Alexander et al v. Cahill et al
Filing
48
Letter Motion from Gregory A. Beck for James L. Alexander, Alexander & Catalano LLC, Public Citizen, Inc. requesting fees and costs submitted to Judge Frederick J. Scullin, Jr.. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum of Law # 2 Declaration of Gregory A. Beck# 3 Beck Declaration Exhibit 1# 4 Beck Declaration Exhibit 2# 5 Beck Declaration Exhibit 3# 6 Declaration of Brian Wolfman# 7 Certificate of Service)(Beck, Gregory)
<![CDATA[
Alexander et al v. Cahill et al
Doc. 48 Att. 4
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 1 of 7
Exhibit 2
Dockets.Justia.com
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 2 of 7
Time Record Report
STAFF
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
DATE CASENAME
1/5/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/15/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/19/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/22/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/22/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
3.5 0.8 0.3 5 0.8 0.5 6 2.7 Review, analyze, write memo on amended rules Ph interview with Jim Alexander Mtg. w/Brian re. merits of case Review N.D. rules, draft preliminary complaint Telephone mtg. w/Jim Alexander re. advertising, review firm's ads Ph. Mtg. with Jim, discuss focum, local counsel, proper defendants Expand/edit complaint, research standing, jurisdictional issues Edit complaint, review complaint with Brian and Jim, research on First Amendment/standing issues Review MCBA mtg. transcript Research on 30-day rule, First Amendment issues Edit/expand complaint, research proper defendants Review complaint w/Brian and Jim, edits Rsrch. Commercial speech issues for PI motion Review PI memo with Jim, edits to memo Rsrch./draft PI memo Prepare civil cover sheet for Scott Review memorandum of First Amendment research project by Emma Cheuse, incorporate her work into PI memo Update/edit complaint Finalize complaint and associated papers for filing, prepare service list, , prepare summonses for all defendants Research/draft PI memo Review filing order Research/draft PI memo Research/draft PI memo, review with Emma
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
1/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/25/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/26/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/28/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/29/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/29/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/30/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 1/30/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.7 2 4 2 2 0.3 7 0.2 1
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
1/31/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.2 4.3
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
2/2/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/2/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/4/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/5/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
7 0.5 2.5 6.5
Printed on: 9/4/2007 5:07:23 PM
Page 1 of 4
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 3 of 7
STAFF
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
DATE CASENAME
2/6/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/7/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/8/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/8/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/12/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/12/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/14/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/14/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/15/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
5 3 1.1 3 2.2 1.5 2 0.2 1.5 1.5 0.2 0.3 Review advertising materials provided by Jim Alexander, research/edit PI memo Edit PI memo, some additional research, create exhibits Prepare Catalano affidavit/exhibits Prepare Alexander Declaration in consultation with Jim, create exhibits Prepare pro hac motions for Brian and me Expand PI memo, some additionaol research, prepare motion Review/prepare DVD exhibit of commercials Edit/finalize pro hac motions Edit/finalize declarations Finalize PI motion/associated papers for filing Prepare corporate disclosure statement Coordinate with Alexander & Catalano paralegal for personal service on NY Ag's office Complete service by mail to all defendants Ph. Call w/Jim Alexander re. service issues/email to Pat McRae Write/file motion to move back hearing, at defendants' request Prepare notices of appearance for me and Brian Research empirical studies/task force on lawyer advertising Review response to PI motion and motion for summary judgment, research procedural issues Research NY corporate law and PC's corporate status Research response/discuss with Brian Research/begin writing reply brief Research First Amendment and procedural issues, write/edit reply brief Research/write reply brief Review corporate papers with Kristin Adams, work with Kristin to draft declaration Proof/edit/finalize/file reply brief
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
2/15/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/5/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/6/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/7/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/27/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.8 0.4 0.8 0.2 6 2.5
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
3/28/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/28/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 3/29/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/2/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/3/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/3/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
3 2 3 8 6 0.6 5
Printed on: 9/4/2007 5:07:23 PM
Page 2 of 4
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 4 of 7
STAFF
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
DATE CASENAME
