The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 258

DECLARATION of Andrew H. Schapiro in Opposition re: 158 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment dismissing with prejudice Defendants' First Defense asserted in Defendants' Answer to the Second Amended Class Action Complaint... Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - 15, # 2 Exhibit 16, Part 1, # 3 Exhibit 16, Part 2, # 4 Exhibit 16, Part 3, # 5 Exhibit 16, Part 4, # 6 Exhibit 16, Part 5)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Schapiro Exhibit 1

268

UN IT ED S TA TE S DIS TR IC T CO UR T FO R TH E SO UT HE RN DI ST RI CT O F NEW Y OR K

VI AC OM I NT ER NA TIO NA L, I NC ., C OME DY PA RT NE RS , CO UN TRY M US IC . TE LE VI SI ON , IN C., P AR AM OU NT PI CT UR ES C OR PO RAT IO N, a nd B LA CK EN TE RT AI NM EN T TEL EV IS IO N, L LC ,

) ) ) ) ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) ) vs . ) N O. 0 7-C V- 21 03 ) YO UT UB E, I NC ., YO UT UB E, L LC , ) an d GO OG LE , IN C., ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) __ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ _) ) TH E FO OT BA LL A SSO CI AT IO N PR EM IER ) LE AG UE L IM IT ED , B OU RN E CO ., e t a l. ,) on b eh al f of t hem se lv es a nd a ll ) ot he rs s im il ar ly si tu at ed , ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) vs . ) N O. 0 7- CV -35 82 ) YO UT UB E, I NC ., YO UT UB E, L LC , and ) GO OG LE , IN C. , ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) __ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ _) VI DE OT AP ED D EP OSI TI ON O F WA RR EN SO LO W NE W YO RK , NE W YOR K JA NU AR Y 14 TH , 201 0 JO B NO . 18 50 9

269 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F W ARR EN SO LOW , h eld at th e o ffi ces of Wi ls on, So nsi ni, Go odr ich & Ros ati , P C, 130 1 Av enu e o f t he Ame ric as, Ne w Y ork , New Yo rk, pu rsu ant to no tic e, bef ore Ma ure en Rat to, Re gis ter ed Pro fes sio nal Re por ter an d N ota ry Pub lic of th e Sta te of Ne w Y ork on Ja nua ry 14, 20 10, a t 10 :13 a. m.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

270 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES

FO R T HE PLA INT IFF S: JE NNE R & BL OCK , L LP BY : S USA N J . K OHL MAN N, ESQ . 91 9 T hir d A ven ue, Ne w Y ork , N Y 1 00 22 (2 12) 891 -16 90 sk ohl man n@j enn er. com

FO R T HE DEF END ANT S: WI LSO N, SON SIN I, GOO DRI CH & R OSA TI, L LP BY : MIC HAE L H . R UBI N, ESQ .

65 0 P age Mi ll Roa d, Pal o A lto , C A 943 04 65 0-8 49- 331 1 MR UBI N@w sgr .co m

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

334 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:52:33 11:52:04 11:51:50 11:51:33 11:51:14

wh at Mar k I shi kaw a i s r efe rri ng to wh en he id ent ifi es pro jec t n umb er two . Q. Th at wou ld be the sa me fo r

Pa ram oun t P roj ect 1 and Pa ram oun t Pr oje ct 2? A. I' m u nsu re of the no men cl atu re

th at Mar k I shi kaw a m ay use in ter nal ly an d h ow it map s t o t he agr eed u pon co ntr act s b etw een th e t wo com pan ies th at are id ent ifi ed by sta tem ent of wo rk. Q. It 's pos sib le, th en, ba sed o n

yo ur und ers tan din g, tha t B ayT SP is re fer rin g t o p roj ect s b y d iff ere nt na mes th an Via com is . Is tha t wha t

yo u'r e s ayi ng, Mr . S olo w? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Y ou can an swe r. I' m s ayi ng tha t I ha ve -- it ha s Ob jec tio n a s t o

re cen tly be en bro ugh t t o m y a tte nti on th at the id ent ifi cat ion of pr oje cts o r su b p roj ect s o r e nde avo rs wit hin Ba yT SP do no t m ap dir ect ly to the ag ree d upo n co ntr act s, sta tem ent of wo rks be twe en th e t wo org ani zat ion s.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

335 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:54:38 11:54:14 11:54:00 11:53:22 11:53:01

Q.

Do th e - - d oes th at de gre e o f

va ria nce in th e m app ing of pr oje ct na me, ba sed up on wha t y ou rec ent ly le arn ed, ha ve an imp act on th e ex ecu tio n b y B ayT SP of Via com 's in str uct ion s? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I' ve not ye t s een th at Ob jec tio n a s t o

ma nif est ed in per for man ce. Q. A. Q. Ha ve you in ves tig ate d i t? No . Wi tho ut reg ard to an y s pe cif ic

pr oje ct, as a gen era l p rop osi tio n, Ba yTS P i s c har ged by Vi aco m w ith se ndi ng tak edo wn not ice s t o o nli ne se rvi ces . Isn 't tha t c orr ect ? Ob jec tio n a s t o

MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Y ou can an swe r.

