Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 782

DECLARATION of Deborah E. Fishman in Support of Amgen's Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Preclude Testimony from Amgen's Belatedly Disclosed Fact Witnesses by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1#2 Exhibit 2#3 Exhibit 3#4 Exhibit 4#5 Exhibit 5#6 Exhibit 6#7 Exhibit 7#8 Exhibit 8#9 Exhibit 9#10 Exhibit 10#11 Exhibit 11#12 Exhibit 12#13 Exhibit 13#14 Exhibit 14#15 Exhibit 15#16 Exhibit 16#17 Exhibit 17#18 Exhibit 18#19 Exhibit 19#20 Exhibit 20#21 Exhibit 21#22 Exhibit 22#23 Errata 23#24 Exhibit 24#25 Exhibit 25#26 Exhibit 26)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 782 Att. 4

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 1 of 18

EXHIBIT 4

Fishman Decl. to Amgen's Opp to Motion to Preclude Testimony from Amgen's Belated Disclosed Fact Witnesses - Public

Dockets.Justia.com

801606

olegnatarF reteP lekceH knaH zciwelearsI kraM dnaleroM elehciM

:cc

)11( serusolcnE

plr:FED
namhsiF .E harobeD

PLL

REDLEHCT,AB & DIRDAM REEBESAC YAD
,sruoy

ylurt yreV

.dezilanif neeb dah redro evitcetorp ruo erofeb dna )6002 ,6 rebmeceD no( oga shtnom ynam uoy ot desolcsid saw ohw ,nosmadA .rD rof redro evitcetorp 'seitrap eht yb ediba ot tnemeerga eht fo ypoc dengis a esolcne I ,noitidda nI .hcae rof redro evitcetorp 'seitrap eht fo smret eht yb ediba ot tnemeerga eht fo ypoc dengis a sa llew sa slaudividni eseht fo hcae rof eativ mulucirruc eht fo ypoc tnerruc a esolcne I .meht htiw lairetaM yrevocsiD laitnedifnoC erahs ot noitnetni ruo fo uoy yfiton ot dna ,31 dna )c( 9 ¶¶ ta redrO evitcetorP desoporp ruo htiw ecnadrocca ni ninuK evetS .rM dna llaW ydnaR ,ressawdloG eneG ,wahsdarB hplaR ,kreB einrA .srD etangised ot etirw I
:moT raeD

)YGW 73221-VC-50( La

te

,.dtL ehcoRaL nnamffoH

.F

.v

.cnI

negmA

:eR

8953-22001 YN ,kroY weN eunevA kraP 524 PLL relohcS eyaK .F samohT

gnimelF

ELIMISCAF & LIAM-E AIV 7002

,9 lirpA

moc.reebesa·yad @namhsifd )804(
7854-243

namhsiF .E harobeD

004 etiuS

,.dvlB keerC

0220-378 )804( :elimiscaF 0110-378 )804( :enohpeleT 41059 AC ,onitrepuC snevetS 00302

PLL

REDLEHCTAB & DIRDAM REEBESAC YAD
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 2 of 18

¸41

1_,7098t·

;lairetaM DNI/ALB l·,itnedifnoC sseccA detcirtseR
evitcetorP eht fo 4

ot

tcepser htiw redrO
eht htiw

hpargaraP

ni htrof tes

·-erudecorp

ylpmoc
ot

oT

)3(

;redrO evitcetorP ehtfo 01 dna 9 shpargaraP
ti ot
ssecca

tnausrup

evah ot dezirohtua nosrep rehtona naht rehto enoyna ot

redrO evitcetorP siht rednu lairetaM

yrevocsiD laitnedifnoC laever
smret eht

ot

toN

)2(

;redrO evitcetorP eht fo
:seerga

yb

dnuob eb oT

)I(

ybereh ,redrO

taht htiw ecnadrovca ni dna ,rettam siht ni

gnuoY

.G mailliW

elbaronoH ehtyb .·-._3( 0)a·

,·,

no

deussi redrO evitcetorP eht daer sah
ni dettimda si

dengisrednu ehT
eht ,yenrotta
na

.]snoitcidsiruj lta[
fI

dengisrednu

.]lesnuoc

edistuo
sa

yb

deniater tna.tlusnoc

ro

trepxe ,lesnuoc edistuo ,.g.e[..

·'k'-<·"·--P
evoba eht ni

noitagitil siht ni

devlovni si

dengisrednu

ehT .rettam

denoitpac

,].on[ ehcoRaL-namrfoH dna ,HbmG scitsongaiD

ehcoR ,LctL ehcoR aL-namffoH .F

stnadnefeD[

].cnI ,negmAffitnialP[ htiw detail·a

si ehs

ro

eh taht stneserper

dengisrednu ehT

REDRO EVITCETORP YB EDIBA OT TNEMEERGA

.stnadnefeD

,.CNI EHCOR AL -NNAMFFOH dna ,Hbm3( SCITSONGAID E'HCOR ,DTL EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F
YGW 73221 .riC 50 :.oN noitcA liviC

·itnialP
,,CNI NEGMA

STTgISUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU
A

TN·IMIFCA·TA
i·/z [nemucoU

lu

ul·"-I
1Z8-T

/UU·;:/U/·U QelI-I

Y3fW-73221-vc-50:1 esaC
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
IBM--LLAH REYOB ALCU-morF ma04:01 TOOZ-60-40

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 3 of 18

073-F

300/200,P

682T-6OZ-013

reyolpmE
emaN

:dct=D

.sesoprup rehto rof ti
o·

esu

,puoC eht

ro

,reilppuS

e·T morf deviecer si
lairetaM

noissimrep sselmL ,noitagitil
hcus
vsu

siht fo sesoprup rof

"ylelos

yrevocsiD laitnedifnoC

oT

,u ·

·l·J·'r
128lT

IUU·gIIUI·U O·llI-I

[nemuoou

Y·LW-73221-vc-50:1 esaC
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
IBM--LLAH REYOB ALCU-morF ma04:Ol TOOZ-GO-40

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 4 of 18

OT3-F

300/300.P

68ZT-602-013

selegnA
etutitsnI
etutitsnI

soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ygoloiB raluceloM ,rotceriD

1002-4991
4991 2991 8891

selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ygoloiB raluceloM ,rotceriD etaicossA selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ygoloiborciM fo tnemtrapeD ,namriahC selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ygoloiborciM fo tnemtrapeD ,rosseforP

