AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR TESTING AND MATERIALS et al v. PUBLIC.RESOURCE.ORG, INC.
Filing 155
REPLY to opposition to motion re #118 MOTION for Summary Judgment filed by AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR TESTING AND MATERIALS, AMERICAN SOCIETY OF HEATING, REFRIGERATING, AND AIR-CONDITIONING ENGINEERS, INC., NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION, INC.. (Attachments: #1 Supplemental Statement of Undisputed Facts, #2 Disputes with Defendant's Statement of Facts, Evidentiary Objections and Opposition to Request for Judicial Notice, #3 Response to Defendant's Statement of Facts, #4 Response to Defendant's Evidentiary Objections, #5 Declaration of Steven Comstock, #6 Declaration of Christian Dubay, #7 Supplemental Declaration of Thomas O'Brien, #8 Supplemental Declaration of Jordana Rubel, #9 Supplemental Declaration of James Thomas)(Fee, J.) Modified on 1/22/2016 to correct linkage (td).
09 0; H? =4 >
fg FV ZZ =0@ <0= 7< A= @? @0=
i >< 08 0A 8O 08 09 90: 0I 0M <08
78 ;A DE ;C
J KL H0L ;L 0F :; NL N; DN PQ =N
>= KC JJ >E M0N 0E ND O0K 06 0M
1 0J B; 0E ;S
RR ;> MN D>
U 8S YU 9
V0W 0X 4Z
00000[ ;C 0F N0H >0D ;> LM M\ :L M?
00005 CO E0F =D M? EN ?F 0N N0D ;>
N 0^ _; Q; Q; 0F =D ;; ;> FM
:; :L ;0` M? MN _0H 0Q N0B NL
> DF Q; EO =D ;0J QF ;? =0Q ;0B F; _0N
;b >; MN 0H P> ;> NN 0N Lc =J E0= :;
C ;> H0< c0L 0? N> DN :; =0L =M
FN L> => M? FE FK ;0N Q0N MH ;e
0000000000W 0g Z` 00i ;B =M LC 0_ 0L ;\
XS `h 79 Kj NF k0B CE => 0C LC
B BC F= 0L DQ NL G; MB JC ;0: =N NF CO
=M DE MO >\ ;M NF O0F =Q ;N HJ :; BL
G D;
L\ S
00000000002 05 74 900` M0= LM LN M0N N0F
34 62 88 E0L >\ Fl F= :L E
L FC \0F ;C _0N 0^ _; Q; Q; O0L M\ N:
GL FM NE _0= :; :L ;0` M? MN Q= 0= ;>
N M\ 0< =0N =Q ;M :0N Lc D> :L
:F EO ;0\ =0E ;0C \N =0Q ;0E ;0N N
J JC FN >F 0? LK FN E0L 0N 0= H0J JC
;= ;0< :0J MN FE FC F; >; :; MC ;= ;
N N0L 0; \F ;0_ 0= 0E GF S
:L >; CF KC => D> ;> B;
U 8S YU 9
V0W 0X 4Z
00000[ M? =0H 0\ =0N E; ;M :E ;B E;
0000` 0? =D =0N := 0C \N 0K LD
F E0H >0D ;> LM M\ :L :; :L ;0` M? MN
NP =D M? EN ?F 0N N0N 0^ _; Q; Q;
> DF E0H 0N MC Lc :; LN FL 0L ;E KC
;b >; =D =0= H0Q ;0N 0Q ;> CE BB EF ;
N ;= ;0< :0J MN FE FC F;
=0J JC FN >F 0? LK FN Ee
0000000000W 0g Z` 00i ;B =M LC 0_ 0L ;\
XS `h 79 Kj NF k0B CE => 0C LC
B BC F= 0G D;
=M DE MO L\ S
00000000002 05 74 900` =Q M; := J; N;
34 62 88 E0E ;= 0< 0= >L E
D ;> :; :L ;0` M? MN =0E J= 0N NO ;0M ?
M? 0N 0^ _; Q; Q; 0N DJ >N :L 0< ;;
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
0
1
0
C
0
J
0
/
0
.
