MCFADYEN et al v. DUKE UNIVERSITY et al
Filing
324
MOTION to Dismiss Causes 5 and 18 by LINWOOD WILSON. Responses due by 1/11/2013 (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Judgement by USCA)(WILSON, LINWOOD)
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 1 of 7
FILED: December 17, 2012
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT
___________________
No. 11-1436 (L)
(1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD)
___________________
DAVID F. EVANS; COLLIN FINNERTY; READE SELIGMANN
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
STEVEN W. CHALMERS; BEVERLY COUNCIL; RONALD HODGE; JEFF
LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER; LEE RUSS; PATRICK BAKER
Defendants - Appellants
and
CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN
HIMAN; DAVID ADDISON; MICHAEL NIFONG; LINWOOD WILSON;
STEPHEN MIHAICH; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED; RICHARD CLARK;
BRIAN MEEHAN
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1438
(1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD)
___________________
DAVID F. EVANS; COLLIN FINNERTY; READE SELIGMANN
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 1 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 2 of 7
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN
HIMAN; DAVID ADDISON
Defendants - Appellants
and
MICHAEL NIFONG; LINWOOD WILSON; STEVEN W. CHALMERS; BEVERLY
COUNCIL; RONALD HODGE; JEFF LAMB; STEPHEN MIHAICH; MICHAEL
RIPBERGER; LEE RUSS; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED; RICHARD
CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN; PATRICK BAKER
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1453
(1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD)
___________________
EDWARD CARRINGTON; CASEY J. CARROLL; MICHAEL P. CATALINO;
GALE CATALINO; THOMAS V. CLUTE; KEVIN COLEMAN; JOSHUA R.
COVELESKI; EDWARD J. CROTTY; EDWARD S. DOUGLAS; KYLE DOWD;
PATRICIA DOWD; DANIEL FLANNERY; RICHARD GIBBS FOGARTY;
ZACHARY GREER; IRENE GREER; ERIK S. HENKELMAN; STEVEN W.
HENKELMAN; JOHN E. JENNISON; BEN KOESTERER; MARK KOESTERER;
JOYCE KOESTERER; FRED KROM; PETER J. LAMADE; ADAM LANGLEY;
CHRISTOPHER LOFTUS; DANIEL LOFTUS; BARBARA LOFTUS; ANTHONY
MCDEVITT; GLENN NICK; NICHOLAS O'HARA; LYNNDA O'HARA; DANIEL
OPPEDISANO; SAM PAYTON; JOHN BRADLEY ROSS; KENNETH SAUER, III;
STEVE SCHOEFFEL; ROBERT SCHROEDER; DEVON SHERWOOD; DANIEL
THEODORIDIS; BRET THOMPSON; CHRISTOPHER TKAC; TRACY TKAC;
JOHN WALSH, JR.; MICHAEL WARD; ROBERT WELLINGTON, IV; WILLIAM
WOLCOTT; MICHAEL YOUNG
Plaintiffs - Appellees
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 2 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 3 of 7
v.
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER
Defendants - Appellants
and
DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS,
INCORPORATED; RICHARD BRODHEAD; PETER LANGE; LARRY MONETA;
JOHN BURNESS; TALLMAN TRASK; SUZANNE WASIOLEK; MATTHEW
DRUMMOND; AARON GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; TARA LEVICY; THERESA
ARICO; J. WESLEY COVINGTON; KATE HENDRICKS; VICTOR DZAU; CITY
OF DURHAM; LINWOOD WILSON; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN;
STEPHEN MIHAICH; DAVID ADDISON; MARSHA COVINGTON
COVINGTON, Executrix of the Estate of John Wesley Covington
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1458
(1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD)
___________________
RYAN MCFADYEN; MATTHEW WILSON; BRECK ARCHER
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER
Defendants - Appellants
and
DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY POLICE DEPARTMENT; AARON
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 3 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 4 of 7
GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; LEILA HUMPHRIES; PHYLLIS COOPER; WILLIAM
F. GARBER, III; JAMES SCHWAB; JOSEPH FLEMING; JEFFREY O. BEST;
GARY N. SMITH; GREG STOTSENBERG; ROBERT K. STEEL; RICHARD H.
BRODHEAD, Ph. D.; PETER LANGE, Ph. D.; TALLMAN TRASK, III, Ph. D.;
JOHN BURNESS; LARRY MONETA, Ed. D.; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH
SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED; PRIVATE DIAGNOSTIC CLINIC, PLLC; JULIE
MANLY, MD; THERESA ARICO, R. N.; TARA LEVICY, R. N.; THE CITY OF
DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; MICHAEL NIFONG; STEPHEN MIHAICH;
EDWARD SARVIS; LAIRD EVANS; JAMES T. SOUKUP; KAMMIE MICHAEL;
DAVID ADDISON; MARK D. GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN W. HIMAN; LINWOOD
WILSON; RICHARD D. CLAYTON; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED;
RICHARD CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN, Ph. D.; VICTOR J. DZAU, MD; ALLISON
HALTON; KEMEL DAWKINS; SUZANNE WASIOLEK; STEPHEN BRYAN;
MATTHEW DRUMMOND; DUKE POLICE DEFENDANTS
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1460
(1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD)
___________________
RYAN MCFADYEN; MATTHEW WILSON; BRECK ARCHER
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
THE CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; DAVID ADDISON; MARK
GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN
Defendants - Appellants
and
DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY POLICE DEPARTMENT; AARON
GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; LEILA HUMPHRIES; PHYLLIS COOPER; WILLIAM
F. GARBER, II; JAMES SCHWAB; JOSEPH FLEMING; JEFFREY O. BEST;
GARY N. SMITH; GREG STOTSENBERG; ROBERT K. STEEL; RICHARD H.