2991

tneserp-6891
6891
2891

selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ygoloiborciM fo tnemtrapeD ,rosseforP etaicossA ygoloiborciM
selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU fo tnemtrapeD ,rosseforP tnatsissA

2891 8791

prahS .A pillihP .rD :rosivdA ygolonhceT fo etutitsnI sttesuhcassaM wolleF noitadnuoF yentihW yaH neleH

8791

7791

notyalC .A divaD .rD :rosivdA enicideM fo loohcS ytisrevinU drofnatS wolleF margorP gniniarT tsitneicS lacideM
ecneirepxE
ainrofilaC ,drofnatS ,enicideM fo loohcS ainrofilaC

6791

1791

lanoisseforP .D.M .B.A

ytisrevinU

drofnatS

6791
1791

,yelekreB ,yelekreB

ta ainrofilaC fo

ytisrevinU

noitacudE ainrofilaC

,selegnA

soL ,9491 rebmeceD 32
htriB fo ecalP dna etaD

EATIV MULUCIRRUC KREB .J DLONRA

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 5 of 18

2

htlaeH fo setutitsnI lanoitaN ,drawA tireM draoB weiveR cifitneicS etutitsnI lacideM secneicS dna strA fo

3002 5002-8991
8991

sehguH

drawoH

ymecadA

naciremA ,wolleF detcelE
Y

noitceS

ydutS

ygoloiB

raluceloM HIN

1002-7991

htlaeH fo setutitsnI lanoitaN ,drawA tireM

5991
7991-4991
4991

tnempoleveD

retneC dna hcraeseR recnaC kcirederF eht rof lenaP weiveR HIN drawA

selegnA soL ,ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ytlucaF s'ecneicS dna sretteL fo egelloC

noisiviD ainrofilaC ,yteicoS recnaC naciremA eettimmoC noitceleS larotcodtsoP ,riahC
noisiviD ainrofilaC ,yteicoS recnaC naciremA eettimmoC noitceleS pihswolleF larotcodtsoP htlaeH fo setutitsnI lanoitaN ,drawA tireM

5991-1991 5991-8891
7891 6891 2991 6891

ecnerefnoC nodroG sesuriV dna slleC laminA ,namriahC
hcraeseR sdicA cielcuN ,draoB lairotidE

yq.oloiB lleC raluceloM ,draoB lairotidE

2991 -6891

yq.oloriV ,rotidE
noitadnuoF ecneicS lanoitaN ,lenaP sciteneG
noisiviD ainrofilaC ,yteicoS recnaC naciremA eettimmoC noitceleS larotcodtsoP drawA hcraeseR

2991
8891 6891 6891

5891 4891 3891
1891 9791

ytlucaF yteicoS

recnaC naciremA

ecneicS lacideM lareneG fo etutitsnI lanoitaN rerutceL evuT evgyrT
wolleF

yentihW yaH

neleH

9791-6791 1791

yelekreB ,ainrofilaC

fo

ytisrevinU ,appaK

ateB ihP

sdrawA dna sronoH

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 6 of 18

3

5002 ,41 naJ seireS muiuqolloC hcraeseR ecneicS egelloC ni rekaepS ,secneicS dna sretteL fo egelloC ALCU secneicS efiL ,drawA s'naeD

5002

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 7 of 18

4

remogilo detanetac fo scimanyd
ni

dna selucelom

rethguad

.201-58 :0)11 .loiB .loM .J .noitamrof ralucric fo ygolopot :sllec-L
esuom

noitacilper

AND lairdnohcotim fo msinahceM .6791 .A.D

,notyalC

dna ,.J.A

,kreB

.6

.M dna tlawanaH .C .P

,noitaluq.eR

sti dna

sisehtnyS
na

AND

775-065 .pp ,).sde( muisopmyS :nI
no

nailuoG .sllec-L
esuom

ni

noitacilper

AND lairdnohcotim fo msinahceM .5791 .A.D

,notyalC

dna ,.J.A fo

,kreB

.5

.428-108 :68 .loiB .loM .J .ecneuqes noitaitini ni

fo revonrut dna

ygolopot
dna

stcepsa
esuom

,selucelom rethguad ralucric fo noitagerges ,sdnarts fo noitacilper suonorhcnysa :sllec-L

noitacilper

AND lairdnohcotim fo msinahceM .4791 .A.D

,notyalC

,.J.A ,kreB

.4

.mehC .loiB .J .dica
ni esanik

cielcunobiryxoed
enidimyht
tcnitsid

lairdnohcotim fo

gnilebal

yllaciteneg

A .3791 .A.D

.9272-2272 :842 evisulcxe :airdnohcotim nailammam dna .J.A ,kreB .3

,notyalC

.esanik

enidimyht cificeps-lairdnohcotiM
ANR
no

.565-365 :451 .cisyhpoiB .mehcoiB .hcrA .3791 .A.D ,notyalC dna ,.J.B ,reyeM ,.J.A ,kreB
.424 :62

enoretsodla fo tceffE .7691 .J.A ,kreB dna .A S

.corP .deF .yendik tar ni sisehtnys ,nalpaK ,.N.S.C ,uzimihS .1 sweiveR dna

srepaP hcraeseR

YN ,kroY weN ,.cnI ,nameerF .H .W .rJ ,llenraD semaJ dna ,yksrupiZ ecnerwaL .S ,ttocS .P wehttaM ,regeirK ytnoM ,resiaK .A sirhC ,ariadustaM luaP ,kreB dlonrA ,hsidoL yevraH .3002 .noitidE htfiF ,yq.oloiB lleC raluceloM
YN ,kroY weN ,.cnI ,nameerF .H .W .rJ ,llenraD semaJ dna ,eromitlaB divaD ,yksrupiZ ecnerwaL ,ariadustaM luaP ,kreB dlonrA ,hsidoL yevraH .9991 .noitidE htruoF ,yq.oloiB lleC raluceloM

.YN ,kroY weN ,.cnI ,nameerF .H .W .rJ ,llenraD semaJ dna ,ariadustaM luaP ,yksrupiZ ecnerwaL ,kreB dlonrA ,eromitlaB divaD ,hsidoL yevraH .5991 .noitidE drihT ,yq.oloiB lleC raluceloM skooB

