IN RE: GUANTANAMO BAY DETAINEE LITIGATION

Filing 723

MOTION to Dismiss Improper Respondents by JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, JOHN D. ALTENBURG, JR, MIKE BUMGARNER, GEORGE W. BUSH, DONALD RUMSFELD, GEORGE WALKER BUSH, DONALD H. RUMSFELD, GEORGE W. BUSH, JR, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, DONALD RUMSFELD, GORDON R. ENGLAND, JOHN D. ALTENBURG, JR, JAY HOOD, BRICE A. GYURISKO, GEORGE W. BUSH, JR, DONALD H. RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, NELSON J. CANNON, GEORGE W. BUSH, J. HOOD, NELSON J. CANNON, JAY HOOD, BRICE A. GYURISKO, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, NELSON J. CANNON, BRICE GYURISKO, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, BRICE GYURISKO, NELSON J. CANNON, ROBERT M. GATES, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, GEORGE WALKER BUSH, NELSON J. CANNON, BRICE GYURISKO, MIKE BUMGARNER, DONALD RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, BRICE GYURISKO, GEORGE W. BUSH, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, BRICE GYURISKO, DONALD RUMSFELD, BRICE GYURISKO, MIKE BUMGARNER, MICHAEL I. BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, DONALD RUMSFELD, BRICE GYURISKO, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, BRICE GYURISKO, JAY HOOD, MICHAEL I. BUMGARNER, MICHAEL I. BUMGARNER, GEORGE W. BUSH, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MICHAEL BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, GEORGE W. BUSH, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JOHN D. ALTENBURG, JR, MICHAEL BUMGARNER, GEORGE W. BUSH, MICHAEL BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MICHAEL BUMGARNER, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, DONALD H. RUMSFELD, JAY HOOD, MICHAEL BUMGARNER, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, DONALD H. RUMSFELD, MIKE BUMGARNER, MIKE BUMGARNER, WADE F. DENNIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JAY HOOD, MIKE BUMGARNER, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, HARRY B. HARRIS, JR, WADE F. DAVIS, DONALD RUMSFELD, WADE F. DAVIS, GEORGE W. BUSH, MARK H. BUZBY, BRUCE VARGO, MARK H. BUZBY, BRUCE VARGO, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT M. GATES, COMMANDER OF THE JOINT TASK FORCE, GTMO, COMMANDER OF PRISON CAMP, GTMO, ROBERT M. GATES, ROBERT M. GATES, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, GUANTANAMO BAY DETAINEE LITIGATION, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT M. GATES, MARK H. BUZBY, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT M. GATES, DONALD RUMSFELD, DAVID M. THOMAS, BRUCE VARGO, JOHN DOE, RICHARD B. CHENEY, CONDELEEZA RICE, MICHAEL V. HAYDEN, GEORGE TENET, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, BRUCE VARGO, DAVID M. THOMAS, BRUCE VARGO, MARK H. BUZBY, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT M. GATES, BRUCE VARGO, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, BRUCE VARGO, BRUCE VARGO, BRUCE VARGO, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT M. GATES, MARK H. BUZBY, DAVID VARGO, ROBERT GATES, ROBERT GATES, DAVID M. THOMAS, JR, BRUCE VARGO, ROBERT GATES, HARRY B. HARRIS, MIKE BUMGARNER, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, GEORGE W. BUSH, DONALD H. RUMSFELD, RICK BACCUS, TERRY CARRICO (Attachments: # 1 Appendix, # 2 Text of Proposed Order)(Marconda, Scott)

APPENDIX A Pursuant to local rule 7(m), counsel for respondents contacted counsel for each of the petitioners in these matters to meet and confer regarding potential opposition to the instant motion. Respondents have set forth below all of the responses received from the petitioners' counsel, as of 6:00 p.m. EST on the day of filing. OPPOSED Civil Action No. 05-CV-2386, 06-CV-1761 05-CV-2386 05-CV-0883, 08-CV-0442 08-CV-1207 05-CV-1497 05-CV-1509, 05-CV-1602, 05-CV-1704, 05-CV-2398, 08-CV-1310 05-CV-0392 05-CV-2378, 05-CV-2386 05-CV-2386 05-CV-0999 05-CV-2386 05-CV-0569 05-CV-2386 05-CV-0889, 05-CV-0892 08-CV-0442, 05-CV-2386 08-CV-1223 04-CV-2022 04-1254, 05-1429, 05-1048 05-392, 05-526, 05-1220, 05-1347, 05-1971, 05-2088, 06-1684, 06-1690, 08-1153 06-CV-1668 08-CV-1230 08-CV-1231 Petitioner(s), if specifically identified by counsel Responding Attorney(s) Thomas Sullivan Charles Carpenter 1 * Paul Rashkind Paul Turner Michael Cooper * Susan Manning * Robert Rachlin H. Candace Gorman Peter Ellis * Shereen Charlick Matthew O'Hara Nancy Hollander James Nickovich Stephen Sady Noah Rashkind Robert Elliot Gaillard Hunt Alan Pemberton Wells Dixon Julia Symon Amy Cleary on behalf of Timothy Ivey, Andy Hart, and Jonathan Witmer-Rich Amy Cleary on behalf of Debra Hughes, Darin Thompson, and Amy Cleary

Al-Nashiri

Saeed Rahman Paracha

1

* Counsel for these Petitioner(s) responded to Respondents' effort to meet and confer, but did not set forth any answer with regard to whether petitioner(s) would oppose the instant motion or not. For purposes of this appendix, said counsel are being treated as if they had expressly objected.

