Schoolcraft v. The City Of New York et al
Filing
397
FILING ERROR - DUPLICATE DOCKET ENTRY - DECLARATION of NATHANIEL B. SMITH in Opposition re: 297 MOTION for Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Adrian Schoolcraft. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit POX 11, # 2 Exhibit POX 12, # 3 Exhibit POX 13, # 4 Exhibit POX 15, # 5 Exhibit POX 16, # 6 Exhibit POX 18)(Smith, Nathaniel) Modified on 2/17/2015 (db).
1
1
2
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
--------------------------------------------------X
ADRIAN SCHOOLCRAFT,
3
PLAINTIFF,
4
-against-
Case No:
10 Civ. 6005
(RWS)
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
.,
·~:..
.. '
-..;_~
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
THE CITY OF NEW YORK, DEPUTY CHIEF MICHAEL MARINO,
Tax Id. 873220, Individually and in his Official
Capacity, ASSISTANT CHIEF PATROL BOROUGH BROOKLYN
NORTH GERALD NELSON, Tax Id. 912370, Individually
and in his Official Capacity, DEPUTY INSPECTOR
STEVEN MAURIELLO, Tax Id. 895117, Individually and
in his Official Capacity, CAPTAIN THEODORE
LAUTERBORN, Tax Id. 897840, Individually and in his
Official Capacity, LIEUTENANT WILLIAM GOUGH, Tax Id.
919124, Individually and in his Official Capacity,
SGT. FREDERICK SAWYER, Shield No. 2576, Individually
and in his Official Capacity, SERGEANT KURT DUNCAN,
Shield No. 2483, Individually and in his Official
Capacity, LIEUTENANT CHRISTOPHER BROSCHART, Tax Id.
915354, Individually and in his Official Capacity,
LIEUTENANT TIMOTHY CAUGHEY, Tax Id. 885374,
Individually and in his Official Capacity, SERGEANT
SHANTEL JAMES, Shield No. 3004 and P.O.'s "JOHN DOE"
#1-50, Individually and in their Official Capacity
(the name John Doe being fictitious, as the true
names are presently unknown) (collectively referred
to as "NYPD defendants"), JAMAICA HOSPITAL MEDICAL
CENTER, DR. ISAK ISAKOV, Individually and in his
Official Capacity, DR. LILIAN ALDANA-BERNIER,
Individually and in her Official Capacity and
JAMAICA HOSPITAL MEDICAL CENTER EMPLOYEES "JOHN
DOE" #1-50, Individually and in their Official
Capacity (the name John Doe being fictitious, as
the tru~ names are presently unknown),
21
22
DEFENDANTS .
--------------------------------------------------X
DATE:
TIME:
23
October 17, 2014
10:20 A.M.
24
(Deposition of JOHN ETERNO, PhD)
25
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
1
info®diamondreporting.com
2
1
2
DATE:
October 17, 2014
3
TIME:
10:20 A.M.
4
5
6
7
DEPOSITION of an Expert Witness,
8
JOHN ETERNO, PhD, taken by the Respective Parties,
9
Pursuant to a Notice and to the Federal Rules of
10
Civil Procedure, held at the offices of the New
11
York City Law Department, 100 Church Street,
12
New York, New York 10007, before Nathan MacCormack,
13
a Notary Public of the State of New York.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
'J
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
2
info@diamondreporting.com
I
I~
31
J. ETERNO
Would we would bring them up in lecture and in
1
.I
2
class discussion.
3
as well.
4
Q.
5
Students often might do papers on this,
Have you ever taught a course dealing with the
topic of emotionally disturbed persons?
6
A.
Not specifically.
7
Q.
Has it ever come up in any of your courses?
8
A.
Again, possibly.
9
Q.
But you don•t have a specific recollection?
10
A.
No.
11
Q.
Do you hold any expert or professional
12
certifications?
13
A.
Yes.
14
Q.
What certification or titles are those?
15
A.
I am CITI-certificated, in terms of social
16
behavioral research, that•s C-I-T-I, which means
17
Collaborative Institutional Training Initiative; I am
18
certificated as a physical fitness instructor for law
19
enforcement; I was certified by the New York City Police
20
Academy to be a Police Academy instructor, where I taught
21
police science, where I taught Emotionally Disturbed
22
People; I am also a verbal judo instructor, and
23
certificated by the New York City Police Department there.
24
...
\
\...... /
I
25
Q.
Can you repeat which courses you have taught on
emotionally disturbed persons?
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
31
info®diamondreporting.com
32
J. BTERNO
1
A.
That would be in police science.
2
Q.
So, when I asked earlier if you had ever taught
3
any course dealing with emotionally disturbed persons you
4
would add that to the list?
