United States of America v. Hendry County School District et al

Filing 119

ORDER granting 117 Joint Motion for Declaration of Partial Unitary Status and for Approval of Stipulation regarding Faculty and Staff Recruitment and Student Discipline. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/20/2017. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit: Stipulation Regarding Faculty and Staff Recruitment and Student Discipline) (mmd)

UNI
TED S
TATES DI TRI CO URT
S W
S
OUTM RN DI
STRI OF FLOO A
W

Ca eNo 7 - 06 - C W - W D ( W s . :1 9
A% o
UNI
TED STA TES OF AM ERI
CA,

Pli i
antf,
V.

BOARD OF EDUCATI OF HENDRY
ON
COU NTY,
m f
endant
.
/
ORDER

n i Ca ei h f r te CO u n te J i Mo n f De l on o Pa i Uni
s us s o e h M po h ont uo or ce
f i
>
Stt s M d f App o l of S i u a i r ga d ng Fa u t a d SkF Re x ii a S d n
au
or
r va
tp l ton e r i
c ly n
c tng nd m e t

Dicpl (heNontMoto ' sbmitd b t Unie Sttsa leBo r o Edu ai o
si i t
ne
i
in' u te y he td ae nd
)
ad f c ton f

He * Co t as kno a teSc oo BoadofHe e Co l (heG s t'(oletvey
n
uny, lo wn s h h l r
n
un t Diic' c lci l,
)
t : ris'.Fo t rme sgve beow, hsOr e g a t t J ntM oi a a pr st e
he ' te ' r he p nn i n l t i d r r ns he oi ton nd p ove h
Px )

Pm is Sip ain r adig Fa ut a Sa Remii a d Std nt Dicplne (he
e' ulto eg r n c ly nd tF c t n u e
ng
si i t
G iulto '
Stp ain).
1
.

Pr e
oe due H lt n a Se uht d Fac g
e o nd
e
t
n e Un t d St t si tae t i l ws i a i s t e Di i to J y 8 1 70 a l gi f t
ie a e niit d h s a u t ga n t h e c n ul , 9 , le ng bn

t Di ctcontnued t om r ea duals
he e
i
o
at
choolsys e bn-. on r On J y 31,1970,t Cour
tm
d ace.
ul
he
t

is d aprlmiay o d rt a r ql e c nv ri o teDi c fo ad l oau o s tm
sue
ei n r r e h t e lr d o e son f h e t r m ua t ni yse
i

i a c da c wi ier uie nss tf % i Siglt v J kmnM u cpal par eSc o
n co ne +
m rme t e o n n eon . ac
nil Se at h ol

Dflff 41 F. 1 1( t Ci.1 9 .bu rs r e nlig on sud n m sg n . n e Co r
zrc, 9 2d 2l 5h r 96 ) t e ev d ln
t e t q inme t
ut

a o e t e Dii c ' s u n a sg n pln on Au s 29 1 0 a i u a s m u nt
d pt d h s ts t de t s i nme t a
gu t , 97 , nd % e
ub e

o nona o ro Aug t4,1 71th l gu t1 71Ore'.die tn leDidc t m*e
pii nd de n us 9 te s s 9
Au
d r' rcig
)
s to
ce n modi tol t t pln.
dmi
fca i u o he a

OnJ n r 1 ,1 75 teCo te txda ore t NaI 1 Or p'+a d sol d
a uay 3 9 ,h ur ne n d r +e I
UG 975 de ) t is ve

teAu s 1 71Ore a pe anntyej n dt DititA m ç p mtn ad ls se o
h gu t 9 d r nd nn e l noie he src
e e ig ua y#m f
o
Ocal i ni bl s hû l. J nu l 1 75 Or ra 1 T% Co tas odee t Did c t
il de tsa e c os' a a 9
y
'
de t .
ur lo
r d he s t o

