ 9[^Z]gS`am AWOPWZWbg ,-) BO`W\S ,-. BO`W\S E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg ,.) B]b]` KSVWQZS ,.. B]b]` KSVWQZS E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg ,/) DbVS` ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g ,/+ ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g &BSRWQOZ BOZ^`OQbWQS =1?@<;-8 5;6B?E ,/. ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g j E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg ,/0 =SOZbV 7O`S( EVO`[OQScbWQOZ ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg ,/1 5aPSab]a ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg =1?@<;-8 =?<=1?AE ,0) DbVS` ;`OcR ,0* I`cbV W\ AS\RW\U ,1) DbVS` ES`a]\OZ E`]^S`bg 8O[OUS ,1. E`]^S`bg 8O[OUS E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg =?5@<;1? =1A5A5<;@ /5C58 ?534A@ --) DbVS` 7WdWZ GWUVba --* K]bW\U --+ 9[^Z]g[S\b --, =]caW\U( 5QQ][[]RObW]\a --. 5[S`' e(8WaOPWZWbWSaj 9[^Z]g[S\b --/ 5[S`' e(8WaOPWZWbWSajDbVS` --1 9RcQObW]\ 4-.1-@ /<?=B@ -/, 5ZWS\ 8SbOW\SS .*) B]bW]\a b] KOQObS HS\bS\QS .,) <S\S`OZ .,. 8SObV ES\OZbg 2<?215AB?1(=1;-8AE /+. 8`cU GSZObSR HSWhc`S ]T E`]^S`bg +* JH7 i 11* /2) DbVS` 8-.<? .-;7?B=A/E -++ 5^^SOZ +1 JH7 i *.1 -+, LWbVR`OeOZ +1 JH7 i *.0 =?<=1?AE ?534A@ 0*) ;OW` AOP]` HbO\RO`Ra 5Qb 0+) AOP]`(BO\OUS[S\b GSZObW]\a 0-) GOWZeOg AOP]` 5Qb 0.* ;O[WZg O\R BSRWQOZ ASOdS 5Qb 02) DbVS` AOP]` AWbWUObW]\ 02* 9[^Z]gSS GSbW`S[S\b >\Q][S HSQc`Wbg 5Qb 59953?-A5<; -/+ CObc`OZWhObW]\ 5^^ZWQObW]\ -/. DbVS` >[[WU`ObW]\ 5QbW]\a 1+) 7]^g`WUVba 1,) EObS\b 1,. EObS\bo5PP`SdWObSR CSe 8`cU 5^^ZWQObW]\ 1-) I`ORS[O`Y @</5-8 @1/B?5AE 1/* =>5 #*,2.TT$ 1/+ 6ZOQY Ac\U #2+,$ 1/, 8>L7(8>LL #-).#U$$ 1/- HH>8 IWbZS MK> 1/. GH> #-).#U$$ 2101?-8 A-D @B5A@ 10) IOfSa #J'H' EZOW\bWTT ]` 8STS\RO\b$ 10* >GHjIVW`R EO`bg +/ JH7 i 0/)2 <A41? .-) BO\RO[ca " DbVS` ..) 7WdWZ GWUVba ... E`Wa]\ 7]\RWbW]\ ./) 7WdWZ 8SbOW\SSj 7]\RWbW]\a ]T 7]\TW\S[S\b <A41? @A-ABA1@ ,0. ;OZaS 7ZOW[a 5Qb ,0/ FcW IO[ #,* JH7 i ,0+2#O$$ -)) HbObS GSO^^]`bW]\[S\b -*) 5\bWb`cab -,) 6O\Ya O\R 6O\YW\U -.) 