5
A.
I would.
6
Q.
When did /you teach that course?
7
A.
This was 1987 through '88.
8
Q.
In what context did you teach that course?
9
A.
I taught recruits at the academy.
10
Q.
Was the course solely on emotionally disturbed
11
persons?
12
A.
No.
13
Q.
What was the context of the course?
14
A.
Police science.
15
Q.
How long was the section on emotionally disturbed
16
persons?
17
A.
I don't recall.
18
Q.
How long was the training that you gave to these
19
new recruits?
20
A.
Approximately six months.
21
Q.
What kind of training did you give with regard to
22
23
emotionally disturbed persons?
A.
There were very strict lectures that we do and
24
, __}
.
cover on emotionally disturbed people.
25
role play, other types of activities for the recruits.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
32
We sometimes do
info®diamondreporting.com
33
J. ETERNO
1
2
Q.
Do you personally have any experience with
emotionally disturbed persons?
3
A.
Yes.
4
Q.
What is that experience?
5
A.
As a police officer, police sergeant, police
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
lieutenant and a police captain.
Q.
And what were your experiences in those different
capacities?
A.
We handle emotionally disturbed people on a
regular basis.
Q.
In your capacity as an employee of the N.Y. P. D.,
did you ever have occasion to declare someone as an E.D.P.?
13
A.
Yes.
14
Q.
And when I say "E.D.P.,
15
11
you understand that I
mean an emotionally disturbed person?
16
A.
I do.
17
Q.
How many times did you declare someone an E.D.P.?
18
A.
I don•t recall.
19
Q.
How did you decide whether or not somebody was an
20
E.D.P.?
21
22
23
24
25
I
·. ·.._.,../
MR. SMITH:
A.
Objection to the form.
Using the patrol guide standard:
Mentally ill
And how would you determine if someone was
mentally ill?
I
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
33
I
I
~
and dangerous to himself or others.
Q.
I
info®diamondreporting.com
I
141
J. ETERNO
1
individuals were disciplined as a result of having that
2
Q.A.D. report?
3
A.
No, they haven't.
4
Q.
You drafted the patrol guide section on
5
complaints when you were employed by the N.Y.P.D.; is that
6
correct?
7
A.
I helped draft it, yes.
8
Q.
Do you know if that section, as written by you,
9
is still in place?
10
A.
No, I don't.
11
Q.
The next section, starting on page 8 of your
12
report, is the Blue Wall of Silence.
13
MR. SMITH:
Why don't we take a lunch break?
14
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
If you let me finish
15
the question, Mr. Smith.
16
take a break while a question is pending.
17
take a break after that.
18
MR. SMITH:
As you know, you cannot
We can
I was suggesting that we take a
break before you asked the question.
19
20
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
Well, I am going to
ask the question, then we can take the break.
21
22
Q.
Your section indicates that the blue --
23
A.
Where are we now?
24
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
25
MR. SMITH:
DIAMOND REPORTING
On page --
She is asking one more question,
(718) 624-7200
141
info®diamondreporting.com
142
J. ETERNO
1
then we are taking a break.
2
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
Mr. Smith, if you
3
are going to continue to interrupt
4
inappropriately I am going to make an application
5
to the court based on your continued malfeasance.
6
Q.
Professor Eterno, your section entitled Blue Wall
7
of Silence indicates that the code of silence has been
8
observed and studied in reports of many police departments
9
throughout the world, right?
10
A.
Yes.
11
Q.
So, do you believe that every police department
12
13
in the world has a blue wall of silence?
A.
I believe that the informal code is something
14
that exists and is well researched.
15
studies that have shown the police culture is pervasive in
16
policing.
17
There are numerous
So, when you say "every police department,
11
I
18
would have to say that it is pervasive, it might not be
19
somewhere.
20
documented.
21
22
23
24
25
_)
But there is an informal code, that is well
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
at this time for lunch.
We can take a break
The time is 1:18 p.m.
(Whereupon, a luncheon recess was taken at
this time.)
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
142
So, we are going
info@diamondreporting.com
143
J. ETERNO
back on the record.
1
2
3
Q.
It is 2:12p.m.
Dr. Eterno, when we left off we were talking
about the blue wall of silence.
4
A.
Yes.
5
Q.
How do you determine whether a police department
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
has a blue wall of silence?
A.
There is a huge amount of research that indicates
that a blue wall of silence is nearly ubiquitous in police
departments.
Q.
This research is well documented.
f
How does the research determine whether a
department has a blue wall of silence?
A.
They use typical social science methods, might
include surveys or qualitative research, where they would
14
actually visit the department and watch what's going on.
15
Q.