YHPARGOILBIB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 8 of 18

a

gnippaM

.5831-1831 :87 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .snoitcnuf ylrae -erp surivoneda fo noisserpxe oviv ni rof deriuqer ecneuqes AND :retomorp citoyrakue .1891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.J.S ,tegreB ,.E ,effaJ-hcruB ,.E.R ,llehcS ,.F.T ,enrobsO .455-345 :8 .seR sdicA cielcuN .esaelcunoxe ralullec a yb noitsegid morf AND dednarts-elgnis stcetorp nietorp lanimret surivonedA .9791 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R ,llehcS ,.M ,enworB-htrowsnuD

.81

.71 .61

.surivoneda fo spam
no

noitpircsnarT

.9791 .M.S

,tegreB

.867-057 :56 .myznE sdohteM dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.A.P ,prahS

.pmyS
fo

robraH gnirpS dloC .sisehtnys sepytonehP .9791 .A.P .prahS

634-924:44 .loiB .tnauQ ANRm ylrae rof stnatum egnar tsoh 5 surivoneda dna ,.J ,smailliW ,.T ,nosirraH ,.F ,eeL ,.J.A ,kreB

.51

ylrae

fo

.495-185 .pp YN ,.cnI ,ssiL .R nalA .setoyrakuE ni noitalugeR eneG no muisopmyS ALCU-NCI .sisehtnys ANRm surivoneda noitalugeR .9791 .A.P .prahS dna .J ,smailliW ,.T ,nosirraH ,.J.A ,kreB ,.F ,eeL
.449-539 :71 lleC

.41

.sANR regnessem lariv ylrae fo gnissecorp dna noitpircsnart etaluger surivoneda ylrae-erP .9791 .A.P ,prahS dna .J ,smailliW ,.T ,nosirraH ,.F snevetS dna oradoT ,snoitcefnI lariV tnetsisreP
04 suriv naimis fo sANRm
no

stcudorp eneg 5 ,eeL ,.J.A ,kreB .31

muisopmyS

.444-134 .pp ).sde( ALCU-NCI .2 surivoneda dna

ylrae

eht ni

gnicilps

ANR .9791 .A.P

,prahS ,prahS ,prahS

dna

,.J.A ,kreB .21
.117

:41 lleC

.sANRm

ylrae

2 surivoneda eht fo erutcurtS .9791 .A.P

dna ,.J.A ,kreB

-596 .11

.8721-4721 :57 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .04 suriv naimis fo sANR regnessem

ylrae decilpS
no

.8791 .A.P

dna ,.J.A ,kreB

.corP .01

.925-325 :24 .loiB .tnauQ ni ANR raelcun '5 eht ta

.pmyS

robraH

gnirpS

dloC .sllec nailammam
.9

suoenegoreteh rof elor a :ANRm etal 2 surivoneda fo inimret stnemges decilpS .8791 .A.P ,prahS dna .T ,nosirraH ,.J.A ,kreB ,.M.S ,tegreB

leg yb

.237-127 :·:1 lleC sANRm surivoneda ylrae fo

.sdirbyh detsegid-esaelcunodne IS fo siserohportcele gnippam dna gniziS .7791 .A.P .prahS dna ,.J.A ,kreB
.55-54 :21 lleC

ylrae

2 surivoneda eht fo

gnippam

teloivartlU .7791 .A.P

,prahS

dna

.sretomorp ,.J.A ,kreB .7

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 9 of 18

AI

noiger ylrae

surivoneda fo

ycneiciffe

noitalsnarT .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L.K

,reldnipS

.23

.5031-3921 :4 .loiB .lleC .loM .seneg AIE surivoneda fo noitrop gnidoc-nietorp eht nihtiw noiger lortnoc noitpircsnarT .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna .M ,enworB-htrowsnuD ,.S.E ,uayT ,.N.D ,nosdivrA ,.F.T ,enrobsO .7283-1283 :21 .seR sdicA .lcuN .setis ecilps '5 ta UG devresnoc eht edistuo noitatum tniop a yb gnicilps ANRm fo noitanimilE .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C ,lletnoM lariv

.13

.03
.92

detargetni

na

fo noitavitca

nietorp

.0511-5411 :3 lanruoJ OBME .eneg AIE surivonedA .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.G ,siotruC

.279 -669 :4 .loiB .lleC .loM .setis ecilps ANR fo seitivitca eht ni tfihs a yb sisehtnys ANRm BIE surivoneda fo lortnoC .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.H.M ,srehturaC ,.F.E ,rehsiF ,.C ,lletnoM

.82 .72

yb
ro

noitamrofsnart

etelpmoC

.169-159 :63 lleC .snietorp AIE htob seriuqer 2 surivoneda .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C ,gnE ,.G ,siotruoC ,.C ,lletnoM

noitcefni

yb nietorp

.7911-3911 :18 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .noitcefsnart sllec nailammam otni decudortni eneg lariv-non a fo noitpircsnart setavitca AI noiger ylrae surivonedA .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.D ,namlliH ,.B.R ,ronyaG .141-231 :94 .loriV .J .lioc aihcirehcsE ni

.62

decudorp snegitna noisuf elbicudni ot aresitna htiw BI dna AI snoiger ylrae morf snietorp gnimrofsnart surivoneda fo sisylanA .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.E.S.D ,ressoR ,,R.K ,reldnipS
lleC

.52
.42

.noitpircsnart

surivoneda fo noitcudni

gnitca-siC

.396-386 :33 .3891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.B.R ,ronyaG

egavaelc

.406-006 :503 erutaN .AAAUAA ecneuqes susnesnoc '3 ANRm ni noitatum tniop a yb noitalynedaylop ton tub ANR fo noitibihnI .3891 .J.A ,kreB dna .H.M ,srehturaC ,.F.E ,rehsiF ,.C ,lletnoM

.32

ylrae
fo

.995-495 :54 .loriV .J .noitacilper AND lariv fo tesno eht retfa dezilitu era noitpircsnart AI noiger surivoneda rof setis noitaitini maertspu raF .3891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.F.T ,enrobsO

.22 .12

noisserpxe

.582-672 :44 .loriV .J .snietorp gnimrofsnart surivoneda decnahnE .2891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C ,lletnoM ,.A ,otomakusT ,.B.R ,ronyaG

