Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Microsoft Corporation

Filing 138

NOTICE by Microsoft Corporation re 135 Trial Brief of Filing Supplemental Exhibits to Claim Construction Brief (Attachments: #1 Index of Supplemental Exhibits, #2 Exhibit 504, #3 Exhibit 1002, #4 Exhibit 1003, #5 Exhibit 1101, #6 Exhibit 1103, #7 Exhibit 1104, #8 Exhibit 1106, #9 Exhibit 1107, #10 Exhibit 1108, #11 Exhibit 1109, #12 Exhibit 1113)(Miner, Curtis)

Exhibit 1003

PATENT APPLICATION

THE CLAT
CLAI

without prejudice

in

w

d

drd included

de

in

at

one

one cdde included
one

is
is

at
o'e

least
least

with

associated
associated

least

mpani

the

at

includes

at

image

dl

key wor

messae

o

ic

at

of

least

one key

one key wors ocated j4he database the

image as a graphic message that
lma8e
a
message
SraPnrc

one
one

least

alphanumeric message

matches

alphanumeric message

least

without

a

at

message

located

does not include
the

flying graphic

least

database the

on

that

at

presenting when the
one word

in

eric

one

rd

display and
disolav

al

a

least
least

ac

least

matches

least

aiphanum

is

that

the

as

word

when

at

representative
representative

presenting
presentin

with

least

at

matches

at

in

image data that
imase

on

determine whether

message

image data associated
associated

locate
locate

is
is

in

database

alphanumeric

message wherein the image data
message
the
image data

message

the

display
disnlav

the

1

further
further

a

a hanumeric

2

the
the

step
step that the

least
least

one code
one code

is
is

step includes the step of
includes
the step

the referencing

reference

comprising prior

to

to

be

claim

abase

umeric word

step
step a display command indicating

code format comparing each
comparine

message with

words

stored

in

by

in

message

in

h

d

the

of
of

presented

the referencing
referencine

etermining prior
includ
include

is

method

step
step

of

ed The

p J wherein

nting
ting

at

s

1 further comprising the
1 further comprising the

ke

4

I

the p
pre

message

to

r Ame
referencing

c1aim
claim

of

pri

alphanumer

bthod
ethod

to

receiving
the
that the

The
The

to

2 Amended

al

tr

the

the

a data
a

alnhanumeric messase
alphanumeric message

by

lal

a

referencing a database
a database
the

messages

for displaying

receiver the method comprising the steps of
steps of

receivine
receiving

included

material and

material

A method

1 Amended
communication

t

claims by adding the underlined

the following

deleting the bracketed

to
to

amend

Please
Please

nn

uo r1

cane 1 Claims

Please

an

IN

PT01367U
PT01.367U

the

PATENT APPLICATION

to

g prior

the

ming message that includes a code key word and
code
ing

r

aa

key
kev word and the image data

9 Amended A data

a
a an

ge

age

and

data associated
associated

at

least

one

one code

least

is

at

in

the

in

one code key word
code ke r

The data

one image

alPhanumeric
alphanumeric message and
least

as

least

a
a

for

for

at

presentinS rhcn
presenting when

one key word

accompanying graphic message

of

the

at

at

by

blz

one key word the

one word does not match

an

at
at

least

least

message without

11 Amended
ed

locating
flocating

with the

the presentation element

message accompanied

alphanumeric

least

for

one image and
lmage ancl

y coupled
coupled

esenting when the

with the

and the database

alphanumeric message

the

the database

data associated
data associated

at
at

ge

so a

east

one word matches

lea

o

co

of

a
a

e receiver
receiver

included

ded

retrie

ay

di

a

o

least

one key word

the database
database

representative
representative

at

wor

d t

eleme

to

at

least

to

in

whether

wherein the image data

the

codes
codes

for storing

a presentation
Presentation

determining

grap

ding
uding

i

codes key words
codes ke

with the

the

ke

a database
a database

code

message

code word
code

one

matches

alphanumeric

at
at

the data communication receiver comprising
data communication receiver comprising

