Kuhnhein v. Kenton County Public Library Board of Trustees

Filing 14

RESPONSE in Opposition re MOTION for Order by Garth Kuhnhein filed by Kenton County Public Library Board of Trustees. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1-Resolution dated 7/5/67, # 2 Exhibit 2-Letter 5/8/95 to Banks from Carter)(Hawkins, Michael) Modified text to describe exhibits on 2/24/2012 (TED).

':=-".-:::"-.-':, :::-':-;."=:".;".;EXH!,B!T,:;:;.".':.='--'-'.=-'"-'=",:.-:,,i;:-:-":
„

,",:.','S.:, =...:,-.:;,;"-;;"':-" l::--'.„'--:

Bo'or)c1c&(-" ')&r

"i':F

.,l,

''"-. Lo!?ex, &:-:

Cc)i?Illl

T't'!;.'('OD&.&"'"D&

L&ol-

tllR'..

.:.,!:!J.ecl

t'I'. i. ".. rJ!3 I v

1

.

~

.'."On t

Deb.i Cion

3!

". "Ie

1:I!
I'1c'",Ior(.

i

?33(in

s r?I;o vol e(. '

&ro '.&3?

h::&3

&

hy-o?;e;:,!,".t pe T::ent:

It

(3c ni

t'i" &:-(!. I)ets! t!Lo!:inc",

'.)I-crn

r!c&

1,!I sb

f;'! '

es L,&:

t.e?) T!!:f&".)&, "O

F loorii

L

&3

She 1(iso&SI

on

'1'I

", l 16b

NQ&IOAlbc&?

Kent,orl

Oi

Co?3?'&

"us I .:.lec!

cli! ty

Libr.:.rv Dist.riel! for

)'&!Jbi. to

sh e

i

it

&

of

ish(»!U...lber

-

o

on)'I(.'3,

(

JCent

o! Co!Jr!SJ&,
&

K(-»t!.Ioic(r, and,

h(

"&&po!Js? 3ric&;.ha"',",

I lb'. 3 ry c,:..t 1 iol! s
s&.a
I& ~r)
—

«

O—

oen'&s
Lo '

o.

Co!3& t.

l.

"S

I

'.file

&)o&l

l.

(I ppea

n

Jon,

t FJ)(en

&&&s

'.o

.':

LI !&a

'. 1

I'".

'. ('ct '« i bl3

"o?JI!&.'(':nfs I

Cf

'3)

r„'. !i)'I

f'e!,

}y

Flr

&

JJO

'Le.'-

sec;

&"

Con.'I Ly

ps! s

s;&(''«

L&

1 3

Di sbr:i&

".I

7&&.,131

l...!n t33e

!113(Ie vr! e:!O)1,

t23(i) ':'. ()1!:, t h J!1
I
?&(,,

o& ~

!i

c)

'-'.i

D1

et.: '."L

f '&

('te'"'a !

b!Jr'!r.',

O,,&

&

'

J b'

l&&3f!

I'

'.; 131

I

of

ev'3

siss

i'.

i

'»e=;
L'! IO

'

t

3

(3?1b

I

1

4zi ()?1

'leCI

1?

0 f!

..33

Qn

'

+h&

01"cc-3'll'Ig
'- 1

~

3(&

&

'US. 0!. 83"'a ssPsser",

tv

03'o&p(3(

1

!?it!33 i r!e 7 &.soe,&.

(

L

On

b&.

f &Jl!

&?

&

be

s; oi

O!?Ip L

'JOJC'&&

1)3 L=r.

&

sf3 1 ci Kent()r&

vn(I

.

'r

t:''F'ODDT'i

'',',''&r'(1's

lo,&&

r'

&p''

?F r

S

1ei. JC

I ne (Ie

Co"',n

G

1

'--

t

&&

)—

. 1"

1

it)la 1

y"

is he,:eb"

'r

sesse&X

rpos

Cr

.

