Grochocinski v. Mayer Brown Rowe & Maw LLP et al

Filing 155

APPENDIX response in opposition to motion 150 Volume 3 (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 88-93, # 2 Exhibit 94, # 3 Exhibit 95-98, # 4 Exhibit 99-102, # 5 Exhibit 103-109)(Joyce, Edward)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS, EASTERN DISTRICT
DAVID GROCHOCINSKI, not individually,
but solely in his capacity as the Chapter 7
Trustee for the bankruptcy estate of
CMGT, INC.
Plaintiff,
v.
MAYER BROWN ROWE & MAW LLP,
RONALD B. GIVEN, and CHARLES W.
TRAUTNER,
Defendants.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

No. 06 C 5486
Judge Virginia M. Kendall

PLAINTIFF’S APPENDIX OF EXHIBITS
VOLUME THREE OF THREE
Exhibit
Description
1
Affidavit of Robert D. Carroll
2
CMGT, Inc. History – Key Events Chronological
Summary
3
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
4
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
5
Contract between Spehar Capital, LLC and CMGT, Inc.
6
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
7
E-mail from Given to Spehar
8
E-mail from Franco to Given
9
E-mails between John Crishon and Franco
10
E-mail from Franco to Given
11
E-mail from Franco to CMGT shareholders and Interested
Parties
12
E-mail from Franco to Given
13
E-mail from Franco to Spehar
14
E-mail from Franco to Given
15
E-mail from Spehar to Given and Franco
16
E-mail from Given to Spehar
17
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
18
E-mail from Franco to Given
19
E-mail from Franco to Spehar
20
E-mail from Franco to Given
21
E-mail from Franco to Given
22
E-mail from Franco to Given
23
E-mail from Given to Franco

Date
7/13/09
9/30/02

Source
N/A
Spehar

6/21/02
8/14/02
9/30/02
8/8/03
8/8/03
7/29/03
7/1/03
8/7/03
8/8/03

Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants

8/6/03
8/8/03
8/8/03
8/9/03
8/9/03
8/9/03
8/9/03
8/11/03
8/12/03
8/13/03
8/14/03
8/13/03

Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar

Exhibit
Description
24
E-mails between Franco and Spehar
25
E-mail from Given to Franco
26
E-mail from Franco to CMGT shareholders and Interested
Parties
27
E-mail from Franco to Given
28
E-mail from Spehar to Franco and Given
29
E-mail from Given to Spehar and Franco
30
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
31
E-mail from Franco to Given
32
E-mail from Given to Franco
33
Spehar Affidavit
34
Given Memorandum to Charles Trautner and John Politan
35
E-mail from Franco to Given
36
E-mail from Franco to CMGT shareholders and Interested
Parties
37
E-mail from Given to Franco
38
E-mail dated from Garrett Furuichi to Spehar
39
E-mail from Spehar to Franco and Given
40
E-mail from Franco to Given
41
E-mail from Given to Franco
42
E-mail from Franco to Given
43
E-mail from Franco to Peter Bentz and Given
44
E-mail from Crishon to Franco and Spehar
45
E-mail from Franco to Given
46
E-mail from Franco to Given
47
E-mail from Given to Franco and Spehar
48
E-mail from Given to Franco and Spehar
49
E-mail from Spehar to Franco and Given
50
E-mail from Spehar to Furuichi
51
E-mail from Spehar to Franco
52
E-mail from Spehar to Franco and Given
53
E-mail from Franco to Given
54
E-mail from Franco to Given
55
E-mail from Franco to Given
56
E-mail from Franco to Given
57
E-mails between Given and Spehar
58
59
60
61
62
63
64

E-mail from Spehar to Franco
Faxes from Rodi Pollock to Franco and Given
Faxes from Rodi Pollock to Franco and Given
E-mail from Franco to Robert Crandall and Wong
Memo from Given to Politan
E-mail from Franco to Given
Franco Citation Deposition Tr.

2

Date
8/14/03
8/18/03
8/16/03

Source
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants

8/15/03
8/19/03
8/19/03
8/21/03
8/21/03
8/21/03
7/10/09
8/22/03
8/23/03
8/27/03

Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants

8/26/03
8/29/03
8/31/03
8/31/03
8/31/03
9/1/03
9/2/03
9/2/03
9/2/03
9/4/03
9/3/03
9/3/03
9/3/03
9/3/03
9/5/03
9/4/03
9/4/03
9/4/03
9/4/03
9/4/03
9/4/03 &
9/5/03
9/5/03
9/9/03
9/11/03
9/12/03
9/14/03
9/15/03
5/7/04

Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar

Exhibit
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105

Description
Letter from Rodi Pollock to Given
E-mail from Given to CMGT shareholders and Spehar
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Given to CMGT shareholders and Spehar
E-mail from Steve Klenda to CMGT’s shareholders and
Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Baliga to Spehar, Franco and Wong
E-mail from Spehar to Baliga
E-mail from Franco to Given
Letter from Politan to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
Fax from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to CMGT shareholders and Spehar
E-mail from Klenda to CMGT shareholders
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Spehar to Franco, Given and Baliga
E-mail from Franco to Peter Bentz
E-mail from Franco to Bentz and Given
E-mail from Given to Franco
Fax from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given and Wong
E-mail from Given to Franco
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Given to Franco
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to CMGT’s shareholders
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-Mail from Franco to Given attaching CMGT’s By-Laws
E-Mail from Franco to Given attaching SC’s October 1,
2001 Contract
E-mail from Franco to Spehar and Given
E-mail from Franco to Spehar
SC’s Verified Complaint
SC preliminary injunction
E-mail from Franco to Given
E-mail from Franco to Given attaching SC’s Amended
Complaint
Plaintiff’s Application to Employ Special Counsel
Plaintiff’s Deposition (from Grochocinski v. Spehar

3

Date
9/16/03
9/17/03
9/18/03
9/19/03
9/19/03

Source
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Spehar

9/19/03
9/20/03
9/20/03
9/20/03
9/21/03
9/22/03
10/1/02
10/2/03
10/3/03
10/3/03
10/4/03
10/4/03
10/4/03
10/22/03
11/4/03
11/28/03
11/29/03
11/30/03
1/12/04
1/14/04
1/30/04
4/12/04
3/14/04
4/10/04
4/13/04
7/23/03
8/25/03
7/17/02

Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants
Defendants

7/17/02
7/31/02
9/9/03
10/3/03
10/14/03
11/28/03

Defendants
Defendants
Spehar
Spehar
Defendants
Defendants

11/14/05
10/30/08

Plaintiff
Plaintiff

Exhibit
106
107
108
109

Description
Capital, LLC, No. 04 B 31669 & 07 A 00838)
Defendants’ Answers to Plaintiff’s Requests to Admit
Letter from Plaintiff to Ira Bodenstein
Letter from Plaintiff to Wong
Letter from Plaintiff to Franco

Edward T. Joyce
Arthur W. Aufmann
Robert D. Carroll
EDWARD T. JOYCE & ASSOC., P.C.
11 South LaSalle Street, Ste., 1600
Chicago, Illinois 60603

4

Date
12/3/07
8/10/05
8/22/06
8/21/06

Source
Defendants
Plaintiff
Plaintiff
Plaintiff

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned attorney, certifies that on July 13, 2009, he caused the attached
Plaintiff’s Appendix of Exhibits Volume Three of Three to be served upon
Stephen Novack
Mitchell L. Marinello
Steven J. Ciszewski
Novack and Macey LLP
100 N. Riverside Plaza
Chicago, IL 60606
by electronically delivering a copy through the Court’s CM/ECF filing system.

/s/ Edward T. Joyce