CABLE NEWS NETWORK, INC. et al v. TRUMP et al

Filing 3

LARGE ADDITIONAL ATTACHMENT(S) re 2 MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order filed by CABLE NEWS NETWORK, INC., ABILIO JAMES ACOSTA. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 7, # 2 Exhibit 8, # 3 Exhibit 9, # 4 Exhibit 10, # 5 Exhibit 11, # 6 Exhibit 12, # 7 Exhibit 13, # 8 Exhibit 14, # 9 Exhibit 15, # 10 Exhibit 16, # 11 Exhibit 17, # 12 Exhibit 18, # 13 Exhibit 19, # 14 Exhibit 20, # 15 Exhibit 21, # 16 Exhibit 22, # 17 Exhibit 23, # 18 Exhibit 24, # 19 Exhibit 25, # 20 Exhibit 26, # 21 Exhibit 27, # 22 Exhibit 28, # 23 Exhibit 29, # 24 Exhibit 30, # 25 Exhibit 31, # 26 Exhibit 32, # 27 Exhibit 33, # 28 Exhibit 34, # 29 Exhibit 35, # 30 Exhibit 36, # 31 Exhibit 37, # 32 Exhibit 38, # 33 Exhibit 39, # 34 Exhibit 40, # 35 Exhibit 41, # 36 Exhibit 42, # 37 Exhibit 43, # 38 Exhibit 44, # 39 Exhibit 45, # 40 Exhibit 46, # 41 Exhibit 47, # 42 Exhibit 48, # 43 Exhibit 49, # 44 Exhibit 50, # 45 Exhibit 51, # 46 Exhibit 52, # 47 Exhibit 53, # 48 Exhibit 54)(jf)

Exhibit 46

11/11/2018

"Doctored" video of CNN reporter Jim Acosta and White House intern shared by Sarah Sanders - CBS News

Trending Videos

CBSN LIVE »
CBS Evening News

Harsh conditions fuel
Calif. wildfires

60 Minutes Overtime

What does liquid gold
look like?

CBS Evening News

Man & dog use creek
to survive Calif. fire
NEWS

S H OW S

VIDEO

CBSN

WAT C H L I V E

MORE

CBSN LIVE

By CHRISTOPHER BRITO / CBS NEWS / November 8, 2018, 4:24 PM

White House accused of
sharing "doctored" video of
CNN reporter, intern
exchange
Share /

Tweet /

Reddit /

Flipboard /

Paid content by Trendchaser

The Real Reason Meg Ryan's
Career Was Destroyed

Email

Less than a day after banning CNN reporter Jim Acosta from the White House,
press secretary Sarah Sanders is facing additional scrutiny after sharing an edited
video clip that showed Acosta's brief exchange with an aide over a mic. Among the
critics was a CNN executive who called it "a doctored video – actual fake news."

Watch CBSN Live

The White House said Wednesday it was suspending Acosta's "hard pass," which
allows him press access to the White House, because it will "never tolerate a
reporter placing his hands on a young woman just trying to do her job as a White
House intern."
"This is a lie," Acosta tweeted in response to that statement.
The incident in question occurred during a White House press conference
Wednesday, when Acosta was trying to ask President Trump a question about
whether his campaign rhetoric "demonized immigrants." "That's enough. That's
enough," Mr. Trump said, and tried to move on to another reporter, but Acosta
persisted with his questioning.
At that point, a White House intern reached over and tried to take the microphone
away from him. "Pardon me, ma'am," Acosta said to her as he hung onto the mic.
(Watch the full video in the player above.)
Sanders shared an edited version of the footage that slows down the intern's
approach to Acosta and then appears to speed up on the journalist's arm
movement. "We will not tolerate the inappropriate behavior clearly documented in
this video," she wrote in a tweet.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jim-acosta-sarah-sanders-cnn-reporter-white-house-intern-video-doctored/

Thousand Oaks shooter was
actively posting on Instagram
during shooting
President Trump blasts
California's forest
management, threatens to
withhold federal disaster funds
President Trump in France to
mark 100 years since the end
of World War I
Death toll from California
wildfires has climbed to at
least 11
Wildfires in California have
killed at least 9, destroyed
thousands of homes, and left
many homeless

1/6

11/11/2018

"Doctored" video of CNN reporter Jim Acosta and White House intern shared by Sarah Sanders - CBS News

Follow CBS News

Tweets by @CBSNews
CBS News
@CBSNews

Sarah Sanders
@PressSec

Can't watch the 2018 E! People's Choice Awards
tonight? Here's the list of winners so far.
cbsn.ws/2QCNiWX

We stand by our decision to revoke this individual’s hard pass.
We will not tolerate the inappropriate behavior clearly
documented in this video.
100K 10:33 PM - Nov 7, 2018
120K people are talking about this

Journalists and others on social media criticized Sanders for distributing the
video, which created the appearance that the encounter was more "violent" than it
actually was.

6m
CBS News
@CBSNews
E! People's Choice Awards: Scarlett Johansson
wins female movie star of 2018
cbsn.ws/2QAf1Yw

White House video was doctored, analyst says

Embed

0:57

View on Twitter

Latest From "60 Minutes"
Europeans take back control
of their data

"Absolutely shameful," CNN vice president of communications and digital
partnerships Matt Dornic tweeted. "You released a doctored video – actual fake
news. History will not be kind to you."

What lies 2 miles below
Earth's surface?
andrew kaczynski
@KFILE

The Griffin brothers' journey to
the NFL

The video shared by the White House to justify banning Jim
@Acosta appears to be a doctored video created by an Infowars
editor.

Why do mass shooters choose
the AR-15 style rifle?

