Willard v. Baker et al

Filing 5

ORDERED P's # 2 Application to proceed IFP is DENIED. FURTHER ORD P shall SHOW CAUSE by 1/14/2012 why petition should not be dismissed as time-barred. FURTHER ORD P shall provide with his response such competent evidence as is available to him of his date of birth. FURTHER ORD shall file in the record and send to P with this order as an attachment to this order consisting of a copy of the state supreme court's December 10, 2010 order of affirmance in No. 54885. FURTHER ORD that the Co urt defers consideration of any other deficiencies in the papers presented until after assessing the timeliness issue in the first instance. Signed by Judge Edward C. Reed, Jr on 12/13/2011. ( Attachments: # 1 NV Supreme Court Order of Affirmance )(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

'

FIED
L
ENTERED

RECEI
VED
SERVEDON
C EtlnTISOFRK ORD
OUNS lA E

1

pEg 1j 2 1
21

2
CL USDI RI COUR
ERK
ST CT
T

3

nlq c OFN V D
sa ! E A A
B
Y:

4

DEPUW
-- -- '
-

5

6

7
8

U N I ED STA TES D ISTR ICT CO U RT
T
D ISTR IC T O F N EV A D A

9
HA RO LD W I
LLA RD ,
1
0

Pettone ,
ii r

3: l c 008 ECR- G C
1 - v- 76W

'

1l
vs.

1
2

ORDER

1 RENEE BAKEK etal,
3
.
1
4

Re ponde s.
s
nt

l5

1
6
Thi h
s abea mat un 28 U. C. 2 c
s t der
er
S. j 254 omes b or t Coud on p ion '
ef e he
et i ers
t
1 appi t ( )t p oc ed i f r pa pe i an f iialevew un Rul 4 o t e Rul
7
l i #2 o r e n o ma u rà d or nt r i
ca on
i
der e f h
es
1 Gover ng Sec i 2254 Cases.
8
ni
ton
1
9

O nt pauperappl i pettonerpai t fl f
he
i on, ii
cat
d he ii eewihhi i tal
ng
t s nii paper Pettoner
s. ii

20 t ef e need notobt n pauperst us t satsf t flng f r r
her or
ai
at o i y he i ee equiement and t e i no
i
,
her s

21 ot r
her equestf r i bef e t Coud t w hi t pauperappl i woul pedai The
or el
ef or he
o
ch he
i on
cat
d
n.
22 fnanci atachm ent pr ent f t est i t pettonerhassufi ent undst payt
i
al t
s es ed urher abl hat ii
sh
fci f
o
he
23 fl f whi as not he has done. The pauperappl i t ef e w i be deni on
ii ee, ch,
ng
ed,
i on her or l
cat
l
ed
24 t showi and paper pr
he
ng
s esent
ed.

2
5

Tur n t i t r iw,t ear h t h pe ioni s j c t dimis wi prj die
nig o nialeve iapp st a t e t i s ube to s s al t e u c
i
t
h

26 as tm e- r f f l e t fl t petton wihi t onei bared or aiur o i he ii
e
t n he
yearl i i perod i 28 U. C .
i t on i n
m at
S.

2 5 2 4( ( ) Pet i er h e or wi bedie t d t s w c e wh t pe ions l no
7
24 d)1 . ion t er f e l
t
l r c e o ho aus y he tt houd t
i
28 be di i
sm ssed as tm e- r
i bared.

l

1

l

Backgr
ound

Th al gat so t p t i a welasif mat s j c t j cal t efom t e
e l i f he e ion s l n or i ube t o udii no i r h
e on
t
on
c

'

1

3 onl r ds of t s at supr e cour and st e corectons deparm ent r l t t
i ecor
ne
he t e
em
t
at
r i
t
efec he

4 f l ng.
ol
owi
5

PettonerHar d W iar chal
i
i
ol l d
l
l
engeshi convi i pur
s
ctonl suantt a gui ypl ofs
o
l ea, exual
t

6 as
saul.
t

7

Th j gmen ofc vitonwasfe on Nov er29, 00
e ud
t on ci
id
l
emb
2 4.

8

No notce ofappeal
i
was fl wihi t t ry daytme perod f flng a diec appeal
i
ed t n he hit i
i or i
i
r t
.