0
Y
0
`
0
b
0
g
1
h
1
1
1
C
1
J
1
/
1
.
1
Y
1
`
1
b
1
g
C
h
C
1
C
C
C
J
C
/
C
.
2 56 402 20; 5< ?6 ?@ 402 A02 43 40;
304 78 9: 403 =0> 28 72 94 30B B< 93
9 40E ?5 ?6 ?< ?4 00I H
:D 7: F= G0> :@ ?2 6H 46
K MH OK R
I0L 0N PQ
00000S 9= 602 2U
0000T 0? 9:
00000V 4W 64 X
0000K :7 0X
0000000000L 0Z QV 00] 4W 35 :< 0F 0: 4G
NH V[ \R @^ 2? _0W <6 38 0< :<
W W< ?3 0W <6 38 B4 <: 35 :G H
35 76 5a :< 0F 06 W7 2? a0D 74
0000000000c 0T \P R00e X0e 4< D4 9: 602
dP ec MM 0X 0@ ?4 02 2f 94
< G7 403 94 2: 24 9: 2f X02 20? 6
:5 :G F02 06 27 a02 20? 60X 9: 2f
A ?5 94 :2 ?: 0: ?< <4 38 43 40; 9
:i G02 0A 48 <6 D: :@ 0F 0B B< ?2
> :@ ?2 6H
?6 ?< ?4
K MH OK R
I0L 0N PQ
00000S 5> 02 5i 37 45 35 02 20K 42 9
0000V 0e 9? 0= 0A 2? 4> 9: 45 4W
3 8: 60: 05 B8 ?2 9: 37 37 0W 6? 80:
B4 24 60: 35 3F 02 20= 0; <> 35 >4 5
: 93 j4 52 =07 48 94 9: 40V 5> 52
72 8? >04 ?2 5> 02 0k F4 A4 A4 U
0000000000L 0Z QV 00] 4W 35 ?6 :2
NH V[ \R @^ 2? _0A 62 46
2 2? 5= :< 0F 0: 4G 0W W< ?3 0D 74
46 A3 a0W <6 38 0< :< 35 76 5a :G H
0000000000c 0T \P R00I H
dP ec MM 46
K MH OK R
I0L 0N PQ
00000S 84 94 0: 03 48 4E 84 52 9:
0000V 02 84 5= 29 08 7? A4 602 2
K 42 90A 20A 20? 8> 02 83 >4 3B 603
45 4W 76 44 503 48 30B D? 0W ?4 F
< 48 =0; i6 30B B< ?2 8? 0> :@ ?2 6
?2 :8 38 02 43 40; 90B 52 ?6 ?< ?4
7 48 94 9: 40V 5> 52
5> 02 0k F4 A4 A4 U
0000000000L 0Z QV 00] 4W 35 :< 0F 0: 4G
NH V[ \R @^ 2? _0W <6 38 0< :<
W W< ?3 0D 74
35 76 5a :G H
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
0
1
0
@
0
G
0
O
0
[
0
`
0
a
0
.
0
e
1
/
1
1
1
@
1
G
1
O
1
[
1
`
1
a
1
.
1
e
@
/
@
1
@
@
@
G
@
O
@
[
00000000002 56 86 36 38 0: 48 7= 37 64 6
34 07 09 09 66 7; 0< 509 90> >?