.841-931 :92 lleC .snoitcnuf AIE surivoneda laitnesse fo noisserpxe rof deriuqer ton era ecneuqes detalsnartnu '5 ANRm eht dna ygolomoh A-T-A-T ehT .2891 .J.A ,kreB dna .B.R ,ronyaG ,.F.T ,enrobsO

.02

.483-083 :592 erutaN .etis ecilps ANRm a ta sisenegatum cificeps etis yb seneg lariv gnippalrevo fo snoitcnuf eht gnivloseR .2891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.H.M ,srehturaC ,.F.E ,rehsiF ,.C ,lletnoM

.91

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 10 of 18

.50151-89051 :262 .mehC .loiB .J .2CIIIFT rotcaf noitpircsnart namuh fo noitaziretcarahc dna seitreporp gnidnib-AND .7891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.K.S ,aganihsoY ,.A.P ,regnaluoB
AIE ni

.64 .54
.44

detacilpmi

.515-215 :623 erutaN .retomorp 2 surivoneda elpmis a fo noitavitca noitpircsnart xob-ATAT .7891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C.M ,tdimhcS ,.E.S.D ,ressoR ,.L ,uW

noitpircsnart

.9853-5853 :48 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .stnenopmoc lanoitcnuf owt otni CIIIFT rotcaf namuh fo noituloseR .7891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.A.P ,regnaluoB ,.K.S ,aganihsoY

.121-701 :651 .loriV sllec tnedor fo noitamrofsnart rof deriuqer era .noitcefsnart AND dna noitcefni lariv yb semarf gnidaer nepo BIE htob morf snietorp surivonedA .7891 .J.A ,kreB dna .D.D ,rekraB
.613 -213 :06 .loriV .J .snietorp AI noiger ylrae 2 epyt surivoneda ni niamod tnanimodonummi nA .6891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L.I ,namssieW ,.M ,grebnesoR ,.B ,nosugreF ,.A ,otomakusT

.34

.983-763 :5

syevruS

recnaC .AIE surivoneda fo snoitcnuF .6891 .J.A ,kreB
.97

-54 :02 .teneG .veR .nnA .noitavitcasnart AIE dna

sretomorp surivonedA .6891

.J.A

,kreB .04
.93 .83

etalpmet fo
a

.8485-4485 :38 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .stcartxe eerf-llec ni debircsnart selucelom rebmun eht sesaercni nietorp-AIE surivonedA .6891 .J.A ,kreB dna .K ,gnoeL fo

gnippam

.22-41 :95 .loriV .J .snietorp AIE 2 surivoneda ni noitalyrohpsohp fo etis rojam citeneG .6891 .B.R ,ronyaG dna .J.A ,kreB ,.A ,illecitnoP ,.A ,otomakusT

tnedneped-AIE

ni esaercni fo noitalumits

.453-343 :5 lanruoJ OBME .noitartnecnoc CIII rotcaf noitpircsnart na rof ecnedivE :1II esaremylop ANR yb noitpircsnart surivonedA .6891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.M ,naH ,.N ,naeD ,.S ,aganihsoY .054-744 :032 ecneicS .nietorp ylrae etaidemmi lariv yb detavitca noitpircsnarT .5891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.T.L ,namdleF ,.B.R ,ronyaG

.73

seneg III ssalc fo

.63

.3897-9797 :28 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .metsys detutitsnocer a ni retomorp etal rojam surivoneda eht morf noitpircsnart etarucca fo elbapac esaremylop ANR citoyrakue tnedneped -remirP .5891 .A ,atpugsaD dna .J.A ,kreB ,.D.C ,worroM ,.K ,gnoeL ,.G.L ,nikdarF
.057-247 :35 .loriV .J .sllec namuh detserra-htworg ni noitacilper AND lariv lamixam rof si nietorp AI noiger ylrae surivoneda nA .5891 .J.A ,kreB dna .C ,gnE ,.L.K

.53

deriuqer ,reldnipS

.43
.33

ylrae

5 surivoneda fo revonrut ralullecartni

dipaR

.017-607 :25 .loriV .J .snietorp AI noiger .4891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L.K ,reldnipS

.788-488 :15 .loriV .J

.noiger

detalsnartnu-'5 eht ni deteled sANRm

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 11 of 18

lanoitalsnart-tsop yb

srotcaf

noitpircsnart citayrakue

fo

noitalugeR

.9891 .J.A ,kreB

.16

.0594-1494 :9 .loiB .lleC .loM .eneg ANRr

S5 siveal suponeX eht ni ecneuqes euqinu a htiw stcaretni yllacificeps 2CIIIFT rotcaf noitpircsnart namuH .9891 .A ,atpugsaD dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.K.S ,aganihsoY ,.G.L ,nikdarF .06 namuh fo niamod

gnidnib

.0777-1677 :71 .seR sdicA cielcuN .2CIII rotcaf noitpircsnart AND A .9891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.D.N ,eliotE'L ,.A.P ,regnaluoB

.95
.85 .75 .65

noitpircsnart
:081

.9877-5877 :68 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .eneg rotcaf xob-ATAT tsaeY .9891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R ,ieP ,.C.C ,oaK ,.C.M ,tdimhcS

.yznE

sdohteM

.sisylana

IS

yb

.743-433 seluceloM ANR fo noitaziretcarahC .9891 .J.A ,kreB

.7033-9923 :9 .loiB .lleC .loM .rotcaf xob ATAT eht fo ytivitca gnidnib AND eht gnitceffa tuohtiw noitpircsnart setavitca lpS ,9891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.Q ,uohZ ,.C.M .tdimhcS
etaidem setis

gnidnib

.6053-9943 :36 .loriV .J .noitavitcasnart AIE surivoneda rotcaf noitpircsnart elpitluM .9891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R ,ieP

.55
.45

.13701-62701 :462 .mehC .loiB .J .2CIII rotcaf noitpircsnart fo noitaziretcarahc dna noitacifiruP .9891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.D.N ,eliotE'L ,.K.S ,aganihsoY

.7084-9974 :8 .loiB .lleC .loM .sllec namuh gniniatnoc-AIE elbicudni ni noitavitcasnart lanoitpircsnart fo ecnedneped noitartnecnoC .8891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.J.L ,tenurB