9 The tm e t do so expied on Decem ber29,2004.
i o
r
1
0

Neary t y s I er on oraboutSept ber18,2006,pettonerfl a st e post
l wo ear at ,
em
ii
i
ed
at
-

11 convitonpetton.The st edititcourdeni r i , t st e supr
ci
ii
at s rc
t ed el and he at
ef
eme coud afim ed.
fr
1 The Supr e Cour ofNevada hel t t petton was untm el The r itt i
2
em
t
d hat he ii
i y.
em ti ssued on
ur
1 Aprl4,2011.
3
i

1
4

O noraferNovem ber8 ,
t
2011,pet i
ionerm ai t f al ii t t Cl koft s
t
l he eder petton o he er hi
ed

1 Cour f flng,
5
t or i l
i
1
6

Accor ng t t st e corectonsdepadment
di o he at
r i
websie,pettonercurenty i 23 year
t
ii
r l s
s

1 oI att s wrtng. Pettonert woul have been appr m at y 16 year oI att tm e of
7
d hi ii
ii
hus
d
oxi el
s d he i

1 t u
8 hej dgmen of on c i an ap oxma el 1 y sol a t t o t e fi o t esat
t c vit
on d pr i t y 8 ear d t he i f h ing f h t e
me
l
1 postconviton pet i z
9
ci
ion.
t
20

Di
scussi
on

21
Pur u t He bs v Co , 60 F.d 1 39 ( hci. 001 ,h Cou t uas nt r s
s anto r t . ok 2
3 0 9t r 2 )t e
r s po e aies
2 t qu t o wh t er h p ioni tme- aredt f l e t fl t e p ii wi i t on
2 he es i f e h t e et i s i b r or ai o i h et on t n he eon
t
ur
e
t
h
2 y I t t p i i 28 U. C, 22 d)1 .
3 ear i a i er n
mi on od
S. j 44( ( )
24

25

l #3, at1. Gi t appr mat y t fy days t el ed bet
see
ven he
oxi el hi
t
hat aps
ween t dat ofmaing st ed i
he e
l
i at n

26 t p r an t e do e i o t e p er b t e Cl r , h Cou t e n de i iv f ct fn i g t t he
he ape s d h ck t f h ap s y h e k t e
ng
r mak s o fnt e a uali d n ha t
i
f alpaper i f wer t
eder
s n act e ender f maii i t prs t ough t pr
ed or lng n he ion hr
he operchannel on November8,
s
27 2 .
011
28

2 eh /
se qp:/

doc. gov/nm at
nv. i esear f m .
ch/or php.

.

'

;.

.

1
Un 28 U. C. j 2 d ( )A) t e f der on y I t t p i une
der
S.
244( )1 ( , h e al e-ear i a i er
mi on
od, lss
2 o h wi t l b n r nni a t 'h dat on whih t e j gmen b ame f b t
t er se ol egis u ng fer' e e
ed,
t
c h ud
t ec
i y he
nal
3 concl on ofdiectr ew ort expiaton of he tm e f seeki such diectr ew. I t
usi
r evi
he
r i
t i or
ng
r evi ' n he
'

4 pr en c e,h I t tonp id, ls t l or bec t adier t t ngdat ons
es t as t e i a i ero une s ol
mi
ed su j to f en sadi
f
e ome
5 ot basi t began r ng on t f oft pr
her
s, hus
unni
he ace he esentr d afert expiaton oft
ecor t he
r i
he
6 tm e perod f fl a diect appeal ie. afer Decem ber 29,2004. Absent t l or a
i
i or ing
i
r
,. , t
olng
i
7 dif ent accr dat t onefer
ual e, he
year I iaton perod woul expie one year I er on
i t i
m
i
d
r
at ,
8 Decem ber29,2005.

9

Un 28U. C.
der
S. j224 d)2)t ef er on ye l t tonp idi s a u oryt l
4( ( ,h ed al e- ari a i ero s t t t i ol
mi
l ed

1 durng t pendency ofa pr
0
i he
opery fl appl i f s at postconvi i r i , However
l i
ed
i on or t e
cat
cton el
ef
,
11 an untm el s at postconvi i petton i not' operyfl 'and i husdoes notst ut i
i y t e
cton ii s
'
pr
l i
edi
tt
at orl
y

1 t lt f all iaton perod. Pace v.Di uglel o,544 U. 408,1 S. .1807,161
2 ol he eder i t i
m
i
G im
S.
25 Ct

1 L. 2 6 ( 5) Pe io ' sa e po tc vc i p ionwasdeni asun i y an
3 Ed.d 69 200 . t iner t t s- on it et i
t
s
on t
ed
t
mel, d
1 t pet i t ef e di not s at orl t lt f
4 he
i on her or d
t
t ut i ol he eder Im iaton perod under Sec i
y
al i t i
i
ton

1 2244( ( .
5
d)2)
1
6

Accor ngl,absentot t lng,ora I eraccr dat t f alI i i perod
di y
her ol
i
at
ual e, he eder i t on i
m at

