The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al
Filing
316
DECLARATION of MICHAEL RUBIN in Support re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 16 - 17, # 2 Exhibit 18 - 26, # 3 Exhibit 27 - 30, # 4 Exhibit 31 - 42, # 5 Exhibit 43 - 44, # 6 Exhibit 45 - 71)(Schapiro, Andrew)
Rubin Reply Exhibit 31
Rubin Reply Exhibit 32
Video ID V i d e o Ti tl e Le n g th ( Se c o n d s) D ate V id e o U p lo ad e d Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t U se r n a m e D a te Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t C r e ate d Sig n u p E m ail Sig n u p I P
ltXNBOTmZE4 Donald Trump vs. Rasputia 53 1/31/2007 parkmyvibe 10/13/2006 parkmyvibe@hotmail.com 63.138.106.242
Rubin Reply Exhibit 33
Rubin Reply Exhibit 34
Video ID V i d e o Ti tl e Le n g th ( Se c o n d s) D ate V id e o U p lo ad e d Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t U se r n a m e D a te Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t C r e ate d Sig n u p E m ail Sig n u p I P
32pbKQAaFl0 gonna make you sweat 48 10/5/2006 thatisalsofunny 9/29/2006 thatisalsofunny@hotmail.com 63.138.106.242
Rubin Reply Exhibit 35
C
I:·:~s:~:::
ED
N1
EDIA,
i·S:t·,·:l'~*rBi:~'~n~
i;til~
9.
·'·'
Online VVrap Up 3/1/06-6/16/06
1CEL~ f~ledia· Nacho LibreOniineCan'~l~!-nign
r\E pnslTION
'
Ccsnficien!iall
i~x~H~elT4
9//0/0
Client:
Paramount
Pictures
Project Run Dates: 311-6116
1111
ICED Media abletosecure was Nacho content a total 126 different during 14weeks theproject. Libre on of sites the on There a goodmixof was
confessionals, trailers, movie clips, photos, soundboards, interviews and more on a variety of sites from entertainment to video game, viral video, music, Latino, comedy, community,toy, wrestling, lifestyle, celebrity, blogs and boards.
The success of this campaignis rootedin the contentthat we were able to provideto such a widearray of sites and blogs. The contentwas compelling and funnythroughoutthe campaign,and receiveda tremendousresponse fromthe onlinecommunity. This, combinedwithour abilityto adapt to the everchanginglandscape of interactive media, resulted in a highlysuccessfulcampaign. We feel stronglythat this multifaceted campaignhas helped to create
the buzz online that Nacho Libre has something for everyone.
Highlights ourcampaign from Include contests sitessuchas Ticketmaster, 35 with CitySearch, LiveDaily, Spin, Zap2lt, CCS, TeenHollywood, Aced,
Shakefire,HipOnline, Hybrid, AndPop,CelebrityCaf~,Entertainment World,Kiwibox, Stuff,Hoopshypeand others. Our SyndicatedBlogContest was
featured on 8 sites as well.
Interview contentgraced homepagesof Shakefire,Entertainment World,Built-Eye, HipOnline, YouTube FHM. and
Confessionals and other Nacho Libre video clips and trailers have been seen on over 100 sites we've worked with. Sites range from Pariguayo to
Goldenfiddle, Joystiq, Keep Me Busy, Kotaku, From Parts Unknown,A Socialite's Life, Fixins, Inside Pulse and others. We also created viral tools such as the Nacho Libre Soundboard and various photoshopped Nacho images for messageboard posting.
The Nacho Libra Myspace page has over 13,500 friends: htto:~www. mvseace.comlnacholikre
Nacho Libre's Myspace Sightings page has over 1.000 friends as well: httn:l/www.mvst>ace.comlnacholikre siahtinas
Our MySpace grassroots campaign was able to utilize the enthusiasm of fans worldwide and continue to create buzz for the filmwith a number of promotions we ran. The Cinco de Mayo program had the greatest response with hundreds of Nacho Libre images placed on comments sections of our friends and friends of friends. Weekly confessional propagation missions helped get the word out about the film early with a combined 500 placements.
