EMG Technology, LLC v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 217

RESPONSE in Opposition re 209 MOTION to Change Venue filed by EMG Technology, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Text of Proposed Order, # 2 Charles Ainsworth Declaration, # 3 Exhibit A to Ainsworth Declaration - Witness Mileage Chart)(Ainsworth, Charles)

EXHIBIT A COMPARISON OF DISTANCES FROM WITNESS LOCATIONS TO TYLER, TX, AND LOS ANGELES, CA WITNESSES IDENTIFIED BY EMG Witness 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29.
1

Relevance See footnote 1 See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹

Nicole Montgomery Rachel Carroll Nathan Ralson Jose Bueno Danny Barrett Griffin Blackburn Doug Cole Jerry Cole Waylon Fulton Jason Jones Bear Bryant Shanell Sutherland Mike Anderson Johannah Rosebury Raeford Bannon Michael Bass Jarett Wright Jason Watson Aaron Mann Jeffrey Whitespeare Matt Schoolcraft David Espizona Norma Macias Mark Torrez Don Anderson Alice Pope Collin Brady Jordan Dennis Patty Brady

Location of Witness Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX

Distance to LAX 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles

Distance to TYR 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles

Potential witnesses with knowledge of discoverable facts regarding sales, offers to sell, and use of infringing instrumentalities in this District, the proportion of the damages base represented by the infringing components or features, customer demand for the patented inventions, and other facts relevant to EMG's remedies.
Page 1

Witness 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. Will Hallstead Chris Hernandes Gary J. Pargament Ezell Thompson Orlando Juarez Garrett Jackson Brandon Clinton Michael DeVries Imran Chotani Tristan Shay Kelly Williams Morris Newman Javier Mendoza David Ortega Max Smart Kristen Cage Jesse Aranda Alex Alexander Clayton Thomas Marisol Hartnett Dustin Carmack Brittany Williams Lowell McAdam Steve Zipperstein Roger Gurnani Mike Ritter John Stratton Anthony Malone Margaret Feldman John Townsend Randall L. Stephenson 61. James W. Callaway 62. Ralph de la Vega 63. Richard G. Lindner

2

Relevance See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote ¹ See footnote 2 See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ²

Location of Witness Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Tyler, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX Longview, TX New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY Dallas, TX Dallas, TX Dallas, TX Dallas, TX

Distance to LAX 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1335 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 1380 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles

Distance to TYR 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 8 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 37 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles

Potential witnesses with knowledge of discoverable facts regarding Defendants' direct and indirect infringement of the Patents-in-Suit in connection with Apple iPhones, Windows Mobile smart phones and/or other infringing instrumentalities, the proportion of the damages base represented by the infringing components or features, customer demand for the patented inventions, and/or other facts relevant to EMG's remedies.

Page 2

Witness 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. Forrest E. Miller Wayne Watts Rayford Wilkins, Jr. Walter Mossberg Caroline McCarthy Owen Thomas Anil Dash Wade Roush Jeremy Caplan Stephen Wildstrom

Relevance See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote ² See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 3 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

74. Sear Carroll 75. John Gruber 76. Andy Ihnatko 77. David Pogue 78. Edward Baig 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. Brian Krebs Brian Bergstein Jenna Wortham Julia Angwin Wayne Westerman

Location of Witness Dallas, TX Dallas, TX Dallas, TX Washington, DC New York, NY New York, NY New York, NY Boston, MA New York, NY Washington, DC New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Boston, MA Hartford, CT Washington, DC Annandale, VA Brookline, MA New York, NY New York, NY Apple Cupertino, CA Microsoft Redmond, WA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA

Distance to LAX 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 2280 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2280 miles 2452 miles 2400 miles 2607 miles 2525 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles 2607 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 338 miles 953 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles

Distance to TYR 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 1100 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1100 miles 1307 miles 1236 miles 1501 miles 1410 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles 1501 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1569 miles 1747 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles

84. Robert J. Bach 85. Brian L. Roberts 86. Stephen B. Burke

3

Potential witnesses (technology industry writers) with knowledge of discoverable facts regarding direct and indirect infringement issues, the proportion of the damages base represented by the infringing components or features, customer demand for the patented inventions, and/or other facts relevant to EMG's remedies. 4 Potential witnesses (employees of Defendants) with knowledge of discoverable facts regarding development, implementation and/or commercialization of the accused instrumentalities, direct and indirect infringement issues, willfulness, the proportion of the damages base represented by the infringing components or features, customer demand for the patented inventions, and/or other facts relevant to EMG's remedies.
Page 3

Witness 87. Michael Angelakis 88. Amy L. Banse 89. David L. Cohen 90. Arthur R. Block 91. Mark A. Coblitz 92. Robert S. Pick 93. Gregg M. Goldstein 94. Payne D. Brown 95. Marc A. Rockford 96. Michael Dell 97. Jeffrey Clarke

Relevance See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

98. Brian Gladden 99. Joe Kremer 100. Brad R. Anderson 101. Stephen J. Felice 102. Ronald G. Garriques 103. Erin Nelson 104. Lawrence P. Tu

Location of Witness Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Comcast Philadelphia, PA Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell Austin, TX Dell

Distance to LAX 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 2400 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles

Distance to TYR 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 1236 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles 199 miles
Page 4

