HOWARD v. AL JAZEERA AMERICA, LLC et al

Filing 1

COMPLAINT against All Defendants with Jury Demand ( Filing fee $ 400 receipt number 0090-4367752) filed by RYAN JAMES HOWARD. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H, # 9 Exhibit I, # 10 Exhibit J, # 11 Exhibit K, # 12 Exhibit L, # 13 Exhibit M, # 14 Exhibit N, # 15 Exhibit O, # 16 Exhibit P, # 17 Exhibit Q, # 18 Exhibit R, # 19 Exhibit S, # 20 Exhibit T, # 21 Exhibit U, # 22 Civil Cover Sheet, # 23 Summons AL JAZEERA AMERICA, LLC, # 24 Summons LIAM J. COLLINS, # 25 Summons DEBORAH DAVIES)(Herman, Andrew)

9@M@C 9FM<I J?<<K
AJ)00 %IWg* "+-/ ;9&

@* %S& GC7@EK@==J

;<=<E;7EKJ

Ryan James Howard
Citizens Bank Park, One Citizens Bank Way
Philadelphia, PA 19148

Al Jazeera America, LLC
Liam James Collins
Deborah Davies

88888

11001
5BHAGL B8 E7F<67A57 B8 8<EFG ?<FG76 6787A63AG RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
%@E L*J* GC7@EK@== 97J<J FECP&

%T& 5BHAGL B8 E7F<67A57 B8 8<EFG ?<FG76 C?3<AG<88 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
%<O9<GK @E L*J* GC7@EK@== 97J<J&

ABG72 <A ?3A6 5BA67@A3G<BA 53F7F$ HF7 G;7 ?B53G<BA B8 G;7 GE35G B8 ?3A6 <AIB?I76

%U& 3GGBEA7LF "8<E@ A3@7$ 366E7FF$ 3A6 G7?7C;BA7 AH@47E#

3GGBEA7LF "<8 >ABJA#

Andrew D. Herman
Miller & Chevalier Chartered
Suite 900, 655 Fifteenth Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005 202-626-5800

Robert Corn-Revere
Davis Wright Tremaine LLP
Suite 800, 1919 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington, D.C. 20006

@@* 87J@J F= ALI@J;@9K@FE

o
o

@@@* 9@K@Q<EJ?@G F= GI@E9@G7C G7IK@<J "C?357 3A e <A BA7 4BK 8BE

"C?357 3A e <A BA7 4BK BA?L#

o

) H&F& 9\cR_[ZR[a
CYNV[aVSS

o

* H&F& 9\cR_[ZR[a
6RSR[QN[a

+ 8RQR_NY DbR`aV\[
"H&F& 9\cR_[ZR[a A\a N CN_af#
, 6VcR_`Vaf
"<[QVPNaR 5VaVgR[`UV] \S
CN_aVR` V[ VaRZ <<<#

C?3<AG<88 3A6 BA7 4BK 8BE 6787A63AG# =FI ;@M<IJ@KP 97J<J FECP"
;=K
GK=

5VaVgR[ \S aUV` FaNaR
5VaVgR[ \S 3[\aUR_ FaNaR
5VaVgR[ \_ FbOWRPa \S N
8\_RVT[ 5\b[a_f

o) o)
o* o*
o+ o+

<[P\_]\_NaRQ \_ C_V[PV]NY CYNPR
\S 4b`V[R`` V[ GUV` FaNaR
<[P\_]\_NaRQ N[Q C_V[PV]NY
CYNPR \S 4b`V[R`` V[ 3[\aUR_ FaNaR
8\_RVT[ ANaV\[

GK=

;=K

o, o,
o- oo. o.

@M* 97J< 7JJ@>ED<EK 7E; E7KLI< F= JL@K
%G^SUW S` O [` a`W USeWYacj( 7)E( eZSe TWde cWbcWdW`ed jafc 9SfdW aX 7Ue[a` S`V a`W [` S UaccWdba`V[`Y ESefcW aX Jf[e&

o

7* Antitrust
0-, 7`e[#cfde

o

o

o

8* Personal Injury/
Malpractice
/-, 7[cb^S`W
/-1 7[cb^S`W GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
/., 7ddSf^e( C[TW^ $ J^S`VWc
//, =WVWcS^ <_b^ajWcd C[ST[^[ej
/0, DSc[`W
/01 DSc[`W GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
/1, Daeac MWZ[U^W
/11 Daeac MWZ[U^W GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
/2, FeZWc GWcda`S^ @`\fcj
/2. DWV[US^ DS^bcSUe[UW
/21 GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
/23 ?WS^eZ 9ScW+GZSc_SUWfe[US^
GWcda`S^ @`\fcj GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
/24 7dTWdead GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej

<* General Civil (Other)

IWS^ GcabWcej
.-, CS`V 9a`VW_`Se[a`
.., =acWU^adfcW
./, IW`e( CWSdW $ <\WUe_W`e
.0, Kaced ea CS`V
.01 Kace GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
.5, 7^^ FeZWc IWS^ GcabWcej
GWcda`S^ GcabWcej
/3, FeZWc =cSfV
/3- KcfeZ [` CW`V[`Y
/4, FeZWc GWcda`S^ GcabWcej
;S_SYW
/41 GcabWcej ;S_SYW
GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej

9* Administrative Agency
Review
-1- DWV[UScW 7Ue

JaU[S^ JWUfc[ej
42- ?@7 %-/51XX&
42. 8^SU] Cf`Y %5./&
42/ ;@N9+;@NN %0,1%Y&&
420 JJ@; K[e^W OM@
421 IJ@ %0,1%Y&&
FeZWc JeSefeWd
45- 7Yc[Uf^efcS^ 7Ued
45/ <`g[ca`_W`eS^ DSeeWcd
45, FeZWc JeSefeacj 7Ue[a`d %@X
7V_[`[decSe[gW 7YW`Uj [d
@`ga^gWV&

FI

o

8S`]cfbeUj
0.. 7bbWS^ .3 LJ9 -14
0./ N[eZVcShS^ .4 LJ9 -13
Gc[da`Wc GWe[e[a`d
1/1 ;WSeZ GW`S^ej
10, DS`VS_fd $ FeZWc
11, 9[g[^ I[YZed
111 Gc[da` 9a`V[e[a`d
12, 9[g[^ ;WeS[`WW l 9a`V[e[a`d
aX 9a`X[`W_W`e
GcabWcej I[YZed
4., 9abjc[YZed
4/, GSeW`e
40, KcSVW_Sc]
=WVWcS^ KSi Jf[ed
43, KSiWd %LJ b^S[`e[XX ac
VWXW`VS`e&
43- @IJ)KZ[cV GScej .2 LJ9 32,5

o

;* Temporary Restraining
Order/Preliminary
Injunction

7`j `SefcW aX df[e Xca_ S`j USeWYacj
_Sj TW dW^WUeWV Xac eZ[d USeWYacj aX USdW
Sdd[Y`_W`e*
'%@X 7`e[ecfde( eZW` 7 YagWc`d&'

=* Pro Se General Civil
=acXW[efcW+GW`S^ej
2.1 ;cfY IW^SeWV JW[kfcW aX
GcabWcej .- LJ9 4425, FeZWc

FeZWc JeSefeWd
/31 =S^dW 9^S[_d 7Ue
0,, JeSeW IWSbbace[a`_W`e
0/, 8S`]d $ 8S`][`Y
01, 9a__WcUW+@99
ISeWd+WeU*
02, ;WbaceSe[a`
02. ESefcS^[kSe[a`
7bb^[USe[a`
021 FeZWc @__[YcSe[a`
7Ue[a`d
03, ISU]WeWWc @`X^fW`UWV
$ 9accfbe FcYS`[kSe[a`

04, 9a`df_Wc 9cWV[e
05, 9ST^W+JSeW^^[eW KM
41, JWUfc[e[Wd+9a__aV[e[Wd+
<iUZS`YW
452 7cT[ecSe[a`
455 7V_[`[decSe[gW GcaUWVfcW
7Ue+IWg[Wh ac 7bbWS^ aX
7YW`Uj ;WU[d[a`
51, 9a`de[efe[a`S^[ej aX JeSeW
JeSefeWd
45, FeZWc JeSefeacj 7Ue[a`d
%[X `ae SV_[`[decSe[gW SYW`Uj
cWg[Wh ac Gc[gSUj 7Ue&

o

>* Habeas Corpus/
2255

o

o

?* Employment
Discrimination

451 =cWWVa_ aX @`Xac_Se[a` 7Ue
45, FeZWc JeSefeacj 7Ue[a`d
%[X Gc[gSUj 7Ue&

00. 9[g[^ I[YZed l <_b^aj_W`e
%Uc[eWc[S6 cSUW( YW`VWc+dWi(
`Se[a`S^ ac[Y[`(
V[dUc[_[`Se[a`( V[dST[^[ej( SYW(
cW^[Y[a`( cWeS^[Se[a`&