> AB 0> 4D D0C 7E B9
84 C6 84 04 B5 B? =F
00000H 4J 09 90E 4: BL D0C 94
0000I ?C 37 605 60K C04 4M 8N
0000000000P 0R US 00X 6M 4L 7Z F
QF ST VW E; 9B Y0A J6
00000000002 0I V] W00^ 78 50E B5 B? =0< 9
\] ^2 __ 90A B6 =0C 7E B9 37
> D6 B4 ?0M C6 B7 4: L6 66 09 7A 4
84 55 L7 86 L9 ?05 64 0L C5 403 609
> AB 07 68 DB 9B 04 B5 B? =F
84 C6 0M 9B M7 4L D0C 7E B9
b _F db W
c0P 0Q ]U
00000H 409 MM 50: 68 ?5 84 44 37 09 9
0000_ 407 65 79 B7 0D :0b K5 86 37
7 0: 60> 5J 909 36 37 60S LC L9 L
86 7C J8 7L 409 0f D6 :6 :6 g07
B BA J7 4J 03 603 09 34 4: 84 04
LC BC ?0< ?C 7A 7C 405 <05 60> 4D D
C 7E B9 =04 04 36 69 C5 37 4J J5
B5 B? =0E L6 D09 0: 34 09 90= 0; 9
C M8 6C 509 90M 86 N
65 BE Y0B 37 48 M9
0000000000P 0R US 00X 6M 4L B5 79
QF ST VW E; 9B Y0: 59 65
9 9B L= 7Z F
65 :4 g0A J6
00000000002 0I V] W00^ 36 37 60S LC L9 5
\] ^2 __ D09 0f D6 :6 :6 0B
4 04 36 6M LB 50< 86 5B 09 6? 68 36
L6 D09 0: 37 5: 6h 0J LZ 40C BA 09
E Kg 36 36 03 09 607 55 B7 4L B9
44 09 L09 86 75 40E L07 4M 9B 0< 307
> 54 B9 0i ?B BL B5 B? =0J 68 36 37 6
68 L0< 307 J7 D= Z0C 7E B9 LC 09 0f D6
S LC L9 404 7B 0M =8 39 0< KF 65
:6 :6 09 E9 L07 4> BZ 6C 48 00c F
b _F db W
c0P 0Q ]U
00000H LC 4J 7A 37 4L ZJ C0B 409
0000S 0= 03 609 90M DB 86 L9 36
5 9< 605 37 36 68 L0M MK 404 L09 9
4D 78 409 909 0> 54 ?B 509 >6 37
< Kg 4J B? 7A L5 6C 37 4J 7A 84 04
48 0= 0< ?03 606 J8 09 90= 03 60> 4D D
C 7E B9 L0D 6N
B5 B? =04 B?
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
0
/
0
K
0
Q
0
[
0
^
0
`
0
a
0
.
0
c
/
d
/
/
/
K
/
Q
/
[
/
^
/
`
/
a
/
.
/
c
K
d
K
/
K
K
K
Q
K
[
K
^
00000000001 04 75 00: => AB EF =B ?@ J
23 56 89 ;< ?@ C0D GH ?D I=
I G= D> 0O BP @A
DF J0L MN AG D? B3
0000000000R 0U 8T 9005 N= YA 0L F= B0X
ST VR WW 0G E0X ZN AF P0@ YA
> AN 0? AX AD 0> ]E Y? 0X M0X E= =Z
YA =N A0P BL P0D A\ @F =P AE Y= 0X E=
G BF Y= YD =05 BP B? N0A 0A GE
N@ 0? 0_ O= H= H= 0D B= O0A
< ?@ >D AB AE A@ 0N 0? E= N0D L= EA >
GN O@ ?@ N0O 0P BF AJ Y= 0@ B0= >? B@
@ @> @A B0b YD YD N0N =? BF Y= E=
BP D? B0@ b0? ?0? ?0@ AH Y@ 0? ]Z
\ H@ =P A0P
=E ?? 0? A3
0000000000W AH B= YA DN A? EA P= EA 0A
A0N =A 0X 0Y 0B 0\ I@ P0\ AO O
P D; @? N0B 0D AX 0? AX AD 0> ]E Y?
@N @L ]0@ A? LL =P A0P BL P0D A\ @F =P
X M0G =E Y= YD =05 BP B? G? Y= AG
AE BP 0? 0_ O= H= H= J0; 0? ]0> LP
P BL P0D G; >0P D@ E0> D? =0> H= N0X M3
AX AD 0\ L@ AH B0A E= @I AH B? AE
e W3 ge 9
f01 02 T7
00000h O0@ DN 0> ]E Y? 0X M0D 0? ]
0000V ?0X 0D A\ @F =P AE BP Y=
D =H =P A0P BL P0@ 0? ]0P 0B 0Y =0\ AO O
?? \? 0? AX AD ?J Y= @P A? DI EA 0A
P D; @? B0O =J YD AG 0Y \=
@N @L ]0A @L 0X ?0X LP D\ Bi
00000000001 04 75 00: => AB B> \L =
23 56 89 ;< ?@ C0@ AH =?