And what kind of information that would be
16
derived from a survey or research, qualitative research,
17
would indicate that a blue wall of silence was in place?
18
A.
Well, the blue wall of silence is really part of
19
the informal code, which is part of police culture.
20
the police culture is something that's in -- it's in every
21
department.
22
code.
23
And
But instead of a formal code, it's an informal
It's just what's going on.
So, the nature of the
24
•...
)
!
I
13
\
1.
I
blue wall of silence may be very different depending on the
25
department.
,.~
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
143
info®diamondreporting.com
t-
144
J. ETERNO
1
2
3
Q.
So, when you use the term "blue wall of silence,"
what do you mean?
A.
Well, again, it's a euphemism for police culture,
4
and it is a way that officers informally deal with what's
5
going on in the dangerousness of the work environment and
6
the loyalty to one another.
7
Because of that danger, they kind of stick
8
together.
And because of that, they will develop a blue
9
wall of silence where they won't talk about things.
10
Because they need to stick together, they need to be loyal
11
to one another.
12
Commission, the Knapp Commission, we have seen this
13
numerous places.
14
15
16
Q.
And again, we have seen this in the Mellen
Is the blue wall of silence necessarily
pejorative?
A.
I think most people do take it that way, as a
17
pejorative term.
18
necessarily a bad thing.
19
But I would say in some cases it's not
It could be at times something healthy, where
20
officers want to keep things to themselves.
21
But generally,
it is used as a negative term.
22
Do you believe it's a pejorative term?
23
A.
I think in general it is, yes.
24
\
\. __ ,...,-./
Q.
Q.
You said that it can manifest in different ways
25
and different agencies; is that correct?
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
144
info®diamondreporting.com
145
J. ETERNO
1
A.
Yes.
2
Q.
And how could it manifest differently in
3
4
different agencies?
A.
In some agencies it may not be as necessary.
5
There may not be as much danger, there may not be as much
6
need for that protection.
7
very strong need for that protection.
8
agency that perhaps is doing things that might be illegal.
9
And officers are aware of that, that you need to make sure
10
In other agencies there may be a
It might be in an
that you don't rat out the other guy.
11
Or it may just be that they are doing things that
12
may be questionable in the eyes of people who are not
13
initiated into the world of policing.
14
at times the officers need to stick together to defend
15
themselves from what they perceive at times to be unneeded
16
circumspection of what they are doing.
17
Q.
And to that extent,
In your answer you mentioned danger and
18
protection.
19
danger and protection you believe are related to this blue
20
wall of silence?
21
A.
Can you be more specific about what kind of
Yes.
The danger of the work environment.
We are
22
talking about perpetrators and others who may be fighting
23
police officers, or just could be animosity against police
24
officers.
25
the police officers.
It could be a community that may be negative to
\._/'
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
145
info®diamondreporting.com
146
J. ETERNO
1
But the danger is generally thought to be, at
2
least in most of the literature, it•s generally seen to be
3
the work environment itself and from the perpetrators.
4
5
6
Q.
And when you
refe~
to protection, what are you
referring to?
A.
Well, protection from various different things
7
from the outside, community pressures, media pressures.
8
could be legal pressures, it could be C.C.R.B, or it could
9
be from the bosses.
10
There is a literature on the New York City Police
11
Department written by Elizabeth Reuss-Ianni, had a very
12
interesting study that compares two cultures of policing.
13
They call them management culture and the street cop
14
culture.
15
between those two, so it could even be protection from
16
management.
She points out that there is some animosity
I
I
17
Q.
A.
R-E-U-S-S dash I-A-N-N-I.
19
20
r
!
The name of the book
is Two Cultures of Policing, one of many of her writings.
Q.
And earlier you mentioned that there were
21
surveys, qualitative research and studies into police
22
culture and the blue wall of silence that you believe are
23
authoritative; is that correct?
24
.....
·...__
A.
Very authoritative, yes.
25
Q.
What are those?
/ ;
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
146
I
;
Can you spell Reuss-Ianni?
18
\
It
info@diamondreporting.com
I
i
I
l
I
147
J. ETERNO
A.
1
Stoddard, Wesley, Fielding 1 Manning, Crank, just
2
to name a few off the top of my head that show that.
There
3
is also research on an attitude effect, Oneman, Wardman and
4
Shepherd, just a few of the names that come to mind.
5
Q.
What do you mean by attitude effect?
6
A.
The attitude effect is where officers respond
7
to
B
the blue wall of silence, that officers respond to the
9
attitude of suspect as to opposed to the legality of what
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
again, this is part of the police culture, just like
the suspect is doing.
Q.
And do you believe that attitude effect is
reflected in your expert report in any way?
A.
It•s possible.
It could be there somewhere.