&!

S

1

Sb iS'hI

0&!

I." I!I xsoT.—

O')31 3 c'.,"bra

r

ti &J.r'd

'e'&it

Lf),

ti!-:reby

&n

'Lll
nq „ecif& 3 s t:c.l.I?Icj

&1?ict

C

!he

c'(J

sen

-L1)FJ

I

73

Lh

t31e! B "I?Iie 1 s

is?Id

".e for Lhe Ke!!t on
COnn" ""

i c)c& 1+

D'L RL'O'L''rD,

GPDT""Fcl.=,(D &3ND

&&

o" C.!;!pt')I'

i?3."s &'f(31?Th 0'C IJx'operti)r

i;e

Coll

(1!'.".(.'!. TJ!1&'3, e 0 1

c&'3&'-

Iillr(?ffienLS

re&

oe?sbs;. DfJj be

C("!In Ly, Ken

3 ICC. !I Ji. Th

1!. I

p jg& 1n&3

on

f!E;RI-" Y

el: 1 Ilg, c",i().i f3pi?)'.'fi(3

O(3

I

prov)L(1FJ'.: th-I

&

~

l&!c3
D

',

le'i"'ist'i.! (?t
J

fC(anbC)n

!.S&'!: n«

?1&'1'&&

". Les h:-i&in(;
G

i'

&I

tl!e

3?3!n(1:&s&I D10 J

c:(133!3 13 bra

')fo

(IOI I nrs %or

IL)1&3, .l!r3;

'" I

sn!?& (&r

0!1e

O?.S

3

)io Lib

'e

l) &I

pC&t..i T&

&!I"''in &! I

.IT&1&

.'K)l!, "'t!1"!B:;T&O!')',
K(a?& t (311

Q

(-.,

J

sv(!31 ',:('. '

c&ri

&

SJ'Jl)oe

v'

=.:

3(IO'3T.

1

'..he

"«! ict

h"., L

&

&.

I

t

t

3(

1,'«

i

n(

!r. 3 'n'&

Sill'ex

fin(i

'! '.:,

1eilI'ir'i in

.

&I

~

'

KB!I

&

(;.,&'5) o!3 (seel'I (3?1"! h&n3c&reel

I

o

':;;..I n

oui„sic)'I d

&)'&

&

OPy ()

(3!1 CC)i?31 '&&

he??Oor i«ho

!»'

&

''J'1 i.:
&

I,„d(i(3

'i;--'3

",.j"8-

ta

. ( ";",;

tr&f'.

n(~:.L,.!i',rlliP::...&l i

aye&qr&-ci:=)n:&
D.=jic'
;-"a;-.

':

a!.''.c Kc n ton 'a&l j

.
„j;.„:,;;,,-;;-;-„i; t;e
g

y

1

0 l.

!
~

&

Ker&t'.1

i.

'~

I,; Q..

'ii! t

!"l e t'"'(1
Cou

j-

i'.

Ka"1 t01! Col.'.

caint

tj~e

z

5

C..'lk

a .01 c cillcc wltfi KK'j '.7 3.

"..'v,'F'oiirt::eat

.

'-'

..i.b~r i.'-.i "-.-.'

July 6,

1&l67

Kent uci&y

Cov in&&ton,
I

Th&c

Fl.scalCourt met 'n "'e&"ular session in Cov.—
6, 1967, (".i th County Judge James

Ke»to!'! County

ington, Ke!!i;ucky on July
Dre..sm.n .ir. presiding,
Ci;a=les Sum(ae, and George
Qnd Count:y Engineer John

was opened with

The Court

Couni:y Co!".Qlissioners

Robel

Ste:n" ord„CounLy Attorney
D. F'eid! (&g be,ing present.
a pra&rer by Yr.

t

Aidemeyer,
John jlfers&

Summe.

tn accept
by Yiz. Ste! nford, secon(ied by Hr. Aldemeyer,
the mi.nutes o" the prev..ous r&sacring with a(,ditions and corrections.
:~lotion c&il"ried.
i~ioi'ior! made

Bids were submitted
The

lred procter

Co

T.
F.

from
and

envelopes.
iiot

': n

",';I&le
I(&

ti~e bi&is

(&

«A.