The team continues to be active and we receive emails and comments everyday. Clips uploaded to YouTube, Bolt, YourFileHost and Del.icio.us were viewed a combined 100,000 times over the course of the campaign.
Our strategically placed message board posts continued to generate conversation. There were Nacho related WWE talk, photoshopped images posted
and general movie talk prompting some good conversations.
!C:EC, I~ledia: Nacho Libre Online Carr·,Cajgn
Coriiidt~-ritjai
Below
are the i 26 sites
featured
in this' document:
13gb,con7 411 mania
ds forboy dreams of hers es
jack black net joystiq
snsa happens a socialite's life
absolute now acsd magazine addicting clips
drunken delight ebaums world elijangueo
keep me busy killmy day ki~uibox
spin.com stuff magazi~e superhero hype
ain't it cool
andpop. cona
all movie portsl
entertainment world
cspire
fever n~g.ozine
kotaku
Ikc~dai~y
loudcrsoft
synthesis magazine
tastes like chicken
teen flova
alloy
bells online
fhm
filcco\y
lovelymrs. davis...
nlanic n·soss
teen hollywood
ticketms.stcr
blogcritics
bolt break.com
filnljerk
filmvad fueins
n'bedicine filnls
migente n-silk aFa cookies
toy tokyo
trailcrd~cxur! d loa true artist entertainment
built-eye buzz patrol
caf0 jock car mag cc.s
free oops fromparts u~kn~xur!
fpu blog gantcrscore blog game set watch
rrkov wet, ic n~ics videos
music fiava my old kentucky blog n~nday morning commute
universityhumor updraft
video detective vmix willianas boa rd
the celebrity cafd
celebritywonder cinema.com cinema blend cityscarch
contact nlusic
golden fiddle
grouper
rryspa:ce
news today
witz.srg
worth 1000 yourfilohost youtube rap2it
chat avenue
guba
hiponline hollywood northreport hollywood tuna
oh no theydidn't
pnriguayo pcrez hiLtrn popmatters
y.ou can't makethis up
hoops hype
popcholic
crave c;rnli~it cravefot dailysonic
dark zero decoy music
hybridmagazin·o iced blog idleriot
ifilm ig17
popyoularity.com profotmagazine productsh6pnye
pro wrestling torch psp world
dcl.icio.us
dcstructoid
d-listed
ilounge
imagcyonatior,
inside pulse
rarrrr I'ma b)lYJ
rotten tomatoes
shctkcfire
dOF! murph and
I watch stuff
silent uproar
;CED Media. Nach0 L.ibre Onlie Can,paign
C:onficitlr·!!inI
Ke~ta kam,CO~
.httP:~www, kotaku,com
(140K Unique visitors per month)
- Nacho LibrePSP downloadabletrailerfeatured on home page
- Feature included photo, official site link and YouTube link
- Site featured XboxGame WithFame video and photos
Video: Jack Black Fleying PGR3
~L~L\
R-:'~·?UHE Z
J.
TheXbor vldeoed Bladk.r Game Fame crew Jad recent with session. look The on i
black's lace II p~colerr when he hits his Ilnt same and the Irrr~thins he hears is
What's up Jack rock ooooonl" Yeah, Vlat'lyour tan base buddy.
a~T~r":~~nr
L·m·l·r *U1~ tty 1 I·Y~IIII~I
*nl·UI·~ o*al~nn;~i rlln i.lll)cnpl~W1*r solt,n. ~ul Ot"l~ll~lU*Ili I~rni-t~mrlr :.lr~n·l*
NIlIDlm miirIIIl Lll,·~·.
