Sprint Communications Company LP v. Vonage Holdings Corp., et al

Filing 369

OBJECTION(S) to 349 First Supplemental EXHIBIT LIST filed by Vonage by Sprint Communications Company LP. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Seitz, Adam)

Sprint Communications Company LP v. Vonage Holdings Corp., et al

Doc. 369 Att. 1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 1 of 39

EXHIBIT A
Sprint's Objections to Vonage's First Supplemental Exhibit List

2623399v1

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 2 of 39

Ex. No. 1001. 1002. 1003. 1004. 1005.

Description DuRee Deposition Ex. 2 - Patent Application for Architecture #2 KAM01482 Duree Deposition Ex. 3- Excerpts of BB-IN Strategic Plan Duree Deposition Ex. 4 - 5-15-92 Sprint SCP/DINA Platform Design Statement KAM00120 Duree Deposition Ex. 5 - 10-15-93 "Intelligent Hybrid Network Architecture" SPRp-01-029- 0001Duree Deposition Ex. 6 - 6-27-94 Sprint Broadband - Intelligent Network Prototype Project Authorization K4963000 (SPRp-0l029-00075 through SPRp-0l-00104) Duree Deposition Ex. 7 - 9-29-95 CCM Phase I Architecture III Requirements (SPRp-007-01-00466) Duree Deposition Ex. 8 - 11-08-97 JCS2000 CP/CPCS-AVM Extended LAB Trial SPRe-008-01-06853 Duree Deposition Ex. 9 - 11-18-96 JCS2000 Software Service Architecture SPRe-004-01- 06269 Duree Deposition Ex. 10 - 1-22-98 JCS2000 Bonanza Project Release 1.2 High Level Architecture SPRe-00101-146051 Duree Deposition Ex. 11 - 1998 The Evolution of JCS2000 SPRe-002-0107840 Ball Deposition Ex. 2 - 11-22-06 Vonage's Third Notice of 30(b )(6) Deposition Ball Deposition Ex. 3 ­ 6-2-98 Sprint and Cisco Memo of Understanding SPRp-012-01-00280-SPRp-012-0100296 Ball Deposition Ex. 4 - 6-2-98 MOU (SPRp-012-01-00280-SPRp-012-0100296
1

Objection Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial and confusing under FRE 403. N/A N/A

1006. 1007. 1008. 1009.

N/A Relevance. Prejudicial and waste of time under FRE 403. Relevance. Prejudicial and waste of time under FRE 403. Relevance. Prejudicial and waste of time under FRE 403. Relevance. Prejudicial and waste of time under FRE 403. N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine.

1010. 1011. 1012.

1013.

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 3 of 39

Ex. No. 1014. 1015.

Description Ball Deposition Ex. 5 - 12-14-98 Sprint and Cisco Master Purchase Agreement SPRe-012-01-00897 Ball Deposition Ex. 6 - 12-17-98 Sprint and Cisco Alliance Agreement SPRe-012-01-00792 through SPRe012-0 1-00848 Ball Deposition Ex. 7 - 7-20-05 Article: "Sprint Deployment of End-to End Cisco IP Next- Generation Network Enables 'Triple Play' Service Offerings to Enterprise Customers Worldwide Ball Deposition Ex. 8 - 7-11-05 Article: "Cisco, Sprint Extend Alliance" Ball Deposition Ex. 9 - 12-17-98 Sprint/Cisco License Agreement (SPRp-012-01-00237 - SPRp- 012-0100254) Ball Deposition Ex. 10 - 12-17-98 Sprint/Cisco JCS2000 Statement of Work (SPRe-012-01- 01026) Ball Deposition Ex. 11 - 4-20-00 Sprint/Cisco Agreement (SPRe-01201-00787 - SPRe-01- 00791) Ball Deposition Ex. 12 - 5-14-99 Sprint Presentation: ''Non-ION Voice Services Platform Alternative Analysis" (SPRe-006-01-04611) Ball Deposition Ex. 13 - 9-24-99 Sprint Presentation "Circuit Switching Analysis Update" SPRe-006-01-04727 Ball Deposition Ex. 14 - 3-11-02 Article: "Cisco Introduces New SIPenabled Voice over IP Solutions Patterson Deposition Ex. 2 - 7-02 LookSmart Article: VoIP ain't easy Reality Check panelists say - For Starters - Voice over IP

Objection Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine.

1016.

1017. 1018.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. N/A

1019. 1020. 1021.

1022. 1023. 1024.

Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403

2
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 4 of 39

Ex. No. 1025.

Description Patterson Deposition Ex. 3 - 10-17-05 Sprint - D 1848 Integrated IP Trunking Architecture Blueprint Version 1.2 (SPRe-001-01-100899900) McGrory Deposition Ex. 1 - Undated List of Contracts (SPRe-002-0100188-889) McGrory Deposition Ex. 2 - 1-14-00 JCS2000 Financial Status (SPRe-00201-06544) McGrory Deposition Ex. 3 - 11-28-94 Anonymix Agreement (SPRp-002-0100759- 775) McGrory Deposition Ex. 4 - 2-16-97 Amendment to KEMM Contract McGrory Deposition Ex. 5 - 2-16-97 Services Agreement Between Sprint Communications Company L.P. and KEMM Consulting, Inc. McGrory Deposition Ex. 6 - JCS2000 Design Document for the 0.2 Development Phase March 31, 1997 McGrory Deposition Ex. 7 - 4-27-95 CCM Detailed Design Revision 0.1 McGrory Deposition Ex. 8 - 9-19-95 BBIN- KEMM-IPDN-I0D Masoud Kamali McGrory Deposition Ex. 9 - Network Architecture Alternatives for CCM Masoud Kamali & Mohsen Emami McGrory Deposition Ex. 10 - 4-17-95 Multiprocessor Multiboard System for CCM Kaplan Deposition Ex. 3 - Bonanza Program Bi- Weekly Status Report for the two weeks ending: June 19, 1997 SPRp-017-01-00117-144) Kaplan Deposition Ex. 5 - ION Alliance Definitive Agreements Executive Status Report As of September, 1998 (SPRp-012-0101173) N/A

Objection

1026. 1027. 1028. 1029. 1030.

Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relvence. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Relevance.

1031. 1032. 1033. 1034. 1035. 1036.

1037.

Relevance.

3
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 5 of 39

Ex. No. 1038.

Description Cordes Deposition Ex. 16 - 3-25-05 Vonage: The Broadband Phone Company PowerPoint (VON_01904580) Cordes Deposition Ex: 2 - 3-31-99 Email from Cordes to BBOSD (SPRe002-01-05569-70) Cordes Deposition Ex. 3 - 4-26-99 Sprint/Cisco Executive Conference Call Meeting Minutes Cordes Deposition Ex. 4 - 1-14-99 JCS2000 Shut Down Plans (SPRe004-01-00012-19) Cordes Deposition Ex. 5 - 1-11-99 Operational Concept Description for JCS2000 SPRe-008-01-07682 Cordes Ex. 6 - Detailed Requirements Statement Overview BBOSD-REQ0042-04 (SPRe-008-01- 2707-754) Cordes Deposition Ex 7 - 7-29-99 Emai1 from Ginger Chase to Cordes (SPRe-002-01-02408-12) Cordes Deposition Ex. 8 - 7-15-99 Cisco Systems Proposal for JCS2000 Direct Access Lines (SPRp- 004-0100445-88) Cordes Deposition Ex. 9 - 9-24-99 Circuit Switching Analysis Update (SPRp-002-01-00718-40) Gardner Deposition Ex. 3 - 9-22-99 Sprint/Cisco Management Status Conference Call Notice (SPRe-00201-00474) Gardner Deposition Ex. 4 - 9-29-95 CCM Phase I Architecture III Requirements (SPRp-007-01- 0046667) Setter Deposition Ex. 6 - Updated Sprint Presentation - How Does Connection Control Work (SPRp-01029-00056-66) N/A

Objection

1039. 1040. 1041. 1042. 1043. 1044. 1045.

Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A

1046. 1047.

1048.

1049.

Relevance.

4
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 6 of 39

Ex. No. 1050.

Description Setter Deposition Ex. 11 - 6-4-97 Bonanza Project Detailed Requirements Statement Overview (SPRe-001-01-106771-812) Setter Deposition Ex. 8 - 1999 Presentation: Bonanza Security SPRe002-01-02530-562) Setter Deposition Ex. 9 - 7-15-98 JCS2000 Systems Engineering Notebook for Project Bonanza SPRp007-01-00294-465) Setter Deposition Ex. 10 - 6-96 Sprint ATM Voice-Band Multiplexer Technical Specification (SPRe-02701-0048-93) Setter Deposition Ex. 12 - 11-8-97 Sprint JCS2000 CP/CPCS- AVM Extended LAB Trial (SPRe-008-0106853-876) Setter Deposition Ex. 13 - 10-9-98 Sprint JCS2000 Glossary of Telecommunications Terms (SPRe008-01-06956-7142) Sims Deposition Ex. 5 - 4-23-07 Answer.com Printout - Advanced Fibre Communications, Inc. Sims Deposition Ex. 9 - 4-28-97 Kansas City Business Journal Article Sims Deposition Ex. 10 [sic] 3-13-06 Wholesale Master Services Agreement (SPRe-025-01-00009-SPRe-025-0100074) Wicker Deposition Ex. 11 - 3-25-04 Wicker Declaration in Foundry Networks v. Nortel Networks Case Nelson Deposition Ex. 1 - 1-19-99 Sprint/Cisco JCS Statement of Team Roster SPRe-012-01-01023-66) Nelson Deposition Ex. 2 -1998 The Evolution of JCS 2000 SPRe-002-0107840-54) Spitzer Deposition Ex. 1 - Undated Spitzer hand drawn sketch of CAF Relevance.

Objection

1051. 1052.

Relevance. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance.

1053.

1054.

Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Relevance.

1055.

1056. 1057. 1058.

Hearsay. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A

1059. 1060. 1061. 1062

Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing, and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Authentication. Relevance. Misleading and confusing under FRE 403.

5
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 7 of 39

Ex. No. 1063.

Description Spitzer Deposition Ex. 2 - 7-12-00 Research and Experimentation 1999 Tax Credit Study - INS (SPRp-02601-00584-606) Spitzer Deposition Ex. 3 - 6-12-00 Research and Experimentation 1999 Tax Credit Study - Primatek (SPRp026-01-00726-46) Spritzer Deposition Ex. 4 - 9-29-95 Appendix G to CCM Requirements MUX Specifications SPRp-007-0100726-51) Spritzer Deposition Ex. 5 - 08-95 Technical Specification for ATM Voice-Band Multiplexer (AVM) SPRe-027-01-00005-47) Dwarkha Deposition Ex. 6 3-29-05 Vonage - Diagram: How to Get Dial Tone VON_096685-6 2-28-07 Halpern Report Ex. C - Call Trace Inbound Call (VON_695938695945)) 2-28-07 Halpern Report Ex. D - Call Trace Outbound at Media Gateway (VON_695946- 695982) 2-28-07 Halpern Report Ex. E - Call Trace Outbound at Outbound Proxy (VON_29521- 29527) U.S. Patent application No. 08/238,605 and File History U.S. Patent Application No. 08/562,206 4-24-97 Cisco Master Purchase Agreement CIS0332-525 12-01 Sprint Alliance Agreement SPRe-012-01-01229 7-29-05 Sprint/Cisco Amended and Restated Alliance Agreement SPRe012-01-01256 RTP Relay Capacity VON_688164

Objection Hearsay. Double hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Double hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A N/A N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. N/A Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Waste of time under FRE 403.