c ntn t ()e enoa to t sg t su e t o fc lylt e orwhhl Kho so t
o iue o: 1
cin o e agae td ns r a ut we n
n ol n he
bai o mc , oo,o nain l i n;2 e s eta saf n a ni% tr aeG e ,si e ,
ss f e c lr r to a orgi () nur h t tfa d dmi s os r hi asgn d
pr ed,pad,demot dim ise a ot w i teaed' wi outr d t mce,col ,or
omot
i
ed, s s d, nd her se r t ' i
egar o
or

n to l ii;()e sl b tn po to i povde o an di i n tq b ss ( e ut
aina orgn 3 n l us rn eAin s r i d n on- xrmiao ai;4) nsr
O ta 1 c ol on % c i , on o i uo a st s l c i n a e do e t pr ve l er c n eof
1 s ho c s ton c s l& n, nd ie e e to r n o e nt e u= c

adu ls tm;a ()e uet t 1itrdiic M nse a pe ltdonan -ici n tv
a yse nd 5 nsr ha a1ne- s t fo m M te
ondsrmlso
b sw e c p t t t e wil n be pe it d :wh r t e c mul tv e t wil r d c
a i x e t ha h y l ot
= te t e e b u a i e fec l e u e

d sge ai 'i He o teoh rsboo dsrc.1 a 23.TheCo r rtie j iditon
ee rg ton'n n* r h tt c l itit d. t ut ean d urs ci

t e freteNr n n ijn io .
o n oc h ma e tnu c n
n eDii c s c e sul d s grg td iss ho s Dl ig te 1 69 70s ho y a ,he
s t u c sf ly e e e ae t c ol. l n h 9 - c ol e r t
r

Did c o mtd 5v s ho l a e r le a r i tl 30 4 s e t ( 4. wht.2 3
s t pe e e c os nd n o ld pp oxmaey ,9 md n s 6 3% ie 5.%
blc a 1 4% o h r. Oneo te;v s ho s Ha lm Ac d my, sad r blc xh ol
a k, nd 0. t e)
f h e c ol, re a e wa eju e a k o .
Fo t e201 - 6 s h ol a,heDitite r le 7.27su nt i t les h s i ldigt
rh
5 1 c o ye r t src n old 1 tde s n wev c ool.ncu n wo

yo hd v lpme amde e .n eDiic' o eale l nti 1 % blc (,4 m d nt)
ut e eo nt z mis
s ts v rl = l s 5 a k 10 2 e s,
me
2 whie( , 2su e t) a 6 ohe ( 6 s de t) n ef l n c Ad sl rm st
0% t 145 t d ns, nd 5% t r 4,33 hz ns.
ol g b '
owi
mmn i he
enr l e ateach s
olm nt
chooli t Lo ele a Cl son communii durng t 201
n he
l nd ewit
tes i he 5-16 Rhool
yea
r:

2

Se l
hx

G m de
s

Bl k
ae

Weli ES
s de
F tieES
>qsd
Ce e l
n ES
ClwbtnMS
e o
Clwit HS
e son
Clwit YDA
e son
Clwit Toas
e son tl

PK5
PK5
PK5
68
9-2
1
61
-2

lA leES
.Rel
PK5
Como Oa ES PKl
ks
5
Up rv ES
iego t
PK5
l l MS
mR:l
e
64
In leHS
.Rel
91
-2
Le el YDA
le
G1
2
Le el To s
l œ
e
ç Flopi
ç ls ul
Es
PK-2
1

Home ou '
b nd '
TOTAL

W hie
t

Ot r
he

Te a
tl

l ( %) 9 (7%)
27 21
81
1 6(P4) 73(3
6 2
1%)
l 4( %) 11 ( 9
3 22
4 1 %)
1 7(5
7 2 %) 1 ( 7
22 1 *)
21 ( %) 1 ( %)
% 25
95 22
1 (2
8 6 %) 4(4
1 %)
8 ( %) 60 ( 8
40 25
6 1 *)

3 6(24
6 6 4)
3 (8
3# 5 %)
3 (PA)
57 5
41 (8
4 5 %)
47 (3%)
05
7(4%)
2
19 (7
.52 5 %)

