The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 182

DECLARATION of Andrew Schapiro Part 2 Exhibit 36 Part 1 in Support re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 36 Part 2 to Schapiro Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 37-42 to Schapiro Declaration, # 3 Exhibit 43-56 to Schapiro Declaration, # 4 Exhibit 57-68 to Schapiro Declaration, # 5 Exhibit 69-81to Schapiro Declaration, # 6 Exhibit 82-84 to Schapiro Declaration)(Schapiro, Andrew)

SCHAPIRO DECLARATION EXHIBITS CONTINUED

Schapiro Exhibit 69

Schapiro Exhibit 70

Schapiro Exhibit 71

Schapiro Exhibit 72

Schapiro Exhibit 73

Schapiro Exhibit 74

Schapiro Exhibit 75

Schapiro Exhibit 76

Schapiro Exhibit 77

Schapiro Exhibit 78

Schapiro Exhibit 79

12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

VI CT OR IA G . TR AUB E ma na ge d to r ea d i t. Q. Oh , gr ea t. S o ea rl ie r,

Ms . Tr au be , yo u t es ti fi ed a bo ut a cl ip t ha t ha d be en u pl oa ded t o Yo uT ub e for "D o- Re -M i" , th at wa s up lo ad ed wi th au th or iz at io n; is t hi s th e cl ip th at y ou we re r ef er ri ng to ? MR . ST EL LI NG S: fo rm o f th e qu est io n. A. re fe rr ed t o. It a pp ea rs to b e th e cl ip I It' s no t -- i t was n ot O bj ec t to t he 10 :1 7: 35 10 :1 7:2 4

up lo ad ed w it h aut ho ri za ti on . Q. Wh en y ou sa y it w as n ot 10 :1 7:5 2

up lo ad ed w it h aut ho ri za ti on , is yo ur te st im on y th at it w as u pl oa de d w it ho ut au th or iz at io n? A. Q. It w as . An d if I co ul d ju st d ir ect y ou r

at te nt io n ag ai n t o th e to p ri ght -h an d bo x, I' m no t su re i f i t' s a bi t di ffi cu lt t o re ad , bu t it a ppe ar s th at t he us er na me w ho up lo ad ed i t is -- a nd I d on 't kn ow h ow t o pr on ou nc e th is , i t sa ys S- A- I- H- T- T- A- M-1 98 8; d o yo u see w he re I 'm

10 :1 8:0 1

10 :1 8:1 5

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

13 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

VI CT OR IA G . TR AUB E lo ok in g? A. Q. I se e wh ere y ou 'r e lo ok ing . Do y ou k now w ho t he u se r t ha t I 10 :1 8:2 6

ju st s pe ll ed o ut th e na me , do yo u kn ow w ho th at u se r is ? A. Q. No . Do y ou k now w ho a ct ua ll y

up lo ad ed t he c lip ? A. No . T hi s c li p, n o, I d o n ot 10 :1 8: 32

kn ow w ho u pl oa ded t hi s sp ec if ic cl ip y ou 'r e sh ow in g me i n thi s sp ec if ic i nst an ce . Q. As f ar a s a c er ta in c li p o f th e

sa me p er fo rm an ce, i t do es n' t nec es sa ri ly ne ed t o be t hi s v er y cl ip , re ali zi ng o f co ur se t ha t th e s am e cl ip c ou ld be u pl oa de d mo re t ha n on ce , a re y ou a wa re of a ny p ar ty th at u pl oa de d a c li p of t hi s per fo rm an ce ? A. It w as m y u nd er st an di ng th at 10 :1 9:1 0 10 :1 8:5 5

th e cl ip w as u plo ad ed b y th e tel ev is io n st at io n wh o cr eat ed t he c li p as pu bl ic it y fo r th e Ma ri a Sta r Se ar ch p ro gra m. Q. Di d th er e c om e a ti me w hen t hi s

cl ip t ha t yo u jus t re fe rr ed t o u lt im at el y be ca me l ic en se d? 10 :1 9:4 2

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 80

I YOucmj~

·---·-~

~··--·····-

·····-

·-·--··I-:··:-

·~·-···~········

~1~ 1

······~r:iLi:i:L·i:i::i::·l

Fnll\~.um or 4p.
Sub·cdptknl HIeLoy j:::~i~~:::l

lir:*d~na~~·l·ell~Home Videos Channele Showe

Sound of MusicI CentralStationAntwerp(Belglum)

PDC)

I' ~

~iiil

`~~~"~' "" MslblZI,ZW9
seihttemlesl

~j~

(*slmU

More than 200 d.nson were pr(onlnp their version ; o('Do Re MP, h the Central 914900d Anlwerp.*ilh lusl 2 rehearaala they oeatad this anYlinB a~mU
Those 4 (antaalic mkulsr sla~ed the 29 of march

2000, 09:00 AM.It II a pmmolion stint for a Belgian televlaiwIprogram, where they are ~o~hg tor someone to play the leadRg role, in the musical oI
me Somd ol MlaIo·

tolollD"I: Enlo~alnn~nl Tnpr.:aouxI ol mupls enturorpen mnvaal
~elgulm

URL I~~Ll~rPm7EY~Uad.

Emb~ i~~~~hu~nmni:I~i
MoreFrom:lalhnsmlgll '· RelatedVldeol Balonoa cW Sln~* L·dla

*t***

1~.6P~O rsllnpr.

12,487,721 vl~rva

~ii~S~g~
EdOl.lSbaor~

--j

FI··h·O·n.0 Plo~·dlll...
P·8yo'oonl7

~/

,~u~

Share"PIayIIete FIag .