a receiver for receiving
a receiver
least

the database
the database

receiver for presenting

communication

an

information

in

image data
storing the lcodel
storins the code

unication receiver

further

r

ccurs

corn

3

user initiated
userinitiated

the alphanumeric message and
response
response

reception

of

mess

to

n pres

on

w
graphic
graphic

in

s

sor for providing
r for providing

the

of

thereto

accom a

ir€

commands

coupled

ge

controls

to

comprising

an

0

1 further
1

of

recervlng
receiving

UJ1
v

claim

step the steps of
step
steps

encing
cing

L

The method
The

co

6 Amended

of

PT01367U

a display

PATENT APPLICATION

15 Amended The
15

data communication

receiver

of

PT01367U

10
10

further

comprising

reception

17 Amended The
The
e

the

the processor for generating
the processor

alphanumeric

data
data

communication receiver and
communication receiver
for

ed
to
to

p

for storing the

an

re

echanism

to

onse
irse

e data
data

cq

an

message
message

an

in

cv

alphanumeric

e processor
processor

alert

message
message

receiver
receiver

communication
communication

of

message memory coup
message
cou

of

a

L5
claim 16 wherein

programming means comprises
means comprises
the receiver for receiving
the receiver

a Programming message inclu
programming
includi

5
a

codel
code

kev wotd
key word and image data

ord and the image data

programming word

18 Amended The ffia
The
programming
contr

m

s

receiver
receiver

claim

L6
16

wherein

comprises
comprises

for receiving a
receiving

a code
programming message comprising a code
message

storing
storing

means
means

storing the

code key word
lcode ke word and the image data
t

database

4

in

image data and

kev
key word

for

the
the

communication
communication

message
programming message

e

of

determining

ta

response
response

th

includes the

to

the database
the database

word

programming

in

storing a

means for storing the code
means
code

ke

memory for

storing

in

y
0

a

PATENT APPLICATION
PT07367U
PT01367U

Amended A data

the data communication receiver comprising
data communication receiver comprising

