AT&T Mobility LLC v. Cellco Partnership

Filing 20

RESPONSE in Opposition re 18 Amended MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order, 3 MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order, filed by Cellco Partnership. (Attachments: # 1 Transmittal Declaration of Kenneth A. Plevan, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Declaration of Joseph Saracino, # 7 Exhibit 5, # 8 Exhibit 6, # 9 Exhibit 7, # 10 Exhibit 8, # 11 Exhibit 9, # 12 Exhibit 10, # 13 Exhibit 11, # 14 Exhibit 12, # 15 Exhibit 13, # 16 Exhibit 14, # 17 Exhibit 15, # 18 Exhibit 16, # 19 Exhibit 17, # 20 Exhibit 18, # 21 Exhibit 19, # 22 Declaration of Jerome Karnick, # 23 Exhibit 20, # 24 Exhibit 21, # 25 Exhibit 22, # 26 Exhibit 23, # 27 Exhibit 24, # 28 Exhibit 25, # 29 Exhibit 26, # 30 Exhibit 27, # 31 Declaration of Susan Sherwood)(Loveland, L.) Modified on 11/17/2009 to remove duplicative text (alc).

EXHIBIT 25

From: Sent: T o: Subject: Attachments:

Gray, Kerwin [[e-mail]] Thursday, July 24, 2008 6:15 PM Karnick, Jerome Misleading inaccurate comparative coverage maps VZW _vs_ATT_Map FINAL.PDF

The comparative coverage maps that are attached are using grossly outdated information to depict AT&T's 3G coverage and severely misrepresent the slight coverage advantage VZ currently has.

VZW_vs_ATT_Map FINAL.PDF (889 ...

VZ cannot produce misleading comparative information and rely upon a small footnote informing the public that the competitor's information is out of date.

Current 3G coverage information for AT&T is available on our web site.

Kerwin L. Gray 404.236.5534

1

The 3G Network that Speaks to the Nation
Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison

Verizon Wireless Network Advantage
High-speed access in more places: · Wecoverover80%oftheU.S. populationwithourhigh-speed broadbandnetwork(EV-DORev.A). · Availabletomorethan245million people.That'salmostdoublethe coverageofAT&T'sbroadband network(HSPA)whichcoversonly 40-50%oftheU.S.population.
MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap(EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess(EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer.©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c.indd 1 6/18/08 5:38:07 PM

Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison
California with Reno and Las Vegas
Premium Products & Devices on the Nation's Most Reliable Wireless Broadband Network
PC Cards, ExpressCards, and USB Modems · Plugintoyourlaptop · SurftheInternetatbroadbandspeeds Smartphone and BlackBerry devices like the Curve · EmailandIM · InternetwithanHTMLbrowser · Useasahigh-speedmodem Phones that let you take web and entertainment mobile · Listen&downloadmusic · Watchvideos,news&sports · Playgames · Text,picture&videomessage · TouchscreensandfullQWERTYkeyboads Never get lostwithVZNavigatorSMgetturnby turndirections,trafficintegration,cheapgas finderandmore.
MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap(EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess(EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer. CAmap0608©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c_FINAL.indd 2 6/19/08 1:38:26 PM

Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison
Hawaii
Premium Products & Devices on the Nation's Most Reliable Wireless Broadband Network
PC Cards, ExpressCards, and USB Modems · Plugintoyourlaptop · SurftheInternetatbroadbandspeeds Smartphone and BlackBerry devices like the Curve · EmailandIM · InternetwithanHTMLbrowser · Useasahigh-speedmodem Phones that let you take web and entertainment mobile · Listen&downloadmusic · Watchvideos,news&sports · Playgames · Text,picture&videomessage · TouchscreensandfullQWERTYkeyboads Never get lostwithVZNavigatorSMgetturnby turndirections,trafficintegration,cheapgas finderandmore.

MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap(EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess(EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer. HImap0608©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c.indd 3 6/18/08 5:38:09 PM

Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison
Mountain
Premium Products & Devices on the Nation's Most Reliable Wireless Broadband Network
PC Cards, ExpressCards, and USB Modems · Plugintoyourlaptop · SurftheInternetatbroadbandspeeds Smartphone and BlackBerry devices like the Curve · EmailandIM · InternetwithanHTMLbrowser · Useasahigh-speedmodem Phones that let you take web and entertainment mobile · Listen&downloadmusic · Watchvideos,news&sports · Playgames · Text,picture&videomessage · TouchscreensandfullQWERTYkeyboads Never get lostwithVZNavigatorSMgetturnby turndirections,trafficintegration,cheapgas finderandmore.
MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap (EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess (EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer. MTNmap0608©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c.indd 4 6/18/08 5:38:11 PM

Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison
Pacific Northwest
Premium Products & Devices on the Nation's Most Reliable Wireless Broadband Network
PC Cards, ExpressCards, and USB Modems · Plugintoyourlaptop · SurftheInternetatbroadbandspeeds Smartphone and BlackBerry devices like the Curve · EmailandIM · InternetwithanHTMLbrowser · Useasahigh-speedmodem Phones that let you take web and entertainment mobile · Listen&downloadmusic · Watchvideos,news&sports · Playgames · Text,picture&videomessage · TouchscreensandfullQWERTYkeyboads Never get lostwithVZNavigatorSMgetturnby turndirections,trafficintegration,cheapgas finderandmore.

MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap (EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess (EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer. PNWmap0608©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c.indd 5 6/18/08 5:38:12 PM

Verizon Wireless vs. AT&T Broadband (3G) Network Comparison
Southwest
Premium Products & Devices on the Nation's Most Reliable Wireless Broadband Network
PC Cards, ExpressCards, and USB Modems · Plugintoyourlaptop · SurftheInternetatbroadbandspeeds Smartphone and BlackBerry devices like the Curve · EmailandIM · InternetwithanHTMLbrowser · Useasahigh-speedmodem Phones that let you take web and entertainment mobile · Listen&downloadmusic · Watchvideos,news&sports · Playgames · Text,picture&videomessage · TouchscreensandfullQWERTYkeyboads Never get lostwithVZNavigatorSMgetturnby turndirections,trafficintegration,cheapgas finderandmore.
MAP KEY
AT&T­DataConnect(HSPA) VerizonWirelessandAT&TNetworkOverlap (EV-DORev.AandHSPA) VerizonWireless­BroadbandAccess (EV-DORev.A)

TheVerizonWirelesscoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywhereitsownedandoperatednetworkisavailablebasedonitsinternaldata.Thecompetitorcoveragedepictedonthismapshowsapproximatelywherethecompetitor'sownedandoperatednetworkisasof03/31/2008 basedonpubliclyavailableinformation,andwecannotvouchforitsaccuracy.Thecomparisonofnetworksdepictedhereisforillustrationpurposesonly,andisnottobereliedupontodeterminetheexactavailabilityofcoverage.Wirelessserviceissubjecttonetworkandtransmissionlimitations, includingcellsiteunavailability,particularlynearboundariesandinremoteareas.Customerequipment,weather,topographyandotherenvironmentalconsiderationsassociatedwithradiotechnologyalsoaffectservice,andservicemayvarysignificantlywithinbuildings.Morerecentbroadband coverageforVZWand/orAT&Tmaybeavailableatwww.verizonwireless.com/bbacoverageandathttp://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer. SWmap0608©2008VerizonWireless
80230_VZW_vs_ATT_Map05c.indd 6 6/18/08 5:38:13 PM