WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al

Filing 357

Exhibit List DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF WI-LAN'S FIRST AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST by Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Ericsson Inc., Exedea INC., HTC America, Inc., HTC Corporation, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Defendants' Objections to Wi-LAN's First Amended Trial Exhibit Lis)(Deoras, Akshay)

Exhibit A

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION

WI-LAN INC.,
Plaintiff
V
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC., et al
Defendants

§
§
§
§
§
§

Civil Action No. 6:10-CV-00521-LED
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF WI-LAN’S FIRST AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 1 of 25

Presiding
Judge:
LEONARD
DAVIS

Plaintiff’s Attorney(s):
David B. Weaver
Avelyn Marie Ross
Ajeet P. Pai
Syed K. Fareed
Jeffrey T. Han
Seth A. Lindner
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
2801 Via Fortuna, Suite 100
Austin, Texas 78746
Steven R. Borgman
Gwendolyn Johnson Samora
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
1001 Fannin
Suite 2500
Houston, Texas 77002
Constance S. Huttner
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
666 Fifth Avenue
26th Floor
New York, New York 10103

Pre Trial
Hearing –
03/21/2012

Court Reporter:

Defendant’s Attorneys:
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA
INC.
Michael E. Jones
Allen F. Gardner
John F. Bufe
POTTER MINTON PC
110 N. College
Suite 500
P.O. Box 359
Tyler, Texas 75710-0359
Gregory S. Arovas
Robert A. Appleby
Jeanne M. Heffernan
Akshay S. Deoras
Ryan P. Kane
KIRKLAND & ELLIS, LLP
601 Lexington Avenue
New York, New York 10022

Courtroom Deputy:
Rosa Ferguson

Jury Selection –
04/01/2012
** Categories: (A) - Will Use; (B) - May Use; (C) Probably Won’t Use

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 2 of 25

TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM
ERICSSON and ERICSSON INC.
Bruce S. Sostek
Richard L. Wynne, Jr.
Adrienne E. Dominguez
J. Michael Heinlen
Timothy E. Hudson
Justin S. Cohen
THOMPSON & KNIGHT LLP
1722 Routh Street
Suite 1500
Dallas, Texas 75201-2533
William J. Cornelius
Jennifer Parker Ainsworth
WILSON ROBERTSON & CORNELIUS
PC
909 ESE Loop 323
Suite 400
P.O. Box 7339
Tyler, Texas 75711-7339

SONY MOBILE
COMMUNICATIONS
AB and SONY MOBILE
COMMUNICATIONS
(USA) INC.
Bruce S. Sostek
Richard L. Wynne, Jr.
Adrienne E. Dominguez
J. Michael Heinlen
Timothy E. Hudson
Justin S. Cohen
THOMPSON & KNIGHT LLP
1722 Routh Street
Suite 1500
Dallas, Texas 75201-2533
William J. Cornelius
Jennifer Parker Ainsworth
WILSON ROBERTSON &
CORNELIUS PC
909 ESE Loop 323
Suite 400
P.O. Box 7339
Tyler, Texas 75711-7339

HTC CORPORATION;
HTC AMERICA, INC.; and
EXEDEA INC.
Stephen S. Korniczky
Martin R. Bader
Daniel N. Yannuzi
Lee Hsu
Graham M. Buccigross
SHEPPARD, MULLIN, RICHTER
& HAMPTON
12275 El Camino Real
Suite 200
San Diego, California 92130
Eric Hugh Findlay
Roger Brian Craft
FINDLAY CRAFT
6760 Old Jacksonville
Highway
Suite 101
Tyler, Texas 75703

USP 6,088,326

WIL-0009775

WIL-0009807

07/11/2000

R; 403; A

2

USP 6,195,327

WIL-0009808

WIL-0009842

02/27/2001

R; 403; A

3

USP 6,222,819

WIL-0009843

WIL-0009876

04/24/2001

R; 403; A

4

USP 6,381,211

WIL-0009877

WIL-0009908

04/30/2002

A

5

Handwritten excerpts from engineering logbooks

AIRSPAN 01608

AIRSPAN 01639

1995-1997

R; M; H; V;
403; 901

6

DSC Communications Corporation Invention Disclosure Form

AS 00021

AS 00027

10/06/1995

R; 403; H; A; F;
V; 901; BE

7

DSC Communications Corporation Invention Disclosure Form

AS 00034

AS 00037

10/06/1995

R; 403; H; A; F;
V; 901; BE

8

DSC Communications Corporation Invention Disclosure Form

AS 00038

AS 00044

10/06/1995

R; 403; H; A; F;
V; 901; BE

9

Discussion paper on a low rate CDMA extension to AS60 by
Martin Lysejko

AS 00394

AS 00398

10/21/1995

R; 403; 901; H;
V

10

Memo from Martin Lysejko to Paul Struhsaker

AS 00411

AS 00412

10/24/1995

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

11

Trinity ASIC Review 16/17/ November 1995 by Marin Lysejko

AS 00399

AS 00401

11/22/1995

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

12

Airspan 60 –Demand Assignment System Design Specification

AS 00402

AS 00410

1/30/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

13

E-mail from Martin Lysejko to Paul Struhsaker regarding
AS60-DA spec. attaching raw draft of Airspan 60 - Demand
Assignment System Design Specification

AS 00010

AS 00019

02/07/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V; I

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 3 of 25

Admitted

1

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

14

E-mail from Martin Lysejko to Paul Struhsaker, cc: I. Cooper;
J. Yeung regarding CDMA waveform extensions

