Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al
Filing
436
REPLY to the 426 Post-Trial Proposed Declaratory Judgment and Permanent Injunction filed by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)(anc)
E
X
H
I
B
I
T
1
Use Checklist
NUA/\
oc
Name
Date
Class or Project
Course
of
Title
Author
Term
and
and
be
any
factors
deciding
Check
Office
use
fair
of the
Where
of
fair
use
those facts
only
Instructors
Board
of
use
outnumber
favor
the factors
favor
whether
in
of
fair
half the factors
in
weighing
given Situation
determinative
counts
favoring
fewer than
facts
total
use
fair
or at the
rner
pages
from the rights holder
consider the
against
the
Where
justified
permission
e.g
used
Where
Instructions
is
ce
Publisher
to
Portions
use
Work
Copyrighted
if
apply
the
No
Legal Affairs
questions
total
of the facts
all
Policy
of
on
the
Use
which
Georgia
and
Complete
establish
can
be found
retain
copy
and
such
use
of
in
use factors
in
on the web
checkkst
this
good
faith
at
for
for
each
Favor
of Fair
Use
Reporting
for
new
utility
Personal
Use
Profiting
use
or
use
for
the
present
at
in
or factor
their
is
institution
of the
sections
four
of the
University
System
copyrighted
work
in
order
to
use should any dispute
the Use
of
Against Fair Use
Entertainment
For publication
For public
changes
activity
from use
ZNon-transformative
Parody
Transformative
of
fair
Commercial
Scholarship
or
use
Weighs
Comment News
Criticism
fair
Purpose and Character
including multiple copies
classroom use
or
be
item
analysis
fair
Research
attempt at applying
94eaching
Research
and
weighing
httpIlwww.usg.edu/copyrightj
Educational
Nonprofit
please see the
Education
fair
arise
Factor
Weighs
fair
Works
Copyrighted
reasonable
regarding
the
regarding
of
will
office
regarding
on
should
facts
single
factors
For more information
reliance
should seek
instructors
split
to
your use
to
the
have
they
evenly
Not
justified
that
should consult
Regents
are
it
instructors
use as opposed
fair
is
those against
use
fair
work
distribution
Use exceeds
purpose
necessary
Study
educational
that
to
which
achieve
is
your intended
purpose
necessary to achieve
your
intended educational
purpose
is
.JFaCtOr
Weighs
in
Favor
of Fair
Use
Li
Factor
Weighs Against
Fair
Use
PLAINTIFFS
TRIAL
EXHIBIT
572
108-cv-1425-ODE
GaStateOO652O6
EXHIBIT 1 - 1
Factor
Weighs
6Published
Favor
in
Nature
Use
of Fair
Work
of Copyrighted
Weighs
work
work
Unpublished
or nonfiction
work
JYFactual
YImportant
to
educational
objectives
films
in
Favor
of Fair
ZISmall
I
of
portion
Portion
used
igniflcant
is
whole
Amount taken
as
or
Weighs
Weighs
Favor
in
Favor
in
of Fair Use
market
stimulates
of Fair
Factor
Effect
on Market
longer
Licensing
for
or
User
market
for
Significantly
few
owns
work
original
or
Columbia
unavailable
classroom
lawfully
or
Weighs
for
use
in
by the
Universitys
reading
acquired or
Favor
work
System
Checklist
reasonably
copies made
affects
classroom
does
not
purchased
own
copy
access
other
the
that
market for
reading
acquired
lawfully
of original
Georgia based
upon
on
the
work
web
forum
public
Factor Weighs
of
or distributed
use
or long-term
Unrestricted
of Fair Use
Use
User
or
_____
University
Fair
Required
El
to students or
appropriagup
copyrighted
permission
demonstrably
Jhe work
or distributed
of original
market or
for
available
Repeated
copies made
access
Revised
for
or sublect
or derivative
Numerous
permission
Restricted
J/actor
by the
in print
copy
other
research
impairs
market
potential
holder
purchased
El
more than necessary
Against Fair Use
Weighs
work
copyrighted
product marketed
Supplemental
One
or
for Original
Licensing
similar
copyright
El
used
work
to
Against Fair Use
Weighs
Use
work
No
work
being taught
on market or
effect
significant
potential
No
is
comment
criticism
Factor
J2tise
central
is
being taught
E1iactor
No
used
heart of the work
narrowly tailored
research
or entire
portion
Portion
purpose such
comment
criticism
Large
or
as
Against Fair Use
Weighs
used
work
to entire
educational
subject
work
Against Fair Use
Portion Used
of
Substantiality
fiction
workJgkbook
Weighs
Use
of Fair
not central
is
J1 Amount taken
to
Favor
in
Factor
Amount and
Factor
Weighs
Use
art music novels
plays poetry
Consumable
VFactor Weighs
work
creative
Highly
Use
Fair
Against
or
_____
Against Fair Use
the Copyright
Advisory
Office
at
http//www.copyright.colurnbja.edu/fair-use-ctecks
GaStateOO652O7
EXHIBIT 1 - 2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?