The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 266

DECLARATION of Andrew H. Schapiro, Group 9, Exhibit 315 - 318 in Opposition re: 158 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment dismissing with prejudice Defendants' First Defense asserted in Defendants' Answer to the Second Amended Class Action Complaint... Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 319 - 335, # 2 Exhibit 336, Part 1, # 3 Exhibit 336, Part 2, # 4 Exhibit 336, Part 3, # 5 Exhibit 337 - 345, # 6 Exhibit 346 - 368, # 7 Exhibit 369 - 373)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Schapiro Exhibit 319

Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 320

Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 321

Schapiro Exhibit 322

Schapiro Exhibit 323

From: Date:

"Morril, Mark" *M ark.Morril @ viacom.com* Thu, 21 Jun 2007 17:13:58 -0400

To:

"Piene-Louis, Stanley" ~[e-mail]>, "Bell
,Alan-Paramount"
[e-mail]>

<Alan,Bell@IParamountcom>,

"Simon, Joe" <Joe

Subject:

FW:Viacom

From: David Estrada [mailto:destrada~~google.com]
Sent: Friday, June 15, 2007 6:32 PM To: Morril, Mark Subject: Fwd: Viacom

Mark, here is the fully executed agreement. This is the final word doc you sent me + the countenigned sig page.
Note that I changed the date and document version number In the footer of the final word doc to match the alreadysigned sig page. It was good working with you on this. Have a nice weekend.
David

-----Forwarded message ------From: Rachel Clanin <rclaRin~·youtube.com>
Date: Jun 15, 2007 11:47 AM

Subject: Viacom To: David Estrada ~[e-mail]
Viacom

RachelClafiin

Legal Assistant YouTube,LLC 1000 Cherry Ave, Suite Z San Bruno, CA 94066 [phone]
List of attachments:

Content Verification Test Agreement - Viacom.pdf

~X~ijSIT

CONFIDENTIAL

VlA02095742

CONTENT

VERIFICATION

TEST

AGREEMENT

This Content Verification Test Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into as of Junel-3,2-00f (~ffectiv~!-Date3-b~-Goog-le-ln c;-a-Delaware corporation with offices at ~600 Amphitheatre Parkway, M~untain CA, 94043, for itself and its

subsidiaries and affiliates("Googie"), Viacom Inc., a Delaware corporationwith and offices at 1515 Broadway,New York, New York 10036 ("Participant") behalf of on itself and its Affiliates, each individuallya uParty"and collectively "Parties". the "Affiliate" respect to either Party means the Party and any entity controlledby with
· such Party where "control" is defined as the ownership of at least 50% of the equity or beneficial interests of such entity or the~right to vote for or appoint a

majoritytheboard directors other of of or goveming ofsuch body entity.
1. Test Overview. The Parties wisli to exchange informationand content in
order to conduct a test (the "Test~~to analyze and evaluate Google's content

verificationtechnologyas applied to Participant's content (the "Purpose"). To
accomplish the Purpose, Googie shall make available to Participant a test account on YouTube.com ('Test Accounr), which Participant and its Affiliates may use

solely to test and evaluate Googie's content verificationtechnology. Participant
may deliver to Google:Reference Video and rest Video to be used solely by
Google for the Purpose. "Reference Video" means audiovisual material owned or

i

controlled by Participant consisting of television shows, motion pictures, or music videos. "Test Video" means audiovisual matedal owned or controlled by

Participant consisting of clips of audiovisualworks that range between thirty
seconds and ten minutes, and that may or may not match a portion of any· Reference Video. Participant may deliver to Google between ten and fiftytotal

hours of Reference Video. Participantwilldeliver Reference Video using a manual
· upload process similar to the upload process available at

http://www.youtube,com/my_videos_upload. Alternatively, subject to agreement between the parties during the Tern, Participant may deliver Reference Video via electronic delivery using Google's electronic delivery specifications. Participant will deliver Test Video using a manual upload process similar to the upload process made available at http://www.youtube.com/my_videoSupload. Google may modify the testing protocol and methodologies as may be required to accomplish the Purpose during the Term, provided that no such changes will modify the Terms of this Agreement without the prior written approval of Participant. Participant shall associate an identification number with each Reference Video (6 'Reference Video ID")and each Test Video (6 '7est Video ID"). At the conclusion of the Test, Participant shall report to Google which Test Video IDs were intended to match which Reference Video IDs, and shall provide information regarding any variables tested by Participant for each Test Video such as video resolution, audio on/off, mashups, alternative codecs, or other variables. Google shall report to Participant the results of the Test, each Test Video ID that matched a Reference Video ID, and the Test-Video IDs that did not match any Reference Video ID. Google and Participant shall make their respective technical representatives available to consult regarding the design and operation of Google's content verification

551626v1

1

'

06/13/2007

CONFIDENTIAL

VlA02095743

technology provided, however,that all nonpublicinformationdisclosed by either
party's technology representatives shall be deemed "Confidential Information" pursuant to paragraph 4·of this Agreement.

2.

