Viacom International, Inc. et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 316

DECLARATION of Susan J. Kohlmann in Support re: 176 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment /Viacom's Notice of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Liability and Inapplicability of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act Safe Harbor Defense.. Document filed by Country Music Television, Inc., Paramount Pictures Corporation, Viacom International, Inc., Black Entertainment Television, LLC, Comedy Partners. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29)(Kohlmann, Susan)

To: From:

'FranckChastagnol'<tchastagnol @youtube.com> 'MatthewLiu'<[e-mail]~

<[e-mail]>. 'Chris Mercy' <[e-mail]>
Bcc:

Cc:

'FreyWaid` <[e-mail]
23:52:31 CST

om,. Chen' 'Steve

Sent Date:

200608-16

Subject.
Guys.

Re: (Uncle]Result of fingerprintingon random videos

I ran through all the videos one by one. C)uitea pain but I classified the videos by type to the best of my knowledge (for a few of the videos I was

unsure...lhere were also some videosthat have been removed).lf tryto we
separate between copyright (MusicVideo, Live Performance, TV

shows/commercials. Karaoke.Mashups. Compilations) non copyright vs. (00
melody or user-generated music) the breakdown is:

-Copyn`gM roughly 47% has some sort of copyright contentin it (bitsof
music. anime. footage from tv commercials, etc...not all of it is
necessan'ly infringing) -Non copyright - 50"/0

Thardts,
Matt

Attachments: ATT00601.htm

result_random_video

Matt.~s

DEPONENT: EXHIBIT# B P~nPr)c~ull cKr~~
Premier League, al.,v. YouTube, al., et et CaseNos.07-CV-2203 07-CV-3582 and A.Ignacio Howard, RPR,CSRNo.9830 CLR, Association

DATE: '~·cZ.o~3

CASE: Viacom,al.,v.YouTube, The et etal., Football

Highly

Confidential

600001-00730943

B
GraceNote(GN)vs AodibleMagic (AM) accuracytests

Feuillel
Date: 13 2006 Sun, Aug 23:27:29 Nbvideos 1
GN matches 1

1

AMmatches

Page 1

E
I
tt·

Peuillel

Ratio

Page2

t;euillel

g

(·,3audio by could bB run AM tosome with matched GN not be through due issUe snippets
----------

:I

5

Page3

E`euillel

6

E

i~euillel

6

Page5

r".
~euillel

a

t'·

o

Papeb
S
w

to

E

B
b
P

I

Page7

I
cO

5]

6

Page 8

Q
B
a F

t~euillel

&

Page5)

I
a

Feuillel

b

Page 10

~6'

n

B
b

6

Page11

tf
-t

o, ~L

bo a

o

~-000000000007

0000

Q

FeujUel

Page 13

I
C

t~euillel

Pa~e 14

E'euillel

F

b

Page 15

t~euillel

o

g:

r·

Page16

o
o o o o o o ::c·-:: o o o o o
o

t

o
o

- ·: I

o o o o o o o ::o o o
o o

o

o
o

o

~d
.3

o
L O lan!na~I O O . O

$

d

O

O

Q

E

~·

: .. -:::::.: i-:i~ ~::i:l;--i- _ ::'~i:_:· iii::lil' i :::i.i::i·:ii~'--: ::: :::

o~

Page18

E

Feuillel

P
r·

e:

r

Page 19

Q
.; 8
C~

Feuillel

$

Page 20

E'euillel

EI

Page 21

Feuillel
a

F

Page 22

t~euillel

P
F

e

Page23

L960EL00-T00003

~e~uapr3u03

6T96+H

VI V1

N

olooooooo~oooooooo~ooooooo-ooo-oo-oo

'd no
p

ru
(D

i.

~D

N

3:

~euille

1

8

Copyrighted

46.97%

a
i!

Non·copyrighted

50.00%

o o

r
o o w
o

Page 25

co m

.p

3

E g

I;euillel

r
o o w o \o
a

o o

Page 26

I

t~euillel
o
o a m

F C

o
o

r
o
o

Page 27

w o to
o

Z

Feuillel
(7

n

o o

r
o o
w

Page 28

o to r

m

Feuillel I
a

B
F

C

o o

Page 29
o o
w

o to h,

i

f~euillel
o

F e

o

Paee 30
o
o

w o to
w

On Aug 14, 2006, at 10:02 AM, Frey Waid =role: =BLOCKQUOTI3 type="cite"~~ii ~ranck, Out of curiosity, did any of the XML responses from =ither GN or AM contain distributor info --

Warner =therwise'! or Maybe, =ould submit we something knowis Warner we content(pcrhaps
= private music file) to see if we get the distributor name in the =eed. No, neither AM nor C;N

seem =o send us back this info, even though the XML responsehas provisionfor returning=t.l

needto follow withthemto =nderstand theydo notpopulatethesefields theresponse. up why in It doesseemclearto me that we willwantto =nvestigate video fingerprinting technology that so we can=ifrerentiate betweencopyrighted audiotracksandcopyrighted music =ideos. agreed,
videc~ =ingerpnnling would hring us to the next level.

Also, I'm not sure we have a =ood solutionyet for identifying live concerts. descriptivetext

filtering almost will =crtainly insufGcicnt. doesnotdo a goodjob at identifying be AM musicon =iveperformance. is better.Now you=aying needto differentiate GN are we copyrighted song
from a live performance vs copyrighted song from a music =ideo or a TV show ~Lel's talk about that - I =ay be Inissing something.
Thanks,Franck

I;ranck Chastagnol wrote: Iii team,

I ran both GraceNote and AudibleMagic against a =andom set of 133 videos from our site:- GN

=dentifiedcopyrightedmusic in
of =hese videos.

* these videos.-AM identifiedcopyrightedmusic in of

'I`his seems confirm resultsoTtheprevious in termsof matching to the =esl technology: is C;N
superior.

I did not have time to look at all the videoswith a =atch but it seems that in most cases, these are

personal videos =hatusers editedto addmusicto.I foundonlya coupleof musicvideo=lips.
Now, one of the conclusion that 1 think we should =Iso draw from these tests is that it seems we

havea prettyhigh=ercentage our contentthal bt:=lagged copyrighted soonas wt: of will as as startusing fingerprinting technology.Note initially willfingerprint against that we only =arner catalog the. so percentage matchwillcertainly =owcr.But westart signing new of be as up
=ontent partners, it will increase.
All the data is available

at:https://trac.sjl.youtube. com/trac/attachment/wiki/Fingerprint EvaY=SPAN "Appleclass=
converted-space"> result_random_video.xls Let me know any queslion,l=ranck ---

UnclemailinglistUncleC~youtube. comhttps:~dev.youru=e.comlmailman/lislinfo/uncle
Uncle mailing listuncleeyoulube.comhttps ://dev.youtu=e.comlmailman/listinfo/uncIe

=SPANclass=Apple-style-span " " style= "horder-collagse: separate; =order-spaoing: Opx; Opx
color: rgb(O,O,O);li~nl-l~ami~y: I-Ielvetica, =ont-size: 12px;font-style.normal;font-variant:

Highly

confidential

600001-00730974

normal; font-weight: =ormal; letter-spacing: normal; line-height. normal; text-align: auto;=khtmllex~-decorations-in-eCl`~cl: text-indent:Opx;=apple-lexl-si~~e-adjuw text-transform: none; : auto; none;orphans:2; =hite-space:normal;widows: 2; word-spacing:Opx;"~Mattbew=iuProducr
Manager510.921.6684 I matthew~youtube.com
~DI V>

Highly

ConfidentidL

600001-00730975