Tafas v. Dudas et al
Filing
174
AMICUS Brief Exhibits in Support of Plaintiffs Summary Judgment by Polestar Capital Associates, LLC, Norseman Group, LLC re 173 Amicus Brief , Exhibits 9-12 to Amici Brief in Support of Summary Judgment (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 9.1# 2 Exhibit 9.2# 3 Exhibit 9.3# 4 Exhibit 9.4# 5 Exhibit 9.5# 6 Exhibit 9.6# 7 Exhibit 10# 8 Exhibit 11# 9 Exhibit 12)(Franco, Craig) Modified text on 12/31/2007 (klau, ). Modified on 1/9/2008 to reflect Exhibits to Amicus Brief (klau, ).
<![CDATA[
Tafas v. Dudas et al
Doc. 174 Att. 7
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 1 of 52
Exhibit 10
Excerpts from production of "Administrative Record" by U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to Tafas Defendants
Dockets.Justia.com
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 2 of 52
REDACTEI)
From! Senh To: Cc: Subtece
---Odglnal Messåge--Cla¡ke Robe¡.t
Thursday, Maró 10,2005 4:05 PM Rolla, Joseph; Spar, Eob Bahr, Robert dahs and percentåges
I asked Toby to run stals to enswer J¡m Toupin's questions re the cla¡m numbers to exceed a comb¡ned threshotd.
Using claim data for newly serialized 2004 appl¡cations, the ficllow¡ng numbers represent certa¡n thresholds:
81.6010
of apPlicat¡ons heve 5 or fewer independent claims, 93% of appl¡cations have 6 or fewer independent claims.
87.23o/o o'l applications have 40 or fewer total claims, 93% of applications have
5l
or fewer total claims.
So a 6/51 limit would impact 7% of new applicat¡ons (without taking into account restrictions or related applications.). ln the attached file, in worksheet 2004 corps dala, column "F" ¡s the percentage of applications having f¡rst X (from column C) . independent and second Y total (column B) cla¡ms and Column 'iM" is ttrdperceiriage of appticatóns havi'ng Z totat claims (colum-n l). The attached file ¡s "huge" s¡nce it has a row for each combination oiindepààdent and depeñdent lf info from_a particular TC is desired, I have provided the data (without an analys¡s) aô worksheet -cLqim. "ClaimcountsbyTC
Clalm Counts by TC
for FYs 02-...
4003554
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 3 of 52
By lndepndent ola¡m
FY
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2001 200É 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
uj;".u*
1
2 3 4 5 6
7 8
I
10
11
12 13 14
t5
't6
17
'18
19
m
21
22 23 24 25 26 27
2A
29 30
31
32 33
34
35 36
37
38 39 40
41
42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
51
52 53
54
55
'"0;;"."*"t "",", I 5.915 1 2,032 1 2.849 '1 3.766 I 3,6s4 1 4,094 1 3,992 1 4,242 I 3,730 I 4,264 1 3,202 1 3,127 I 2,497 1 2,363 1 2,182 1 1,951 I 1,706 I 1,674 1 1,377 1 2,886 'I 1,028 1 832 1 673 I 674 1 560 1 488 1 427 'I 4t5 1 342 I 334 1 244 1 272 1 232 1 190 1 228 1 173 1 157 1 124 .1 102 1 114 t99 r 118 r64 188 161 r58 166 179 157 r45 145 'I 43 135 f36 136
Total counl
r¿ercnlaqe
Efective lndepsndent
Cla¡ms
1
Cleims
1 ,|
count
5,915 7,947 10,796 14,562 't8,216 22,310 26302 30.544 34,274 38,542 41,744 44,87 t 47,360 49,731 51,913 53,864 55,570 57,244 58,621 61,507 62,535 63.367 64,040 64,714 65,274 65.762 66.189 66.6M 66,946 67,280 67,524 67,798 68,028 68,218 68,446 68,619 68,776 68,904 69.006 69.120 69.219 69,337 69,40't 69,489 69,550 69,608 69.674 69,753 69,e10 69,855 69.900 69,943 69,97E 70,014 70,050
1,94%
2.600À 3.53%
4.77%
5.96%
7.300/"
8.61% 10.00%
11.2210
12.62%
13.6670 14.69Vo
15.50%
16.28%
16.99%
17.63%
18.19%
18.74% 19.19%
20j3yo
20.47yo
20.74%
20.96%
21.14Þ/0
21.370/r
21.530h
21.670/o 21.A0Vo
21.91% 22.02%
22.1QYo
22.19% 22.27%
22.33yo
22.400/c
22,46% 22.51./.
22.559/o
22.59% 22.62% 22.66% 22.70.h 22.72%
22.75o/o 22.770/o
22.780/.
22.A10/.