coupled
coupled

a
a

memory coupled
coupled

a
a

database
database

coupled

words and image data
words

a message
message

the receiver for
receiver

decoding the message

recover

more alphanumeric words therefrom

to to

or

at
at

a decoder

one code one
one

to

a receiver for receiving

least
least

receiver for presenting

the decoder
the

associated
associated

decoder

for storing the
for storing a

message

plurality

codes key
codes

image data representative
aata rep

therewitn
therewith the
tne

of

information

communication

to

1

of

6
4

to

in

at

is

at

in

retrieve

when

least

least one
least one

message

additional
additional

that
that

key word the
key word the

conveys

one alphanumeric

word does
graPhic
graphic

any

5

i
t

one
one

a

a meaning without

information accompanied
information accompanied

one key word the message unaccompanied
word
message unaccomPanied

least
least

at

ghcn
element for presenting when
element

the
the

not

message
message

match

messages

at

as
as

that

by

and for presenting

one code and

the presentation

a graphic
a

at

requiring presentation
presentation

referencing the database
referencing

least

one image and
one image

one alphanumeric word matches
matches

corresponding image
image

least
least

database

determining

the message matches
the message

at
at

least
least

coupled

of
of

least

display

the

with the

for

by

a
a

associated
associated

at
at

representative
representative

of

image data that
data

the database

one alphanumeric word included
one alphanumeric
included

to

least
least

element coupled

one key word included

is

least
least

at

e

whether
whether

at
at

a presentation
a presentation

to

images

PATENT APPLICATION
PT01367U
PT01357U

1

Claims 1

are pending
are pending

to

application

19
19

above identified patent

the

have been rejected and the specification has been objected
have
been objected

Additionally
Examiner Additionally

various

mistakes have been noted

other

by by

1

19

In

REMARKS
Claims

the
the
the
the

Examiner

the Office
the Office Action

26 1996
26 1996

dated December
December

Claims 4,5 and
45

19
19

to

response

17 36 9 11 15 and 17
3 6,9,77,15 and 17

amended The specification
The specification

have been

3 sheets
sheets

Additionally

three

concurrently

has been
has been

amended
amended

in
in

have been canceled without prejudice Claims
have
prejudice
Claims

of

12

14
14 In

RESPONSE TO THE OFFICE ACTION

one
one

1 place
1 place

proposed drawing corrections are submitted
corrections

herewith

the specification

is

it

FIGs 1823 Accordingly

be

to

descriptions for

to

is

the specification

objected

does not describe FIGs 18 23
Drawings does not describe FIGs 1823
one

respectfully

1

to

the

have therefore amended the specification
the specification

Applicants

objection

26 1996
26 1996

December

in

Action

the Office
Office

because the Brief Description

of

of

In

OBJECTION TO THE SPECIFICATION

place

requested

include

that

the

withdrawn

of

Action

corrections for sheet 1 correcting
1 correcting

FIG 14
14

in

sheet
sheet

6 correcting
5 correcting

FIGs 14 16 and
FIGs 14 15

reference

database
database

157 has been added
has been added

ink

red

500
500

number 155 has been replaced with
number
has
replaced with

and 16 the figure numbers have been interchanged
and 15 the figure numbers
been

as
as

red ink

Regarding FIGs
red ink

Regarding

Once

a reference

15
15

in

FIG 1
1

Regarding

marked

1
1

FIG 21
FIG 21

Regarding

marked

FIG
FIG

Examiner notes several errors
notes

as
as

correcting

the
the

submitted proposed drawing
proposed drawing

the

indicated that

FIG 21

the spelling

Charlotte has been corrected
has been

Examiner has approved the proposed drawing
has

in

8

therefore
therefore

of

sheet

26 1996
1996

December

in

the Office
Office

drawings Applicants have
Applicants have

red ink
ink

changes and
changes

above identified
the above identified patent application includes allowable subject
application includes allowable subject

matter Applicants

will

furnish

a

set

the

set

of

in

In

PROPOSED DRAWING CORRECTIONS

approved changes
changes

6

formal drawings incorporating

PATENT APPLICATION

the

displayed

aa graphic
graphic

35

35

a
a key

word

message
alphanumeric message

35

image

corresponding

the

message
message along with the alphanumeric message
alphanumeric message

message does not include a word matching any key word
does
a

is

is

When

as
as

image

any word

a database
database

with image data representative

associated
associated

message includes a word that matches
a

has

remarks herein

determining whether

for

an

wherein the key word
the

USC S102b
USC 102 b

alphanumeric message matches a key word included

is

a received

Gaskill Applicants

1 3 under
1 3 under
Claims 1 3 and the
Claims
Claims
Claims

amended Independent Claim 1 calls
1

under

of in

by

amendments

the

al

Gaskill

L

133 are rejected
are

Claims
Claims

displayed
displayed'alone
alone

an

As

been overcome
been overcome

of

of

being anticipated
being anticipated

102 b
S102G

USC

26 1996
26,7996

submit that the rejection
that the rejection

respectfully

When

UNDER
UNpER

to of
of

102
S102 b

3

December

by

b

USC

as
as

In

the Office Action

et

1
13

REJECTTON
REJECTION OF CLAIMS
CLATMS

35
3s

PT01367U

without

the

accompanying graphic

a code
which the sender can input a code
aa pager
pager

The pager

or
or

sent
sent

as
as

11

line
that
line 11 that

to
to

8
8

is

column
column

is

line
line

to
to

7

a
system
shows a paging system

64
64

Gaskill

column

amended depend from Amended Claim 1
from Amended Claim 1

in

3

Claims 2 and

as
as

message

code and displays a graphic symbol such
a
symbol

recognizes the
recognizes

a house
a

office
office

2331
31

Gaskill

alphanumeric message received
message
does
does not disclose the step
disclose
step