AS 00020

AS 00020

02/26/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

15

Trinity ASIC: Functional Requirement Specification

AS 00362

AS 00374

7/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

16

AS60 CDMA Waveform Enhancements

AS 00375

AS 00393

9/11/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V; BE

17

System description of Airspan Wireless Fixed Access System

AS 01448

AS 01486

10/12/1996

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V

18

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '819 patent

WIL-0296648

WIL-0296799

R; 403; H; M;
F; A; V; 901

19

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '327 patent

WIL-0296800

WIL-0296899

R; 403; H; F; A;
901; M; V

20

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '326 & '211 patents

WIL-0297328

WIL-0297474

R; 403; H; F; A;
901; M; V

21

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '819 patent

WIL-0296755

WIL-0296774

12/05/1996

R; 403; H; F; A;
901; M; V; BE

22

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '326 & '211 patents

WIL-0297417

WIL-0297474

12/05/1996

R; 403; H; F; A;
901; M; V; BE

23

Prosecuting atty's files for UK version of '327 patent

WIL-0296874

WIL-0296889

12/05/1996

R; 403; H; F; A;
901; M; V; BE

24

WCDMA evolved - high speed packet-data—Ericsson White
Paper

WIL-0140758

WIL-0140767

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 4 of 25

R; 403; 901; H;
26(a); A; F

Admitted

Objection

3G Evolution, HSPA and LTE for Mobile Broadband –
[specific bates ranges cited to: 674-688; 794; 823-828; 841-899
and 1279-1304]
"HSPA, the Undisputed Choice for Mobile Broadband,”
Ericsson White Paper

WIL-0000674

WIL-0001324

00/00/2008

R; 403; H; A;
901; 703

WIL-0007374

WIL-0007392

02/2009

R; 403; ILL; D;
S; 703; H; A; F

27

"Basic Concepts of HSPA,” Ericsson White Paper

WIL-0007393

WIL-0007412

02/2007

R; 403; D; 703;
H; A; F

28

“Understand HSPA - High-Speed Packet Access for UMTS,”
Qualcomm presentation

WIL-0007552

WIL-0007599

2006

R; 403; 901; H;
F; V; 703; A

29

Lucent PowerPoint slides titled "2004 Bell Labs President's
Award, Lucent's HSDPA Initiative

ALUWL00327449

ALUWL00327468

30

3GPP TS 25.212 v6.10.0 (2006-12) Technical Specification
[specific bates ranges cited to: 389-395 and 447-453]

WIL-0278389

WIL-0278472

31

3GPP Technical Specification, 3GPP TR 25.848 – [specific
bates ranges cited to: 473-484]

WIL-0278473

WIL-0278561

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

32

3GPP Technical Specification, 3GPP TR 25.858

WIL-0278562

WIL-0278592

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

33

3GPP TS 25.104 v6.18.0 (2009-05) Technical Specification
[specific bates ranges cited to: 593-605]

WIL-0278593

WIL-0278655

05/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

34

3GPP TS 25.201 v6.2.0 (2005-06) Technical Specification

WIL-0278656

WIL-0278670

06/05/2005

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

35

3GPP TS 25.211 v6.10.0 (2009-09), Technical Specification –
[specific bates ranges cited to: 671-715]

WIL-0278671

WIL-0278721

09/09/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

26

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 5 of 25

Offered

END BATES NO.

Marked

BEG BATES NO.

25

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

R; 403; H; A; F;
U
12/00/2006

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

36

3GPP TS 25.302 v6.8.0 (2006-09) Technical Specification –
[specific bates ranges cited to: 814-842]

WIL-0278814

WIL-0278886

09/00/2006

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

37

3GPP TS 25.306 v6.13.0 (2006-03) Technical Specification –
[specific bates ranges cited to: 887-913]

WIL-0278887

WIL-0278920

03/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

38

3GPP TS 25.308 v6.4.0 (2007-03) Technical Specification

WIL-0278921

WIL-0278949

03/00/2007

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

39

3GPP TS 25.321 v6.18.0 (2009-03) Technical Specification –
[specific bates ranges cited to: 950-016]

WIL-0278950

WIL-0279044

03/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

40

3GPP TS 25.331 Technical Specification – [specific bates
ranges cited to: 047-073; 135-138; 437-438; 573-575]

WIL-0279045

WIL-0279575

41

3GPP TS 23.107 v6.4.0 (2006-03) Technical Specification

WIL-0280380

WIL-0280419

03/00/2006

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

42

Alcatel-Lucent 9311 Macro Node B Outdoor Product
Description

ALUWL00026589

ALUWL00026655

11/04/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

43

HSDPA System Specification

ALUWL00064541

ALUWL00064741

05/28/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

44

HLC_UA06.0 High Level Compliance to 3GPP specifications

ALUWL00089611

ALUWL00089650

09/21/2007

R; 403; I; H; A;
F; U

45

UA07.1 High Level Compliance to 3GPP specifications

ALUWL00088494

ALUWL00088534

10/10/2009

R; 403; I; H; A;
F; U

46

UA07.1 High Level Compliance to 3GPP specifications

ALUWL00326337

ALUWL00326377

09/30/2010

R; 403; I; C; H;
A; F; U

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 6 of 25

R; 403; H; A; F;
901; 703

UA07.1 High Level Compliance to 3GPP specifications

ALUWL00091852

48

UA8.1 High Level Compliance to 3GPP specifications

49

3G Evolution Towards High Speed Downlink Packet Access
Haberland, Bloch and Braun, Alcatel Telecommunications
Review - 4th Quarter 2003/1st Quarter 2004
Alcatel-Lucent – Embedded Test Mode for HSUPA [xCEM
modem diagram]