Th at is a c omp one nt of -- of th e

se rvi ces th ey pro vid e. Q. An d w ith re gar d t o t hat

co mpo nen t o f t he ser vic es the y p rov id e, th ere ar e s ome on lin e s erv ice s t o whi ch Ba yTS P i s a uth ori zed to se nd tak edo wn

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

336 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:56:10 11:55:45 11:55:27 11:55:03 11:54:50

no tic es on Via com 's beh alf an d t her e ar e o the r o nli ne ser vic es wit h r esp ec t to wh ich Ba yTS P i s n ot aut hor ize d to se nd tak edo wn not ice s. ri ght ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Ye s. Wh ich on lin e s erv ice s h as Ba yTS P Ob jec tio n a s t o Is n't th at

be en aut hor ize d t o s end ta ked own no tic es to? A. Th ose se rvi ces th at are l ist ed

in th e a gre ed upo n a nd cou nte r s ig ned st ate men t o f w ork s b etw een th e t wo co mpa nie s. I bel iev e t hat th at li st

wo uld in clu de You Tub e, Goo gle vi deo , My Spa ce and Ya hoo vi deo , a t l eas t for a pe rio d o f t ime . Q. A. Ca n y ou rec all an y o the rs ? I' m s orr y. I' ll nee d

cl ari fic ati on her e a nd per hap s m y an swe r w ill be cl ari fyi ng. I can 't spe ak to the sc ope of th e P ara mou nt pro jec ts. in clu ded ot her si tes . T hey ma y hav e The y m ay or ma y

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

337 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:57:11 11:56:57 11:56:45 11:56:38 11:56:25

no t h ave .

As I s aid , t her e i s a P 2P

co mpo nen t m iss ing ou t o f h is de scr ipt ion or -- of wh at he ref er s t o as Vi aco m P roj ect 1. Q. To be cl ear , w hen yo u say "h e"

yo u a re ref err ing to Mr . I shi kaw a in th e d ocu men t s ent to yo u t itl ed "W arr en' s a nsw ers " i n t he for m o f Ex hib it 3? MS . K OHL MAN N: ca n a nsw er. A. Q. Ye s. My qu est ion wa s n ot lim it ed to Ob jec tio n. Yo u

th at doc ume nt or to Mr. Is hik awa , jus t to be cl ear . A. Q. Ok ay. Su re. C oul d y ou rep eat i t t hen ? I wa nte d t o s te p b ack You ca n a ctu all y set

fr om Exh ibi t 3 .

it as ide if yo u l ike , a nd ask t he br oad er que sti on. Vi aco m h as aut hor ize d B ayT SP to se nd tak edo wn not ice s t o c ert ain on li ne se rvi ces on it s b eha lf but no t t o ot her s. A. Co rre ct? Vi aco m d efi ned th e l ist o f s ite s

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

338 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:58:30 11:58:16 11:58:09 11:57:52 11:57:38

fo r w hic h B ay sho uld fo cus th eir ef for ts. I 'm not aw are of an y doc ume nt

th at sai d d o n ot loo k a t t his s ite . Q. Ok ay. B ut Bay TSP is n ot

au tho riz ed to sen d t ake dow n n oti ces o n Vi aco m's be hal f t o a ny sit e t han t hos e ex pre ssl y l ist ed in the ag ree men ts be twe en the tw o c omp ani es. ri ght ? A. Th at I'm aw are of , t her e cou ld I sn' t tha t

-- to th e e xte nt of my awa ren ess , yes . Q. Mr . S olo w, can Ba yTS P o n its ow n

in iti ati ve sen d t ake dow n n oti ces to a ny si te it so cho ose s f or any Vi aco m co nte nt tha t i t s o c hoo ses ? A. No . MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. G o a hea d. No . In fa ct, it ca n o nly s end Ob jec tio n a s t o

ta ked own no tic es to the si tes th at Vi aco m d ire cts it to do so , f or th e co nte nt tha t i t i s d ire cte d t o s en d no tic es for pu rsu ant to th e r ule s tha t Vi aco m d ire cts . Isn 't tha t r igh t?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

339 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 12:00:18 11:59:48 11:59:20 11:58:54 11:58:41

MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Y ou can an swe r.

