Viacom International, Inc. et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 304

DECLARATION of Andrew H. Schapiro, Group 4, Exhibit 78, Part 1 in Opposition re: 176 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment /Viacom's Notice of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Liability and Inapplicability of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act Safe Harbor Defense.. Document filed by Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC, Google, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 78, Part 2, # 2 Exhibit 79 - 84, # 3 Exhibit 85 - 90)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Schapiro Exhibit 79

Schapiro Exhibit 80

Subject: Hitmaker Comp
From:
To: Cc:

"Jackson, Brendan" "EX:/O=VIACOM/OU=MTVUSNCN=RECIPIENTS/CN=

BJACKSON69575362~
Roesch, Scott; Sanders, Joel; Albrecht, Chris; Barrera, John
Joves, Steve

Date:

Thu, 05 Apr 200716:45:59 +0000

i wanted to pass along the latest versions of the Hitmaker cpage. The text Is still FPO, but Chris's team should be providing copy tomorrow. From a layout perspective i think we are good to go though, and unless there are any major comments/concerns, we are going so start building these pages out. Please let me know any questions.
Thanks -

Brendan

brendan jackson
senior product manager
atom films/addicting clips
mtv networks

225 bush st. #1200

san francisco, ca 94104
0: 415.503.2442

f: 415.503.2555

List of attachments:

aL04_hitmaker.jpg ac06_hitmaker.jpg

CONFIDENTIAL

VIA 00866489

Become a star: Upload Now!

Now playing on Comedy Central:
Fat Girls On Bikes
from: kllerburrlto77

Your chance to be on

AtomFilms

You've just hit the big time
CLICK HERE TO UPLOAD VIDEOS!

Started on ,t,tomFilms and you can now see it on Comedy Central.

Future Shock
fruii.: kïllllrOurrlvll

Comedy Central's Test Pilots
StartinQ in June you can submit your pilot for and see if Comedy Central will put you on lV,

Lorem ipsuri dolor sit arnet., consectetur
adipisicing elit) sed do eiusrrod tempor

