Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Filing 618

Additional Attachments to Main Document: #578 Proposed Pretrial Order,.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit B, #2 Exhibit G, #3 Exhibit H, #4 Exhibit L, #5 Exhibit M)(Jones, Michael)

Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Doc. 618 Att. 3

EXHIBIT H

Dockets.Justia.com

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS TO BEDROCK'S DESIGNATION OF THE DEPOSITIONS OF NON-GOOGLE DEFENDANTS Google objects to the designation of testimony from other defendants, including Yahoo! Inc., Amazon.com Inc., SoftLayer Technologies, Inc., MySpace Inc., Match.com, LLC and AOL Inc. as irrelevant under Federal Rule of Evidence 402 and 403, unfairly prejudicial, confusing, and a waste of time. As of March 17, 2011, Bedrock and Match.com have executed a settlement agreement with a provision that Match.com will be dismissed from the litigation. In the event that Bedrock still intends to use deposition designations from Match.com employees during its trial against Google, Google reserves the right to submit objections and counterdesignations to those designations. DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF NEENA BUDHIRAJA ON JANUARY 5, 2011 Google generally objects to the designation of any of Ms. Budhiraja's testimony based on Federal Rule of Evidence 402 and 403 as irrelevant and unfairly prejudicial because Bedrock's damages expert does not rely on any of the revenue information in his report, and on the ground that this revenue information offered by Bedrock fails to satisfy the standard for relevance or admissibility under the Federal Circuit's recent decision in Uniloc USA Inc. v. Microsoft Corp., No. 03-CV-0440 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 4, 2011). Google further objects generally because this testimony is subject to the Court's ruling on a pending motion in limine. In addition to these general objections, Google further objects as indicated below:

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

6:9 - 6:10 6:13 - 6:14 6:17 - 6:20

402

1

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

14:6 - 14:23 17:12 - 17:23 24:4 - 25:1 36:17 - 36:24 39:15 - 39:24 46:14 - 46:17 46:20 - 47:5 47:7 - 47:7 47:9 - 47:12 47:14 - 47:14 47:16 - 48:1 48:5 - 48:7 59:22 - 59:25 60:2 - 60:2 60:4 - 60:8 68:8 - 68:13 68:15 - 68:16 68:18 - 68:20 68:22 - 68:25 69:2 - 69:5 69:24 - 70:3 70:5 - 70:7 73:24 - 74:8 74:13 - 74:16

402 104a, 402, MIL, 30b6 104a, 402, V, DI, MIL, 30b6 104a, 402, MIL, 30b6 104a, 402, MIL, 30b6 402, MIL 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 402, MIL, 30b6, 104a 403, MIL, 104a, 402, 30b6 403, MIL, 104a, 402, 30b6 403, MIL, 104a, 402, 30b6 104a, 402, MIL 104a, 402, MIL 104a, 402, MIL 104a, 402, MIL 104a, 402, MIL, 30b6 104a, 402, AA, 30b6, MIL 104a, 402, AA, 30b6, MIL 104a, 402, AA, MIL 104a, 402, AA,

16:25 - 17:7 25:2 - 25:13

2

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

74:18 - 74:18 77:5 - 77:7 77:9 - 77:9

MIL 104a, 402, AA, MIL 104a, 402, DI, V, 30b6, MIL 104a, 402, DI, V, 30b6, MIL

3

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF LAURENT CHAVEY ON JANUARY 7, 2011
Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

5:10 - 5:13 5:17 - 5:24 6:2 - 6:9 9:22 - 11:13 13:2 - 14:8 17:19 - 18:23 23:19 - 23:21 23:23 - 23:23 27:15 - 27:16 27:18 - 27:20 27:24 - 28:3 28:5 - 28:9 28:11 - 29:11 30:3 - 30:8 31:17 - 31:18 31:20 - 32:2 32:4 - 32:22 37:12 - 38:3 39:9 - 39:10 39:13 - 39:15 42:5 - 42:7 43:20 - 44:12 44:23 - 44:25 45:2 - 45:2 45:7 - 45:10 45:12 - 45:14 45:16 - 45:19 45:22 - 46:5 47:9 - 48:4 52:13 - 52:13 52:15 - 52:18 52:23 - 53:2 53:10 - 53:14 58:8 - 58:17 65:12 - 65:23 65:25 - 66:1