Test Account. The Test Account will be protected by a username and
Participant and all Affiliates will be able to access the Test Account

password.

from up to ten IP addresses specified by Participant. The Test Account, Reference Videos and Test Videos willnot be accessible to anyone except Google and those
using the Participant username and password from a specified IP address.
Participant may remove Reference Videos and Test Videos from the Test and the

~Test Account at any time in its sole discretion, subject only to delays caused by the

technicalmethodsof delivery removalused bythe Parties,and Googlemay and
limitor discontinuethe use of the Test Account at any time ifGoogle reasonably believes the Test Account is being used by an unauthorized party or in any manner
that breaches this Agreement.

3.

Grant and Limitation of Rights. Participantgrants to Google a non-

exclusive, nontransferable limited right and license, with no right to sublicense, during the Term to store, copy (including the right to make temporary cache and

storage copies), internallydistn'bute,technicallymodifyor reformat,excerpt,
analyze, create algorithms based on, and otherwise use the Reference Video

and/or Test Video solely for the Purpose. Google will not use the Reference Video and/or Test Video for any purpose not expressly authorized hereunder. No reproduction or other use of the Reference Video and/or Test Video may be made

by Google, in whole or in part, except as described above. Participantreserves all rights not expressly granted hereunder. Google agrees to maintainParticipant's
Test Video and Reference Video in a secure manner, and shall use the same

degree of care, but no less than a reasonable degree of care, as Google uses with
respect to its own confidential information. In particular, and without limitingthis

general Google notmake copies the Reference duty, will the of Videos Test or
Videos provided hereunder publicly accessible. 4. Confidentiality. Neither party will disclose the existence or terms of this

Agreement to any third party, or issue any publicannouncement regarding the existence or terms of this Agreement, withoutthe other party's Priorwritten
agreement. All nonpublic information disclosed by Google to Participant in connection with the Test, including, without limitation, all data, methods, business plans, software, systems, security techniques, technology, know-how and results, is "Confidential Information" of Google. -The titles, durations, numbers of files and clips, and other details pertaining to the Reference Video and Test Video deliver~d by Participant or its Affiliates to Google and all other nonpublic information disclosed by Participant to Google hereunder for the Testis "Confidential

Information" Participant. Participantwillmake commerciallyreasonable efforts of
not t~ disclose to Google any other non-public information in connection with this

Agreement

Participant and Google may use the other party's Confidential

Informationonly for the Purpose, sharing it only with those of its employees who

55 1626v1

2

·

06/13/2007

CONFIDENTIAL

V1A02095744

need to know it to accomplish the Purpose. Google and Participant will protect the other Party's Confidential information with the same degree of care, but no less

than a reasonabledegree of care, as it uses withrespectto its ownconfidential
~ ... _.. .__jafarma~io~I~I_Nej~b~er_ea~ic.ip.ao.t. n.or_G_oagle~j Il_communicate_the_ofb.e.rPal·~ls Confidential Information toa third party or the public. Without Google's and Participant's prior written agreement, neither Google nor Participant will make copies of documents or electronic materials containing the other Party's Confidential Information; reverse engineer, disassemble, decompile, translate, or or attempt to discover any prototypes, software, algorithms, processes, or code that embody the other Party's Confidential Information. For the avoidance of doubt, Google is permitted to make server copies of Reference Videos and Test

Videos as necessary to conduct the Test. Except with respect to the terms'and
existence of this Agreement, this Agreement imposes no obligation upon Google or Participant with respect to the other Party's Confidential Information that: (i) a Party knew before receiving it from the other Party pursuant to this Agreement or the Test ; (ii) becomes publicly available through no fault of the other Party; (iii) is rightfully received by the other Party from a third party withbut a duty of confidentiality; or (iv) is independently developed by a the other Party without reference to the Google Confidential Information. If this Agreement or the Confidential Information of either Party is required to be produced by law, the noticed Party shall promptly notify the other Party (unless such notification is barred by law) and cooperate to obtain an appropriate protective order prior to disclosing any Confidential Information. Notwithstanding the foregoing, this Section shall have no effect whatsoever on Google's and/or Participants' discovery

rights and/or obligations in Viacom Infemational, Inc. et al v. Youfube, Inc. et al.,
Case No. 1:07-cv-02103-LLS, filed Rnarch 13, 2007, and currently pending in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, and any related litigation ('The Lawsuit"), and nothing herein shall be cited as a defense to production of any relevant material in discovery in the Lawsuit provided however that Google and Participants agree that Confidential Information received hereunder shall be designated as confidential pursuant to an appropriate protective
order entered therein.

5. Intellectual Property Rights. Other than the limited licenses expressly set forth herein, Google shall not acquire any intellectual prope~ rights from

Participant in the Reference Video or the Test Video. Participantshall not acquire
any intellectual property rights from Google in connection with this Agreement.

