Rockstar Consortium US LP et al v. Google Inc

Filing 200

Joint Claim Construction Chart Pursuant to Patent Rule 4-5(d) by Google Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix A - U.S. Patent No. 7,236,969, # 2 Appendix B - U.S. Patent No. 7,469,245, # 3 Appendix C - U.S. Patent No. 7,672,970, # 4 Appendix D - U.S. Patent No. 7,895,178, # 5 Appendix E - U.S. Patent No. 7,895,183, # 6 Appendix F - U.S. Patent No. 7,933,883, # 7 Appendix G - Ordering Agreements and Disputes, # 8 Appendix H - Antecedent Basis Agreements and Disputes)(Anderson, Carl)

APPENDIX G:
ORDERING AGREEMENTS AND DISPUTES
Claim to be ordered
Rockstar’s Construction
Order of steps of claim 1 of [Agreed]
the ‘969 patent.

Google’s Construction
[Agreed]

Court’s Construction
1[a] must occur before 1[b] and 1[c].

Order of steps of claim 8 of [Agreed]
‘969 patent

[Agreed]

1[d] must occur after 1[b] and 1[c].
8[a] must occur before 8[b] and 8[c].

Order of steps of claim 1 of [Agreed]
‘245 patent

[Agreed]

8[d] must occur after 8[b] and 8[c].
1[a] must occur before 1[b].
1[c] must occur before 1[d] and 1[e].
1[b] must occur before 1[e].
1[d] and 1[e] must occur before 1[f].

Order of steps of claim 17
of ‘970 patent

[Agreed]

[Agreed]

17[a] must occur before 17[b] and
17[c].
17[d] must occur after 17[b] and
17[c].
17[e] must occur after 17[d].
17[f] must occur after 17[e].

1

Order of steps of claim 26
of ‘970 patent

[Agreed]

[Agreed]

26[a] must occur before 26[b] and
26[c].
26[d] must occur after 26[b] and
26[c].
26[e] must occur after 26[d].

Order of steps of claim 41
of ‘970 patent

[Agreed]

[Agreed]

41[a] must occur before 41[b] and
41[c].
41[d] must occur after 41[b] and
41[c].

Order of steps of claim 1 of [Agreed]
’178 patent

[Agreed]

1[a] must occur before 1[b] and 1[c].
1[b] and 1[c] must occur before 1[d].
1[d] must occur before 1[e].
1[e] must occur before 1[f] and 1[g].
1[f] and 1[g] must occur before 1[h].

2

Order of steps of claim 12
of the ‘178 patent

[Agreed]

[Agreed]

12[a] must occur before 12[b].
12[b] must occur before 12[c].
12[c] must occur before 12[d], 12[e],
or 12[f].
12[d], 12[e], and 12[f] must occur
before 12 [g].
12[g] must occur before 12[h].

Order of steps of claim 1 of [Agreed]
the ‘183 patent

[Agreed]

Order of steps of claim 9 of [Agreed]
the ‘183 patent

[Agreed]

1[a] must occur before 1[b] and 1[c].
1[b] and 1[c] must occur before 1[d].
1[a] must occur before 1[b].
1[b] must occur before 1[c].
1[c] must occur before 1[d] and 1[e].

Order of steps of claim 1 of [Agreed]
the ‘883 patent

[Agreed]

1[a] must occur before 1[b].
1[c] must occur before 1[d].
1[e] must occur after 1[a].
1[f] must occur after 1[d] and 1[e].

Order of steps of claim 17
of the ’970 patent
Order of steps of claim 26
of the ’970 patent

Steps 17[b] and 17[c] need
not occur in order
Steps 26[b] and 26[c] need
not occur in order

Steps 17[b] and 17[c] must occur
in order
Steps 26[b] and 26[c] must occur
in order
3

Order of steps of claim 41
of the ’970 patent
Order of steps of claim 1 of
the ’178 patent

Steps 41[b] and 41[c] need
not occur in order
Steps 1[b] and 1[c] need not
occur in order.

Steps 41[b] and 41[c] must occur
in order
Steps 1[b] and 1[c] must occur in
order.

Steps 1[f] and 1[g] need not
occur in order
Order of steps of claim 12
Steps 12[d], 12[e], and 12[f]
of the ’178 patent
need not occur in order
Order of steps of claim 1 of Steps 1[b] and 1[c] need not
the ’183 patent
occur in order

Steps 1[f] and 1[g] must occur in
order
Steps 12[d], 12[e], and 12[f]
must occur in order.
Steps 1[b] and 1[c] must occur in
order

4