08-CV-1233

08-CV-1236 05-CV-1645, 05-CV-1646 05-CV-2371 05-CV-0270 06-CV-1765 08-CV-5339 [sic] 05-CV-1678 07-CV-2337 07-CV-2338 07-CV-1710 05-CV-1638 Al Darbi El-Mashad and Algazzar Saleh Hentif Ahmed al Yazidi al Shubati Nasser Ghanem

Amy Cleary on behalf of Edward Bryan, Carlos Warner, and Jonathan Witmer-Rich Amy Cleary on behalf of Jacqueline Johnson, Vicki Werneke, and Amy Cleary Michael Poulshock and Judith Chomsky Karen Abravanel Carol Elder Bruce * Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson Adil Haq on behalf of Brent Rushforth and Kit Pierson

UNOPPOSED Civil Action No. 08-CV-1085 Petitioner(s), if specifically Responding Attorney(s) identified by counsel Scott Fenstermaker

CONSENT SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS 2 ** Civil Action No. 02-CV-0828
2

Petitioner(s), if specifically Responding Attorney(s) identified by counsel Matthew MacLean

** Counsel for these Petitioner(s) conditioned their consent to Respondents' motion on agreement by Respondents to several conditions which spoke to the legal authority of the Secretary of Defense, as the only proper respondent, to carry out the relief requested by Petitioners and to act on behalf of the government in the course of this litigation. Because such authority is dictated by the operation of law, Respondents consider such responses as effective refusal to consent to Respondents' motion.

05-CV-2386 05-CV-1353, 05-CV-1504, 05-CV-1505, 05-CV-1506, 05-CV-2087 04-CV-1194 05-CV-1487 05-CV-2384 05-CV-2386 06-CV-1761 05-CV-1983, 05-CV-2104 05-CV-2398 05-CV-2386 04-CV-1194 05-CV-1490 05-CV-0280 05-CV-2386 08-CV-1235, 08-CV-1237, 08-CV-1238 05-CV-0877 05-CV-1244 05-CV-2386 05-CV-2380 05-CV-2379 05-CV-0329, 05-CV-0764, 05-CV-1457, 05-CV-2386, 08-CV-1440 05-CV-0748 05-CV-0492 05-CV-1607 04-CV-1144, 08-CV-1360 05-CV-2386 05-CV-2386 05-CV-1124, 05-CV-1601, 05-CV-2367 05-CV-2199 04-CV-2035 05-CV-0998 08-CV-1224 08-CV-1227

Barbara Olshansky Anne Castle Al Madhwani Al-Sahlani Al Qahtaani and Zahrani Sulaiman Abdessalam Hassan and Thabid Al Yafie and Al Bihani Anam, Al Madhwani and Bin Amer Faraj Al-Assani, Al-Nahdi, AlAdahi, Bawazir and Hamdoon Al-Haag and Al Shamiri Khiali-Gul Alsawam Jabbarov Al-Baidany Ali-Awad Sarah Crane Sarah Crane Sarah Crane Sarah Crane Sarah Crane Wesley Powell George Clark George Clark Darold Kilmer Eldon Greenberg Brian Spahn Brian Spahn Craig Harbaugh Mary Petras Mary Petras Michael Mone Glenn Jones Glenn Jones Zachary Katznelson Joseph O'Neil Agnieszka Fryszman and Matt Handley Agnieszka Fryszman and Matt Handley George Brent Mickum Gordon Woodward David Marshall Juliet Sarkessian John Snodgrass Jonathan Hafetz Brian Mendelsohn Brian Mendelsohn Brian Mendelsohn

Aboassy petitioners Aziz Rabbani Mattan Ajam

Karim Gul Hafizullah

08-CV-1229 05-CV-0247 05-CV-2386 04-CV-2046 05-CV-2386 05-CV-0993 04-CV-2215 05-CV-0764 05-CV-0764 05-CV-1457

Yakubi Al-Mohammed Alsa'ary Zemiri Sohail Aamer Boujaadia Nasser Dhiab

Brian Mendelsohn Samuel Kauffman David Marshall Debra Schneider Ellen Lubell Scott Tilsen Cori Crider Cori Crider Cori Crider Cori Crider