STUDENTS FOR FAIR ADMISSIONS, INC. v. UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA, et al
Filing
45
Joint MOTION for Protective Order by ROGER AIKEN, W. LOUIS BISSETTE, JR, JAMES W. DEAN, JR, STEPHEN M. FARMER, JOHN C. FENNEBRESQUE, CAROL L. FOLT, H. FRANK FRAINGER, HANNAH D. GAGE, ANN B. GOODNIGHT, PETER D. HANS, THOMAS J. HARRELSON, HENRY W. HINTON, JAMES L. HOLMES, JR, RODNEY E. HOOD, W. MARTY KOTIS, III, G. LEROY LAIL, SCOTT LAMPE, STEVEN B. LONG, JOAN G. MACNEILL, HARI H. MATH, MARY ANN MAXWELL, W. EDWIN MCMAHAN, W.G. CHAMPION MITCHELL, ANNA SPANGLER NELSON, ALEX PARKER, R. DOYLE PARRISH, JOAN TEMPLETON PERRY, THERENCE O. PICKETT, DAVID M. POWERS, ROBERT S. RIPPY, THOMAS W. ROSS, HARRY LEO SMITH, JR, J. CRAIG SOUZA, GEORGE A. SYWASSINK, RICHARD F. TAYLOR, RAIFORD TRASK, III, UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA, UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL HILL, UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA BOARD OF GOVERNORS, PHILLIP D. WALKER, LAURA I. WILEY. (Attachments: # 1 Text of Proposed Order)(SCUDDER, MICHAEL)
<![CDATA[
1
2 4561 46814
469824 2
7 41
31 732 9 1 9 41
1 2 824 2
1
4561 8861 9 41 3
451
2
3
1
0
0 / 0
00 0 0
0
0
/ "-00
0 '0
0
0
/ 114 53
0 23 *460
0 0 0 0 !#%& / 0
"$#'0 0
&
0
/0
0
(0
/0
0
0
/ 7
7
9 7
46 42
86 1
0
681
861
)0 *+0 0
)0
/
0
, 0 ,0 ,, %!0 /
0 ) ) 00 0 0
-"
0
/
0
0 0 0 0000--.$'0 /
0000 &$"% 0
0000
0
/
0
/
0
0
0
0
9 6681 86342 4:1 7
46 42
86 0
32
2
381
861
0
;'"%0.0 0 (0 >@ $0A$%-"<- $0$0%;"#$00<;$00- # 0 ?/".;00 0C-D-% .'# !% 0&B0
% = 0
B
" A 0 %
A<#'0- 0<0$'C00"'00'-" <%@#-<-00#0 %<A0-% C
"% B0 ;%#.00.@;-%#;00 0-% 0 .<$%'D"% <%@# 0
-% &
0'
( # B -0 $
%-@$#-%!E00-%#0 %<"0'.&$.F!G/B% EF0<.@.#0 B00&.$##0& <"$ "-#!"0-#-0-0 0"0 0-A0;-0 % 0
"% @
?
% D"
$B
@;'0&B'!#"#$0 @<#CE0- 0<0$-'%-&!G#C<-2
0<-00#0% % 0.$! B0 ;% %<0 0 ! $0 .<0
% #C 0 @
%
- B 00
0
HJ 862 42 1
I
32
39
11 L OQNTQVQUUYUX] Y_NN\^`SOYUWR Y_
K MNPRSU PWONZ[\^PO[OUX R R _PO ZU
P X
U
NX O ^X
#%<0"0E<'0' -A$-%00a-%0"D#0$G- !"#C0
$-<C%<0-A$-0'0'0 "< ;'00. %"' <A-.$
<
0- % 0
&! C0< %-0&< %$#0$0 < A0;-0< #@0-00#0@#$0
#$ 0B<$0D"# 0 "E& D0<.@.00'!'.#%'"%
# 00 # 0 $ 0
.
$B 0
GB%-00;%<!0<B0C0$0 "'00#@(<0;B<b.F0G
-B< !$"# 00<;B"ED-$0& '0-E"%0#-0E! 0
( E %
.
"
".GB%-0E"A<E0004"%00#0@#$0
$0 -B< 00"%0< $A<E%%'"%
F
$
0B 0
1= Ldef UUPc^RU ]NRYS iOYUQj\U Ok 0
K c gTRO UN Sd[\O NU hU [fRNZg\ 0
Wh Z X eR N
=
l1mC0$0'# !D-% C<C!%$ 3 0%5 -A<#'
0== .#0 - $# 0 ;"# '0 0 50 0"% 0
" % DA $ - 0 m
A0 B "n0 -C0"0 0 E"AE%0-%#0 %<"0"00a-%.00
@$G!.-% % D"0A!0 @<"$ "-#!B%'< ;'-0<
B
0
% #0
357900
0
0 934
4
48 69 0934
4686
0 0 90 5 90
0 0
5
9 7
9
959005 0 0 0
40
6 83
5
0
! "#%'( +,)%*%)/1'%$())5'/1#1)&%-))7#)
$&#) )%-% -.02-1'3'4))0$'60)16$& %(
*#
# 2' $
$ 0%
704 5
9 09 9:
000990
53
5
070 94
345 ;
69 6
8 5 8
0 <
8
9 4=3905 9>5 0 4
0 84@ 0
56
0 0 9 6 0 0 4
?5
07 9560 A
5 9
4
8
> 0 0 D 2 909;
0004 8905 3
0
8579
? 0 10 E:
< 359 6 07 640
B9 C 0
0
4 8
0 030A97
04 8
95645051
8579
3
9 0 A 59 049A4 640
8 4 5 3 9 0
49 :4
< 90 404903 0934
0 9
99 5090
4 9
096750 0 0
0 ; 5 F
9
2(G'H*#%'( +,)%*%)
002-1'()') 4000
0( 1) $&#) )%-% -.
