Fix et al v. Hajjar et al
Filing
1
COMPLAINT with Jury Demand against All Defendants Filing fee: $ 350, receipt number 0101-3711684 (Fee Status: Filing Fee paid), filed by Katie L Boltas, Denise R Fix. (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet Civil Cover Sheet, # 2 Category Sheet, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit Exhibit K-1, # 14 Exhibit Exhibit K-2, # 15 Exhibit Exhibit K-3)(Lewis, Katherine)
!"#$%&'()"*&+#,-./."0-&
!"#$%&'()"*&+#,-./."0-&
!10"#-00&23(#&
!10"#-00&23(#&
4556&
4556&
!
"#$%&!'()!*+&$,!-+,.!
78&981#:-.0;&&7<-.%3&=(>>(.&?&@-#"0-&A&9"B&
7.-(,"C-&D.",-.;&&EF%&2-..-(13,&
!10"#-00&G1//8.,;&&H(.(&I%&A8:)-.0&
EXHIBIT E
!"#$%&'#(%)*%(+,-./''0'#(,
1%#2+,3).%4,5#('/6/%7',
!"# $%# &'()*%"++(# ,'(# ,-*))(# "+# ".,"# ".)# /)0+1# ($%20+%)*# +3# 2+'3$()'"$,0# $'3+*4,"$+'# 4,5# 6*+7$()# 2)*",$'# $'3+*4,"$+'# ".,"# $%# ,'(# 4&%"# /)# 8)6"#
2+'3$()'"$,09##:+#)'%&*)#".)#6*+")2"$+'#+3#%&2.#$'3+*4,"$+';#,'(#"+#6*)%)*7)#,'5#2+'3$()'"$,0$"5#')2)%%,*5#&'()*#6,")'"#,'(<+*#"*,()#%)2*)"#0,1%;#$"#
$%#,-*))(#".,"#
=9#
:.)#>+'3$()'"$,0#!'3+*4,"$+'#"+#/)#($%20+%)(#2,'#/)#()%2*$/)(#,%#,'(#$'20&()%?#
!'7)'"$+'#()%2*$6"$+'@%A;#")2.'$2,0#,'(#/&%$')%%#$'3+*4,"$+'#*)0,"$'-#"+#6*+6*$)",*5#$(),%#,'(#$'7)'"$+'%;#$(),%;#6,")'",/0)#$(),%;#
"*,()#%)2*)"%;#(*,1$'-%#,'(<+*#$00&%"*,"$+'%;#6,")'"#%),*2.)%;#)B$%"$'-#,'(<+*#2+'")460,")(#6*+(&2"%#,'(#%)*7$2)%;#*)%),*2.#,'(#
()7)0+64)'";#6*+(&2"$+';#2+%"%;#6*+3$"#,'(#4,*-$'#$'3+*4,"$+';#3$','2)%#,'(#3$','2$,0#6*+C)2"$+'%;#2&%"+4)*%;#20$)'"%;#4,*8)"$'-;#
,'(# 2&**)'"# +*# 3&"&*)# /&%$')%%# 60,'%# ,'(# 4+()0%;# *)-,*(0)%%# +3# 1.)".)*# %&2.# $'3+*4,"$+'# $%# ()%$-',")(# ,%# D>+'3$()'"$,0#
!'3+*4,"$+'E#,"#".)#"$4)#+3#$"%#($%20+%&*)9#
##
:.)# F)2$6$)'"# %.,00# 0$4$"# ($%20+%&*)# +3# >+'3$()'"$,0# !'3+*4,"$+'# 1$".$'# $"%# +1'# +*-,'$G,"$+'# "+# $"%# ($*)2"+*%;# +33$2)*%;# 6,*"')*%;# 4)4/)*%;#
)460+5))%#,'(<+*#$'()6)'()'"#2+'"*,2"%#@2+00)2"$7)05#*)3)**)(#"+#,%#D,33$0$,")%EA#.,7$'-#,#'))(#"+#8'+19##:.)#F)2$6$)'"#,'(#,33$0$,")%#
1$00#'+"#($%20+%)#".)#2+'3$()'"$,0#$'3+*4,"$+'#+/",$')(#3*+4#".)#($%20+%)*#&'0)%%#*)H&$*)(#"+#(+#%+#/5#0,19#
#
:.$%# I-*))4)'"# $46+%)%# '+# +/0$-,"$+'# &6+'# F)2$6$)'"# 1$".# *)%6)2"# "+# ,'5# >+'3$()'"$,0# !'3+*4,"$+'# @,A# ".,"# 1,%# $'# F)2$6$)'"J%# 6+%%)%%$+'#
/)3+*)#*)2)$6"#3*+4#K$%20+%)*L#@/A#$%#+*#/)2+4)%#,#4,"")*#+3#6&/0$2#8'+10)(-)#".*+&-.#'+#3,&0"#+3#F)2$6$)'"L#@2A#$%#*$-."3&005#*)2)$7)(#
/5#F)2$6$)'"#3*+4#,#".$*(#6,*"5#'+"#+1$'-#,#(&"5#+3#2+'3$()'"$,0$"5#"+#".)#K$%20+%)*L#@(A#$%#($%20+%)(#1$".+&"#,#(&"5#+3#2+'3$()'"$,0$"5#