Google shall not be limited, restricted or obligatei~ in any way in its use of ideas or
suggestions provided by Participant in connection with the Agreement.
a. DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES. ALL CON~IDENTIAL INFORMATION, CONTENT VERIFICATION TECHNOLOGY, REFERENCE VIDEO, AND TEST
VIDEO LIMITED PROVIDED HEREUNDER IS PROVIDED "AS IS". THE PARTIES OF THE

DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES,
TO WARRANTIES

EXPRESS

OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
OR PERFORMANCE

AS TO THE QUALII~Y

INFORMATION,

TECHNOLOGY

AND/OR CONTENT

PROVIDED

AND

55 1626v1

3

06/13/2007

CONFID~ENTIAL

VlA02095745

WARRANTIES
RELIABLE.

THAT INFORMATION

PROVIDED

WILL BE ACCURATE

OR

7.

LIMITATION OF LIABILITY.

EXCEPT

WITH RESPECT

TO ANY BREACH

OF CONFIDENTIALITY UNDER SECTION 4, NEITHER PARTY WILL BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER FOR ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, LIQUIDATED, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES OR
PENALTIESARISING FROM THIS AGREEMENT OR ANY BREACH THEREOF. THIS SECTION SHALL HAVE NO EFFECT WHATSOEVER ON ANY LIABILlTY
ARISING FROM THE LAWSUIT.

8.

Term. This Agreement will commence

on the Effective Date and continue

for six months, unless terminated earlier by either Party, or extended by mutual agreement (the "Term"). Either Party may terminate this Agreement at any time by
providing not less than thirty days advance written notice to the other Party.

Except as provided in the finalsentence of this section, withinfifteendays after any
termination or expiration of this Agreement, Participant shall return to Google (if Google sorequest~)-or-destroy all Confidential Information of Google, and Google shall retum to Participant or destroy (if Participant requests) all Reference Video, Test Video and Confidential Information of Participant. The provisions of Sections

This Section have effect shall no whatsoever onGoogle's Participant's and/or duty
to preserve all evidence relevant to The Lawsuit.

4, 5,.6, 7, 8, and 9 shallsurvivethe expiration termination thisAgreement. or of

-I

9. Miscellaneous. The Parties are independent contractors, and nothing in this Agreement shall create an agency, partnership, or joint venture. Neither Party
may assign its rights or delegate its obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the othei Party. This Agreement sets forth the entire

agreement between the Parties and supersedes any prior or collateral agreements with respect to its subject matter. This Agreement may be amended only in a
writing signed by both Parties. Any notices made under this Agreement shall be in writing and sent to the other Party at the address listed in the first paragraph of this

Agreement to the attention of the Legal Department. This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of California (excluding California's choice of law rules) and applicable federal laws. Any litigation hereunder shall be brought in any state or federal court of competent jun'sdiction in Santa Clara County, California; the Parties consent to the venue and exclusive personal jurisdiction of, such
courts. This Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original and all of which taken together shall constitute
one and the same instrument. This Section shall have no effect whatsoever on the

forum, venue, personal jurisdiction, or choice of law applicable in The Lawsuit.

~o. Effect of Agreement on Lawsuit. The terms of this Agreement including Participant's participation in the Test and individual test results relating to

551626v1

4

06/13/2007

CON~1DENTIAL

VlA02095746

p~rtici~an~s Test Account, shall not be cited by any Party in the Lawsuitas an
admission of or a waiver by the other Party.

Google Inc.

Psrticipant: Wacom Inc.

BY: ~L(~r~r,rn ~L.a
NAME:~AA~C~ I a. fUoROc

Tln~.:~sa~ia_k~2~ae~8L TITLE:6~C I~s;o~il~C~ti
~cn~-~

551626vr

·

5

06/~312007

CONFIDENTIAL

VlA02095747

Schapiro Exhibit 324

Schapiro Exhibit 325

1

UN IT ED ST ATE S D IS TRI CT CO UR T FO R THE S OUT HER N DIS TR ICT O F N EW YO RK -- -o 0o- -TH E FOO TB ALL AS SO CIA TI ON PR EM IER L EAG UE LI MIT ED AN D BO UR NE CO ., ET AL ., ON BE HA LF OF T HEM SE LVE S A ND AL L OTH ER S SI MI LAR LY SI TUA TE D,, ) ) ) ) ) ) PL AI NTI FF S, ) vs . ) 07 CI V. 35 82( LLS ) ) YO UT UBE , INC ., YO UTU BE , L LC ) AN D GOO GL E, INC ., , ) ) DE FE NDA NT S. ) ) __ __ ___ __ ___ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ ) ) VI AC OM IN TER NAT IO NAL I NC. , ) CO ME DY PA RTN ERS , COU NT RY MU SIC ) TE LE VIS IO N, INC ., PA RA MOU NT ) PI CT URE S COR POR AT ION , AND ) BL AC K E NT ERT AIN ME NT ) TE LE VIS IO N, LLC , ) ) PL AI NTI FF S, ) vs . ) 07 C IV. 2 103 (L LS ) ) YO UT UBE , INC ., YO UTU BE , L LC ) AN D GOO GL E, INC ., , ) ) DE FE NDA NT S. ) __ __ ___ __ ___ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ ) VI DE OTA PE D D EPO SI TIO N OF JI M P ATT ER SON FR ID AY, D ECE MBE R 18, 2 009 SA N FRA NC ISC O, CA LIF OR NIA Jo b No. 1 841 1