50

Admitted

47

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

ALUWL00091892

09/30/2010

R; 403; I; C; H;
A; F; U

ALUWL00093719

ALUWL00093759

05/30/2011

R; 403; I; H; A;
F; U

WIL-0280298

WIL-0280308

ALUWL00294618

ALUWL00294638

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

R; 403; A; F; H
10/00/2007

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

51

Overview of the OneChip Plus Channel Element – [Marc
Shelton – Emad Farag] [OC+ diagram]

ALUWL00300793

ALUWL00300812

52

Alcatel-Lucent – OC Plus Channel Element Architect For
WCDMA [Emad Farag] [eCEM modem diagram]

ALUWL00321386

ALUWL00321411

12/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

53

Alcatel-Lucent – WCDMA UCUIII Evolution Workshop –
11wk03 in MH Workshop Readout [UCU-III modem diagram]

ALUWL00324351

ALUWL00324375

01/21/2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

54

Alcaltel-Lucent University document

WIL-0277716

WIL-0277824

2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
ID

55

Algorithms Specification for OneChip TX (Downlink
Transmitter) - Issue 01

ALUWL00183382

ALUWL00183463

11/05/2002

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

56

Algorithms Specification for Packet Data Physical Layer
Resource Management Algorithms for HSDPA - Version 4.0

ALUWL00189972

ALUWL00190079

08/18/2004

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

57

MAC-hs Algorithms in Release U5 –

ALUWL00243922

ALUWL00243962

01/10/2007

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 7 of 25

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Admitted

Objection

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

END BATES NO.

58

Technical Note for NodeB MAC HSDPA

ALUWL00264144

ALUWL00264358

59

Deoras Ltr to Fareed re 08-30-12 Ltr

60

picoChip Response to ALU RFQ for Femtocell

ALUWL00251024

ALUWL00251073

61

Alcatel-Lucent 9360 Small Cell Solution for the Enterprise

ALUWL00094268

ALUWL00094277

2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

62

Alcatel-Lucent 9360 Small Cell Solution for the Home

ALUWL00094288

ALUWL00094295

2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

63

Alcatel-Lucent 9361 Home Cell V2

WIL-0277881

WIL-0277882

2011

R; 403; A; H; F

64

Alcatel-Lucent 9361 V2 Home Cell

ALUWL00097767

ALUWL00097768

2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

65

Alcatel-Lucent 9361 Home Cell V2 Product Description

ALUWL00106180

ALUWL00106198

04/11/2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

66

9362 ENTERPRISE CELL V1 .5 21 OOMHz WCDMA Product Description

ALUWL00094219

ALUWL00094236

12/17/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

67

Alcatel-Lucent 9362 Enterprise Cell V2.2

WIL-0277867

WIL-0277868

2012

R; 403; A; H; F

68

Alcatel-Lucent 9362 Enterprise Cell V2

ALUWL00096024

ALUWL00096025

2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

69

Alcatel-Lucent 9362 Enterprise Cell V1.5 Product Description

ALUWL00094219

ALUWL00094236

12/17/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

70

Alcatel-Lucent 9363 Metro Cell Indoor V2

WIL-0277871

WIL-0277872

2011

R; 403; A; H; F

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 8 of 25

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

4/25/2012

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

09/04/2012

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

R; 403; V; I; H;
A; F
R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Admitted

Objection

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

END BATES NO.

71

Alcatel-Lucent 9363 Metro Cell Indoor V2

ALUWL00096022

ALUWL00096023

2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

72

Alcatel-Lucent 9363 Metro Cell Indoor Product Description

ALUWL00094158

ALUWL00094174

02/01/2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

73

Alcatel-Lucent 9364 Metro Cell Outdoor Product Description

ALUWL00094717

ALUWL00094733

01/01/2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

74

PC8219-202 / PC8219E-202 Product Datasheet

MDSPD001213

MDSPD001274

02/2010

R; 403; H; A; F

75

PC8229 - 323 Product Brief

MDSPD001275

MDSPD001279

5/24/2011

R; 403; 901; H;
A; F

76

PC8209-302 / PC8219-312 Product Datasheet

MDSPD001280

MDSPD001337

2011

R; 403; H; A; F

77

PC8209-302 Product Brief - 4-User HSPA Fentocell

MDSPD001338

MDSPD001343

78

BSR Femto White Paper

ALUWL00110183

ALUWL00110197

01/2000

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

79

Alcatel-Lucent 9360 Small Cell - RELEASE # BCR 2.4 - Sales
Brief

ALUWL00097714

ALUWL00097719

02/2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

80

“BSR_Product_Structure_Call_2009-10-29” Spreadsheet

ALUWL00102157

ALUWL00102157

NATIVE

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

81

Base Station Router BSR Femto Feature Planning Guide BCR
2.1

ALUWL00101677

ALUWL00101738

05/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

82

Base Station Router Femto Feature Planning Guide BCR 2.2

ALUWL00102009

ALUWL00102041

09/00/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 9 of 25

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

R; 403; 901; H;
A; F

MAC-hs / MAC-e Scheduler Configuration - Version: 0.1

ALUWL00148649

84

Picochip PowerPoint slides titled "Agenda - HSDPA"

85

Admitted

83

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

ALUWL00148660

05/22/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

ALUWL00151299

ALUWL00151309

2011

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Picochip PowerPoint slides titled "PicoChip MAC-hs / MAC-e
Schedulers"

ALUWL00251220

ALUWL00251228

05/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

86

AT&T - Mobility Technology Lifecycle Management
Organization Feature Request Form

ALUWL00028572

ALUWL00028581

08/07/2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

87

Alcatel-Lucent Presentation titled "W-CDMA AT&T Node B
Program Review"