I
didn•t specifically mention it, but it might be there.
Q.
Have you formed opinions in this case about the
attitude effect?
A.
Not specifically.
But there might be
18
circumstances that come up when we are talking that it may
19
come up.
20
Q.
But in your expert report, have you come to a
21
conclusion or opinion about the attitude effect as it
22
relates to Adrian Schoolcraft?
MR. SMITH:
23
Objection to the form.
24
, _ _./
A.
No.
25
Q.
In your expert report you mention that the issue
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
147
info®diamondreporting.com
148
J. ETERNO
1
of the blue wall of silence has repeatedly come up in the
2
history of New York City; is that correct?
3
A.
Yes.
4
Q.
And in doing so, you cite to the 1972 Knapp
5
Commission and the 1994 Mollen Commission; is that correct?
6
A.
Yes.
7
Q.
Are you aware of any other commissions or studies
8
on New York's blue wall of silence in the last 20 years?
A.
9
No.
Those are the two main commissions.
There
10
haven't been any commissions since Mollen regarding -- at
11
least at that level.
12
Corruption, Mark Pomerantz, which I do talk about in my
13
expert report.
14
There was the Committee to Combat
But that was basically cut off and not allowed to
15
do
16
to rebuke.
17
18
19
20
21
Mark Pomerantz eventually quit when he wasn't allowed
Q.
Was the subject of the Committee to Combat
Corruption the blue wall of silence?
A.
No.
That was complaint reports at the time and
the gaming of complaint reports.
Q.
Are you aware of any studies outside of the
22
commissions' on the blue wall of silence's prevalence in
23
New York City in the last 20 years?
24
I
A.
25
the Law:
No.
I did mention it in my book, Policing Within
A Case Study of the New York Police Department.
··..._/
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
148
info®diamondreporting.com
149
J. ETERNO
1
Q.
When was that book published?
2
A.
2003.
3
Q.
Have you done any research, qualitative research,
4
on the blue wall of silence yourself?
5
A.
Not qualitative, no.
6
Q.
Have you done any quantitative research on the
7
8
9
10
blue wall of silence?
A.
Yes.
As I said, it •s in my book, Police Culture,
Policing Within the Law, where there is quantitative work
on the police culture.
11
Q,
And what is that quantitative work?
12
A.
It was a survey that I sent out as part of my
13
dissertation.
14
Q.
What was that survey?
15
A.
It was a survey on whether officers would follow
16
the law in various situations.
17
hypothetical situations and asked them what they would do
18
in that situation.
I put them in various
19
Q.
How does that relate to the blue wall of silence?
20
A.
One of the variables was police culture, where I
21
mention the loyalty to one another, which is part of the
22
blue wall of silence.
23
I also did measure the attitude effect.
24
25
We also talk about the language, and
Also, one of the variables that was in the
instrument that I used included a measure of police
·J
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
149
info®diamondreporting.com
150
J. ETERNO
1
culture.
2
Q.
What was that measure of police culture?
3
A.
Again, it was a survey question, and they were
4
put into hypothetical situations which included the police
5
culture.
6
Q.
7
8
9
When you say
11
Which included police culture,
11
what do you mean, what was the survey question?
A.
Well, it -- it•s hard to explain.
It was a
factorial survey method, which means that when it came to
10
police culture, and putting them in various hypothetical
11
situations, when I put them in those situations I used
12
specific language that measures the extent to which the
13
police culture has an effect on them.
14
15
16
Q.
What questions did you ask that got to the issue
of the blue wall of silence?
A.
The police culture was measured in every
17
question, so the police culture including loyalty.
18
like that were in various questions, depending on the type
19
of questioning.
20
survey method, which means they don•t get -- every officer
21
doesn•t get the same exact method.
22
question they get is randomly selected.
23
Things
Since it•s something called the factorial
It•s randomly-- the
And then, looking at the differences in the
24
_)
._
officers• responses, we can determine how much influence
25
the police culture has.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
150
info®diamondreporting.corn
151
J. ETERNO
1
2
3
4
Q.
What was the result of that survey as it related
to the blue wall of silence?
A.
The police culture did have an effect on some
officers at certain times.
5
Q.
On how many officers?
6
A.
Well, I don't have that in front of me.
7
8
9
10
I would
have to take a look at the -- look it over again.
Q.
Do you recall approximately what the percentage
of officers was?
A.
I don't recall right now, but it depended on the
11
situation.
The police culture had more of an effect, and I
12
compared it, certain situations and stop situations.
13
in the stop situations, the police culture had more of an
14
effect in the stop as opposed to the search.
15
Q.
Can you explain that further?
16
A.
Okay.
And
There are a number of different types of
17
scenarios that I put them in legally; some were search
18
situations, some were stop situations.