Witness 105. Robert W. Reding 106. Gerard J. Arpey 107. Daniel P. Garton 108. Gary F. Kennedy 109. Monte E. Ford 110. Virasb Vahidi 111. Thomas W. Horton 112. Isabella D. Goren 113. Craig S. Kreeger 114. Don B. Casey 115. Roger C. Frizzell 116. Andrew O. Watson 117. Beverly K. Goulet 118. Fred E. Cleveland 119. Daniel Henry 120. Derek DeCross 121. Paolo Brajnik 122. Enrico Scoda 123. Gary C. Kelly 124. Laura H. Wright 125. Ron Ricks 126. Darren Dayley

Relevance See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

Location of Witness Austin, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Am. Airlines Ft. Worth, TX Usablenet New York, NY Usablenet New York, NY Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest

Distance to LAX 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles

Distance to TYR 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles
Page 5

Witness 127. Laurie Hulin 128. Madeleine Johnson 129. Bob Jordan 130. Kevin Krone 131. Jan Marshall 132. Dave Ridley

Relevance See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

133. Michael Van De Ven See footnote 4 134. Rodger Riney 135. Ron Wiese 136. Catherine Maher 137. Chris X. Moloney 138. Mark Warmack 139. Ian Patterson 140. Scott DePriest 141. Andrew Riordon 142. Mike Sieben 143. J. W. Marriott, Jr. 144. John Marriott 145. William J. Shaw 146. Arne M. Sorenson 147. Carl T. Berquist 148. Bancroft S. Gordon

See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

Location of Witness Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Southwest Dallas, TX Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Scottrade St. Louis, MO Marriott Bethesda, MD Marriott Bethesda, MD Marriott Bethesda, MD Marriott Bethesda, MD Marriott Bethesda, MD Marriott

Distance to LAX 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1234 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 1589 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles 2280 miles

Distance to TYR 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 102 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 522 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles 1100 miles
Page 6

Witness 149. Carl Wilson 150. Jeffery H. Boyd 151. Daniel J. Finnegan 152. Ronald V. Rose 153. Peter J. Millones, Jr. 154. Brett Keller 155. Robert J. Mylod, Jr. 156. Lisa Gillingham 157. Nina S. Zagat 158. Tim Zagat 159. Tiffany Barbalato 160. Leonard Riggio 161. Stephen Riggio 162. Mitchell Klipper 163. David S. Deason 164. William J. Lynch, Jr. 165. Joseph Lombardi 166. Jennifer Daniels

Relevance See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4

Location of Witness Bethesda, MD Marriott Bethesda, MD Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Pricline.com Norwalk, CT Zagat New York, NY Zagat New York, NY Zagat New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY

Distance to LAX 2280 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles 2452 miles

Distance to TYR 1100 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles 1307 miles

Page 7

Witness 167. Jaime Carey 168. Kevin M. Frain 169. Thomas J. Pritzker 170. Mark Hoplamazian 171. H. Charles Floyd 172. Harmit J. Singh 173. Susan T. Smith 174. International Business Machines Corporation 175. Kathryn H. Britton 176. Steven Dale Ims 177. Brad P. Topol 178. Timothy W. Bickmore 179. Michael J. Beranek 180. Christian Lita 181. Dimitri Kanevsky 182. Thomas Alexander Bellwood 183. Matthew Francis

Relevance See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 See footnote 4 Assignee of alleged prior art patent Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's

Location of Witness Barnes & Noble New York, NY Barnes & Noble New York, NY Hyatt Chicago, IL Hyatt Chicago, IL Hyatt Chicago, IL Hyatt Chicago, IL Hyatt Chicago, IL Armonk, NY Chapel Hill, NC Apex, NC Apex, NC Somerville, MA Austin, TX Austin, TX Ossining, NY Austin, TX Pflugerville,

Distance to LAX 2452 miles 2452 miles 1737 miles 1737 miles 1737 miles 1737 miles 1737 miles 2452 miles 2239 miles 2239 miles 2239 miles 2607 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles 2452 miles 1249 miles 1249 miles

Distance to TYR 1307 miles 1307 miles 781 miles 781 miles 781 miles 781 miles 781 miles 1307 miles 979 miles 979 miles 979 miles 1501 miles 199 miles 199 miles 1307 miles 199 miles 199 miles
Page 8

Witness Rutkowski 184. Michael John Walker 185. James Corvin Fletcher 186. David Bruce Lindquist 187. Xerox Corporation 188. Bob Bajoras 189. AT&T corporate headquarters employees 190. AT&T retail store employees 191. Verizon Wireless retail store employees 192. Sprint retail store employees 193. T-Mobile retail store employees

Relevance alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Apple's alleged prior art Assignee of alleged prior art patent Identified by Defendants See footnote 2 See footnote 1 See footnote 1 See footnote 1 See footnote 1

Location of Witness TX Austin, TX Apex, NC Raleigh, NC Stamford, CT Erie, PA Dallas, TX Texas Texas Texas Texas Witnesses identified by EMG: Witnesses identified by Defendants: TOTAL:

Distance to LAX 1249 miles 2239 miles 2239 miles 2452 miles 2141 miles

Distance to TYR 199 miles 979 miles 979 miles 1307 miles 1070 miles

327896 miles

109961 miles

8,207 miles

49,763 miles

336,103 miles 159,724 miles

WITNESSES IDENTIFIED BY THE DEFENDANTS (taken from Exhibit A to the Carraway Declaration in Support of the Defendants' Motion to transfer):

Page 9

Page 10

Page 11

300047040.1

Page 12