Printing, St. Regis Paper Co,
for t«(lx b111
& Associates

A. Klenk

secnnderi bv .'ir. Aldeo!eyer
to re er
bv .'ir. Summa
Li!e Kenton (.'ounty Shel" I s Qttice..«Tot j&!n carried.

..f

&'.ett(&r received and filed from the Kent.'on County Clerk's Office
regaI. ding th&e ' accep Lance of. Stand(&rd 0 f Ice ar! d Supply CL&&3pany
for the i&in& ir!g of the 1967 tax bil is„and Ti&e Hovard Shaw Gom-.
pauy for the, supplying of books ar!d. binders for records.
secor ded by Nr. Summe, to ac epi:
l&('Lion ((LIde by 'Ar. Aldemcyer,
these bids upon recommendation of the County Clerk's 0f fice.

ot

'n

c&.&I"ri.8 &i

The Kenton

Tnsnectnr
1»ade -by

!cool ts

""&&

County
s RepoI

.

Ste

t

patrol Rcpor ts,

and the Kenton Co nty Building
sobs!it te(! i;n the Fiscal Court, &~jot-.oo
seccnde d by,""ir Sum&ac L 0 a capt these

«/as
L.! 01, (i
&

&

i&ot Lor) car'rre&J.

resolution assessi(&g and levying a one-point seven cent
tax oI. al i.sr'l -hand'ersogal propert.y in Canlp'bell
and. Kcnton Counties upon each one hundre(i dollars vs.luat ion
Qs of JilnuQry 1»367 Was sub Gi tted and f fled,
A

&',1.7cg

Three:.Qsolutions .~ere submjttecl tn tie Fisc'ourt of
!"Int( n County authoriz':!;,
County.T!Idge t(; b~r: o~r &om
t'e County Deposito&ry, the Fi st hational P Ink ar!d Trust:

',

0 0!&!pliny

L he

s L!!'Is

o
&'"&!

Inc Thousand
F&

fty Ti;ousand

Do

&

lars

{,r&)&

D&ollarl&

000 00)

f 0 the

(y"!0,0!)0,00) for

Hea

the,

Fifty Thous.nd Doll. rs (,&50,000.00) l.or the

lti'!

1'un d

(;eneral

Fund

Road and 'Bridg'. F nd.

&~herewith to pay claims «gainst said fund: of the. County ol
N(!tion !!"&de by i".'r . Summe, seconded by i!r.
Kenton, KenLucky.
ldemeyer
to adopt a cepL'n(i appx ove these resolutioxls.
Y&ot .i.nn ca i ried.

u!s su&bmitted to the Kenton (.ounty
and the Kenton-b&none:;Boa:d of Realators
appea&x&..d oefore ti!e i"!.sc;il Court vo'c ing their opposition
to Leis& !.eso!1&t j on,

The .&'Ollovzing

F'seal (.'ourt

resolution

Notion made bv Yr. Su!!jr!le, SBCOnded by 8r. Steinfard, ta
Upon rail call,
adopt, accept;, and approve this resolution.
the follawin'ote was recorded:
Ayc: Nr. Summe, Nr, Ste f'x{i) Nx. Aldemeyer, and Judge Dressman. Nay: Hone.
l"10 t 10D c ax x'B d.

bid

A

sons

of

b

was submitted to
Company, general

J„G.