word matches

the

well

as
as

when

key word

as
as

the

the

the data communication receiver
data communication receiver
presenting

when

message
message

an

Gaskill further

presenting

message corresponding
message

no

the step
the step

does not disclose the step

alphanumeric message matches a
alphanumeric message matches a

to

a database
a database

a graphic
a

that

a received
a received

of by

original

in

key word stored
a key word
a

submit

of

respectfully

whether a word
a word

of
or of

Applicants

determining

of

icon corresponding thereto
thereto column 10 lines 23
column 10 lines

words match any key words the alphanumeric message without an
anyi
alphanumeric message

respectfully

Claims

no

is
is

information that

suggestion that a graphic
a

supplement the meaning
supplement the meaning

of
of

displayed

received
received

pager There
There

aaconventionally
conventionally

alphanumeric message Therefore Applicants
alphanumeric
Therefore Applicants

submit that Gaskill does not disclose each element
Gaskill
not disclose each element

13

7

of
of

and

be

message can
message can
entered

code that permits the sending
code

the recipient

is
is

a different
a

directly displayed

of

can
a
Gaskill the sender can either enter a code that causes the display

by

icon

or

an

of

Instead

to

in

accompanying graphic message
messale

Amended
Amended

PATENT APPLICATION

102 b has been
S102 b has been

traversed
traversed

amendments

the

3
Claims 13 under
Claims

1

Claims

3
1 3 and

35
35

believed that the rejection
the rejection

to of
of

Accordingly

by

it
is

PT01367U

the

USC
USC

remarks

hereinabove

103 has been overcome
103 has been overcome

35
35

by

in
in

Claims

6 7 are rejected

view

and Lipp
Lipp

Miyashita

submit that the rejection
submit that the rejection
the amendments
the amendments

under

are

Claims
Claims

et 35
et 35

103
5103

of
of

over Gaskill

being unpatentable
being

Applicants respectfully
Applicants respectfully

by
by

USC

USC
USC

26 1996
26 7996

December

to
to

as
as

103
5103

4

of

of

35 at
35

the Office Action

Lipp

under

Miyashita Applicants
Miyashita

5 has been rendered
Claims 4 5 has been rendered moot

35
3s

OF CLAIMS 6 7 UNDER
OF CLAIMS 5 7 UNpER

al

view
view

Claims 4 and 5 without prejudice
prejudice
5

REJECTION

USC

4

5 are
Claims 4 5 are rejected

of
of

35
3s

over Gaskill
over Gaskill

In

the cancellation

103
5103

26 1996
26,1996

December

being unpatentable
being unpatentable

submit that the rejection
submit that

respectfully

USC
USC

in

103
5103

of

of

the Office Action
Office

of

USC
USC

as
as

In

REIECTTON OF CLATMS 4 5 UNDER
REJECTION OF CLAIMS 4 5 UNDER

67 under
7

Claims 1 and 6
Claims 1 and 6 and the

of

of

message
message

Independent

the cited art further

does not

Claim 1
Claim 1

as
as

an

accompanying
accompanying graphic message
graphic message

amended
amended

displayed

pager There

suggestion that a graphic
suggestion

supplement the meaning
the meaning

8

information that

is
is

that permits the sending
sending

recipient

of
of

be

by the

no

a different code
code

of

Gaskill the sender can either enter a code that causes the display
can
a
causes

directly displayed

message can
message

the step

message
message

called for

is
is

icon

a received

message
when no message words match any key words

message without

Independent

or

an

of

Instead

presenting

to

called for

in

alphanumeric

combination

as
as

the step

in

the

amended The

database

the original alphanumeric
the original alphanumeric

the data communication receiver
communication

of

suggest

1
1

as
as by

Claim

well

a
a

a graphic
a graphic

in

key word

word
word

as

to

the

corresponding
received

a key
a key

as
as

word matches
matches

as
as

the

Gaskill Miyashita
Gaskill Miyashita

determining whether a word
a

alphanumeric message matches a key word stored

when

recognition

messages
messages

canned

submit that the combination
that the combination

respectfully

and Lipp does not teach the step

presenting

a

of

programming

in

Applicants

code
code

canned message
canned message

receives

of

a
a

over the

that

or

paging receiver

of
of

a

of

which causes display
Lipp describes

as

the limitations thereof
the limitations thereof

describes

of

Miyashita

of

and include

Claim 1 as amended
Claim 1
amended

amended depend from Independent

air

67
all
all

Claims

of as
of as

remarks herein

aa conventionally
conventionally

PATENT APPLICATION
PT01367U
PT07367U

be
be

graphic
message
determine whether a graphic message representative
determine
the alphanumeric message
along with the alphanumeric message