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

UN IT ED S TAT ES D IS TRI CT C OU RT FO R TH E SOU TH ER N DIS TR IC T OF NE W YO RK -- -o 0o -- TH E FO OT BAL L AS SO CIA TI ON PR EM IE R LEA GU E LI MIT ED A ND BO UR NE C O., E T AL ., ON B EH ALF OF T HE MS ELV ES A ND AL L OT HE RS SI MI LA RL Y S IT UA TE D,, ) ) ) ) ) ) PL AI NT IF FS, ) vs . ) 07 CI V. 3 582 (L LS ) ) YO UT UB E, IN C. , YO UTU BE , LL C ) AN D GO OG LE, I NC ., , ) ) DE FE ND AN TS. ) ) __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ _) VI AC OM I NTE RN AT IO NAL I NC ., ) CO ME DY P ART NE RS , COU NT RY M USI C) TE LE VI SI ON, I NC ., PA RA MO UN T ) PI CT UR ES CO RP OR AT ION , AN D ) BL AC K EN TER TA IN ME NT ) TE LE VI SI ON, L LC , ) ) PL AI NT IF FS, ) vs . ) 07 C IV . 210 3 (L LS ) ) YO UT UB E, IN C. , YO UTU BE , LL C ) AN D GO OG LE, I NC ., , ) ) DE FE ND AN TS. ) __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ _) VI DE OT AP ED DE PO SI TIO N OF J IM PA TT ER SON , TA KE N ON B EH AL F O F TH E PLA IN TI FF S, AT 9 :0 5 A .M ., WE DN ES DA Y, DE CE MB ER 16 , 20 09 AT 6 01 CA LI FO RN IA ST RE ET , SUI TE 1 40 0, SA N FR ANC IS CO , CAL IF OR NI A B EF OR E MA RY J AC KSO N, C SR NO . 86 88 , P UR SU AN T T O NO TI CE.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES Fo r the P lai nti ff Vi ac om: JE NN ER & BLO CK, L LP 10 99 Ne w Yor k A ve nue , NW, S uit e 9 00 Wa sh ing to n, D.C . 200 01 BY : LU KE PL ATZ ER , E SQ . SA RA H M AG UIR E, ES Q. (2 02 ) 6 37 -63 61 lp la tze r@ jen ner .c om sm ag uir e@ jen ner .c om Fo r the P lai nti ff s T he Fo ot bal l A ss oci at ion P rem ier Le ag ue Li mit ed: BE RN STE IN , L ITO WI TZ, B ERG ER & GRO SS MAN 12 48 1 H ig h B luf f Dri ve , S ui te 300 Sa n Die go , C ali fo rni a 921 30 BY : BE NJ AMI N G AL DST ON , E SQ . (8 58 ) 7 20 -31 88 be ng @bl bg law .co m Fo r the D efe nda nt s G oo gle a nd You Tu be: WI LS ON, S ONS INI , GOO DR ICH & RO SAT I 65 0 Pag e Mil l R oa d Pa lo Al to , C ali fo rni a 943 04 BY : MA UR A R EES , ESQ . (6 50 ) 4 93 -93 00 mr ee s@w sg r.c om

AL SO PR ES ENT :

AD AM BA REA , Cou nse l for G oog le AR MA NDO C ARR ASC O, Vi de ogr ap her

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

36 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:55 9:54 9:54 9:54 9:54 9:54 9:54

A. Q.

M ax imu m do ll ar am ou nt . O ka y. D o yo u k no w wh at th e ma xim um d ol lar

am ou nt t o w hi ch Y ouT ub e ha s e ve r in dem ni fi ed a pa rt ne r? A. Q. ma gn it ud e? A. Q. N o, I do n' t. T ha t's s om et hin g we c oul d fi nd ou t if w e I d on' t. D o you k no w app ro xi ma tel y or de r o f

lo ok ed a t t he a gr eem en ts t hem se lv es ? A. Q. Y es , I i ma gi ne th at 's tr ue . D o you k no w rou gh ly h ow ma ny o f t he

pa rt ne rs hip a gr ee men ts h av e i nd em ni fic at io n pr ov is io ns of t ha t n at ur e? MS . RE ES : sc op e of th e no ti ce. TH E WI TN ESS : nu mb er . Q. A. Q. A ro und f iv e? I d on' t kn ow . It w ou ld be a n exc ep ti on . I b eli ev e it 's a ve ry sm al l Sa me o bje ct io n, ou ts id e the

I 'd li ke t o cha ng e ge ars f or a bi t an d ask

ab ou t a dif fe re nt to pi c. A. Q. M m- hmm . I 'd li ke t o ask s om e que st io ns ab ou t ho w

co nt en t get s sy nd ica te d to pa rt ne rs in t er ms of h ow

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

37 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 9:57 9:56 9:57 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:56 9:55

it a ct ua lly h ap pe ns.