"+#,#".$*(#6,*"5#/5;#+*#1$".#".)#,&".+*$G,"$+'#+3;#K$%20+%)*L#+*#@)A#$%#$'()6)'()'"05#()*$7)(#/5#F)2$6$)'"9#
#
:.$%# I-*))4)'"# %",")%# ".)# )'"$*)# ,-*))4)'"# /)"1))'# ".)# 6,*"$)%# 2+'2)*'$'-# ".)# ($%20+%&*)# +3# >+'3$()'"$,0# !'3+*4,"$+'9# # I'5# ,(($"$+'# +*#
4+($3$2,"$+'#"+#".$%#I-*))4)'"#4&%"#/)#4,()#$'#1*$"$'-#,'(#%$-')(#/5#".)#6,*"$)%9#
I0".+&-.#".$%#I-*))4)'"#4,5#/)#%$-')(#/5#".)#F)2$6$)'"#6*$+*#"+#%$-',"&*)#/5#K$%20+%)*;#".)#+/0$-,"$+'%#.)*)$'#1$00#/)2+4)#)33)2"$7)#+'05#&6+'#
".)#F)2$6$)'"#*)2)$7$'-#,#%$-')(#2+65#+3#".)#I-*))4)'"9#
!3# ,'5# +3# ".)# 6*+7$%$+'%# +3# ".$%# I-*))4)'"# ,*)# 3+&'(# "+# /)# &')'3+*2),/0);# ".)# *)4,$'()*# %.,00# /)# )'3+*2)(# ,%# 3&005# ,%# 6+%%$/0)# ,'(# ".)#
&')'3+*2),/0)#6*+7$%$+'@%A#%.,00#/)#())4)(#4+($3$)(#"+#".)#0$4$")(#)B")'"#*)H&$*)(#"+#6)*4$"#)'3+*2)4)'"#+3#".)#I-*))4)'"#,%#,#
1.+0)9#
!"#$#%&$#'( )*+( ,-.)/+0( -123456+78+( )*-)( )*+9( *-:+( .+-7( -37( ;37+.0)-37( )*/0( <8.++=+3)( -37( :46;3)-./69( -11+,)( )*+( 7;)/+0( -37(
4>6/8-)/430(0+)(?4.)*(*+.+/3@(
$+1/,/+3)(4?(A43?/7+3)/-6(B3?4.=-)/43C(
#
M,4)#@N*$'"A?#
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO#
#
P$-',"&*)?##
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO#
#
K,")?#
#
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO#
D/01640+.(4?(A43?/7+3)/-6(B3?4.=-)/43C#
#
M,4)?#
#
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO#
#
#
#
!"#"$%&'()*+%#,'-"./$0+10)#2'
'
30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'80&&'+$)90:"'"#1"$1%0#*"#1';)$'/<0&:$"#'1<$)=6<'#=$."$,'$<,*".'
%#:' .1)$,>))4.' "#/)*+%..0#6' &0;"' .40&&.' .=/<' %.' %//"+10#6' )1<"$.?' 1%40#6' /%$"' );' )=$'
+&%#"1'%#:'1)&"$%#/"';)$')1<"$.':0;;"$"#/".'0#')=$':09"$."'.)/0"1,@'
'
50..0)#'A1%1"*"#12''
B<"'30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'*0..0)#'0.'1)'>$0#6'>%/4'1<"'*%60/'0#1)')=$'/<0&:$"#C.'&09".'
>,';)/=.0#6')#'.)#6.'%#:'.1)$0".'"#/)*+%..0#6'*)$%&':"9"&)+*"#1'%#:'1"%/<0#6'1<"*'
1)'$".+"/1'1<"*."&9".?')1<"$.'%#:'#%1=$"@'
'
3=.0#"..'D<0&).)+<,2'
3=.0#"..'D<0&).)+<,2'
7#$0/<0#6'1<"'&09".');'/<0&:$"#'0#')$:"$'1)'+).0109"&,'0*+%/1'1<"';=1=$"');')=$'.)/0"1,@'
'
B%$6"1'*%$4"12''
B%$6"1'*%$4"12''
B<"'+)..0>0&010".'%$"'"#:&"..@''E#,)#"'1<%1'/)*".'0#1)'/)#1%/1'801<'/<0&:$"#@''F1'.1%$1.'%1'
<)*"' 801<' +%$"#1.' 1<"#' >$%/<".' )=1' 1)' .)/0"1,' 8<"1<"$' 01' 0.' %1' ./<))&?' :%,/%$"?'
&0>$%$0".?')$'<).+01%&.@'''
!"
!"
!"#:"$'G'3)1<'
!"
J)/%10)#'G'EJJ'
!"
F#/)*"'&"9"&'G'EJJ'
!"
A)/0%&'/&%..'%#:')//=+%10)#'G'EJJ'
!"
