Direct Marketing Association, The v. Huber

Filing 99

MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment Counts I and II (Commerce Clause) by Defendant Roxy Huber. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1- Fox Decl. & Rep., # 2 Exhibit 2-1 IRS Tax Gap, # 3 Exhibit 2-2 IRS Tax Gap, # 4 Exhibit 2-3 IRS Tax Gap, # 5 Exhibit 2-4 IRS Tax Gap, # 6 Exhibit 2-5 IRS Tax Gap, # 7 Exhibit 2-6 IRS Tax Gap, # 8 Exhibit 2-7 IRS Tax Gap, # 9 Exhibit 2-8 IRS Tax Gap, # 10 Exhibit 3- Saliman Decl., # 11 Exhibit 4- Corjuo Decl., # 12 Exhibit 5- Gable Decl. & Rep., # 13 Exhibit 6- Barry Dep., # 14 Exhibit 7- Stevens Decl., # 15 Exhibit 8- Thompson Decl., # 16 Exhibit 9- Lichtenstein Decl. & Rep., # 17 Exhibit 10- Adler Dep.)(Snyder, Melanie)

z

[

-Q

C

o

-

D

o

o

3

2.

Ex.10

H
H

P)

C)

*

CDI

P)

Ft

0
b0

N
CD

hxj

Hi

<

CD

Z

-

Ft
0

C)

CD

0
N

CD

Pi

CD

0

H-

CD

Ft

Hi

Ft0

H
H-Hi

P)

CD

CD

(Q

i

W

NJ

C)

P)
Ui
110
--)
0
CD
FtHi
0

Ft

CD

CD
C)
Ft

0
C)

H

P)

Hh-

H-

CD
D-

CD

H-Hi

DO

H

H-

11

CD

CD
i

HC)

<

CD

h-

Ft
Ft
0

3’

FtQ

JCD

Ft

0

-

—J

t’

CD

C)
Ui

NJ

-

CD
CD
Ft

CD

CD

Zi

Hi

‘-<

C)

Ft

0

GD

C)

H-

Ft

-

p

Q

CD

h-

Ft

0
1

H
0

Ft

0

ij

-

0

Cl)

CD
Ft

‘]

Cl)

i

i

(I)
Hk<
Cl)
-

Cl)
—

P)

10

lOP)
Cl)
Ft
FtP)

d

HP)

h

C)
u0

CD

0

CD

i

0

CD

H-Ri
j
Hi
N
1-liH
UJCJ)W
C)
FtP)
h
—J
HP)
P)
3
H-C)
C)
CD

0
II
CD
Cl)

Pi

H
h
GD

GD

Cl)

0

H-H-•
i
Cl)
Ft
Ft
H-Q
0

HCD

H

H(flC
U]
J
CD
NJ
C)
U]
H-

1)

NJ
C)

NJ

<
CD
lCD
‘I

CD

NJ
NJ

0
h
P)

H3

0

NJ
H
U]

0

H
H
W

0
<Cl)

0

-

Ft

H

0

00

H

H

H

CD
11

Cl)

CD

11

H-

Cl)

.

0

H

NJ
0

-

P)
Ft

CD

P)

Ft

U

d

i

t’l

NJ
NJ
U

C-.
CD
1.

0

Ft

CD

CD

1

CD

<

Ft

C)

I-

H-

<

Ft
CD

CD

CD
—

<

GD

H-

-

Hi

Hi

0

I

C)

0

H

Z
Q

0

C)
Ft
H

H
H

C)

H

%fls.

U]

0

()
H
P)
Ft
H-

Cl)

C)

t’l
W

CY

U]

0

CD

Cl)

H-

Ft

H-

I)

CD

‘I

C)
Ft

CD

H-

CD

H

G

HFt

d

—J

UJ

Cl)
H

U

H

I-H

‘i

H

Z

I-H

H

C)
H
0J

OD
‘I H
Cl)

H
L’J
HCJ)

C)

I-H

Cl)
H

H

D

‘i

H

0

NJ

H

DC)
00

H-

CD

I-H

QC)
H

Ft

CD

CD

C)

d

N

Hitli

0

FtP)
CD

HFt

h

C)
P)
PCD
p)d
P)
P)
i

DPi
CD
Hi
0
CD
J

-‘

0

H

C)-

0

—

Ft
0

-

D

D
F--Q

C)