ALUWL00056657

ALUWL00056739

8/19/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

88

Alcatel-Lucent PowerPoint slides titled "MGR PL and AT&T
CT Strategy meeting"

ALUWL00057453

ALUWL00057538

2006

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

89

The potential market for small cell services Establishing a
femto cell service in American households

ALUWL00097175

ALUWL00097178

2009

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

90

Alcatel-Lucent Technologies PowerPoint presentation titled
"HSDPA: A Step in UMTS Evolution"

ALUWL00193833

ALUWL00193886

91

Bell Mobility Femtocell Specifications, Version 1.0 – [specific
bates ranges cited to: 741-840]

ALUWL00109741

ALUWL00109997

92

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.214

ERICSSON00547267

ERICSSON00547278

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

93

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.321

ERICSSON00547279

ERICSSON00547293

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 10 of 25

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

R; 403; F; H; A;
U
06/16/2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

12/14/2006

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

94

WCDMA R5 and GSM R12 - 3GPP Statement of Compliance

ERICSSON00547294

ERICSSON00547427

95

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.104

ERICSSON00547460

ERICSSON00547473

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

96

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.212

ERICSSON00547574

ERICSSON00547589

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

97

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.331

ERICSSON00547607

ERICSSON00547735

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

98

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.213

ERICSSON00547802

ERICSSON00547808

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

99

UTRAN P5 CNP – Statement of Compliance to TS 25.211

ERICSSON00547809

ERICSSON00547817

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

100 HSDPA Overview WCDMA RAN USER DESCRIPTION

ERICSSON00553417

ERICSSON00553435

03/04/2008

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

101 HSDPA User Plane WCDMA RAN User Description

ERICSSON00677993

ERICSSON00678039

06/30/2008

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

102 QoS Handling: User Description

ERICSSON00787593

ERICSSON00787611

12/09/2010

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

103 AT&T WCDMA RAN License Status – Up to and Including

ERICSSON00835826

ERICSSON00835826

NATIVE

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

104 Appendix U5 UMTS RAN Features Technical Specifications

ERICSSON00838447

ERICSSON00838481

08/11/2006

V; F; 403; H; I;
A; R; U

WCDMA W12B

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 11 of 25

ERICSSON01112136

106 Spreader & Weighting, AURORA ASIC

Admitted

105 DS for SPR Block in CROWN

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

ERICSSON01112159

12/08/2005

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

ERICSSON01112211

ERICSSON01112238

08/14/2008

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

107 Library Overview RBS3000 Description

ERICSSON00008724

ERICSSON00008749

09/17/2008

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

108 Unit Description, TX Board Description

ERICSSON00327957

ERICSSON00327967

09/29/2006

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

109 E/// – RBS and Baseband

ERICSSON00734715

ERICSSON00734731

04/12/2011

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

110 Digital Unit Description

ERICSSON00816360

ERICSSON00816371

10/11/2010

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

111 Library Overview RBS 6000 Description

ERICSSON00824968

ERICSSON00824988

09/21/2011

V; F; 403; R; H;
A; U

112 80-V7864-27A Rev C – Modem Core (MSM7600™)

QC1WILAN521D0000001

QC1WILAN521D0000318

12/12/2006

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

113 80-V7864-31 A Rev. A – Artemis Modem Core (MCDO)

QC1WILAN521D0000319

QC1WILAN521D0001150

01/10/2007

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

114 UMTS "Athena" Modem (MSM7200) HLD

QC1WILAN521D0001424

QC1WILAN521B0002139

10/30/2006

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

115 NikeLT Core

QC1WILAN521D0002140

QC1WILAN521D0003365

5/2012

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 12 of 25

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

QCWILAN521D0001340

QCWILAN521D0001423

11/7/2008

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

QUALCOM0000983

QUALCOM0001096

08/06/2009

V; F; 403; 901;
H; 703; A

SEMC00028819

SEMC00029060

00/00/2009

V; F; 403; R; H;
A

119 HTC Devices with Processors [Summary Document]

WIL-0300461

WIL-0300463

120 AT&T Device Requirements document – [specific bates ranges

HTC00162727

HTC00163952

121 Shift – Feature Sheet

HTC00179995

HTC00179996

122 E-mail from Prashant Watchmaker to David Brant, cc:

WIL-0172617

WIL-0172718

116 Poseidon 2 Modem Core High Level Design
117 Qualcomm QSD8250/QSD8650 Snapdragon User Guide
118 Implementation Conformance Statement for Ericsson Mobile

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

Platform U365 Test Report

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

U; R; 403
03/14/2008

cited to: 727-728; 777; 783-788; 871-876; 889-898]

R; F; 901;
26(a); 403; H
R; F; 901;
26(a); 403

05/20/2009

[e-mail]; Paul Ackerman; Curt Dodd;
William Middleton; Deborah Smyth regarding Airspan / WiLAN attaching agreements and patent assignment document
123 Declaration of Per Beming

R; 403; M; ILL;
F; H; 901; A

03/26/2012

R; 403; H

124 Deposition - Wi-LAN's Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition to

06/19/2012

R; 403

11/14/2012

V; 403; R; H;
A; F

11/14/2012

R; 403; H; A; F

11/14/2012

R; 403; H; A; F

Defendants HTC Corporation, HTC America, Inc., and Exedea
Inc.
125 Discovery - Sony Mobile 1st Amended Objections and
Responses to Wi-LAN 1st Individual Request For Admissions
[1-8]
126 Discovery - A-L Objections and Responses to Wi-LAN 1st
Individual Request for Admissions [1-10]
127 Discovery - A-L Objections and Responses to Wi-LAN 2nd
Common Request for Admissions [5-10]
Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 13 of 25