Yo u men ti on ed ea rl ie r tha t

pa rt ne rs ac ce ss Y ouT ub e vi deo s th ro ugh t he I nte rn et ; is t ha t cor re ct ? A. P ar tne rs a cc ess t he Y ouT ub e se rvi ce

th ro ug h the I nt er net , ye s. Q. S o You Tu be s tor es t he vi de os o n i ts o wn

se rv er s and p ar tn ers c an t hen r en de r t ho se v ide os o n th ei r se rvi ce s or de vi ce s? A. Q. pa rt ne rs ? A. Q. H as wh ic h al way s be en th e ca se ? T ha t v id eo s the ms el ve s r em ai n pos te d on Y es . H as th at a lw ays b ee n the c as e for a ll

Yo uT ub e' s o wn s er ver s? A. I b eli ev e th at ha s al mos t al wa ys be en t rue

ex ce pt f or on e ve ry ea rl y cas e an d the n on ly on a ve ry s ma ll sc al e. Q. A. Q. W as th at V er izo n? Y es . A nd in t he c ase o f Ve riz on , di d Y ou Tu be

de li ve r cop ie s of th e vi de os to V er izo n? A. Q. I b eli ev e, y es. D ur ing w ha t tim e fr am e w as t ha t m et ho d of

sy nd ic at ion u se d? A. I b eli ev e it wa s ar ou nd 20 06 .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

38 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 9:58 9:58 9:58 9:57 9:57 9:58 9:58 9:57 9:57 9:57 9:57 9:57 9:57 9:57

Q. A.

An d abo ut ho w l on g d id it la st ? I do n't kn ow fo r sur e. I be li eve i t

wa s -- I don 't kn ow fo r s ur e.

I ca n - - I c an gi ve

yo u my se nse , b ut I ca n't s ay aut ho rit at ive ly . Q. A. mo nt hs. Q. Ok ay . At th at po int - - a t s om e p oi nt -At so me po int V eri zo n b eg an Gi ve me yo ur se ns e p le ase . My s ens e i s it' s pro ba bly ab ou t s ix

so rr y s tr ike th at .

ac ce ssi ng vi deo s hos te d o n You Tub e ser ve rs? A. Q. Ye s. An d are th er e a ny pa rt ner s o th er th an

Ve ri zon t o w hom Y ouT ub e d el ive red c opi es of t he vi de o f or sy ndi ca tio n? A. Q. A. Q. I do n't be li eve s o. Th at wa sn' t the p roc ed ure us ed fo r Hel io ? I do n't be li eve s o. Ro ug hly ho w man y vid eo s d id Yo uTu be

sy nd ica te to Ve ri zon ? MS . REE S: O bje ct ion , vag ue as to t ime ,

va gu e a s to syn di cat e. MR . PLA TZ ER: fa ir ob je cti on. qu es tio n. MR . PLA TZ ER: Q. D ur ing t he per io d o f T ha t's a fa ir -- th at 's a

Let m e t ry to re ph ras e the

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:00 10:00 9:59 9:59 9:59 9:59 9:59 9:58

ti me d ur ing w hi ch Yo uT ub e syn di ca te d v id eo s to Ve ri zo n by su pp ly ing V er iz on wi th c opi es o f the vi de os , app ro xi ma tel y ho w man y vi de os di d Yo uTu be pr ov id e to Ve ri zo n? A. I w oul d es ti mat e th e cum ul at iv e t ot al a t

ab ou t 20 00. Q. T he st an da rd pr oc ed ur e t ha t yo u d es cr ib ed

ea rl ie r whi ch i s tha t vi de os re ma in po st ed o n Yo uT ub e ser ve rs t hat a re r end er ed b y t he p ar tne r, th at 's a fa ir c ha rac te ri za tio n of h ow it u su all y wo rk s? MS . RE ES : Ob je ct ion , va gu e a s to r end er . Y es . Q. Do es t ha t p ro ce du re

TH E WI TN ESS : MR . PL AT ZER :

re qu ir e You Tu be t o m ak e th e v id eo s ava il ab le in co de cs o the r th an fl as h? A. Y ea h. F la sh is n' t re all y a co dec , bu t it

re qu ir es us t o ma ke th e vi deo a va il abl e in m ult ip le fo rm at s. Q. W ha t f or ma ts ha s Yo uT ube o ve r tim e us ed to

ma ke v id eos a va il abl e fo r syn di ca ti on pa rt ne rs? A. T he de ta il s get p re tt y t ec hn ic al, b ut i n a

va ri et y of di ff er ent f id el iti es , di ffe re nt s ize s, di ff er en t c an va s siz es , so pi xe l di men si on s, fo r ex am pl e, an d a va rie ty o f dif fe re nt de gr ee s of

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:02 10:02 10:01 10:01 10:01 10:01 10:01 10:01

co mp re ss ion f or r ela ti ve ly fa st er o r r el at iv ely sl ow er I nte rn et c onn ec ti on s. Q. at a t im e. fi de li ti es. A. Q. A. U h- huh . C an yo u ex pl ain w ha t tha t me an s? Y es . So s om e d ev ic es li ke a p hon e, h av e a So yo u ne ed to d el ive r th e L et 's un pa th th at a nd ta lk a bo ut th os e one Y ou m ent io ne d fir st v ar iet y of d iff er en t

ve ry , ve ry sm al l scr ee n.