When I compared the differences between the stop
19
20
and the search situations, I found that in the stop
21
situations the officers did react more to loyalty and other
22
police culture factors that would be involved in the blue
23
wall of silence.
24
\.__)
25
Q..
And that's what you meant when you said that this
has a greater effect on some officers at some times?
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
151
info@diamondreporting.com
152
J. ETERNO
1
A.
Yes.
2
Q.
Did you find that any officers were more or less
3
4
immune to this blue wall of silence?
A.
From -- again, from my recollection, just off the
5
top of my head, but from my recollection of my research,
6
there were officers that were more prone than others.
7
Would you say that this research that you
Q.
8
conducted is some of the facts and data on which you relied
9
in creating your expert report?
10
11
12
A.
Not really.
It•s just basic knowledge.
I didn•t
rely on that for this report, no.
So, at trial, you would not rely on that research
Q.
13
in defending your report?
14
MR. SMITH:
15
A.
No.
Objection to the form.
However, I would rely on general knowledge
16
that I have on the police culture and the blue wall of
17
silence.
18
Q.
That, I would rely on.
The next section on the next page, page 9, is
19
titled
20
Officer Schoolcraft."
21
22
11
The Blue Wall and Forceable Hospitalization of
You claim that the blue wall of silence likely
contributed to Officer Schoolcraft?
23
Yes.
24
'~--/j
A.
Q.
What do you mean by "likely contributed 11 ?
25
A.
11
Likely 11 means that it appears to have.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
152
info®diamondreporting.com
153
J. ETERNO
1
2
Q.
Is that to a reasonable degree of scientific
certainty?
3
A.
Yes.
4
Q.
And on what do you base that opinion?
5
A.
on what•s in appendix B, and all the other
6
7
8
materials, my knowledge and expertise.
Q.
Did you read the depositions of any officers
involved in this case?
9
A.
Not in their entirety.
10
Q.
Did you read any in part?
11
A.
There was, I think, an Officer Duncan that I
12
13
14
looked at.
Q.
And earlier today, when I asked you about
documents, you did not mention Officer Duncan?
15
A.
Isn•t that in appendix B?
16
Q.
I am sorry, that one is in appendix B.
17
18
19
20
MR. SMITH:
Q.
A.
Yes.
MR. SMITH:
But he did mention that there
were subsequent reports.
22
THE WITNESS:
23
Yes, the lieutenant•s special
assignment from the medical division.
24
25
So, the only depositions you reviewed would be
Finnegan and Duncan?
21
\J
As is Finnegan.
Q.
So, you did not review the complete deposition of
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
153
info®diamondreporting.com
178
J. ETERNO
1
still doesn't make her statement meaningless.
A department psychologist's opinion is very
2
3
important.
4
what she has to say about him very seriously.
5
6
Regardless of the circumstances, I would take
So, you would take very seriously, the fact that
Q.
she removed his guns based on anger issues very seriously?
MR. SMITH:
7
Objection to the form.
8
A.
Yes.
9
Q.
Is it your understanding --
10
A.
Let me clarify that.
I would also take seriously
11
the fact that she said he is not a danger to himself or
12
others.
13
14
Both statements are important.
Do you believe that she saw Adrian Schoolcraft on
Q.
October 31, 2009?
MR. SMITH:
15
Objection to the form.
16
A.
I don't know when she saw him.
17
Q.
So, on page 10, the next real sentence starting
18
with
19
You can read it into the record if you like, or if you
20
like, you can read it to yourself.
11
We note.
11
I would like you to read that page for me.
21
A.
We are talking about two issues?
22
Q.
Yes.
23
A.
I guess we should read this in.
11
Two issues with
24
this are, one, the EMT only states he is potentially
25
emotionally disturbed, which is not emotionally disturbed.
'-...-./
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
178
info®diamondreporting.com
179
J. ETERNO
1
And two, according to police procedure, a police officer,
2
not an EMT, must reasonably believe that the person being
3
taken into forcible custody is mentally ill or temporarily
4
deranged and his behavior is likely to cause serious injury
5
to himself other others."
6
Q.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Great.
I will move on.
To what police procedure are you referring to?
A.
This is the patrol guide procedure on emotionally
.
disturbed persons.
Q.
Is that cited in your appendix?
It's the last
page of your report.
A.
It's not in the appendix, but it's in the
references section, page 28 at the bottom.
Q.
This just states the "N.Y.P.D. patrol guide,
unpublished," correct?
16
A.
Yeah, unpublished.
17
Q.
So, I am asking which patrol guide procedure,
18
specifically, you are referring to?
19
A.
Emotionally disturbed persons.
20
Q.
You don 1 t know the number?