/1'%$ I45 9
0
*#
#3 F
9 5 9359 0 0
0 4005
50 0
7J800 04 8
50 :
F9
04960
5 ;<
8
5
49049 04 5 3
4 6 06 6
00
99
9
5
070 03 0 079 09
90 K
3 5 8 5 ;
6 L
4
<
87
50
6 A 405
900
0099 A 6 070
0 0 9
6
0
9 5F 8
.M(#'12(6)6-21-')O)%%1R
</1#1)M&0#()
#M' $ ) %34 )%'%) NPQ&'5)
00$'6.%61(
/0 ' #
1
;
+
9
9
4 5 5070 3
506 '1))%
6
0 5
0 04 5 03 0 4
03$$ )
5 4 8
0Q
8 94
:4 8905 3
0
8579347 00 ? 0
9 0 59 6 07 6407 5> 0
3
4 8
B9 C 0
D 2 04
< 90 404903 0934
0
0 1: 090
4 9
096750 0
5 ; 5
9
S . M'#'12(3'/U%)(*#%'()U*'%)+#)M(#$0)
! TM( $ ) %) (-6#( $B, $-,)1#M' 1) &
/0 ' 1
)
$
/ 2
50098 94
049996098 94
05
634
6
0
9 508
90 0
9 00 41 0
5
4
4
44
$%#M'#$6#M'#'12&- 6'1)/U'H,$0)
96 0 )M( 1V)M( $ ) ) *'60W1(-1)U) $
Q /
/ 0 0#
'
1
6 X 0
03(#$6?5 3
50 0 90
90 0 < 9M' 1V) 50 3
04 5
4
5; 0 /
85
3
4 0A4 8
A9 840=484
708
9A
3 0 A 04300 59A 7484 0
85 5 9
9
9
684 :209
A9 0 05 44
9
00 0 < 7 0 9 A 689 0 6 0 0
;9 5
9
3
;<9 4095
44
93
6;<
3 : 0 50896 0 6 0 03 : 0 0
8 0 9 4
59
8 0 S
#+-/*%$)0$''H#)M(#$61*%)-&6W0'(%U')
1)0U 16/1#11)1#M' 1V)# W -%6) /#) /&$
/
# 6 6 +
4
0854 90
9A4 909 0
7 9A
50 0
4 7
0 660 0
4 45
0
55
5 9 55 3
9
9
4 07
9
0 0990
8
9
6
0 5
80 40969 6
056
0
5C
440 9
4
99 5 04 8
0
96950 9090407J800 359 0
50
K .$-136#( 0 06960 5849 0 500 560
! YU%$)Q(9
7 074 60494 0
0
9
9
98 94
04 0 904 56098 94
0
9 50 6650 4 0
0
9 0
9 9 9
0
L . M'#$) #6#+'-7-#) 06, $-#)M(#'12&
! TM( 13*%1)1) ''U( )U*'%)1#M' $ ) )
/
1
GQ $
/0 0
50098 94
A96950 9
4
9 0
6
0
9 040 900 450
5
4
3
9A9
6
5A4 86500
6 60 906
0 090
6
53
0
Z . 6(61)#$3&2&)))#$)& 01 00
08
0
! ['/0'H\&+)%%6$#M&+0) 134 0 5
0
1
5
5
35790 4
468F9
0
] . /''H\&+)2&)))#$) 0&/'%) $&#O
! ^%%71)#$3& %6$#M&+GQ) %76"#%'(
% 0
%
0
0
10
01
20
0
35 7
9
99
9 9
9
46 89
0
9
!# $ &*)
" %&'() &+,(+)
-3 ./13531278594031<81471;01>;70 :;@7B418C
46 020 0 043 0 :;67 50=1073 0 ?3 071A 3740
46 1
6 94 0
2;?1008008D0 167 7 ;018D3@0D813C7 86:
7@0@83543 A 310 0 3 5=410;E@D80 0=C0
D6 ; <6 ; D @
4; 6
0D813C80?8=4:107344:8A? 7A7 1083D;0
;E@D8ADC@D0D0/12ADC550 994:0 0 5728 0E
40
0 5
;@ ;
4:B418C@3018105D0D0 37407 ;? D5G5@;07
D0 374A44@7F@?8=4:B418C 0 09130410D;0
0
;@
=D73@?8=4:B418C54C1?10;1:E7 ?255;01
114105D0D0 374A6CG05@5CC0 0 7;10E60
0 0
;2
3
2;1?8D;01150E6543D00?8=42450D0 7D0310
7503 07 ED1;08008 ADC@D021CA @E 0;;67
; @
3 ;8
4 ;
27;10
?254
-- H;G0?I0001278?40;E@D8C:2;13D0E380 @7
46 015G13;3 043 C7 D813 807308 5;0 5J71A
36 0 0
43
; 6
0
B418C 50 L 10D813C7 86:0D813C 380191DD0
3740 330 0;E@D80 0=C0;E@D80 6D3 0 48=
9? K G
4; 6
4<8 6
;013D32;080 @70D0 LG018D3@0D813C7 86:
E 08 040E65J71N @K 01@5=410;E@D80 0=C0
M ; 3
4 4; 6
0D813C?543;M08D2;080 @70
;E@D80 7?D0013 00E65J714