5
91
57
7
6
05
71
3
83
8
29
3
798

21(%)
4
6 (%)
48
l (%)
94
41(%)
5
53(%)
5
3(2
1 %)
27 (%)
57
1(%)
4

9 (6
5 1 %)
1 (8
43 1 %)
1 ( %)
35 2:
l (3
71 2 %)
22 ( %)
9 28
5(P4)
1
7 4( %)
6 21
8(3%)
3

47 (0%)
58
60 (4*)
07
3 (:
24 6 %)
5 (2
42 7 %)
7 ( %)
07 67
1 (9
8 6 %)
2,66(2%)
6 7
1 ( %)
5 63

591
80
7
4
7%
74
5
10
,49
26
37 5
,0
2
4

10 2 1
4 5%

14 ;0%
52

463 65%
3

71 7
2

Al u teDitit a x re d sgnfc nt o ha dc n gi de pa c sn e
t gh h src h se peinc i iia grwt n b n ng mo phis ic
ho

teic p i of h r t Ditit sman ane ad e g t su e te ol n ta e s
h n e ton t e m-,he src ha it i d esm aed t d n nr lme th tr:*
t e ov r lX i lc m m s to o t e Di c . S ci l du i te 2 5- 6 s h ye al
h e al a o
ii n f h e t m l l rng h 01 1 c oel r, l
ka y,

ee no , d e a hihs h ol fl wihn+/ l % o teDiz cwi a e a eb s dont
lme t midl, nd g c o s el t i - 5 f h s t de v r g a e
he
pe cent ofbl and whies udent enr l i Cl son a 1>Rdl s
r age
ack
t t
s oled n ewit nd
e chool.
s

n e ei noe d n eo d s rm i t a i pe t l st s u e ta sgn nt t e s h l,
r s vi e c f i c i na i s t rs n o t d n s i me be we n c oo s
on
' poraton,f lte orexf r r aracdvi . ForevAmpl t Did cthas gr ed and
mnq t i aciiis,
m nlHcul
des
e, he s
ant
deni sudentM nsf s i ccmplance w i t Dii cts t f polcy w ihoutdic:m i i
ed t
er n
i
+ he s ' mnser i
t
s
natng

o t ehq i of a e n e et n f r d n ha eane a ee f c o de e e toni ie Di d c '
n h qs r c . s m q e s o ot v
g uv fe t n s g ga i n
s ts
x hool. n e Did d al mli ai non- s i l oe m lces and pmclces wih r s ctt
s
s
so nt ns
dicrm '
nat
ii
i
t em o
3

ê po t to an pr vi st n po t to t sud n si ano - e ga i a d no - di rml r
mnR ra i n d o de - K ra i n o t e t n n s m tve n n sc i ne y
n ne . Fl e ,t e Di c ha n tc no l o c s i t d s hx l i a mA ne t twou d
un r l r h e t s o o
dh
ce r on oldae c s n
n r ha
l

itre e w1 is d grg ton o ia i a d do s not h v a y ne c ns iain o
ne fr 1 t e e ai blg tons n
e
ae n
w o old to r
c nsr c
o tu don p a i t e n r f t e Fi a l , t e Did c o a a wi v re y of s u e
l ns n h e uur . n ly h s t se
de a i t
t d nt

e r c c lra tviist alsu e t wi tmg t rc .
xta e ua c i te o l t d n s t
hou rd o a e
Wihrs e t fc t a ds ,heDid c a sg f c lya dsa os h ol t ug nu
t e p d o a ul n * t s t sins a ut n tft c o s ko h t
y
t Dii c i a m u t bl mnn e . Ho v r t e Dizc h s ex e in e c le go wi
he s t n n ia e
nr
we e , h s t a p re c d haln
t
h

mi Hl rc un a hrn o rtel s ve y-m . M o trc n l i t 201 1 Khx l
no e mi g nd iig ve h %t e Y
s e e ty, n he 5- 6
ye r ba k f c t c siue o y6 oft Did c ' tt l a ulype ne a t x we en
a, lc a uly on tt td nl % he s ts o a fc t aon l nd he
r o
blc Prn i l. ' Pa te a e t t m o e pr s > n % m a i t e a e o m l o iy
a k i c pas I
he ri s m ha r om s %
de n h r a f n rt
.

