The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 314

DECLARATION of ANDREW H. SCHAPIRO in Support re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 110 PART 6, # 2 Exhibit 111 - 134, # 3 Exhibit 135 - 146, # 4 Exhibit 147 PART 1, # 5 Exhibit 147 PART 2, # 6 Exhibit 148 - 155, # 7 Exhibit 156 - 161, # 8 Exhibit 162 - 198)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Schapiro Exhibit 148

Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 149

Schapiro Exhibit 150

1

U NI TE D ST AT ES D IS TR IC T C OU RT F OR T HE S OU TH ER N DI ST R IC T OF N EW Y OR K

V IA CO M IN TE RN AT IO NA L, IN C. , CO ME DY P AR TN ER S, C OU NT RY M US I C. T EL EV IS IO N, I NC ., P AR A MO UN T P IC TU RE S CO RP OR AT IO N, an d BL AC K E NT ER TA IN ME NT T EL EV IS IO N , LL C,

) ) ) ) ) ) P la in ti ff s, ) ) v s. ) NO . 07 -C V- 21 03 ) Y OU TU BE , IN C. , YO UT UB E , LL C, ) a nd G OO GL E, I NC ., ) ) D ef en da nt s. ) _ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ _ __ __ __ __ __ _) ) T HE F OO TB AL L AS SO CI AT I ON P RE MI ER ) L EA GU E LI MI TE D, B OU RN E C O. , et a l. ,) o n be ha lf o f th em se lv e s an d al l ) o th er s si mi la rl y si tu a te d, ) ) P la in ti ff s, ) v s. ) NO . 07 -C V- 35 82 ) Y OU TU BE , IN C. , YO UT UB E , LL C, a nd ) G OO GL E, I NC ., ) ) D ef en da nt s. ) _ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ _ __ __ __ __ __ _) V ID EO TA PE D DE PO SI TI ON OF T HE OD OR A MI CH AE LS S AN F RA NC IS CO , CA LI FO R NI A S EP TE MB ER 2 4, 2 00 9 J OB N O. 1 77 64

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

A P P E A R A N C E S: LI EFF CA BRA SER HE IMA NN & B ERN STE IN, L LP At tor ney s f or Pla int iff an d W itn ess 25 0 H uds on Str eet 8t h F loo r Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k 1 001 3-1 413 BY : ANN IKA K. MA RTI N, ESQ .

MA YER BR OWN , L LP At tor ney s f or Def end ant 16 75 Bro adw ay Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k 1 001 9-5 820 BY : CHR IST INE M. HE RNA NDE Z, ESQ . AN D JA SON KI RSC HNE R, ESQ .

AL SO PRE SEN T: NI CHO LAS GU ZMA N, Vid eog rap her

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

102 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:27:17 13:27:18 13:27:18 13:27:25 13:27:29 13:27:29 13:27:32 13:27:36 13:27:38 13:27:40 13:27:41 13:27:41 13:27:47 13:27:52 13:27:55 13:27:58 13:28:01 13:28:04 13:28:05 13:28:05 13:28:08 13:28:10 13:28:10 13:28:10 13:28:20

A. Q.

Y es . O ka y. Is t hi s a t ru e an d c or re ct co py o f the

wa y th e The od or a Mic ha el s You Tu be c han ne l ap pea rs on Y ou Tu be? A. Y es . Wi th t he ex ce pt ion t ha t my ba by

ni ec e lo oks s uc h cut er o n the o ri gi nal . Q. F ai r e no ug h, fa ir e no ugh . An d th en , i f yo u loo k on t he th ir d pag e of t hi s exh ib it - A. Q. Y es . - - it sa ys , "Vi de os ( 11) ," a nd th en

th er e is 11 , so rt of t hu mb nai l im ag es of v id eos . Ha ve y ou ev er p os ted a ny v ide os t o Yo uT ub e -- fi rs t -- le t me st ri ke t hat . Th e vi de os th at a re sh ow n her e on t he th ir d pa ge of t hi s e xh ib it , a re t he y, in f ac t, al l th e vi de os th at y ou up lo ad ed? A. Q. Y es . H av e y ou e ve r h os te d any v id eo s t o

Yo uT ub e tha t ar e not s ho wn on t he t hir d pa ge of th is e xh ibi t? A. Q. N o. A nd yo u se e the t hu mb nai l im ag e a nd t he

ti tl e, " Bes t of t he Vi ew "; do y ou s ee th at ?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

