Northeastern University et al v. Google, Inc.,

Filing 160

NOTICE by Google, Inc., re 127 Notice of Disclosure Objections to Plaintiffs' Pre-Trial Disclosures (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Duarte, Enrique)

Northeastern University et al v. Google, Inc.,

Doc. 160 Att. 1

ATTACHMENT A: DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

- Page 1

Dockets.Justia.com

OBJECTION KEY TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS Abbreviation 106 402 403 602 701 801 802 805 A/C AA AF AR BER CQ CS E F IA IQ MC OS V WC Objection F.R.E. 106 F.R.E. 402 F.R.E. 403 F.R.E. 602 F.R.E. 701 F.R.E. 801 F.R.E. 802 F.R.E. 805 Attorney Client Privilege and/or Work Product Immunity Asked and Answered Assumes Fact(s) not in evidence Argumentative Best Evidence Rule (F.R.E. 1002) Compound Question Calls for Speculation Expert testimony from a person who was not designated as an expert and who did not submit an expert report Lacks Foundation Incomplete Answer Incomplete Question Mischaracterizes witness's testimony Outside the Scope of Rule 30(b)(6) topics Vague Waste of time/Cumulative evidence

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 2

BILL COUGHRAN (taken on February 4, 2011) Plaintiffs Designations 10:16-25 17:16-18:11 19:18-20 20:2-3 20:6-21:3 21:8-22:7 22:12-14 23:10-15 24:12-15 24:19 25:14-22 26:24-27:7 28:9-29:22 30:23-31:22 32:14-33:10 33:15-24 34:3-5 34:7-10 34:12-15 34:17-21 35:7-13 35:15-18 36:3-7 36:23-37:12 37:21-38:9 39:3-8 39:10-12 39:14-40:3 40:23-25 41:2 44:21-25 47:16-25 48:5-10 48:25-49:2 49:12-19 50:19-23 51:11-17 52:3-18 54:13-56:7 60:9-61:7 61:12-15 64:17-65:8 69:18-70:16 Google Objections to Designations 106 106 106, MC, AR 106, MC, AR 402, 403 402, 403, MC, AR V 106 106, V 106 106, V, MC, AA 106 106, 602, CS 602, CS 602, 801, 802, CS 106 V, AR V, AR V, AR, AA 106, V, AR, AA V, AR, AA V, AR, AA 602, CS 106 106 402, 403, 701, V, AF, CS 402, 403, 701, V, AF, CS 602, CS, BER, IA V, CS, BER, IA V, CS, BER, IA 106 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 106, 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 106 106 V 106 402, 403, 601, 701, 802

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 3

Plaintiffs Designations 70:22-23 84:16-85:9 86:18-21 86:25-89:2 89:7-15 92:6-17 93:22-94:22 95:1-96:19 102:11-103:14 105:16-107:11 117:14-19 119:7-18 120:2-6 121:20 121:22-122:1 122:6-11 123:2-125:24 126:20-127:8 128:4-129:14 131:3-133:4 133:10-134:4 134:13-136:3 138:21-139:21 140:17-22 140:25-141:11 Counter-Designations 11:1-9 18:12-19 19:2-5, 7-16 23:5-9 24:16-18 25:5-13 27:8-10 29:23-30:1 33:25-34:2 34:25-35:4 37:13-16 38:10-13 45:1-4 51:5-10 53:17-54:6 56:17-57:8 61:8-11 65:9-17 70:25-71:3

Google Objections to Designations 106, CS, V 106 106 402, 403, CS, V 402, 403 106 402, 403 602, CS AA, AR, MC 106 A/C A/C A/C 106 A/C A/C 402, 403, OS 402, 403, OS 106 602, CS 106 106, AR, AA AR, AA 602, CS A/C, 602, CS

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 4

71:5-12 82:25-83:7 84:5-15 86:22-24 92:18-19 107:12-24 108:13-21 121:17-19 129:15-23 134:5-12 136:4-13 SUNIL DALUVOY (taken on December 7, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 16:11-15 17:6-18:19 19:8-11 31:20-22 36:4-37:4 43:11-44:10 54:9-23 59:4-60:2 61:2-18 65:18-66:8 71:20-73:12 74:10-17 83:9-85:22 86:4-19 98:25-99:3 101:21-102:16 106:19-107:1 114:3-115:22 116:17-23 117:5-118:18 130:12-20 131:22-132:6 132:13-16 132:20-133:1 141:5-23 147:12-19 152:1-11 Google Objections to Designations 106 106 106, 403, V 106, 402, 403 106 402, 403, V, MC 106 106, V, CS, IA V V 402, 403, V, MC, AR, AF 106, V V, MC, AR, AF, F 106, 402, 403, 602 106, 402, 403, 602 402, 403, 602, V, MC 106 602, 701, CS, V, AR, E, OS 602, 701, CS, V, E, OS 602, 701, CS, V, E, AF, F, OS V, AA, AF 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS 602, CS, V, OS 602, CS, V, OS 106, 402, 403, 602, CQ, CS, V, OS