Yo uT ub e ser vi ce i n a w ay t hat i t ca n b e re nd ere d on th at v er y s ma ll s cre en i n rel at iv el y l ow f id eli ty . Wh er ea s in co nt ra st, s om e PCs h av e a v er y la rge sc re en a nd a ve ry po we rf ul CP U, s o the y ar e cap ab le of h an dl ing m or e dat a an d ren de ri ng a vi de o in hi gh er f ide li ty . So i n or der t o al low t he Y ouT ub e se rvi ce to b e ac ces se d ov er th e In ter ne t by a nu mb er of di ff er en t d ev ic es , w e ma ke th em a va ila bl e in di ff er en t f id el it ies . Q. O ka y. S o Yo uTu be m ak es mu lt ip le co pi es of

th e vi de os th at i t s yn di ca tes e ac h in a di ff ere nt fi de li ty ? A. Q. Y es . O ka y. H ow m any d if fe ren t fi de lit ie s ha s

Yo uT ub e use d ov er ti me t o mak e it s vid eo s av ail ab le

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 326

Schapiro Exhibit 327

Schapiro Exhibit 328

Schapiro Exhibit 330

Schapiro Exhibit 331

Schapiro Exhibit 332

Redacted at the request of Defendants pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 333

Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 334

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

0230 1 2 3 4 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC., COMEDY PARTNERS, COUNTRY MUSIC TELEVISION, INC., 5 PARAMOUNT PICTURES CORPORATION, and BLACK ENTERTAINMENT TELEVISION, LLC, 6 7 8 v. Plaintiffs, Case No. 07 CV 2103 9 YOUTUBE, INC., YOUTUBE, LLC, and 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 CONTINUED DEPOSITION of WARREN SOLOW, taken by the Defendants, on Wednesday, September 19, 2007 at 9:33 a.m., pursuant to Notice, at the offices of Wilson, Sonsini, Goodrich & Rosati, 1301 Avenue of the Americas, New York, New York, before Marie Foley, a Registered Professional Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter and Notary Public within and for the State of New York. GOOGLE INC., Defendants. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x

230

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

1 2 3

A P P E A R A N C E S: JENNER & BLOCK Attorneys for Plaintiffs

4 919 Third Avenue 5 37th Floor 6 New York, New York 7 [phone] 8 F: [phone] 9 [e-mail] 10 BY: 11 12 13 FAEGRE & BENSON, LLP 14 Attorneys for Defendants 15 2200 Wells Fargo Center 16 90 South Seventh Street 17 Minneapolis, Minnesota 18 [phone] 19 F: [phone] 20 [e-mail] 21 22 23 24 25 BY: JOHN H. HINDERAKER, ESQ. 55402-3901 SUSAN J. KOHLMANN, ESQ. 10022-3908

231

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

BERNSTEIN, LITOWITZ, BERGER & GROSSMAN, LLP Attorneys for Premier League and Bourne Music 1285 Avenue of the Americas New York, New York [phone] F: [phone] [e-mail] BY: ERIC T. KANEFSKY, ESQ. 10019

Also Present: 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 DAVID N. YERICH, ESQ., Faegre & Benson STANLEY PIERRE-LOUIS, ESQ., Viacom

232

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

issues? A. Other than human moderation and the

AM filter, I don't believe so. Q. Can you think of any other data

fields in the database that contains information about these user uploaded videos? A. No. MR. HINDERAKER: This would

probably be a good time to take a break and take a minute to organize my next. (Recess was taken.) BY MR. HINDERAKER: Q. Let's take a look at question 22, It says,

please, in the notice, topic 22.

"Any databases or similar systems used by Viacom to store, index or maintain information, including date, titles, honors, responses, tags, description, duration, rating, view count, comments, et cetera about videos, including, but not limited to, content, available or previously available through any Viacom online properties." some specifications about that database. Now, with respect to the database Then

404

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

associated with Spike TV, which we've been talking about before the break, is there any additional information that you could offer that would be responsive to that topic number 22? A. Q. Not that I can recall. Another Web site that I believe is

operated by Viacom is Atom something. Do you know what the name of that site is? A. Q. A. Atom Entertainment has two sites. What are the two sites? I believe one is called Atom Films

and one is called Atom Uploads. Q. A. Q. Are they part of MTVN? Yes. I'm looking here at Atom Uploads,

and as you can see, that's another site. It's a different format and has some different features, but it's another site where users can upload videos, and they appear on the Atom Uploads sites; is that right? A. Q. Yes. Are you generally familiar with the

405

9/19/2007 Solow , Warren (ESI Day 2)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Atom Uploads site? A. Q. In a very basic sense. In preparation for your testimony

here today, did you go out and try to gather any information about the Atom Uploads site and thousand works? A. Q. A. Yes. How did you do that? I spoke to counsel. I reflected on

my previous interactions with Atom Entertainment personnel. I spoke to

personnel at Atom, and I caused others to speak to people at Atom. Q. What did you learn from that

investigation? A. That my previous understanding of

Atom was accurate. Q. A. In what respects? That information that I previously

held was confirmed. Q. A. What sort of information? Information concerning the function

of Atom Entertainment's Web sites. Q. A. How they function, you mean? Yes.