Ob jec tio n a s t o

Th at is cor rec t. Wi th res pec t t o t he sit es fo r

wh ich Ba yTS P i s a uth ori zed to se nd ta ked own no tic es you id ent ifi ed fou r; Yo uTu be, Go ogl e v ide o, MyS pac e a nd Ya hoo vi deo . My que sti on is, ar e the re

mo re tha n t hos e f our th at you ar e awa re of ? A. Q. No . Wh at pee r t o p eer ne two rk s i s

Ba yTS P a uth ori zed to mo nit or? A. Q. A. I don 't kno w. Wh o w oul d k now th at? It de pen ds on the ti me pe rio d

th at you ar e s pea kin g o f. Q. A. Q. To day . St anl ey Pie rre -Lo uis . Do yo u k now wh o w oul d kno w t hat

fo r t he per iod ar oun d M arc h, 200 7? A. In Ma rch of 20 07 Bay w as

mo nit ori ng eDo nke y, my rec oll ect ion is fa ili ng me the re. A nyb ody wh o h ad

ac ces s t o t he sta tem ent of wo rk wo uld

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

340 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 12:01:34 12:01:16 12:01:06 12:00:39 12:00:30

-- co uld te ll you th at.

I co ul dn' t

te ll you wh o, off th e t op of th eir he ads , c oul d p rov ide th at inf orm ati on. Q. Do yo u k now wh at ste ps Ba yTS P

wa s a uth ori zed to ta ke wit h r esp ect t o P2 P n etw ork s o the r t han mo nit ori ng th ose se rvi ces ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Y ou can an swe r. I don 't rec all wh at the e xac t Ob jec tio n a s t o

pr oto col wa s o n t he P2P si de. Q. As pa rt of Bay TSP 's tak ed own

wo rk flo w f or Via com , B ayT SP mak es a co py of eac h Y ouT ube cl ip pri or to se ndi ng a t ake dow n n oti ce to You Tub e, co rre ct? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Q. Ye s. Ob jec tio n.

Th ey end eav or to do th at.

In fa ct, th ey do tha t pri or to

se ndi ng a t ake dow n n oti ce, do n't th ey ? A. Q. Ye s. Is th at wor k f low in p lac e f or

ea ch of the fo ur ser vic es tha t B ay TSP mo nit ors fo r V iac om? MS . K OHL MAN N: Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

422 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:51:30 14:51:21 14:51:09 14:50:49 14:50:31

pa rti es or Via com ag ent s t o w hom t hat in for mat ion ha s b een pr ovi ded as yo u si t h ere to day ? A. I bel iev e i t w oul d b e pro vid ed

to Gl oba l. Q. Ot her th an Via com 's age nts w ho

ar e i nvo lve d w ith id ent ify ing Vi aco m co nte nt on the in ter net , d o y ou kn ow if it 's eve r b een pr ovi ded to an y o th er Vi aco m a gen ts or any ot her th ird pa rti es? A. As a lis t? Wh at -- I don 't

un der sta nd the ob jec t o f t he sen ten ce , wh at hav e I pr ovi ded ? we 're pr ovi din g? Q. Th e i nfo rma tio n c ont ain ed in Wha t i s it tha t

wh at Mic hae l H ous ley ag gre gat es at yo ur di rec tio n r ega rdi ng the up loa din g ac tiv ity of Vi aco m a nd its ag ent s on th e Y ouT ube we bsi te and on th e i nt ern et ge ner all y. MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Fo r c lar ity , a re we tal ki ng Ob jec tio n a s t o

di sse min ati on of a l ist th at Mic hae l

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

423 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:52:48 14:52:24 14:52:11 14:51:52 14:51:42

Ho usl ey has cr eat ed or are we ta lk ing ab out th e u pst rea m f rom th at? st rea m o f t hat ? I'm st ill no t D ow n

un der sta ndi ng wha t i t i s t hat yo u'r e as kin g i s b ein g d iss emi nat ed. Q. Le t's fo cus fi rst on th e

in for mat ion be ing di sse min ate d a s ag gre gat ed by Mr. Ho usl ey. MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

Ca n y ou -- now , c an yo u r epo se

th e q ues tio n? Q. Su re. I n t he for m a s agg reg ate d

by Mr . H ous ley at yo ur dir ect ion , do yo u k now if th e d ata re gar din g V ia com an d i ts age nts up loa din g a cti vit y o f Vi aco m c ont ent on th e i nte rne t in clu din g Y ouT ube ha s b een pr ovi ded t o an y V iac om age nt or oth er thi rd pa rty , ot her th an tho se tha t a re inv olv ed in mo nit ori ng the in ter net fo r V iac om co nte nt? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Ye s. Pl eas e i den tif y t hem ? Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

424 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:55:02 14:54:44 14:53:46 14:53:28 14:53:04

A.