displayed

to

compared

or

word

message can
message

be

key words
key

to

stored
stored

alphanumeric
alphanumeric

received
a received

does not

be

words forming

is
is

teach that
teach that

similarly

of

Miyashita
and received alphanumeric message Miyashita
and received alphanumeric message

to

entered
entered

itself

the

whether

of

of

is
to

shows
displayed
the alphanumeric message
thealphanumericmessageistobedisplayedalone alone Rather
Rather Miyashitashows
canned
a
code
the reception
a general message and a code that causes display
reception
Miyashita

the

key

word Lipp does not correct
Lipp does not correct

the deficiencies
the deficiencies

Gaskill

and

in

a stored

of
of

to
to

or

in
in

of

in

teaches away from
message with the general message Miyashita therefore
messagewiththegeneralmessage'Miyashitathereforeteachesawayfrom
with the general message
response
the general message
presentation
a graphic message along
a graphic message along
presentation
the general message match
the general message
words included
included
determining that one
more
more
determining

can cause display

by

alphanumeric message
alphanumeric

of

that words included
the
Miyashita because Lipp also does not suggest
MiyashitabecauseLippalsodoesnotsuggestthatwordsincludedinthe
graphic message accompanied
a graphic message accompanied

in

the
the

as
as

fluent
not fluent

a

a
a

graphic
graphic

key word

part

can
message
message that can

At

a

of

some circumstances
under some circumstances

still

presentation
alphanumeric message causes presentation

by

be of

the
the

who

Specifically sending
sending
specifically

message
message

presented
understand the presented
understand

o

message can
message

a user
a user

of

of
of

the presented

that
that

and 7
Amended Claims 6 and 7

is
is

described
described

the invention

which depend from Amended Claim 1
depend from Amended Claim 1
language
language

in

The advantage

is
is

of

the alphanumeric message itself
alphanumeric message itself

is

of

by

is

so
so

all

of

languages
the same time the alphanumeric
understood
users
beunderstoodbyusersofalllanguages Atthesametime thealphanumeric
that meaning
that
presented along with any graphic message
any graphic message
message itself
presented along
message

Amended Claim 1 which
Amended Claim 1

are included

suggest

Dependent

the features

Claims 6 and
Claims

7

as
as of

or

Miyashita
teach
Miyashita and Lipp does not teach

Gaskill
Gaskill

in

of
of

a user having the appropriate
the graphic message
clarified when read
thegraphicmessageisclarifiedwhenreadbyauserhavingtheappropriate
submit
combination
language skills Applicants therefore respectfully submit that the combination
Applicants therefore respectfully