42 3 ; 3
0
-2 H607308D0E65J7106CD32C00 37404A7;00
46 12;13 5;080 @7 4C;0 2:3B418C63287;
; 3
5 04 ;
30 3
@5C57008008D0 5<8 8014340;558D;0D<C@1;0
80;?183543 A 0 3D3 00?C 515;07 ; 1=0E
D6 ; <4 6 6 2
O
4P11FD04307 5434C0?C0D<C@107F@@340 1
0 088=Q7:;0 00?C 2G8O; 1=A ;810 360
<4 : 0
2
63
B418C80;01; 0?C0D<C@137?640007 985;0E0
3740@D3 0912G8O; 1=0 ;=0D43 0 58D;0
@ G
0
6
;;
4
P11FD0434R0D00113D0D0430C8 040 3740 50
088=Q7:0E @33 0/13 :27:04953 3 18C A
0 4 ;6 4
6 B4 <4
287;@5C57008008D0 38054340;558D;0D<C@10
7;0080;?183543 A 6D800?C 515;07O; 1=A
3
D6 ; <8 3 2
;0 52G80D<C@101>;706C@37 D0 8627:6531
7 0?C O; 1=A60 ?3 4C11981<60043040 0
<4 0
3
5 0
6
G710E 7FD04043D407400 302C4C0<4
?@D;0 ;8=3 3 0000;@D1<8 428 G1C 0
2 6E 8
6 0 4
S# ,($UVWXT &*)
"
T &V) YWX(+T W$%&V*T WZ)
WZ) ) ,(VXT
23 [11407F5;5
46 D7C ;88D0
Q
233 ]80;8=Q7:94018D30 374050D813C7 86:
446\0 5C5D0430 :@5=41B418C 0;E@D80 0=C0
4
4; 6
0D813CD:801B418C300;E@D8C7 86:
;E@D80 C0 3 0 3740 L50D813 0 0=C0
4; E6
K8
4; 6
0D813C5@ED@G013D320D0 L5D3/C@@E;
;E@D80 01810:M08 04N @K 00;0 0?10 90
44
; 4 -8 1
7
315;1;080 @7 :M08D-20
60020E65J710 013 0440
3
G ; 0
23- 0205;67 507F@@8080 @731@5=48D;0
446./13 031<812;810 35J71A6018D3 0E
4
D6
0
;
B418C50D813C7 86:0D813C6?@G0 @07;0
3740 0;E@D80 0=C0;E@D80 ;C01941287
4
4; 6
45
3A7;3927D;5:<8A607@08D;080;?1;040
;0 0 D1 ;41?C0 3012;?3 07 5C570E63
;0
63
; @
3
^9_ a 9
_
b _ 9
9^9_
`
0D813C7 86:0D813C36091;07@08D;0
;E@D80 0=C0;E@D80013 0E ;?3 07
4; 6
443 8 2 ;
@5C570E60 3740;5D36<11A 8180=34100
80;?1;01B418C 10;A; F7<4F057 6037;
3
@ 0 0 38 C 3
0
10
01
20
0
35794
4 9465864
06 864
93
4
468
0 0
90 03860
7038680 0
9
90
90
667
90357949 94686
440
55809
0 50468
080
90
0 050
90
354055
4
0
900468
3864
6
040 0 0
0 94653579403860
9 0
6
9
06 864
4090
9090430483553
703860
46 59
940640
99
9
00 667
080
40458086 0 667
9 44809
0 9
0
4
04 4480
906404 4601386
90
9
0
553
0
588864
0 46 9
3
9 9 5 0
06
4
0 6 50
90 53553
90
8
0 09
0 0 946 0640
9
4 9469048357940386
6 864
0
90 540468
3864
0 070386
9
90
93
904
4
0 5!
40489
80
0 64 85060 3
080
40 0
4
7
548064090
9" 0
355
0
5 4
55
0
460 5164
3
9 0
357968590 4996804 866
468
0 8
50806
550 0
06
7
6
080 667
6054
9 4357968
6 6
089 44809
0
0080
1468
0
96
4
354 8
804 9460 4440 93579680
65696 0 0
9#
9
00468
0
0 5
40 667
59
904 9465864
9 44809
0
4
0
90 03860 0
0
9
9
703869
67
04357968080$004
6 864
380
0468
354
0
90
9
4
80 5!
40
6 5060 3
0
0
%& 4 30 57968
'
50 68
0
4
%&( 667
90468
0
905864
')0 55809
0 35794 946 03860 0
9
9
967066704 9468998
8
84
0
80
*808
0
9000 84090 0
44
9
6
60 6
+,/013415-2+689 > BCD0 667
-,/ ,,-/ / 7/:;<=?@<A> E0 55809
0
.- 2 , .