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 5

Plaintiffs Designations 159:2-160:6 163:23-164:8 164:22-167:19 Counter-Designations 16:16-17:1 18:20-22 19:12-23 30:18-23 35:7-36:3 37:5-12 38:10-39:4 60:4-11 66:10-24 67:4-8 67:10-68:13 99:3-23 107:2-4 153:17-154:23 161:5-11

Google Objections to Designations 402, 403, 602, CQ, CS, V, OS 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS

DR. JEFFREY DEAN (taken on November 2, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 10:13-18 10:24-11:3 11:8-12 11:15-25 12:5-18 12:22-25 13:5-9 29:6-16 31:21-32:6 36:14-17 47:15-49:2 51:1-13 60:15-61:4 114:13-25 115:7-18 117:9-12 119:15-23 Google Objections to Designations 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 V, CQ 106 402, 403 106 OS 106 106 106 106, 402, 403, V, CQ, OS

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 6

Plaintiffs Designations 156:25-157:5 181:11-182:5 186:11-187:1 194:1-22 Counter-Designations 10:19-22 11:4-6 11:13 12:1-3 12:19-20 13:1-3 13:10 24:7-9 29:17-21 36:18-20 49:17-50:25 114:4-12 115:1-6 115:19-24 117:13-118:1 118:17-19 118:21-119:3 157:6-18 158:7-10

Google Objections to Designations 106 602, CS, OS 602, CS, OS 402, 403, 602, CS, V, OS

DR. NADAV EIRON (taken on May 12, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 25:17-26:15 28:2-12 50:15-18 64:22-66:7 74:4-9 79:20-22 91:4-17 105:18-106:2 114:11-13 118:11-18 122:23-123:8 130:14-18 133:25-134:9 169:20-170:19 Google Objections to Designations 106 602, CS, V 602, CS, V 106 106 106 106 106 106, IA 106 106, IA 106 106, IA 106

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 7

Plaintiffs Designations 171:1-9 209:14-19 213:3-18 214:17-215:12 217:21-24 222:23-224:8 228:4-7 228:9-11 232:18-19 242:4-11 246:4-7 246:15-18 255:21-256:6 257:17-22 260:15-261:16 273:19-20 274:10-12 Counter-Designations 26:16-20 27:9-14 66:8-67:4 68:4-5 73:17-74:3 75:1-8 79:1-7 79:23-80:9 105:10-17 106:3-22 114:14-18 118:7-10 123:9-12 130:19-131:4 134:10-18 170:20-24 171:10-14 225:1-18 242:12-25 255:8-14 257:23-24 258:1-15 273:3-18 273:22-274:6 274:13-17

Google Objections to Designations 106, IA 402, 403 V, CS, AF, F V 602, V, AA, CS, OS 106, 402, 403, 602, CS 602, CS 602, CS 402, 403 106, IA 403, 701, E, OS 403, 701, E, OS 106 106, 403, 701, E, OS 403, 701, E, OS 106, IQ, IA 106, IA

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 8

DR. URS HOELZLE (taken on November 4, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 54:10-24 57:13-15 91:17-92:15 104:18-105:24 106:17-23 121:16-123:9 128:15-24 139:6-23 140:9-141:8 149:25-150:20 171:23-172:11 173:4-25 174:16-176:2 176:21-178:4 181:8-182:10 187:24-188:10 Counter-Designations 33:23-36:14 36:16-37:17 51:4-53:13 105:15-24 106:3-16 KAUSTUV (taken on December 3, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 7:24-8:4 22:4-15 27:7-22 31:4-32:10 36:25-38:2 49:11-16 58:5-8 76:24-77:15 77:17-78:1 89:3-92:24 99:6-100:2 136:2-15 136:21-139:8 142:8-16 152:11-25 Google Objections to Designations IQ 402, 403, V, CS 402, 403 602, V, CS, OS 106, IQ 602, V, CS, AF, F 602, V, CQ, CS, AF, F 402, 403, V, MC 402, 403, V, MC 106, IA 106 106, 602, CS, AF, F, OS, IQ, IA 602, CS, AA, AF, F, OS 602, CS, AA, AF, F, OS 106, AA, WC Google Objections to Designations 106, V 106, V 402, 403 106, V, IA 106 402, 403 602, CS 106, V 106, V 403, V 402, 403, OS, V 402, 403 402, 403, V 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 9

