Viacom International, Inc. et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al
Filing
377
DECLARATION of ANDREW H. SCHAPIRO in Support re: 177 MOTION for Summary Judgment Regarding Applicability of the DMCA and on Plaintiffs' Inducement Claims.. Document filed by Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC, Google, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 110 Part 6, # 2 Exhibit 111 - 134, # 3 Exhibit 136 - 146, # 4 Exhibit 147 Part 1, # 5 Exhibit 147 Part 2, # 6 Exhibit 148 - 155, # 7 Exhibit 156 - 161, # 8 Exhibit 162 - 198)(Schapiro, Andrew)
Schapiro Exhibit 148
Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.
Schapiro Exhibit 149
Schapiro Exhibit 150
1
U NI TE D ST AT ES D IS TR IC T C OU RT F OR T HE S OU TH ER N DI ST R IC T OF N EW Y OR K
V IA CO M IN TE RN AT IO NA L, IN C. , CO ME DY P AR TN ER S, C OU NT RY M US I C. T EL EV IS IO N, I NC ., P AR A MO UN T P IC TU RE S CO RP OR AT IO N, an d BL AC K E NT ER TA IN ME NT T EL EV IS IO N , LL C,
) ) ) ) ) ) P la in ti ff s, ) ) v s. ) NO . 07 -C V- 21 03 ) Y OU TU BE , IN C. , YO UT UB E , LL C, ) a nd G OO GL E, I NC ., ) ) D ef en da nt s. ) _ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ _ __ __ __ __ __ _) ) T HE F OO TB AL L AS SO CI AT I ON P RE MI ER ) L EA GU E LI MI TE D, B OU RN E C O. , et a l. ,) o n be ha lf o f th em se lv e s an d al l ) o th er s si mi la rl y si tu a te d, ) ) P la in ti ff s, ) v s. ) NO . 07 -C V- 35 82 ) Y OU TU BE , IN C. , YO UT UB E , LL C, a nd ) G OO GL E, I NC ., ) ) D ef en da nt s. ) _ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ _ __ __ __ __ __ _) V ID EO TA PE D DE PO SI TI ON OF T HE OD OR A MI CH AE LS S AN F RA NC IS CO , CA LI FO R NI A S EP TE MB ER 2 4, 2 00 9 J OB N O. 1 77 64
2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
A P P E A R A N C E S: LI EFF CA BRA SER HE IMA NN & B ERN STE IN, L LP At tor ney s f or Pla int iff an d W itn ess 25 0 H uds on Str eet 8t h F loo r Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k 1 001 3-1 413 BY : ANN IKA K. MA RTI N, ESQ .
MA YER BR OWN , L LP At tor ney s f or Def end ant 16 75 Bro adw ay Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k 1 001 9-5 820 BY : CHR IST INE M. HE RNA NDE Z, ESQ . AN D JA SON KI RSC HNE R, ESQ .
AL SO PRE SEN T: NI CHO LAS GU ZMA N, Vid eog rap her
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
102 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:27:17 13:27:18 13:27:18 13:27:25 13:27:29 13:27:29 13:27:32 13:27:36 13:27:38 13:27:40 13:27:41 13:27:41 13:27:47 13:27:52 13:27:55 13:27:58 13:28:01 13:28:04 13:28:05 13:28:05 13:28:08 13:28:10 13:28:10 13:28:10 13:28:20
A. Q.
Y es . O ka y. Is t hi s a t ru e an d c or re ct co py o f the
wa y th e The od or a Mic ha el s You Tu be c han ne l ap pea rs on Y ou Tu be? A. Y es . Wi th t he ex ce pt ion t ha t my ba by
ni ec e lo oks s uc h cut er o n the o ri gi nal . Q. F ai r e no ug h, fa ir e no ugh . An d th en , i f yo u loo k on t he th ir d pag e of t hi s exh ib it - A. Q. Y es . - - it sa ys , "Vi de os ( 11) ," a nd th en
th er e is 11 , so rt of t hu mb nai l im ag es of v id eos . Ha ve y ou ev er p os ted a ny v ide os t o Yo uT ub e -- fi rs t -- le t me st ri ke t hat . Th e vi de os th at a re sh ow n her e on t he th ir d pa ge of t hi s e xh ib it , a re t he y, in f ac t, al l th e vi de os th at y ou up lo ad ed? A. Q. Y es . H av e y ou e ve r h os te d any v id eo s t o
Yo uT ub e tha t ar e not s ho wn on t he t hir d pa ge of th is e xh ibi t? A. Q. N o. A nd yo u se e the t hu mb nai l im ag e a nd t he
ti tl e, " Bes t of t he Vi ew "; do y ou s ee th at ?