)0
90468
0
905 70386 9670667
35794 946 06 864
0 080
*80
9
9
9
04 9468998
8
84
0
057
8
0
9000 84090 0
44 6 60 66
0
6
60 6
4 6
4 30!<=?@<A> /
0
59 > BCF
BAA;G<@H/ / E
@H@I;<CHD0
%&& 86
90
406
045090
386
' 0 0 4
7
0
54
4
0 864
0 0
98
3
5
9
70386
9 0550 0468
3
6 864
0 46
4
84904357940
9 9 0 4
864
6 864
7
4
550
04
3860 0703860 0 46 0 0 84 6
0
9
9 9 8 4
+68/:;<=?@<A> /7:;<=?@<A> /
709 > BCE6/ > BCF
9
BAA;G<@H/
@H@I;<CHD/8
49
964080386
6
/ E/ 0 0 8
864
0 070
4 9
9
864
804
550 0
336004994
3860
6 0 0 84904 640 95
0
9
4
8
34
433
049830 055593
80 840
0 6004
84080
9
4
6
940
84
4480 3
59
9640498
8
30 440
6J84060 8
0 60
4 0
4
30 0550046
90 6406
0
04
84
0 4
7
0
8354
4 8
50
5K/.10L2/G2K00OP,2-1P6RL,P/T0
4 4
0520L1--M N2-/6Q8P,/Q7 - F T
96
/ 9
L, 6 S
550
6400343 6
5500
940
4 8489836938 0 0 8466
3
8
4 58
.7,/57Q7P2E
22P4/ 22OD0
2
0
0
10
01
20
353 9 8 0
0
0
0
990
44678
0
0 9 00 90
9
0 8
8
000 8
0 0 0
9
0 09 9808080
9
3
8
9 800
00 8 0
80 0
0
9
0 0 0
8
0 9
4 0
0 8
090
90
9 80
0 0 8 0 0
0
0 9
8
00
8
9
8 8
0 800
0 0 0
0 8
00
9
9
9
!30
00
03090
0
00
04" 9
08" 9
"
8
090
0
8
0 0 90#0
0 0 0
9
9 9
99 9 80
"
0
08
0
0 08084
90 0 0 8 0
$
00
8
0 0
0
90
0 0 0
#
9
03090
0 8 08
0
0
0
0808 0
0
9
9
8 90
0
0
"
8 090
998"
0 90 0
9
9
080%84&8
0
0'
8
0
8 80 0 0 0
0
0 # 9
0 9 0 90
8
#900
0 0 0
9
9
08 80
0 0
0 0 0
0 8
0 0
9
0
0088
0'
0
"
0
0 0 0 00 0
9
9
9
0
090
(8
)
8 8 0
0 8
0 0 8
0 0 0
9
9 84
8
0
35* 0
8
8900
0
446+
0 0 0
0
08
9
9,9
0
90 8
0
0
0 0
80
" "8#9
#
#"0
0
90
9
9
9#900
0 0 0
00 " 0
9
" 0 0
0
#
#0 090
9 000
'"
"
0 00 0 9 )0 00
(
9 99 0
""8 0
00 0
0
0
0 0 08
9
8 0#
#"
0
9
#
#0 000
090 99
08 0
9#9
8##
0
0
#
8 0 #
#090099 0
0
0 9 0 0 0
,9
8 8 0 847
90
890900
#0
0
08 0
8
0
0
8
8
08 0
0
0
0
0
80 09 0 9
80 8
9
8
-
08 08
0 000
0 089
9
00
0 9
9
08
09
0
0 0
0 08
00
" 0 90 #8
9
8098 9 0
9
0
' 908
0
0 0
0
0#0 0
40
0
33 %
00
.
0
46 9 %
0 9
9
33! 0
090 9
9
9
00
446/0
&8#90 00
0
09
9
.
&80 0
9
00
9
0901
0 0
0
0 9
9
8.
&80 0
#0
00 0 9
094/
01
0 0 0 08
0
9
0.
&8
00990#980
#9 0 0 9
090
98
00
9
90
0 470 9
&8
0
0 0 #90 .
090
9
0
90
090 1 0
0 0
&8 00 0
0
9
0
10
01
20
0
357968
40 50894600 84
0350800
468
0 8
770 98440 9345936
4 8
56054
4 68
04864
3579680
54 0 04
0
0 38660468
0
4
9
0
4468
793
4 44809
0084
054
0 5796 09
080 0 6679490 0
8
4
4354767
4864
35796804 4480
06
049380 0 38660468
0 667
9
90 089 94
68604 0 867
4
9
0
94906
0
0
0
9 780 0
8 4
357968080044
800 66798404
468
0 3
0 4
44809
0 75
0
0 9 9
4
864
357968 00 5796704 0
38660468
0 468
09
0
9
9
9
8
5 0
3
80 6 5
440 00 384!60
44
64! 09
090 038 0 8990
6
9690!
4 0
9
""# 4380894 805679984
00 386
$8679074
4
4 800 70 9864
60
4
9
3579683 4
8""&00 7 00
83
468
0840 6 0 0 6 089
6 0840
% 9 8
%68""&04'9468(4
8594
4
390 386
4
0 0
90056 0 0 9405864
0
6 0
9
06 864
80004 4
80 5)4
70 3860 354
0
6 5 060 30
99
*, -.012/ 7 56 :89-1. 2<7
+ / 3456 7
3/ 89-7
9;7 =8>54. -5/;98>5-7
817 .