1 expied on Decem ber29,2005. Pettonerdi notm ait f alpetton untl orafer
7
r
ii
d
l he eder
ii
iUn
t
1 Nov ber8,2011,neary si year afert I iaton perod had expied,abs t l or
8
em
l x
s t he i t i
m
i
r
ent olng
i

1 a I eraccr dat The pet i t ef e i untm el on t f oft r d.
9
at
ual e.
ion her or s i y
t
he ace he ecor
20
' Pettoner t ef e m ust show cause i wrtng w hy t petton shoul not be
ii
her or
n ii
he
ii
d

21 dimis wi prj c ast bared,
s s ed t eudie i
h
me- r
22

.

I t sr
n hi egar pettoneri i or ed t t oned, ii
s nf m
hat he
yeari iatonperod m aybe equi y
Im t i
i
t
abl

23 t ld. Equt e t ln i appr i e ony it e pe io c sh w '( )t a h h bee
ol
e
i
abl ol g s
i
opr
at l f h t iner an o ' 1 h t e as n
t
'
2 pur nghi r t dig ty an ( t ts
4
sui s i s l en l, d 2) ha omeexr di yci umsanc so i hsway
gh i
taor nar r
c t e t od n i
'
25 and pr
event tm el flng. Lawr
ed i y i '
i '
ence e.R orda,549 U. 327,336,1 S. .1079,1085,
/
S.
27 Ct

2 1 6 L. 2d 92 ( oo7lquo ig pr au h i ) Equi e t l g i ' vai bl i mos
6 6 Ed.
4 z t tn i t or y .
or
t
t
abl oln s '
i
una l e n
a
t
2 c e 'Mi v Pnmt 1 F.d 1 04,1 07 ( hCi.999) a 'h t r hol n es ar t
7 as s, l .
' es
y, 87 3 1
1 9t r1 , nd ' e h es d ec s y o
t
28 t i
rggerequiabl t l i ver hi I t exceptons swal t r el Mianda v.Caslo,
t e oli s y gh,est he
ng
i
l he ul ' r
ow
'
r
3-

-

'

1 292F. 1 1 66(t Ci. 02)q& n Uni kt e v Ma c / 21 F, 1 1 0
3d 063, 0 9h r20 ( o# g t ats . re/ 2 3d 005, 01
ed
o,
2 ( t Ci.000), Th pe ionerutma el h t b den ofp oo on t s ' xta diar
7 h r2 )
e ti
t
l t y as he ur
i
r f hi ' r or n y
e
3 excl on. 292 F. at 1065. He accor ngl m us dem onstat a causalr atonshi
usi '
'
3d
di y
t
r e
el i
p

,

4 bet
ween t extaor nar cicum st
he r di y r
ance and t I eness ofhi flng.E. ,Spisyn v Moor
he at
si
i
g. t
.
e'

5 345 F, 796,799 ( h Ci.2003) Accor 8r ? v,Arzona Atom ey Gener b499 F.
3d
9t r
.
d yarl ' i
.
t
al
3d
6 1 6,10 ( t Ci. 7)
05
61 9 h r 200 .
7

Pet i
ioneral i i or
t
so s nf med t ,undercerai cicum s ances, he onehat
tn r
t
t
yearIm i i
i t on
at

8 per may be n r ig on a I erdae orma be s a u ory t l See 28 U. C.j
i
od
gi unnn
at
t
y
t t t i ol
l ed.
S.
9 22 d)1 ( , C)& ( & ( ( .
44( ( )B) (
D) d)2)
1
0

M or
eover i pettonerseeks t avoi appl i oft tm e- bas upon a cl m
, f ii
o
d
i on he i bar ed
cat
ai

11 ofact i
ual nnocenc he m ustcom e f war wih new r i e evi
e,
or d t
el
abl
dence t ng t es abl
endi o t i
sh

1 hi i oc c i ,endigt esabl ht a noj r ac i r s
2 s nn en e,. t n o t i h t u or t ea onabl woul h ef n hi
e.
s
ng
y
d av ou d m
1 guiy beyond a r
3
l
t
easonabl doubt as t aI oft char pendi agai thi i t case
e
, o I he
ges
ng
ns m n he

1 pr t t pe See Hous v Bel 5 U. 51 1 6 S. . 64,1 L. 2d 1( 6)
4 i o he la.
or
e . l 47 S. 8, 2 Ct 20
,
65 Ed.
200 *
,
l Bou ly v Uni St es'5 U. 61 11 S. .1 4,1 L. 2d 828 ( 99 .Le 7
j
se . t
ed at 23 S. 4, 8 Ct 60 40 Ed.
1 8) e .
,
1 L
6 ampe l653 F.d 9 ( hCi. 1 ( ba )
r
3 29 9t r 201 )en nc .