402 402, 403, 501 V, DI 104a, 402, 403, 501, 702 V, 103, 104a, V, 103 V, 103

14:9 - 14:14

23:25 - 24:13

V V 32:23 - 34:8 V V 42:17 - 42:20 V V, 103 V, 103 V V V 48:5 - 48:18 49:11 - 49:14 50:14 - 52:12 53:15 - 54:2 56:7 - 56:16 57:3 - 58:7 58:18 - 58:20 59:20 - 60:24 4

MT MT

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

68:21 - 68:25 69:2 - 69:3 69:5 - 69:7 74:14 - 75:23 76:3 - 76:12 81:25 - 82:2 99:7 - 99:9 99:21 - 100:2 101:20 - 101:23 104:1 - 104:11 127:22 - 129:23 129:25 - 129:25 130:2 - 130:8 134:9 - 135:4 135:12 - 136:1

V, 30b6 V, 30b6 V, 30b6 402, 403, AA, 30b6, 702 402, 403

61:11 - 61:22 68:8 - 68:20

94:25 - 96:4 96:14 - 96:18 96:21 - 99:3 100:3 - 100:5 101:4 - 101:16 101:24 - 102:2 102:4 - 102:5 102:8 - 102:16 103:1 - 103:13 104:12 - 106:24 113:11 - 113:16 114:10 - 114: 12 123:24 - 127:5 134:5 - 134:8 136:2 - 136:5 137:11 137:13

5

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF JOSEPH D'AVANZO ON DECEMBER 7, 2011
Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

138:2 - 138:23 139:21 - 141:13 141:15 - 142:4 154:17 - 154:25 155:2 - 155:10 156:10 - 156:13 156:15 - 156:16 156:18 - 156:22 156:24 - 156:24 157:14 - 157:17 157:19 - 157:20 157:22 - 157:25

AA AA, 104a, 402 104a, 402, 611c 701 402 104a, 402, 602, 701 104a, 402, 602, 701 104a, 402, 602, 701 104a, 402, 602, 701 402 402 402

84:12 - 84:22 88:16 - 90:1

6

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF SUNIL DALUVOY ON JANUARY 14, 2011 Google generally objects to the designation of any of Mr. Daluvoy testimony based on Federal Rule of Evidence 402 and 403 as irrelevant and unfairly prejudicial because Bedrock's damages expert does not rely on any of the revenue information in his report and on the ground that this licensing information offered by Bedrock is irrelevant under the Federal Circuit's decision in ResQNet.com, Inc. v. Lansa, Inc., 594 F.3d 860 (Fed. Cir. 2010). Google further objects generally because this testimony is subject to the Court's ruling on a pending motion in limine. In addition to these general objections, Google further objects as indicated below:

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

5:6 - 5:8 5:13 - 5:20 23:18 - 24:10 24:17 - 24:18 24:20 - 25:2 25:19 - 25:21 25:23 - 25:24 33:14 - 33:19 34:4 - 34:9 34:11 - 34:11 34:13 - 34:15 43:9 - 43:11 43:16 - 43:17

402 5:21 - 6:2 104a, 30b6, 402 V, 104a, 30b6, 402 V, 104a, 30b6, 402 104a, 30b6, 402 104a, 30b6, 402

26:5 - 26:23 30:18 - 31:19 41:17 - 41:19 41:21 - 42:5 42:12 - 42:21 42:23 - 43:3

104a, 501, 30b6, 402, V, 602 104a, 501, 30b6, 402, V, 602

7

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF ALEXEY KUZNETSOV ON JANUARY 27, 2011
Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