8/029<. 81777777777770
7 -59>. 77777777777
77777777777
?& @5080 87 0 864
90
$ 493A936 0 3860 46
8 9'9
?&& 59
%68#&0
90468
390 386 6
$8004
0 46 579405864
0 070
'9 3
9
864
9468
759 0440 6 40
3860 00 5796 09
0 8
053 05530
9
8
0
3
9 44809
0
0 840 8050
40904
80 667 055 0 4 8
0
6
9
468 04450 59
80679950 60
5
0 84 0606 83804B 5
3
6
0
CDFGIHDLKNINJFEHF NJNMIMRENKS 6
EDHD JKJ HMI IKHPKQK IR NKFJ I 070
F M O
M L
Q
864
900
0(90 4
080
996
3860 46 !6 4 0 94 4 8550
9'9 9
0
5
90 46
8 04864
6 864
0 56 0 0 3860 070 3860
3
9
9
'94690 90804 9670 70
95
9 5!4596438 68 660 86
0
0 0
0
6 4 0
80
667 0867
090 864
40
4
898804380 4 0 3860 0
3
4 5
9
70 386
9
6 864
0 46
9'9 0
?&# 05 64004
8?#0 840 80 667
$T 4
0336%6 0 5 0 44809
0
9
8 9
5949
953579405864
6
40'9460468
390 3860 070
0 0
9
864
6060 40 64545 0800044
3860 8 5 0 50 5568936950
9!6
4
8
940
90
0
?&" 08
446NJ UVDWHLNFJMJFRSUKIF
$T 4
0 0 57QK IQJGIMHNII I K I J I
N
J O KN NO
0
90909048357940 386 6
0 46
540468
3864
0 070
'9
9
864
9!6 8000
04 080940
386 09
0 567
4!6
0
0
90
6 9
9
65 085
090 386
90 0
090 8980430 4 864
0 46 96
4
4
9'9 5 0 4
50
9059
4 440 0
946 800 035 0 90 4Y?0
X 0
0
10
01
20
0
353 8
08
90
9 0
446789
0 0 0
0 9
!$ &"( +*%,%-* "%.
" %' " " . ,*"(,. 0 0
#
)*
*
/080
2 8
00
28
80
/19
1 0
/8
130
0
/ 0 0
24 " 4,"6789;<=>? 0+BC=D;<=>? "
2
0 " +%# : @A&" ? @AE
55
#
@>>CF=<G" " "" 4,". ,"$ + .
<G<HC=AG& %" +%,""+* *$*" "
(5
*
9
4
/0
0
35I 0 0 0 /8
0
0
4468
/0 7
0 8/3/0 0/ 0 80
/
0 0
9 2
0
2 8 /19
8 /
09
0 0080
2 0
80
00 0
/
J / /
830
0
9
01 3 08
0
01
/
0
0
18
/9
9
03
9
0800
0
0
0 0
8 00 0
0 2 0
02
/
0 0 L
0
9
0 1
8
/8 4K
M 0 990 0
0
0
0
0
09
8 /19
8
0
0
2 0 0080
2 0 0
00
/
3
3 81M 3
:
0 340
8 18 80
0 0
9 L
0
35N 0
0
2 8 /19
8/8
446J
8 0
09
0 0080
2 0 8
0
/
0
80
0/8
0 80
09
0
00 9
0
8
0
/
/
1
M
1O
M04:0
2/
80 00 9 0P10 0M0 0 900
13
0 /
8/08
8 0
80R
00
9
0
0/8Q08
31
0 0
0
9 9
81
0
J
8
0
0
2 02/0 4
/
0
352 0
98
02/0 08J
8
0
4467/0
9
0
8 8 0 0
0
0
0
9
8 /19
8
0 0 0
09
0
2 0 0080
2 0 /7
0
M
/
0M
0
00
28L 0
6
0/830
90 0 0 0 8
9
// 0
00
S 9
0P102/0 8000
0
0 804:0
S 9
0P1
0
/
0
L 00
J
8 130
T0M
0 /0
/0 0 0
100
98
0
/
0 2
O
M00/89 1 0 008J
8
9 0P18
0 L 0 8 0 0
0
0 2 / 0
0
2 8 /19
8
0 0 0
0
9
0 0080
2 0 7
0
/
/
9
00M
0
00
28L 0
6
00
M
90 0
0 0
9
// /
3
0
4
10
0
3U P S 9
0
46
0 8
7
00
00
35W0 9
0 0
//0M V9 044 802
8 0
0
J
0
2 8 /19
8 130 01 0
28L 0
9
0 0080
2 0 0
80 0 8 0
/
/
9
X
990
3U5 80
L
30 09
7
2 8
446Y
/ 0/3 01P
0 9
0
/
M 0
J
8 130 9
00 0 0 00
0 0
8
0 0 8
0
/ 0
/
980
81
000
0
0
/M0
0 0
02 8 0
0
/
9 L/
L
Q0
38 0
9 L 0 0 0 1
0 0 9
0 8 470
// 0
0
0
10
01
20
0
3 68370 00 7
6900 0
7
3
457309
3
7400734
359 00 0
533 306030
6 3003
9 03
3
63
7 06
93
07 0
0
0 0 7
097700 939 0
03
360360
80357 0930
0
9
03
9
07 30
3
7 6
9
0 80730!" 9 097430
3
0 36 036
00 33
0 9 9
4
7
5 7
793
9
304573700
000
0"
30970 9 9 6830 598