Plaintiffs Designations 153:7-154:9 Counter-Designations 7:21-23 38:3-6 92:25-93:3 100:3-14 136:16-19 153:1-6

Google Objections to Designations 402, 403

DR. COSMOS NICOLAOU (taken on October 18, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 28:22-29:2 37:24-38:17 46:12-47:13 49:14-50:1 69:2-15 92:23-95:25 105:18-24 106:3-10 107:15-108:1 108:20-109:9 116:12-117:17 119:20-120:5 130:11-131:2 131:8-15 136:1-25 138:1-11 138:17-139:9 143:21-144:2 171:9-12 186:4-15 193:21-195:25 213:3-16 223:5-19 224:10-225:16 266:20-267:23 268:18-270:11 271:15-17 272:18-274:8 275:3-18 276:5-19 278:19-279:16 282:5-285:10 Google Objections to Designations 106 106 106, IQ 106 106, 801, 802 106, IA 402 402 402 402 106 106 106 106, 602, CS, F 602, CS, F 106, IA 106, IA 602, CS, F 402, 403, 602, CS, F 106, IA, IQ 106, IA, IQ 106, IA 106 602, CS, F 402, 403, 106, A 402, 403 402, 403 106, 402, 403, 602, CS, F 402, 403 402, 403 106 106

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 10

Plaintiffs Designations 286:2-16 287:25-288:6 291:4-20 Counter-Designations 28:14-16 28:18-20 46:5-11 49:10-13 69:16-25 96:1-12 106:11-18 117:18-118:7 129:6-20 131:3-7 131:16-19 138:12-16 186:16-19 196:1-10 213:17-20 223:20-25 268:6-20 274:9-12

Google Objections to Designations 402, 403, BER 402, 403, 602, 801, 802, CS, F OS

DR. ANNA PATTERSON (taken on October 13, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 32:13-15 32:20-22 36:23-37:2 37:5-10 37:12-13 37:15-16 37:18-25 38:11-12 39:14-16 42:10-18 45:17-46:10 46:22-25 54:22-55:12 57:4-14 57:18-25 58:20-23 59:3-6 Google Objections to Designations 402 402 V 402, 403, 602, CS, F, V 402, 403, 602, CS, F, V 402, 403, 602, CS, F, V 402, 403, 602, CS, F, V 106, 402, 403 402, 403, 602, CS, F 106, 403, 602, CS, F 402, 403 106 403, BER 106, 403, V 106, V 106 V

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 11

Plaintiffs Designations 59:20-60:3 62:16-24 69:3-11 69:16-70:5 70:15-18 70:20-24 71:4-11 71:22-72:5 78:10-23 79:6-19 79:22 79:25-80:2 80:13-14 80:17 80:19-20 93:9-11 94:9-15 98:20-99:2 99:19-100:16 102:16-18 102:22-23 102:25-103:1 103:3-11 103:16-104:18 108:7-15 113:13-14 114:9-17 114:23-115:3 115:13-15 122:6-18 126:22-127:10 127:13-23 133:14-16 137:12-138:2 152:8-153:2 153:6-21 154:7-18 154:24-155:20 159:13-160:4 160:18-161:16 161:18-24 162:1-6 162:8-9 162:17-165:4 173:12-174:4 175:14-22

Google Objections to Designations V 106 106, 403, 602, BER, CS, F 403, 602, CS, F 403, V 106, 403, V 106, 403, V 402, 403, V 402, 403, CQ 106, 403, 602, CS 402, 403 106, 402, 403 106, 402, 403, CS, MC 106, 402, 403, CS, MC 106, 402, 403, CS, MC 106, 602, CS, F 602, BER, CS, F 402, 602, CS, F 602, CS BER V V V V 106 106, 402, 403, BER 602, CS, V, F V 106 602, CS, F V 106, V 602, F, CS 106 402, 403, 602, CS, BER, F 402, 403 402, 403, BER BER, CS, F, 602 402, 403, V, BER V V V V 106, 402, 403, 602, BER, CS, F, V AA, BER, MC V

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 12

Counter-Designations 38:8-10 42:19-22 46:16-21 55:22-56:22 57:15-17 57:18-20 58:2-18 62:25-63:5 69:12-15 70:25-71:2 71:12-21 93:11-15 93:20-21 108:13-18 113:15-16 113:18-22 115:10-12 128:8-9 137:2-10 137:24-138:5 167:4-168:2

DAVID ROACHE (May 25, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 82:20-84:18 276:5-24 277:7-279:8 286:20-287:23 288:20-290:10 Counter-Designations 82:16-19 84:19-21 287:25-288:4 290:11-16 296:16-23 297:2-9 298:8-16
DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 13