'
E6"'G'H'1)'I',"%$'
7:=/%10)#'G'EJJ'
F#:=.1$,'
F#:=.1$,'
'
F1C.' %' .%:' ;%/1' 1<%1' /<0&:$"#' .+"#:' ;%$' 1))' *=/<' 10*"' 8%1/<0#6' BK?' -K-.' )$' +&%,0#6'
90:")' 6%*".' L' %#:' %' .1=:,' .=66".1.' 1<%1' %#' %&%$*0#6' #=*>"$' );' >%>0".' %$"' >"0#6'
1=$#":' 0#1)' M./$""#' 10*"M' N=#40".' %.' 8"&&@' ' ' D%$"#1.' %$"' #%1=$%&&,' %#O0)=.' %>)=1' 1<"0$'
/<0&:$"#C.'8"&;%$"'%#:';=1=$".?'%'*%$4"1'1<%1'>%$"&,'"O0.1":'%'6"#"$%10)#'%6)'LL'0.'#)8'%'
*=&10L>0&&0)#':)&&%$'0#:=.1$,@'
'
F#'%'.1=:,');'*)$"'1<%#'P?HHH';%*0&0".?'Q@A@'$"."%$/<"$.';)=#:'1<%1'IH'+"$/"#1');'1<$""L
*)#1)=1' RH' +"$/"#1' );' 40:.' %6":' 18)' ,"%$.' )$' ,)=#6"$' $"6=&%$&,' 8%1/<'
1"&"90.0)#?' -K-.' )$' 90:").@' B<"' .1=:,' ;)=#:' 1<%1' 1<"' 0#;%#1.' %#:' 1)::&"$.' 8"$"'
.+"#:0#6' =+' 1)' P' PST' <)=$.' %' :%,' 90"80#6' 1"&"90.0)#' .<)8.' )$' -K-.?' %#' %/10901,' 1<"'
$"."%$/<"$.'.%,'/%#'>"'<%$*;=&'1)'/)6#0109"':"9"&)+*"#1@'
'
7%$&,' /<0&:<)):' ":=/%1)$.' <%9"' &)#6' 4#)8#' 1<"' *%#,' >"#";01.' *=.0/' /%#' >$0#6' 1)'
/<0&:U.':"9"&)+*"#1?'.=/<'%.'&%#6=%6"'%#:'*)9"*"#1'.40&&.?'/)#/"+1.');'<06<'%#:'&)8?'
&)=:'%#:'.);1?'%#:'"9"#'/)&)$.'%#:'#=*>"$.@'3=1'8<%1'30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'*%$9"&.'
%1'0.'<)8'1<"',)=#6".1'>%>0".'%$"'%>&"'1)'$".+)#:'1)'%#:'/)**=#0/%1"'1<$)=6<'*=.0/@'
D"$<%+.'*).1'0*+)$1%#1&,?'+%$"#1'%#:'/<0&:'80&&'>"';)/=.":')#'1<"'<"$"'%#:'#)8@''F1U.'%'
+%$"#1U.' $".+)#.0>0&01,' 1)' >"' %>&"' 1)' +$"+%$"' 1<"0$' /<0&:$"#' ;)$' 1<"' 1$%#.010)#.' );' &"110#6'
1<0#6.'6)@'''
'
'
D$):=/1'
D$):=/1'
(<0&:$"#' %$"'#%1=$%&&,'%#O0)=.' 8<"#' 01' 0.' 10*"' 1)'609"' =+' %' /)*;)$1' 01"*' .=/<' %.' 1<"0$'
30#4,C.@''B<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.)#6'.))1<".'%'/<0&:U.';"%$'%>)=1'&"110#6'6)');'1<"0$'>"&)9":'
30#4,@'''
A)&:'%.'%'."1'.)'+%$"#1U.'/%#'0#1$):=/"'1<"'.)#6'1)'1<"0$'/<0&:'1)'+$"+%$"'1<"*@''B<"$"'
80&&'>"'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.)#6?'%';)&:')=1'.1)$,'%>)=1'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,@'B<"'F#:06)'V)$".1'
E#0*%&' 1<%1' 1<"' /<0&:' <%.' /<)."#?' 8<0/<' 80&&' <%9"' 1<"' 30#4,' V%0$,' A)#6' 0#.0:"@' B<"'
30#4,'>)O'1<%1' +%$"#1.' 80&&' =."' 801<' 1<"0$' /<0&:' .)' 1<%1' 1<",' /%#' .%,' 6)):'>,"'1)'1<"0$'
>"&)9":'30#4,@''W<0&"'1<"0$'/<0&:'0.'.&""+0#6?'1<"'+%$"#1'80&&'1%4"'%8%,'1<"'30#4,'>)O@'
W<"#'1<"'/<0&:'%8%4".'%#:';0#:.'1<"0$'30#4,'0.'6)#"'1<",'/%#'+$"..'1<"'>"&&,');'1<"0$'
F#:06)'V)$".1'E#0*%&'%#:'01'80&&'<"&+'1<"*'$"*"*>"$'8<%1'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.%#62'
W<"#',)=C$"'1=/4":'%8%,'%.&""+'0#'>":'
J%,'1<"'30#4,'#"%$',)=$'<"%:'
'
A<"C&&'8%9"'<"$'*%60/'8%#:'
E#:'*%4"',)='>06'%#:'.1$)#6'
W<"#',)='8%4"'=+?'0#'1<"'*)$#0#6'
B<"'30#4,'80&&'>"'6)#"'
'
A<"C&&'1%4"'1<"')&:'30#4,';$)*',)='
%#:';)$'1<"'>%>0".'*%4"'01'#"8'
A)'1<",'/%#'6)'1)'.&""+'%#:'$".1'1<"0$'",".'