1064.

1065.

1066.

1067. 1068. 1069. 1070. 1071 1072. 1073. 1074. 1075. 1076.

6
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 8 of 39

Ex. No. 1077. 1078. 1079. 1080. 1081.

Description Equipment Inventory Document VON_685735 3-31-07 Vonage 2007 10-Q net2phone Timeline, web.net2phone.com/ about/company/timeline.asp VonageŽ Provides SIP-based VoIP Services to pulver.com, Vonage Press Release, July 23,2001 Vonage Announces the Next Generation of Broadband Phone Service With the Most Popular Features and Unlimited Calling for One Flat Rate of $39.99, Vonage Press Release, March 20,2002 Cisco Introduces New SIP-enabled Voice over IP Solutions, Cisco News Release, March 11,2002 Vonage Completes $12 MM in Initial Financing, Vonage Press Release, May 2, 2001 Vonage Holdings Corp. Reports Second Quarter and Full Year 2006 Results, Vonage Press Release, August 1, 2006 Vonage Announces Pricing Of Its Initial Public Offering of Common Stock, Vonage Press Release, May 23, 2006 "Cisco Systems Named Overall Leader in Packet Voice, VoIP," Cisco News Release, December 11, 2001 "In-Stat Reports 7.9% of U.S. Households Now Use a VoIP Telephone Service, Up From 6.5% at the End of Q2," In-Stat Press Release, December 20,2006 "Time Warner Cable reaches VoIP deals," cnetnews.com, December 15,2003 "VoIP providers face price war," cnetnews.com, November 4, 2003

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Waste of time under FRE 403. Speculative. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A Hearsay. Authentication. Foundation. Relevance.

1082. 1083. 1084.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. N/A N/A

1085.

N/A

1086. 1087.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance.

1088. 1089.

N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication.

7
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 9 of 39

Ex. No. 1090. 1091. 1092.

Description "Internet Telephone Quality Still Lags, Survey Says," PCWorld, July 12, 2005 "More Home Users Call on VoIP Phones," PCWorld, July 24,2006 "Sprint scraps high-tech plan: Company lost edge on phone switches, officials say," The Kansas City Star, November 25, 1999 "Sprint Drops ION, Suspends MMDS Fixed Wireless Deployments," Converge! Network Digest, October 18, 2001 "A blow to convergence," Telephonyonline, June 18,2001 "Is VoIP ready for prime time?," cnetnews.com, August 5, 2003 "Guide to Cisco Systems' VoIP Infrastructure Solution for SIP," Version 1.0, 2000 "Angels steer clear of last year's disappointing tech investments," San Francisco Business Times, September 28, 2001 Infringement Assertion Letters SHB009-01- 00204-219 Standard & Poor's Industry Survey: Telecommunications - Wireline, February 8, 2007 Standard & Poor's Industry Survey: Telecommunications - Wireline, March 22, 2007 2002-2007 Vonage Awards, www.vonage.com/corporate/press_aw ards.php CNET Editors' Choice February 2006 "Battle of the Bundles: Packaging of Services to Accentuate Two-wire Dominance" Legg Mason June 2002 3-13-01 Bernstein Research Call Report on Domestic Telecom SPRp023-01-00045 Vonage "Digitalvoice" Report Principia Capital Group VON_532373
8

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication.

1093.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403.

1094. 1095. 1096. 1097.

1098. 1099. 1100. 1101. 1102. 1103. 1104. 1105.

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 10 of 39

Ex. No. 1106.

Description "Sending the Right Signals: Promoting Competition Through Telecommunications Reform" A Report to the US Chamber of Commerce, September 22, 2004 "Telecommunications Sector, Bruised and Battered, Looks to a Brighter Future" FDIC: Bank Trends, June 2002 Sprint 2001 Annual Report and 10- K Holder Deposition Ex. 16 - 12-31-00 Selected Financial Data VON_572709 Citron Deposition Ex. 3 - 11-14-06 Vonage's Form S-l Citron Deposition Ex. 6 - Undated Vonage Financials and Business Overview VON_571965 Wu Deposition Ex. 5 - 23-06 Vonage Prospectus 4-23-02 Vonage Corporate Presentation VON_280790-831 US Patent No. 4748658 US Patent No. 4991172 US Patent No. 5003584 US Patent No. 5115426 US Patent No. 5115427 US Patent No. 5204857 US Patent No. 5212789 US Patent No. 5327421 US Patent No. 5339318 US Patent No. 5345445 US Patent No. 5345446 US Patent No. 5363433 US Patent No. 5365524
9

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading and cumulative under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A N/A Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive.

1107.

1108. 1109. 1110. 1111. 1112. 1113. 1114 1115 1116 1117 1118 1119 1120 1121 1122 1123 1124 1125 1126

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 11 of 39

Ex. No. 1127 1128 1129 1130 1131 1132 1133 1134 1135 1136 1137 1138 1139 1140 1141 1142 1143 1144 1145 1146 1147 1148 1149 1150

Description US Patent No. 5297147 US Patent No. 5373504 US Patent No. 5384771 US Patent No. 5392402 US Patent No. 5422882 US Patent No. 5425021 US Patent No. 5426636 US Patent No. 5428607 US Patent No. 5434852 US Patent No. 5440563 US Patent No. 5452296 US Patent No. 5452297 US Patent No. 5473677 US Patent No. 5473679 US Patent No. 5483522 US Patent No. 5483527 US Patent No. 5506844 US Patent No. 5509010 US Patent No. 5513178 US Patent No. 5539884 US Patent No. 5544163 US Patent No. 5563939 US Patent No. 5568475 US Patent No. 5600643
10

Objection N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Nonresponsive. N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive.