1/, ?STWSd 9acbfd l >W`WcS^
1-, Dae[a`+MSUSeW JW`eW`UW
02/ ?STWSd 9acbfd l 7^[W`
;WeS[`WW

'%@X bca dW( dW^WUe eZ[d VWU]&'

o

B* Labor/ERISA
(non-employment)
3-, =S[c CSTac JeS`VScVd 7Ue
3., CSTac+DY_e* IW^Se[a`d
30, CSTac IS[^hSj 7Ue
31- =S_[^j S`V DWV[US^
CWSgW 7Ue
35, FeZWc CSTac C[e[YSe[a`
35- <_b^* IWe* @`U* JWUfc[ej 7Ue

M* FI@>@E

o - Fc[Y[`S^

GcaUWWV[`Y

o . IW_%&$#

Xca_ JeSeW
9afce

o

@* FOIA/Privacy Act

o

-1. IWUagWcj aX ;WXSf^eWV
JefVW`e CaS`
%WiU^fV[`Y gWeWcS`d&

'%@X bca dW( dW^WUe eZ[d VWU]&'

o

A* Student Loan

C* Other Civil Rights
(non-employment)

o

D* Contract
--, @`dfcS`UW
-., DSc[`W
-/, D[^^Wc 7Ue
-0, EWYae[ST^W @`decf_W`e
-1, IWUagWcj aX FgWcbSj_W`e
$ <`XacUW_W`e aX
AfVY_W`e
-1/ IWUagWcj aX FgWcbSj_W`e
aX MWeWcS`md 8W`WX[ed
-2, JeaU]Za^VWcmd Jf[ed
-5, FeZWc 9a`ecSUed
-51 9a`ecSUe GcaVfUe C[ST[^[ej
-52 =cS`UZ[dW

00- Mae[`Y %[X `ae Mae[`Y I[YZed
7Ue&
00/ ?afd[`Y+7UUa__aVSe[a`d
00, FeZWc 9[g[^ I[YZed
001 7_Wc[US`d h+;[dST[^[e[Wd l
<_b^aj_W`e
002 7_Wc[US`d h+;[dST[^[e[Wd l
FeZWc
004 <VfUSe[a`

E* Three-Judge
Court
00- 9[g[^ I[YZed l Mae[`Y
%[X Mae[`Y I[YZed 7Ue&

o / IW_S`VWV Xca_ o 0 IW[`deSeWV ac o 1 KcS`dXWccWV Xca_ o 2 Df^e[)V[dec[Ue o 3 7bbWS^ ea
7bbW^^SeW 9afce

IWabW`WV

S`aeZWc V[dec[Ue
%dbWU[Xj&

C[e[YSe[a`

;[dec[Ue AfVYW
Xca_ DSY* AfVYW

M@* 97LJ< F= 79K@FE %9@K< K?< L*J* 9@M@C JK7KLK< LE;<I N?@9? PFL 7I< =@C@E> 7E; NI@K< 7 8I@<= JK7K<D<EK F= 97LJ<*&

28 U.S.C. § 1332 (diversity citizenship). The primary cause of action is libel.
M@@* I<HL<JK<; @E
9FDGC7@EK

5;75> <8 G;<F <F 3 9C7JJ
79K@FE HA67E 8&E&5&C& *+

M@@@* I<C7K<; 97J<%J&
@= 7EP

"FRR V[`a_bPaV\[#

1/5/2016
;7K<6 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

;<D7E; # more than 75,000
ALIP ;<D7E;6
P<J

8

EF

5URPX L7F \[Yf VS QRZN[QRQ V[ P\Z]YNV[a

P<J

8

EF

<S fR`$ ]YRN`R P\Z]YRaR _RYNaRQ PN`R S\_Z

/s/ Andrew D. Herman
J@>E7KLI< F= 7KKFIE<P F= I<9FI; RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
@EJKIL9K@FEJ =FI 9FDGC<K@E> 9@M@C 9FM<I J?<<K AJ)00
7feZac[ej Xac 9[g[^ 9agWc JZWWe