incididunt ut labore et dolor'e magna

~~~!L
.:IOlJl'

Star Wars Fan Movie Challenge
o;tartlnlJ in June you can submit 'i'our pilot for and see if Comedy Centlal will put you on TV,

Futiirp shock
from: kìllerburnlo77

Lorem ipsum deilol' sit arnet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor
incididunt ut labore et dol

Atom Films Studio
Starting in June you can submit \'our pilot for and see if Comedy Central will put you on 1\1,

ore magna

Future Shock
frm: kil"..burrto 71
Lorem ipsum doloi' sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna

500 MORE REASONS TO UPLOAD

. Sed LIt perspiciatis LInde om nis

. Sed ut perspiciatis LInde om nis
Future shock
froni: kilerbun;1. 7 7

Lorern ipsurn dolor sit ,3met, consectetUl'
adipisicing a/it, sed do E'¡usrnod tempor

. Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis
. Sed LIt perspiciatis LInde om nis

incididunt ut labore et dolore magna

VIA00866490

Future Shuck
frn"ll J(ille:mumoo77 ~,

Comedy CentralTs Test Pilots
Starting in June you can submit your pilot for and
see if Comedy Centtal will put you on lV,

Lo¡-cm ipsum dolor :;it dmct! con::cctctUl adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor

incididunt ut labore et dolore magna

;,_
ilãtoll'

Star Wars Fan Movie challenge
staitiiig in June you can si~bmit your pilot for and
see if Comody Centlal will put you on Tv.

i'~:,;;;;,\,,',';t.;;iii,;',"

Future Shock
frm: killeroumto71

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing ellt, sed do eiusmod tempoc' incididunt ut labor8 et dolore magna

AtomFilms StLldio
Starting in June you can submit your pilot for and see if Comedy Central will put you on TV,

Future Shock
frtH. ltillcrbuml:'J"J

Lorem ìpsurn dolor sit arnet, consectetur adlpisicinQ elit, sed dc, en.ismod tempor incididunt ut labot8 et dolore magna

. Sed ut perspiciatis LInde om nis
. Sed LIt perspiciatis LInde om nis

Future Shock
frm; itilierourni'o77 Lorern ipsurn dolot sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eilismod ternpor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna

. Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis . Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis

VIA00866491

Schapiro Exhibit 81

Schapiro Exhibit 82

Schapiro Exhibit 83

1

U N I T E D S T A T E S D I S T R I CT C O U R T F O R T H E S O U T H E R N D I S TR I C T O F N E W Y O R K

VI AC OM I NT ER NA TI ON AL , INC ., C OM ED Y P A R T N E R S , C O U N T R Y M U SI C T E L E V I S I O N , I N C . , P A RA M O U N T PI CT UR ES C OR PO RA TI ON , and B LA CK E N T E R T A I N M E N T T E L E V I SI O N , L L C ,

) ) ) ) ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) ) vs . ) NO . 07 -C V- 22 03 ) Y O U T U B E , I N C . , Y O U T U BE , L L C , ) an d GO OG LE , IN C. , ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ) ) T H E F O O T B A L L A S S O C I A TI O N P R E M I E R ) L E A G U E L I M I T E D , B O U R NE C O . , e t a l . , ) o n b e h a l f o f t h e m s e l ve s a n d a l l ) o t h e r s s i m i l a r l y s i t ua t e d , ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) vs . ) NO . 07 -C V- 35 82 ) Y O U T U B E , I N C . , Y O U T U BE , L L C , a n d ) GO OG LE , IN C. , ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ) VI DE OT AP ED D EP OS IT IO N OF CH AD H UR LE Y S A N F R A N C I S C O , C A L I F OR N I A WE DN ES DA Y, A PR IL 2 2, 2 009 B Y : A N D R E A M . I G N A C IO H O W A R D , C S R , R P R , C L R JO B NO . 16 78 9