Rc u t t
r imen .
W ih m s d t wih n s h ls g e a i r l t d t e ' n dicplne teDi c ' 2 4t pe o t i c oo e r g ton e a e o de t s i i , h e ts 01

1 s ho ye d ' rve ldno l d s fe a s ves Kh ss gg tn t tblc su e t
5 c ol r nx e ae obe ipe s t e rl ool u esig ha a k t d n s
aeG i pe s e wih s s n i n a c nsdea l hi e r tsl n whiesu n s M ov ver
r ng
h d t u pe so s t o i r by gh r ae b n t tde t.
,
bl c s u e t a edipr po o t l r r s nt da Clw it You h De l pme tAM de . n e
a k t d n s r s o ni na ey ep e e e t e son t ve o n
my
Pm i sa e O tmor p o e sc n b ma i + i a e .
e gr e
e r gr s a e de n s r a
I.
I

Le lSt xd ds
ga a ar

Toobnnade l uo ofu o sau,t Didc mutsow O tissh ol Mv ()
fl cm n ni tts he s t s h
'
t c o s e: 1
Rlya d stsa trl c id wiht Co tsde re fraraon bl p rodo tme (
l n aifcoiy omple t he ur' ce s o es a e ei f i ; 2)
ei n td te vetg s of pir dej r dsrmi to t t e tntprc a e;O d ()
l ae h sie
mi
ro
ue ici nxin o he xe a dc bl
3
de ns tdagrv-ai c mmime tt t wh eo t CoM ' de r e a dt t s pr son
mo kae
v lfi o t n o he ol f he
s c e s n o ho e ovii s

o telw % teCo ui t t r t pe iaefrudca i e ni i tefrtne n e
fh a nd h netton ha wee he rdc t o j iilntwe ton n h ls i c .

4

Se Mf v fv J n is 51 U. 7 8 -9( 9 )Fre nv Pit,5 3U. 46 4919 4
e ro r . e kn , 5 S. 0, 72 1 95) e ma . ts 0 S. 7, -2, 98

(99 ; o c o l maCi Pu Sc # Do l, U. 237 24 5 (991.
1 2)Bi - .fokaho l b. k . wel498 S. , 8-0 1 )
/sA
y
n eSupe Co h qi ni d sx aeu,c mmonyu o h t u en fcos
rme M n de tôt i r o
l wn s be Gre a trl
whc mu t1 a drse a patofied tnnnain o whe e as hx ldie c ha f sle is
ih s
d esd s r
ee i to f
r c
s t s ul ld t

duisa d ei n e v si o lt pi dO ls tm t iee tn prcia e:()m de
te n lmia etgo f
ror
yse o
xe t atc bl 1
nt

asg q()fc l ( ss ( f som to ( e % c rc a a tvto; n ()fcite .
sinmen 2 a ul;3) 'f;4)mnp in;5) x uriulr ciii a d 6 a lis
i
Gre v Sc #J o wKe tC1.3 U. 430, 5( 9 8) seMannn e rlMan n #
en . h. fNe n , 91 S. 43 1 6 ; e
iz x e. nig .
Sc . o ls o o ghC@.,44F.d9 94 ( 1 Ci. 01 (ttn t tGo adidc c ud
h 22 fHilb r u
.2 3 27, 2 11 r20 ) s ig ha fr s t o
t dee n whehe teve tg so d srmi to h ve% e1 lmi tdt t e tnt a tc be
o te e t r h sie f ici nain a
1ei nae o he x e prcia l,

imus e a n .. teGre fcor'.n eSupxmeCo tas h% a p dc sdt ino
t t x mie .h e n at s'
)
ur l;
p mve oni mto f
o h ri ii s c a u ai ofe uc to ' a i odn tfco f rd nnnig wh te te
t e ndca, u b s qu ll
d ain, s mp n a tm o de i n eh r h
'
Die c hu f l l isd s grg to obi to .Fr e ,5 U. a 49 93.
q t u5l< t e e e ain lgai ns e man 03 S. t 2A dititc u t a a lw p rilo i c me t d q is lo t ede g e a i c s G f e
src o r m y lo a ta r n m n al im s a f h x r g ton a e or

flc mpla c ha &e ahive i e ? a aofsh ol eai st xb auii u i cin
ul o in t s n c e d n ve
c o op rton,he y nngjrdito
o rtos ne tno y ti f lc mpla c a dtnni tn uidc no rtos np i whih
ve h e rn t e n ul o in e n e naigj rsiNo ve h e rxq n c
c mpin ei f d.Fr e ,5 U. a 49 91
o la c s oun
e man 03 S. t 0- .
1 .
11

