Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 224

DECLARATION re #222 MOTION to Compel Production of Roche's Cell Lines, #223 Memorandum in Support of Motion BY DEBORAH E. FISHMAN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1#2 Exhibit 2#3 Exhibit 3#4 Exhibit 4#5 Exhibit 5 (submitted in camera)#6 Exhibit 6#7 Exhibit 7#8 Exhibit 8#9 Exhibit 9#10 Exhibit 10#11 Exhibit 11#12 Exhibit 12#13 Exhibit 13)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 224 Att. 10

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 1 of 9

01 TIBIHXE
Dockets.Justia.com

95832800

CTI-MA

291930076MA

/// ///

///

///
.redrO evitcetorP
detucexe

detalupitS

ot tnemdnemA tsriF
sa

ylud

a

si truoC eht

yb

noitucexe dna

gnilif

rof A tibihxE

dehcattA

.aneopbus
siht ot ytrap driht
a

ot

tnausrup ,noitca
dna stnemucod

,.cnI ,seigoloiB aznoL yb decudorp eb
a

ot

sgniht

niatrec ot

ytilaitnedifnoc

fo level dnoces

edivorp

ot yrasseeen si tnemdnema ehT

.redrO evitcetorP

detalupitS
ehT

eht ot tnemdnemA tsriF eht retne ot truoC eht

evom

yltnioj ybereh seitrap

REDRO EVITCETORP DETALUPITS DNEMA OT NOITOM TNIOJ

)
.stnadnefeD

,.CNI ,SEIPAREHT CITOYRAKSNART
dna .CNI

) ) ) ) ) )
)

,LESSUOR NOIRAM TSHCEOH
.v

)
YGW-41801-79 .oN noitcA liviC

)

,ffitnialP

) )

,.CNI NEGMA

STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID

TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 2 of 9

06832800

CTI-MA

391930076MA

·hl fo ·oc euh

a ta-rJ v·ec ybereh ·ICIVR·IS F·C ·ACIFITR:IC

0005-842 )716( 90120 AM ,notsoB teertS etatS 35 ecalP egnahcxE

TRAWETS & LLAH ,ETAOHC

)037165# OBB( ttodnaraM )042771# OBB( .rJ ,knarF .S
0009-695

.J eirE treboR

)212(

02001 YN ,kroY weN saciremA eht fo eunevA 1521 EVAEN & HSIF

)022712# )BB(

.rJ

,yelaH

.F semaJ

namreH .B htenneK

.F trebreH

:yB

.CNI ,SEIPAREHT CITOYRAKSNART dna .CNI ,LESSUOR NOIRAM TSHCEOH ,stnadnefeD roF

9991

,..·.·

rebmevoN :detaD

5523-552

)804(

41059 AC ,onitrepuC 057 etiuS ,.dvlB keerC snevetS 00402 REDLEHCTAB & DIRDAM REEBESAC YAD hctertS .E rehpotsirhC reebesaC .H giarC

:yB

.CNI

NEGMAffitnialp

eht roF

9991

,·

rebmevoN :detaD

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 3 of 9

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 4 of 9

16832800

CTI-MA

491930076MA

26832800

CTI-MA

591930076MA

DETALUPITS OT TNEMDNEMA TSRIF
aznoL dna seitraP eht

gniwollof

eht taht eerga
sa

ybereh

,)"NOITAMROFNI LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH"
ro

ot derrefer

retfaniereh( noitamrofni laicremmoc
rehto
ro

tnempoleved ,hcraeser
selpmas
dna

laitnedifnoc

ylhgih

terces edart niatnoc

ro

eb

ot

demialc eb yam fo

knab llec dna aidem erutluc

llec

yrateirporp

sti ot

gnitaler ,aznoL

sgniht
sa

,stnemucod ,noitamrofni niatrec

taht dna

,)"NOITAMROFNI LAITNEDIFNOC"
laicremmoc
ro

ot derrefer

retfaniereh(
ro

noitamrofni

tnempoleved ,hcraeser

laitnedifnoc rehto

terces edart niatnoc

ro

eb ot demialc eb yam ,noitca siht ot

ytrap-driht a ,)"aznoL" retfaniereh( .e· s¢·oloiB

aznoL fo

sgniht

dna ,stnemucod ,noitamrofni niatrec taht
a

gniraeppa
.cnI

tI

.redrQ

evitcetorP

detalupitS

otni deretne

)"seitraP

eht"