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

AP RI L 22 , 20 09 9: 08 a .m .

VI DE OT AP ED D EP OS IT IO N OF CH AD H UR LE Y, h e l d a t t h e o f f i c e s of S H E A R M A N & S T E R L I N G , 5 2 5 M a r k e t S t r e e t , S an F r a n c i s c o , C a l i f o r n i a , p u r s u a n t t o n o t i c e , be f o r e A N D R E A M . I G N A C I O H O W A R D , C L R , C C R R , R PR , C S R L i c e n s e N o . 9 8 3 0 .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

A P P E A R A N C E S:

FO R THE P LA INT IF FS VI ACO M IN TER NA TIO NA L, IN C. : JE NN ER & BL OCK , LLP By : SC OT T WIL KE NS, E sq.

10 99 Ne w Yo rk Av enu e, NW , Su ite 9 00 Wa sh ing to n, D. C. 20 00 1 (2 02 ) 6 39 -6 000 swi lk ens@j en ner .c om

F O R T H E L E A D P L A I N T I F F S AN D P R O S P E C T I V E C L A S S : BE RN STE IN L ITO WI TZ BE RGER & GRO SS MAN N LLP By : JO HN C . B RO WNE , Esq .

1 2 8 5 A v e n u e O f T h e A m e r i ca s Ne w Yor k, N ew Yo rk 10 019 (2 12 ) 5 54 -1 533 joh nb @blbg la w.c om

FO R THE P LA INT IF FS VI ACO M IN TER NA TIO NA L I NC .: SH EA RMA N & STE RL ING L LP By : S T U A R T J . B A S K I N , E sq .

59 9 Lex in gt on Av enu e N e w Y o r k , N e w Y o r k 1 0 0 2 2 -6 0 6 9 (2 12 ) 8 48 -4 000 stu ar t.bas ki n@s he arm an .co m

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES

(Continued.)

F OR T HE D EF EN D AN TS Y OUTU B E, I NC ., Y OU T UB E, L LC a nd G OO GL E, I NC .: M AY ER B RO WN , L LP B y: AN DR EW H . S CH AP IRO, Es q. B RI AN W IL LE N, Es q. 1 67 5 Br oa dw ay N ew Y or k, N ew Yo rk 1 0019 - 58 20 ( 21 2) 5 06 -2 27 9 as ch apir o @m ay er .c om

A LS O PR ES EN T: G OO GL E B y: ADAM L. BAREA, Litigation Counsel

1600 Amphitheater Parkway Mountain View, California 94043 ( 65 0) 2 14 -4 87 9 ad am bare a @g oo gl e. co m

KEN REESER, Videographer.

- -- oO o- --

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

76 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:58:49 10:58:55 10:58:59 10:59:02 10:59:06 10:59:09 10:59:11 10:59:13 10:59:18 10:59:22 10:59:26 10:59:30 10:59:32 10:59:34 10:59:37 10:59:41 10:59:44 10:59:45 10:59:48 10:59:50 10:59:53 10:59:58 11:00:00 11:00:02

H UR LE Y, C HA D Q Did you have any other goals at that time

w it h re sp ec t to t h e Yo uT ub e we bs it e ? A I can't, you know, remember specifically.

I t' s ju st w e -- w e w an te d to b ui ld a -- a g re at s i te . W e wa nt ed t o bu il d a g re at t ea m. w e we re c re atin g b us in es s. o n al l le ve ls. Q Was one of your goals at this time to W e -- y ea h, I m ea n ,

We w an t t o be s uc ce ss fu l

p ot en ti al ly sel l t he Y ou Tu be w eb si t e? A I mean, yeah. Y ou c ou ld d re am . We - - we It

n ev er i ma gi ned wh a t wo ul d ha ve h ap p en ed, yo u kn ow . l oo ks l ik e I'm di s cu ss in g go in g pu b li c. I me an , we

d id h av e th e ex pe r ie nc e of b ei ng i n vo lved w it h Pa yP a l. W e sa w wh at was p o ss ib le w it h ju st -- com e up w it h a s im pl e id ea tha t w ou ld e mp ow er p eo p le wit h, y ou k no w , an otherwise complicated procedure that, you know, g iv e th em a sol ut i on . S o, y ou k no w, i f w e di d th e ri gh t t hi ngs, p ot en ti al ly we co u ld - - we w ou ld f i nd our se lv es i n t he s am e po si ti on. Q W e w er e op ti mi st ic ab out th at .