E#:'8"'8)#C1'<"%$'1<"0$'&011&"'/$0".'
B<"0$'F#:06)'V)$".1'E#0*%&'#)8'>"/)*".'%'#"8'/)*;)$1'01"*'1<%1'0.'"*)10)#%&'<"%&1<,@'''
'
'
'
'
-""+'0#'1<"';)$".1'#"%$'%'.1$"%*'
1<"'3FXYZ'VEF[Z'&04".'1)':$"%*'
'
A<"':$"%*.');'1<"'&011&"'>),.'%#:'60$&.'
\"&+0#6'1<"*'6$)8'0#'%'6$)8#'=+'8)$&:'
'
B<"':)/1)$'.%,.'1<"'30#4,'*=.1'6)'
.)'1<%1',)=C$"'1""1<'/%#'6$)8'
'
W<"#',)=C$"'1=/4":'%8%,'%.&""+'0#'>":'
J%,'1<"'30#4,'#"%$',)=$'<"%:'
'
A<"C&&'8%9"'<"$'*%60/'8%#:'
E#:'*%4"',)='>06'%#:'.1$)#6'
W<"#',)='8%4"'=+?'0#'1<"'*)$#0#6'
B<"'30#4,'80&&'>"'6)#"'
'
'
A<"C&&'1%4"'1<"')&:'30#4,';$)*',)='
%#:';)$'1<"'>%>0".'*%4"'01'#"8'
A)'1<",'/%#'6)'1)'.&""+'%#:'$".1'1<"0$'",".'
E#:'8"'8)#C1'<"%$'1<"0$'&011&"'/$0".'
'
'
'A)':)#C1',)=';$"1'#)8?':)#C1',)=';"%$'
Z)='8)#C1'.<":'%'.0#6&"'1"%$'
'
B)#06<1'0.'1<"'#06<1'.<"'80&&'1%4"';&06<1'
A)'&%,',)=$'<"%:'%#:'/&)."',)=C$"'",".'
'
'
A<"'/)*".'8<"#',)=C$"'%.&""+'
E#:',)='8)#C1'<"%$'%'+""+'
B<"')#&,'8%,'1)'.""?'0.'1)'>"&0"9"'
F#'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,'
'
-""+'0#'1<"';)$".1?'#"%$'%'.1$"%*'
B<"'30#4,'V%0$,'&04".'1)':$"%*'
'
A<"':$"%*.');'1<"'&011&"'>),.'%#:'60$&.'
\"&+0#6'1<"*'6$)8'0#'%'6$)8#'=+'8)$&:'
'
!
B\7'3FXYZ'VEF[Z,
B\7'3FXYZ'VEF[Z
']#/"'=+)#'%'*0:#06<1'<)=$'
'W01<'1<"';&%.<');'<"$'8%#:?'F#'1<"'>&0#4');'%#'","''
B<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.%8'%';&)8"$'
B<"';%0$,'.)%$":'1<"'.1%$&01'.4,'
'
'
'A<"'>&"..":'01'801<'<"$'+0O0"'8%#:'
'E#:'%&&'1<"';)$".1'/%*"'%&09"'
B)'1%4"'01.'60;1'>";)$"'1<"':%8#'
W<"#'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,':0:'%$$09"'
'
'
'B<"'/$,.1%&'>&)..)*'8%.'1<"';&)8"$'
'B<"';)$".1';$0"#:.'<%:'8)$4'1)':)'
F1.'6)&:"#'#"/1%$'6%9"'<"$'+)8"$'
B0*"'1)'*%4"'1<"'30#4,'#"8'
'
'
'B<"';&)8"$'80.<":'1<"';%0$,'8"&&'
B<",'8)$4":'1<"0$'*%60/'1<$)=6<'1<"'#06<1'
E#:'8%1/<":'<"$'/%.1'<"$'*%60/'.+"&&'
3,'*)$#0#6'1<",'8"$"')=1');'.06<1'
'
'
'A<"'.+$"%:'<"$'80#6.'0#1)'1<"'#06<1'
-""+'0#'1<"';)$".1'#"%$'%'.1$"%*'
E#:';&"8');;')#'<"$'*,.10/';&06<1'
B<"'30#4,'V%0$,'#)8'/%#':$"%*'
'
'
'A<"'+"$/<":'=+)#'1<"'80#:)8'.0&&'
'A<"'$".1.'<"$'80#6.'0#'1<"'8%$*'.=#&06<1'
E#:'1<$)=6<'1<"'6&%..'1<"'/<0&:'&%0:'.10&&'
A))#'.<"U&&'1%4"'%#)1<"$';&06<1'
'
'
'A<"'8%9":'<"$'8%#:'%#:'0#'.<"';&"8'
'E#:'0#'1<"'*)$#0#6'%'/<0&:'%8)4"'
B8%.'10*"'1)'*%4"'1<"'30#4,'#"8'
["*"*>"$0#6'1<"'8)$:.'1<%1'.<"'.+)4"'
'
'
'A<"'+&%/":'<"$'8%#:'=+)#'<0.'<"%:'
'J011&"';%0$,'?'F':)'>"&0"9"'
A+0&&":'+0O0"'+)8:"$'?'1<"#'.<"'.%0:'
F#'1<"'*%60/'1<%1',)='/)#/"09"'
'
FU&&'$=#'%#:'1"&&'"9"$,'>),'%#:'60$&'
F';&,'1)'1<""?')<'&011&"')#"'
B<%1',)='<"&+'=.'6$)8'0#'%'6$)8#'=+'8)$&:'
Z)='*=.1'>"'>$%9"?'1<"'10*"'<%.'/)*"'
'
Z)=$'30#4,',)='8)#U1'#"":'%6%0#'
FU9"'*%:"',)='.1$)#6?'*,'.+"/0%&';$0"#:'
''
"#$%&!'(#)&*!+(*!