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 12 of 39

Ex. No. 1151 1152 1153 1154 1155 1156 1157 1158 1159 1160 1161 1162 1163 1164 1165 1166 1167

Description US Patent No. 5606553 US Patent No. 5673262 US Patent No. 5680390 US Patent No. 5825780 VON_865215-865648 US Patent No. 5926482 US Patent No. 5940393 US Patent No. 5991301 VON_866932-871657 US Patent No. 6067299 US Patent No. 6104718 VON_865649-866931 US Patent No. 6115380 VON_862764-864419 US Patent No. 6181703 VON_853676-862763 US Patent No. 6324179 US Patent No. 6343084 VON_875143-877177 US Patent No. 6366586 VON_864420-865214 US Patent No. 6452928 VON_871658-875142 US Patent No. 6643282 VON_877178-878607 Japanese Patent No. 4100452A2

Objection Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, cumulative, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, cumulative, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, cumulative, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, cumulative, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Non-responsive. Relevance. Confusing, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Relevance. Confusing, misleading and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.
11

1168 Japanese Patent No. 7170324A2

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 13 of 39

Ex. No. 1169

Description

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. FRCP 37. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. FRCP 37. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. FRCP 37. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. FRCP 37. Relevance. Confusing, waste of time and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403.
12

Japanese Patent No. 8242288A2 1170 Japanese Patent No. 9172683A2 1171 11-4-00 Declaration of Gregory Milsteed for AU Patent No. 693883 1172 8-31-99 Declaration of Evelyn Swenson for AU Patent NO. 693883 1173 10-11-99 Declaration of Richard Vizard for AU Patent No. 693883 1174 1-2-02 Declaration of Michael Rumsewicz for AU Patent No. 693883 1175 1176 1177 1178 1179 1180 1181 1182 1183 1184 International Publication No. WO 94/28660 Sprint Market Profile Version 2007.1 April 2007 (SPRE-033-00270) Sprint Market Profile Version 2006.2 July 2006 (SPRE-033-00903) Sprint Market Profile Version 2006.3 December 2006 (SPRE-033-00247) Sprint Market Profile Version 2005.1 June 2005 (SPRE-033-00001) Sprint Market Profile Version 2005.2 December 2005 (SPRE-033-00646) Sprint Market Profile Version 2004.1 June 2004 (SPRE-033-00442) Sprint Market Profile Version 2004.2 December 2004 (SPRP-033-01720) Sprint Market Profile Version 2003.1 June 2003 (SPRP-033-01164) Sprint Market Profile Version 2003.2 December 2003 (SPRP-033-01340)

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 14 of 39

Ex. No. 1185 1186 1187 1188 1189 1190 1191 1192. 1193. 1194. 1195. 1196. 1197. 1198. 1199. 1200. 120l. 1202.

Description Sprint Market Profile Version 2002.1 May 2002 (SPRP-033-03355) Sprint Market Profile Version 2002.2 October 2002 (SPRP-033-00959) Sprint Market Profile Version 2001.1 March 2001 (SPRP-033-00529) Sprint Market Profile Version 2001.3 December 2001 (SPRP-033-00752) Sprint Market Profile Version 2000.1 May 2000 (SPRP-033-03131) Sprint Market Profile Version 2000.2 November 2000 (SPRP-033-00315) Sprint Market Profile Version 99.1 March 1999 (SPRP-033-00211) Sprint Market Profile Version 99.4 December 1999 (SPRP-033-02920) Sprint Market Profile Version 98.3 September 1998 (SPRP-033-00001) Sprint Market Profile Version 98.4 December 1998 (SPRP-033-00103) Sprint Market Profile Version 95.4 December 1995 (SPRP-033-02838) 02-07-06 Vonage's Response and Objections to Sprint's First Set of Interrogatories 12-29-06 Vonage's First Supplemental Response to Sprint's First Set of Interrogatories 4-10-07 Vonage's Second Supplemental Response to Sprint's First Set of Interrogatories 5-17-07 Vonage's Third upplemental Response to Sprint's First Set of Interrogatories 6-11-07 Vonage's Fourth supplemental Response to Sprint's First Set of Interrogatories 2-7-06 Vonage's Response and Objections to Sprint's Second Set of Interrogatories 8-7-06 Vonage's Response and Objections to Sprint's Third Set of Interrogatories

Objection Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Cumulative and a waste of time under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

13
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 15 of 39

Ex. No. 1203. 1204.

Description 2-12-07 Vonage's Response to Sprint's Fourth Set of Interrogatories 2-7-06 Vonage' Response and Objections to Sprint's First Request for the Production of Documents and Things 9-6-06 Vonage's Response to Sprint's Second Request for Production of Documents and Things 2-12-07 Vonage's Response to Sprint's Third Request for Production of Documents and Things 4-11-07 Vonage's Response to Sprint's Fourth Request for Production of Documents and Things 3-20-06 Sprint's Response to Vonage's First Set of Interrogatories 2-5-07 Sprint's First Supplemental Response to Vonage' s First Set of Interrogatories 4-3-07 Sprint's Second Supplemental Response to Vonage's First Set of Interrogatories 5-17-07 Sprint's Third Supplemental Response to Vonage's First Set of Interrogatories 3-29-07 Sprint's Response to Vonage's Second Set of Interrogatories 3-20-06 Sprint's Response to Vonage's First Request for Production of Documents and Things 2-12-07 Sprint's Response to Vonage's Second Request for Production of Documents and Things 2-14-07 Sprint's Response to Vonage's Third Request for Production of Documents and Things 5-14-07 Sprint's First Supplemental Response to Vonage's Third Request for Production of Documents and Things 7-02 Simulation Data Version 2.22 VON_210204
14

Objection N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

1205. 1206. 1207. 1208. 1209. 1210. 1211. 1212. 1213. 1214. 1215.