Would -- would having additional traffic help

a dv an ce y ou r go al of p ot en ti al ly s e ll ing th e Yo uT ub e w eb si te ? A S ur e. It c ou l d be a f ac to r.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

77 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:00:04 11:00:09 11:00:11 11:00:13 11:00:15 11:00:16 11:00:23 11:00:27 11:00:30 11:00:31 11:00:34 11:00:38 11:00:42 11:00:47 11:00:50 11:00:53 11:00:56 11:00:59 11:01:02 11:01:05 11:01:08 11:01:12 11:01:15 11:01:20

H UR LE Y, C HA D Q Would having additional traffic help increase

t he p ri ce b y wh ic h y ou m ig ht b e ab l e to s el l th e Y ou Tu be w eb site ? A Y ea h. Again, it -- it could be one of the

f ac to rs t ha t so me o ne w ou ld c on si de r . Q Can you think of any other reason, other than

o ne s th at w e've d i sc us se d, w hy - - w hy You Tu be n ee de d t o at tr ac t more t r af fi c in J ul y of 20 05? M R. S CH AP IR O: T HE W IT NE SS : y ou n ec es sa rily m e an . Ob j ec ti on ; la ck s fo u nd atio n. Y ea h , I -- I d on 't k n ow wha t I t ju st - - l ik e I sa id , we w e re

t ry in g to b uild a gr ea t se rv ic e, a gr eat si te o n al l l ev el s, j us t... M R. B RO WN E: Q. B ut a s of J ul y of '0 5

a nd - - an d I'm so r ry i f yo u an sw er e d this a lr ea dy , b ut y ou w er e al read y c on si de ri ng - - yo u a nd y ou r cofounders were already considering selling a dv er ti se me nts on th e Yo uT ub e we bs i te ; is t ha t ri gh t ? A It's probably something -- it's probably I do n' t kn ow , y ou I c an 't

s om et hi ng t hat we we re c on si de ri ng .

k no w, s pe ci fica ll y i f -- o f ou r pl a ns . r em em be r at the t i me .

Y ou k no w, a g ai n, a no th er t hi n g

t ha t we w er e -- w e w er e lo ok in g at do ing is - - is , y ou k no w, c re at ing a s it e th at p eo pl e c ou ld s ha re t he ir

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

78 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:01:23 11:01:24 11:01:26 11:01:31 11:01:34 11:01:37 11:01:40 11:01:42 11:01:44 11:01:46 11:01:51 11:01:52 11:01:53 11:01:56 11:01:58 11:02:02 11:02:03 11:02:06 11:02:08 11:02:10 11:02:12 11:02:23 11:02:28 11:02:28

H UR LE Y, C HA D e xp er ie nc es . i m ea n, t he se s it e s, S tu pi d Vi de os or Big B oy s or , yo u kn ow , w hi ch b ec am e gr e at , th es e we re s it es t ha t were p a yi ng p eo pl e to d o , basi ca ll y, s tu p id t hi ng s. Yo u kn ow , j um pi ng o ff b ui l di ngs, d ri nk in g a T ha t' s n ot wha t we w an te d

g al lo n of m ilk, w h at ev er . t he s it e to be ab o ut . c om mu ni ty . Q

W e we re t ry i ng to bu il d a

Well, you were also, at that time, thinking

o f wa ys t o star t m ak in g mo ne y of f o f the we bs it e; w er en 't y ou ? A I'm sure, but, I mean, we were thinking about I me an , at

l ot s of t hi ngs be y on d ju st a dv er ti s in g.

t he e nd o f the da y , yo u ha ve t o cr e at e a gr ea t se rv i ce f or y ou r us ers an d b ui ld a g re at c o mm unit y to - - to h av e an y ch ance o f s uc ce ss . Q And you have to have a lot of traffic to have

a ny c ha nc e of s uc c es s; i s th at r ig h t? A Again, that's another factor that would come Sur e. Le t' s m ar k Ex hi bi t 6.

i nt o pl ay .