Exterk„rap
theFXiscal Court from
Contractors, for, the construction af

addition to the Kenton Count; C'arage.
Nr. Steinford, scconded by Hr. Aldemeyer,
approve this bid. Notion carried.
an

1&y

Motion made

to;:accept

and

I.ibraxy Petition {vas submitted ta the F'seal
of 3.6,513 signituxes, duly attested by the
County Clerk as being mare than 51% of the Dumber of duly
registered voters who voted in the last general election af
Hovember 8, 1966. The following resolution was submitted
accalllpanv3 ng the s1gni'Lljx'es:
The Kentan

CauDLy

Court cons.isting

R" &OLUT I 0{{!
Lt was moved by Commissioner
Aldemeyer)
Steinfoxd that: the following»
by Commissioner

and seconded
Resolution be

adopted:

that a. duly certified Petition containing
(51;r) er cent of the number o" duly
Qua li~ iea vatex'S who voted 1'fl the la st Cenera1 l'ection OD
Ãavcmbex 8, 1966, h v-'ng 'been filed petitirjned the Piscal
Court o" Keaton County, Ker)tacky to establish a Public
"Bj"" TT RESOj'{!ED

mare

than

fifty-one

'hrary Distr"'ct for

Keaton County,

Kentucky)

and,

af the act relat jng to
public library diatricts being KRS ly3-i'10 et seq., prox ides
nat tne "seal Court Qt the GQLIDLv sahll adopt a 1esolution
0 der1ng tlje levy of «l taic as required XD the pe't j.tloDs
filed jn the sum of six ccats QD each one hun{ixed dollars
~'artb of p aperty assessed for local tazatiaD) a!id)
Tt appearing that said petition filed with the Fiscal
Court. was sa filed within less than ninety (90) d"ys after
the date of the firsL signature o" on SuCh petition, and,
furtller appc{XX'3 D « tljat I"B require!))cut S Of ChapL r 1 /3
Of l(entuaky RBVi Sea Statutea hav j D«been full
Q~g-)Lie ri
th
HOW, Ti~l"RZPGP.) TT IS HEREBY ORDERED Ale DTRZCTED, l-hat a
)(entan County Public I.ibra y DisLxct be and ti;e same is hereby
es=ablished and that a levy of a tax for said Kenion County
I,ibrary District in the sum of six cents ( !Q6) be and the
same
s hex'e'by made on caci. One IIundred Dollars worth af
property assessed far taxation within Kenton County, Kentucky
for the purpose of establishing, constructing) equipping)
mailjtian:ng administering ox cofltracting fax such library
service for the Keaton County Public I.ibxary District en!bra{ lng
l.he entire CaunLy and a cerrified copy of this Order shall
be Piled ))lith the County Clerk of Kenton County, Kentucky„
within thirty (30) days fnom the date hereof who wi 11 arid
the levy to the Deist annual tax bill ox bills of Kenton
appearin«

that the provision

~

r

Col]I'liy)

Kentucky.

It is furtner

(,

~jT&

ordered and directed that the County
Clerk in behalf of the Kenton Fiscal Court in accordance
with KRS 173,. 725 shall a!. once notify the Kentucky Dep:.rLment
af I.ihraries of the estab ishm"DL of said I.lbrary Distr Lct
by rnrw- rding a certifie{! r opy of th!.s x'esolutlon
to said

De 'lax'tlllen L,

1&3

t(OII

c'is

triot

&r

O'.
d,l. s

Ti'h(c

lirii

t 0

( Olili

17 OI1

'

&

--.c
.'.

vali')J om 'I:.=x o

(7CI

o I'rQp(?

1

bevel&y

r&o i

1—

ty to

I .&Ii

I

p(ih ',1,) 1 r 2)ld 1'y

&)

Kelitol: County (vhi(i«sh=,11 have Lhe su+hori ter to 1!T(pos('.

d'or

i"s (&'o). I

C(&u»ty

est'cch

Ile 2!Sru" "'O(t 1

i

:»pc&ioi..l
I

"I''l(j

-o" lo)lc!.IJ&-; (inly;&uelij:ie&d cvoters o'. I"enton

rlli=
i

P'&..'TT

IiKIcRY

isso,.'sed - ox'

trc

I".

i!ii E n&inOC'"

~

!,06)

cent'::

Ii(I Ouere

L&

or)a

Df

On

t »(et 1()n "n

I

t &lcc

0'1 CO(lnty

K." n I

ith(?

cioI—

on eicoh one hun()recj
id&

."

