Rockstar Consortium US LP et al v. Google Inc

Filing 36

REPLY to Response to Motion re 18 MOTION to Change Venue filed by Google Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Sam Stake, # 2 Exhibit 45, # 3 Exhibit 46, # 4 Second Declaration of Abeer Dubey)(Mann, James)

EXHIBIT 46

Table C-5.
U.S. District Courts—Median Time Intervals From Filing to Disposition of Civil Cases
Terminated, by District and Method of Disposition,
During the 12-Month Period Ending March 31, 2013
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

TOTAL
198,301
8.4
43,423 5.0 128,042 8.5
24,058
12.7
2,778
23.8

DC
1,974
8.9
721
7.3
1,201
9.8 10
38.4
42 43.5

1ST
4,940
9.6
1,067 3.9
2,543 9.6
1,228
15.2
102
27.5
ME
373
7.8
137
6.2
220
8.8
12
19.3
4
MA
2,434
8.3
623
3.0
803
6.9
953
14.9
55
30.6
NH
468
9.6
81
3.9
206
6.7
169
15.2
12
19.3
RI
652
13.7 85
8.0 522
14.7 34
16.1
11 40.4
PR
1,013
11.6
141
6.7 792
11.6 60
19.9
20 26.0

2ND
18,455
8.8
3,799 5.0
10,820 8.6
3,515
12.1
321
32.2
CT
1,656
10.7
776
8.0 760
11.1 69
21.5
51 37.9
NY,N
1,163
11.8
251
5.2
580
11.5
300
17.3
32
28.8
NY,E
5,533
8.8
1,162
5.5
3,096
8.6
1,176
11.7
99
31.0
NY,S
8,441
8.3
1,198
4.4
5,176
7.5
1,944
11.4
123
28.8
NY,W
1,389
7.4
377
2.9 976
9.6 24
34.6
12 67.1
VT
273
8.9
35
3.8
232
9.5
2
-
4
3RD
23,315
9.2
2,467 4.0
17,015 9.3
3,506
11.9
327
27.0
DE
1,226
8.0
441
4.6 648
8.8 78
14.3
59 34.2
NJ
5,908
6.1
544
4.0
3,326
3.6
1,974
13.2
64
35.1
PA,E
12,617
14.6
579
3.1
10,626
17.9
1,290
9.4
122
17.8
PA,M
1,472
7.7
459
4.7 913
8.1 57
22.4
43 28.6
PA,W
1,870
6.2
325
2.9
1,491
7.0 33
24.3
21 29.2
VI
222
18.0
119
14.0 11
11.5 74
19.9
18 29.0

4TH
12,392
7.4
2,302 5.3
8,437 7.1
1,467
10.4
186
20.2
MD
3,191
7.1
404
6.3
2,151
5.6
582
13.5
54
30.1
NC,E
1,012
9.0
300
7.8
697
9.5
7
-
8
NC,M
551
10.1
361
9.0
159
12.2
22
16.4
9
NC,W
930
8.2
298
4.8 533
8.7 84
14.7
15 22.6
SC
2,484
8.8
265
3.7
2,051
9.0
135
12.1
33
25.4
VA,E
2,358
5.0
330
3.0
1,434
4.1
554
7.7
40
11.1
VA,W
678
8.0
167
3.8 449
8.9 46
12.5
16 12.0
WV,N
428
8.8
115
6.4
302
9.2
8
-
3
WV,S
760
8.7
62
2.6
661
9.1
29
17.9
8
-

Page 1 of 3

Table C-5. (March 31, 2013—Continued)
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

5TH
22,514
10.9
4,961 6.0
15,381 12.2
1,838
13.6
334
20.2
LA,E
6,391
26.0
169
0.9
5,315
30.4
861
14.4
46
18.1
LA,M
579
12.1
192
10.3 347
12.1 24
16.6
16 35.0
LA,W
1,358
12.5
489
8.9 777
14.0 58
20.1
34 24.1
MS,N
581
10.6
196
7.9
215
10.4
155
14.2
15
22.2
MS,S
1,392
10.8
631
9.2 715
11.7 23
19.5
23 18.4
TX,N
3,200
6.8
603
5.4
2,547
7.1
4
-
46
20.2
TX,E
2,234
8.7
572
6.9
1,593
9.0 33
24.4
36 25.5
TX,S
4,506
7.5
1,402
4.3
2,454
8.4
581
10.2
69
19.8
TX,W
2,273
7.0
707
6.2
1,418
6.6 99
15.8
49 19.0

6TH
16,864
8.9
4,882 4.6
8,073 9.0
3,737
12.5
172
24.9
KY,E
1,187
8.3
158
4.6 994
8.4 24
21.8
11 23.2
KY,W
1,114
8.5
323
4.5
752
9.4
31
18.4
8
MI,E
4,388
7.7
997
3.1
1,559
5.3
1,795
13.2
37
20.4
MI,W
1,143
7.0
210
1.7
668
6.8
249
11.9
16
23.1
OH,N
3,239
8.9
864
4.2
1,533
12.5
819
9.6
23
24.7
OH,S
2,266
9.9
869
5.5
717
11.1
654
13.3
26
31.9
TN,E
1,238
10.4
578
5.5
509
12.4
132
14.2
19
22.3
TN,M
1,208
10.4
175
10.0
1,005
10.2 10
19.3
18 26.3
TN,W
1,081
10.7
708
9.5 336
11.5 23
22.8
14 23.5