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

128 Discovery - Ericsson Defendants Objections and Responses to

11/14/2012

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

129 Discovery - Ericsson Defendants Objections and Responses to

11/14/2012

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

130 Discovery - Ericsson Responses to Written Questions re HDL

09/14/2012

V; F; 403; H; A;
R

131 Discovery - Ericsson's Responses to Wi-LAN's Follow-Up

09/20/2012

V; F; 403; H; A;
F; R

132 Discovery - HTC Objections and Responses to Wi-LAN 1st

11/14/2012

R; 403

133

11/14/2012

R; 403

02/06/2013

V; 403; ; H; A;
F; R

02/12/2013

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

11/14/2012

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

06/19/2012

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

Wi-LAN 1st Individual Request for Admissions [1-10]
Wi-LAN 2nd Common Request for Admission [5-10]
Code

Questions Regarding HDL Code

134

135

136

Request for Admissions [1-7]
Discovery - HTC Objections and Responses to Wi-LAN 2nd
Common Request for Admissions [5-10]
Discovery - Sony Mobile Communications AB and Sony
Mobile Communications (USA) Inc.’s 4th Amended Responses
to Wi-LAN’s 1st Set of Discovery Requests and Appendix to
4th Amended Responses to Wi-LAN’s 1st Set of Discovery
Requests
Discovery - Sony Mobile Communications AB and Sony
Mobile Communications (USA) Inc.’s 5th Amended Responses
to Wi-LAN’s 1st Set of Discovery Requests
Discovery - Sony Mobile Objections and Responses to Wi-LAN
2nd Common Request for Admissions [5-10]

137 Discovery - Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson and Ericsson

Inc.’s 3rd Amended Responses to Wi-LAN’s 1st Set of
Discovery Requests

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 14 of 25

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

V; 403; H; A; F;
R
V; 403; H; A; F;
R

11/08/2012

R; 403

02/06/2013

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

02/06/2013

142 Discovery - Sony Mobile's 4th Amended Appendix to

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

08/21/2012

Inc.'s Responses to Wi-LAN's 2nd Set of Individual
Interrogatories [No. 2]
139 Discovery - Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson and Ericsson
Inc.'s 2nd Amended Responses to Wi-LAN's 3rd Set of
Individual Interrogatories [Nos. 3- 4]
140 Discovery - HTC Corporation, HTC America, Inc., and Exedea
Inc.’s 3rd Supplemental Response to Wi-LAN, Inc.’s 1st Set of
Discovery Requests to All Defendants
141 Discovery - Sony Mobile’s 4th Amended Responses to WiLAN’s 3rd Set of Individual Interrogatories [Nos. 3-4]

DATE

06/11/2012

138 Discovery - Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson and Ericsson

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

V; 403; H; A; F;
R

Defendants Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB and
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications (USA)'s 4th Amended
Responses to Wi-LAN's 3rd Set of Individual Interrogatories
[Nos. 3-4]
143 Excel spreadsheet, Invoice Per Quote UMTS

ALUWL00257895

ALUWL00257901

NATIVE

R; 403; M; ID;
MIL; H; A; F;
U

144 Purchase Order (No. 006783) from GTA Teleguam

ALUWL00257903

ALUWL00257906

12/20/2011

R; 403; ILL;
MIL; H; A; F;
U

145 Excel Spreadsheet, Invoice Summary for AT&T Mobility of

ALUWL00258457

ALUWL00258458

NATIVE

R; 403; M; ID;
MIL; H; A; F;
U

modem software and modem hardware for specified calendar
years

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 15 of 25

146 Excel Spreadsheet - invoicing data for U.S. sales for calendar

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

ALUWL00258459

ALUWL00258463

NATIVE

year 2008 for Pine Technologies, Excel Spreadsheet - invoicing
data for U.S. sales for Bug Tussel Wirless LLC, Global Wirless
Mgnt. Corp., and Pine Telephone Co., Excel Spreadsheet invoicing data for U.S. sales for Bug Tussel Wirless LLC, CT
Cube, Global Wirless Mgnt. Corp., New Core Wireless and
Pine Telephone Co.
147 Excel Spreadsheet - invoicing data for U.S. sales