75:2 - 76:5 76:7 - 77:15 78:2 - 78:7 78:19 - 78:22 78:25 - 79:3 79:5 - 79:8 79:10 - 79:13 79:16 - 80:22 80:24 - 81:15 86:10 - 86:21 94:21 - 95:1 95:3 - 95:5 95:7 - 95:10 95:18 - 95:21 98:8 - 98:14 98:16 - 98:24

AA, 402, 403 AA, 402, 403 402, 403 A, 403, CC, 104a A, 403, CC, 104a A, 403, CC, 104a A, 403, CC, 104a 402, 403, 104a 401, 402, 104a 401, 402, AA 401, 402, AA A, AA, 403, 701, MIL A, AA, 403, 701, 802, MIL, CD CD A, 403 A, 403 403, 701, 802, DI 403, 701, 104a, MIL, V 403, 701, 104a, MIL 802, 104a, 701, 602, MIL, DI, V 802, 104a, 701, 602, MIL, DI, V AA, 402, 403,

64:7 - 64:23 73:22 - 74: 3

81:16 - 82:19 86:24 - 86:25 87:2 - 87:8 87:10 - 87:13 87:15 - 88:3 95:22 - 97:20

99:1 - 99:1 100:9 - 100:18 100:20 - 101:10 101:22 - 102:2 102:9 - 102:11 102:13 - 102:13 104:5 - 104:8 104:10 - 104:10 107:1 - 107:2

102:3 102:5 - 102:7 102:14 - 102:16 102:18 - 102:20 104:11 104:13 - 105:5

8

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

107:4 - 107:4 108:1 - 108:2 108:4 - 108:14 108:16 - 108:18 109:5 - 109:6 109:8 - 109:11 110:18 - 111:9

701, 802, DI AA, 402, 403, 701, 802, DI 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403

107:6 108:19 - 108:20 108:24- 109:4 109:12 - 109:3 109:15 - 109:20 111:19 - 112:18 114:13 - 114:17 115:5 - 115:9 115:11 - 115:13 115:15 - 115:18 115:23 - 115:25 116:7 - 116:9

9

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF DAMIAN MENSCHER ON JANUARY 14, 2011 Google generally objects to the designation of any of Mr. Menscher's testimony based on Federal Rule of Evidence 802 as hearsay to the extent he testifies at trial. In addition to these general objections, Google further objects as indicated below:

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

5:6 - 6:1 7:18 - 8:8 9:8 - 9:13 10:4 - 10:9 10:14 - 10:19 11:4 - 11:12 11:21 - 11:25 12:20 - 12:22 13:3 - 13:4 25:1 - 25:5 25:7 - 25:9 26:11 - 26:12 26:14 - 26:15 26:17 - 26:18 26:20 - 26:22 26:24 - 26:25 27:2 - 27:3 27:5 - 27:7 27:9 - 27:13 27:15 - 27:19 27:21 - 27:22 27:25 - 28:4 28:6 - 28:7 28:9 - 28:12 28:14 - 28:18 28:23 - 29:5

402, 403 402 402, 403, 501 402, 403, 501 AA, 402, 403, 501 402 402, 403, 501 402, 403, 501 30b6, 103, 104a, 402 30b6, 103, 104a, 402 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a V, CD, 30b6, 104a V, CD, 30b6, 104a 103, 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a 30b6, 104a V, 30b6, 103 V, 30b6, 103 V, 30b6, 103 V, 30b6, 103

10

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

29:7 - 29:9 29:10 - 29:16 30:10 - 30:11 30:13 - 30:14 30:16 - 30:18 31:13 - 31:14 31:16 - 31:18 31:20 - 32:1 32:24 - 35:11 44:21 - 44:24 46:22 - 47:12 47:14 - 47:16 47:18 - 47:20 47:22 - 47:22 58:3 - 58:12 58:14 - 58:15 58:17 - 58:24 59:1 - 59:1 59:4 - 59:13 59:16 - 59:18 59:20 - 59:21 59:23 - 60:1 61:10 - 61:10 61:12 - 61:13 61:15 - 62:24 64:25 - 65:2 66:19 - 67:11 67:17 - 68:13 69:15 - 70:3 73:12 - 73:13 73:15 - 73:16 73:18 - 73:21 73:23 - 73:25