.35

.223-813 :761 .loriV .retomorp BIE 2 surivoneda eht ni tnemele xob ATAT eht seriuqer nietorp ylrae etaidemmi suriv seibaroduesp eht yb noitavitca lanoitpircsnarT .8891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L ,uW

.25
.15

noitpircsnart gnidnib
rotcaf

III ssalc fo

gnidnib retomorp

.5203-7103 :8 .loiB .lleC .loM .2CIIIFT dna ICIIIFT srotcaf eht gniredrO .8891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.N ,naeD

noitpircsnart

.114-304:2 .veD dna seneG .retomorp surivoneda elpmis a ni setis neewteb gnicaps no stniartsnoC .8891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L ,uW

.05

.4771-5671 :8 .loiB .lleC .loM .rotcaf noitpircsnart xob -ATAT eht htiw etanoitcarf sllec detcefni surivoneda fo stcartxe fo ytivitca lanoitpircsnart rehgih eht rof elbisnopser srotcaF .8891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L ,tenurB ,.K ,gnoeL

.94 .84

yb stnenopmoc

.7099-5989 :51 .seR sdicA cielcuN .yhpargotamorhc ytiniffa AND cificeps ecneuqes lanoitcnuf owt otni CIIIFT fo noitarapeS .7891 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.N ,naeD

.7883-0883 :7 .loiB .lleC .loM .srotcaf noitpircsnart cificeps fo noitavitcanI :surivoilop yb noitpircsnart detaidem-llI esaremylop ANR llec tsoh fo noitibihnI .7891 .A ,atpugsaD dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.S ,aganihsoY ,.G.L ,nikdarF

.74

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 12 of 18

.4542-1442
.47

:5 .veD dna seneG .noitcaretni nietorp-nietorp tcerid yb AND retomorp htiw noitaicossa DIIFT sezilibats nietorp rotavitca-snart atZ ehT .1991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.M .P ,namrebeiL

.673-563 :76 lleC .rotcaf noitpircsnart xob ATAT eht ni taeper cisab eht sdnib niamod noitavitca A1E surivonedA .1991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.X ,uiL ,.O.G ,tnayrB ,.C.C ,oaK ,.S.W ,eeL
susrev eno

.37
.27

.11402-60402 :662 .mehC .loiB .J .setis gnidnib lpS owt fo stniartsnoc ecnatsid dna ytivitca retomorP .1991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.R ,lageS

.0132-5032 :01 .J OBME .tcartxe raelcun llec aLeH morf AII rotcaf noitpircsnart fo noitacifirup ytiniffA .1991 .H ,adnaH dna ,.J·A ,kreB ,.A ,atobuK ,.Y ,adusU

.17

.2581-3481 :01 .J .OBME .DIIFT eaisiverec .S fo niamod devresnoc eht ot lanimret-N yletaidemmi seudiser dica onima cidica rof tnemeriuqeR .1991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.C .M ,tdimhcS ,.Q ,uohZ

.07

.47-36:11 .loiB .lleC .loM .egnahc lanoitamrofnoc decudni-xob ATAT a rof ecnedive dna Dil rotcaf noitpircsnart tsaey eht ni sniamod tcnitsid owT .1991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C.C ,oaK ,.C.M ,tdimhcS ,,M.P ,namrebeiL .418-608 :971 ,ygoloriV .snietorp K 55 BIE 2 surivoneda eht dna 35p ralullec eht neewteb noitaicossa ortiv ni rof deriuqer sniamoD .0991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R.P ,weY ,.C.C ,oaK

.96
.86

.sisenegatum

.508-597 :971 ygoloriV noitresni-reknil rosserppus yb editpepylop K 55 BI ylrae 2 surivoneda eht ni sniamod lanoitcnuf fo noitcessiD .0991 J.A ,kreB dna ,.C.C ,oaK ,.R.P ,weY .0561
a

.76

-6461 :842 ecneicS .rotcaf gnidnib ATAT namuh evitca .0991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R ,ieP ,.Q ,uohZ ,.C.M ,tdimhcS

yllanoitpircsnart

fo

gninolC

,.M.P ,namrebeiL ,.C.C ,oaK .66

noitavitca

.3154-9054 :78 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .Dil rotcaf noitpircsnart nailammam rof tnemeriuqer cificeps :rotaitini ro ATAT hguorht detcerid sa lpS yb .0991 .D ,eromitlaB dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.C.M ,tdimhcS ,.T.S ,elamS

lanoitpircsnarT

.56

.8652-0652 :46 .loriV .J dna noitaziremid ,noitavitca

.nietorp atZ suriv rraB-nietspE eht fo yticificeps gnidnib AND lanoitpircsnart ortiv nI .0991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.M.P ,namrebeiL
.551-151 :4

.46

.veD dna seneG ?krow srotcaf

noitpircsnart

od woH .0991 .C.M

,tdimhcS dna ,.J.A ,kreB .36

.06-15 :46 .loriV .J .srotcaf cificeps esahp etal rof setis gnidnib maertsnwod seriuqer retomorp etal rojam surivoneda eht morf noitpircsnart level hgiH .0991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.W ,eeL ,.K ,gnoeL

.26

.901-301 :9001 atcA

acisyhpoiB

acimehcoiB .noitacifidom

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 13 of 18

01

,maharG ,.A ,tteB ,.H.W ,edirBcM ,.F.D ,eetnlcM ,.M ,eerB

nav

,.E.K ,nazarD ,.E.M ,etesC .78

xelpmoc AND retomorp-AIIFT-DIIFT fo tnemecnahne niamod lanoitpircsnart ni sFAT rof msinahcem A .4991 .J.A ,kreB

.6001-599 :8 .veD dna seneG .noitamrof noitavitca :noitavitca dna ,.M.P ,namrebeiL

.68

.ltaN .corP fo noiger

.nietorp gnidnib-xob regnif cniz ehT .4991

.2942-8842:19 ASU .icS .dacA ATAT eht htiw sexelpmoc niamod gnitavitcasnart A1E eht .P.R ,idraicciR dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.S.W ,eeL ,.V.J ,grebsieG

.58 .48 .38

.6561-2561 :19 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .tinubus gnidnib-B xob CIIIFT namuH .4991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.R ,dlosrebeA ,.Y ,nehS ,.L.M ,kcotsenhaF ,.D.N ,eliotE'L
a