103 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:28:23 13:28:23 13:28:28 13:28:31 13:28:32 13:28:33 13:28:39 13:28:42 13:28:43 13:28:43 13:28:44 13:28:59 13:29:02 13:29:07 13:29:11 13:29:12 13:29:14 10:16:23 10:16:23 13:29:14 13:29:49 13:29:49 13:29:51 13:29:51 13:29:53

A. Q.

Y es . A nd it s ta te s, "o ne m ont h ag o, " i s th at

co rr ec t, in i nd ic ati ng t ha t y ou p os ted t ha t vid eo ab ou t a mon th a go ? A. Q. Y es . A nd is t hi s vid eo , "B est o f th e V ie w" ,

th e on e you r ef er enc ed e ar lie r, w it h y ou r hu sba nd in t he a udi en ce ? A. Q. Y es . O ka y. MS . HE RN AND EZ : I am g oi ng to m ar k as

Ex hi bi t 11, a ga in , t wo p ag es pr in te d f ro m th e Yo uT ub e web s it e, of a v id eo po st ed by u se r na me T he odo ra M ic hae ls , th e u se r na me fo r Mi ss M ic hae ls , an d t he se w ere p ri nt ed on Se pt em be r 1 8t h. ) (P ri nt ou ts of M is s M ic ha el 's ch an ne l o n Yo uT ub e mar ke d Ca rli n Ex hi bit 1 1 fo r id en ti fi cat io n. ) TH E WI TN ESS : BY M S. H ERN AN DE Z: Q. A. Q. H av e y ou h ad a ch an ce to l oo k at it ? Y es . A nd Mi ss M ic hae ls , is th is a t rue a nd O ka y.

co rr ec t cop y of t he Yo uT ub e w eb p ag e f or t he "B es t

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

104 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:29:57 13:30:00 13:30:00 13:30:00 13:30:01 13:30:05 13:30:09 13:30:11 13:30:13 13:30:16 13:30:16 13:30:16 13:30:19 13:30:22 13:30:22 13:30:29 13:30:32 13:30:35 13:30:46 13:30:49 13:30:52 13:30:57 13:31:06 13:31:06 13:31:11

of T he V iew " vi de o t ha t yo u t es ti fi ed yo u up lo ad ed ? A. Q. Y es . O ka y. An d th is is a c li p f ro m th e T V sh ow , "T he V ie w," f ro m an ep is od e t ha t ai red o n Au gu st 5 th, 2 00 9; th at i s rig ht ? A. Q. ri gh t? A. Q. Y es . H ow di d yo u com e to h ave , in y our Y es . A nd "T he V ie w" pl ay s on th e ne two rk A BC ,

po ss es si on, t he v ide o cl ip th at y ou up lo ad ed as "B es t of th e Vi ew "? A. I d own lo ad ed it f ro m -- fr om e ith er t he

of fi ci al AB C we b sit e or t he of fi ci al we b si te fo r "T he V ie w." Q. I fo rge t wh ic h o ne .

A nd yo u wr it e, in t he to p ri gh t-h an d

bo x, " I' ve ne ve r see n th e sho w, b ut th at i s my Ke vi n in th e re d shi rt , da nci ng w it h t he c as t o f Ha ir , on 8/ 5/ 09 ." A. al lo ws . Q. A. " Sm ile y Fa ce ," di d yo u w ri te t hat ? Y es . I z oom ed i n on hi m as mu ch a s iMo vi e

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

105 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:31:11 13:31:13 13:31:20 13:31:24 13:31:32 13:31:35 13:31:38 13:31:39 13:31:39 13:31:41 13:31:45 13:31:45 13:31:50 13:31:54 13:31:55 13:31:55 13:31:56 13:31:56 13:32:02 13:32:05 13:32:06 13:32:07 13:32:09 13:32:11 13:32:11