I bel iev e t hat it ha s bee n

pr ovi ded to Je nne r & Bl ock an d S he rma n & Ste rli ng. Q. Do yo u k now wh en tha t

in for mat ion wa s p rov ide d t o y our co uns el in thi s a cti on? A. No t s pec ifi cal ly, no . MR . R UBI N: Su san , I 'll as k

ri ght no w t hat in for mat ion be pr odu ce d in th e c ase . If you wa nt to me et and

co nfe r a bou t i t I 'm hap py to do so . It 's pla inl y r esp ons ive . Q. Ot her th an the pa rtn ers y ou' ve

id ent ifi ed thu s f ar, an d s ett ing as id e th ose th at are in vol ved in mo nit ori ng th e i nte rne t f or Via com co nte nt, ca n yo u i den tif y a ny oth ers to wh om th at da ta has be en pro vid ed? A. Q. No . Do yo u b eli eve th at set o f d ata

is co mpr ehe nsi ve, Mr . S olo w? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. I don 't kno w. Wh at lea ds you to be u nab le to Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

425 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:56:35 14:56:10 14:55:46 14:55:30 14:55:16

co ncl ude th at the da ta pro vid ed to yo u fr om Via com su bsi dia rie s a nd Via com ag ent s r ega rdi ng the ir upl oad ac tiv ity wi th res pec t t o V iac om con ten t o n the in ter net an d o n Y ouT ube mi ght no t be co mpr ehe nsi ve? MS . K OHL MAN N: Mi sst ate s t he rec ord . A. Ob jec tio n. You ca n a ns wer .

Wh en one do esn 't kno w t he ex ten t

of th e u niv ers e o f a da ta set i t's ha rd to ma ke a d ete rmi nat ion th at som eth in g is mi ssi ng. Q. Ha ve you ha d a ny exp eri en ce tha t

le ads yo u t o c onc lud e t hat da ta ha s be en, fr om tim e t o t ime , b een mi ss ing fr om tha t d ata se t? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I can 't rec all an in sta nc e w her e Ob jec tio n a s t o

an in sta nce or ev ent th at pla yed o ut wh ich le d m e t o b eli eve th at. Q. Is th is dat a s et che cke d pri or

to th e s end ing of a tak edo wn not ic e f or a giv en pie ce of con ten t t o i nsu re th at th at con ten t i s n ot aut hor ize d t o be on

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

426 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:58:28 14:58:03 14:57:38 14:57:14 14:56:50

th e s erv ice at is sue ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Th ere is an ex pec tat ion t hat Ob jec tio n a s t o

wi ll hap pen , y es. Q. Wh at is the pu rpo se of ha vin g

th at exp ect ati on? A. I wan t t o m ake su re I und ers tan d

th e q ues tio n. Q. Le t m e a sk it aga in. It mig ht

be a bit co nfu sin g.

Wh o c hec ks th at

da ta set pr ior to se ndi ng a t ake do wn no tic e t o i nsu re tha t t he con ten t in th e t ake dow n n oti ce is not al so in th at da ta set ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Ge ner all y B ayT SP. Is it co rre ct tha t B ayT SP ch eck s Ob jec tio n a s t o

th e s et of dat a r efl ect ing wh at Vi aco m su bsi dia rie s a nd age nts ha ve ide nti fie d as co nte nt the y h ave up loa ded to Yo uTu be and ot her ar eas of th e i nt ern et pr ior to se ndi ng a t ake dow n n oti ce fo r th e p urp ose of in sur ing th at the

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

535 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:11:44 18:11:28 18:11:18 18:10:55 18:10:42

ru le. Q. An d y ou alw ays ma rk the f lag

hi gh imp ort anc e o n e -ma ils yo u s ent ? A. Q. I do not . Do yo u o nly do so wh en yo u

be lie ve the im por tan ce to act ual ly be hi gh? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Q. Ob jec tio n.

In mo st cas es, ye s. Wh at did yo u w rit e t o Ms. Ni ema n

th at you de eme d t o b e s o u rge nt an d o f su ch hig h i mpo rta nce ? A. I was en dea vor ing to ge t her to

ac t q uic kly to re -- to fac ili tat e the re pos tin g o f t hes e c lip s. Q. Cl ips th at had be en tak en do wn

by Vi aco m, is tha t c orr ect ? A. Q. Th at' s c orr ect . Di dn' t y ou als o t ell he r you ha d

be en und er the im pre ssi on tha t t his us er was on th e p rot ect ed, do no t tak e do wn lis t? MS . K OHL MAN N: ca n a nsw er. A. Th at is wha t i t s ays h ere in Ob jec tio n. Yo u

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

536 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:12:59 18:12:46 18:12:36 18:12:14 18:11:52

th is e-m ail , y es. Q. Wh y w ere yo u u nde r t hat

im pre ssi on at the ti me you se nt th is e- mai l, Mr. So low ? A. I don 't rec all wh y s pec if ica lly

I was un der th at imp res sio n. Q. Do yo u s ee the re spo nse f rom

Ev ely n E spi nos a t o C our tne y N iem an an d Tr avi s H ill ? A. Q. A. Ye s. Wh at doe s i t s ay? "O nce ag ain ... h ow do yo u/t he

vi deo gr oup KN OW who is on th e pr ote cte d l ist ? ? ? ? ? " Q. An d i n f act , " kno w" is in al l

ca ps, co rre ct? A. Q. Co rre ct. In yo ur exp eri enc e i n e -m ail

is n't a wor d p ut in all ca ps fo r em pha sis ? A. Q. Of ten . Ho w d id Cou rtn ey or the v ide o

gr oup kn ow who wa s o n t he pro tec te d li st? MS . K OHL MAN N: Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

