Hughes et al v. Lumpkin
Filing
57
Memorandum of Opinion and Order For the reasons set forth herein, Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorney Fees and Costs (ECF No. 53 ) is granted in part and denied in part. The adjusted lodestar amount in fees that Plaintiffs are awarded is &# 036;62,040.50. Furthermore, the Court orders that Plaintiffs be reimbursed for $1,832.81 in costs. Judge Benita Y. Pearson on 9/30/2015. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A: Plaintiffs' Itemized Time and Expense Records with hours that have been excluded highlighted) (JLG)
<![CDATA[
Exhibit A
Browning & Meyer Co., LPA
300 W. Wilson Bridge Road
Suite 250
Worthington, OH 43085
Ph: 614-471-0085
Fax:614-430-8132
Sandra Cleaver, Esq.
4917 Munson St., N.W.
P.O. Box 35007
Canto,n, OH 44735
May 30, 2014
File#:
Inv#:
Attention:
RE:
4987-litm
35107
Medicaid Litigation for Carole L. Hughes
DATE
Jun-29-10
Jul-19-10
Jul-20-10
Jul-29-10
Aug-10-10
Aug-11-10
DESCRIPTION
HOURS
1.70
Conference call with Akron
counsel; work on Complaint;
conference with law clerk
4.70
Prepare complaint and conduct
legal research; develop factual
recitations for both Hughes and
Bardin plaintiffs
3.10
Prepare complaint for declaratory
and injunctive relief for us district
court northern district of Ohio for
both Hughes and Bardin, combined
complaint, with legal research.
2.40
Second draft of complaint
including specific IRA sections and
fourth cause of action for violation
of equal protection clause; requisite
legal research regarding same
3.60
Prepare exhibits; redact exhibits;
cite-check all statutes, print, tab,
and submit to Attorney Browning
for final review; contact Cleaver's
office to retrieve denial notice; final
edit of complaint;
0.60
Review complaint; meeting with
Attorney Browning
5.70
Work on final version of federal
court complaint; Revise Motion for
Stay; Draft Common Pleas Court
brief
RATE AMOUNT
$435.00
739.50
LAWYER
WJB
$125.00
587.50
DSB
$125.00
387.50
DSB
$125.00
300.00
DSB
$125.00
450.00
DSB
$435.00
261.00
RFM
$435.00
2,479.50
WJB
Invoice#:
35107
Page 2
Final preparations of complaint;
final changes; preparation of
Motion to Stay Administrative
Appeal; research for Common
Pleas Brief; preparation of other
briefs for Attorney Browning to
reference as he drafts the common
pleas brief
Work on Common Pleas Court
Brief
Application for Admission to
Northern District of Ohio
Draft letter to AG concerning
stipulations
Review and save time stamped
copy of filed Complaint
Review of Memorandum Contrary
Stay and Brief; Work on Reply
Memorandum
Work on Reply Brief
May 30, 2014
Aug-17-10
Aug-18-10
Aug-24-10
Sep-24-10
Oct-05-10
Nov-19-10
Nov-22-10
Nov-23-10
Nov-29-10
Nov-30-10
Dec-01-10
Dec-02-10
Dec-03-10
$125.00
562.50
DSB
2.40
$435.00
1,044.00
WJB
1.10
$125.00
137.50
DSB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
0.30
$125.00
37.50
DSB
1.90
$435.00
826.50
WJB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
WJB
Work on Reply Brief
Aug-12-10
4.50
0.50
$125.00
62.50
DSB
Draft memo in opposition to
motion to dismiss
Conference with law clerk
concerning 2 Memorandum
Strategy
Work on Memorandum Contra;
Review of Rorick decision
Draft merits of memo & opposition
& motion for summary judgment
Work on Merits portion of memo in
opposition
Work on Memorandum Contra
7.30
$125.00
912.50
DSB
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
0.90
$435.00
391.50
WJB
5.00
$125.00
625.00
DSB
7.00
$125.00
875.00
DSB
0.90
$435.00
391.50
WJB
1.80
$435.00
783.00
WJB
3.10
$125.00
387.50
DSB
2.90
$125.00
362.50
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
Work on Memorandum Contra;
Conference with law clerk
Continue work on memorandum in
opposition, particularly the merits
and incorporating Attorney
Browning's changes; inserting
pincites to the record
Final review and revise of memo
in opposition, submission to
Attorney Browning
Review final version of Memo for
file; meeting
Invoice#:
Feb-01-11
35107
Page 3
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
0.70
$125.00
87.50
DSB
1.80
$125.00
225.00
DSB
0.30
$125.00
37.50
DSB
1.00
$125.00
125.00
DSB
0.40
$435.00
174.00
WJB
0.30
$435.00
130.50
WJB
1.30
$435.00
565.50
WJB
0.40
$435.00
174.00
WJB
0.20
$125.00
25.00
DSB
0.70
$125.00
87.50
DSB
0.60
$125.00
75.00
DSB
0.30
$125.00
37.50
DSB
0.40
$125.00
50.00
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
WJB
Nov-30-11
Docket report to Cleary Law
Offices
Draft Supplemental Authority
Notice
Finalize notice of supplemental
authority
File Notice of Supplemental
Authority
Emailing 'Samantha Baum at
Cleaver Law Office
Telephone conference S. Wright;
Work assignment to law clerk
contact court; draft letter to T.