7][[S`QS -/) 8S^]`bObW]\ -0) GOQYSbSS` >\TZcS\QSR " 7]``c^b D`UO\WhObW]\a -1) 7]\ac[S` 7`SRWb -1. ISZS^V]\S 7]\ac[S` E`]bSQbW]\ 5Qb -2) 7OPZS(HOb IK 1.) HSQc`WbWSa(7][[]RWbWSa( 9fQVO\US 12) DbVS` HbObcb]`g 5QbW]\a 12* 5U`WQcZbc`OZ 5Qba 12, 9\dW`]\[S\bOZ BObbS`a 12. ;`SSR][ ]T >\T]`[ObW]\ 5Qb 12/ 5`PWb`ObW]\ 122 5R[W\Wab`ObWdS E`]QSRc`S 5Qb(GSdWSe ]` 5^^SOZ ]T 5US\Qg 8SQWaW]\ 2.) 7]\abWbcbW]\OZWbg ]T HbObS HbObcbSa <?535; "5E=?A!=G!S;T!DG!4GA!(HP!4GEQ# D`WUW\OZ E`]QSSRW\U /-B@1 <2 -/A5<; + GS[]dSR T`][ HbObS 7]c`b , GS[O\RSR T`][ 5^^SZZObS 7]c`b - GSW\abObSR ]` GS]^S\SR . I`O\aTS``SR T`][ 5\]bVS` 8Wab`WQb "KIA?DBQ# / BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\jI`O\aTS` 1 BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\j8W`SQb ;WZS 7WbS bVS J'H' 7WdWZ HbObcbS c\RS` eVWQV g]c O`S TWZW\U "#,!+,/!%(/'!)0-(.&(%/(,+$*!./$/0/'.!0+*'..!&(1'-.(/2#3 18 USC ยง 1962 6`WST RSaQ`W^bW]\ ]T QOcaS3 Alleged violation of the Racketeer Influenced & Corrupt Organizations Act C55' ?1>B1@A10 5; /<9=8-5;A, 7=97@ >; I=>H >H 5 /8-@@ -/A5<; JC89G GJA9 +,% ;SR' G' 7Wd' E' C555' ?18-A10 /-@1#@$% 52 -;E "7AA!DGKLJM?LDHGK#& 5D' 019-;0 " ?J8<9 05C5@5<;-8 -@@53;91;A #/O\OR 8UIGR ?[RK *&)$ @-; 2?-;/5@/<(<-78-;0 #=RGIK GT `Da OT <TK .U] <TR^$ 0-A1 10/22/2019 7=97@ N9H ]\Zg WT RS[O\RSR W\ Q][^ZOW\b3 6B?E 019-;0, NSa C] 8D7@9I CJB69G @-; 6<@1 @53;-AB?1 <2 -AA<?;1E <2 ?1/<?0 1B?17-&9/75;81EC5881 /s/ Jack P. DiCanio ?H&75C8 -- #`Sd' )0(*2$ 5;@A?B/A5<;@ 2<? -AA<?;1E@ /<9=81A5;3 /5C58 /<C1? @411A 2<?9 6@&/-;0 ++ -[ZNUXOZ^ 2UX /O\OR /U\KX @NKKZ' IVS ?H&75C8 -- QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb O\R bVS W\T]`[ObW]\ Q]\bOW\SR VS`SW\ \SWbVS` `S^ZOQSa \]` ac^^ZS[S\ba bVS TWZW\Ua O\R aS`dWQS ]T ^ZSORW\U ]` ]bVS` ^O^S`a Oa `S_cW`SR Pg ZOe% SfQS^b Oa ^`]dWRSR Pg Z]QOZ `cZSa ]T Q]c`b' IVWa T]`[% O^^`]dSR W\ Wba ]`WUW\OZ T]`[ Pg bVS ?cRWQWOZ 7]\TS`S\QS ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa W\ HS^bS[PS` *20-% Wa `S_cW`SR T]` bVS 7ZS`Y ]T 7]c`b b] W\WbWObS bVS QWdWZ R]QYSb