R; 403; M; ID;
MIL; H; A; F;
U

ALUWL00258465

ALUWL00258467

NATIVE

R; 403; M; ID;
MIL; H; A; F;
U

148 Excel spreadsheet, WCDMA PL's Actuals

ALUWL00287868

ALUWL00287868

NATIVE

R; 403; MIL; H;
A; F; U

149 Small Cells Revenue 2012

ALUWL00325472

ALUWL00325472

NATIVE

R; 403; MIL; H;
A; F; U

ERICSSON00637463

ERICSSON00637468

151 Sales Data Spreadsheet

HTC00143865

HTC00144032

152 Texas Certificate of Termination

Lai Dep. Exh. 9

Lai Dep. Exh. 9

153 Sales Data Spreadsheet

HTC00146422

HTC00146731

154 HTC Sales Sheet

HTC00146732

HTC00146940

155 Sales Data Spreadsheet

HTC00147336

HTC00147342

R; 403; M

156 Sales figures

HTC00175297

HTC00175409

R; 403; M

157 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and General

WIL-0084447

WIL-0084465

150 High-Speed Downlink Packet Access HSDPA Product

V; F; 403; H; A;
F; U

Description

Mobile Inc.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 16 of 25

R; 403; M
12/30/2011

R; 403
R; 403; M

00/00/2008

08/20/2009

R; 403; M

R; 403; 408; R;
MIL; 703

WIL-0179387

159 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and Casio

Admitted

158 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and CalAmp

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

WIL-0179416

04/16/2010

R; 403; 408; R;
MIL; 703

WIL-0186815

WIL-0186830

06/30/2009

R; 403; 408; R;
MIL; 703

160 Nokia White Paper - Nokia HSDPA Solution

WIL-0192721

WIL-0192728

00/00/2003

R; 403; H; A; F

161 Nortel, HSDPA and Beyond - White Paper

WIL-0192729

WIL-0192756

162 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and Cal-

WIL-0202023

WIL-0202038

04/23/2010

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

163 Wi-Lan International Inc. Global Patent License Agreement

WIL-0202239

WIL-0202281

09/27/2010

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

164 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and

WIL-0202393

WIL-0202412

12/05/2011

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

165 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN Inc. and

WIL-0202440

WIL-0202465

12/31/2009

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

166 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN International

WIL-0202500

WIL-0202510

04/01/2010

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

167 License Agreement between Wi-LAN International Inc. and

WIL-0202583

WIL-0202613

01/01/2010

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

168 Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN International Inc.

WIL-0202614

WIL-0202630

12/21/2010

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

169 Settlement and Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN

WIL-0202781

WIL-0202800

01/26/2011

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

Corp.

Computer Co., Ltd..

R; 403; H; A; F

Comp Electronics and Communications Company Limited
between Wi-Lan Inc. and Huawei Technologies Company Ltd.
PureWave Networks, Inc.
RuggedCom Inc.

Japan Inc. and Sharp Corporation
ZTE Corp.

and LG Electronics Inc.

Inc. and Motorola Solutions Inc.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 17 of 25

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

WIL-0202831

WIL-0202853

01/27/2011

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

WIL-0237316

WIL-0237353

12/16/2008

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

172 Mobility Report 4Q07 by Dell'Oro Group - Market Summary &

WIL-0253146

WIL-0253289

02/13/2008

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

173 M25A_Mobility_Forecast_Report_Jan12.xls

WIL-0254381

WIL-0254381

01/25/2012
NATIVE

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

174 Settlement and DSL Patent License Agreement between Wi-

WIL-0269905

WIL-0269919

01/26/2011

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

175 Settlement and DSL Patent License Agreement between Wi-

170 Settlement and Patent License Agreement between Wi-LAN

Inc. and Motorola Mobility Holdings, Inc. and Motorola
Mobility, Inc.
171 PowerPoint presentation titled "EDGE, HSPA, LTE Broadband
Innovation" from 3G Americas Webinar

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

Vendor Information

LAN Inc. and Motorola Solutions, Inc.

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

WIL-0272144

WIL-0272161

01/27/2011

LAN Inc. and Motorola Mobility Holdings, Inc. and Motorola
Mobility, Inc.
176 IDC, Worldwide Quarterly Mobile Phone Tracker 2012Q2

R; 403; 408;
MIL; 703

WIL-0280505

WIL-0280548

09/06/2012

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

177 Rysavy Research, HSPA to LTE-Advanced: 3GPP Broadband

WIL-0284901

WIL-0285018

09/00/2009

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

178 Connectedplanetonline.com - HSDPA GSM's LONG ANSWER

WIL-0289605

WIL-0289607

05/17/2004

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

179 Eric Stasik, Royalty Rates And Licensing Strategies For

WIL-0293021

WIL-0293026

09/22/2010

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

WIL-0293575

WIL-0293608

04/00/2009

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

Evolution to IMT-Advanced (4G)
TO EV-DO

Essential Patents On LTE (4G) Telecommunication Standards
les Nouvelles
180 N. Van Zeebroeck, The Puzzle of Patent Value Indicators CEB
Working Paper No. 07/023, April 2009.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 18 of 25

181 Dell’Oro Group, Mobile RAN Report 2Q12 Vol 12(2).

WIL-0294406

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

08/13/2012

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

05/23/2011

R; 403; H

05/23/2011

182 Letter from R. Wynne to D. Weaver re CRA with Wi-LAN and

LM Ericsson
183 Letter from R. Wynne to D. Weaver re CRA with Wi-LAN and
SEMC USA
184 E-mail chain from David Brant to Martin Lysejko regarding
WiLAN Patent Analysis
185 Small Cells and WiFi A technical comparison - Technology
White Paper

Admitted

WIL-0294194

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

R; 403; H

AIRSPAN 01134

AIRSPAN 01135

04/07/2009

R; 403; V; H

ALUWL00097205

ALUWL00097212

2010

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

ERICSSON00678555

ERICSSON00678570

10/03/2007

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

AIRSPAN 00054

AIRSPAN 00082

04/30/2009

H

WIL-0286640

WIL-0286775

189 High Speed Packet Access on the Uplink, HSPA UL

ERICSSON00634779

ERICSSON00634798

01/15/2008

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

190 Settlement and License Agreement between Cypress

ERICSSON00838119

ERICSSON00838134

03/09/2012

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

191 Settlement and Non-Exclusive Patent License Agreement

ERICSSON00838155

ERICSSON00838169

01/28/2011

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

192 Amendment #1 to Limited Field of Use Patent License

ERICSSON00838270

ERICSSON00838271

07/01/2007

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

186 HSPA Vs. WiMAX (Extended) Questions and Answers
187 E-mail from Prashant Watchmaker to Paul Ackerman, cc: Curt

Dodd regarding Signed Final Agreements attaching executed
agreements between Wi-LAN Inc. and Airspan Networks Inc.
188 Airspan 2008 10-K part 1

R; 403; 703

Presentation

Semiconductor and Ericsson

between Ericsson Inc. and InNova Patent Licensing, LLC
Agreement between Ericsson and Telular