M R. B RO WN E:

( Do cu me nt m arke d H ur le y, C ., E xh ib i t 7 f or i de nt if icat io n .) M R. B AS KI N: I be l ie ve , Ex hi bi t 7.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

79 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:02:30 11:02:41 11:02:57 11:03:01 11:03:02 11:03:03 11:03:05 11:03:07 11:03:08 11:03:10 11:03:12 11:03:13 11:03:19 11:03:20 11:03:28 11:03:29 11:03:32 11:03:45 11:03:48 11:03:51 11:03:54 11:03:56 11:03:58 11:04:00

H UR LE Y, C HA D M R. B RO WN E: T HE W IT NE SS : M R. B RO WN E: s ai d 7. M R. S CH AP IR O: M R. B RO WN E: T HE W IT NE SS : M R. B RO WN E: T HE W IT NE SS : T hi s is 7 . O h, o ka y. S o yo u we re r i gh t. O h, E xh ibit 7. Th an ks . W ai t. I' m so rr y .

T h at 's a l on g o ne .

I said 6, and you guys

Sh ou ld I s t ar t re ad in g i t? Y ea h, y ou k n ow - It l oo ks l i ke a r es um é i n th e

m id dl e he re , s o I' ll ski p t hr ou gh t ha t . M R. B RO WN E: Q w ha t -A Q t ha t. A Q In the middle there. Y ea h. I s th at t he ri gh t on e? S or r y ab ou t I 'm s or ry. Ca n I se e

You said it looks like a resumé?

We ha ve t he s a me o ne .

It didn't seem right to me. Y ea h. Y ea h, i n f ac t, M r. H u rl ey , I -- s o w e ca n al l

g et o ut o f he r e to da y, I -- I 'l l te ll yo u I' m no t going to ask you any questions about any part of this d oc um en t st ar t in g on the se co nd h al f o f pa ge t wo an d c on ti nu in g to th e en d. A l ea st . O ka y. I'll hurry up and read my part, at

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

267 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:10:01 17:10:05 17:10:06 17:10:09 17:10:16 17:10:22 17:10:25 17:10:29 17:10:31 17:11:38 17:11:47 17:11:49 17:11:51 17:11:53 17:11:57 17:11:59 17:12:02 17:12:09 17:12:14 17:12:19 17:12:24 17:12:24 17:12:29 17:12:32

H UR LE Y, C HA D e -m ai l? A Q Y ea h, i t l oo ks l ik e I go t i t. A nd t he re ac tu al ly w as a pr io r e- ma il

r ef er en ce t ha t y ou s en t ou t o n No ve mb er 1 6t h , 20 06 , r es po nd in g to P e te r Ch an g in wh ic h yo u st at e d th at t hi s co ul d po te n ti al ly b e a v er y po we rf ul a c qu is it io n f or G oo gl e; c or r ec t? A Y ea h, i t l oo ks l ik e th at ' s wh at I d id , y ea h.

M R. S CH AP IR O:

O bj ec ti on ; as k ed a nd a ns we re d .

M R. B AS KI N:

Q.

A nd , in f ac t , ba si ca ll y al l

o f th e me di a co m pa ni es t ha t y ou w er e ta lk in g t o in a nd a ro un d Oc to be r 2 00 6 wa nt ed y o u to a do pt a s i mi la r t ec hn ol og y to t h is , a fi lt er i ng t ec hn ol og y; is n' t th at c or re ct ? M R. S CH AP IR O: M R. B AS KI N: A Q. O bj ec ti on ; la c ks f ou nd at io n. I s th at t ru e , si r? I --

I t ma y ha v e be en t he c as e .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

268 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:12:35 17:12:37 17:12:41 17:12:44 17:12:45 17:12:48 17:12:56 17:12:58 17:13:02 17:13:04 17:13:07 17:13:10 17:13:13 17:13:13 17:13:15 17:13:21 17:13:22 17:13:26 17:13:26 17:13:28 17:13:29 17:13:38 17:13:44 17:13:45

H UR LE Y, C HA D Q A D o yo u kn ow w ho K e vi n Do na hu e is ? Y ea h, I t hi nk h e l ea ds p ar tn er sh ip s, s o me I th in k he r ep or ts t o - - to

p ar tn er sh ip s fo r us . C hr is , I th in k. Q

A nd d id h e re po rt to y ou t ha t al l of yo ur