1216. 1217.

N/A

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 16 of 39

Ex. No. 1218. 1219. 1220. 1221. 1222. 1223. 1224. 1225. 1226. 1227. 1228. 1229.

Description Simulation Data 2002-2007 VON_852292 Simulation Data 2003-2008 Version 3.02 VON_852116 11-26-97 Sprint Presentation: Welcome to Bonanza SPRp-007 -0101020 1-4-99 JCS2000 Expenditures SPRp004-0 1-01495 Cisco's Sprint support Proposal SPRp-004-01- 01362 5-15-07 Koperda Declaration to Vonage' s Summary Judgment Motion 5-15-07 Halpern Declaration to Vonage's Summary Judgment Motion 10-30-06 Vonage's First Rule 30(b)(6) Notice of Deposition to Sprint 10-30-06 Sprint's Second Rule 30(b)(6) Notice of Deposition to Vonage 10-30-06 Sprint's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition to Sprint 4-17-07 Vonage 10k N/A N/A N/A

Objection

Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Hearsay. Relevance. N/A N/A N/A Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.

1230.

1231.

1232. 1233.

11-17-06 Declaration of Adam Seitz to Sprint's Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Extend Deadlines 6-11-07 Wicker Declaration, Ex. A to Hearsay. Relevance. Sprint's Motion for Summary Judgment Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. One Minute Audio (VON-878608Confusing, undue delay, waste of time and 885684) misleading under FRE 403. Fed. R. Civ. Pro. 37. Hearsay. Foundation. Confusing, waste of Sonus Inbound Call Flow time and misleading under FRE 403. Fed. (VON_885685-715) R. Civ. Pro. 37. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial, 06-23-98 Draft MOU between Cisco confusing and misleading under FRE 403. and Sprint (SPRP-028-01-00028) Subject to Motion in Limine.

15
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 17 of 39

Ex. No. 1234. 1235. 1236. 1237. 1238. 1239. 1240. 1241.

Description Undated Draft MOU between Cisco and Sprint (SPRP-028-01-00069) Patent Board Assessment (SPRe-03400033-192) Setter's Notes and Drawings (SPRP01-029- 00024-33) 10-15-93 Intelligent Hybrid Network Architecture w/ Ball's Notes SPRp0l-029-00034-55) 7-23-01 Press Release: Vonage Provides SIP Based VoIP Services to pulver.com Strickland Deposition Ex. 1 Undated Chart: Vonage Financing Chronology 5-02-01 Press Release: Vonage Completes 12MM Initial Financing Strickland Deposition Ex. 16 -5-0699 JC2000 Detailed Requirements Statement Overview SPRe-008-0102707 Strickland Deposition Ex. 17-11-99 JCS2000 Presentation on Shutdown SPRp-016-01-0000 1- 17 Strickland Deposition Ex. 18 -3-1306 Sprint/Antietam Cable TV Wholesale Master Services Agreement SPRe-025-01-00009 Strickland Deposition Ex. 19 -1-1007 Mark Lemley and Carl Shapiro, "Patent Hold-up and Royalty Stacking" (Draft) Strickland Deposition Ex. 20-4-18-07 WSJ Article: "Vonage Says Patent Lawsuits Can Lead to Bankruptcy" Israel Cidon et al., PARIS: An Approach to High - Speed Integrated Private Networks, International Journal of Digital and Analog Cabled Systems vol. 1(2), pp.77-86 (1988).

Objection Hearsay. Relevance. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Hearsay. Relevance. Misleading under 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Misleading under FRE 403. N/A

1242.

1243.

N/A

1244.

1245.

Relevance. Speculative. Misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.

1246.

16
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 18 of 39

Ex. No. 1247.

Description B. Awerbuch, I. Cidon, I. Gopal, M. Kaplan and S. Kutten, Distributed Control for PARIS, (Extended Abstract) Association for Computing Machinery, pp. 145-159(1990) I. Cidon and I. Gopal, control Mechanisms for High-Speed Networks, in Conf. Record, IEEE Int. Conf. Comm., 1990 (ICC '90); pp. 259-263 I. Cidon, I Gopal, M. Kaplan and S. Kutten, D. Strickland, Control Architecture for High-Speed Networks, IEEE Transactions on Communication vol. 43(5), pp. 195060 (1995) I. Cidon, I. Gopal and H. Heleis, PARIS: an Approach to Integrated High-Speed Networks, in Proc. IEEE Int. conf. Comm. (ICC '87) pp. 764768 (1987) Halpern Deposition Ex. 10 - 1992 Stallings, William "ISDN and Broadband ISDN" Halpern Deposition Ex. 11 - 7-93 Heinanen, Juha "Multiprotoco1 Encapsulation over ATM Adaptation Layer 5 6-4-99 Non-Ion Voice Services Platform Alternative Analysis (SprpP-002-01-00876-883) 6-4-99 Non-ION Voice Services Platform Alternative Analysis (SPRP-002-01-00876-83) Summary of Cisco Patent License (SPRp-012-01- 00278-79)

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Misleading under FRE 403.

1248.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Foundation. Foundation.

1249.

1250.

1251.

1252.

1253. 1254.

Relevance. Misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Relevance. Misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.

1255.

1256.

Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Hearsay. ION Lessons Learned (SPRp-012-01- Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial and 01003-174) misleading under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.

17
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 19 of 39

Ex. No. 1257.

Description IBM Corp., High Speed Networking Technology An Introductory Survey 88 (1st ed. March 1992) (VON_PRI_012767-13120)

Objection

1258.

1259.

1260.

1261.

1262.

1263.

1264.