.202-091 :8 .veD dna seneG .35p ot niamod noisserper lanoitpircsnart srehtet nietorpocno B1E surivonedA .4991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.X ,uiL ,.R.P ,weY ·914-214 :563 erutaN .Bk-FN yb noitavitca lanoitpircsnart setaidem nietorp dna leR nietorpocno-otorp neewteb noitaicossA .3991 .M.I ,amreV dna

gnidnib-ATAT

,.J.A ,kreB ,.Q ,uohZ ,.J.T ,reyoB ,.J.M ,ttimhcS ,.P ,yelsmaW ,.J.L ,enosnaR ,.D.L ,rreK

.28 .18

.3281-0181 :7 .veD & seneG .DIIFT -oloh htiw A1E surivoneda fo snoitcaretni lanoitcnuF .3991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.G.T ,reyoB

.0033-1923 :31 .loiB .lleC .loM .noitpircsnart stibihni niamod 35p gnirobhgien a dna DIIFT-oloh ni editpepylop gnidnib xob-ATAT eht sdnib niamod noitavitca 35p .3991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.H.P ,relffeoK ,.W.C ,relliM ,.X ,uiL

.08

.781-081 :7 .veD & seneG .niamod eroc devresnoc nietorp gnidnib xob-ATAT htiw tcaretni noitpircsnart detavitca rof deriuqer )sFAT( srotcaF .3991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.G .T ,reyoB ,.Q ,uohZ

.97

.7321-2321 :31 .loiB .lleC .loM .ortiv ni dna oviv ni C3 esaetorp surivoilop yb nietorp gnidnib-ATAT namuh fo egavaelc tceriD .3991 .A ,atpugsaD dna ,.J .A ,kreB ,.M .P ,namrebeiL ,,E.M ,kralC
.247-727 .pp ,kroY

.87

weN ,robraH gnirpS dloC ,sserP robraH gnirpS dloC ,.sde ,thginKcM .L .S dna otomamaY .R .K ,noitaluq.eR lanoitpircsnarT nI .noitcnuf srotcaf noitpircsnart lareneg eht woh gninrael eriuqer lliw ti gnidnatsrednU :noitavitcasnart A1E surivonedA .2991 .J .A ,kreB
.4791-4691 :6 .veD

.77

& seneG .retomorp ssel-ATAT a morf dna srotavitca esrevid yb noitalumits lanoitpircsnart stroppus DIIFT-oloH .2991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.G .T ,reyoB ,.M .P ,namrebeiL ,.Q ,uohZ .67 rof

deriuqer

.58-28 ,753 erutaN .nietorp B 1 ylrae surivoneda yb noitamrofsnart noitavitcasnart 35p fo noitibihnI .2991 .J .A ,kreB dna .R .P ,weY

.57

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 14 of 18

.6601-9501 :311 yregruS ralucsavoidraC dna cicarohT .J .noitcudsnart detaidem dohtem :stfargolla caidrac ot senikotyc evisserppusonummi -surivoneda fo ycaciffe dna fo refsnart eneg yranorocartnI .7991 .L .J ,gnaW dna ,,rJ ,.C .D ,retawknirD ,.A ,kreB ,.O ,stravhS ,.F ,llohcS ,.M ,amayonoN ,.H ,skaL ,.L ,uW ,.R ,renuarB
.99 .89

tnerruC
.oviv ni

.]lairotide[ noisserpxe

.903-703 :9 .loiB lleC ni noinipO eneg dna suelcuN .7991 ,.W.I ,jattaM dna ,.A ,kreB

.4052-1942 :01 .veD dna seneG

noitpircsnart detavitca rof deriuqer secafrus nietorp gnidnib xob-ATAT slaever sisenegatum lacidaR .6991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.K .S ,yelruB ,.S .L ,letraM ,.O .G ,tnayrB

.79
.69

.452-932 :162 .loiB .loM .J .xob ATAT eht ezingocer snietorp woH .6991 .E ,R ,nosrekciD dna ,.J .A ,kreB ,.I ,volakiaB ,.M .P ,namrebieL ,.K .T ,uihC ,.S .Z ,ouJ

gnidnib

.1714-3614 :61 .loiB .lleC .loM .esaetorp C3 surivoilop htiw noitcessid yb delaever CIII rotcaf noitpircsnart fo snoitcaretni tinubus dna niamod AND ehT .6991 .A ,atpugsaD dna .J .A ,kreB ,.P ,ilihcnamalaY ,.M ,ogI ,.Y ,nehS

.59
.49

.dacA .ltaN .corP .5991

.emyzneoloh

eht ni

sciteneg

steem

yrtsimehcoiB

.45911-25911:29 ASU .icS .5991 .J .A ,kreB

.86811-46811 :29 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP .gnidnib xob-ATAT ni evitcefed DIIFT rotcaf noitpircsnart tnatum a fo noitcnuf cificeps-retomorp eroC .5991 .G .R ,redeoR dna ,.J .A ,kreB ,.T ,regalhcsegleO ,.D .N ,eliotE'L ,.Q ,uohZ ,.E ,zenitraM

.39

.ylbmessA xelpmoC
DIIFT dna BIIFT htob

.3746-5646 :51 .loiB .lleC .loM retomorP-DIIFT-AIIFT setalumitS dna AIIFT htiw yltceriD stcaretnI sniamoD noitavitcA fo ssalC A .5991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.G .T ,reyoB ,.N ,ihsayaboK

.29 .19

yb gnihcleuqS 35p

.8746-4746 :51 .loiB .lleC .loM ortiV nI fo lasreveR .5991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.X ,uiL

enisoryt

.997-197:11 enegocnO .esanik raelcun lbA-c eht yb noisserppus htworg tnedneped 35p .5991 .L .C ,sreywaS dna ,.N .O ,ettiW ,.J .A ,kreB ,.K ,lahceneS ,.M .T ,hcubmaH ,.X ,uiL ,.A ,agoG
a