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
103 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:28:23 13:28:23 13:28:28 13:28:31 13:28:32 13:28:33 13:28:39 13:28:42 13:28:43 13:28:43 13:28:44 13:28:59 13:29:02 13:29:07 13:29:11 13:29:12 13:29:14 10:16:23 10:16:23 13:29:14 13:29:49 13:29:49 13:29:51 13:29:51 13:29:53
A. Q.
Y es . A nd it s ta te s, "o ne m ont h ag o, " i s th at
co rr ec t, in i nd ic ati ng t ha t y ou p os ted t ha t vid eo ab ou t a mon th a go ? A. Q. Y es . A nd is t hi s vid eo , "B est o f th e V ie w" ,
th e on e you r ef er enc ed e ar lie r, w it h y ou r hu sba nd in t he a udi en ce ? A. Q. Y es . O ka y. MS . HE RN AND EZ : I am g oi ng to m ar k as
Ex hi bi t 11, a ga in , t wo p ag es pr in te d f ro m th e Yo uT ub e web s it e, of a v id eo po st ed by u se r na me T he odo ra M ic hae ls , th e u se r na me fo r Mi ss M ic hae ls , an d t he se w ere p ri nt ed on Se pt em be r 1 8t h. ) (P ri nt ou ts of M is s M ic ha el 's ch an ne l o n Yo uT ub e mar ke d Ca rli n Ex hi bit 1 1 fo r id en ti fi cat io n. ) TH E WI TN ESS : BY M S. H ERN AN DE Z: Q. A. Q. H av e y ou h ad a ch an ce to l oo k at it ? Y es . A nd Mi ss M ic hae ls , is th is a t rue a nd O ka y.
co rr ec t cop y of t he Yo uT ub e w eb p ag e f or t he "B es t
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
104 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:29:57 13:30:00 13:30:00 13:30:00 13:30:01 13:30:05 13:30:09 13:30:11 13:30:13 13:30:16 13:30:16 13:30:16 13:30:19 13:30:22 13:30:22 13:30:29 13:30:32 13:30:35 13:30:46 13:30:49 13:30:52 13:30:57 13:31:06 13:31:06 13:31:11
of T he V iew " vi de o t ha t yo u t es ti fi ed yo u up lo ad ed ? A. Q. Y es . O ka y. An d th is is a c li p f ro m th e T V sh ow , "T he V ie w," f ro m an ep is od e t ha t ai red o n Au gu st 5 th, 2 00 9; th at i s rig ht ? A. Q. ri gh t? A. Q. Y es . H ow di d yo u com e to h ave , in y our Y es . A nd "T he V ie w" pl ay s on th e ne two rk A BC ,
po ss es si on, t he v ide o cl ip th at y ou up lo ad ed as "B es t of th e Vi ew "? A. I d own lo ad ed it f ro m -- fr om e ith er t he
of fi ci al AB C we b sit e or t he of fi ci al we b si te fo r "T he V ie w." Q. I fo rge t wh ic h o ne .
A nd yo u wr it e, in t he to p ri gh t-h an d
bo x, " I' ve ne ve r see n th e sho w, b ut th at i s my Ke vi n in th e re d shi rt , da nci ng w it h t he c as t o f Ha ir , on 8/ 5/ 09 ." A. al lo ws . Q. A. " Sm ile y Fa ce ," di d yo u w ri te t hat ? Y es . I z oom ed i n on hi m as mu ch a s iMo vi e
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
105 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:31:11 13:31:13 13:31:20 13:31:24 13:31:32 13:31:35 13:31:38 13:31:39 13:31:39 13:31:41 13:31:45 13:31:45 13:31:50 13:31:54 13:31:55 13:31:55 13:31:56 13:31:56 13:32:02 13:32:05 13:32:06 13:32:07 13:32:09 13:32:11 13:32:11