,-%./*&!(+!+$-*0!
D$)*)10#6'+$):=/1'&0#"2'
D$)*)10#6'+$):=/1'&0#"2'
B<"'30#4,'5%60/'A)#6'
B<"'30#4,'5%60/'A)#6'
W"'80&&'>"'*%$4"10#6'1<0.'01"*';0$.1@''W"'80&&'=10&0^"'1<"'#"8".1'1"/<#)&)60".')#'1<"'
0#1"$#"1'801<'*=.0/':)8#&)%:0#6'8">.01".@'''
!"
'F1=#".'
!"
X%+.1"$'
!"
[<%+.):,'
!"
A)#,'0#'_':0;;"$"#1'/)=#1$0".'
!"
3$)%:N%*@/)*''
!"
E*%^)#@/)*''
B<"'+)..0>0&010".'%$"'"#:'&0.1@''W01<'1):%,':"+"#:"#/"')#'1<"'0#1"$#"1'8"'80&&'>"'%>&"'
1)'$"%/<'*0&&0)#.');'+")+&"'%&&')9"$'1<"'8)$&:@'
W"'<%9"'/$"%1":'%'*,.+%/"'+%6"'`*,.+%/"@/)*S>0#4,*%60/"#1"$+$0.".a'8<0/<'0.'%'
+)8"$;=&'1))&'1<%1'0.';$""'%:9"$10.0#6'0#'%#10/0+%10)#');'%'.=//"..;=&'&%=#/<@''V$)*'1<0.'
$".)=$/"'8"'80&&'."1'=+'B<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.)#6'.)'1<%1',)='80&&'>"'%>&"'1)'>=,'1<"'.)#6'
)#'A#)8/%+?'1<"'*,.+%/"':)8#&)%:0#6'+&%1;)$*@''''
W"' <%9"' +=$/<%.":' 1<"' :)*%0#' #%*"' 30#4,5%60/@/)*@' ' B<0.' 80&&' "#%>&"' =.' 1)'
%:9"$10."' )=$' /)*+&"1"' &0#"' );' +$):=/1.@' ' W"' 80&&' *%4"' B<"' 30#4,' V%0$,' .)#6'
:)8#&)%:%>&"';$)*')=$')8#'8">.01"'%.'8"&&@''W"'<%9"'%&$"%:,'+=$/<%.":'%'<).10#6'
+%/4%6"'1<%1'80&&'"#%>&"'=.'1)';"%1=$"'_'+%6".@'
!
V=1=$"'D$):=/1'7O+%#.0)#'
V=1=$"'D$):=/1'7O+%#.0)#'
E=:0)'3))4.2'
E=:0)'3))4.2
'
W"'80&&'>"'$"/)$:0#6'%#'%=:0)'>))4');'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,'.1)$,'1<%1'<%.'>""#'/$"%1":'@'
B<0.'.1)$,'80&&'>"'%9%0&%>&"'%.'%'D):'/%.1')#'2F1=#".'0#'_':0;;"$"#1'/)=#1$0".@'
'
]1<"$'.01".'8"'80&&'>"'*%$4"10#6'1)'0#/&=:"2'
!"
E=:0>&"@/)*3'
!"
3$0&&0%#/"'%=:0)@/)*'
!"
E*%^)#@/)*'
!"
(%#:&"&06<1'.1)$0".@/)*'
W"'80&&'%&.)'>"'."%$/<0#6';)$'*)$"');'1<"."'+%$10/=&%$'.01".'1)'+=1')=$'.1)$,')#@'
3))4.2'
3))4.2'
W<0&"'1<"'30#4,'V%0$,'A)#6'."1'0.'>"0#6'*%$4"1":?'8"'80&&'>"'&))40#6'1)'0&&=.1$%1"'%#:'
/$"%1"'%'/<0&:$"#C.'>))4'+$)+).%&'1)'>))4'D=>&0.<"$.@''E&)#6'801<'1<0.'.1)$,S.)#6?'8"'
<%9"'*%#,')1<"$'.)#6.'%#:'.1)$0".'1<%1'8"'8)=&:'&04"'1)'+$)+)."'1)'D=>&0.<"$.'%.'8"&&@'
V)$'"O%*+&"2'
!"
B<"'B))1<'V%0$,'.1)$,'%#:'.)#6'
!"
B<"'D)11,'V%0$,'.1)$,'%#:'.)#6'
!"
B<"'3=>>%'V%0$,'.1)$,'%#:'.)#6'
!"