30b6, 103, 104a 30b6, 103, 104a V, 30b6, 104a V, 30b6, 104a V, 30b6, 104a V

30:18

V, C 103, 602 602 602 602

103, 104a, 403, 602, 30b6, 402 103, 104a, 403, 602, 30b6, 402 103, 104a, 403, 602, 30b6, 402 402

35:19 35:21 35:23 - 36:20 36:22 - 36:25 37:2 - 37:4 37:9 - 37:18 42:10 42:12 - 42:13 47:24 - 48:9 48:11 48:13 - 49:1 49:16 - 49:17 49:21 - 50:3 50:9 - 50:24 52:19 - 54:19 55:19 - 56:9 56:18 - 58:2 60:2 - 61:5 63:15 - 63:16 63:19 - 63:20 74:14 - 75:23

30b6, 602, 104a 30b6, 602, 104a

11

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF TRISHA WEIR ON JANUARY 13, 2011 Google generally objects to the designation of any of Ms. Weir's testimony based on Federal Rule of Evidence 802 as hearsay to the extent she testifies at trial. In addition to these general objections, Google further objects as indicated below:

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

5:7 - 5:9 5:19 - 5:23 6:18 - 7:6 11:11 - 12:1 17:17 - 17:18 17:22 - 17:25 18:4 - 18:10 20:19 - 20:22 27:15 - 27:17 32:12 - 34:18 47:12 - 47:14 47:16 - 47:18 48:11 - 48:13 51:9 - 52:7 54:15 - 54:16 54:18 - 54:18 56:13 - 56:23 57:17 - 57:19 57:22 - 57:23 62:23 - 63:13 65:2 - 65:3 65:5 - 65:6 66:20 - 66:24 73:8 - 73:11 73:18 - 73:24

30b6, 602, 103 30b6, 602, 103 30b6, 602, 103 103, 104a 103, 30b6 CD CD

104a, 103 104a, 103 V, 30b6, MIL, 402, 403 104a, 402, 403, MIL 104a, 402, 403, MIL 30b6, 402, 403, MIL, 104a AA, 30b6, 602 30b6, 602, 402, 403 402, 104a, 30b6 V, 402, 104a, 30b6

7:8 - 7:11 8:11 - 11:10 12:2 - 12:15 13:3 - 13:11 13:25 - 14:14 18:12 - 19:3 26:22 - 27:14 27:18 - 29:2 29:4 - 24:17 30:21 - 32:4 46:23 - 47:11 47:20 - 48:4 48:6 - 48:9 48:14 - 48:20 53:15 - 54:14 55:2 - 55:9 55:20 - 55:22 55:24 - 56:11 56:24 57:2 57:13 - 57:16 58:11 58:20 64:20 - 64:24 66:5 - 66:7

12

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

74:20 - 75:9 83:4 - 83:7 84:24 - 85:4 85:6 - 85:6 85:18 - 85:20 85:23 - 85:23 94:3 - 94:22 95:10 - 95:11 95:13 - 95:16 98:12 - 98:21

602, 402, 104a, 30b6 30b6, 103 30b6, 602 30b6, 602

66:9 - 66:16 72:25 - 73:2 73:4 - 73:6 73:12 - 73:13 73:15 - 73:16 73:25 - 74:3 74:13 - 74:19 83:10 - 83:19 87:19 - 89:4 90:11 - 91:2 97:21 - 98:11

30b6, 104a, 103 30b6, 602, MIL 30b6, 602, MIL

13

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION OF MIKHAIL LOTVIN ON JUNE 4, 2010
Bedrock's Objections to Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

Bedrock's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Bedrock's Responses to Defendants' Objections

Defendants' Rebuttal Designations

244:16 - 244:17 244:19 244:21 - 245:2 245:6 - 245:17 245:19 - 245:25

14