LegalAnal x
ysi

Bn e o t i o mn a d u p d d b leDiz c t t e Untd Sae M d te
q d n he nfr éon nd a xvie y
s t o h ie tts
h
i o= ai i te Pa e 'J n Moto te Co tGn t tte Did c ha c id wih le
nf ton n h ï s oit in, h ur ds h h s t s omple t

p r n n ijncinfra- qr l y ro o tmea dha ei M tdtev sie o patJ
ema e t nu to o
oe e id f i n s lmi e h e tg s f s e
j r di i n tont tee tn prc a l w11 xs c t su e ta sg ntY t ns hx l,
u e xrmiai o h xt t a uc be t1 pe t o t d n s inme
we c z
ta po/-l f lteG and exeacuri ar ac i tes n e Cour c u ,t ef t t
r ns
on, aciii
rcul tvii .
t oncl des her om, hat he

Dii c h s a f i d p ri lu tl sa u i l a e s of su nta sg= e b t e s ho l ,
s t a tl ne a ta ni y tt s n he r a
a
t de s i
nt e we n c o s

t n po t to , f c lu , a d e c r i u a a tvii s a i e tte t dis lton of ie
m s ra i n a ii es n xa u rc l r c i te . nd s n ild o s oui

p n a e tnu cinOdds s o ti at ni tt ae : n eCo da r w11h Pe e
e n n n ij n t
o
imiY fhs ci n h x ra.
o
u gœs t te
1
s
+ a H d to lp o es r 1 > d i t e A % off c ly A z sAF ac utng a d wihi K h l
t ii na r gr s >n
e n h - * a ut nl f
r ii n t n oo
.

s egauon r aung t s ntdici i . n emf e.t Cour appr s t Pe i Supulton
ep
el
o mde s plne
or he
t
ove he
es'
ai

rgnan Faul a dStFRe riiga dSmd nt si iea wilrti urs ito pusun
e rig c l n n cutn n
e Dicpln nd l eanj idcin rl t
t t t r qo t S i ulfo P e Ex. 1
o he e m. f he tp a n.
.

Ac or n y i i hee y ORBEQED ta:
c digl, t s rb
ht
n eJ n M o i i GRANTED;
oit ton s

n eDikiti d ca dN il u i wih rs c t sud n a sgn ntb t
s c : el
al no
y
t e pe t o t e t si me ewœn
s h l ,m nn ra i f c lt s a d e rc c lra tviis
c oo s f m tton, a iii , n xta e ua ci te ;
e

3
)

Al p ir ij n t n i ti cs = DI S
l ro nu ci s n hs ae
o
S OLVED a d j rsit n i
n uidci s
o

TERM W ATZD wih rs c t s n a sg me be e n s ho s t po ton fc l iw
t ey t o mde t si n nt - e c ol, mnn M i , a ii e
t
M de- c c lra tviis
um'ua ci te ;

4
)

n eSiuainrgA n Fa ut a d S## Remii a d Smd n Dicpln i
tp lto e Mig c ly n n c tng n
e t si ie s

APP
ROU D,adteCo t lrtl uidito a ipe lmt fc t a dse rc tnga d
n h urwileAnjrs cin : t *nn o aul n t e mii n
y
s n d s i i e p rt t r o t e Stp a n.
mde t i cpln e he e ms f h i ul uo

ENTERED T

D

ls/ù DAYo
l
l
F

2 1.
07

Uni d S e D ' 't u ge
t
e
s
cpd

.

.

PA > Q $
>

6