Semple
Draft letter to Nursing Home
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
Dec-01-11
Revise letter to T. Semple
0.20
$435.00
87.00
WJB
Dec-07-11
Call court to determine how a
status conference or hearing can be
established.
Arrange telephone conference with
attorneys and Attorney Browning
0.30
$125.00
37.50
DSA
0.40
$205.00
82.00
DSB
Mar-16-11
Apr-20-11
Apr-22-11
Apr-26-11
Jun-03-11
Jun-10-11
Jun-21-11
Jun-24-11
Aug-31-11
Sep-01-11
Oct-31-11
Nov-02-11
Nov-04-11
Nov-21-11
Nov-29-11
Jan-30-12
Review of pleadings and strategy;
Review of new assignment;
Telephone conference with Sandra
Cleaver concerning status
Prepare notice of additional case
authority Bernard v. Kansas Health
Policy Authority.
Review email from Mark Fowler
regarding motion for Status
Conference and draft motion for
submission accordingly
Notice of Supplemental Authority
review from Attorney Browning,
ready to file
Review order on motion and
calendar status conference
Telephone conference with S.
Wright and S. Cleaver
Telephone conference with T.
Semple
Prepare for Status Conference;
attend status conference by phone
Telephone conference with
co-counsel
Check docket, status
May30, 2014
Invoice#:
Feb-27-12
Feb-29-12
Mar-06-12
Mar-08-12
Mar-13-12
Mar-15-12
Apr-16-12
Apr-25-12
May-03-12
May-10-12
May-11-12
May-14-12
Jun-04-12
Jun-05-12
Jun-06-12
Jun-18-12
Jun-21-12
35107
May 30, 2014
Page 4
0.60
$435.00
261.00
RFM
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
3.20
$205.00
656.00
DSB
Review of 1st draft of Motion for
Injunctive Relief
Work on injunction
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
1.40
$205.00
287.00
DSB
Work on letter to Ms. Cleaver and
Mr. Wright regarding injunction
Telephone conference with Sandra
Cleaver
Review of status of filing of
Motion
Work on Hughes/Bardin Motion for
Injunction
Review of order from court;
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning summary memorandwn
Review court order; draft
supplemental memoranda; meet
with Attorney Browning; research
Review of Memorandum in
Support
Proof reading Attorney Banas'
memorandum.
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning filing of brief; Review
of briefs filed by the AG
File Memorandwn; Review ODJFS'
Pleading
Email Stephan Wright analysis
memo regarding decision
Review of decision; start outline of
potential appeal issues
Email correspondence with Sue
Sokolowski
Telephone conference with
co-counsel concerning 6th Circuit
appeal
Teleconference with co-counsel
concerning 6th Circuit appeal
E-file appeal transcript request;
Email correspondence with
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
0.30
$435.00
130.50
WJB
4.00
$205.00
820.00
DSB
0.60
$435.00
261.00
WJB
3.80
$205.00
779.00
DSB
0.90
$435.00
391.50
WJB
0.60
$125.00
75.00
DSA
1.50
$435.00
652.50
WJB
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
0.60
$205.00
123.00
DSB
1.60
$435.00
696.00
WJB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
1.00
$205.00
205.00
DSB
1.80
$205.00
369.00
DSB
Discussion with Associate on
injunctive relief
Meeting with Attorney regarding
briefs
Research and work on injunctive
relief
Work on injunction and affidavits
Invoice#:
Jun-28-12
Jul-09-12
Jul-10-12
Jul-12-12
Jul-18-12
Jul-20-12
Jul-23-12
Jul-24-12
Jul-25-12
Jul-30-12
Jul-31-12
Aug-01-12
Aug-02-12
Aug-03-12
Aug-04-12
35107
Page
5
Attorney Browning; file Notice of
Appeal
Email correspondence with
Attorney Browning; calendar
docket & briefing schedule; Email
correspondence with Sandra
Cleaver
Email correspondence with
Attorney Browning
File Notice of Appearance; Civil
Appeal Statement; Corporate
Disclosure
Draft letter to NSCLC and AARP;
draft motion for OSBA
Email correspondence with
Attorney Browning
Email correspondence with Sandra
Cleaver
Email correspondence with
receptionist
Retrieve Morris Brief from Pacer;
Outline Local Rules
Email correspondence with
receptionist
Download Appellants/Appellee's
Briefs and Amicus Curiae Brief,
scanning documents to file, and
printing for Attorney Banas.
