Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 141

MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 140 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits (Settlement Related and Pre-August 2003 Objections).. Document filed by M.J.G. Lime Wire Family Limited Partnership, Lime Wire LLC, Lime Group LLC, Mark Gorton. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A-B)(Baker, Charles)

EXHIBIT A

EXHIBIT A Exhibit No. 41 42 43 44 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 151 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 Exhibit Description E-mail from M. Gorton to E. Berger E-mail from J. Pelzer to storedev@limewire Article: Is LimeWire Going Legit? Not Yet P2P Blog: Limewire wants to start contextual advertising, became the Google of the P2P space Outline Conversion Proposal Conversion Plan Spreadsheet: Value of Converted Purchasers Conversion Plan Spreadsheet: Analyses of Users Conversion Plan: Projections Conversion Plan: Analyzing the LimeWire User Base Conversion Plan: LimeWire Users: Grouping Attitude and Behavior Document Relating to LimeWire's Conversion Into a Legitimate P2P Client E-mail from G. Bildson to R. Sterne Plan for LimeWire/Conversion Process Term Sheet: Lime Wire and RealNetworks, Inc. E-mail from G. Bildson to K. Catillaz, et al. E-mail from K. Catillaz to G. Bildson E-mail from M. Gorton to G. Bildson and K. Catillaz Draft Term Sheet: Lime Wire and iMesh E-mail from T. Marco to M. Gorton and K. Catillaz Draft Digital Sales Growth Plan Conversion Proposal Conversion Plan (Partial) Plan for Digital Market Growth Outline: New Plan E-mail from M. Gorton to N. Lovejoy

Exhibit No. 285 286 289 290 291 292 325

Exhibit Description E-mail from J. Rubenfeld to J. Rubenfeld (attaching Letter) Numerous documents re Filtering Hybrid Filtering Solution E-mail from G. Bildson to C. Bell E-mail from A. Rofman to G. Bildson, J. Rubenfeld and K. Catillaz E-mail from G. Bildson to S. Dupont E-mail from G. Bildson to A. Lenard, et al.

Deponent Catillaz

Page/Line 259:9-12 259:21-260:3 267:22-25 268:2-21 285:22-286:3 288:6-22 323:19-21

Bildson

152:16-21 161:16-162:20

Cho Rubenfeld Gribble

80:20-81:7 332:11-333:17 201:6-22 203:13-20 299:25-301:7

EXHIBIT B

EXHIBIT B Exhibit No. 3 13 14 52 53 54 64 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 Exhibit Description Email from J. Rubenfeld to M. Gorton with attached 2001 Lime Wire Offering Statement Email from M. Kotzen to J.K. Barret Slashdot Part of Lime Wire Offering Memorandum Letter from M. Gorton to Potential Investors Statement of LimeWire Goals The DCIA Conference & Exposition: P2P Media Summit LA Document (recent advances in peer-to-peer network design) by M. Gorton E-mail chain (S. Cho to G. Bildson, et al.) E-mail from S. Cho to M. Gorton, et al. E-mail chain (G. Bildson to J.K. Barret, et al.) E-mail chain (G. Bildson to M. Gorton, et al.) LimeWire List Several e-mails from J.K. Barret to websites Article: Online services vie to capture...Napster's users E-mails chain (G. Bildson/B. Hunter, et al.) E-mails from S. Ward to M. Gorton, et al E-mail from J.K. Barret to G. Bylinsky Press Release: In Wake of Napster Controversy, LimeWire Announces Explosive Growth of Gnutella Network E-mails from G. Bylinsky to J.K. Barret E-mail from G. Bildson to J.K. Barret Google Customer Account Pages E-mail from G. Bildson to everyone@limepeer Several articles including: Napster surfers catch New free wave E-mail from G. Bildson to [e-mail] E-mail from C. Rohrs to S. Cho E-mail from J.K. Barret to G. Bildson E-mails between M. Kotzen and J.K. Barret

Exhibit No. 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 102 120 121 122 123 124 135 136 137 138 139 174 178 179 187 188 189 190 192 196 205 206 Various promotional e-mails

Exhibit Description E-mail from G. Bildson to [e-mail] PC Pitstop: Napster and the File-Sharing Revolution Appendix I: Article ­ Napster: The Hot Idea of the Year Draft LimeWire Offering Memorandum (April 2001) Draft LimeWire Offering Memorandum (May 2001) Draft LimeWire Offering Memorandum (August 2001) Several Articles Including: Privacy Pillages Music Industry Google Customer Account Pages E-mail from G. Bildson to J. Watkins Press Release: Limewire Sees Usage Surge as Morpheus Falters Article: LimeWire Sees Usage Surge as Morpheus Falters Letter from M. Gorton to A. Gorton Letter from M. Gorton to "Dad & Mom" E-mail from S. Cho to everyone@limepeer E-mail from G. Bildson to everyone@limepeer E-mail from J. Watkins to J.K. Barret E-mail from A. Fisk to J.K. Barret E-mail chain (G. Bildson, M. Gorton, J.K. Barret, A. Brophy) Gnutella Forum >> Lime Wire Section Numerous Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Gnutella Forums >> LimeWire Section E-mail from S. Cho to G. Bildson, M. Gorton and others Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Google Groups Message Board Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Article: File Sharers Thrive Under RIAA Threat Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum

Exhibit No. 207 208 209 210 221 222 232 233 234 235 236 240 241 242 243 247 248 249 252 253 254 255 256 257 260 302 313

Exhibit Description Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Gnutella Developer Forum Article by A. Fisk Draft Article; Ultrapeers: Another Step Towards Gnutella Scalability E-mail from S. Cho to A. Fisk E-mail from C. Rohrs to G. Bildson, A. Fisk, et al. E-mail from G. Bildson to J.K. Barret Lime Wire >> Gnutella Network Health Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum E-mail from C. Rohrs to a Bang Networks employee Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum E-mail from A. Fisk to Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developer Forum Lime Wire Message Board Lime Wire Message Board E-mail from A. Fisk to S. Daswani, et al. Lime Wire LLC Profit and Loss Statement (Jan. 2000 to Sept. 2006) E-mail from C. Rohrs to J. Chang E-mail from C. Rohrs to R.A. Morris E-mail from C. Rohrs to A. Fisk Lime Wire "Backgrounder" Gnutella Forums >> Lime Wire Section Article: Will Gnutella Get Morpheus Back on Track? Numerous Articles Describing LimeWire's Use Yahoo! Groups--The Gnutella Developers Forum