B<"'X%+10*"'V%0$,'.1)$,'%#:'.)#6'
]=$'.1)$0".'%#:'#=$."$,'$<,*".'%$"'6"%$":'1)'<"&+'/<0&:$"#'%//"+1'%#:'6$)8'.)'1<",'
/%#'%/<0"9"'1<"'*%#,'/<0&:<)):'*0&".1)#".'1<%1'1<",'80&&'<%9"'6)'1<$)=6<@'
'
]1<"$'+)..0>&"'+$):=/1'&0#".2'
'
W"'+&%#')#'%::0#6'%'/<0&:$"#C.'(&)1<0#6'&0#"'/%&&":'F#:06)'3%>0".@''W"'%$"'0#'1<"'
+$)/"..');'1$%:"'*%$40#6'1<0.'#%*"@'''
b"8"&$,'&0#"';)$'/<0&:$"#'
'
B<"'F#:06)'V)$".1'()&&"/10)#'80&&'>"'/$"%1":'=.0#6'1<"'%#0*%&.';$)*'B<"'7#/<%#1":'
V)$".1'.1)$,@''W"'%$"'0#'1<"'+$)/"..');'1$%:"'*%$40#6'1<0.'#%*"@'
'
E#'7:=/%10)#%&'6%*"'.=/<'%.'B<"'7#/<%#1":'V)$".1'!%*"@'
'
E'."$0".');'3))4.');'%&&');'1<"'V%0$0".?'"%/<'<%90#6'1<"0$')8#'."$0".@'
'
E#0*%1":'1"&"90.0)#'."$0".'%#:'5%N)$'*)10)#'+0/1=$"'
A%&"'1)'.1)$".'.=/<'%.2'
!"
'
3%>0".'['Q.'
!"
'
3%>,'-"+)1'
!"
'
B),.'$'Q.'
!"
'
W%&*%$1'
!"
'
B%$6"1'
!"
'
A+"/0%&10".'.<)+.'
'
30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'8%#1.'1<"0$'0*%6"'1)'$";&"/1'8<)'8"'%$"'%#:'8<%1'8"'.1%#:';)$c'
%.' *)1<"$.' 8"' %&8%,.' %:9)/%1"' ;)$' )=$' /<0&:$"#' %#:' &))4' %;1"$' 1<"0$' 8"&&' >"0#6@' ' W"'
*%4"' .=$"' 1<",' ;""&' .%;"' %#:' ."/=$"' 0#' 1<"0$' "#90$)#*"#1@' ' ]=$' 6)%&' 0.' 1)' >$0#6' 1<"'
>"&0"9"');' *%60/' >%/4' 0#1)' /<0&:$"#U.' &09".'>,' .10*=&%10#6' 1<"0$'0*%60#%10)#.@'' W<,' #)1'
609"' )=$' /<0&:$"#' 1<"' /<0&:<)):' 1<%1' 1<",' :"."$9"@' ' J"1.' 6)' %>)9"' %#:' >",)#:' 1)' ;0&&'
1<"0$'&09".'801<'+"%/"'%#:'&)9"';)$')#"'%#)1<"$@'J"1U.'+$%0."'1<"*'8<"#'1<",'=."'1<"0$'
0*%60#%10)#.@''Z)='*=.1'>"&0"9"'1)'.""d'
'
'
'
'
'
B<"'W)*"#');'B<"'30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'
B<"'W)*"#');'B<"'30#4,'5%60/'7#1"$+$0."'
'
(<"$,&'J"06<'\%NN%$'8%.'>)$#'%#:'$%0.":'0#'X)$1<'E#:)9"$?'5%..%/<=."11.@'''
(<"$,&'.1%$1":'+&%,0#6'/&%..0/%&'+0%#)'%1'%6"'e'%#:';$)*'1<"$"'8"#1')#'1)'.1=:,'*=.0/'
1<")$,'%#:'/)*+).010)#'%1'Q5%..'J)8"&&@''A<"'%&&'.)'<)&:.'%'3E'0#'($0*0#%&'b=.10/"'%#:'
0.'%';)$*"$'+%$%&"6%&@''
(<"$,&' 0.' %/109"&,' +=$.=0#6' %' .)#68$010#6' /%$""$' %.' %' +)+S/)=#1$,' 8$01"$@' ' A<"' <%.'
8$011"#' %#:' +$):=/":' *%#,' );' <"$' )8#' 8)$4' <"$."&;' %#:' 1$%9"&.' >%/4' %#:' ;)$1<' 1)''
X%.<90&&"'/)L8$010#6'%#:'+$):=/0#6'*%1"$0%&@''
(<"$,&'0.'%&.)'%'.0#6&"'*)1<"$');'%'_',"%$')&:'>),'#%*":'-,&%#@'
'
-"#0."'[@'V0O'8%.'>)$#'%#:'$%0.":'0#'A%&"*?'5%..%/<=."11.@'
-=$0#6'1<"'+%.1'TH',"%$.'-"#0."'<%.'=.":'<"$'%>0&010".'0#'*%#,'8%,.?'.)*"');'8<0/<'
<%9"' 0#/&=:":2' ' D$)90:0#6' +.,/<0/' $"%:0#6.' 1)' +")+&"' %/$)..' 1<"' 8)$&:c' 5%40#6'
1"&"90.0)#'%++"%$%#/".'%#:'+"$;)$*0#6'+.,/<0/'$"%:0#6.';)$'/"&">$010".c'/)#.=&10#6';)$'%'
.+0$01=%&' *)90"c' /<%#60#6' 1<"' &09".' );' 1<)=.%#:.c' );;"$0#6' &0;"L%&1"$0#6' 0#;)$*%10)#@''
-"#0."' 0.' )+"#' 1)' *%#,' :0*"#.0)#.' );' &0;"' %#:' 90>$%10)#.' );' "#"$6,@' ' A<"' %//"+1":'
1<"."'%>0&010".'%.'60;1.'%#:'8%#1":'1)'.<%$"'<"$'1$"%.=$"'801<')1<"$.@'''']9"$'1<"',"%$.'