Do MI NZ ·T·w... Re 8111100, · WalhOon
Aallrv·y

11)9·U56VIC*r

i
P

___."~o....._.._._""".. ~.....-~L.. .._._..... .._.__...._...._._.. .._....""h~"pU~J . _.._.
DarnloldTh*Song: ) 81·ll.llo·LO·I· AmsYmMp3 ITunn Muedmmml

·Vugo~udruy·

BIWB~
788 7-140990 ULllonk~g
sd~lru~l~abn~0

No pants Bubway II.~LP0.075dU*I

Rids 2009

InWouEv~y*kn
Danoa

~V*·oRnponls·(ll)

6~nlnala*IV~LooRaapaso

~a~sJ.aes*hr~

Vlawne ·

PI·y~l1[81~11~uoHo·..p~s 0~111118
8u·an Boyle - SIngr DriIeins Oot Tllant 2000... A1.Q35.008 ub~vr

i IIg[IIIII#

DlnceRlbas·rrroC...
·1.81P.6:17Vi~l~ BoumS~·d·n

[OFACIC·4 J·okson Mlcha·l

noml.~n..d.~lll..~ ORO)
n,, Inm ,,. ,,,. I*I ,,, apon~ynlauH ,, IhM.t lolr~IfninXy~u In.
hers.

a~au 094 /~B~i
R·ply 004

thankyou,have a niceday.

F~stur~d Vldeol

LeDaU( huurs.Oo) (3
Wham oapllaliam ruler, eodbes advertising. Somy about that. And I euspeot that the partlolpanta In thIa partlculsr Ylarh mob'were pmbably quite enloylng themselves, along with many olthe people ~tshbg.

Go to the YouTube channel'Irrprov eveywhere'and you will flashmobs aee Interdedforpure entertainment. rebellion. marketing. fun.:) No No Just

OanwllTurn· WorlnpYou, Unumed·nd i PelnInto Core:How Do Unsut: to i 10.084 *.*. S:8*ow. 9.llgnac

AoLlcokohours (7 agol
I am getting Imrsadn~ly tired of these pseudo Ibsh mobs organlsed by marketing 'oreat*H1'. Flash mobs used O bs an aot of rebellion. Nowdays the so ulled 'sreatlve' sgensiee killed it's spirit and turned II Into a marketing tool. I am lust wondering about 2 things: 1)How Is this supposed to eneounp· me to watoh a TV show? 2) Do he idiots who loin In spontaneously reaiise they am making fools ol themaelves for free, whsreaa everyone else Is getting paid for 117

Ro~Y ·1Qb

I~···

-·· ··~C~··

- --~dmalplon·~

ooIdesIgn hol,ro (~ ago)
what sxsdly were they man~ll~?l Have you thought about psrformanre an or perlonnanoe as an id ct rebellion) I understand apend·a r~da~ adopt or steal IIaaa bom Imm Ihs underelaalea~ground I.e Orafliti ~ Vodalore I mean you are probably wearing high top nlke dr Jordana from the late BO'ebut now Ihe~re mol again. I wonder why? ooldnlgn (5 hours agoi

R·ply opb

Cumnarl nl~mvnb by IIBa

e·l·lu ie hours ago)
Coreogrfia meravelloua, en un Iloo pliblic lar~ una canc6 Imlvldabls.

R·lly 009 A·ply Ogdl) "dv ·a~

88001010(12 ego) Ilours
Hahaha this Is so fllppln awesomei

llyd·.711(IL: hounego)
gawd. It made ms tear up, but II waa tug what I needed In these times. I would have wantt~ to Ilve In Ihla cor~*ely nnerern world wae everyone just broke out In song Irom time to Ilms

DEFENDANT'S

.~b11(14hoursaUo!
Esb dems~do
demaslado bello...

R·ply ~~BQ

espsclacular rsalmenle estoy ~omrendMa a*oy sin palabraa

"i'l~
I la.

,,,,, 1'7 aUo) i,,,
aaahahahahhaaaaa Ihls Is rmndellulll I waloh it aII the Ilme and I laugh weryllrol woulddl It be dec n we oould ail break out Into aong?? :) 8howlng 1Dol 10.231 mramants Show Mora Commenta

,r, ··90
ViswLII 10231 comments

Would you Ilke to comment'l
~bil YouTube lor a Ime smovll, or sign Is syou am aimady a member.

,a

Try YouTube last, web Ina new browsed L~avlllLo-AI~LJ;fi~s~1P~hLPmClprI~C;

YouTulN

PmgrYnr

n~ly

P~IF/

OilWvDI

CmtaolUs
~ouTub. sullmlw aors 8141

~dranslng
Dov~lop~n

MH·IC
Yourub~ Ha~boo*

P~.rm Wlry
TomrolSanis~

YouTuDe YourPh~n· m
Y~uTuboonYou~SII·

PmM Rmm Y~uTubo Blog
C.n~IILwallun CUne~lL·I~UlrlU. World~ld· Engll·k

Por~alah~
~nloaMsnoQ~mo~

Comrmnlh HelpF.n~m~
SOl.hl CDlllOr

Cop~rulhl N~l~ol
Comnunl~hlldalln~s

VouTuD~aY~u,N
'louTubo RSS F~od·

Cnnlo(. Como~
Shavlmnlkru Sharla~uo~o· 020PB Y~uTub·. LLC ~dd *oulub·

To~tTu~a
to your Oooll· kon*p·0·

Schapiro Exhibit 81