Q. A.
W ha t i s iM ov ie? I Mo vie i s a pro gr am t hat c am e wit h ou r
Ma ci nt os h c om pu te r t ha t al low s vi de o e di ti ng . Q. A nd so y ou m ani pu la te d t he v id eo th at
yo u do wn loa de d, f rom e it he r A BC o r "Th e Vi ew "'s we b si te , i nt o th e f or ma t tha t yo u the n ul ti mat el y up lo ad ed to Y ou Tu be; t ha t is ri gh t? A. Q. Y es . D o you k no w who o wn s the c op yr igh t to
th is A ug ust 5 th , 200 9, e pi sod e of " The V ie w" ? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o di sce rn t he co py ri gh t
ow ne r be for e yo u dow nl oa de d t he v id eo fr om A BC or "T he V ie w"' s we b sit e? A. Q. A. Q. N o. I a m s or ry ? N o. O ka y. D id y ou at te mp t t o di sc ern t he
co py ri gh t o wn er b efo re y ou ma ni pu la ted t he v ide o us in g iM ovi e? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o di sce rn i ts co py ri gh t
ow ne r be for e yo u upl oa de d the c li p? A. Q. N o. D o you h av e aut ho ri za tio n fr om AB C to
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
106 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:32:15 13:32:16 13:32:17 13:32:20 13:32:20 13:32:21 13:32:24 13:32:24 13:32:24 13:32:27 13:32:29 13:32:30 13:32:31 13:32:34 13:32:40 13:32:40 13:32:42 13:32:44 13:32:47 13:32:50 13:32:53 13:32:57 13:32:59 13:33:00 13:33:05
po st t hi s v id eo ? A. Q. N o. D o you h av e aut ho ri za tio n fr om th e
pr od uc er s o f "T he Vi ew "? A. Q. el se ? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o se cur e au th ori za ti on N o. D id yo u ha ve au th or iz ati on f ro m a ny on e
fr om a ny one b ef or e y ou u pl oad ed i t? A. Q. A. Q. us e? A. A ct ual ly , le t m e am en d t ha t. I be li ev e i t ei th er to b e fai r us e, or , if i t is n't f ai r use , "T he Vi ew " is un li ke ly to ca re v er y m uc h -- or t he c opy ri gh t own er s, r ath er , ar e un li kel y to c are v er y muc h. Q. L et 's do t ho se in p ar ts. Wh y do y ou be li ev e t ha t it is po te nt ia lly a f ai r-u se ? A. S ev era l fa ct ors . O ne is , if I re ca ll N o. W hy no t? B ec aus e I be lie ve i t to be f ai r u se . W hy ; w hy d o you b el ie ve it t o be fa ir
co rr ec tl y, th e or igi na l sh ow wa s ap pro xi ma te ly
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
107 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:33:09 13:33:12 13:33:17 13:33:22 13:33:23 13:33:28 13:33:31 13:33:34 13:33:35 13:33:36 13:33:37 13:33:38 13:33:41 13:33:43 13:33:44 13:33:45 13:33:45 13:33:49 13:33:49 13:33:55 13:33:56 13:33:58 13:34:01 13:34:03 13:34:06
40 m in ut es; o f th at, I t oo k o nl y 40 se co nd s. Th at 4 0 sec on ds , I u se d ap pro xi ma te ly 50 p er cen t of t he o rig in al i mag e, a nd I di dn 't us e an y of th ei r au dio . So I u se d o nl y a sma ll f ra cti on o f the or ig in al wo rk . MS . MA RT IN: I ac tua ll y do n't w an t you Th at i s y ou r
to c on ti nue t hi s tes ti mo ny .
le ga l op ini on , as to w hy y ou di d th is. A. Q. O ka y. I a m s or ry . MS . MA RT IN: I am ob je ct in g. T hi s is
he r le ga l o pi ni on , a bo ut h er ow n ac tio ns , sh e is m ak in g. MS . HE RN AND EZ : th at ? Is t ha t a p ro pe r ins tr uc ti on, n ot t o an sw er ? Sh e wa s act in g as an a tt or ney w he n she up lo ad ed a cl ip o f " Th e Vi ew. " MS . MA RT IN: Ok ay , c on ti nu e. I t hi nk it U nde r wh at pr iv il eg e i s
is , he r fai r us e is -MS . HE RN AND EZ : I am n ot s ure w he re
an ti ci pa tio n of l iti ga ti on fi ts i nt o t hi s, ei th er .
DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 (212)705-8585
Schapiro Exhibit 151
Schapiro Exhibit 152
Schapiro Exhibit 153
Schapiro Exhibit 154
Schapiro Exhibit 155
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?