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning Amicus filings
Review and revise Amicus request
letters; contact AARP, NSCLC, and
NAELA; Revise Motion to Elder
Law Committee; Prepare letters for
mailing with exhibits; Email
correspondence with Attorney
Browning; Amicus requests
Review Motion for OSBA to file
Amicus brief; discussion with
OSBA on procedures, filing and all
other matters
Conference call with S. Cleaver
Draft Hughes Brief for appeal;
research local rules; Draft Hughes
Brief
Draft letter to client outlining
litigation process; draft memo
May 30, 2014
0.50
$205.00
102.50
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.00
$205.00
205.00
DSB
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.40
$205.00
287.00
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.10
$125.00
137.50
DSA
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
2.20
$205.00
451.00
DSB
1.80
$435.00
783.00
RFM
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
3.50
$205.00
717.50
DSB
1.30
$435.00
565.50
WJB
Invoice#:
Aug-06-12
Aug-07-12
Aug-08-12
Aug-13-12
Aug-15-12
Aug-17-12
Aug-20-12
Aug-21-12
Aug-22-12
35107
Page 6
concerning policy issues for amicus
and our brief
Draft Appellate Brief; Mediation
Background Information Due;
prepare and file; contact clerk
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning status of brief and
overview of policy arguments
Email correspondence with
Attorney Browning
Research private verses public
pension funds for Attorney Banas.
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach; Drafting brief
Work on Brief; attend Mediation
conference call
Mediation telephone conference;
Per Mediation Conference Notice:
Debra Chernocki mediator.
Conference call with AARP and
NSCLC attorneys
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach; Email correspondence
with Stacy Canan
Call clerk of court; draft suggestion
of death; print out entire docket
from Northern District of Ohio.
Telephone conference with Rene
Reixach; File Suggestion of Death
and Notice of Withdrawal of
Appeal; Email correspondence with
Rene H. Reixach.
Review of Morris decision in
greater detail
Conference with Attorney Banas;
work on brief
Print off entire docket for Attorney
Banas. Draft Voluntary Dismissal
of Lester and Thelma Bardin and
provide to Attorney Banas.
Work on brief
Draft suggestion of death, voluntary
dismissal, proofread appellate brief
for Attorney Banas.
Proofread Appellate brief for
Attorney Banas.
Email correspondence with
Kenneth Zeller; Email
May 30, 2014
5.10
$205.00
1,045.50
DSB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
0.40
$205.00
82.00
DSB
3.40
$125.00
425.00
DSA
3.10
$205.00
635.50
DSB
2.10
$435.00
913.50
WJB
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
WJB
0.50
$205.00
102.50
DSB
2.00
$125.00
250.00
DSA
1.20
$205.00
246.00
DSB
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
1.20
$435.00
522.00
WJB
2.00
$125.00
250.00
DSA
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
1.00
$125.00
125.00
DSA
2.90
$125.00
362.50
DSA
0.60
$205.00
123.00
DSB
Invoice#:
Aug-24-12
Aug-27-12
Aug-29-12
Aug-31-12
Sep-04-12
Sep-20-12
Oct-01-12
Oct-10-12
Oct-17-12
Oct-18-12
Oct-19-12
Oct-21-12
35107
Page 7
correspondence with Rene H.
Reixach.
Email correspondence with Eric
Carlson of NSCLC regarding
Amicus; Email correspondence
with Kenneth Zeller of AARP;
Draft Brief
Work on brief
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning revisions to brief
Call 6th circuit clerk of court for
Attorney Banas.