1265.

1266.

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading and confusing under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit Uyless D. Black, Voice Over IP 21available for review. Sprint reserves the 22 (2000) right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day Roger L. Freeman, Reference Manual of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit for Telecommunications Engineering available for review. Sprint reserves the (2d ed. 1994). right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day Roger L. Freeman, Reference Manual of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit for Telecommunications Engineering; available for review. Sprint reserves the Update (2d ed.1995). right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Henry Sinnreich & Alan B. Johnston, Vonage offered after close of business day Internet Communications Using SIP: of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit Delivering: VoIP and Multimedia available for review. Sprint reserves the Services with Session Initiation right to provide its objections following Protocol (2001) Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. J.H. Saltzer, et al. End-to-End Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Arguments in System Design ACM Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, TOCS, Vol. 2, No.4, ACM, 277-288 confusing and a waste of time under FRE (1984) 403. Brian Carpenter and the Internet Foundation, Authentication. Relevance. Architecture Board (IAB). RFC 1958: Architectural Principles of the Internet June 1996 Vonage offered after close of business day Raif O.Onvural, Asynchronous of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit Transfer Mode Networks: available for review. Sprint reserves the Performance Issues (2d ed. 1995) right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Henry Sinnreich & Alan B. Johnston, Vonage offered after close of business day Internet Communications Using SIP: of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit Delivering VoIP and Multimedia available for review. Sprint reserves the Services with Session Initiation right to provide its objections following Protocol (2d ed. 2006) Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. JCS2000 and Fastbreak Architecture Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. and Issues (SPRe-0ll-0l-00336-41) Prejudicial under FRE 403.
18

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 20 of 39

Ex. No. 1267.

Description IBM International Technical Support Organization (ITSO), Networking BroadBand Services (NBBS) Architecture Tutorial (June 1995). IBM Redbooks, International Technical Support Organization, Networking BroadBand Services (NBBS) Architectural Tutorial (June 30, 1995) ATM Forum Trip Report (SPRe-01101-00001-2) 8-5-99 Email from Myrick to Cordes (Spre-002- 01-02288 6-3-98 FastBreak & Bonanza Technology Approach (SPRe-011-0 1-00294-317) Citron Deposition Ex. 3 - 11-14-06 Vonage's Form S-1 Holder Deposition Ex. 1 - 9-08-06 Sprint's First 30(b)(6) Notice 10-4-05 Sprint's Complaint in Sprint v. Vonage Case No. 05-2433 10-12-05 Sprint's Amended Complaint in Sprint v. Vonage Case No. 05-2433 11-3-05 Vonage's Answer and Counterclaim to Amended Complaint in Sprint v. Vonage Case No. 052433 Holder Deposition Ex. 11 - 1-31-02 Cisco/Vonage Beta Test Agreement (CIS0013) Holder Deposition Ex. 12 - 10-17-03 Cisco/Vonage Master Beta Test Agreement (CIS0006) Holder Deposition Ex. 16 - 12-31-00 Selected Financial Data (VON_572709) 11-08-06 Sprint's Fourth 30(b)(6) Notice Rego Deposition Ex. 4 - 08-21-06 Vonage Holdings' Form S-1

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject to Motion in Limine. Vonage has withdrawn this exhibit as it is a duplicate of Exhibit 1267.

1268.

1269. 1270. 1271. 1272. 1273. 1274. 1275.

Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

1276.

N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

1277. 1278. 1279. 1280. 1281.

19
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 21 of 39

Ex. No. 1282. 1283. 1284.

Description Rego Deposition Ex. 12 - Undated Summary Financial Information (VON_019388) Spitzer Deposition Ex. 1 - Undated Spitzer hand drawn sketch of CAF Spitzer Deposition Ex. 2 -7-12-00 Research and Experimentation 1999 Tax Credit Study - INS (SPRp-02601-00584) Spitzer Deposition Ex. 3 - 6-12-00 Research and Experimentation 1999 Tax Credit Study - Primatek (SPRp026-01-00726) Spitzer Deposition Ex. 4 - 9-29-95 Appendix G to CCM Requirements MUX Specifications Spitzer Deposition Ex. 5 - 08-95 Technical Specification for ATM Voice- Band Multiplexer (AVM) Miron Deposition Ex. 4 - 10-03-05 Vonage Call Processing -- SIP 101 (VON_012447-501) Miron Deposition Ex. 5 - 10-03-05 Vonage Call Processing - SIP 101 (VON_012447a-501a) Citron Deposition Ex. 4 Vonage Timeline Citron Deposition Ex. 5 Vonage Provides SIP- based VoIP Services to pulver.com, Vonage Press Release July 23,2001 Citron Deposition Ex. 6 - Undated Vonage Document Containing Financials and Business Overview (VON_571965-2006) Citron Ex. 7 - Selected Financial Data July 2002 to December 2002 (VON_572709-14) Citron Deposition Ex. 8 - 5-18-05 Board of Director's Meeting VON_018837 Citron Ex. 10 - Computer List of Patents N/A

Objection

Hearsay. Authentication. Relevance. Misleading and confusing under FRE 403. Hearsay. Double hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Double hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. N/A N/A N/A N/A

1285.

1286. 1287. 1288. 1289. 1290. 1291.

N/A

1292.

N/A N/A N/A

1293. 1294. 1295.

20
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 22 of 39

Ex. No. 1296. 1297. 1298.

Description Citron Deposition Ex. 11 - 8-19-04 Letter to Citron from Trent Webb Citron Deposition Ex. 12 - 11-12-04 Letter to Citron from Trent Webb SPCC.001159 Citron Deposition Ex.13 - 5-9-05 Letter to Citron form John Gibson (SPCC.001160) Demonstrative Vonage TA Telephone Adapter Demonstrative Vonage TA and Router Combined Demonstrative Vonage Telephone Router and TA in one Demonstrative Vonage SIP Gateway 5300 Demonstrative Vonage RTP Media Relay N/A N/A N/A

Objection

1299.