Y A? ?@ LJ D> 0O BP @A
]\ Y= >D 0L MN AG D? B3
0000000000R 0U 8T 9001 BP N? P@ 0@ O0? ]
ST VR WW ]0G =E DB BF N0@ Y=
Y =0B 0\ I@ P0\ AO O0P D; @? 0?
DI A? EA P= EA 0A @N @L ]J Y=
j XB DP G? B0P N0B 0D =D B0? 0? L= DF
kA LA j0; ?A A= A? \\ E0A Y= @? 0\ =J
N Y= DB @B G? YD =0Y =0? 0X MJ G? Y=
A0? ]0> 0O P0A 0? ?0X DI Y= AE 0; 0? ]
> Z? AX AD ?0G =N Y= 0D AG 0Y 0? ?
DB 0P BL P0@ BL N0? @E >> B? DN YD
= ;L J0D 0? B0? E= 0D G? B0? ?0N XN \
BD =P BP Y= Y= ZN 0; ?A YD YA 0G
? ?0N NJ AX A0] 0X ?0? AX AD ?i
YD D] 0S 0P AG DB A0P BL P0@
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
0
1
0
J
0
R
0
/
0
]
0
^
0
b
0
.
0
e
1
f
1
1
1
J
1
R
1
/
1
]
1
^
1
b
1
.
1
e
J
f
J
1
J
J
J
R
J
/
J
]
00000000002 05 86 00; >? BC EF 0H
34 67 9: <= @A D0? FG BI
G ?L @A M0F NG BL E@ CM EQ 4
K> FE BC E? 0H CO AB 0P L>
0000000000S 0V 9U :002 CO G@ OA 0Z 0@ @
TU WS XX Y0L >I EC CQ EG [E
B 0B [> G> H0@ 0G CC 0< NG EG B0\ >
C> H0@ 0L G0B [> ?E >O BB 0Z 0@ EN
< NG ?? GA >0@ >B >0Z [0O E< A@ G4
BB 0E >G S
c aS ec W
d1H 1B ^I
11111f >1M 1h E18 1K M1> 89 34 47 1>
1111g >@ 5> >E 45 J13 12 56 62 5
? <; 92 7A 21E 2; 1i >E 45 J1? ;5 JJ
@= A1B >@ 9C 9= 39 i18 1K M1> <4 3; C2
2 56 62 84 79 :4 4= 1> @= A1B >@ 9C
34 47 13 314 14 ;< <9 51? <; 92 7A 2
E 2; 14 1> M14 ;< <9 51? 1J K4
9= 39 79 5< :4 4= 1; gj >7 3R
11111U >S
1111V
11111f >1M 1h E18 1K M1> 89 34 47 13 3
1111g >@ 5> >E 45 J13 12 56 62 84
4 14 22 1; 8; 42 79 5< :4 4= 1>
79 31; @9 513 21A 914 1> M14 ;< <9 5
? <; 92 7A 21E 2; 1; gj >7 3R
@= A1B >@ 9C 9= 39 51? 1J K4
11111U >S
1111V
11111f >1M 1h E1; 89 @K 713 31;
1111g >@ 5> J13 15 =9 84 2
4 ;< <9 51? 1J K4 21N 43 13 513 15 =9
:4 4= 1; gj >7 31; 79 97 84 89 @K 7
4 ;< <9 51F I1J K4
:4 4= 1; GH >7 3R
1111111111H 1T IU 11X 9A >5 4N S
BS U? VW =Y 3; Z1: @9
1111111111G 1_ V^ W11` >@ 1= ;h M1J K1K
F^ `G aa 31E <6 91< 9< 7> M
; [9 ;> J13 16 9A 7; 13 313 79 >@ 1=
52 A3 51> 89 ;7 3> 92 84 89 1E <6 9
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/0
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
1
2
1
.