Discussion with Attorney
Browning; Prepare Brief for Filing
File Appellant's Brief & Appendix;
Send copies to Amicus and Clients
and their counsel; Email
correspondence with Jessica Emch
regarding Anlicus effort & OSBA;
Email correspondence with
Attorney Meyer regarding OSBA
amicus effort; Email ·
correspondence with Rene H.
Reixach regarding IRA annuity and
no transfer
All matters regarding OSBA
approval; meetings, review of
proposals
Telephone conference with R.
Thomas concerning extension
Review emails; meetings with
Attorney
Review of Administrative appeal
decision summaries; memo to
Attorney Banas
Email correspondence with
Attorney Meyer
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach and Attorney Browning
Draft Reply Brief; Review
Appellee's Brief
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach and Attorney Browning
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach
Review of state's brief
May 30, 2014
4.70
$205.00
963.50
DSB
I.IO
$435.00
478.50
WJB
LOO
$435.00
435.00
WJB
0.20
$125.00
25.00
DSA
6.30
$205.00
1,291.50
DSB
3.90
$205.00
799.50
DSB
2.10
$435.00
913.50
RFM
0.30
$435.00
130.50
WJB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.30
$435.00
565.50
WJB
Invoice#:
Oct-22-12
35107
Page 8
May 30, 2014
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
Oct-25-12
Continue review of state's brief;
Telephone conference with
Attorney Banas
Work on Reply Brief
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
Oct-30-12
Work on Reply Brief
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
Nov-01-12
Prepare Bluebook citations for
Attorney Banas.
Proofread appeal for Attorney
Barias.
Review and Revise Reply Brief;
Research; discuss with Attorney
Browning; Submit
Draft letter to client and Sandra
Cleaver, Esq.
Hughes Prep for Attorney
Browning
Start preparations for oral
arguments
Preparations for Oral Arguments
0.60
$125.00
75.00
DSA
1.10
$125.00
137.50
DSA
3.50
$205.00
717.50
DSB
0.30
$435.00
130.50
WJB
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
1.70
$435.00
739.50
WJB
2.00
$435.00
870.00
WJB
Meeting with Attorney Browning to
discuss oral arguments
Continue preparations
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
1.50
$435.00
652.50
WJB
Continued preparations for oral
arguments
Continue preparations
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
3.00
$435.00
1,305.00
WJB
0.80
$205.00
164.00
DSB
3.10
$435.00
1,348.50
WJB
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
Mar-14-13
Final preparations; attend oral
arguments
Email correspondence with Rene
H. Reixach
Continue analysis for Supplemental
Brief
Draft memo to Attorney Banas;
Telephone conference with Sandra
concerning status
Draft Supplemental Brief
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
Mar-15-13
Research for Attorney Banas.
1.60
$205.00
328.00
DSA
Mar-18-13
Draft Supplemental Brief
3.10
$205.00
635.50
DSB
Mar-19-13
Work on Supplemental Brief
0.90
$435.00
391.50
WJB
Revise Supplemental Brief
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
Nov-02-12
Jan-15-13
Feb-06-13
Feb-12-13
Feb-14-13
Feb-15-13
Feb-27-13
Mar-02-13
Mar-04-13
Mar-07-13
Mar-08-13
Mar-11-13
Invoice#:
Mar-20-13
35107
Page 9
May 30, 2014
Work on Supplemental Brief
1.70
$435.00
739.50
WJB
Revise Hughes Supplemental Brief
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
Mar-21-13
File Supplemental Brief
0.80
$205.00
164.00
DSB
Mar-22-13
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
1.20
$205.00
246.00
DSB
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
Aug-07-13
Email correspondence with
Attorney Browning
Review of March through June
related decisions; memo to
Attorney Banas
Draft Citation of Support
Authorities
Work on 2nd Draft Hughes
Supplemental Brief
Draft Hughes Brief
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
Aug-09-13
Work Supplemental Brief
1.00
$435.00
435.00
WJB
Aug-12-13
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning brief
Review Attorney Browning's edits
and revisions to Supplemental Brief
Draft; Discuss with Attorney
Browning addition of section
describing annuities and how they
work; research file
Review Supplemental Brief;
comments to Attorney Banas
Review and Revise Supplemental
Brief
Read and proofread brief for
Attorney Banas.
Work on Brief and Annuity
explanation
Revise and revise Supplemental
Brief
Work on Brief; Conference with
Attorney Banas
Review brief for Attorney Banas.