537 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:14:04 18:13:50 18:13:38 18:13:20 18:13:07

fo rm. A. Q. I don 't kno w. In fa ct, it wa s y our

un der sta ndi ng at lea st on May 1s t tha t th ere wa s s ome br eak dow n i n t hat pr oce ss, ri ght ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Ri ght . Alt hou gh, I did c ouc h i t So Ob jec tio n a s t o

as I was un der th e i mpr ess ion .

gi ven an in tim ate un der sta ndi ng of ho w I com mun ica te, th at was my wa y o f gi vin g t hem a cha nce to co rre ct me wh ere I was wr ong . Q. In dee d. Bu t i t w as in fa ct you r

im pre ssi on at the ti me tha t t her e was so me bre akd own in th e p roc ess re gar di ng co nfi rmi ng whe the r o r n ot a c lip w as au tho riz ed pri or to iss uan ce of a ta ked own no tic e. Is n't th at rig ht? Ob jec tio n.

MS . K OHL MAN N: A.

My im pre ssi on was th at th is use r

wa s o r s hou ld hav e b een on a pr ote cte d do no t t ake do wn lis t. Q. Do yo u k now if a ret ra cti on was

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

538 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:15:07 18:14:55 18:14:44 18:14:34 18:14:13

se nt for an y o r a ll vid eos at tac he d t o th e 6 6 i n 2 008 ? A. I bel iev e r etr act ion s w ere s ent

fo r t hes e c lip s. Q. Do yo u k now if th ose v ide os are

li fe on the se rvi ce tod ay? A. Q. I don 't bel iev e t hey ar e. Bu t d idn 't you ju st tes ti fy tha t

Vi aco m i ssu ed a r etr act ion fo r t hos e vi deo s? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

Ca n w e h ave th e c our t rep ort er

re ad bac k m y a nsw er? Q. Wh y d on' t y ou jus t a nsw er it

ag ain , M r. Sol ow? A. I' d s ay it wou ld be mo re

co nsi ste nt to rel y o n m y a nsw er. Q. I' ll ask yo u t he que sti on ag ain .

It is yo ur und ers tan din g t hat Ba yTS P is sue d a re tra cti on for so me or al l t he vi deo s s et for th in the th ose at ta che d to Ex hib it 28 on Via com 's beh alf ? Is n't th at rig ht? A. Ye s. MR . R UBI N: Le t's ma rk Exh ibi t

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

539 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:17:04 18:16:43 18:16:32 18:16:14 18:15:44

29 . (S olo wP- 29 is rec eiv ed and ma rke d f or ide nti fic ati on. ) Q. Mr . S olo w, Exh ibi t 2 9 i s a

do cum ent pr odu ced by Ba yTS P i n t his ac tio n b ear ing Ba yTS P 0 011 248 69 co nsi sts of a ret rac tio n n oti ce sen t by Ba yTS P t o Y ouT ube on Ma y 1 st, 20 07 ju st a few ho urs af ter th e e -ma il we sa w i n Ex hib it 28. A. Q. A. Q. Ye s. Do yo u r eco gni ze thi s d oc ume nt? No . I do no t. Is th is a d ocu men t t hat c ont ain s

a ret rac tio n o f s ome or al l o f the no tic e o f a lle ged in fri nge men t co nta ine d a s a tta chm ent s t o E xhi bit 2 8? MS . K OHL MAN N: ca n a nsw er. A. I don 't kno w, sho rt of go ing Ob jec tio n. Yo u

th rou gh and ma tch ing ev ery one of th es e vi deo ID s t o t he IDs in he re, I do n't kn ow. Q. Le t's sh ort cu t t hat an d jus t

fo cus on on e.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

540 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:17:49 18:17:40 18:17:29 18:17:20 18:17:09

A. Q.

Ok ay. If yo u c an pul l u p E xh ibi t 2 8 i n

fr ont of yo u. A. Q. A. Q. Ye s. An d t urn to th e s eco nd pa ge. Ye s. Do yo u s ee tha t v ide o ID

en clo sed in th e t ake dow n n oti ce in th e fi rst in ti me e-m ail ? A. Q. Th e o ne tha t e nds in W 8. Ex act ly, th e o ne tha t e nd s i n W 8

on th e p age th at end s i n B ate s num ber 95 1. A. Q. Ye s. If I can tu rn you r a tt ent ion no w

to Ex hib it 29. A. Q. Ye s. Do yo u s ee the re' s a l ong li st

of UR Ls tha t e nd in vid eo IDs ? A. Q. Ye s. If I can br ing yo ur at ten tio n t o