406

Schapiro Exhibit 335

1

UN IT ED ST ATE S DIS TR ICT C OUR T FO R THE S OUT HE RN DI STR IC T O F NEW Y ORK VI AC OM IN TER NA TIO NA L I NC ., CO MED Y PA RT NER S, CO UN TRY M USI C TE LE VIS IO N, IN C., P ARA MO UNT PI CT URE S COR PO RAT IO N, an d B LA CK EN TE RTA IN MEN T TEL EV ISI ON LL C, Pl ai nti ff s, vs . ) C as e N o. YO UT UBE , INC ., YO UT UBE , LLC , an d GOO GL E, IN C., ) ) ) ) ) ) )

) 1: 07C V0 210 3 ) ) De fe nda nt s. ) __ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ _) TH E FOO TB ALL A SSO CI ATI ON PR EM IER ) LE AG UE LI MIT ED , B OU RNE C O., e t a l. ,) on b eha lf of t hem se lve s and a ll ) ot he rs si mil ar ly si tua te d, ) ) Pl ai nti ff s, ) vs . ) C ase N o. YO UT UBE , INC ., YO UT UBE , LLC , and ) 07 CV3 58 2 GO OG LE, I NC. , ) ) De fe nda nt s. ) __ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ) VI DE OTA PE D D EP OSI TI ON OF WA DE DA VI S Ne w Yor k, Ne w Yor k Th ur sda y, Au gu st 6t h, 20 09 RE PO RTE D BY: ER IC A R UG GIE RI , C SR , R PR JO B NO: 1 741 0

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Au gus t 6 , 2 009 10 :08 a. m.

VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F W ADE DA VIS , he ld at the of fic es of May er Bro wn , 1 675 Br oad way , N ew Yor k, New Yo rk, pu rsu an t t o no tic e, bef ore be for e E ric a L . R ugg ie ri, Re gis ter ed Pro fes sio nal Re por ter an d No tar y P ubl ic of the St ate of Ne w Yor k.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES

FO R T HE PLA INT IFF S: JE NNE R & BL OCK , L LP BY : SUS AN KOH LMA NN, ES Q.

91 9 T hir d A ven ue 37t h F loo r Ne w Y ork , N Y 1 002 2-3 908

FO R T HE DEF END ANT S MA YER BR OWN , L LP BY : AND REW SC HAP IRO , E SQ.

16 75 Bro adw ay Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k (2 12) 50 6-2 146 @m aye rbr own .co m 100 19

AL SO PRE SEN T: CA RLO S K ING , V ide ogr aph er

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

163 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:28:08 02:27:58 02:27:43 02:27:23 02:27:17

DA VIS Do yo u h ave a gen era l re col lec tio n t hat Bo b t hou ght th at Yo uTu be wa s w ort h l ess th an a b ill ion do ll ars ? A. I hon est ly don 't hav e a

re col lec tio n o f w hat Bo b t hou ght th e val ue wa s. Q. Do yo u h ave a rec oll ect io n o f

wh at any one th oug ht the va lue wa s? MS . K OHL MAN N: Yo u c an ans wer . A. Ot her th an -- oth er tha n the Ob jec tio n.

au tho r o f t his bl og, no . Q. Di d V iac om, by th e w ay, m ake an

ac qui sit ion of an on -li ne pro per ty in th e su mme r o f 2 006 ? I' ll giv e y ou a h int . th ink ing ab out At omF ilm s. A. Ye ah. I wa s t ryi ng to re cal l i f I'm

it wa s i n t he sum mer . I don 't rec all ex act ly whe n t hat ac qui sit ion cl ose d. Q. It wa s s ome tim e a fte r y ou ha d

ar riv ed at the co mpa ny, yo u w ere w ork ing th ere ?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

164 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:29:04 02:28:53 02:28:35 02:28:27 02:28:18

DA VIS A. Q. Ye s, yes . If I sug ges ted th at the

an nou nce men t w as Aug ust 10 th, 20 06, w oul d th at see m a bou t r igh t? A. Ag ain , I ju st don 't rec al l w hen

th e a nno unc eme nt mig ht hav e b een ma de ve rsu s w hen we mi ght ha ve act ual ly cl ose d th e t ran sac tio n. Q. A. Wh at is Ato mFi lms ? Ag ain , t he com pan y w e a cq uir ed

is At om Ent ert ain men t. Q. I' m s orr y. Wh at is At om

En ter tai nme nt? A. At om Ent ert ain men t w as a

co lle cti on of Int ern et pro per tie s t hat in clu ded Ad dic tin gGa mes , S hoc kwa ve, At omF ilm s, Add ict ing Cli ps and ot her In ter net pr ope rti es. Q. An d w oul d V iac om hav e p er for med

du e d ili gen ce bef ore an ac qui sit ion o f th at siz e? MS . K OHL MAN N: Yo u c an ans wer . A. Ye s. Ob jec tio n.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