retfaniereh(

,seiparehT eitoyraksnarT

dna ,.cnI lessuoR noiraM tsheeoH

,.cnI negmA ,7991 ,3 rebmetpeS nO

REDRO EVITCETORP DETALUPITS OT TNEMDNEMA TSRIF

.stnadnefeD

,.CNI ,SEIPAREHT CITOYRAKSNART
dna

.CNI

,LESSUOR NOIRAM TSHCEOH
.v

YGW-41801-79 .oN noitcA liviC

,ffitnialP

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

,.CNI

NEGMA

STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 5 of 9

36832800

CTI-MA

691930076MA

.redrO siht fo
eht ot

snoisivorp

tnausrup slairetam eht

taert retfaereht llahs ohw
ro

,seitrap
sa

lla ot eciton

gnivig

yb
ot

os

od yam ti ,LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH

LAITNEDIFNOC

slairetam

etangised

deliaf

yltnetrevdani

ti taht senimreted retfaereht aznoL fI
ro

.dnegel
rennam

"LAITNEDIFNOC

YLHGIH" dna stnemucod hcus
ro

"LAITNEDIFNOC" eht htiw
ot

elbisiv

a

ni slairetam
YLHGIH" .2

gnilebal yb noitcudorp

roirp "LAITNEDIFNDC

"LAITNEDIFNOC"

detangised

eb llahs slairetam rehto dna stnemucoD

.REDRO EVITCETORP DETALUPITS OT TNEMDNEMA

TSRIF siht fo YLHGIH"
ro

snoisivorp

eht ot tnausrup detaert eb llahs
a

,dnegel "LAITNEDIFNOC ytilaitnedifnoc

"LAITNEDIFNOC"

htiw

noitangised

nopu ,detressa si

hcihw ot hcae
ro

sa

dna amroL
egap hcae

yb decudorp sgniht
no

dna stnemucod ,noitamrofnI
na

.decudorp gniht

no ro

rebmun

gniyfitnedi

raeb llahs

,seipoc gnidivorp yb decudorp
ro

noitcepsni

rof

decudorp

noitamrofni LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH

LAITNEDIFNOC

hcus llA .noitca siht ni

aneopbus

ot

tnausrup aznoL yb decudorp sgniht dna stnemucod

,noitamrofni LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH dna LAITNEDIFNOC lla ot ylppa llahs
REDRO EVITCETORP DETALUPITS OT TNEMDNEMA TSRIF sihT
.1

:DEREDRO YBEREH SI TI

.htrof tes retfaereh

snoisivorp

eht ot

tcejbus ,noitamrofni
yb

LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH dna LAITNEDIFNOC
ssecca

hcus ot seitraP eht

edivorp

ot deretne eb REDRO EVITCETORP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 6 of 9