w ou ld -b e pa rt ne rs b as i ca ll y wa nt Y ou Tu be t o a gr ee t o c er ta in f il te ri ng a nd co py ri gh t pr ot ec ti on s t an da rd s a s pa rt o f tr an sa ct io n s? A I t ma y ha ve b ee n t he c as e. I me an , w e ma ke

o ur t oo ls a va il ab le t o t he m.

We w an t to m a ke o ur Th ey do n' t ne ed

t oo ls a va il ab le g en er a ll y to a ny on e.

t o -- t o en te r in to a li ce ns in g ag re em en t b ec au se o f i t. Q O ka y. We 'l l ge t t o th at .

W e' ll j us t ma rk - - le t 's m ar k as E xh ib it 2 6 , w hi ch w e' ll p ro vi de t o e ve ry on e. ( Do cu me nt m ar ke d Hu rl e y, C ., E xh ib it 2 6 f or i de nt if ic at io n. ) T HE V ID EO GR AP HE R: y ou r mi cr op ho ne u p? M R. B AS KI N: M R. S CH AP IR O: T HE W IT NE SS : q ui ck ly . Ye s. So r ry . Co u ns el , co ul d yo u sl id e

Sh e' s m ar ki ng i t. O ka y. L et m e ju st r ea d th is

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

269 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:13:50 17:13:51 17:13:55 17:13:57 17:13:58 17:14:56 17:14:59 17:15:03 17:15:05 17:15:06 17:15:09 17:15:13 17:15:17 17:15:18 17:15:20 17:15:21 17:15:26 17:15:29 17:15:34 17:15:36 17:15:40 17:15:43 17:15:43 17:15:46

H UR LE Y, C HA D M R. B AS KI N: Ju s t, a ga in , to sp ee d th in gs

a lo ng , I' m on ly go in g to b e r ef er en ci ng t he fi rs t p ar ag ra ph w it h y ou , so w e ca n t ry t o ge t ev e ry on e to t he g ar ag e on t i me . T HE W IT NE SS : M R. B AS KI N: O k ay . Q. A ll r ig h t.

N ow , ag ai n, th is i s an

e -m ai l, E xh ib it 26 , an e -m ai l , in f ac t, r ec e iv ed b y y ou , co rr ec t, s i r? A Q Y ea h, t ha t 's w ha t it l oo k s li ke . A nd i n th e f ir st p ar ag ra p h, M r. D on ah ue is

d is cu ss in g wi th yo u so me o f t he w is he s of t h e ne tw or ks a nd s tu di os w it h w hi ch y ou a r e en ga gi ng i n d is cu ss io ns a t th e ti me ; is th at c or re ct ? A Y ea h, i t l oo ks l ik e th at ' s wh at h e' s

d is cu ss in g he re . Q A nd a mo ng th e th in gs t ha t t he y wa nt , I

b el ie ve , he s ay s , "I b el ie ve th e bu si ne ss d e ve lo pm en t p eo pl e wo ul d li k e to d o a de a l, b ut y ou m us t - - th ey m us t sa ti sf y th e ir l aw ye rs a n d th at m ea ns t h at t he y w an t Yo uT ub e to ag re e to c er t ai n fi lt er in g a nd c op yr ig ht p ro te c ti on s ta nd ar d s" ; do y ou s ee th at ? A Q I s ee t ha t . A nd w as t h e tr an sa ct io n w it h Au di bl e Ma g ic ,

a t le as t in p ar t , in te nd ed t o p ro vi de a f il t er in g

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

285 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:35:14 17:35:15 17:35:17 17:35:18 17:35:21 17:35:22 17:35:24 17:35:27 17:35:32 17:35:36 17:35:38 17:35:46 17:35:49 17:35:49 17:35:52 17:35:52 17:35:52 17:35:54 17:35:55 17:35:56 17:36:00 17:36:03 17:36:07 17:36:08

H UR LE Y, C HA D c om e on b oa rd . Q A re y ou s u gg es ti ng t h at y ou t hi nk yo u mi gh t

h av e en te re d i nt o a tech n o- - - a li ce n se a gr ee me n t w it h NB C in a n d ar ou nd F e br ua ry 2 00 7? A I d on 't k n ow i f it w a s pa rt o f t ha t de al o r I do n' t k no w.

i f th is w as a se pa ra te o n e. Q

And did you, in fact, not end up offering to