II
-‘

H

HO

H

C)

Hi

CD

H

NJ

H-

C)
1’l

H
C

00
C)

CD

)

C)

‘d

CD

çj
Ft
Ft

-J

H

o

0

n

o

z

Ex.10

C

C

tO

tO

LQ

0

CD

(Q

CD

HCD
CD

CD

Ft

0

Ft

d

o

•

CD

Di
><
CD

Ft

o

H-

<

Di

0
Ft

Di

CD

0

H
CD

k<

Cl

Ft

H
H-

(Q

H-

Cl

Ft

•

0

Ft
CD

i

0

CD
CD

h

•‘i

CD

Ft

<

CD

0

(X

H-

hI

Ft

-

CD

Ft

CD

Ft

0

Cl

Di
CD
CD

C)

hI

ti

Ft

0

0

Ft

CD

H

0
d

CD

CD
CD

H-

h-ti

C)
Di

z

Ft

0

Cl

Mi
H-

0

Ft

Ft
CD

Dl

CD

Di
Ft

-

CD
CD

Ft

0

Ft
H-

Cl
C)

ci

0

CD
C)
HMi
HC)

CD

‘cl

Co

H

CD

Ft
CD

H

H

H-

i

0

h

l

o

h

Di

<
0

0

Mi

CD

<

CD

Mi

0

0

o

i

CD

CD
CT)

Di

CD
C)

H-

CD

CD
CD

>‘

Di

CD
Ft
Ft
H-

Ft

U)
0

0

H

o

H-

0

tO

Di
Ft
H-

Cl

Di

-

H-

d

D
Ft

H-

<

0

zI

Di

H

Ft

N-)

CJ

-

tO

CD

Ft

Mi

0

Di
Ft

CD

CD

-

Di

Mi

0

Cl

H-

CD

H-

H

CD

0
0

H

HCD

Ft

U)
0

H

H

i

HCD

Ft
CD

0

Di
Ft

Ft

0
CD

H
to

CD
Mi
Mi
CD

H-

Di
CD

H
Di

CD

Ft

Di
Ft

Ft

Di
CD

0

Ft
H-

C)

H
H
CD

C)
0

0

Ft
Ft

•

Ft

C)

CD
Mi
Mi
CD

i

H-

H

Di

‘-)

CD
Di

Di
Ft

Ft

h

CD

CD

-<

H
Ui

C)

•

H

Di

H

P1

CD

Ft
CD
H
H

0

Di

C)

•

Ft

H

-<

Dl

CD

H-

Ft

CD

Z

•

Di
-<

0

0

n

H
CD

•

Ft

C)

CD
Mi
Mi
CD

H-

to

-<

P1

CD

CD
Di

H
Ft

•

0

CD

H-

Ft

-

Ft

Cl

H-

H

0

H
H

H

Z

0

0

O

0

k<

CD

h

CD

-

HFt

<

Cl
Di

Mi
Mi
H-

Di

)

hI

CD
H
H
CD

Di

Mi
HH
CD

0

Ft

H

Q
0

Ft

0

CD

CD
M

-<
0

-‘

CD
H
H

CX)

•

-<

CD
CD

J

Ft

CD

C)

l
0

CD

Ft

CD

CD

-<

I-

CD

CD

Ft

Cl

Di

HFt

Di

CD

Ft

Mi
H
H
CD

CD
H
H

H
CD
C)

)

Ft

H

d
0
0

HH
H

h-

CD
Mi
CD

Di

C)

•

H-

Ft
H-

•

C)

hI

CD

Di
1
Di
Ft
CD
hI
H
N
CD
CD

CD

to

CD

C/)

0

Ui

Mi

Mi

Di

tCD

C)

CD

LJ

0

••

‘I
Li

L’I

C)

U)

•

Lfl

CD

hI

CD

CD

Ft

0

LQ

Ft
H

CD

Q

C)

CD
H
H
CD

0

1
Q
Mi
CD
CD
CD

Ft

0

0

H