6
# 0
5 3
7 7
3
00
000
0
37$ 076
70598
6
0 70 9 9 5
0
7 7
3
3
07 00
0 0"7
5 099
0
3
0
6
# 000373
06
7 7
7
3005390
033
730933
50
0
5
0
09703007870
9
0 8533
9743033
959 93 68309
0 09 0 0 9 9 997
34573 0
%
7 7 0 0 0
7
3
7400730 0
7
3533
00 7
690 4
359 00 09 0
306030097700 90
3
3
63
70357 093
0
0
7 6
9
0674
036
071
0&3
3
0 36 0 80730 5983590
7
59 003
(00790593
5030
7' 0 7
37
90 07893
7
9
59 003
0 003 79
7' )*0
7' 0
0
59 003
0
7
7 0
7
* 607 6
9
0 80730 8
!"7 30 9
+8 3
0 36 036760 00 670
4
4
7
3590"
033 6830 0 707 30 70
0
# 0
04573
3
0 6 0
3
3 7
7$ 07607 00
0 0"7
9 9 5
0 3
0
6
# 000
3
3
7 7
5 09
6
3005390
03 3
7309
373
0
0 0
5
0
0970
7 9
93007870 % 0457309 00 7
690
33
50
0 83 68370 3
740073
0
0 0
7
3533 306030
3
4
359 00 09 03
3
63
70 0
0
57 0930
03
3603600
97700 939 0
0
9
03
9
3 +8 3
6
9
0674
036
0
7 30 607 0 36 0 80730
0
7
5983590
7' (00790593
71
0&3
9 003
0 7
37
90 0
5
7
9
5030
7' 0 003 79
7893 9 003
0
0
59 0
5
7
7 0
03
)*0 0 930079090 343
7' 0 %3
0 9 03
03
93 0 0
7 0
7
7
7
3,7 -980
9
30 607 6
0 6 0
3603
08 3
0
4
67036
0 0
303 70 6 03
6
0730
879 9709
80
0
0
7
5
3
59
3 30
0 463
3
7 6 08 3
6
9
0 807300
3
0 607 0 36 036
4
7
37
90
30 9 3770 007359700
7905933 0 5
03 80
9
7
7
3
60
30 9045973709 0
56 3 036
050 7 6
0
8
7
3
5
7
57
/1 $ 0770
9
-976900 0
590004
530 36"0970073
8
. 0
0
7
03 5974
039 7 0 3003
5970 03 0 09
0 7430
93
0
0
7
09 093
7 0803
4700 90
3
0
0
10
01
20
356
0
0 0 900
44789
0
09
0 0
9
0 90
0 09! 0
0
9109
0
0
90 0$&$)'+-'0124 9
0
0 "#%& ( &, /'(3- 0090
'* .
!
90 09990 0
9
0 0 0 00 0 0 0
9
0! 0
0
0
0 0 0 9 0 0 00
9 9
0
0
00
0 9
0
9
00 ! 09
009
0
0
9
90 0
0 9 0 0099050
546 00
! 0 0
0
0
0700 :9 090
0
0
89
!
0
0
6 9489
0 9
0 0
0 00:09 90
6
0 0 9
0
0
0
90
!
0 700 9
0
:9
0
0 !09
0
9 0
9
09
00 94;0
900
00
0
0
9
0 9
0 0
0!
00
0 9 0 50 0 0 00 0
9
9 00 90 0 50
00900
!
0
0 90 0
0 0
9
09 0090 0 0
0 <00
0
0 8940
0
6 00
9
0 0
9 00
0
0 0 9 0
00 00 0
0 0 9 9
0 0 0
0
9 9
9
0! 0 0900 0
09
0 0 0 0
0 0
9 46
9
9
90 9
0 00 0 090
90
0 0 ! 99
0! 0 90
09
0 0
0 0 0 0
9
9
0
0 9
0
0 9 0 940
9 9
0
35= 0 9
0
0
447> 9 90
0
09
0 90
0
0
00
0 !0000
0
909 0 ?
0
0 99 ;
9
09
0090
9
0 009
0
9
0
9 0
09 90 0
00
! 9 09 0 00 0 0
9
9
!
! 0890
0
90 00
0 0 0
0
00
0
0 9
0
0
0 09
0 009
0
9
9
0909 90 0
09
9
0 0 00 0
0
9 9
0 0
9
000
48 9
9 0900 9 0 0 0 900
9
9
0
00 90 90
0
9 0 00
0 0
9 0
9
9
0:
9
0 009
0 0 0 0
9
0
9
0 0 0 9 9 894
0 0 0
9
0
3@ A
B
> 9 0
47 9 0 0
3@C 00
0 0 ! 000 90
447;08 0
90
0
9
00
0
900
0
9
0 009
0 990
9
B
D 0 5
090 9 0
0 0
89 0
0
E
00 0
09 0
0
0 8 0" 0 ! 0
0
10
01
20
0
4579 8
05
75075060660
68
7 0
009
66
60 5705
9
5
6 0 70
7507605975
0
55
9
500970 0
5 0
7 97
0
05
0
56900
80 975 0 579 05690
6
0 7
! 09
66
6!55
50 5
6070
750750
0 0 0 06
0 5
"
590 560
0
56900$ 05
0#5 05690
6 555 0
0
6
% (* -/ )2)2 4- )22 2 6.23221'-2
&')+,.0-1 .&/-0-1*5-5*)71 1:31 8.