reiection
the rejection

amendments
been
been traversed bY the amendments

6

Claims 6 7 under
7
Claims

35
35

of
of

that

to
to

believed

by

103 has
has
103

is
is

Accordingly
Accordingly

it

amended

USC
USC

Claims 1 and 6 and the remarks
6
Claims L

under 35

USC
USC

and the remarks herein
the remarks herein

9

Miyashita
Miyashita

under

amendments
amendments

usc
USC

Lipp and Deluca
LilPP'and DeLuca

submit that the rejection
the rejection
submit

the
the

35
35

rejected
rejected

of

view

respectfully
fesPectfully

has been overcome

Claim 8
Claim 8

is
is

103

of

in

Gaskill
over Gaskill

005 Applicants
103
103

USC

26,1996
26 1996

to
to

Deluca
DeLuca

Decembet
December

by
by

of

being unpatentable
being

35

al
al

et
et

103
103

OF CLAIM 8 UNDER

the Office Action
the office

as
as

In

REJECTION

35

hereinabove

Claim 8
8

6
Claims 1 and 6
Claims 1

PATENT APPLICATION

1

Claim 1
Claim 1

believed

Claims 6
Claims 6

be

7 Independent
T

is
is

set

connection with the rejection
connection
the rejection

be patentable over the combination

and
Applicants respectfully
that combining
Gaskill Miyashita and Lipp Applicants respectfully submit that combining
Miyashita and Lipp does
with Gaskill Miyashita and Lipp does not render Independent