1
E
1
N
1
0
1
S
1
U
1
]
1
^
2
/
2
2
2
.
2
E
2
N
2
0
2
S
2
U
2
]
2
^
.
/
.
2
.
.
.
E
.
N
.
0
111113 56 9: =
11114 78 ;<
111111111111111> @9 1A 96 81C
?7 :; 6@ B6 D6
11111111117 6G H9 CJ L1C 1G 61G :8 8G
FF G9 I9 1K D6 7M C7 7A
1111111111F C6 1A 86 81H
K: :C 6: A6 J
1111111111O I9 56 PA QR 17 1C G6 L
PH FQ GK F6 A; :8 DK 1K
1111111111C 1L 617 6G TC :G AK 86 J
D6 A6 FF G1K 9K 1T @9 81H
1111111111C 1V 3X Y? Z17 13 \X C19 J
D6 WO 13 53 :8 Y[ 19 G1M
1111111111K :9 1C C1O I9 56 PA QR
T9 K: D7 PH FQ GK F6 A;
1111111111F A6 IJ AK 86 D6 :I
PA :C 1T @9 G1C 1K J
11111111117 6G HI TC :1L
FF G9 61K 9K KA
1111111111T TI F9 `6 1B D1T :C
6K 6_ C9 :G 9C A9
11111111118 7H 9C G1C FF G1C G6
9G 9I 96 K17 6G D6
1111111111G :8 8G
C7 7A Q>
11111a :8 :1L M9 1C C1K :9 X1J 1F T7 8
11113 19 KA :; D7 T9 K: KP KM A6
C 1G :8 8G D7 6A @7 7H 1K
D6 C7 7A 1C C1B 617 9I I6 :
O I9 56 PA QR bG 6H C6 9C D6 A6 FF G
PH FQ GK F6 A; 1B G9 1B D1C 1L 617 6G
K 9K 1T @9 81H I7 C9 G19 KA :; D7
TC :G AK 86 J1O 9: LL :1L M9 1C C
K :9 c19 D7 KA FC
T9 K: G1C C1F A6 d
111113 KA FC
1111e A6 Q
11111a 98 KP @7 7C :J fW 69 1G 81H
1111f 1J 16 IP 617 1O G1H :; KI J
V 319 KA :; D7 T9 K:
WO :1L M9 1C C1K :9 d
111113 KQ
1111V
11111a 98 KP @7 7C :J fW 69 1G 81H
1111f 1J 16 IP 617 1O G1H :; KI J
3 53 :1L M9 1C C1K :9 d
Y? Z19 KA :; D7 T9 K:
111113 KQ
1111V
$&' (6)*+
%&6 %
( 6
,,, 23178
3
21
6-6#
01 45 294 09 9 6 "!
6
.
/0
01 45 294 6
21
2316
309
78
831 69346
84 6 18354 56 56
86 !"!
8 6 31 6 4
166 3789 #
9
816
1
2
1
.
1
O
1
R
1
W
1
0
1
Z
1
^
1
_
2
/
2
2
2
.
2
O
2
R
2
W
2
0
2
Z
2
^
2
_
.
/
.
2
.
.
.
O
.
R
.
W
111113 56 89 ;< <> ?7 4A 8= 71D G15
11114 17 1: =9 :1< 1@ B1B 61C EF ?
H J5 1> >18 ?5 N
8I ?K L< M5 8?
11111D 8Q
1111P
111113 81S ?17 1B 1> >1@ =5 U: 9I QV
1111E L: 89 <7 L< 9C TQ B8 T: IK
T I: =7 I8 6: L: ?= TT B5 :18 58 8I
9I ?> 1M ;5 B1> 18 71< :B C= M> ?1H
M M= T5 Y: 1S L1M ?> 5B 5= 5: 81< :B
:8 :X >5 ?B 5> I5 16
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.