The video ends with Blackrayins 7Csno secret I'm a garner. Myskillsare Jlorp. My skills are extremely rharp.~Yeah, but we don't see you wrappios your gitly hands around the controller for a Iltlle Halo i, do we! auh nurktr Jack Blackis a Clmer: My Ytlllrare Shnrp...' (Gamerrcoreblogl
RE4DI·Y)RE: PGU. F*I·U~U1EIC. Qfi~*~WN~K. ~1L3 2.IACKIIL4:h'.C~M IICON)IE1(TS) j~~l:
t ................~ .·..._.~...iirrru
I1~E~:i Mecija: Nach~LibraOniine i~alnpaiUn
:5
·;i
" bo ~P
CE
~iS
1
i·ii
EO
?
~c:
"
"
BZ
BE
P
_EbI6
s= EC
51 oc
PoO
i sgsOg
fs iz~
f
f·
cc J
1 B
t
1
E "·::1 " i
i ,:
LI
:t I ~P
·B
:r :
%9
r
i
L ,-
i
I%
j
ii
a
,B
n
4
o -·"1 ~~--- iBi I.~~aE". i ~ at ~,~y i~g .,s -"o I
'-F O
EQ "
i;
O,f ~~ 1:" .n
H'L e-"~d
r; ;
LOZ
' 19ia a
)L O
r
di; rP c
08 i
ps
r0
"
g
pi
·a·
O P I~
(5
iS " ric9
1
;ii
·Z
F·
" itD
i
-
~B
"'
1" -·Z -L
'~]~~f t
ii
.i.i
B
is
B
all
I
f
pB
9'
Bp
P
%u
3
la··='
-,e
fP
an,
·
-Y-bi:
ji5o~-
981~= dEO
I ~,C~bilr~ 1:
U3 a -~7
'8~;9~.
So~IhuDima O ~;c~cr~·i~iai
51:
I·:4 Oa'ms~rgfr-;9 rs·. Ba-, Pb" 9p Eh PI
,
Do
ggOd
"I"" ~~ '' le
,-C P
Is-
i3
ti,I iiPie4 I I
a
d
:ri
nia '
!r%· 11S1P
e
ii 3
IIfi
I,
I;z
1
i:J2 U ·I i ii! ;1i i:
iii :I
g 1
a
aj
ii;
,Ii;isi
~
I
P
.r·IBBf I:I
L
1
r
n
E
ca o
3
il I1~I aIIrII
o P' li_Y
D a Imi
i·!
jI
8 -~ S.
o
el~r
te
sji,,r
E ~n
O
·e
O a
v, 3
"
S-:Si'i ,-
o
o a, r L. Q) >
a
e~~ o
E
i
1
f
R ·r
Lt
t
o
E n!
8
E
Ug a~o
T3Oj mO
O
IB =I! 111
i ,i
e·
r
~I
i:'
-·
a-
,=
-,;?
,,
B
z
EK
1
;;
r
r
B
n
;-,-,
··~ e,-ar,
I
r
r;en
o~ ii P i~n
~-m
~aP FF oo~B
~o~ p, r;
1z f
P
q a
U s
e
4
sr
o~
c~;u
:r;
a,r-=m
a, -P
z
a, m
ma, 1~ err >
r o
o c~
-t:
p
s
I
I
~
II
,o
I
o
~'"l,fg
(Duo
DH P"
·.
gi
;i
I
1
1
Od
oi Si:
rp
Im
r Q)
I
~
a
I '5
J
u
~
m
a
4
1
.s
~:P
r3
e~~-
L
c·a, ~L2
~"
4
,
·,
I
E
J
ZS~=
T--'-i
., Syjp~X'g 4
np 1 - If.:
8,
= t
I Yr
6' 5
2
,· B >
..