21
A.
Not off the top of my head.
22
Q.
How did you receive that document?
23
A.
Again, I have the patrol guide on my computer at
24
-...)
[:
work.
25
i
I
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
179
I am going to ask
I
i
r
info®diamondreporting.com
•.
180
J. ETERNO
1
for production of the E.D.P. procedure in which
2
the expert relied in creating his report.
3
Q.
In that police procedure, does it state what
4
information has to be captured on an unusual incident
5
report?
6
A.
Do you have a copy of the procedure?
7
Q.
I don't.
8
A.
Okay, I am not sure.
9
Q.
When you wrote this report, did you believe that
10
to be the case?
11
MR. SMITH:
Objection to the form.
12
A.
Believe what to be the case?
13
Q.
Did you believe that the police procedure
14
required information to be included in the unusual incident
15
report?
16
A.
An unusual incident report is a separate
17
procedure in the patrol guide.
18
of patrol needs to know should be included in the unusual
19
report.
And anything that the chief
I think it would be critical for the chief patrol
20
21
22
hospital.
24
\
of the service is being forcibly placed into a mental
23
-...___)
to know why a member of the service -- a uniformed member
report.
25
Q.
So yes, I believe that should be in the unusual
And you believe it's not contained in the unusual
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
180
info®diamondreporting.com
181
J. ETERNO
1
incident report drafted by Captain Lauterborn?
2
A.
3
memo.
4
indication specifically delineating how Officer Schoolcraft
5
was found to be mentally ill and dangerous.
6
From my recollection, because I don't have the
But from my recollection of the memo, there was no
Q.
Is it possible that by writing "potentially
7
emotionally disturbed 11 Captain Lauterborn was indicating
8
that he reasonably believed plaintiff was emotionally
9
disturbed?
10
11
MR. SMITH:
A.
Objection to form.
The issue with that, if that's what the EMT said,
12
"He is a potential emotionally disturbed person," this to
13
me does not indicate that he is emotionally disturbed.
14
as I say in my expert opinion, the situation that led to
15
this was actually created, in my view, by the police
16
department.
17
18
Q.
And
Did you read the deposition of Lieutenant Hamlon
of the F.D.N.Y.?
19
A.
I did not.
20
Q.
So, do you know whether by stating
11
potentially
21
emotionally disturbed 11 she believed that he was emotionally
22
disturbed?
23
A.
11
Potentially" means potentially . . I take that for
24
:
·-....___/
what it says.
So, if she has some other meaning or somehow
25
communicated something else, it's not in the written
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
181
info®diamondreporting.com
182
J. ETERNO
1
I
!,
record.
•
2
Q,
Is it appropriate to make a determination about
3
someone 1 s mental illness, to make a diagnosis on the scene
4
of an incident?
5
MR.
A.
6
7
10
Objection to the form.
You are not making a diagnosis.
That 1 s going to
be made at the hospital.
8
9
S~ITH:
Q.
So, you can • t make a diagnosis about whether
someone is mentally ill while at the scene of the accident;
is that correct?
11
MR. SMITH:
Objection to the form.
12
A.
Correct, you don 1 t make a diagnosis.
13
Q.
Because police officers don 1 t make diagnoses,
14
correct?
15
A.
Correct.
16
Q.
So, they have to reasonably believe that an
17
individual is emotionally disturbed?
18
MR. SMITH:
Objection to the form.
19
A.
That is correct.
20
Q.
And you don't believe that by writing
21
11
potentially 1' someone could mean
22
23
MR. SMITH:
A.
11
reasonably believing 11 ?
Objection to the form.
I think that it 1 s showing what an EMT thought.
24
It is not showing what any of the officers thought at the
25
scene.
I'
·,,_/
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
182
info®diamondreporting.com
183
J. ETERNO
Your report mentioned that the duty captain
Q.
1
2
referred complaint reports to Internal Affairs for
3
followup; is that right?
4
A.
Again, you are referring to the Lauterborn memo?
5
Q.
No.
I am just referring to your report.
On page
"Additionally, the duty captain refers the complaint
6
10,
7
reports to Internal Affairs for followup, which is referred
8
to Quality Assurance, which, in turn, confirms Officer
9
Schoolcraft's allegations about the corrupt activity in the
10
precinct.
n
11
12
So, this does seem to be you paraphrasing from
the unusual incident report?
13
A.
Yes.
14
Q.
So, based on this, the duty captain did not try
15
to cover up the complaint report he found in Schoolcraft's
16
apartment?
17
MR. SMITH:
Objection to the form.
18
A.
No.
19
Q.
Does that fit within your concept of the blue
20
21
wall of silence?
A.
Well, the tape recorder not being put in
22
certainly is something that bothers me.