BRODHEAD, Ph. D.; PETER LANGE, Ph. D.; TALLMAN TRASK, III, Ph. D.;
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 4 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 5 of 7
JOHN BURNESS; LARRY MONETA, Ed. D.; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH
SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED; PRIVATE DIAGNOSTIC CLINIC, PLLC; JULIE
MANLY, MD; THERESA ARICO, R. N.; TARA LEVICY, R. N.; MICHAEL
NIFONG; STEPHEN MIHAICH; EDWARD SARVIS; LAIRD EVANS; JAMES T.
SOUKUP; KAMMIE MICHAEL; LINWOOD WILSON; RICHARD D. CLAYTON;
DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED; RICHARD CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN, Ph.
D.; VICTOR J. DZAU, MD; ALLISON HALTON; KEMEL DAWKINS; SUZANNE
WASIOLEK; STEPHEN BRYAN; MATTHEW DRUMMOND; DUKE POLICE
DEFENDANTS; PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN W. CHALMERS; RONALD
HODGE; LEE RUSS; BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL
RIPBERGER
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1465
(1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD)
___________________
EDWARD CARRINGTON; CASEY J. CARROLL; MICHAEL P. CATALINO;
GALE CATALINO; THOMAS V. CLUTE; KEVIN COLEMAN; JOSHUA R.
COVELESKI; EDWARD J. CROTTY; EDWARD S. DOUGLAS; KYLE DOWD;
PATRICIA DOWD; DANIEL FLANNERY; RICHARD GIBBS FOGARTY;
ZACHARY GREER; IRENE GREER; ERIK S. HENKELMAN; STEVEN W.
HENKELMAN; JOHN E. JENNISON; BEN KOESTERER; MARK KOESTERER;
JOYCE KOESTERER; FRED KROM; PETER J. LAMADE; ADAM LANGLEY;
CHRISTOPHER LOFTUS; DANIEL LOFTUS; BARBARA LOFTUS; ANTHONY
MCDEVITT; GLENN NICK; NICHOLAS O'HARA; LYNNDA O'HARA; DANIEL
OPPEDISANO; SAM PAYTON; JOHN BRADLEY ROSS; KENNETH SAUER, III;
STEVE SCHOEFFEL; ROBERT SCHROEDER; DEVON SHERWOOD; DANIEL
THEODORIDIS; BRET THOMPSON; CHRISTOPHER TKAC; TRACY TKAC;
JOHN WALSH, JR.; MICHAEL WARD; ROBERT WELLINGTON, IV; WILLIAM
WOLCOTT; MICHAEL YOUNG
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
CITY OF DURHAM; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN; DAVID
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 5 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 6 of 7
ADDISON
Defendants - Appellants
and
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER; DUKE
UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED;
RICHARD BRODHEAD; PETER LANGE; LARRY MONETA; JOHN BURNESS;
TALLMAN TRASK; SUZANNE WASIOLEK; MATTHEW DRUMMOND;
AARON GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; TARA LEVICY; THERESA ARICO; J.
WESLEY COVINGTON; KATE HENDRICKS; VICTOR J. DZAU; LINWOOD
WILSON; STEPHEN MIHAICH; MARSHA SAUNDERS COVINGTON, Executrix
of the Estate of John Wesley Covington
Defendants
___________________
JUDGMENT
___________________
In accordance with the decision of this court, judgment is entered affirming in
part, dismissing in part, reversing in part and remanding in these consolidated appeals.
In No. 11-1436 (1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court is
REVERSED on all issues appealed (Counts 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 below).
In No. 11-1438 (1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court is
AFFIRMED as to Count 13 below against Defendants Gottlieb and Himan. The
judgment is REVERSED as to Count 13 below against Defendant Addison. The
judgment is REVERSED as to Counts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 14 below against all defendants.
The judgment is REVERSED as to Counts 13, 16, and 17 below against the City of
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 6 of 7
Appeal: 11-1436
Doc: 92
Filed: 12/17/2012
Pg: 7 of 7
Durham. The City's appeal as to Count 23 below is DISMISSED.
In No. 11-1453 (1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court is
REVERSED on all issues appealed (Counts 21, 25, and 27 below).
In No. 11-1465 (1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court is
REVERSED as to Counts 21, 23, and 25 below against all defendants. The judgment is
REVERSED as to Counts 26, 30, and 31 below against the City of Durham. The City's
appeal as to Count 32 below is DISMISSED.
In No. 11-1458 (1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court is
REVERSED on all issues appealed (Counts 1, 2, 5, 13, and 18 below).
In No. 11-1460 (1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD), the judgment of the district court
is REVERSED as to Counts 1, 2, 5, and 18 against all defendants. The judgment is
REVERSED as to Counts 12, 14, 25, and 26 below against the City of Durham. The
City’s appeal as to Count 41 below is DISMISSED.
This judgment shall take effect upon issuance of this court's mandate in
accordance with Fed. R. App. P. 41.
/s/ PATRICIA S. CONNOR, CLERK
Case 1:07-cv-00739-JAB-JEP Document 183 Filed 12/17/12 Page 7 of 7
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?