7TH
15,666
7.6
4,480 5.4
8,717 6.9
2,270
12.7
199
27.6
IL,N
8,741
6.6
2,519
5.8
5,404
6.2
714
11.5
104
33.7
IL,C
724
9.0
291
7.1
412
9.7
6
-
15
36.7
IL,S
1,141
11.0
519
11.7
589
10.2
11
32.3
22
24.5
IN,N
1,293
9.9
399
3.2
407
8.7
469
16.3
18
29.9
IN,S
2,053
9.2
277
3.4
944
6.9
817
12.5
15
24.8
WI,E
1,045
6.7
218
3.2 790
7.2 25
16.3
12 16.4
WI,W
669
6.0
257
2.5
171
6.6
228
11.2
13
16.4

8TH
13,983
12.2
4,887 7.1
8,027 13.6
909
13.3
160
21.9
AR,E
4,204
46.3
1,084
47.1
3,091
45.7
5
-
24
19.6
AR,W
863
11.7
121
8.5
722
11.8
3
-
17
18.8
IA,N
406
9.7
85
7.6
311
9.8
1
-
9
IA,S
507
7.9 89
4.1 308
7.1 99
14.7
11 23.5
MN
2,825
5.4
1,301
2.4
753
5.1
745
12.4
26
23.2
MO,E
2,232
10.6
1,038
9.6
1,159
11.0
9
-
26
22.1
MO,W
2,054
8.4
1,010
4.4 987
11.0 35
17.2
22 18.9
NE
496
9.0
36
2.8
430
9.1
11
17.8
19
28.8
ND
159
8.4
8
-
150
8.5
0
-
1
SD
237
11.4
115
10.2
116
12.4
1
-
5
-

Page 2 of 3

Table C-5. (March 31, 2013—Continued)
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

9TH
34,756
6.7
9,346 4.7
22,196 6.8
2,750
13.8
464
23.4
AK
250
9.2
53
7.4
187
9.0
2
-
8
AZ
2,538
7.0 82
2.4
2,388
7.0 42
24.2
26 31.0
CA,N
5,054
6.4
827
3.6
2,747
4.7
1,424
12.5
56
27.5
CA,E
3,046
8.3
1,119
5.8
1,832
9.6 68
18.2
27 30.2
CA,C
12,112
5.4
4,097
4.9
7,716
5.5
146
16.8
153
20.0
CA,S
2,316
6.7
321
3.5
1,251
5.2
709
12.9
35
26.9
HI
673
9.4
333
7.0 265
9.3 55
22.8
20 15.6
ID
513
10.2 43
1.7 375
9.8 80
19.0
15 27.3
MT
442
9.1
166
4.5
161
8.9
106
14.3
9
NV
2,207
8.8
343
6.0
1,753
9.0 84
10.2
27 37.8
OR
1,805
10.1
676
7.3
1,079
11.2
9
-
41
21.4
WA,E
703
9.4
315
4.9
372
13.1
7
-
9
WA,W
3,042
6.2
942
2.8
2,051
7.6
11
16.4
38
20.0
GUAM
26 16.2
5 -
16 18.4
5
-
0
NMI
29
24.5
24
19.8
3
-
2
-
0

10TH
8,600
8.4
2,268 5.0
5,069 8.5
1,100
13.6
163
22.7
CO
2,602
6.0
749
3.7
1,654
6.2
139
18.6
60
23.1
KS
1,305
7.6
373
4.5
808
8.2
102
18.1
22
24.9
NM
890
8.6
316
6.6
332
8.7
226
11.3
16
24.0
OK,N
729
12.0
55
4.1
652
12.3
13
19.8
9
OK,E
396
11.7
251
10.3
135
13.1
8
-
2
OK,W
1,188
8.7
297
3.7
447
8.1
423
11.7
21
16.4
UT
1,277
11.2
172
6.7 984
10.9 98
22.2
23 38.8
WY
213
10.1 55
5.8 57
6.3 91
12.2
10 15.6

11TH
24,842
7.3
2,243 4.0
20,563 7.2
1,728
12.7
308
18.9
AL,N
2,631
7.9
126
5.3
2,448
7.9 22
25.2
35 21.9
AL,M
639
10.2 51
4.1 532
9.7 41
16.3
15 23.2
AL,S
566
8.4
93
3.7
455
8.8
11
15.8
7
FL,N
1,277
7.4
41
3.9
1,210
7.4
12
10.6
14
21.1
FL,M
7,451
10.2
410
5.5
6,833
10.2
129
18.4
79
20.5
FL,S
6,685
5.2
554
3.7
5,918
5.2
96
12.0
117
16.3
GA,N
4,236
6.4
480
2.6
2,331
4.7
1,401
11.6
24
20.9
GA,M
755
8.7
262
6.0
481
10.3
2
-
10
16.3
GA,S
602
8.1
226
5.8
355
9.7
14
25.0
7
NOTE: Median time intervals are not computed when fewer than 10 cases reported. This table excludes land condemnations, prisoner petitions, deportation reviews, recovery of overpayments, and enforcement of judgments.
Includes cases filed in previous years as consolidated cases that thereafter were severed into individual cases. For fiscal years prior to 2001, this table included data on recovery of overpayments and enforcement of judgments.

Page 3 of 3