The video slows down the intern's approach/speeds up Acosta's
arm movement, making it appear more
violent.businessinsider.com/jim-acosta-vid…
4,470 8:21 AM - Nov 8, 2018

Riding the waves of Nazaré with Garrett
McNamara

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jim-acosta-sarah-sanders-cnn-reporter-white-house-intern-video-doctored/

2/6

11/11/2018

"Doctored" video of CNN reporter Jim Acosta and White House intern shared by Sarah Sanders - CBS News

The Senate race predicting
America's future

Whistleblower says bishop
allowed problem priests to stay
on job

White House appears to share Jim Acosta mic grab video doc…
Sarah Huckabee Sanders is accused of using a video of CNN's Jim
Acosta doctored by Infowars as justification for suspending the

The final phase of America's
war on ISIS

businessinsider.com

The new maestro of the New
York Philharmonic

3,073 people are talking about this

Tracing family trees to catch
killers

THE ULTIMATE
HOLIDAY GIFT
SELECTION

Rafael Shimunov

SHOP NOW

@rafaelshimunov

1) Took @PressSec Sarah Sanders' video of briefing
2) Tinted red and made transparent over CSPAN video
3) Red motion is when they doctored video speed
4) Sped up to make Jim Acosta's motion look like a chop
5) I've edited video for 15+ years
6) The White House doctored it
191K 3:34 AM - Nov 8, 2018
93.5K people are talking about this
play VIDEO

Harsh conditions fuel Calif.
wildfires

Asha Rangappa
@AshaRangappa_

.@PressSec you are seriously tweeting out an obviously
doctored video – from InfoWars no less – to substantiate a false
accusation of assault against a journalist???

Latest From CBS News
Trump criticized for
"demeaning" comments about
California fires

The standard for libel against a public figure is acting with
“actual malice,” and your tweet is Exhibit A.
Sarah Sanders

E! People's Choice Awards
2018: Winners and highlights

@PressSec

We stand by our decision to revoke this individual’s hard pass. We
will not tolerate the inappropriate behavior clearly documented in this
video.

E! People's Choice Awards 2018 list of
winners

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jim-acosta-sarah-sanders-cnn-reporter-white-house-intern-video-doctored/

3/6

11/11/2018

"Doctored" video of CNN reporter Jim Acosta and White House intern shared by Sarah Sanders - CBS News

Your Data, Ultra Deep, The
Pact

Factors contributing to
California's explosive and
deadly wildfire season
Death toll jumps as historic
California wildfires prompt
disaster declaration request

47.6K 6:51 AM - Nov 8, 2018
19.9K people are talking about this

Reporters from CNN, Newsweek, the Washington Post and other outlets traced
the origins of the edited video and said it was first posted by a commentator
associated with Alex Jones' right-wing conspiracy site, InfoWars.

Nicole Goodkind
@NicoleGoodkind

This is a video that Infowars made. They sped it up so that it
seems more violent than it is.
Sarah Sanders

55 PHOTOS

Wildfires tear through Northern,
Southern California

@PressSec

We stand by our decision to revoke this individual’s hard pass. We
will not tolerate the inappropriate behavior clearly documented in this
video.

Popular On CBS News

01

Trump criticized for
"demeaning" comments about
California fires
96655 views

02
03
2,774 11:42 PM - Nov 7, 2018
1,350 people are talking about this

Celebrity homes, "Westworld"
set, destroyed by Calif. wildfire
Cruz opposes legislation to
protect Mueller investigation

04

63798 views

59839 views

Trump marks 100 years since
end of WWI with tribute to
fallen soldiers
15253 views

Brian Stelter

05

@brianstelter

Vet mocked by Pete Davidson
accepts apology in surprise
"SNL" appearance
7205 views

Question for @PressSec: Where'd you obtain the distorted
@Acosta video you posted? InfoWars personality
@PrisonPlanet posted the same video two hours before you did.
Surely you don't trust InfoWars...?
24.6K 12:52 AM - Nov 8, 2018
9,548 people are talking about this

Sanders stuck by the White House statement — and the video — on Thursday.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jim-acosta-sarah-sanders-cnn-reporter-white-house-intern-video-doctored/

4/6

11/11/2018

"Doctored" video of CNN reporter Jim Acosta and White House intern shared by Sarah Sanders - CBS News

"The question is: did the reporter make contact or not? The video is clear, he did.
We stand by our statement," Sanders told the press pool.
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Share /

Tweet /

Reddit /

Flipboard /

Email

Sponsored Links

If Your Dog Eats Grass (Do This Everyday)
Ultimate Pet Nutrition

U.S. Cardiologist: It's Like a Power Wash for Your Insides

CBS News on Amazon Fire TV

Health Headlines

Antonio Banderas Daughter Is All Grown Up And Looks Just Like Tippi Hedren,
Her Famous Grandmother
InvestmentGuru

Georgia high school band spells out racial slur with instrument covers during
half-time show
Scott Walker narrowly loses Wisconsin governor's race – and he can't ask for a
recount because of a law he put in place
.

Sponsored Links

Play this strategy for 3 minutes and see why everyone is addicted
Total Battle - Online Strategy Game

27 Discounts Seniors Get Only If They Know
Senior Discounts Club

CBSNews.com

CBS Interactive

Follow Us

Site Map
Help

Privacy Policy
Ad Choice

Facebook
Twitter

Contact Us
CBS Bios
Careers
CBSi Careers
Internships
Development Programs

Terms of Use
Mobile User Agreement
About CBS
Advertise
Closed Captioning
CBS News Store

RSS
Email Newsletters
YouTube
CBS News Radio
CBS Local

Search...

Copyright © 2018 CBS Interactive Inc.
All rights reserved.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jim-acosta-sarah-sanders-cnn-reporter-white-house-intern-video-doctored/

5/6