Google Objections to Designations 106 602, 801, 802, 805, CS, F 106, 602, 801, 802, 805, CS, F 106 106

ANTHONY TOMASIC (taken on May 5, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 10:14-24 17:22-18:2 19:23-20:3 22:10-15 23:8-17 28:1-10 32:17-22 35:14-24 41:24-42:7 42:13-43:11 45:24-46:13 47:24-48:15 49:23-50:4 51:10-14 51:23-52:16 54:14-16 55:15-24 57:25-59:6 63:6-64:12 64:25-65:3 65:18-66:18 71:15-23 75:3-11 76:25-77:20 79:7-17 80:19-83:22 84:12-14 86:9-16 92:13-93:14 94:8-96:19 101:10-104:10 106:18-21 107:4-108:8 108:14-109:22 113:14-20 114:11-115:2 121:10-122:9 122:15-124:17 126:3-9 126:16-127:14 128:13-129:5 131:9-24 132:3-11 137:5-17 152:12-153:25 Google Objections to Designations V BER, V BER, V V 106 V 106 BER, V 106, BER, V 106, BER, V 106, BER, V 106, BER, V 106, AA, BER, MC BER, V BER, V 106, 402 BER, V 106 BER, V 106, BER BER, V 106, V 106, V V 106, V, BER 106, H, V 106, BER, V V BER BER, V 106, BER 106, BER BER 106, BER BER 106, BER BER 106, AA, BER 106, BER 106, BER 106, BER 106, BER BER 106, BER 106, BER

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 14

Plaintiffs Designations 156:11-157:18 157:23-158:11 159:13-24 Counter-Designations 22:20-23:7 31:9-32:16 40:8-41:5 45:8-23 46:14-47:17 54:13-54:13 54:17-20 57:8-24 64:20-24 71:7-14 79:1-6 84:8-19 100:16-101:9 105:17-106:17 108:9-13 113:21-114:10 122:10-14 125:4-126:2 127:15-18 128:7-12 131:3-8 137:18 151:25-152:11 159:25-160:1

Google Objections to Designations 402, 403 402, 403 106, 402, 403

SHALOM WERTSBERGER (taken on September 28, 2010) Plaintiffs Designations 28:13-15 28:21-24 56:24-57:19 88:11-89:7 Counter-Designations 93:2-22 93:25-94:3
DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 15

Google Objections to Designations 106 106 106 106, 402, 403, 602, CS, F

DR. YONATAN ZUNGER (taken on August 20, 2009) Plaintiffs Designations 9:9-12 21:18-22:9 29:10-12 42:7-43:9 68:10-13 71:10-16 71:20-72:3 81:2-11 81:18-24 94:4-11 114:10-11 117:24-118:7 122:25-123:14 129:6-8 140:20-141:1 152:17-153:1 153:20-23 162:22-163:4 164:8-17 Counter-Designations 21:14-17 29:8-9 43:10 68:14-24 71:17-19 81:12-20 81:25-82:8 95:11-14 115:5-21 114:7 117:17-23 118:11-17 123:15-19 124:5-9 129:9-19 141:2-7 162:17-21 164:18-19 Google Objections to Designations IA, 106 106 106, IQ 106, IA 106 402 106, 602, CS, F 106 106, IA 106 106, IQ 106, IQ, IA 106 106, IA 106 602, CS, F 106, IQ, IA 106, IQ, IA 106, IA

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 16

OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' INCOMPLETENESS DESIGNATIONS (D.I. 139-1) DR. KENNETH BACLAWSKI (taken on December 13, 2010) Plaintiffs Incompleteness Designations 6:16-17 9:25-11:3 119:23-121:13 Google Objections to Designations 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403, 801, 802

DR. URS HOELZLE (taken on November 4, 2010) Plaintiffs Incompleteness Designations 194:8-17 Google Objections to Designations 402, 403

DR. ANNA PATTERSON (taken on October 13, 2010) Plaintiffs Incompleteness Designations 124:17-20 141:6-9 Google Objections to Designations 402, 403, AR, AF, F, MC, V 402, 403, AA, AR, MC, V

DAVID ROACHE (May 25, 2010) Plaintiffs Incompleteness Designations 106:9-107:8 122:4-123:13 154:14-155:6 Google Objections to Designations 402, 403, 801, 802, CS, AF, F 402, 403, 602, 801, 802, CS 402, 403, 801, 802, CS, AF, F

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 17

KAUSTUV (taken on December 3, 2010) Plaintiffs Incompleteness Designations 22:4-6, 22:8 39:12-16
50764935.doc

Google Objections to Designations 402, 403, 801, 802, CS, AF, F 402, 403, 602

DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS- Page 18