.09

.935-435 :51 .loiB .lleC .loM .xelpmoc DIIFT lanoitcnuf sFAT namuh htiw selbmessa niamod eroc PBT tsaeY .5991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.Q

otni

,uohZ .98

.1151-8051:75 noitatnalpsnarT .stfarg revil cienegnys ni ANDc derrefsnart fo noisserpxe lufsseccuS :1I traP .gnittes tnalpsnart eht ni refsnart eneg detaidem-surivonedA .4991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.W.R ,littusuB ,.L ,uW ,.E.K ,nazarD ,.E.M ,etesC ,.A ,dekahS .7051-2051 :75 noitatnalpsnarT .setycotapeh devreserp dloc ni seneg derrefsnart fo noisserpxe rof snoitidnoC :I traP .gnittes tnalpsnart eht ni refsnart eneg detaidem-surivonedA .4991 .A ,dekahS dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.W.R ,littusuB ,.L.F

.88

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 15 of 18

2]

,obaK .M.J ,eeL .P.Y ,retsilIAcM .P ,uW .L ,nosnevetS .S ,iksiulaD .A ,.R.J ,namrebeiL .211
rof

stnemeriuqeR tnednepeD-

.4435-3335 :37 .loriV .J .noitacilpeR 5 surivonedA ni K55-B1E dna tnednepedn1-35p .9991 .kreB .J .A dna ,.N .J ,adaraH .111
II

lleC ni

noinipO tnerruC .noitpircsnarT

esaremyloP

.533-033 "11 ygoloiB ANR fo noitavitcA .9991 .J .A ,kreB .011

.197-587 :6 yparehT eneG .slaminA gniviL ni eneG retropeR a sa rotpeceR 2D enimapoD eht fo gnigami evisavni -noN ,evititepeR .9991 .namhcsreH .R.H dna ,splehP .E.M ,yrrehC .R.S ,kreB .J.A ,uW .L ,imukoyoT .T ,nietsfrahS .S ,oirraB .R.J ,yhtrumaytaS .N ,rihbmaG .S.S ,.C.D ,neraLcaM

.901

.972-672 :993 erutaN .nietorp A1E surivoneda nailammaM .9991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.P.R ,idraicciR
.4143-3043 :91 .loiB .lleC .loM

yb detegrat

si

xelpmoc rotaideM/BRS

,.E ,seeL ,.D.E.M ,nitraM ,.G.T ,reyoB .801

-000,55 B1E surivonedA rof deriuqer rosserperoC .9991 .J.A ,kreB dna .D .E .M ,nitraM .701
.8332-3332 :69 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP

.noitpircsnart lasab fo noisserper nietorp thgiew ralucelom

.yhpargomot

noissime

gnivil ni noisserpxe eneg retroper detcerid-larivoneda gnigamI .9991 .R .H ,namhcsreH dna ,.R .S ,yrrehC ,.J .A ,kreB ,.K ,neyugN ,.C .D ,neraLcaM ,.E ,reuaB ,.A .L ,neerG ,.L ,uW ,,N ,yhtrumaytaS ,.M ,iravamaN ,.M ,reyl ,.E .M ,splehP ,.R .J ,oirraB ,.S .S ,rihbmaG .601
.252-342 :36 ygoloiB evitatitnauQ no muisopmyS robraH gnirpS dloC .srotavitcA lariV fo smsinahceM .8991 .grebnezeirT .J.S dna ,ybruS .A.M ,pooK .R ,navilluS .M.S ,nroH .J,P ,ihsayaboK .N.N ,thgirbE .E.R ,sidinapaK .N.A ,reyoB .G.T ,.J.A ,kreB .501

nortisop

htiw slamina

.1102-3002 :93 .deM .lcuN

.J .rivolcicnag htiw ecim ni noisserpxe eneg retroper esanik enidimyht 1 epyt suriv xelpmis sepreh detcerid larivoneda fo gnigamI .8991 .R.H ,namhcsreH dna ,.E.M ,splehP ,.R.S ,yrrehC ,.J.A ,kreB ,.S ,nietsfrahS ,.A.L ,neerG ,.E ,reuaB ,.R.A ,iehgroB ,.C.D ,neraLcaM ,.C ,hsirraP ,.N ,yhtrumaytaS ,.M ,iravamaN ,.M ,reyl ,.L ,uW ,.R.J ,oirraB ,.S.S ,rihbmaG

.401

.933-033 ".61 .seR .pohtrO .J .stnedor ni noitamrof enob ciportoreteh secudni enil llec lamorts enirum gnicudorp 2-PMB a htiw ypareht eneg lanoigeR .8991 .nosnevetS .S dna ,ettiW .N.O ,kreB .A ,namreniF .M.A.G ,uW .L ,eeL .Q.L ,.R.J ,namrebeiL .301 .1304-3204 :81 .loiB .lleC .loM .noitavitcA lanoitpircsnarT C61PV rof deriuqeR ytivitcA ylbmessA xelpmoC-AD .8991 .kreB .J .A dna ,reyoB .G.T ,grebnezeirT .J.S ,navilluS .M.S ,nroH .J.P ,.N ,ihsayaboK .201
oslA PBT III nI
no

)loP( esaremyloP

.0071-2961 :81 .loiB .lleC .loM .noitpircsnarT II loP detavitcA rof deriuqeR ecafruS a ot sdniB frB rotcaF detaicossA-)PBT( nietorP gnidniB-xoB ATAT .8991 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.O.G ,tnayrB ,.G ,sitevassaK .Y ,nehS .101 .4513-6413 :27 .loriV .J .ortiV K55 B1E surivonedA .8991 .J .A ,kreB dna ,.D.E.M ,nitraM .001

noitavitcA-35p sesserpeR

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 16 of 18

kcuT ,QJ purtsjevS ,K lhurtS ,R hcirtS ,J D namllitS ,WP grebnretS ,M ikzcipiS ,H iarukaS ,I ikswodaS ,H ennoR ,D grebnieR ,M enhsatP ,DJ nivraP ,K htymsaN ,MA raaN ,M tsenreretsieM ,TJ siL ,A ztueL ,L saruK ,J Y miK ,AJ gninheaJ ,CF egetsloH ,S grebmloH ,GA hcsubenniH ,KP namreH ,X eH ,M naH ,MC nossfatsuG ,T awasakuF ,PL namdeerF ,DJ llednoF ,WS snommE ,CR yawanoC ,WJ yawanoC ,M noslraC ,M yeraC ,T eferggroB ,KT llewkcalB ,S dnulkrojB ,J A kreB ,J F sairutsA ,ZA irasnA ,A areliugA ,MH nobruoB .421
.80021-30021 :001 ASU .icS .dacA .l'taN .corP .AND retomorp no ylbmessa xelpmoc noitaitini-erp noitpircsnart etomorp snoitcaretni rotaidem-niamod noitavitcA .3002 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.L.J ,snevetS ,.T .G ,nitnaC .321