Y
=f
:i
w
f
'5 iI
: m
~ Ed
r*~:i
9~
o, r;
=
O
Rubin Reply Exhibit 36
Rubin Reply Exhibit 37
Rubin Reply Exhibit 38
Accounts for which a review of the discovery produced in this action reveals no evidence that it was the subject of communications between Viacom and a YouTube employee in which Viacom's affiliation with the account was referenced Account Name
114th alexmtransformers BAAFamily BroadwayJoe
Videos Uploaded
0 4 3 26
Evidence Showing Connection to Viacom
Rubin Reply Ex. 40 Rubin Opening Ex. 126; Rubin Reply Ex. 41 Rubin Reply Ex. 42; Rubin Reply Ex. 43
Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 32), 96; Rubin Reply Ex. 19
BroadwayJoe415 damonjohnson demansr
5 82 3
Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 33), 96; Rubin Reply Exs. 17, 44 Rubin Opening Exs. 86, 87 (Response to RFA 68); Rubin Reply Ex. 28 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 61), 88; Rubin Reply Ex. 45 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 37), 96; Rubin Reply Ex. 46 Rubin Opening Exs. 112, 113 Rubin Opening Exs. 102, 103; Rubin Reply Ex. 47; Rubin Opening Ex. 96; Rubin Reply Ex. 48 Rubin Opening Exs. 31, 87 (Response to RFA 66), 107 Rubin Opening Ex. 86, 87 (Response to RFA 64); Rubin Reply Ex. 28 Rubin Opening Exs. 86, 87 (Response to RFA 69); Rubin Reply Ex. 28 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 43), 108, 109; Rubin Reply Ex. 49 Rubin Opening Exs. 102, 104; Rubin Reply Ex. 50 Rubin Opening Ex. 126
FiveChemical funfunfunnyvideo
3 1
Globe427 gooddrugy gossipgirl40
3 2 7
isitfridayyet
30
jerseymouth1
8
keithhn
120
Live2rhyme88 markblu22
2 2
Account Name
Videos Uploaded
Evidence Showing Connection to Viacom
MrTsNumberOneFan NMarketing ParkMyVibe PinkStrawberry PinkStrawberry1 reaction2006 strangewildernessuk StuntManForever
13 25 3 0 3 7 20 25
Rubin Opening Ex. 86; Rubin Reply Exs.51, 52 Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 56) Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 36), 96; Rubin Reply Ex. 53 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 34), 96 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 35), 96 Rubin Opening Exs. 86, 87 (Response to RFA 62); Rubin Reply Exs. 28, 54 Rubin Opening Ex2. 87 (Response to RFA 39), 114 Rubin Reply Exs. 55-58 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 30), 96, 115; Rubin Reply Ex.34 Rubin Opening Exs. 87 (Response to RFA 31), 96 Rubin Opening Ex. 105; Rubin Reply Ex. 59 Rubin Opening Ex. 96; Rubin Reply Ex. 62 Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 88)
thatisalsofunny thatsnotfunny the110th ultrasloppyjoe waytobluefrance Total Videos Uploaded
7 0 0 1 66 471
-2-
Rubin Reply Exhibit 39
Accounts for which Viacom contacted YouTube after having mistakenly taken down videos it had authorized to be uploaded to those accounts Evidence Showing Connection to Viacom
Ostrow Opening Dec. ¶2-6; Rubin Reply Ex. 15 Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 105); Rubin Opening Ex. 49; Rubin Opening Ex. 50; Rubin Reply Ex. 60 Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 67); Rubin Opening Ex. 31; Rubin Reply Ex. 20; Rubin Reply Ex. 25; Rubin Reply Ex. 22; Rubin Reply Ex. 23; Rubin Reply Ex. 24
Account Name