th e e igh th fro m t he bot tom ? A. Q. Ye s. Do yo u s ee tha t t hat 's th e s ame

vi deo ID th at' s i den tif ied in th e

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

541 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:18:43 18:18:36 18:18:25 18:18:14 18:18:02

se con d p age of Ex hib it 28? A. Q. Ye s. Ra the r t han re pea tin g t his

ex erc ise fo r e ver y o ne of the m, wo uld yo u a gre e t hat Ex hib it 29 is at le ast a re tra cti on not ice fo r s ome or at l eas t on e o f t he vid eos re pre sen ted in t he ta ked own no tic es att ach ed to Exh ibi t 28 ? A. Q. Ye s. An d y ou hav e n o r eas on to

be lie ve tha t t he res t o f t he vid eo s id ent ifi ed in Exh ibi t 2 8 w ere n't al so co nta ine d i n r etr act ion no tic es iss ued by Ba yTS P o n V iac om beh alf to Yo uT ube , do yo u? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Q. No . Bu t I be lie ve you te sti fi ed tha t Ob jec tio n.

it 's you r u nde rst and ing th at the se vi deo s a ren 't liv e o n t he ser vic e to day ? MS . K OHL MAN N: Q. A. Is th at rig ht? I hav e n ot che cke d t hat r ece ntl y Ob jec tio n.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

542 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:20:32 18:20:00 18:19:39 18:19:21 18:19:08

bu t I be lie ve tha t t hat is th e cas e. Q. A. Wh y w oul d t hat be th e cas e? Be cau se we ult ima tel y d ete rm ine d

th at the ri ght s t o t hes e c lip s w er e n ot -- we re not th ose -- we re not t he ri ght s o f t he per son wh o c omp lai ned ab out th e - - t hat wa s a n i nar tic ul ate wa y o f s ayi ng tha t. We be lie ved th at the pe rso n fi lin g t he or com pla ini ng abo ut the ta ked own wa s n ot the ac tua l r igh ts ow ner . MR . R UBI N: I' d l ike to

in tro duc e E xhi bit 30 . (S olo wP- 30 is rec eiv ed and ma rke d f or ide nti fic ati on. ) Q. Wh en you sa y " we" , M r. So low ,

wh o i s t he "we " t hat ma de tha t dec isi on or re ach ed tha t c onc lus ion ? A. Th at was th e c omm una l V ia com

le gal co mmu nit y, we, th e p eop le in vol ved in th is typ e o f w ork , a co lla bor ati ve inv est iga tio n. Q. Ex hib it 30 is a d ocu men t

pr odu ced by Ba yTS P i n t his ac tio n,

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

543 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 18:22:19 18:21:38 18:21:26 18:21:13 18:20:55

be ari ng Bat es num ber Ba yTS P 0 037 338 04. Do yo u r eco gni ze thi s d ocu men t? A. Q. Ye s. Th is is the do cum ent th at

re fle cts th e c omm uni cat ion fr om Via com to Ba yTS P o f t he con clu sio n t hat y ou ju st des cri bed re gar din g a uth ori zat ion of th e B ull Run vi deo s, isn 't it? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Ye s. An d t his ca me on May 7 th, 20 07 Ob jec tio n a s t o

is n't th at rig ht? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Q. Ye s. In Ex hib it 28 we wer e loo kin g a t Ob jec tio n.

a mom ent ag o o n M ay 1st , 2 007 , the Tu esd ay bef ore is wh en you se nt yo ur ur gen t e -ma il ask ing th at the se vid eo s be re sto red to th e s erv ice . ri ght ? A. Q. Ye s. Mr . S olo w, hav e y ou eve r use d Isn 't th at

th e Y ouT ube se rvi ce bef ore ? A. Ye s.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 2

Schapiro Exhibit 3

Schapiro Exhibit 4

From: Sent: T o: Cc: Subject: Michael,

W ilkens, Scott B [SW [e-mail]] Thursday, February 18, 2010 2:47 PM Rubin, Michael Kohlmann, Susan J.; 'Gitterman, Noah Siskind'; Volkmer, Bart W atch Data