23
in -- excuse me, when he put this in, and not the tape
24
recorder, that seems a little conflicting to me.
25
Q.
When he put this
But does the fact that he -- on its own, the fact
't.,_ ._,...,'
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
183
info®diamondreporting.com
184
J. ETERNO
1
that the duty captain reported the complaint reports he
2
found to Internal Affairs fit within your concept of the
3
blue wall of silence?
A.
4
How do you mean?
What do you mean, fitting
5
within my concept of the blue wall -- who is being silent?
6
What are you driving at?
7
8
Q.
Well, the duty captain didn't try to cover up
these complaint reports, did he?
A.
9
Yeah, the duty captain is a supervisory officer
10
involved with this.
11
do with officers, you know, police officers' rank.
12
The blue wall of silence really has to
The supervisor has a completely different set of
13
responsibilities and duties that he or she would have to
14
do.
15
within the blue wall of silence 11 in this context.
16
17
So, I am not quite sure what you mean by "fitting
Q.
think we had that before.
18
19
So, for you, the blue wall of silence relates
only to other officers, of the rank of officer?
MR. SMITH:
20
21
Well, thank you for that clarification, I don't
A.
Objection to the form.
Sorry, not totally.
But in this case, they
22
clearly have been brought in as a supervisory type of
23
thing, they are now working under formal guidelines.
24
)
25
The blue wall is an informal thing, it's not
something that is written down.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
184
They weren't operating
info®diamondreporting.com
185
J, ETERNO
1
under patrol guide procedures now.
2
things that they need to do.
3
with that thesis.
4
Q.
There are very specific
So, this would not fall in
So, if a supervisor, for example, were within the
5
blue wall of silence, trying to protect someone else, you
6
don't believe they could have covered up those complaint
7
reports found in his room?
8
9
A.
I see what you are saying.
Yes, that's very
possible, if they were trying to cover up for him.
But I
10
don't think in this case the supervisors were trying to
11
cover up for him.
12
don't think that was ever an issue.
13
14
Q.
I don't think that was an issue.
I
You don't believe they were trying to cover up
for themselves?
15
A.
That's a separate issue.
16
Q.
You claim that plaintiff was found in good
17
18
19
I don't know.
condition in his apartment; is that right?
A.
Based on the Lauterborn memo, yes, and the tape
recordings.
20
Are you aware of his elevated heart rate?
21
A.
I am aware of that, yes.
22
Q.
And you are aware of his elevated blood pressure?
23
A.
Yes.
24
-~
Q.
Q.
And you believe that, given the elevated heart
25
rate and elevated blood pressure, he was in good condition?
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
185
info@diamondreporting.com
186
J. ETERNO
1
A.
I think anyone would have an elevated heart rate
2
having a team of armed officers in your living room
3
refusing to leave.
4
Q.
But you didn't answer the question, which is, do
5
you consider having elevated heart rate and elevated blood
6
pressure to be a good condition?
7
A.
Depends on the situation.
8
Q.
You believe in this situation his elevated heart
9
10
11
rate and elevated blood pressure was a good condition?
A.
I think it was completely normal given the
situation.
12
Q.
Were you there that night?
13
A.
No.
14
Q.
Have you seen any video of that evening?
15
A.
No.
16
Q.
You haven't read the officers' depositions who
17
were there that day, other than Officer Duncan?
18
A.
Right, yes.
19
Q.
So, you don't know whether they perceived him to
20
be in good condition or not; is that correct?
MR. SMITH:
21
Objection to the form.
22
A.
Correct.
23
Q.
As you just mentioned, you believe that if he
24
appeared emotionally disturbed, it was only the direct
25
result of the actions of the N.Y.P.D., correct?
~ •• M00/.1
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
186
info®diamondreporting.com
187
J. ETERNO
1
2
A.
I didn • t say •'only,
11
but I do feel that that was
certainly a contributing factor.
I believe you do say it•s a direct result.
On
3
Q.
4
page 11,
5
they occurred after they entered the apartment.
6
if they occurred, they apparently were the direct result of
7
the actions of the N.Y.P.D. 11
11
If any actions appeared emotionally disturbed
In fact,
8
A.
Apparently.
9
Q.
So, what do you mean by apparently, then?
10
A.
It appears that that was the direct reaction of
11
them staying in his living room, or bedroom, not sure
12
which.
13
would drive anyone's blood pressure, I think, higher.
But they stayed there against his wishes.
That
14
Q.
Do you have any medical background or training?
15
A.
Just what I had with the Police Academy.
16
Q.
So, are you qualified to make a determination
17
about the impact of others on an individual•s mental or
18
physical health?
19
20
21
22
A.