3
1
89 3
06;$77<=
55
0 0
0
>?@ 9 555 905690
0
5 5
6070
==AB0 090
0
0
607 0 0 06
5
5 5"
508
550 6690
05
0
7 0
5
87477860 0 0
0
0
9
876090
0
07 80
70 70
9 605690
7 0
55
9
578 07 0900
6070
75"
5=
5 990
5
05 06 5 0
0
5
CE FGH LMIFH K
D
IJK NO
P2 Q2)2-:)*2)92 *92*22312292139)U219.T4SV
=A R ST4*24 1S+82 )1 T4S11:,9 1 2 %8423172
3
- 1 : 3 *8 9/ * 3
7500 5
0#5 05 90
0 090
556
690
560
0
7 0 57
70979!7 070
790905
576950
0 95 0 67 0
0 0 5
0
9
78
6
#5 6975
7975
05750W79
5650 00970 080976905 0
27
0
2?090 700$ 0565070
W79@?05
= 0 9 50 0 06"
50 05 0=0
@6 5
7
0$ 00070
5578 5X
1
0
0
0 555
06"
50 0$ 0 0 7
9
Y)*:0-1R 4-2 )9-1,S[4-282\841
0
.4- )2 2 -.Z*R.)992 .41-% 9.
* &/
31 U
Y)*:0-1V81T-42:Y]99&2--*2)2--R-2 (2)2
.4- )7232 T3:32 8^1 841_ .1 431403-3S
13
2
3 8
568
7906
W79?070
`5578
7 0579 6
9005 006"
5= 0$ 0
0
9
5X
1
0
5 5 5 7
500 !7 05
0 7
;96 90
0
0856 0 0
0
6
976070
6 7005a
67 905
5 090 906"
590 0 77 00
7
0
6
0
66099070
005 7
55505
0
50
78 6"
5=B 0
0
0$ 6 0
5
0
X
1
0
5 5
05055550
7
;96 950 50 00
6
5 0$
0 6 76 0
;96 5 9
6 057
790
5 90 0
7 0 0 =
0 5 78 0
P@ B090
06500 5
5 0
9
79 0907
=A
7 6
690 0 960
0
0
6
7
70979!7 070
7905
7678 5690
0 95 0 67 0
0 90 0 5
6
9
78
6
0
6
5
06"
509 5 7
08 50 05699
500070
0 0
0
5
0 5
00
!7
7
!05 7
0$ 05X
1
0
5 5 705
500 0
0
0 555 0 7
;96 900
7
6059055507 1
5 0
0
0660
7 51060 05
0 0 0 7
5 90
05"
5=b
5090
0
0
06500
7 6 750 0
0 5
67
0
6
6900907
70979!7 070
79 7
09
0
5
0
0 95 0 67 0
0 5
9
78
070
6
50 70>0509
06"
500
6"
50
5 920
6
070
0
6 0 !7
5
0
70
9
0
60 7 5
6
500 5
00
6"
50 0 7
7 09!0 0
05
699
0
5
7
0
0
1 31
00
20
354389
0 754 70
70641870 546
46009
0 4087 0 66 67 0 543 670
7 3 63
0
7603
3
0360
00545850 304 7603 404
06
7408706 0 68304 9336 7 0
8
3
3 7303594
679 74803 8"66#0
45
0 67 0 0 90350 69400
3
83
8!8
406"66#08706#5
06754 304
870
4 460 77 0 41870 6830
7
9336 896790376$67 087080
3 404
09 5867 0 0 8 47 7
0
5 7576 67 74803594
6790
6 860 0 %
0 69 67 0 0 90350 06
!8
83
83 7
3043 404
76 896 70 60
6830 9336 0 03 09 03
47& 0
0
0
7
900 0049 0936 0366793 730
8 858985380 76'0 0#0 8945
04
6
'
& 6
0
0 3
5 9 4003594
679 74806860
3 6306
67 0 0 90350 69 0 5
7
83
8!8
9 0(609
0 0 4 40004#506
6 4 45 0 0 643630088 87367 0
6
80
7
3
$67 0870634 006)7074660770
660
8 47 03777 60 6# 0 3 06
3 3 8
70 673763 7303594
679 7480
33%
00 045
0 67 0 0 90350 69
7
3
83
8!8
4 000 3043 404
8738
0 6830 9336 0
7
0
* 06667053806 300 3006006
7 0#0 857 9 4304 7% 04 % 57 0
8
6 7 3 3
9880087787097868
00 7480675
7 0 84080 4 8930 #0
6 7!869 860
7 3
7
0
3
5
803594
6796 76
9135404
67 0 0 90350 9 0 06 %60873 0
83
8
7
036 0
7 859
06+340 846 006 5
7
947 6 600 60 77 0 770 6673 030
0 6
7
0674 0 8460 540
7 0 300 65,46
6 7
0
-/ 012345 90:9
.