1300.

1301.

1302.

1303.

1304.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1305.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1306.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1307.

Reserved For Demonstratives

Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.
21

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 23 of 39

Ex. No. 1308.

Description

Objection Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.
22

Reserved For Demonstratives

1309.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1310.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1311.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1312.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1313.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1314.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1315.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1316.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1317.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1318.

Reserved For Demonstratives

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 24 of 39

Ex. No. 1319.

Description

Objection Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.
23

Reserved For Demonstratives

1320.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1321.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1322.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1323.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1324.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1325.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1326.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1327.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1328.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1329.

Reserved For Demonstratives

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 25 of 39

Ex. No. 1330.

Description

Objection Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.
24

Reserved For Demonstratives

1331.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1332.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1333.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1334.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1335.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1336.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1337.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1338.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1339.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1340.

Reserved For Demonstratives

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 26 of 39

Ex. No. 1341.

Description

Objection Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.
25

Reserved For Demonstratives

1342.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1343.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1344.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1345.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1346.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1347.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1348.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1349.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1350.

Reserved For Demonstratives

1351.

Reserved For Demonstratives

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 27 of 39

Ex. No. 1352.

Description

Objection

1353.

1354. 1355.

1356. 1357. 1358.

1359.

1360.

1361.

1362. 1363.

Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its Reserved For Demonstratives objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its Reserved For Demonstratives objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. 11-12-04 Letter Webb to Temnorod Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and (Broadvox) follow up to 8-19 letter re misleading under FRE 403. patent portfolio SHB- 009-01-00206 11-12-04 Letter Webb to Walker Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and (Dialpad) responding to letter of 8misleading under FRE 403. 25-04 letter SHB-009-01- 00207 11-12-04 Letter Webb to Gittes Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and responding to letter of 10-18-04 misleading under FRE 403. regarding Sprint portfolio SHB-00901-00208 - 00209 11-12-04 Letter Webb to Walker Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and (Dialpad) SHB- 009-01-00207 misleading under FRE 403. 5-9-05 Letter Gibson to Walker Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and (Dialpad) responding to 12-3-04 misleading under FRE 403. letter regarding portfolio SHB-00901-00210 5-9-05 Letter Gibson to Miller Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and Sheehan responding to 12-9-04 letter misleading under FRE 403. regarding portfolio SHB-009-0100211 (SPCC.001156) 5-9-05 Letter Gibson to Gittes SHBFoundation. Relevance. Confusing and 009-01-00212-00213 responding to misleading under FRE 403. 12-21-04 letter regarding patent portfolio with respect to Deltathree 5-9-05 Letter Gibson to Chudakoff Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and responding to 11-23-04 letter misleading under FRE 403. regarding portfolio with respect to Broadvox SHB-009-01-00214 7-13-04 Letter Lupo to Broadvox Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and describing patent claims SHB-009-0 misleading under FRE 403. 1-00215 - 00216 7-13-04 Letter Lupo to Walker Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and (Dialpad) describing patent claims misleading under FRE 403. SHB-009-01-00217 - 00218

26
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 28 of 39

Ex. No. 1364.

Description 7-13-04 Letter Lupo to Cespedes (Voiceglo) describing patent claims SHB-009-01-00219 - 00220 (SPCC.001149 -1150) 7-13-04 Letter Lupo to Zimels (Deltathree) describing patent claims SHB-009-01-00221 - 00222 8-19-04 Letter Webb to Cespedes (Voiceglo) following up 7-13-04 letter SHB-009-01-00223 00224 (SPCC.001154 -1155) (SPCC.001163- 1164) 8-25-04 Letter Walker to Webb responding to 8-19-04 and 7-13-04 letters SHB-009-01-00225 9-15-04 Letter Casey to Webb responding to 8-19-04 and 7-13-04 letters SHB-009-01-00226-00227 (SPCC.001152 - 1153 12-22-04 Letter Webb to Miller Shehan regarding 12-9-04 letter re patent claims (SPCC.001151) 10-13-04 Letter Webb to Casey regarding Sprint Patents SPCC.001161 -1162 Newton's Telecom Dictionary (16th Ed. 2000)

Objection Foundation. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403.

1365.

1366. 1367 1368

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint.

1369 1370 1371

1372

The Essential Guide to Telecommunications (4th Ed. 2005)

1373

William Stallings, Data and Computer Communications (4th Ed. 1994)

27
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 29 of 39

Ex. No. 1374

Description Tehrani's IP Telephony Dictionary (2004)

Objection Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. N/A

1375

IBM International Technical Support Centers High-Sped Networking Technology: An Introductory Survey (June 1993). Eisen Deposition Ex. 5 Vonage Brand and Advertising Tracking (AW_00118-58) Eisen Deposition Ex. 6 [SIC] New Customer Tracking Research Analysis of February 2006 Subscribers (VON_640462-495) "AT&T Begins Selling Net Phone Service", CNet News.com, March 12, 2004 Verizon News Release, Verizon Rings in Next Generation of Vonage Service with VoiceWing Broadband Phone Service," July 22,2004 11-11-06 "85 VoIP Service Providers Shutdown in 15 Months", www.myvioprovider.com NASDAQ Composite Index price data, http://finance.yahoo.com

1376 1377

1378 1379

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403.

1380 1381 1382 1383

1384

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Broadband Technology, 65 Broadband Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Technology 12 (1991) Relevance. Confusing, misleading and waste of time under FRE 403. Alan E. Baratz et al., SNA Networks of Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Small Systems, 3 IEEE Journal On Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, Selected Areas in Communications confusing and a waste of time under FRE 416 (1985). 403. Daniel Brier, Sprint Plans Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. "Sweeping" Network Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, Revisions, 10 Network World 1 confusing and a waste of time under FRE (1993) 403. Subject to Motion in Limine.