1
7

I THEREFORE I ORDERED t tp ion ' appl a i ( t pr ee i fc a
T
S
ha et i er
t s
i t #2) o oc d n o
c on

1 pau i i DENI on t showi and paper pr
8
pers s
ED
he
ng
s esent
ed.

1
9
I FURTHER I ORDERED t a , t i t it ( ) y o en r o t sor er p ion
T
S
h twihn hry 30 da s f ty f hi d , et i er
t
2 s al SHOW CAUSE i wr ig wh t pe ion s l n b dim is wi prj die as
0 h l
n in y he t i houd ot e s s ed t e u c
t
t
h
21 tme- r I pettonerdoesnottmel r
i bared. f ii
i y espond t t sor ,t pettonwi be di i
o hi jer he ii l
l sm ssed
2 wi prj ie astme b r d wi ou f t radv c no ie.I p ionerr pon bu f l
2 t e udc
h
i - are t t urhe
h
an e t f et i
c
t
es ds t ai
s
23 t show w ih specii det l and com pet evi
o
t
fc, ai
ed
ent dence t t petton i tm el t ac i
hat he ii s i y, he ton

I

l

2 wi be dimis wi prj ie.
4 l
l s s ed t e udc
h

,
'

25

.

I FURTHER I O RDERED t aIasseri off m ade by pettoneri r
T
S
hat I
tons act
ii
n esponse

;

2 t t ss w c eorer s b d ai mu tb s ecfcast tme an pl e, mus
6 o hi ho aus d mu t e et l
ed, s e p ii o i d ac and t

I

27 be suppored by com pet evi
t
ent dence.The Coud wil consi any as tonsoff tt
lnot
der
seri
ac hat

'

I

28 ar notspeci as t tm e and pl
e
sc
o i
ace,t ar notm ade pur
hat e
suantt a decl aton under
o
ar i
4-

-

:

'

(

1 pen t o p j y b ed u
al f erur as pon peron k owl e, and/ t ar not suppored by
y
s al n edg
or hat e
t

!

2 com pet evi
ent dence fl by pet i
i
ed
ioneri t f
t
n he eder r d. The f ls at coud r d w i
al ecor
ul t e
ecor l
l

'

3 no bea ai l t t Co oreviw wi p ioner s w c s r po e.Pet i t s
t v l e o he udf r e t et i ' ho au e es ns
ab
h t
s
ionerhu
t
4 m ustatach copi ofg
t
es l mat i suponwhi hebaseshi ar
l eral
ch
s gumentt t pettonshoul
hat he ii
d

1

!

.

5 notbe di i
sm ssed as untmel Unsuppored assedi off w i be di egar
i y.
t
ons act l
l
sr ded.
6

I FURTHER I O RDERED t pettoner shal pr de w ih hi r
T
S
hat ii
l ovi
t s esponse such

7 c pet evi
om ent dence as i avai e t hi ofhi dat ofbit
s
l
abl o m
s e
rh.
8

I FURTHER I O RDERED t t Cl k ofCour shalfl i t r d and send t
T
S
hat he er
t
l i n he ecor
e
o

9 pettonerwiht s or anatachm entt t sor
ii
t hi der
t
o hi derconsitng ofa copy oft st e supr e
si
he at
em
1 coud' Decem ber10,2010,or ofafim ance i No.54885, ch can be gener ed as a
0
s
der
fr
n
whi
at
ll . 5I fom t st e supr
pdf e r he at
eme cour' onl docketsheetatt Ink i t f not bel .
ts i
ne
he i n he oot e ow 3
1
2

I FURTHER I ORDERED t t sor does notsi f by om i ont ei
T
S
hat hi der
gniy
ssi hat t
hert
he

1 petton or t cl m s t ei ot wi ar fee of defci es, as t Cour def s
3
ii
he ai
her n her se e r
i enci
he
t er
1 consi aton of any ot defci es i t paper pr
4
der i
her i enci n he
s esent untlafer as
ed
i t
sessi t
ng he
1 tm el
5 i i
ness i
ssue i t fr ti t
n he is ns ance.

l
6

DATED:

/ Q ; t.
3,
l

17

1
8
9
l

20

DA- V
-.

C. .
W

Unied St es DititJudge
t
at
s rc

1

21

22
23
24

25
26

'

27

'

28

B /casei o.nvsupr
hqpi/
nf
emecoud. publ
us/ i
/casevi do?cslD=s8z4
ew.
l
-

5-