640788 5
;2 <0 9 08708067 !8697804860
6794
$
3 47 7 860 74800
67580350 0
5
83
679
00 080 748000
70
90350 037 67 67 7 698
803 67
88 3 !8
0674 0 ,4695006354034630 6 0
77 0 300 54
7 048
0
6 7
0
360806
670 748035 75503063 0 90
4#557 7037 30 69 06 86037
6
7
!8
800 930 60
84 7
0
6 0 0
;= 0 7480800(6750
#400 %
0009 307461
697 4 60 5 36 6738
80 7
!8 7 6
7
83
04#9 607460 4045
407604 530
9 7 7
3)3 730 34 30
0
6 6 83
08
3 730 869438 39030686700870
45
0
0 7480 04 7 0 57 0 50 84
3
3 3
3
>@A?DBFHJDDLMGPHSTJDDLQUOBDARDOEKBCH
?A C AG KEA BNOQR?HKEA BH CKOHH QBCPA
BE I B H
B
DP
F
3 6006
00780 3 7 890
45
57 03463069 7
045
0903
80
7 3
3 0
6 63076
6
7 68
8#4 30 39 709 5
4%5
04 4 03 700 60 4 760 0 06
860
3
7
3 0 6 8 37
6009 308#46745
0 50 70 673
4#9 0
805670 3 7 0 86
4
00
6 08
3
6 7
!86906
3300
0870
08709
748060 7 0 750 "66# 406"66# 4 89
7
8
7
0
3 7074006$
3 08706!869 70 76
80
494 77 0 9 47 0 7480 0
0 09
6 3
83
308#46745
60 506"66#087097
5670 3 7 0806860 57 0
4 8930
3
8
0
676!869300 044 4600 70 6
0 0 7480 4 436 70 760 54 06+340
8
9 3 3 7 0
0
1 21
00
20
0
455890 00 79 0700 97
56 0
677
76007 0 7 07 0 07 0
9
5 9
77
905909
5
905 57
8 50 57
0
50 90
67 00
00
5
6 7
7505 767
05 60 9067
05
0 90 0 0907 9909 0
7
9 0 8
5765500 75 77
0 9590
09 8090
8 50
7
5 0
" #$
509
89090 0 9005%
0
! 70
0 55
07
0 0
0
7 0
675
0
57
705
50 0 9 5 0
50 0
590 050
7 8
70 070
&55 00 0
0 7$
5'600 0
8 05%
0
5
0
0
" #$
509
65
5
7
70
0
70
( 70
0 5090 0 09690
9
0
7
901 578058 7
70
0950
9050
0 0 99
0 50 &07 0
&5
9 7
70
$
5
0
" *0700
5 50 05 &5 0 0
95
) 9 9605057 0 &087 0 00+7 0
7
7
8 7905
0$
50 695 695 %
7 00 070
07000 070
5
0
60
7057 70 67999-/139
7 0 9 0 90 9 067
0.02,0 0
5 0 7 7
, 2
4 68: 4 <>89A?A6=>8=?E=?B8B8A=8
70
54798 ;4=? >>8A BCD=>8B>8 74C9F6
5
7
@ 49 : : 4
0
57
50
0
0
G $4 H4H 0970II0IIIIIJ)
$0
0 II0 0 IIIII0 20
I
3
0
KLM
0
0
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII0
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
0
0
0 5
N
0
0
1 31
00
20
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1234 67
54 80
0
1 4563 46834
469814 1
7 43
23 721 9 3 9 43
3 1 814 1
3
4563 8863 9 43 2
453
1
2
3
0
0 / 0
00 0 0
0
0
/ "-00
0 '0
0
0
/ 114 53
0 23 *460
0 0 0 0 !#%& / 0
"$#'0 0
&
0
/0
0
(0
/0
0
0
/3
0
)0 *+0 0
)0
/
0
, 0 ,0 ,, %!0 /
0 ) ) 00 0 0
-"
0
/
0
0 0 0 0000--.$'0 /
0000 &$"% 0
0000
0
/
0
/
0
0
0
3
451 8
493
87
628
9
66243
: 6683 86241 493
3
21
1
86 0
0
0
1; <=4"%0@@@@@@@@@@@@0--?B/0'$'%0-%= 0
#.>=?@@@@@@@@@@@@ =A0#0 $-%0 % 0 D'
<
C 0< EGIFKJMJHPQRPGTJNGFKUVEGWJPLPYSPHLP[ GS]EH
FHJGLFHNOH SPH FKPL KHFHSLIK H GS OHYSP\^M
K L
EL
X Z
H
-%=.A0- 0= $0#00'$'%0-`='#%$00- 0=0 = _>''00
$--0?% 0 _%".B/ $-%0 % 0 #.C# 0&<0 _%00 =0-0&
< 0 # C 0< _ 0 %
&>
-&=#a%-%= 0&<0 .=0
$0C$0 0 D'00-=-
<- %
0
b; c?--_#a%#0 #. "%0 .=- $ <0#.>=?"=-00A.0
0dC% 0 '<=4 =?$0'D-%%-%=4"%0a-'%"#$<
0 <
0
A0-%= 0$00.%$0&<0 .=0
?% 0 D'".C$#0'00-=-
<# %
0
0
13 4508 0
0
0
8
967676
9696
0
2 67 9
60 7
45870 86 0 0 0 0
0
6
5
5 5
77006862
60 85
7 0 80
5 0
0
960
860 6
0
767 8
0
77 !0
70 60 0
46650
"#60
$%
"
9
0 0
6
60 8
800
"0 807
45
&60
7 0
0
60
78 0
0
0
0
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