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
1.70
$205.00
348.50
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
4.60
$205.00
943.00
DSB
1.90
$205.00
389.50
DSA
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
3.20
$205.00
656.00
DSB
2.70
$435.00
1,174.50
WJB
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSA
Final revisions to brief
0.40
$435.00
174.00
WJB
Proofread appeals brief for
Attorney Banas.
Submit Hughes Brief
0.50
$205.00
.102.50
DSA
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
Jul-24-13
Jul-26-13
Aug-06-13
Aug-13-13
Aug-14-13
Aug-15-13
Aug-16-13
Aug-19-13
Invoice#:
35107
Page
IO
May 30, 2014
Aug-20-13
Review State's Supplemental Brief
1.00
$205.00
205.00
DSB
Aug-21-13
Review of State's Final Brief
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
Oct-26-13
0.60
$205.00
123.00
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
1.90
$205.00
389.50
DSB
Dec-23-13
Review decision; email
correspondence with Attorney
Browning
Meeting with Attorney Browning
regarding decision
Review of 6th Circuit decision;
outline actions to pursue with
District Court
Contact Sandra Cleaver; email
decision
Research federal rules of procedure
regarding en bane review; remand
procedure
Attend Status Conference
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
Feb-05-14
Begin Hughes Brief drafting
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
Feb-06-14
Drafting opposition to petition for
cert; research supreme court rules;
contact publisher; draft opposition
to cert petition
Work on Response to Writ for Cert
4.00
$205.00
820.00
DSB
1.20
$435.00
522.00
WJB
Work on Memorandum Contra
Cert.; Conference with Attorney
Banas
Work on Memorandum Contra Cert
1.80
$435.00
783.00
WJB
1.30
$435.00
565.50
WJB
1.10
$205.00
225.50
DSA
Feb-21-14
Review brief; Meet with Attorney
Banas regarding brief.
Final proofread.
0.60
$205.00
123.00
DSA
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
Feb-24-14
Work on Opposition to Petition for
Writ of Certiorari
Review Brief Proof from Cockle
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
Feb-25-14
Reply to Cockle with revisions
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
Feb-27-14
Contact publisher to confirm
delivery
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning order from court and
avoidance of remand to ODJFS
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
Oct-28-13
Nov-08-13
Feb-11-14
Feb-17-14
Feb-18-14
Feb-20-14
Mar-07-14
Invoice#:
Mar-13-14
Apr-01-14
Apr-07-14
Apr-10-14
May-02-14
35107
Page
11
Discuss proposed Order in
Common Pleas with Attorney
Browning
Review of State's Reply to US
Supreme Court
Discussion with Attorney Browning
regarding Hughes Case and
ongoing litigation
Discuss request for State to
withdraw appeal
Conference with J. Pecquet
concerning ongoing annuity
litigation and compliance with
Hughes
Draft letter to AG concerning
compliance with decision
May 30, 2014
0.20
$205.00
41.00.
DSB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
RFM
0.20
$205.00
41.00
DSB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
272.80
Totals
DISBURSEMENTS
Mar-07-13
Feb-25-14
Mar-21-14
$71,173.00
Disbursements
Mileage to U.S. 6th Circuit Court - 117.52 X 2
X.55
Lodging
Professional Services
Publication of Brief
Totals
Receipts
129.27
624.62
287.32
325.00
$1,366.21
Total Fees & Disbursements
$0.00
$72,539.21
Previous Balance
Previous Payments
$0.00
$0.00
Balance Due Now
$72,539.21
Please remit to Browning & Meyer Co. LPA.
Please include the File # on the check. Thank you.
Payment by Mastercard, Visa and Discover is now available for your convenience. Please
contact Marcy at (614) 471-0085 or (866) 88-ELDER if you would like to use this service.
Browning & Meyer Co., LPA
300 W. Wilson Bridge Road
Suite 250
Worthington, OH 43085
Ph: 614-471-0085
Fax:614-430-8132
Sandra Cleaver, Esq.