N BC i n an d ar o un d Fe brua r y 20 07 v id eo te ch no - -fingerprinting technology once they declined to enter i nt o a li ce ns e a gr ee ment wi th Y ou Tu be ? M R. S CH AP IR O: M R. B AS KI N: u nc le ar s yn ta x . M R. S CH AP IR O: o ff er in g -T HE W IT NE SS : M R. S CH AP IR O: M R. B AS KI N: i t up . Q O nc e th ey de cl in ed t o e nt er i nt o a l ic en se Ye ah . - - on ce t h ey d ec li ne d. O ka y. Thank you. L et m e c le ar D id y ou, i n fa ct , no t e nd u p O bj ec tion ; u nc le ar s yn t ax . You can answer a question with

a gr ee me nt w it h y ou , isn' t i t tr ue , si r , th at y ou r ef us ed t o pr o vi de N BC w i th - - wi th f i lt er in g t ec hn ol og y -- wi th f inge r pr in ti ng t ec h no lo gy i n an d a ro un d Fe br ua r y 20 07 ?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

286 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:36:10 17:36:11 17:36:12 17:36:14 17:36:17 17:36:19 17:36:20 17:36:24 17:36:28 17:36:29 17:36:31 17:36:35 17:36:37 17:36:41 17:36:42 17:36:43 17:36:44 17:36:47 17:36:51 17:36:53 17:36:55 17:37:00 17:37:02 17:37:05

H UR LE Y, C HA D M R. S CH AP IR O: d ec li ne d. T HE W IT NE SS : Y ea h , so , as su mi ng t h ey Ob j ec ti on ; as su me s t he y

d ec li ne d an d, y ou kn ow , as su mi ng I wo uld re me mb er t h is deal, I -- I do not know. M R. B AS KI N: Q. V ia co m th e sa me t h in g? We re

y ou p re pa re d to o f fe r Vi ac om f in ge r pr inti ng t ec hn ol o gy i n an d ar ou nd D ec e mb er , Ja nu ar y, F e br uary , of 2 00 6 a nd 2 00 7? A Q I -- I don't know. And once Viacom refused to enter into a

l ic en se a gr eeme nt wi th Y ou Tu be , di d Y ouTu be o ff er V ia co m fi ng erpr in t in g te ch no lo gy i n - - in a nd a ro un d F eb ru ar y 20 07? M R. S CH AP IR O: c om po un d. T HE W IT NE SS : A ga i n, l ik e al l of t h es e Ob j ec ti on ; fo un da ti o n;

e xa mp le s, I do no t k no w wh at w as i n t he d ea l te rm s. M R. B AS KI N: Q. H ow a bo ut E MI M us i c Grou p?

A re y ou f am ilia r w it h th at t ra ns ac t io n? A You know, I -- I know of the company. Yo u

k no w, t he - - I kn e w we w er e tr yi ng to ent er d ea ls w i th a ll o f th e majo r m us ic l ab el s. t he s pe ci fi c te rm s , bu t. .. Ag a in , I do n' t kn ow

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

287 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:37:06 17:37:10 17:37:11 17:37:11 17:37:14 17:37:16 17:37:17 17:37:17 17:37:20 17:37:23 17:37:25 17:37:26 17:37:28 17:37:32 17:37:33 17:37:37 17:37:37 17:37:40 17:37:48 17:37:57 17:38:01 17:38:06 17:38:07 17:38:10

H UR LE Y, C HA D Q A t he m. Q A nd a s pa r t of t ha t t ra ns ac ti on w i th E MI , D id y ou e n te r in to a tr an sa ct io n w it h EM I? I think we were able to reach agreement with

t he y pr ov id ed yo u wi th a li ce ns e ag re e me nt , di d th e y n ot ? A Q Y ea h. A nd a s pa r t of t he t r an sa ct io n wi t h EM I fo r a

license agreement, you offered them fingerprint t ec hn ol og y, d i d yo u not, Mr . Hu rl ey ? A Q I d on 't k n ow . Are you familiar with the -- with the D i d an yo ne r ep o rt t o yo u a bo ut

t ra ns ac ti on w i th E MI ? i t, s ir ? A M ax cy . Q

Again, it would probably go up to Chris

W er e yo u t ol d, s ir , t ha t in c on ne c ti on w it h

EMI's transaction, that YouTube contracted to provide E MI w it h au di o f in ge rpri n ti ng t ec hn ol o gy t ha t sh al l be -- shall be 95 percent or greater effective at p ro te ct in g th e m fr om upl o ad s on y ou r w eb si te ? A W el l, c on s id er in g I d on 't r em em be r t he t er ms