Q. A.

W ha t i s iM ov ie? I Mo vie i s a pro gr am t hat c am e wit h ou r

Ma ci nt os h c om pu te r t ha t al low s vi de o e di ti ng . Q. A nd so y ou m ani pu la te d t he v id eo th at

yo u do wn loa de d, f rom e it he r A BC o r "Th e Vi ew "'s we b si te , i nt o th e f or ma t tha t yo u the n ul ti mat el y up lo ad ed to Y ou Tu be; t ha t is ri gh t? A. Q. Y es . D o you k no w who o wn s the c op yr igh t to

th is A ug ust 5 th , 200 9, e pi sod e of " The V ie w" ? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o di sce rn t he co py ri gh t

ow ne r be for e yo u dow nl oa de d t he v id eo fr om A BC or "T he V ie w"' s we b sit e? A. Q. A. Q. N o. I a m s or ry ? N o. O ka y. D id y ou at te mp t t o di sc ern t he

co py ri gh t o wn er b efo re y ou ma ni pu la ted t he v ide o us in g iM ovi e? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o di sce rn i ts co py ri gh t

ow ne r be for e yo u upl oa de d the c li p? A. Q. N o. D o you h av e aut ho ri za tio n fr om AB C to

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

106 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:32:15 13:32:16 13:32:17 13:32:20 13:32:20 13:32:21 13:32:24 13:32:24 13:32:24 13:32:27 13:32:29 13:32:30 13:32:31 13:32:34 13:32:40 13:32:40 13:32:42 13:32:44 13:32:47 13:32:50 13:32:53 13:32:57 13:32:59 13:33:00 13:33:05

po st t hi s v id eo ? A. Q. N o. D o you h av e aut ho ri za tio n fr om th e

pr od uc er s o f "T he Vi ew "? A. Q. el se ? A. Q. N o. D id yo u at te mpt t o se cur e au th ori za ti on N o. D id yo u ha ve au th or iz ati on f ro m a ny on e

fr om a ny one b ef or e y ou u pl oad ed i t? A. Q. A. Q. us e? A. A ct ual ly , le t m e am en d t ha t. I be li ev e i t ei th er to b e fai r us e, or , if i t is n't f ai r use , "T he Vi ew " is un li ke ly to ca re v er y m uc h -- or t he c opy ri gh t own er s, r ath er , ar e un li kel y to c are v er y muc h. Q. L et 's do t ho se in p ar ts. Wh y do y ou be li ev e t ha t it is po te nt ia lly a f ai r-u se ? A. S ev era l fa ct ors . O ne is , if I re ca ll N o. W hy no t? B ec aus e I be lie ve i t to be f ai r u se . W hy ; w hy d o you b el ie ve it t o be fa ir

co rr ec tl y, th e or igi na l sh ow wa s ap pro xi ma te ly

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

107 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:33:09 13:33:12 13:33:17 13:33:22 13:33:23 13:33:28 13:33:31 13:33:34 13:33:35 13:33:36 13:33:37 13:33:38 13:33:41 13:33:43 13:33:44 13:33:45 13:33:45 13:33:49 13:33:49 13:33:55 13:33:56 13:33:58 13:34:01 13:34:03 13:34:06

40 m in ut es; o f th at, I t oo k o nl y 40 se co nd s. Th at 4 0 sec on ds , I u se d ap pro xi ma te ly 50 p er cen t of t he o rig in al i mag e, a nd I di dn 't us e an y of th ei r au dio . So I u se d o nl y a sma ll f ra cti on o f the or ig in al wo rk . MS . MA RT IN: I ac tua ll y do n't w an t you Th at i s y ou r

to c on ti nue t hi s tes ti mo ny .

le ga l op ini on , as to w hy y ou di d th is. A. Q. O ka y. I a m s or ry . MS . MA RT IN: I am ob je ct in g. T hi s is

he r le ga l o pi ni on , a bo ut h er ow n ac tio ns , sh e is m ak in g. MS . HE RN AND EZ : th at ? Is t ha t a p ro pe r ins tr uc ti on, n ot t o an sw er ? Sh e wa s act in g as an a tt or ney w he n she up lo ad ed a cl ip o f " Th e Vi ew. " MS . MA RT IN: Ok ay , c on ti nu e. I t hi nk it U nde r wh at pr iv il eg e i s

is , he r fai r us e is -MS . HE RN AND EZ : I am n ot s ure w he re

an ti ci pa tio n of l iti ga ti on fi ts i nt o t hi s, ei th er .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 151

Schapiro Exhibit 152

Schapiro Exhibit 153

Schapiro Exhibit 154

Schapiro Exhibit 155