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 19 of 25

Admitted

ERICSSON01111944

Objection

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

ERICSSON01111975

01/01/2003

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

HTC00145454

HTC00145629

04/08/2011

R; 403; M; I; ID

HTC00145907

HTC00145924

02/24/2004

R; 403

SEMC00023655

SEMC00023716

197 Settlement and License Agreement between Datascape, Inc. and

SEMC00040859

SEMC00040871

05/25/2010

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

198 Settlement and License Agreement between WIAV Solutions,

SEMC00040940

SEMC00040974

11/09/2011

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

SEMC00040991

SEMC00040997

11/29/2011

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

WIL-0200257

WIL-0200267

12/21/2009

MacCrae regarding Airspan Patent Portfolio Valuation as of
December 31, 2009
201 Ericsson Annual Report 2011

R; 403; H; A

WIL-0225311

WIL-0225474

00/00/2012

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

202 Federal Communications Commission, Annual Report and

WIL-0280937

WIL-0281244

06/24/2011
Released
06/27/2011

R; 403; H; MIL;
703; 901

Corporation and Ericsson Inc. and Telefonaktiebolaget LM
Ericsson
194 Patent License and Settlement Agreement between Round Rock
Research, LLC and HTC Corporation
195 Settlement and License Agreement between Digcom and TMobile USA and HTC
196 PowerPoint presentation titled Menu, Portfolio Research, US
Lead Devices 2012

END BATES NO.

Offered

DATE

193 Patent License Agreement between Interdigital Technology

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB

LLC, and Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB and
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications (USA) Inc
199 Settlement and License Agreement between HW Technology,
LC and Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB

200 Memorandum from Cory Houston to Shaun McEwan, cc: Doug

Analysis of Competitive Market Conditions with Respect to
Mobile Wireless, Including Commercial Mobile Services
Fifteenth Report, Adopted June 24, 2011.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 20 of 25

WIL-0289137

204 Damien Geradin & Anne Layne-Farrar, Patent Value

Admitted

203 Chintagunta et al., Wireless Carriers’ Exclusive Handset

Objection

END BATES NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

WIL-0289171

10/00/2011

R; 403; H; F; A;
I; MIL; 703;
901

WIL-0290572

WIL-0290601

01/21/2011

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL; 703; 901

WIL-0292076

WIL-0292138

04/11/2008

R; 403; H; F; A;
703; M; 901;
MIL

WIL-0292412

WIL-0292555

2012

R; 403; H; F; A;
703; 901

WIL-0293528

WIL-0293529

09/07/2009

R; 403; H; F; A;
703; 901

SEMC00040681

SEMC00040715

12/22/2008

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

209 Patent License Agreement between Interdigital Technology

SEMC00040814

SEMC00040848

1/1/2003

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F

210 Email string between Andrew Parolin and James Mahon

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

Arrangements: An Empirical Look at the iPhone, Net Institute
Working Paper No. 11-35, October 2011.

Apportionment Rules for Complex, Multi-Patent Products Santa
Clara Computer and High Technology Law Journal
Symposium, January 21, 2011.
205 Qualcomm’s Response to Broadcom’s Letter to the Court dated
April 4, 2008, in re: Broadcom Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc., Case
No. 05-3350 (MLC) (JJH), U.S. District Court for the District
of New Jersey, April 11, 2008.
206 Rysavy 2012_09_Mobile_Broadband_Explosion
207 Nick Wood, Mobile data traffic growth 10 times faster than

fixed over next five years – Nokia Siemens Total Telecom,
September 7, 2009, available at
http://www.totaltele.com/view.aspx?ID=448681.
208 Patent License Agreement between Helferich Patent Licensing,
LLC and Sony-Ericsson Mobile Communications AB
Corporation and Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB

SEMC00015328

SEMC00015332

11/12/2007

regarding Sony-Ericsson - WiLAN Inc. proposal after meeting
on 11/12/07
211 Email between Jung Lee and Cory Houston regarding BelAir

R; 403; H; A; F;
U

WIL-0145333

WIL-0145333

11/14/2007

R; 403; H; F

212 Spreadsheet of Worldwide LAN Market – Service Provider

WIL-0086130

WIL-0086130

(Mesh Nodes)

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 21 of 25

R; 403; H; F; A;
MIL

WIL-0150660

WIL-0150660

214 Patent License Agreement between Alcatel Lucent and HTC

Admitted

213 Spreadsheet of Total Markets and Notebook Sales – North

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

R; 403; H; F;
MIL

America Sales

HTC00139536

HTC00139560

07/1/2004

Corporation
215 Patent License Agreement between Telefonakfiebolaget LM
Ericsson and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.

R; 403

ERICSSON00640687

ERICSSON00640701

06/29/2007

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

216 Patent License Agreement between Telefonaktiebolaget LM

ERICSSON00640673

ERICSSON00640686

12/18/2001

R; 403; MIL;
703; H; A; F; U

217 HSDPA, Competition: 2006-01-27 presentation

ERICSSON00637927

ERICSSON00637996

1/22/2006

R; 403; F; 703;
H; A; F; U

218 Letter from Ericsson to Cingular re Ericsson's Response to

ERICSSON00645134

ERICSSON00645136

7/16/2004

R; 403; F; 703;
H; A; F; U

ERICSSON00901075

ERICSSON00901083

2/14/2011

R; 403; F; 703;
I; H; A; F; U

220 LTE Product Supplement Financial Terms & Discounts

ERICSSON01111712

ERICSSON01111729

221 Office Action regarding Appl. No. 10/545,264 – [previously

Vecella Depo Exh. 97

Vecella Depo Exh. 97

8/2/2007

R; 403; MIL; A;
F

222 USP 7,359,359 – [previously produced at WIL-0278281 – 295]

Vecella Depo Exh. 96

Vecella Depo Exh. 96

4/15/2008

R; 403; MIL; A;
F

223 USP 7,920,469

WIL-0278296

WIL-0278306

4/5/2011

R; 403; F; MIL

224 US APP No. 11/424,352 - USPTO Office Communication -

WIL-0278272

WIL-0278280

09/18/2009

R; 403; F; I;
MIL

Ericsson and Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.