Videos Uploaded
Evidence of Mistaken Takedown
BrienTA
231
Rubin Reply Ex. 63
bullrunvideo
179
Rubin Opening Ex. 50
fanscapevideos
1142
Rubin Reply Ex. 64; Rubin Reply Ex. 21
FanscapeVideos4U
38
Rubin Opening Ex. 31; Rubin Reply Ex. 26; Rubin Opening Ex. 116 Rubin Reply Ex. 66; Rubin Reply Ex. 67 Rubin Reply Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 87); Rubin Reply Ex. 10 Rubin Opening Ex. 46; Rubin Opening Ex. 47; Rubin Opening Ex. 48
Rubin Reply Ex. 65
HGiantVid
58
Rubin Reply Ex. 68
tastefullymine
14
Rubin Reply Ex. 10
Tesderiw
5
Rubin Opening Ex. 47
Account Name
Videos Uploaded
Evidence Showing Connection to Viacom
Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 29); Rubin Opening Ex. 115; Rubin Reply Ex. 35
Evidence of Mistaken Takedown
thatsfunny
158
Rubin Reply Ex. 69
TheFilmFactoryUK
25
Rubin Opening Ex. 125 Rubin Opening Ex. 87 (Response to RFA 85); Rubin Reply Ex. 36
Rubin Reply Ex. 70
waytblue
109
Rubin Reply Ex. 36
zachbraffdotcom Total Videos Uploaded
15 1974
Rubin Opening Ex. 99; Rubin Opening Ex. 100
Rubin Reply Ex. 71
-2-
Rubin Reply Exhibit 40
Subject:
From:
To: Cc:
YouTube SoundOff
Tipton, Kristina - Paramount oeEX:/O=VIACOM/OU=PARAMOUNT/CN=
RECIPIENTS/CN = TIPTON KR~
Wahtera, Megan - Paramount, Simard, Stephanie - Paramount
Bordo, Sara - Paramount, Griswold, Kristina - Paramount Mon, 26 Feb 2007 17:12:08 +0000
Date:
Hi Megan and Steph,
We were finally able to acquire http:/iyoutube,com/soundoff. YouTube had to help since there was a
user that already had the name soundoff, but now we should be all set. We also have
youtube,com/114th. Can we meet for a few minutes today to discuss how we should start populating
the profile? Also, YouTube says that we won't be able to make youtube,com/soundoff our group URL. We're still going back and forth with them trying to figure out a way around, but just wanted to let you
know this may be an issue.
Here's our log-in:
Email Account:soundoff2007@yahoo.com
password:_
Username: Soundoff
password_
Group URL: N/A
Let me know when you'd like to discuss. Thanks!
Kristina Tipton
Paramount Pictures
Interactive Coordinator, Promotions & Publicity
323-956-8453
Highly Confidential
VIA 1 0483944
Rubin Reply Exhibit 41
Video ID Vid eo T it le L e ng t h (S e c o nd s ) Dat e V i d e o U p l o ad e d Y o uT ub e A c c o unt U s e r na m e D a t e Y o uT ub e A c c o unt C r e a t e d S i g nup E m a i l S i g nup I P Vid eo ID Vid eo T it le L e ng t h (S e c o nd s ) Dat e V i d e o U p l o ad e d Y o uT ub e A c c o unt U s e r na m e D a t e Y o uT ub e A c c o unt C r e a t e d S i g nup E m a i l S i g nup I P Vid eo ID Vid eo T it le L e ng t h (S e c o nd s ) Dat e V i d e o U p l o ad e d Y o uT ub e A c c o unt U s e r na m e D a t e Y o uT ub e A c c o unt C r e a t e d S i g nup E m a i l S i g nup I P
axZWLhPp4tA transformers 11 3/21/2007 alexmtransformers 3/21/2007 alexmoran@terra.com.mx 189.179.10.42 JW69bIuAsNo transformers 11 3/21/2007 alexmtransformers 3/21/2007 alexmoran@terra.com.mx 189.179.10.42 B4QmFL_hArI transformers 11 3/21/2007 alexmtransformers 3/21/2007 alexmoran@terra.com.mx 189.179.10.42
Rubin Reply Exhibit 42
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?