Software Rights Archive, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 213

RESPONSE to Motion re 198 Opposed MOTION Granting Defendants Leave to Amend and Supplement Invalidity Contentions filed by Software Rights Archive, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Affidavit, # 9 Text of Proposed Order)(Kaplan, Lee)

Software Rights Archive, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Doc. 213 Att. 4

Exhibit 4

Dockets.Justia.com

INVALIDITY CLAIM CHART FOR U.S. PATENT No. 5,544,352 OF CERTAIN EXEMPLARY COMBINATIONS

Each reference identified as anticipatory of any claim herein in Defendants' P. R. 3-3 Disclosure also renders such claim obvious alone and in view of any of the one or more other references as identified in the char below. In additon, combinations of two or more of the references identitied in the char below render the claims obvious.

26. A non-semantical method for numerically

Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox,
1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner,

representig objects in a computer database and for

computerized searching of the numerically represented objects in the database, wherein direct and indirect relationships exist between objects in the database, comprising:

1967;Botafogo, 1992;Alain, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose,

(26a) marking objects in the database so that each marked object may be individually identiied by a computeried search;

1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bìchteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992;Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMARì Kessler, 1967;Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II,

1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko,
1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Alaín, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Guinan, 1992;Salton,

1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose,
1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991 ;Piroll, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992;ENVISION;SMART Kessler, 1967;Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;Fox/Smart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia,

1989;Frisse/Cousìns, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk,
1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part ",

(26b) creating a first numerical representation for each identified object in the database based upon the object's direct relationship with other objects in the database;

1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger,
1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton. 1977;Salton. 1970;Salton and McGil, 1983;Salton,

1

(26c) storing the first numerical representations for use in computeried searching;

1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U,S. Pat. No. 5,446,891;Rose, 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoXiSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffmàn, 1969;Pinski,
1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schimínovich, 1971 ;Guinan,

1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose,
1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART

(26d) analyzing the first numerical representations Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxiSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, for indiect relationships existing between or among 1984;Fox, .1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, objects in the database;

1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Freì & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski,

1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan,

1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose,
1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART

(26e) generating a second numerical representation of each object based on the analysis of the first numerical representation;

Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979; FoxJSmart, 1 983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox,
1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Burt,

1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew,
1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada,

.. ..

1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVIS/ON;SMART

(26fJ storing the second numerical representation for use in computerized searching; and

;Saiton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979¡FoxJSmart, 1 983;Fox Collections, 1983¡Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox,
1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ¡Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982¡Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski,
1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan,

1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose,

(26g) searching the objects in the database using a computer and the stored second numerical

representations, wherein the search identies one or

more of the objects in the database.

1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974¡Rada, 1991 ;/ntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVIS/ON;SMART Salton, 1971 ¡Garfield, 1979;FoxJSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990¡Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski,
1976;Garner, 1967;Alain, 1992;Shepheri:, 1990 ;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton,

1988;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew,
1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992j Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART Kessler, 1967;Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxJSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ¡Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part ", 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TI P;Shìmko, 1974;Salton,

27. The non-semantical method of claim 26, wherein the objects in the database include words, and semantic indexing techniques are used in combination with the non-semantical method, the

method futher comprising the step of creatig and

stoling a Boolean word index for the words of the objects in the database.

1970;Salton and McGil, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton,
1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Alain, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schirninovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Lucarella, 1990;Rose, 1989;Belew, 1986;Rose. 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bìchteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART

28. 'The non-semantical method of claim 26 wherein Salton, 1971 ;Fox/Smart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson. the first and second numerical representations are 1989;Kommers, 1990;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part vectors that are aranged in firt and second I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Salton, matrices; 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Salton, 1963;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft,

3