-"#0."' <%.' :"9"&)+":' <"$' .40&&.' %.' %' +.,/<0/' <"%&"$@' ' W01<' 1<0.' 4#)8&":6"' %#:'
.+"/0%&0^":' 1$%0#0#6' -"#0."' .1%$1":' <"&+0#6' /<0&:$"#' 0#' #"":@' ' V)$' PH' ,"%$.' .<"' <%.'
>""#'8)$40#6'801<'*=&10+&"'6)9"$#*"#1'%6"#/0".'+$)90:0#6'%'&)90#6'<)*"';)$'/<0&:$"#'
801<'.+"/0%&'>"<%90)$%&'#"":.@'''
-"#0."' 0.' 1<"' *)1<"$' );' ;)=$' /<0&:$"#' b"##0;"$?' D<0&0+?' Y%10"' %#:' b"$"*0%<@' (=$$"#1&,''
-"#0."'0.'0#'1<"'+$)/"..');'>"/)*0#6'%#'%++$)9":'%:)+109"'<)*"@'''\"$'<)+"'0.'1)'>"'
%>&"'1)'%:)+1'1<"';).1"$'/<0&:$"#'1<%1'%$"'/=$$"#1&,'+&%/":'0#'<"$'<)*"@''
'
'
E*,'D"$$"%=&1'8%.'>)$#'%#:'$%0.":'0#'J%8$"#/"?'5%..%/<=."11.@'
E*,'%11"#:":'J".&",'Q#09"$.01,'.1=:,0#6'0#'\=*%#'-"9"&)+*"#1'801<'%'50#)$'0#'7%$&,'
(<0&:<)):'7:=/%10)#@''A<"'/=$$"#1&,'0.'$=##0#6'<"$')8#'<)*"':%,/%$"@''W01<'<"$'
":=/%10)#%&'>%/46$)=#:'E*,'0.'%>&"'1)'"#$0/<'1<"'&09".');'"9"$,'/<0&:'.<"'0.'0#'/)#1%/1'
801<@''''\"$'6$"%1".1'+%..0)#.'%$"'<"$';%*0&,'%#:'<"$'&)9"';)$'/<0&:$"#U.'&01"$%1=$"@'
E*,'%&.)');;"$.'Pe',"%$.'"O+"$0"#/"'0#'$"1%0&'*%#%6"*"#1'%#:'/)$+)$%1"'1$%0#0#6';)$'%'
&%$6"'$"1%0&')+"$%10)#@'''''
E*,'0.'1<"'*)1<"$');'%'T'PST')&:'>),'#%*":'X0/<)&%.@!
'
'
'
B%$%'K,'[):6"$.'8%.'$%0.":'0#'F+.80/'5%..%/<=."11.@'
A/<))&":'0#'3=.0#"..'E:*0#0.1$%10)#.'%1'Y%1<%$0#"'!0>>.'A/<))&'0#'3).1)#?'5E@''B%$%'
);;"$.'PR',"%$.'"O+"$0"#/"'0#'1<"':%,'1)':%,'$=##0#6');'%#');;0/"'"#90$)#*"#1@''A<"'<%.'
"O+"$0"#/"'801<'1<"';)&&)80#6'2''E[SED?'\[SD%,$)&&'f'7O"/=109"'A"/$"1%$,':=10".@'
A<"'/=$$"#1&,'<)&:'1<"'+).010)#');'A"#0)$'3=,"$'801<'%'.801/<'*%#=;%/1=$0#6'/)*+%#,@''
A<"'<%.'"O+"$0"#/"'801<'0#1"$#%10)#%&'9"#:)$.'&)/%1":'0#'V$%#/"?'QY?'5g?'(<0#%?'\)#6'
Y)#6?'"1/@''''
A<"'0.'1<"'*)1<"$');';)=$'/<0&:$"#'b).<=%'`Pha?'7&0N%<'`PHa?'X)%<'`ea'%#:'7&&%'`Pa@!
PHHH'
PHHH'
THHH'
THHH'
iHHH'
iHHH'
_HHH'
_HHH'
PHHHH'
PHHHH'
P_HHH'
P_HHH'
THHHH'
THHHH'
(-'V%/"';0&*'()&)$'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
jTH@HH'
(-C.'801<'I'/)&)$'
;%/"'
jH@Ih'
jH@II'
jH@IT'
jH@IT'
jH@IH'
jH@ik'
jH@ik'
h'D%#"&'ISI'0#."$1'
f'1$%,'/%$:'
jH@Ik'
jH@iH'
jH@TR'
jH@Ik'
jH@Te'
jH@Th'
jH@Ii'
b"8"&'>)O?'
