Irving H. Picard v. Saul B. Katz et al

Filing 31

DECLARATION of Fernando A. Bohorquez, Jr., in Opposition re: 20 MOTION to Dismiss THE AMENDED COMPLAINT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.. Document filed by Irving H. Picard. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Errata 12, # 13 Exhibit 13-1, # 14 Exhibit 13-2, # 15 Exhibit 14, # 16 Exhibit 15, # 17 Exhibit 16, # 18 Exhibit 17, # 19 Exhibit 18, # 20 Exhibit 19, # 21 Exhibit 20, # 22 Exhibit 21, # 23 Exhibit 22, # 24 Exhibit 23, # 25 Exhibit 24, # 26 Exhibit 25, # 27 Exhibit 26, # 28 Exhibit 27, # 29 Exhibit 28, # 30 Exhibit 29, # 31 Exhibit 30, # 32 Exhibit 31, # 33 Exhibit 32, # 34 Exhibit 33, # 35 Exhibit 34, # 36 Exhibit 35, # 37 Exhibit 36, # 38 Exhibit 37, # 39 Exhibit 38, # 40 Exhibit 39, # 41 Exhibit 40, # 42 Exhibit 41, # 43 Exhibit 42, # 44 Exhibit 43, # 45 Exhibit 44, # 46 Exhibit 45, # 47 Exhibit 46, # 48 Exhibit 47, # 49 Exhibit 48, # 50 Exhibit 49, # 51 Exhibit 50, # 52 Exhibit 51, # 53 Exhibit 52, # 54 Exhibit 53, # 55 Exhibit 54, # 56 Exhibit 55, # 57 Exhibit 56, # 58 Exhibit 57, # 59 Exhibit 58)(Bohorquez, Fernando)

Download PDF
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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?