4917 Munson St., N.W.
P.O. Box 35007
Canton, OH 44735
November 4, 2014
File#:
Inv#:
Attention:
RE:
Medicaid Litigation for Carole L. Hughes
DATE
Jun-04-14
DESCRIPTION
Review of compliance issues
Jun-09-14
Continue work on Injunctive
measures; continue review of
proposed relief; Review of 5-24-14
Administrative Appeal decision
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning parameters for motion
for injunctive relief
Meeting with Attorney Browning
regarding Motion for Injunctive
Relief
Meeting with Attorney Browning
regarding file
Conference with Attorney Banas
and Attorney Meyer concerning
grand writs and proposed order
Meeting with Attorney Browning
regarding proposed order
Review of constitutional issues;
review of compliance and 209b
issues; meeting with Attorney
Banas concerning motion
Meeting with Attorney Browning to
discuss Hughes
Draft Motion for Injunction
Jun-10-14
Jun-11-14
Jun-12-14
Jun-25-14
Jun-26-14
4987-litm
36204
Work on Motion for Injunctive
Relief
HOURS
0.40
RATE AMOUNT
$435.00
174.00
LAWYER
WJB
1.80
$435.00
783.00
WJB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
0.70
$205.00
143.50
DSB
0.50
$435.00
217.50
RFM
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
0.50
$205.00
102.50
DSB
2.70
$435.00
1,174.50
WJB
1.50
$205.00
307.50
DSB
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
1.10
$435.00
478.50
WJB
Invoice#:
Jun-27-14
Jun-30-14
Jul-17-14
36204
Page 2
Telephone conference with R.
Goodman, Esq. Concerning
administrative appeal decision
ignoring Hughes; Review of
decision; conference with Attorney
Banas concerning Wagner decision
Prepare for status conference;
attend telephone status conference
Attend telephone Status Conference
November 4, 2014
1.60
$435.00
696.00
WJB
1.60
$435.00
696.00
WJB
1.60
$205.00
328.00
DSB
0.90
$435.00
391.50
WJB
Jul-29-14
Aug-13-14
Sep-16-14
Oct-01-14
Oct-18-14
Oct-21-14
Oct-22-14
Oct-23-14
Oct-24-14
0.90
$205.00
184.50
DSB
3.70
$435.00
1,609.50
WJB
1.00
$205.00
205.00
DSB
3.10
$435.00
1,348.50
WJB
Finish Work on Hughes Reply
Jul-25-14
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning state hearing decisions
and reply
Conference with Attoney Browning
regarding Reply memorandum
Review of Immel arguments with
Attorney Banas; Work on Reply
Memorandum
Meeting with Attorney Browning;
review of Immel arguments
Work on Reply Brief
2.50
$205.00
512.50
DSB
Conference with Attorney Banas to
discuss status and hearing strategy
Conference with Attorney
Browning to discuss strategy
Start preparation for Oral Hearing;
Outline probable witnesses
Review of injunction strategy in
light of Wagner injunction
Continue preparation for hearing;
review of AG's supplemental
authority
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning proposed entries
Prepare for Oral Argument and
Draft Proposed Entries; meeting
with Attorney Browning
Continue preparation for hearing
0.50
$435.00
217.50
WJB
0.50
$205.00
102.50
DSB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
WJB
0.80
$435.00
348.00
WJB
2.30
$435.00
1,000.50
WJB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
3.00
$205.00
615.00
DSB
0.70
$435.00
304.50
WJB
Draft Hughes Supplemental Filing;
Prepare for efiling·
Prepare for Hearing, research
Edelman case; travel
Travel to Youngstown; attend
hearing
2.00
$205.00
410.00
DSB
4.00
$205.00
820.00
DSB
7.00
$435.00
3,045.00
WJB
Invoice#:
36204
Page
3
November 4, 2014
Travel; Attend Hearing
Oct-27-14
7.00
$205.00
1,435.00
DSB
Conference with Attorney Banas
concerning efforts necessary to
conclude action in ND of Ohio
Discuss hearing and strategy going
forward with Attorney Browning
0.30
$435.00
130.50
WIB
0.30
$205.00
61.50
DSB
59.70
Totals
DISBURSEMENTS
Oct-17-14
Filing Fee - Hughes
Mileage - 310 X .56 Atty. Browning
Oct-24-14
Mileage - 310 X .56 - Attorney Banas
$19,529.50
Receipts
$466.60
Totals
Disbursements
120.00
173.00
173.60
$0.00
Total Fees & Disbursements
$19,996.10
Previous Balance
$72,539.21
Previous Payments
$0.00
Balance Due Now
$92,535.31
Please remit to Browning & Meyer Co. LPA.
Please include the File # on the check. Thank you.
Payment by Mastercard, Visa and Discover is now available for your convenience. Please
conta~arcy at (614) 471-0085 or (866) 88-ELDER ify ou would like to use this service.
_
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