28
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 30 of 39

Ex. No. 1385

Description Israel Cidon et al., Distributed Control for PARIS, Association for Computing Machinery, (1990) Israel Cidon et al., PARIS: An Approach to Integrated Private Networks, International Journal of Digital and Analog Cabled Systems (1988). Israel Cidon and Inder S. Gopal, PARIS: An Approach to Integrated High-Speed Private Networks Harry Newton, NEWTON'S TELECOM DICTIONARY (CMP Books 1992) Jan Thorner, Intelligent Networks (Artech House Publishers 1994)

Objection Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Foundation. Authentication.

1386

1387 1388

Vonage has withdrawn this exhibit as it is a duplicate of Exhibit 1250. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Subject of Motion in Limine. N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403. Vonage has withdrawn this exhibit as it is a duplicate of Exhibit 1248.

1389

1390

1391 1392

Guide to Cisco Systems' VoIP Infrastructure Solution for SIP, Version 1.0, Cisco Systems (2000) Cisco Signaling Link Terminal Data Sheet, Cisco Systems, (1992-2006) Evolution of Alcatel Exchanges, 65 Electrical Communication 19, at 20 (1991). IEEE Proceedings, Tl NetworkingPast, Present, Future Perspective, by Jack T. Woods. (1989). IEEE Proceedings, The Evolving Intelligent Interexchange Network-An SS7 Perspective, by Manu Bahl et al. (1992). IEEE Paper CH2$29-0/900/000000259 Control Mechanism for High Speed Networks, Israel

1393 1394

1395

29
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 31 of 39

Ex. No. 1396

Description McGraw-Hill Computer Handbook, "Voice Recognition" (1983)

Objection Vonage offered after close of business day of 8/21/07 to make this book exhibit available for review. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Vonage has withdrawn this exhibit as it is a duplicate of Exhibit 1259. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Relevance. Relevance.

1397

1398 1399 1400

1401 1402

Reference Manual for Telecommunications Engineering, Fiber Optics Transmission (2004) Vonage Expands Area Code Selection in Virginia, Vonage Press Release, August 17, 2006 Sprint Nextel Completes Merger, Sprint Nextel New Release, August 12,2005 Sprint 'Powers Up' Largest Mobile Broadband Network With More Upgraded Markets, Faster Speeds, New Device and Integrated GPS Capabilities, Sprint Nextel News Release, January 30,2007 Sprint Nextel Reports Third Quarter 2006 Results, Sprint Nextel News Release, October 26, 2006 "USA - VoIP Market - Analysis & Statistics," October 5, 2006 "SIP: The Promise Becomes Reality," Cisco Systems White Paper, 2002 "Has Vonage Bottomed Out?," Seeking Alpha Article, January 23,2007 "The VoIP Players: Who's Who in Internet Calling," February 23, 2005 "Vonage Posts Narrower Loss But Adds Fewer Customers," The Wall Street Journal, February 16, 2007 "VoIP: A Threat to PSTN?," Ibrahim Ayad, Tzu-En Huang, Haijing Zheng, 2002

Relevance. Vonage has failed to produce this exhibit. Sprint reserves the right to provide its objections following Vonage's production of the exhibit to Sprint. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403.

1403 1404 1405 1406 1407

30
2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 32 of 39

Ex. No. 1408 1409 1410 1411 1412 1413 1414 1415

Description Vonage Company Fact Sheet, Third Quarter 2006 "The Mad Scramble over VoIP Patents" BusinessWeek.com, March 19, 2007 12-12-01 "Cablevision, Vonage Site Visit" VON_572440 Examples of Obstacles Overcome by "SIP-thru- NAT" VON_571971 6-02 Analyst Report SPRp-023-0100061 Vonage Testing VON_532377 John G. van Bosse, Signaling in Telecommunication Networks, Wiley Interscience, 1998 CCITT Study Group XI, "Specifications of Signaling System No.7, CCITT Yellow Book CCITT Study Group XI, "Specifications of Signaling System No.7, CCITT Red Book CCITT Study Group XI, "Specifications of Signaling System No.7, CCITT Blue Book A. Modaressi and R. Skoog, "Signaling System No.7: A Tutorial", IEEE Communications Magazine, July 1990 RFC 3700 Internet Official Protocol Standards, July 2004 RFC 2543 SIP: Session Initiation Protocol, March 1999 RFC 2543 SIP: Session Initiation Protocol, June 2002 RFC 3264 An Offer/Answer Model with the Session Description Protocol, June 2002
31

Objection Relevance. Prejudicial and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. N/A N/A N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, confusing and misleading under FRE 403. N/A N/A

1416

N/A

1417

N/A

1418

N/A

1419 1420 1421

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Confusing, cumulative, misleading and a waste of time under FRE 403 Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication.

1422

2623399v1

Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL

Document 369-2

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 33 of 39

Ex. No. 1423 1424 1425 1426 1427 1428

Description RFC 0791 Internet Protocol, Version 4, September 1981 RFC 0793 Transmission Control Protocol, Version 4, September 1981 RFC 0768 User Datagram Protocol, Version 4, September 1980 RFC 2327 Session Description Protocol RFC 1577 Classical IP and ARP over ATM, January 1994 http://www.vonage.com/corporate/ N/A N/A

Objection

Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Misleading and Confusing under FRE 403. N/A Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Hearsay. Foundation. Authentication. Relevance. Prejudicial, misleading, confusing and a waste of time under FRE 403.

1429 1430 1431 1432

1433

Relevance. Confusing and misleading under FRE 403. Hearsay. Relevance. Confusing and Landmarks in Sprint History http://web.archive.org