f ro m an y of t h es e de als, I' m su re I d o n' t re me mb e r t ha t nu mb er a s w el l.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

316 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:40:47 18:40:54 18:40:58 18:41:01 18:41:04 18:41:10 18:41:15 18:41:16 18:41:19 18:41:19 18:41:23 18:41:25 18:41:27 18:41:28 18:41:29 18:41:29 18:41:30 18:41:33 18:41:34 18:41:36 18:41:38 18:48:58 18:49:02 18:49:02

H UR LE Y, C HA D Q Do you recall the proposals or suggestions

t ha t Mr . Fr ickl as ma ke s on t he t op of pag e tw o of t h is letter having been discussed internally at YouTube? A We may have. Li ke I s ai d, I d i dn 't s ee t hi s. I --

I d on 't r em embe r s ee in g th is s pe ci f ic doc um en t. I -- I can't remember if it was discussed, these s pe ci fi c po ints . M R. B AS KI N: T ha nk y ou . T HE W IT NE SS : T ha n k yo u. T hi s co nc lu de s t od ay's I ha v e no f ur th er q ue s ti ons.

T HE V ID EO GR APHE R: v id eo ta pe d depo si t io n -M R. S CH AP IR O: u nf or tu na te ly. T HE V ID EO GR APHE R: M R. S CH AP IR O:

No , n o, i t do es n' t,

O ka y.

I' m g oi ng t o ha ve a co uple o f

m in ut es o f redi re c t, b ut w e' ll n ee d t o st ep o ut a nd p re pa re f or a s ec o nd . T HE V ID EO GR APHE R: T he t im e is 6 :4 0 .

W e' re o ff t he r ec o rd . ( Re ce ss t ak en.) T HE V ID EO GR APHE R: T he t im e is 6 :4 8 p .m.

W e' re b ac k on t he re co rd . / //

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

317 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:49:04 18:49:04 18:49:08 18:49:11 18:49:14 18:49:15 18:49:19 18:49:23 18:49:29 18:49:32 18:49:35 18:49:35 18:49:38 18:49:40 18:49:43 18:49:46 18:49:48 18:49:50 18:49:50 18:49:51 18:49:51 18:49:51 18:50:06 18:50:06

H UR LE Y, C HA D E XA MI NA TI ON B Y M R. S CHAP I RO M R. S CH AP IR O: Q. M r. H u rl ey , do y ou re ca ll

g iv in g so me t e st im on y ea r li er t od ay a b ou t th e lo ss of s om e of y ou r e -m ai l mess a ge s? A Q Yes, I remember that. I'm going to represent to you that this W as th e lo ss o f t he

l aw su it w as f i le d in Mar c h 20 07 .

e -m ai ls p ri or to t he fil i ng o f th is l a ws ui t? A Yes, the -- the loss of my e-mail happened

while we were in San Mateo and well before the l aw su it . Q Was the loss of those e-mails prior to the

acquisition of YouTube by Google? A Y es , ab so l ut el y. M R. S CH AP IR O: M R. B AS KI N: w it hi n tw o mi n ut es . M R. S CH AP IR O: G re at . S a id w e wo ul d. N ot hi ng f u rt he r. That was easy. Yo u ma de it

T HE V ID EO GR AP H ER :

T his c on cl ud es t he

d ep os it io n of Ch ad H urle y i n th e ma tt e r of V ia co m International, Incorporated, and The Football Association Premier League Limited, et al., vs. YouTube, Incorporated. W e' re o ff t he re co rd .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

318 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:50:07 18:50:10

H UR LE Y, C HA D T he t im e is 6:4 9 p .m . ( WH ER EU PO N, the d e po si ti on e nd ed a t 6 :49 p. m. ) - -- oO o- --

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 805 Third Avenue, New York, New York 10022 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 84