E.."*>&,'f'A<$0#4'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
jH@TI'
3%$/):"'%1'X)'
(<%$6"'
jP?THH@HH'
jP?RkH@HH'
jT?keH@HH'
j_?hkR@HH'
jR?P_I@HH'
jPi?iPP@_H'
jTP?Hke@Ph'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
B)'3"'+=$/<%.":'
0#'1<"'QAE'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
A)=#:'5):=&"'
(=.1)*'PH'."/'
j_@T_'
jI@ek'
jI@i_'
ji@Rh'
ji@hH'
ji@Tk'
jT@Rk'
7*>$)0:"$,'%#:'
1%6'
jP@HH'
jH@RP'
jH@ki'
jH@e_'
jH@hR'
jH@hT'
jH@_e'
3)O')$'3%6';)$'
30#4,'
jT@_H'
jT@Tk'
jT@He'
jP@kk'
jP@eP'
jP@_h'
jP@IT'
D&=.<'A1=;;":'
E#0*%&'PHLPTM'
j_@HH'
jI@__'
jI@PI'
ji@ee'
ji@Ii'
ji@PT'
jT@kI'
'
jPi?e_H@HH'
jT_?HT_@HH'
jiI?P_R@Pi'
j_P?kHk@HP'
jRI?TRH@_e'
jPTk?eHh@hi'
jP_h?PhI@HI'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
B)1%&'V$"06<1'
jP?IR_@HH'
jT?eHH@_H'
ji?eHT@RP'
j_?eIR@eH'
jPH?iII@Ih'
jPI?THP@kP'
jPe?eT_@PT'
B)'.%9"')#';$"06<1'/<%$6".@''A"1'=+'%'>&%#4"1')$:"$')9"$'%'PT'*)#1<'+"$0):'1)'>"'$"&"%.":')#'%'*)#1<&,'>%.".@''B<0.'80&&'%&&)8',)='1)'<)&:'>=&4'+$0/0#6@'
B<0.'%&.)'%&&)8.',)='1)'<%9"',)=$'0#9"#1)$,'.1)$":');;.01"'
801<'1<"'9"#:)$@'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
V=#:.'X"":":';)$'
A"1'
jPh?II_@HH'
jPh?II_@HH'
jTR?eH_@_H'
jTR?eH_@_H'
jIH?eiT@HI'
jIH?eiT@HI'
jhi?TIh@eP'
jhi?TIh@eP'
jPPi?ekR@Hi'
jPPi?ekR@Hi'
jP_h?TPR@RI'
jP_h?TPR@RI'
jPRI?Reh@iT'
jPRI?Reh@iT'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
B)1%&'().1'D"$'
01"*'
jPh@I_'
jPI@k_'
jPi@_k'
jPT@h_'
jPP@ik'
jPH@IP'
jR@e_'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
W<)&".%&"'1)'
:0.1$0>=1)$.'`_Hl'
);'/).1a'
jTI@he'
jTT@Tk'
jTH@ie'
jPk@Re'
jPe@He'
jP_@hT'
jPI@hT'
'
jTI?hhe@_H'
jII?__k@T_'
jhP?HRk@Hh'
jRI?keH@Hh'
jPeH?hki@_I'
jTiI?iTR@RP'
jTRT?IhI@IR'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
'
D$);01'0;'.)&:'
jk?TTT@_H'
jk?TTT@_H'
jPI?k_T@e_'
jPI?k_T@e_'
jTH?ihh@HT'
jTH?ihh@HT'
jiP?hTi@i_'
jiP?hTi@i_'
j_h?kRI@_P'
j_h?kRI@_P'
jek?PHR@Re'
jek?PHR@Re'
jRe?Ikk@Ph'
jRe?Ikk@Ph'
1<$)=6<':0.1'
1<$)=6<':0.1'
'
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
["1%0&':0$"/1&,'1)'
(=.1)*"$.'
jiI@_i'
jiP@PR'
jTk@_P'
jTh@_h'
jTi@RH'
jTP@ke'
jTH@Ie'
`W<)&".%&"mIHla'
D$);01'0.'.)&:'
jPR?_kI@_H'
jPR?_kI@_H'
ji_?ieh@__'
ji_?ieh@__'
jIk?_Hk@P_'
jIk?_Hk@P_'
je_?iTP@Hk'
je_?iTP@Hk'
jPi_?_PT@iR'
jPi_?_PT@iR'
jPkh?HIi@e_'
jPkh?HIi@e_'
jTiT?PRR@Hk'
jTiT?PRR@Hk'
:0$"/1&,'
:0$"/1&,'
'
3FXYZ'5E!F('7XB7[D[FA7'
!
jThH?h_R@P_'
jThH?h_R@P_'
jPk@iR'
jPHR?Iie@H_'
jPHR?Iie@H_'
!
!
jPi@Pi'
jiTk?iPP@PI'
!
jk@e_'
!
jTPk?keI@PH'
jTPk?keI@PH'
!
jT@_k'
jPee?hih@hH'
!
jPR?kRe@h_'
jP@TR'
jH@_T'
jT@eP'
jTP?iiR@k_'
!
jH@TI'
jH@T_'
jH@ih'
T_HHH'
T_HHH'
jTH@HH'
"#$%&!'(#)&*!+(*!
1&23-.&!)(%!
"#$%&!'(#)&*!+(*!
.*$)&!4$5&!
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?