4/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/12/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/13/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/17/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/18/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/19/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/20/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/25/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/27/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/8/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/11/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/24/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/25/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 6/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 6/15/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
4 2 3 2 4.5 7.9 0.2 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 1.2 1.8 6 0.4 4 0.2 4 6 0.2 0.3 0.4 1.5 4 10 12 0.8 1.5 Prepare for oral argument, review cases and briefs Moot court Prepare for argument, review cases First Amendment research Travel to Syracuse for hearing Travel to Syracuse, hearing on PI motion/motion to dismiss, travel to DC Telephone conference with defendants' counsel and Brian re. case management Draft civil case management plan Initial telephone conference with Magistrate Lowe, defendants' counsel Review transcript of hearing Review order on PI/motion to dismiss Draft proposed stipulation Draft joint letter to court, edits per Nelson Sheingold, review with Brian Research/draft memo. in support of SJ Ph. Cal with Nelson, revise stipulations Research/draft memo. In support of SJ Draft motion for summary judgment Write/edit SJ brief Research/write SJ brief Ph. Call with Nelson, edit joint statement Draft Beck declaration Edit joint stipulations, ph. Calls with Nelson Sheingold Review state's memorandum/answer Proof/edit SJ memorandum Research/write response memo. Research/write/edit response brief Review defendants' reply brief M oot
Printed on: 9/4/2007 5:07:23 PM
Page 3 of 4
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 5 of 7
STAFF
Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg Beck, Greg
DATE CASENAME
6/15/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 6/17/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 6/18/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 7/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 8/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 8/27/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 8/28/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 9/4/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
3 3 11.6 1 0.5 6.5 3 2 230.1 Prepare for argument, review briefs and cases Prepare for argument Travel to Syracuse for hearing, meet with clients, hearing, return home Review memorandum decision Letter motion re. fees Research Second Circuit law on fees, draft fee motion Research/draft fee motion, Beck Declaration Proof/edit fee motion, create exhibits
Sum:
Printed on: 9/4/2007 5:07:23 PM
Page 4 of 4
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 6 of 7
Time Record Report
STAFF
Wolfman, Brian
DATE CASENAME
1/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
1.5 Review and edit draft complaint (.8), talk to Greg Beck about possible changes to draft (.5), and consider argument to challenge 30day rule (.2) Talk to G Beck re status of complaint and temporary relief to be sought (.3) and read and edit second draft of complaint (.8) Read and edit most recent draft of complaint Read and edit draft by G Beck of preliminary injunction memorandum Meet with Greg Beck regarding questions and issues raised by his draft of prelim injunction brief Read and edit second draft of preliminary injurnction motion (1.3); work on my p.i. affidavit (.1) Read NY AG's opposition brief on PI motion (.7) and talk to Greg Beck re same (.3) Read and edit Greg Beck's draft reply brief in support of PI Talk to GB regarding my suggested edits and ideas for reply brief on PI Read and edit next draft of reply brief in support of PI Read briefs in prepartion for tomorrow's moot court Moot court and discussion in prepartion for Greg Beck for Friday's preliminary injunction hearing in Syracuse Travel to Syracuse for hearing Telephone conference with defendants' counsel about upcoming discovery conference with Magistrate Judge Preliminary injunction hearing in NDNY and return to DC Discussions with Greg Beck and reviewing letter to send to Magistrate Judge about stipulation Read and edit joint stipulations and material fact statement Review and edit Greg Beck's draft summary judgment brief
Wolfman, Brian
1/26/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
1.1
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
1/30/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/1/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 2/2/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.8 1.4 0.8
Wolfman, Brian
2/7/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
1.4
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
3/28/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/2/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/3/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/4/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/9/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
1 1.4 0.3 1.2 0.5 1.4
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
4/12/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/17/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
4.5 0.2
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
4/17/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 4/27/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
7.9 0.4
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
5/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 5/10/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.1 1.4
Printed on: 9/4/2007 2:25:42 PM
Page 1 of 2
Case 5:07-cv-00117-FJS-GHL
Document 48-5
Filed 09/04/2007
Page 7 of 7
STAFF
Wolfman, Brian
DATE CASENAME
6/18/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
TIME (hr) DESCRIPTION
11.6 Travel to Syracuse for summary judgment hearing, meeti with clients, hearing before Judge Scullin, and return to Washington (leave 8:35 am, get home 10:15 pm) Read district judge's ruling on summary judgment Review and edit fee motion (.3) and Beck declaration (.1), and draft my own fee declaration (.1) - - for section 1988 application
Wolfman, Brian Wolfman, Brian
7/23/2007 Alexander v. Cahill 8/31/2007 Alexander v. Cahill
0.7 0.5
Sum:
40.1
Printed on: 9/4/2007 2:25:44 PM
Page 2 of 2
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