aVSSb' 7]\aS_cS\bZg% O QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb Wa acP[WbbSR b] bVS 7ZS`Y ]T 7]c`b T]` SOQV QWdWZ Q][^ZOW\b TWZSR' IVS Obb]`\Sg TWZW\U O QOaS aV]cZR Q][^ZSbS bVS T]`[ Oa T]ZZ]ea3 5' G$ =RGOTZOLLY&0KLKTJGTZY' 9\bS` \O[Sa #ZOab% TW`ab% [WRRZS W\WbWOZ$ ]T ^ZOW\bWTT O\R RSTS\RO\b' >T bVS ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Wa O U]dS`\[S\b OUS\Qg% caS ]\Zg bVS TcZZ \O[S ]` abO\RO`R OPP`SdWObW]\a' >T bVS ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Wa O\ ]TTWQWOZ eWbVW\ O U]dS`\[S\b OUS\Qg% WRS\bWTg TW`ab bVS OUS\Qg O\R bVS\ bVS ]TTWQWOZ% UWdW\U P]bV \O[S O\R bWbZS' H$ /U[TZ^ UL ?KYOJKTIK' ;]` SOQV QWdWZ QOaS TWZSR% SfQS^b J'H' ^ZOW\bWTT QOaSa% S\bS` bVS \O[S ]T bVS Q]c\bg eVS`S bVS TW`ab ZWabSR ^ZOW\bWTT `SaWRSa Ob bVS bW[S ]T TWZW\U' >\ J'H' ^ZOW\bWTT QOaSa% S\bS` bVS \O[S ]T bVS Q]c\bg W\ eVWQV bVS TW`ab ZWabSR RSTS\RO\b `SaWRSa Ob bVS bW[S ]T TWZW\U' #CDI93 >\ ZO\R Q]\RS[\ObW]\ QOaSa% bVS Q]c\bg ]T `SaWRS\QS ]T bVS kRSTS\RO\bl Wa bVS Z]QObW]\ ]T bVS b`OQb ]T ZO\R W\d]ZdSR'$ I$ -ZZUXTK^Y' 9\bS` bVS TW`[ \O[S% ORR`Saa% bSZS^V]\S \c[PS`% O\R Obb]`\Sg ]T `SQ]`R' >T bVS`S O`S aSdS`OZ Obb]`\Sga% ZWab bVS[ ]\ O\ ObbOQV[S\b% \]bW\U W\ bVWa aSQbW]\ k#aSS ObbOQV[S\b$'l 55' 6[XOYJOIZOUT' IVS POaWa ]T Xc`WaRWQbW]\ Wa aSb T]`bV c\RS` ;SRS`OZ GcZS ]T 7WdWZ E`]QSRc`S 1#O$% eVWQV `S_cW`Sa bVOb Xc`WaRWQbW]\a PS aV]e\ W\ ^ZSORW\Ua' EZOQS O\ kMl W\ ]\S ]T bVS P]fSa' >T bVS`S Wa []`S bVO\ ]\S POaWa ]T Xc`WaRWQbW]\% ^`SQSRS\QS Wa UWdS\ W\ bVS ]`RS` aV]e\ PSZ]e' #*$ J\WbSR HbObSa ^ZOW\bWTT' ?c`WaRWQbW]\ POaSR ]\ +1 JH7 ii *,-. O\R *,-1' HcWba Pg OUS\QWSa O\R ]TTWQS`a ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa O`S W\QZcRSR VS`S' #+$ J\WbSR HbObSa RSTS\RO\b' LVS\ bVS ^ZOW\bWTT Wa acW\U bVS J\WbSR HbObSa% Wba ]TTWQS`a ]` OUS\QWSa% ^ZOQS O\ kMl W\ bVWa P]f' #,$ ;SRS`OZ _cSabW]\' IVWa `STS`a b] acWba c\RS` +1 JH7 i *,,*% eVS`S Xc`WaRWQbW]\ O`WaSa c\RS` bVS 7]\abWbcbW]\ ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa% O\ O[S\R[S\b b] bVS 