I am writing in reference to our last meet and confer regarding watch data, As we have noted before, and as we repeat here, we do not understand the relevance of the video viewing data for an account that was used to upload authorized marketing materials, in some cases only one or two clips. And as we have repeatedly emphasized, any purported relevance of such data has to be weighed against the privacy interests at stake for the accounts at issue. You agreed during the last call that any non-anonymized watch data produced would be produced pursuant to the new highest level of confidentiality under the protective order, which we believe is important in light of the privacy interests that attach to accounts used for personal viewing. Although we continue to dispute Defendants' claim of relevance, in order to reach agreement and ensure that the watch data for all parties is produced expeditiously, following is a list of YouTube account names, each of which was used by Viacom to upload one or more authorized Viacom marketing clips to YouTube. Assuming we can agree on the wording of an appropriate stipulation, which we discussed briefly on the last call, we agree to the production of non-anonymized data for these accounts for the time period previously agreed by the parties. W e have already made clear that we do not object to the production of watch data for YouTube accounts that were used by BayTSP, Auditude or a viral marketer acting on Viacom's behalf, although we continue to dispute the relevance of such data. W e will circulate a proposed stipulation shortly. beheard bestweekever bestweekevertv BroadwayJoe BroadwayJoe415 chu2007 Damonjohnson Demansr FiveChemical JackassTwoMovie keithhn mosjef73 mysticalgirl8 MTV2 MTV2AllThatRocks mtvnewsinterns MTVSneakAttack NMarketing Paraccount ParamountClassics ParamountGermany paramountpictureshow ParamountVantage ParkMyVibe PinkStrawberry Reaction2006 reno911miami SpikeTV StuntmanForever thinkmtv veehonerockz
1

VH1staff virtualmtv Regards, Scott

Scott B. Wilkens Jenner & Block LLP 1099 New York Avenue, N.W . Suite 900 W ashington, DC 20001-4412 Tel [phone] Fax [phone] SW [e-mail] www.jenner.com

CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete it from your system.

2

Schapiro Exhibit 5

Schapiro Exhibit 6

Schapiro Exhibit 7

Schapiro Exhibit 8

Schapiro Exhibit 9

Schapiro Exhibit 10

Subject: From: To: Cc:

Re: Flickr & Del.icio.us "Amy Powell" <> Kristina Tipton Megan Crowell

Date:

Fri, 10 Mar 2006 17:27:27 +0000

great! thanks. Amy Powell Senior Vice President, Interactive Marketing Paramount Pictures

-- Replied by Amy Powell on 3/10/2006 9:27:21 AM From:Kristina Tipton

-

03/10/2006 09:18 AM
To: Amy Powell cc: Amy Powell, Megan Crowell Subject: Re: Flickr & Del.icio.us Notes document link <http:// godfather3.paramount.com/88256e710071b6d7/38d46bf5e8f08834852564b500129b2c/6d2d69fb4f7c97fl8825712d005e5081> Both YouTube and Del.icio.us have the Nacho Confessional trailer up, and Scott knows they are both a priority for us to get Nacho assets on: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ULZRrg7LRQ&search=nacho%20libre http://del.icio.us/thatsfunny Thanks! Kristina Tipton Coordinator, Interactive Promotions & Publicity Paramount Pictures

323-956-8453
-- Replied by Kristina Tipton on 3/10/2006 9:13:51 AM

From:Amy Powell

03/10/2006 09:10 AM
To: Amy Powell cc: Kristina Tipton, Megan Crowell Subject: Re: Flickr & Del.icio.us Notes document link <http:// godfather4.paramount.com/88256fld007573c4/38d46bf5e8f08834852564b500129b2c/

a3ed4f84e428e01a8825712c00070e04>
KT: can i get an update? Amy Powell Senior Vice President, Interactive Marketing Paramount Pictures

CONFIDENTIAL

VIA00366609

Replied by Amy Powell on 3/10/2006 9:10:10 AM Fronv.Amy Powell 03/08/2006 05:17 PM To: Amy Powell cc: Kristina Tipton, Megan Crowell Subject: Re: Flickr & Del.icio.us Notes document link <http:// godfather3.paramount.com/88256e710071b6d7/38d46bf5e8f08834852564b500129b2c/572717427923a20b88257128008270ao KT: did we reach out to these sites with the confessional trailer? Amy Powell Senior Vice President, Interactive Marketing Paramount Pictures

Replied by Amy Powell on 3/8/2006 5:16:22 PM From:Amy Powell 03/05/2006 03:44 PM To: Megan Crowell cc: Kristina Tipton Subject: Re: Flickr & Del.icio.us megan- thanks so much for this great analysis. it sounds like we should concentrate on del.icio.us & youtube. KT: can you have Scott Hurwitz start concentrating on both sites asap? thanks. Amy Powell Senior Vice President, Interactive Marketing Paramount Pictures

-Megan Crowell/Marketing/MP/Paramount_Pictures wrote: To: Amy Powell/Marketing/MP/Paramount_Pictures@Paramount_Pictures From: Megan Crowell/Marketing/MP/Paramount_Pictures Date: 03/01/2006 04:06PM cc: Kristina Tipton/Marketing/MP/Paramount_Pictures<3>Paramount_Pictures Subject: Flickr & Del.icio.us Hi Amy, Just wanted to follow up from earlier this week when you asked about opportunities to integrate our movies into Flickr & Del.icio.us. For Flickr, I don't feel that there are any meaningful ways to promote existing content within their site. However, if we were to get talent or filmmakers to shoot a production diary of sorts, I think this would be something that might attract attention & interest from their users. I'd imagine we could get optimal presence by launching this on a portal or film site, and then once off exclusive the photos could be extended to Flickr as part of a wide distribution. If we were limited to, for instance, one behind the scenes Beowulf pic, once off exclusive, we could post it to Flickr from a dummy user account & mix in other random photos for a sense of authenticity.