'r(

u

() .j..'.I&'irv

r&uhl
I

t.r 1.o L..
CLiTII" JCRi'10t'&c

"" u.!7 Oi

i

t

ric, (r'1!1

I)

K("n t()'

Ch&)

t17A

ther

1'o&'1 t!i)I!

CO

(.oils I

."

(

0,

sr

sl(7ro

I'ti dri 1

last

in, Konton

X&2

Gl'u
ui:('::c'& ouzel

('O (rsri

1

t

iinr h

tOC::

6, .&(P s J.'jnd burr's

I

",1x.o('lio

l&)err

t

( t or; end

'. in(f

dont!

"I'TEE

CO!Cjyjl

Ii br&7-

DC&I!'

I)9, t -'")! voL'es in Lho

c&'1st

x''Iro

C!vc" o

'T'el(i& s '-I&1od,

J'IJI

lljlf(ANY

BY

of

nuIT37ez

-.=;if V

r;

'j

K36

'Bnci

(-":c»otc&rcl

on:)Tove!Tiber

lc(nLuc'cy,;.s requ j red snd provid(&d in

County,

C

'Ldd'(s...es

r

(I(J t y

'ection

Gccneial

r

'='

0, 19613,

173. 7 (.r'.

. I&) ddletio!1 Co-Chill. &le'1
Kelltog c ortnt;y T&1I)'"cry . Otttl!!I !!Lee

C p;-(.''e

4

+I&

~r;(.,&.'Am~ Lcf

'g )" i,~g

Jloc I« Grallicg, CO-Chil J, Nc)I1
Kcin LDIl Coucl Liy 1 iI&T n J y C:)rrizi',
)Ciu& T".c.

s~o!. n to

Suj&s I.il&ed 7!7d

celi(i
4)T&

r'&'.

&

th-

r

me hy Cj yet(1 W. Il&(tc! jetDI. (inc! 'f.„-&u-

GII&'(Us(., Cc) —
C:"1&1 '(11&i. c) f tj7P KPT1 ton

f'-

. 4&trt,!„iy ()r,Ttl I v

Coram!

i&1y

I&cl! Dre

ss

C.

o(&Ilty I 1 bra iiy

( o&7rji'. l.

t t ee,

I )67

I.on c pi rc&s

NDL:,ry I'lt&1!("
Ci(R'J'~'r'T(,1

fy thet

du
L

en&"i

. ',

i

orl

.) 1"Oc

Th-i&"-

Or. 7

)n

t

I'0Ã Cc&TI(I'I'Y C1~EI)~'.

":

Nc

v('mhex

cj-'-y

&Jd

}C&ric)

or

wj'0 on

&)0 t:mr,.

8,,'66
I

4

)

Jrc",..r I
* )

&r

t

&ll

C(

1117

P.. 'I'.
'l.r

&&!";

certi-

I6,:53 s).gliijo

tlh:

number

'J.'

29 .(r7 votes

In K-'-'t.

4

then

morco

&

do hero,'~y

-.Onta! njn&:;

LJ&.f.l).ed

r rl
1 c&6

Court,

Kenton County

dates consists of

olxd

1.

dr d ( Ii

~th

th!(.

Y&ic&

1)etc tjon hi"rc)i!I cjuly oex

4'!&e

tlires, sddre; ses

of

Clj~'(&

ot

."... . Kooc&, Clerk
T

l

r

ln tl.e

1&re&.

tr;, Ken'. (ioI(y,

(rr'ooc'.,

C.": e

r

k

ten(&r&i.L

"',-. I ecIrt

i! ed