46832800

CTI-MA

791930076MA

eht rof

ylelos

seitraP eht

yb

desu eb llahs aznoL
ro

yb decudorp sgniht

ro

stnemucod .6

,noitamrofni LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH

LAITNEDIFNOC llA
ro

.stcerid esiwrehto truoC eht sselnu
ot

erusolcsid eht
esoht naht

gnitirw

ni stnessa aznoL sselnu evoba 4 dna 3

shpargarap yb dessapmocne

rehto enoyna ot delaever eb ton llahs

)lairetam hcus

morf devired seirammus dna stcartxe
eht dna

gnidulcni( lairetam hcus ni deniatnoc noitamrofni
YLHGIH
ro

dnegel LAITNEDIFNOC

LAITNEDIFNOC eht htiw

detangised

lairetam

ynA

.5

.srotalsnart dna sretroper truoc

)e(
)d(

;lennosrep sti
;REDRO EVITCETORP DETALUPITS eht
eht
fo 6
ro

dna truoC eht

hpargarap yb detalpmetnoc tnemeerga gnitlusnoc
sa

dengis

evah ohw dna

strepxe gniyfitset

noitca siht rof

yllacificeps

deniater

)stnatsissa

dna ffats yrassecen rieht

dna( strepxe tnednepedni
;)stnatsissa

)c(

dna ffats yrassecen rieht

dna( seiparehT eitoyraksnarT tnadnefed rof
rof ruof

eno

dna

,lessuoR noiraM tshceoH tnadnefed
erom on

,negmAffitnialp

rof syenrotta esuoh-ni evif naht

)b(

;)stnatsissa

dna ffats yrassecen rieht
no

dna(

lesnuoc edistuo

sa

seitrap

eht

gnitneserper
)a(
:ot

smrif wal eht ni noitca siht

gnikrow stnega

dna syenrotta eht

ylelos

detcirtser eb llahs

,slairetam hcus ni deniatnoc noitamrofni eht fo erusolcsid dna ,dnegel

LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH eht htiw

detangised

slairetam lla ot sseccA

.4

.REDRO EVITCETORP DETALU·TS eht fo 4 ni detcirtser eb llahs dna

hpargarap

htiw ecnadrocca

,slairetam hcus ni deniatnoc noitamrofni eht fo erusolcsid
eht htiw

,dnegel LAITNEDIFNOC

detangised

slairetam lla ot sseccA

.3

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 7 of 9

56832800

CTI-MA

891930076MA

5275-994 evirD retneC

)508(

9971-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT negmA enO .CNI NEGMA

yardroC euqinoM
drofetihW .A ydneW .D.hP ,kooC .R treboR
ttaW .L trautS

erdO .M nevetS :lesnuoC fO
0013-895

)716(

0062-01120 sttesuhcassaM ,notsoB roolF ·t 41 ,ecalP lanoitanretnI enO PLL REHCSKCEH & SIRROM ,ENAUD

)I

)961065# OBB( gnoW .M drahciR 15545# OBB( ittergellA sinneD .D
2046-60606 sionillI

,ogacihC

evirD rekeaW .S 332 rewoT sraeS 0036 NUROB & YARRUM

,NIETSREG ,ELOOT'O ,LLAHSRAM
reltetshcoH .C ssalguoD nuroB .F leahciM elooT'O .M drawA_F 5523-552 )804( 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 057 etiuS ,.dvlB keerC snevetS 00402 REDLEHCTAB & DIRDAM REEBESAC YAD hctertS .E rehpotsirhC

r·eJes·C .HgiarC
.CNI NEGMA

:yB
9991

ffitnialp
ro

eht roF

,·_rebmevoN
eht ot

:detaD

.dlrow eht fo ytnuoc yna ni

sthgif

ralimis rof tseuqer yna

noitacilppa tnetap
on

yna fo
ro

noitucesorp

gnitaler
esu

esoprup yna rof noitamrofni LAITNEDIFNOC YLHGIH

LAITNEDIFNOC yna

seitraP eht fo yna llahs tneve

on

nI .esoprup rehto

rof dna tiuswal siht fo

noitaraperp

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 8 of 9

66832800

CTI-MA

991930076MA

egduJ tcirtsiD setatS detinU gnuoY .G mailliW

9991,
0005-842 )716( 90120 AM ,notsoB teertS etatS 35 ecalP egnahcxE

fo

yad

SIHT DEREDRO

TRAWETS & LLAH ,ETAOHC

)037165# OB30 ttednaraM .J cirE )042771# OBB( .rJ ,knarF .S treboR

)022712# )BB(

0009-695 )212( 02001 YN ,kroY weN saciremA eht fo eunevA 1521 EVAEN & HSIF .rJ ,yelaH .F semaJ namreH .B htenneK

·f·

,·trawhc· .F trebreH

:yB

.CNI ,SEIPAREHT CITOYRAKSNART dna .CNI ,LESSUOR NOIRAM TSHCEOH ,stnadnefeD roF 9991

·

rebmevoN :detaD

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 224-11

Filed 01/10/2007

Page 9 of 9