in

a
a

along with the

message
any key
message words match any key

message
message

displayed

be

believed

the limitations

accompanying
accompanying

Amended

over the combination
combination

patentable

Claim 8 under
Claim 8 under

35
35

that the rejection
the rejection

amendments
amendments

the

to

believed

been traversed

of
of

Miyashita Lipp and DeLuca
Deluca

Accordingly
has
has

also
also

to

1 Claim8

Gaskill

it
by is

Claim

is

Because Dependent Claim 8 includes

without

alone

of
of

message
message

of

alphanumeric

of

the

graphic

displayed

that when

all

words

key word

a
a

key word a graphic
a

a

an

the

message itself

no

alphanumeric

Claim 1
1

words included

key words

stored

message matches
message

is

message corresponding

the
the

is

word

or

a

to

database that when
database

of
of

alphanumeric message are compared

received

suggest that
suggest

to

obvious because DeLuca also does not teach
Deluca also does not

in

DeLuca
Deluca

or
or

of

and
and

forth above
above

of
of

claim that depends from Amended Claim 1
from Amended Claim

dependent

to

a

For the reasons

in
in

Claim 8
8

set

is

I'T01367U
PT07367U

USC
USC

103
5103

Claims 1 and 5 and the remarks
1
6

Claims

911

has
has

35

26 1996
26 1996

over
over

11

that the rejection
rejection

USC
USC

103
6103
Claims
Claims

9 1L are rejected
911 are rejected

Gaskill Applicants respectfully

been overcome
been

the
the

under

35
35

December

3s

submit

amendment

to

Action

being unpatentable
being unpatentable

of

103
5103

UNDER

by
by

the Office

as
as

In

USC
USC

of

OF CLAIMS 9
OF CLATMS 9

REIECTTON
REJECTION

11
11

hereinabove

bv
by

traversed

the

amendment

rendered obvious
obvious

that

iI in
it

the rejection
rejection

believed that
believed

Gaskill
Gaskill

Claims

9 11
9

has
has

been

Claim 9 and the remarks hereinabove
remarks hereinabove

10

in

connection with the
connection
the

is
is

to

67
Claims 5 7

11

are not
are

believed

of

the Rejection

by
by

amended

those called for

2 For the reasons set forth
For
reasons set

of

911
911

Accordingly

contain features similar

1 and
133 and

it
is

Claims

Claims

as
as

Rejection

of

Independent Claims L and
1

to

Amended Claims 9

11

Claim 9 and the remarks herein
herein

PATENT APPLICATION

14

35

view

of

over Gaskill
over Gaskill

unpatentable
unpatentable

Miyashita Lipp and
Miyashita

submit that the rejection
the rejection

has been rendered moot

under

rejected
are rejected

Claims

the cancellation

14 14

103
103

2

26 1996 claims 12 4
26 1996 Claims

December
December

Applicants respectfully
Appticants respectfully

USC
USC

under 35
under

103

of of

35

DeLuca 005
Deluca

being

USC

in

103

103

UNDER

by

as
as

In
35
35

the Office Action
office

of
of

OF CLAIMS 12

REJECTION

USC
usc

14

PT01367U
PT01.367U

12 l 4

Claims12
L2

prejudice
without prejudice

103
s103 has been overcome

amendments
amendments

the
the

Claims 15

19

of
of

of

of

35

19

submit that the rejection
the rejection

respectfully
respectfully

under

rejected

Miyashita Lipp and

to
to

35
35

USC
usc

view

and 17
Claims 9 and 17
Claims

19

under
under

over Gaskill
over Gaskill

being unpatentable
unpatentable

Applicants
Applicants

in

103
103

DeLuca 005
Deluca

Action

by
by

as
as

In
35
35

the Office
the office

USC
USC

USC 103
UNDER
26 1996 Claims
December 26 1996 claims 1519 are

OF CLAIMS 15

REJECTION

Amended Claim 9
Amended Claim 9

the

set

Rejection

Amended Claim f
Claim 1

of

5 7 and
6

Amended Claim

patentable
patentable

9

Amended

over the combination

of

of

are also believed
are

to

Claims 15
Claims 15

include

all

Claims 15
Claims 15

like

includes

Deluca since
Gaskill Miyashita Lipp and DeLuca Since
Gaskill Miyashita

limitations
the limitations

of

that

of
of

believed

Claims

9 which

the reasons

is

Rejection
connection with the Rejection

over the combination
combination
over

patentable
patentable

from Amended Claim
from Amended

Amended claim 1 For
Amended Claim

of

those called

in

for

amended depend
amended

be

is

Claim 8
8

it

above
above

18 18
18 18

forth
forth

similar
similar

in

features
features

to

15 18
Claims 1518

as
as

herein
19 and the remarks herein

Gaskill

as

Miyashita Lipp and DeLuca
Deluca
Miyashita

be
be

also believed
also believed

patentable

over the

35

19

Del uca
Gaskill Miyashita Lipp and DeLuca

of

combination
combination

of

Therefore Amended Claim 19
Claim
Therefore

to
to

Claim 9
L
Amended Claim 1 and Amended Claim 9

is

called for

19

those
those

in

similar
similar

to
to

limitations
includes
Independent
19
Independent Claim19 as amended includes features and limitations

11

remarks hereinabove
hereinabove

19

by

to

it
is

Claims 15
under
USC
believed that the rejection
Accordingly itisbelievedthattherejectionofClaims15 19under35USC
amendments
Claims 9 and 17 79 and the
and 17
103 has been traversed
has been
the amend ments
103

PATENT APPLICATION

allowance

and
and a favorable response

to
to

response
response

the Office
the office

13 611 and 15 19
i 3,6 and 15

Claims
Claims

19

that
that

rr

submitted

is
is

for

a full and complete
complete

an

condition

26 1996
26 1996

at

in

are

submitted

dated December
December

as

The foregoing
Action

It
rt
is

is
is

PTOI 367U
PT01367u

an early date
date

earnestly solicited
solicited

of

3

owing

this
this

time
time

be

any excess fee has been received
any excess fee has been

charge any fees which may be
charge

deposit account
deposit account

13 4778
13 472g
be

Examiner believes that there are any informalities which
that
believes
informarities which can be
by Examiner's amendment a telephone call
Examinerg amendment
the undersigned

ilu

DELUCA

IP

Kelly

Dept MS96
Dept MS96

submitted

et
al

Respectfully

MOTOROLA INC

rdv

Al Gardner
6 Gardner

Attorney for Applicant

1500 Gateway Blvd
Gateway

No 35,147
35,147
Tel [phone]
Tel
567
FAX 56r 73e 282s
FAX [phone]
Reg

12

Beach
Boynton Beach Florida 33426
33426

T2

3

which are

respectfully solicited
soliiited

Law

three

above identified

at
at

due

or

is

fee

due

or

no
is

hereby authorized
hereby

any overpayment
any

to
to

or

any fee

claims three

the
the

is
is

corrected

that
that

claims including

to

If

the

credit

is
is

be determined

Commissioner

required

14

Applicants submit that
Applicants submit that

be

should
Should

it

independent

20

Amendment

After the foregoing
After the

application includes
application includes fourteen
fourteen

patent

the

have previously paid for twenty

claims

to

Applicants

independent