Direct Marketing Association, The v. Huber
Filing
99
MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment Counts I and II (Commerce Clause) by Defendant Roxy Huber. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1- Fox Decl. & Rep., # 2 Exhibit 2-1 IRS Tax Gap, # 3 Exhibit 2-2 IRS Tax Gap, # 4 Exhibit 2-3 IRS Tax Gap, # 5 Exhibit 2-4 IRS Tax Gap, # 6 Exhibit 2-5 IRS Tax Gap, # 7 Exhibit 2-6 IRS Tax Gap, # 8 Exhibit 2-7 IRS Tax Gap, # 9 Exhibit 2-8 IRS Tax Gap, # 10 Exhibit 3- Saliman Decl., # 11 Exhibit 4- Corjuo Decl., # 12 Exhibit 5- Gable Decl. & Rep., # 13 Exhibit 6- Barry Dep., # 14 Exhibit 7- Stevens Decl., # 15 Exhibit 8- Thompson Decl., # 16 Exhibit 9- Lichtenstein Decl. & Rep., # 17 Exhibit 10- Adler Dep.)(Snyder, Melanie)
z
[
-Q
C
o
-
D
o
o
3
2.
Ex.10
H
H
P)
C)
*
CDI
P)
Ft
0
b0
N
CD
hxj
Hi
<
CD
Z
-
Ft
0
C)
CD
0
N
CD
Pi
CD
0
H-
CD
Ft
Hi
Ft0
H
H-Hi
P)
CD
CD
(Q
i
W
NJ
C)
P)
Ui
110
--)
0
CD
FtHi
0
Ft
CD
CD
C)
Ft
0
C)
H
P)
Hh-
H-
CD
D-
CD
H-Hi
DO
H
H-
11
CD
CD
i
HC)
<
CD
h-
Ft
Ft
0
3’
FtQ
JCD
Ft
0
-
—J
t’
CD
C)
Ui
NJ
-
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CD
Zi
Hi
‘-<
C)
Ft
0
GD
C)
H-
Ft
-
p
Q
CD
h-
Ft
0
1
H
0
Ft
0
ij
-
0
Cl)
CD
Ft
‘]
Cl)
i
i
(I)
Hk<
Cl)
-
Cl)
—
P)
10
lOP)
Cl)
Ft
FtP)
d
HP)
h
C)
u0
CD
0
CD
i
0
CD
H-Ri
j
Hi
N
1-liH
UJCJ)W
C)
FtP)
h
—J
HP)
P)
3
H-C)
C)
CD
0
II
CD
Cl)
Pi
H
h
GD
GD
Cl)
0
H-H-•
i
Cl)
Ft
Ft
H-Q
0
HCD
H
H(flC
U]
J
CD
NJ
C)
U]
H-
1)
NJ
C)
NJ
<
CD
lCD
‘I
CD
NJ
NJ
0
h
P)
H3
0
NJ
H
U]
0
H
H
W
0
<
CD
Ft
o
H-
<
Di
0
Ft
Di
CD
0
H
CD
k<
Cl
Ft
H
H-
(Q
H-
Cl
Ft
•
0
Ft
CD
i
0
CD
CD
h
•‘i
CD
Ft
<
CD
0
(X
H-
hI
Ft
-
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
0
Cl
Di
CD
CD
C)
hI
ti
Ft
0
0
Ft
CD
H
0
d
CD
CD
CD
H-
h-ti
C)
Di
z
Ft
0
Cl
Mi
H-
0
Ft
Ft
CD
Dl
CD
Di
Ft
-
CD
CD
Ft
0
Ft
H-
Cl
C)
ci
0
CD
C)
HMi
HC)
CD
‘cl
Co
H
CD
Ft
CD
H
H
H-
i
0
h
l
o
h
Di
<
0
0
Mi
CD
<
CD
Mi
0
0
o
i
CD
CD
CT)
Di
CD
C)
H-
CD
CD
CD
>‘
Di
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
Ft
U)
0
0
H
o
H-
0
tO
Di
Ft
H-
Cl
Di
-
H-
d
D
Ft
H-
<
0
zI
Di
H
Ft
N-)
CJ
-
tO
CD
Ft
Mi
0
Di
Ft
CD
CD
-
Di
Mi
0
Cl
H-
CD
H-
H
CD
0
0
H
HCD
Ft
U)
0
H
H
i
HCD
Ft
CD
0
Di
Ft
Ft
0
CD
H
to
CD
Mi
Mi
CD
H-
Di
CD
H
Di
CD
Ft
Di
Ft
Ft
Di
CD
0
Ft
H-
C)
H
H
CD
C)
0
0
Ft
Ft
•
Ft
C)
CD
Mi
Mi
CD
i
H-
H
Di
‘-)
CD
Di
Di
Ft
Ft
h
CD
CD
-<
H
Ui
C)
•
H
Di
H
P1
CD
Ft
CD
H
H
0
Di
C)
•
Ft
H
-<
Dl
CD
H-
Ft
CD
Z
•
Di
-<
0
0
n
H
CD
•
Ft
C)
CD
Mi
Mi
CD
H-
to
-<
P1
CD
CD
Di
H
Ft
•
0
CD
H-
Ft
-
Ft
Cl
H-
H
0
H
H
H
Z
0
0
O
0
k<
CD
h
CD
-
HFt
<
Cl
Di
Mi
Mi
H-
Di
)
hI
CD
H
H
CD
Di
Mi
HH
CD
0
Ft
H
Q
0
Ft
0
CD
CD
M
-<
0
-‘
CD
H
H
CX)
•
-<
CD
CD
J
Ft
CD
C)
l
0
CD
Ft
CD
CD
-<
I-
CD
CD
Ft
Cl
Di
HFt
Di
CD
Ft
Mi
H
H
CD
CD
H
H
H
CD
C)
)
Ft
H
d
0
0
HH
H
h-
CD
Mi
CD
Di
C)
•
H-
Ft
H-
•
C)
hI
CD
Di
1
Di
Ft
CD
hI
H
N
CD
CD
CD
to
CD
C/)
0
Ui
Mi
Mi
Di
tCD
C)
CD
LJ
0
••
‘I
Li
L’I
C)
U)
•
Lfl
CD
hI
CD
CD
Ft
0
LQ
Ft
H
CD
Q
C)
CD
H
H
CD
0
1
Q
Mi
CD
CD
CD
Ft
0
0
H
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?