165 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:30:09 02:29:50 02:29:37 02:29:25 02:29:13

DA VIS Q. An d w oul d V iac om hav e i nq uir ed

ab out th e l ega l r isk s a sso cia ted wi th ac qui rin g A tom Fil ms? A. Q. Ye s. An d d id Via com lo ok at po ten tia l

le gal ex pos ure re lat ed to cop yri ght in fri nge men t t hat At omF ilm s f ace d, bef or e ac qui rin g t he com pan y? MS . K OHL MAN N: I' m g oin g t o j ust

ca uti on the wi tne ss, to th e e xte nt it co mes up in th e a nsw er, I' m s ure Mr . S cha pir o i s n ot ask ing yo u f or at tor ney -cl ien t p riv ile ge; bu t j ust to be ca ref ul in you r a nsw er not to di scu ss any thi ng tha t m igh t b e at tor ney -cl ien t p riv ile ge. TH E W ITN ESS : I g ues s I 'm not

aw are of ex act ly wha t w oul d b e at tor ney -cl ien t p riv ile ged in for mat ion . Do es it mak e s ens e t o t ake a br eak so yo u c an des cri be tha t t o me? MS . K OHL MAN N: We ll, wh y

do n't -- yo u w ant to re rea d t he

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

166 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:30:57 02:30:49 02:30:42 02:30:31 02:30:15

DA VIS qu est ion , a nd may be the re' s a wa y to an swe r t he que sti on, an d t hen we c an ha ve a d isc uss ion . Q. Wi tho ut tel lin g m e a nyt hin g

ab out th e r esu lts of su ch inq uir ies . MR . S CHA PIR O: Al tho ugh wh ile

no t c onc edi ng, gi ven th e c urr ent st at e of mo tio n p rac tic e, tha t t hat is o r i s no t p riv ile ged . But I' m h app y - - I'm

no t i nte res ted ri ght no w i n w hat t he re sul t o f a ny leg al inq uir ies we re. Q. Ca n y ou tel l j ust te ll me , I

th ink yo ur cou nse l a nd I w ill bo th ag ree th at -MS . K OHL MAN N: su bje ct mat ter . Q. -- it is no t - - t hat y ou are Th e g ene ral

fi ne ans wer ing wh eth er the re act ual ly wa s so me exa min ati on of leg al exp osu re, wi tho ut tel lin g m e w hat co ncl usi ons w ere re ach ed. A. So is th e q ues tio n - - can yo u

re pea t t he exa ct que sti on? Q. Su re. I t h as now sc ro lle d u p,

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

167 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:32:13 02:31:44 02:31:36 02:31:20 02:31:08

DA VIS bu t I 'll re pea t t he que sti on, wh ich i s: Di d V iac om loo k a t p ote nti al le gal ex pos ure re lat ed to the co pyr ig ht in fri nge men t t hat At om' s F ilm -- th at At omF ilm s m igh t h ave fa ced , b efo re ac qui rin g t he com pan y? A. I don 't rec all sp eci fic

di scu ssi on -- spe cif ic eva lua tio n o f co pyr igh t e xpo sur e. Q. I thi nk you me nti one d e ar lie r a

se rvi ce cal led Ad dic tin gCl ips ? A. Q. Ye s. Th at was pa rt of Ato m

En ter tai nme nt? A. Q. Ye s. An d d o y ou hav e a n u nd ers tan din g

of wh at the Ad dic tin gCl ips si te was , or wh at it did ? A. Ye s. It wa s p red omi nan tl y

us er- gen era ted co nte nt. Q. An d d o y ou kno w w het her V iac om

co ncl ude d t hat Ad dic tin gCl ips wa s c ove re d by th e p rot ect ion s o f t he Dig ita l Mi lle nni um Cop yri ght Ac t?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

168 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 02:32:57 02:32:47 02:32:37 02:32:28 02:32:15

DA VIS MS . K OHL MAN N: Ob jec tio n, cal ls

fo r a le gal co ncl usi on. Yo u c an ans wer . A. I don 't rec all . I m ea n w hat do

yo u r eca ll -- I m ean th e p rim ary r eas on we ac qui red th at bus ine ss was no t f or an y o f th e v ide o p rop ert ies , i t w as for t he ca sua l g ami ng pro per tie s. An d i n fac t,

we 've sh ut dow n, I t hin k w e h ave s hut do wn al l o f t he vid eo pro per tie s. Q. do wn? A. Q. A. co mpa ny. Q. An d w as tha t a cqu ire d w he n y ou I don 't. Wh at is Tag Wor ld? Ta gWo rld wa s a so cia l n et wor kin g Do yo u k now wh y y ou sh ut the m

we re at Via com ? A. Q. Ye s. An d d o y ou kno w i f d ue di lig enc e

wa s d one , i n c onn ect ion wi th the T agW orl d ac qui sit ion ? A. Q. Ye s. An d d o y ou kno w i f t ha t

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]