Cingular Wireless' Request for Proposal for UMTS
Infrastructure Equipment & Services
219 Ericsson PowerPoint presentation titled Mass Market Mobile
Broadband with Smartphones presentation

R; 403; F; 703;
H; A; F; U

produced WIL-0278315-326]

Inventory Shupeng Li

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 22 of 25

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

225 Bandwidth Bubble Bust: The rise and fall of the global telecom

WIL-0300377

WIL-0300451

2001

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; MIL; 703;
901; 26(a)

226 Jacobs's Patter: An Inventor's Promise Has Companies Taking

WIL-0300491

WIL-0300497

09/06/1996

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; MIL; 703;
901; 26(a)

WIL-0300464

WIL-0300490

10/06/1997

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; MIL; 703;
901; M; 26(a)

228 Over the Paradigm Cliff - Forbes February 24, 1997 - George

WIL-0300452

WIL-0300460

02/24/1997

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; MIL; 703;
901; 26(a)

229 Ericsson Video: HSPA

WIL-0300372

WIL-0300372

VIDEO

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; 901; 26(a)

230 Ericsson Video: The History of Mobile Broadband: You

WIL-0300373

WIL-0300373

VIDEO

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; 26(a)

231 Ericsson Video: The History of Mobile Broadband: Hype and

WIL-0300374

WIL-0300374

VIDEO

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; M; 901;
26(a)

232 Ericsson Video: The History of Mobile Broadband: Hard Times

WIL-0300375

WIL-0300375

VIDEO

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; 26(a)

233 Ericsson Video: The History of Mobile Broadband: HSPA To

WIL-0300376

WIL-0300376

VIDEO

R; 403; H; F; A;
U; 26(a)

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

industry” by Grahame Lynch

Big Cellular Gamble --- Qualcomm Boss's Innovation In
Digital-Phone System Is Problematic -- and Late --- Are Claims
Hope or Hype? By Quentin Hardy, Staff Reporter of The Wall
Street Journal
227 Light Speed Trap Ahead - Forbes October 6, 1997 - George
Gilder

Gilder

Always Need To Go Faster
Visions

The Rescue

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 23 of 25

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

Admitted

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

234 Expert Report of Jonathan Wells re infringement

9/21/2012

R; 403; H

235 Supplemental Expert Report of Jonathan Wells re infringement

10/5/2012

R; 403; H

236 Second Supplemental Expert Report of Jonathan Wells re

1/31/2013

infringement
237 Rebuttal Expert Report of Jonathan Wells re validity

R; 403; H

11/2/2012

R; 403; H

238 Expert Report of John Jarosz

10/3/2012

R; 403; H; MIL

239 Sony Mobile Defs' 3rd Amded Resp to Wi-LAN 3rd Individual

12/12/2012

R; 403; H; A; F

Interrogatories [3-4] and 3rd Amded Appendix WiLAN 3rd
Individual Interrogatories [3-4]
240 Email – Email from Andrew Parolin to Chris Godziela RE WiLAN’s 2nd quarter licensing activities and wireless acquisitions
241 1 Email – Email chain dated 11/12/07 from Andrew Parolin to
James Mahon regarding Sony Ericsson – Wi-LAN proposal
after meeting on 11/12/07
242 Email - Email chain dated 12/03/07 from Curt Dodd of Wi-LAN to
James Mahon of Sony Ericsson forwarding draft agreement
243 Email – Email chain dated 12/13/07 from Curt Dodd of Wi-

LAN to James Mahon of Sony Ericsson regarding revised
agreement
244 Email – Email chain dated 12/18/07 from Curt Dodd of WiLAN to James Mahon of Sony Ericsson regarding proposed
agreement language

1

WIL-0272692

WIL-0272696

WIL-0167608

WIL-0167611

11/12/2007

R, 403, F, 26(a),
V, 408, C, I, H

WIL-0167908
WIL-0300642

WIL-0167910
WIL-0300654

12/03/2007

R, 403, F, 26(a),
V, 408, C, I, H

WIL-0167947
WIL-0300655

WIL-0167951
WIL-0300668

12/13/2007

R, 403, F, 26(a),
V, 408, C, I, H

WIL-0187784

WIL-0187788

12/18/2007

R, 403, F, 26(a),
V, 408, C, I, H

R; 403; H

Defendants object to these exhibits because they were designated outside the deadline contained in the Docket Control Order. The issues purportedly addressed by the exhibits are not
new, nor are the documents newly discovered. Defendants reserve the right to assert additional objections to these belatedly-designated documents.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 24 of 25

245 Email – Email chain dated 01/14/08 from Curt Dodd of Wi-

LAN to James Mahon of Sony Ericsson forwarding revised
draft agreements

WIL-0167981
WIL-0300526

Wi-LAN reserves the right to use any exhibits identified on another party’s exhibit list.

Defendants’ Objections to Wi-LAN First Amended Trial Exhibit List - Page 25 of 25

Admitted

WIL-0167979
WIL-0300499

Objection

END BATES NO.

Offered

BEG BATES NO.

Marked

DESCRIPTION

Category

PLTF
EXH.
NO.

DATE

DEFENDANTS’
OBJECTIONS

01/14/2008

R, 403, F, 26(a),
V, 408, C, I, H