CONFIDENTIAL

VIA00366610

As for del.icio.us, I think the key way to integrate here, is to add on to the video sharing site strategy, by linking to our content (i.e. clips on YouTube) & tagging these links with numerous relevant terms. For Nacho I'm sure we could come up with 50+ terms (funny, wrestling, Jack Black, etc). Please let me know your thoughts on this and the broader video sharing strategy. Looking forward to actualizing these ideas. Megan Crowell Paramount Pictures Interactive Marketing

323.956.8471 fax: [phone]

CONFIDENTIAL

VIA00366611

Schapiro Exhibit 11

Schapiro Exhibit 12

Schapiro Exhibit 13

Schapiro Exhibit 14

To: From: Cc: Bee: Received Date:

Kevin Donahue ~kevin@youtube,com? Andrew Lin heather gillette ~heather@youtube,com?; Andrew Lin ~[e-mail]?

2006-05-051847:14 CST
Re: Hi Kevin" '/Question

Subject:
Thanks Kevin,

Heather - Good to meet you"" would love to speak with you, In the short term, could you make sure that An
Inconvenient Truth trailer is not removed, It is definitely authorized to be on YouTube and we have many partners linking/embedding it (including our own site)
Please let me know if you have any questions"

Andrew [e-mail] 323/956-8873

On May 5, 2006, at 954 AM, Kevin Donahue wrote:

Andrew,

Looking forward to hammering out the plan for the new filmmakers program with you, Some time next week, Does Friday afternoon work for you? Maybe 2pm?

RE the notice below, I was informed of this by our copyright agent yesterday, Apparently Paramount is using some third party service to search YouTube and other sites for copyright infringing material and this is one of the pieces of content that the third party, acting on Paramount's behalf (as I understand it) wanted us to

remove,

You can learn the details from Heather Giette who I've cc'd here,

Best,
Kevin

From: Andrew Lin Sent: Thursday, May 04,200611 :33 PM

Confidential

G00001-01151214

To: Kevin Donahue
Subject: Hi Kevin,,'/Question

Importance: High

Kevin,

Great seeing you this week and thanks again for coming down and meeting some of the Paramount Classics team, Let me know if you're free next week to hammer out the "new filmmakers" program,

Also - i just received this note today", is there someone that i should speak to at you YouTube
regarding the below message? Obviously, we're very happy with the Trailer being showcased on YouTube, I'm not sure who's the "third party" who complained,

best,
Andrew

Andrew Lin - v: _ airn/msn:_ skype:_

Begin forwarded messge:

From: DMCA Complaints ?
Date: May 4, 200611 :46:55 AM PDT
To: Paramount

Classics ?

Subject: Video Rejected: Copyright Infringement

Dear Member:

This is to notify you that we have removed or disabled access to the following material as a result of a

Confidential

G00001-01151215

third-party notification claiming that this material is infringing:

An Inconvenient Truth - Trailer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUiP6dqPynE
Please Note: Repeat incidents of copyright infringement will result in the deletion of your account and all videos uploaded to that account. In order to avoid future strikes against your account, please delete any videos to which you do not own the rights, and refrain from uploading additional videos that infringe on the copyrights of others, For more information about YouTube's copyright policy, please read the Copyright Tips guide,

If you elect to send us a counter notice, to be effective it must be a written communication provided to our designated agent that includes substantially the following (please consult your legal counselor see 17 U,S,C,

Section 512(g)(3) to confirm these requirements)
(A) A physical or electronic signature of the subscriber.

(B) Identification of the material that has been removed or to which access has been disabled and the location at which the material appeared before it was removed or access to it was disabled,

(C) A statement under penalty of perjury that the subscriber has a good faith belief that the material was removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification of the material to be removed or disabled,
(D) The subscriberis name, address, and telephone number, and a statement that the subscriber consents to the jurisdiction of Federal District Court for the judicial district in which the address is located, or if the subscriberis address is outside of the United States, for any judicial district in which the service provider may be found, and that the subscriber will accept service of process from the person who provided notification under subsection (c)(1 )(C) or an agent of such person,
Such written notice should be sent to our designated agent as follows:

DMCA Complaints YouTube, Inc.
PO Box

2053

San Mateo, CA 94401

Email: copyright@youtubecom
Please note that under Section 512(f) of the Copyright Act, any person who knowingly materially misrepresents that material or activity was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification may be subject to
liability,

Sincerely,
YouTube, Inc,

To change or cancel your email notifications, go to your email options
Copyright @ 2006 YouTube, Inc,
abuse-copyright: tm pi

Confidential

G00001-01151216