7]\abWbcbW]\% O\ OQb ]T 7]\U`Saa ]` O b`SObg ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa' >\ QOaSa eVS`S bVS J'H' Wa O ^O`bg% bVS J'H' ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Q]RS bOYSa ^`SQSRS\QS% O\R P]f * ]` + aV]cZR PS [O`YSR' #-$ 8WdS`aWbg ]T QWbWhS\aVW^' IVWa `STS`a b] acWba c\RS` +1 JH7 i *,,+% eVS`S ^O`bWSa O`S QWbWhS\a ]T RWTTS`S\b abObSa' LVS\ 6]f - Wa QVSQYSR% bVS QWbWhS\aVW^ ]T bVS RWTTS`S\b ^O`bWSa [cab PS QVSQYSR' #HSS HSQbW]\ >>> PSZ]e4 ;<A1, LKJKXGR W[KYZOUT GIZOUTY ZGQK VXKIKJKTIK U\KX JO\KXYOZ^ IGYKY'$ 555' ?KYOJKTIK #IOZO_KTYNOV$ UL =XOTIOVGR =GXZOKY' IVWa aSQbW]\ ]T bVS ?H&75C8 -- Wa b] PS Q][^ZSbSR WT RWdS`aWbg ]T QWbWhS\aVW^ eOa W\RWQObSR OP]dS' BO`Y bVWa aSQbW]\ T]` SOQV ^`W\QW^OZ ^O`bg' 5C' ;GZ[XK UL @[OZ' EZOQS O\ kMl W\ bVS O^^`]^`WObS P]f' >T bVS \Obc`S ]T acWb QO\\]b PS RSbS`[W\SR% PS ac`S bVS QOcaS ]T OQbW]\% W\ HSQbW]\ K> PSZ]e% Wa acTTWQWS\b b] S\OPZS bVS RS^cbg QZS`Y ]` bVS abObWabWQOZ QZS`Y#a$ W\ bVS 5R[W\Wab`ObWdS DTTWQS b] RSbS`[W\S bVS \Obc`S ]T acWb' >T bVS QOcaS TWba []`S bVO\ ]\S \Obc`S ]T acWb% aSZSQb bVS []ab RSTW\WbWdS' C' <XOMOT' EZOQS O\ kMl W\ ]\S ]T bVS aWf P]fSa' #*$ D`WUW\OZ E`]QSSRW\Ua' 7OaSa ]`WUW\ObW\U W\ bVS J\WbSR HbObSa RWab`WQb Q]c`ba' #+$ GS[]dSR T`][ HbObS 7]c`b' E`]QSSRW\Ua W\WbWObSR W\ abObS Q]c`ba [Og PS `S[]dSR b] bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`ba c\RS` IWbZS +1 JH7 i *--*' LVS\ bVS ^SbWbW]\ T]` `S[]dOZ Wa U`O\bSR% QVSQY bVWa P]f' #,$ GS[O\RSR T`][ 5^^SZZObS 7]c`b' 7VSQY bVWa P]f T]` QOaSa `S[O\RSR b] bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`b T]` Tc`bVS` OQbW]\' JaS bVS RObS ]T `S[O\R Oa bVS TWZW\U RObS' #-$ GSW\abObSR ]` GS]^S\SR' 7VSQY bVWa P]f T]` QOaSa `SW\abObSR ]` `S]^S\SR W\ bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`b' JaS bVS `S]^S\W\U RObS Oa bVS TWZW\U RObS' #.