Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 176

MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: 140 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits (Settlement Related and Pre-August 2003 Objections). ("Plaintiffs' Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Defendants' Settlement Related And Pre-August 2003 Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits To Their Motion For Partial Summary Judgment And Defendants' Motion To Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits"). Document filed by Capitol Records, Inc., Elektra Entertainment Group, Inc., Interscope Records, Laface Records LLC, Motown Record Company, L.P., Arista Records LLC, Priority Records LLC, Sony BMG Music Entertainment, UMG Recordings, Inc., Virgin Records America, Inc., Warner Bros. Records Inc., Atlantic Recording Corporation, BMG Music. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Forrest, Katherine)

EXHIBIT

B

EXHIBIT

B

: Exhlbit
3

::ˇ

ˇ

ˇ

,,,:

,,,ˇ,ˇ,,ˇ,,

ˇ

:::,ˇ : ::;,
.:

Exhibit
,k

Email
Statement

from

J. Rubenfeld

to

M.

Gorton

with

attached

2001

Lime

Wire

Offering

13 14 52 53 54

Email Slashdot
Part Letter Statement The

from

M.

Kotzen

to J.K.

Barret

of Lime from

Wire
M.

Offering Memorandum
to

Gorton

Potential

Investors

of LirneWire Conference

Goals &

64
68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75

DCIA

Exposition:

P2P

Media network

Summit

LA M. Gorton

Document E-mail

(recent advances
chain from chain
chain

in peer-to-peer

design) by

(S. Cho
S. Cho
to

to

G. M.

Bildson, Gorton,
to J.K.
to et

et

al.)

E-mail E-mail E-mail LimeWire Several Article: E-mails E-mails E-mail
Press

al.
et et

(G. Bildson (G. Bildson

Barret, Gorton,

al.) al.)

M.

List e-mails Online chain from from from
services J.K. vie Barret
to to

websites
users

capture...Napster's
Hunter,
et et

76
77

(G. Bildson/B.
S. Ward J.K. In Barret Wake
to

al.)
al

M.
to

Gorton,
G.

78
79

Bylinsky
LimeWire Announces

Release:

of Napster Controversy,
Network
J.K. Barret Barret
to

Explosive
80 81 82 E-mails

Growth
G.

of

Gnutella

from

Bylinsky
to

E-mail

from

G. Bildson Account

J.K.

Google
E-mail Several E-mail
E-mail E-mail

Customer

Pages
to

83
84 85 86 87

from

G. Bildson

everyone@limepeer
wave

articles from
from

including: Napster surfers catch New.free
to to

G. Bildson
C. Rohrs J.K. Barret M.

evervoneˇaˇmail.linˇepeer

S. Cho
to

from

G.

Bildson and J.K.
Barret

88

E-mails

between

Kotzen

89 90 91 92 93

E-mail
Various PC

from

G.

Bildson

to

[e-mail]

promotional

e-mails

Pitstop: Napster and the File-Sharing
I: Article
-

Revolution Idea

Appendix
Draft Draft Draft
Several

Napster: The

Hot

of the

Year

LimeWire LimeWire LimeWire
Articles Customer

Offering Memorandum Offering Memorandum Offering Memorandum

(April 2001) (May 2001) (August 2001)
Music

94
95 96 102 120 121 122 123 124 135 136 137 138 139 174 178 179 187 188 189 190

Including: Privacy Pillages
Account
to

Industry

Google
E-mail Press

Pages
J. Watkins Sees

from Release:

G. Bildson

Limewire Sees Gorton
Gorton
to

Usage Surge
as

as

Morpheus Falters

Article:
Letter Letter

LimeWire

Usage Surge
to to

Morpheus Falters

from from from from from from
chain

M. M.

A.

Gorton & Mom"

"Dad

E-mail E-mail E-mail E-mail
E-mail

S. Cho

everyone@limepeer
to
to

G. Bildson J. Watkins A. Fisk
to

everyone@limepeer
J.K. Barret

J.K.

Barret M.

(G. Bildson,
>>

Gorton,
Section
Lime Section

J.K.

Barret,

A.

Brophy)

Gnutella
Numerous

Forum Gnutella Forums Forums

Lime
Forums

Wire
>>

Wire

Section

Gnutella Gnutella
E-mail Gnutella

>>

Lime

Wire

>>

LimeWire
to

Section
M. Gorton

from

S. Cho
>>

G.

Bildson,
Wire

and others

Forums

Lime

Section

Google Groups Message Board
Gnutella Article: Gnutella
Yahoo!

192 196 205 206

Forums File

>>

Lime Thrive Lime

Wire

Section
RIAA

Sharers
>>

Under Wire

Threat

Forums

Section

Groups--The

Gnutella

Developer

Forum

207
208

Yahoo!
Yahoo!

Groups--The Groups--The Groups--The Groups--The Developer

Gnutella
Gnutella

Developer Developer Developer Developer by
A.

Forum Forum Forum Forum

209 210
221 222 232 233 234 235 236 240 241 242 243 247 248 249 252

Yahoo! Yahoo! Gnutella Draft E-mail
E-mail E-mail

Gnutella Gnutella
Forum

Article

Fisk Gnutella

Article; Ultrapeers: Another
from from from Wire
>>

Step Towards

Scalability

S. Cho C. Rohrs G.

to

A.

Fisk

to G.
to

Bildson,
J.K. Barret

A.

Fisk,

et

al.

Bildson
Gnutella

Lime Yahoo! E-mail
Yahoo!

Network Gnutella
to
a

Health

Groups--The
from
C. Rohrs

Developer

Forum

Bang Networks Developer Developer

employee
Forum Forum

Groups--The Groups--The
from Wire Wire from Wire from from from Wire
A. Fisk
to

Gnutella Gnutella Yahoo!

Yahoo! E-mail Lime Lime E-mail Lime E-mail E-mail E-mail
Lime Gnutella

Groups--The

Gnutella

Developer

Forum

Message Board Message Board
A. LLC

Fisk

to S. and
to to to

Daswani,
Loss

et

al.

Profit

Statement

(Jan.

2000

to

Sept. 2006)

253
254

C. Rohrs C. Rohrs

J.

Chang
Morris Fisk

R.A. A.

255
256 257 260

C. Rohrs

"Backgrounder"
>>

Forums Will

Lime
Get

Wire

Section
on

Article:
Numerous

Gnutella

Morpheus Back

Track?

302
313

Articles

Describing LimeWire's
Gnutella

Use Forum

Yahoo!

Groups--The

Developers