I am a physical fitness instructor for law
enforcement, but I am not a qualified doctor of medicine.
Q.
And have you ever done any studies on the impact
of others on someone•s physical and mental health?
i
23
A.
I actually did a study for the police department
24
•, ___
./
on physical fitness standards and their effect on arrests
25
that went on to win an award.
DIAMOND REPORTING
It won a police foundation
(718) 624-7200
187
info®diamondreporting.com
'
l
188
J. ETERNO
1
Hemmerdinger award, which did indicate that those who are
2
able to have higher cardiovascular endurance made more
3
arrests, things like that.
4
Q.
I'm sorry, but that didn't answer the question,
5
which was, have you done any research on the impact of
6
others on someone•s mental or physical health?
7
A.
Again, it's a physical fitness study on policing
8
and it's effect on police.
9
as a study on somebody's health, on fitness and how they
10
11
And I think that would qualify
react.
Q.
On causation of outside forces, on someone's
12
physical or mental health, you believe your research does
13
that?
MR. SMITH:
14
Objection to the form.
15
A.
Can you rephrase?
16
Q.
You believe that your research on officer's
17
physical fitness actually relates to the causation of an
18
outside force on an individual's physical and mental
19
health?
20
21
22
A.
What do you mean by causation --
I am not clear
on the question.
Q.
My question to you is, is the impact of other
23
24
~
individuals on someone's physical or mental health, that's
a causation?
25
A.
I understand what you are saying.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
188
No, that would
info®diamondreporting.com
i
r
189
J. ETERNO
1
2
not be it.
Q.
Your report indicates that it would have been
3
exceedingly prudent to contact the legal bureau for advice,
4
as well as notify them directly; is that correct?
5
A.
Yes.
6
Q.
Is it required that officers contact the legal
7
8
9
bureau before declaring someone an E.D.P.?
A.
It's not required to declare someone an E.D.P.
But this is an extremely unusual situation, where a
10
uniformed member of the service is being declared
11
emotionally disturbed.
12
prudent to contact the legal bureau on this.
It would have been extremely
13
Q.
But is it required?
14
A.
No.
15
Q.
Moving on to the next section, which is also on
16
page 11.
17
right?
That's your section on hospital data; is that
18
A.
Yes.
19
Q.
Mr. Smith has represented that the Health and
20
Hospital Corporation data is no longer available on the
21
website and no copy has been maintained by the expert; is
22
that accurate?
23
Yes.
24
I
A.
Q.
So, there is nothing --
25
MR. SMITH:
Just correct one thing.
I
',_./
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
189
info®diamondreporting.com
i
I
I
i=
190
J. ETERNO
1
didn't do the independent determination of
2
whether or not this data was available on the
3
website.
That was done by, I believe, the
4
witness.
So, I would be passing on information
5
about the existence of the data, I wasn't
MS. PUBLICKER METTHAM:
6
It was your
representation to the rest of the codefendants.
7
MR. SMITH:
8
To the extent that was the
representation, I would like to clarify.
9
I did
10
not go to the hospital's website.
I spoke to the
11
witness about his ability to do so.
12
we will get to the information of what he did to
13
try to get information.
And I think
14
But to the extent that someone was
15
suggesting that I did it, I want to make a
16
correction.
17
Q.
So, was that statement I read accurate, that the
18
Health and
19
hardcopy has been maintained by the expert?
Hospi~al
data is no longer on its website and no
20
A.
Yes.
21
Q.
So, for us to review or check your data here,
22
there is no way you can think of for us to do that?
23
Contact Health and Hospital.
24
~J
A.
Q.
What data would we ask for?
25
A.
You would ask for the datas from the hospital
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
190
info®diamondreporting.com
191
J. ETERNO
1
2
3
which is collected by them from 1999 through 2006.
Q.
just
Was there a title to this particular section,
11
hospital data,
--
11
generally?
4
A.
It's
5
Q.
Have you made any efforts to locate this data?
6
A.
Yes.
7
Q.
What efforts have you made?
8
A.
Searching through the materials on my study,
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
actually, emergency room visits.
getting on the website.
Q.
So, how did you write the section without access
to those materials?
A.
I did have access at one time.
And it's in our
book, so I know it's true.
Q.
So, you haven't actually looked at any of this
data since before writing your report in this case?
16
A.
The data itself?
17
Q.
Yes.
18
A.
No.
19
Q.
So, you are relying on data you have used in
20
21
22
other books?
A.
section, yes.
23
Q.
24
., __ //
In the book that I cited in the references
research?
25
A.
When was the last time you looked at that
I
Just before we wrote the book.
DIAMOND REPORTING
(718) 624-7200
191
info®diamondreporting.com
!
i
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?