$ I`O\aTS``SR T`][ 5\]bVS` 8Wab`WQb' ;]` QOaSa b`O\aTS``SR c\RS` IWbZS +1 JH7 i *-)-#O$' 8] \]b caS bVWa T]` eWbVW\ RWab`WQb b`O\aTS`a ]` [cZbWRWab`WQb ZWbWUObW]\ b`O\aTS`a' #/$ BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\ I`O\aTS`' 7VSQY bVWa P]f eVS\ O [cZbWRWab`WQb QOaS Wa b`O\aTS``SR W\b] bVS RWab`WQb c\RS` OcbV]`Wbg ]T IWbZS +1 JH7 i *-)0' LVS\ bVWa P]f Wa QVSQYSR% R] \]b QVSQY #.$ OP]dS' #1$ BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\ 8W`SQb ;WZS' 7VSQY bVWa P]f eVS\ O [cZbWRWab`WQb ZWbWUObW]\ QOaS Wa TWZSR W\ bVS aO[S RWab`WQb Oa bVS BOabS` B8A R]QYSb' EZSOaS \]bS bVOb bVS`S Wa \] D`WUW\ 7]RS 0' D`WUW\ 7]RS 0 eOa caSR T]` VWab]`WQOZ `SQ]`Ra O\R Wa \] Z]\US` `SZSdO\b RcS b] QVO\USa W\ abObcbS' C5' /G[YK UL -IZOUT' GS^]`b bVS QWdWZ abObcbS RW`SQbZg `SZObSR b] bVS QOcaS ]T OQbW]\ O\R UWdS O P`WST RSaQ`W^bW]\ ]T bVS QOcaS' 0U TUZ IOZK P[XOYJOIZOUTGR YZGZ[ZKY [TRKYY JO\KXYOZ^' 9fO[^ZS3 J'H' 7WdWZ HbObcbS3 -0 JH7 i ..,' 6`WST 8SaQ`W^bW]\3 J\OcbV]`WhSR `SQS^bW]\ ]T QOPZS aS`dWQS' C55' ?KW[KYZKJ OT /USVRGOTZ' 7ZOaa 5QbW]\' EZOQS O\ kMl W\ bVWa P]f WT g]c O`S TWZW\U O QZOaa OQbW]\ c\RS` ;SRS`OZ GcZS ]T 7WdWZ E`]QSRc`S +,' 8S[O\R' >\ bVWa a^OQS S\bS` bVS OQbcOZ R]ZZO` O[]c\b PSW\U RS[O\RSR ]` W\RWQObS ]bVS` RS[O\R% acQV Oa O ^`SZW[W\O`g W\Xc\QbW]\' ?c`g 8S[O\R' 7VSQY bVS O^^`]^`WObS P]f b] W\RWQObS eVSbVS` ]` \]b O Xc`g Wa PSW\U RS[O\RSR' C555' ?KRGZKJ /GYKY' IVWa aSQbW]\ ]T bVS ?H&75C8 -- Wa caSR b] WRS\bWTg `SZObSR ^S\RW\U QOaSa% WT O\g' >T bVS`S O`S `SZObSR ^S\RW\U QOaSa% W\aS`b bVS R]QYSb \c[PS`a O\R bVS Q]``Sa^]\RW\U XcRUS \O[Sa T]` acQV QOaSa' 5D' 0O\OYOUTGR -YYOMTSKTZ' >T bVS CObc`S ]T HcWb Wa c\RS` E`]^S`bg GWUVba ]` E`Wa]\S` ESbWbW]\a ]` bVS [ObbS` Wa O HSQc`WbWSa 7ZOaa 5QbW]\% ZSOdS bVWa aSQbW]\ PZO\Y' ;]` OZZ ]bVS` QOaSa% WRS\bWTg bVS RWdWaW]\OZ dS\cS OQQ]`RW\U b] 7WdWZ A]QOZ GcZS ,&+3 kbVS Q]c\bg W\ eVWQV O acPabO\bWOZ ^O`b ]T bVS SdS\ba ]` ][WaaW]\a eVWQV UWdS `WaS b] bVS QZOW[ ]QQc``SR ]` W\ eVWQV O acPabO\bWOZ ^O`b ]T bVS ^`]^S`bg bVOb Wa bVS acPXSQb ]T bVS OQbW]\ Wa aWbcObSR'l 0GZK GTJ -ZZUXTK^ @OMTGZ[XK' 8ObS O\R aWU\ bVS QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb'

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?