.4215-5115 :22 .J OBME .1II dna II sesaremylop ANR yb noitpircsnart rof PBT no etis nommoc .A.G sitevassaK ,.J.A kreB ,.P.E kehcsudieG ,.O.G tnayrB ,.O redorhcS .221
A

.)3002(

.119-509 :A-58 .mA .gruS tnioJ enoB .J .star ni noisuf lanips no sllec worram enob gnicudorp-2-nietorp citenegohprom enob htiw ypareht eneg lanoiger fo tceffE .3002 .R.J namrebeiL ,.J.A kreB ,.A.P llebpmaC ,.S ooY ,.E.L minaK ,.C.J gnaW .121 .6029-4919 :67 .loriV .J .yrenihcaM noitanituqibU ot kniL stI slaeveR emoetorP derohcnA K55-B1E surivonedA eht fo sisylanA nA .2002 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.C.D ,sallaP ,.A ,oknehcvehS ,.A ,oknehcvehS ,.N.J ,adaraH .021

.6029-4919:67
.loriV .J .slleC demrofsnarT- dna detcefnl-surivonedA ni xelpmoC rotaideM namuH eht htiw nietorP A1E egraL surivonedA fo noitaicossA oviv nI .2002 .J.A ,kreB dna .G ,gnaW .911
.857-557 :692 ecneicS .tinubuS rotaideM 2ruS aiv yawhtaP esaniK PAM dna A1E yb lortnoC noitpircsnarT .2002 .kreB .J .A dna ,oknehcvehS .A ,oknehcvehS .A ,gnaW .G ,nitnaC .T.G ,.L.J ,snevetS .811 .8972-8872 :22 .loiB .lleC .loM .slleC nailammaM ni noitpircsnarT detavitcA rof deriuqeR erA snoitcaretnI PBT-FAT tahT ecnedivE .2002 .kreB .J.A dna ,nworB .J.H ,.S.L .letraM .711 YN ,kroY weN ,sserP cimedacA ,relliM .H yerffeJ dna rennerB yendyS .sdE ,sciteneG fo aidepolcycnE nI .srotcaF noitaitinI ;sexoB ssengoH ;sesurivonedA .1002 .J .A ,kreB .611 .3164-4064 :12 .loiB .lleC .loM .tcartxE raelcuN lleC aLeH morf rotaideM fo noitaziretcarahC .1002 .kreB .J .A dna ,snevetS .L .J ,nitnaC .T .G

sexelpmoC ,.G ,gnaW

.511

.8-5 :201 lleC .sucoF otni emoC srotcaF ekil-PBT .0002 .J .A ,kreB .411 rotceV
.9857-2857 :37 .loriV .J .ycneiciffE hgiH htiw slleC derutluC smrofsnarT ylbatS taht dirbyH suriV rraB-nietspE-surivonedA nA .9991 .kreB .J .A dna ,uW .L ,.T .B ,naT .311

fo

yparehT

eneG

.719-509 :18 yregruS tnioJ dna enoB .J .staR ni stcefeD laromeF latnemgeS riapeR eht no slleC worraM-enoB gnicudorP 2-nietorP citnegohproM enoB htiw lanoigeR fo tceffE ehT .9991 .ettiW .N.O dna ,kreB .J.A ,namreniF .M.A.G

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 17 of 18

41

etal lariv setalumits

]elcitra thgiltopS[ .785-575:18 ,.loriV .J .tropxe esagil nietorp-nitiuqibu surivonedA .7002 .JA

raelcun ANRm kreB ,LJ ,ooW .131
.snoruen

.64-539:02 .J BESAF

cigrenimapod niarbdim fo ssol eht sesaercni ecim tluda ni RhCAn *4ahpla evitisnesrepyh fo noisserpxe decnahnE .6002 .AH retseL ,J A kreB ,SJ liG ,P ednaphseD ,C acrabaL ,F rengeW ,A reztutS ,O ogiroD ,CS zrawhcS ,J zrawhcS
]elcitra thgiltopS[
.61-40041:97 .loriV J eht

.031

stiolpxe surivonedA

.xelpmoc NRM eht etavitcani ot esnopser emosergga ralullec .5002 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.A ,oknehcvehS ,.A ,oknehcvehS ,.Y ,uiL .921

.1923-1823 :231 tnempoleveD .noitazinagro ranimal stceffa dna noitaitnereffid erutamerp ot sdael ailg nnamgreB ni noiteled NETP .5002 .X ,uiL ,.H ,uW ,.A gnisseM ,.J.A ,kreB ,.S.J liG ,.M rezsorG ,.Q ,euY .821
:71 lleC .loM lhurtS .K yb tnemmoC( .496-386 :71 lleC raluceloM .noitaitinI noitpircsnarT ni spetS tnemtiurceR-tsoP dna tnemtiurceR htoB rof tnemeriuqeR rotaideM .5002 .J.A ,kreB dna ,.H ,adnaH ,.H ,ihcugamaY ,.L.J ,snevetS ,.A.M ,sitomalaB ,.G ,gnaW .721 .00921-88821 :87 .loriV .J .1 rof 2ruS rof tnemeriuqeR .4002 .R.K

).457-257

epyT surivonedA esuoM fo noitacilpeR tneiciffE ,reldnipS dna ,.J.A ,kreB ,.L.J ,snevetS ,.L ,gnaF .621
.6656

-6556 :87 .loriV .J .sllec nailammam fo noitamrofsnart elbats eht rof rotcev dirbyh suriv rraB nietspE-surivoneda tnedneped-repleh levon a fo tnempoleveD .4002 .kreB .J.A dna

,solaC .P.M ,nietsnewoL .R.P ,ortsaC .G.M ,naT .T.B ,rehallaG .D.S ,liG .S.J ,.O ,ogiroD .521
.755-355 :41 4002 .lleC loM fo stinubus
.1I esaremylop ANR ot srotaluger lanoitpircsnart gniknil sexelpmoc rotaidem nietorp rof erutalcnemon deifinu A .DR grebnroK ,GR redeoR ,F notsniW ,S

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 782-5

Filed 07/30/2007

Page 18 of 18