GUR =F%,, PVcVY P\cR_ `URRa N[Q aUR V[S\_ZNaV\[ P\[aNV[RQ UR_RV[ [RVaUR_ _R]YNPR` [\_ `b]]YRZR[a` aUR SVYV[T` N[Q `R_cVPR` \S ]YRNQV[T` \_ \aUR_ ]N]R_` N` _R^bV_RQ
Of YNd$ RePR]a N` ]_\cVQRQ Of Y\PNY _bYR` \S P\b_a& GUV` S\_Z$ N]]_\cRQ Of aUR =bQVPVNY 5\[SR_R[PR \S aUR H[VaRQ FaNaR` V[ FR]aRZOR_ )1/,$ V` _R^bV_RQ S\_ aUR b`R \S aUR
5YR_X \S 5\b_a S\_ aUR ]b_]\`R \S V[VaVNaV[T aUR PVcVY Q\PXRa `URRa& 5\[`R^bR[aYf$ N PVcVY P\cR_ `URRa V` `bOZVaaRQ a\ aUR 5YR_X \S 5\b_a S\_ RNPU PVcVY P\Z]YNV[a SVYRQ&
?V`aRQ ORY\d N_R aV]` S\_ P\Z]YRaV[T aUR PVcVY P\cR_ `URRa& GUR`R aV]` P\V[PVQR dVaU aUR E\ZN[ AbZR_NY` \[ aUR P\cR_ `URRa&
@*

5BHAGL B8 E7F<67A57 B8 8<EFG ?<FG76 C?3<AG<88'6787A63AG "O# 5\b[af \S _R`VQR[PR2 H`R ))(() a\ V[QVPNaR ]YNV[aVSS VS _R`VQR[a
\S JN`UV[Ta\[$ 65$ 00000 VS ]YNV[aVSS V` _R`VQR[a \S H[VaRQ FaNaR` Oba [\a JN`UV[Ta\[$ 65$ N[Q 11111 VS ]YNV[aVSS V` \ba`VQR aUR H[VaRQ FaNaR`&

@@@*

5<G<M7AF;<C B8 CE<A5<C3? C3EG<7F2 GUV` `RPaV\[ V` P\Z]YRaRQ \[Yf VS QVcR_`Vaf \S PVaVgR[`UV] dN` `RYRPaRQ N` aUR 4N`V` \S =b_V`QVPaV\[
b[QR_ FRPaV\[ <<&

@M*

53F7 3FF<9A@7AG 3A6 A3GHE7 B8 FH<G2 GUR N``VT[ZR[a \S N WbQTR a\ f\b_ PN`R dVYY QR]R[Q \[ aUR PNaRT\_f f\b `RYRPa aUNa OR`a
_R]_R`R[a` aUR ]_VZN_f PNb`R \S NPaV\[ S\b[Q V[ f\b_ P\Z]YNV[a& L\b ZNf `RYRPa \[Yf \[R PNaRT\_f& L\b Zb`a NY`\ `RYRPa \[R P\__R`]\[QV[T
[Nab_R \S `bVa S\b[Q b[QR_ aUR PNaRT\_f \S aUR PN`R&

M@*

53HF7 B8 35G<BA2 5VaR aUR H&F& 5VcVY FaNabaR b[QR_ dUVPU f\b N_R SVYV[T N[Q d_VaR N O_VRS `aNaRZR[a \S aUR ]_VZN_f PNb`R&

M@@@*

E7?3G76 53F7"F#$ <8 3AL2 <S f\b V[QVPNaRQ aUNa aUR_R V` N _RYNaRQ PN`R$ f\b Zb`a P\Z]YRaR N _RYNaRQ PN`R S\_Z$ dUVPU ZNf OR \OaNV[RQ S_\Z
aUR 5YR_Xh` BSSVPR&

4RPNb`R \S aUR [RRQ S\_ NPPb_NaR N[Q P\Z]YRaR V[S\_ZNaV\[$ f\b `U\bYQ R["b_R aUR NPPb_NPf \S aUR V[S\_ZNaV\[ ]_\cVQRQ ]_V\_ a\ `VT[V[T aUR S\_Z&