22.83%
22.As./o
22.87%
22.A8%
22,E90/o
22.91yo
22.92%
22.930/0
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 200Á 2004 2ñ4 2004 2004 2oo4 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 200¿ 200/ 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 20M 2004 2004 2004 2004 200a 2004 2004 2004 2004
2
2 3 3 3 4 4 4
4
2,O32
1,226
1
5,915 1.940/o 7,947 2.600/" 3.00% 9, t73
12,022 3.94% 12,645 4-14V. 't3,451 4_400/o 17,217 5.64% 18,594 6.09% 18,888 6.18% 19,373 6.34yc 23,027 7.54% 24,3¿4 7.97Vo 24,814 8.12% 24,964 8.17% 25,151 8.23%
2,849 806 3,766
1,377
2
3
I
2
294
4E5
1
5
5 5
3,654
1,317
470
4
5 5 6 6 6 6
150
'i87
'1
4,094 2,068
2
25245 9.57% 3 t,313 10.25yo
32,032
10.480/0
719 230
65
6
ô 7 7 7
7
202
f
3,992 1,164 ?95
255
92 46 7
1
7
7 7
I I
E
86 4,242 2,659 893 486 114
E5
I I I I I I I I
9 9
7
1
3.730 2,331 't,283 152 96
I I I I
10 10
7 8
38
14
I
1
56
4,268 3,474
t0
r0
10
1472
631
219
154
7
r0
10 10
32,262 1o.s6vo 32,327 't0.5gvo 32,529 10.657o 36,521 11.95% 38,285 12.53% 39,080 12.79% 39,335 12.88% 39,427 12.9t% 39,473 12.92% 39,559 12.S5% 43.801 14.34õ/¡ 46,460 15.210/. 47,353 15.50% 47,839 15.660/0 47,953 15-70Vo 48.03E 15.72Vo 4S,063 15.730/o 4A,148 15.760/0 51,678 16.98% 54,209 17.74% 55,492 18.16% s5.855 18.247ù 56,007 18.33% 56,103 18.3670 56,141 i8.38% 56,155 18.38% 56,211 18,40% 60.479 19.80% 63,9s3 20.93% 65,425 21.i2% 66,056 21,620/0 66,275 21.69% 6Ê,429 21.74%
66.47'1
21.760/.
21.77o/o
r0
10
I I
10
32
14 3E
66,503
66,517 66,555
21.77% 21.74'/.
4003555
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 4 of 52
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 20M 2004 20M 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2oo4 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
56 57
58 53
1
70.085 70,118
28
22.94Vo 22.95Vo
2004
2004
11 11 11
1
I I
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
,1
2
70,146 70,166 70,198 70,213 70.235 70.256
70,24O
22.96"/"
22.970/o
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004 2004
20
32 15 22
21
l1
1'l
11
60 6'l 62 63
64
22.98% 22.98% 22.99%
6 7
8.00ro
23.OOyo
1't
I
9
10
11
1
24
17 14 16
21
1'l
11
65
66
70,297
70,311
23.OlVo
23.0 tvo 23.02yo 23.O!yo
23.030/.
2004 2004
67 68 69 70
71
1 1 1 1
1
70,327
20M
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
12 12 12 12
12 12 12 12
70,u8
70,370 70,376 70,388 70,405 70,414 70,422 70,429 70,439 70,449
70,461
22
6
12 17
23.04%
23.O4yo
23.05ô/ø
72 73
74
1
'1
23.05%
23.05% 23.O5V. 23.0ôvo
23.060/o
7
1
1 1 1
I
10
11
75 76
77
7A 7S
7 10
l0
12
I
1
23.06% 23.06%
23.O7%
23.O7Vo
12
70,465
13
20u
2004 2004 2004
2004
13
1
80
81
'|
.1
I I
1
a2 83
84
5
15 11
70,478 70,484 70,489 70,504 70,515 70,518 70,523 70,526
2
l3
5
2X.O7% 23.O8ab
23.08yo
'2004
20M
2004
6
7
8s 86
87
I I
1
23.08%
23.oge/r
I
13 13
23.08%
23.09%
2004
88 89 90
91
I f
1 1
t1
3
70,537 70,540 70,546 70,550 70.556 70,558
20M
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
't0
11 12
23.09% 23.05%
23.O9%
23.A9Yo 23.100/6
f3
13
14 14 14 14 14 14 14
t3
1
92 93
94 95
I
I
I
1 1
6 5
70,564 70,569 70.570
70,571
23.10%
23.1010
s6
97 98 99 100
101
I
1
23.10%
23.100k 23.1o?o 23.10%
'|
I
1 1
70,574
1
7
70,575 70,579
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
14
14
I
9
10
11
23.10%
23.100/o
I
1 1
70,582
70,583 70,586
70,591
3 5 5
14
14 '14 14
102
103 104 105
23.'tovo 23.10%
23-11Vo
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
13
't06
107 108 109
2
1
70,596 70,538 70,599
23.'t1% 23-11%
23.11yo
14
'15
't4
1
15
70,602
70,605 70.610
23.11%
23.11Vo
15
15
1't0
23,11%
2@4
2004 2004
15
5
11'l 112
113
2
70,612
70,614 70,616
23.1f/.
23.11% 23-11%
I
1
f5
2æ4
l5
3,202 2.591 1,419 502 230 9A 51 21 19 5 24 3,127 3,392 1.840 754 254 224 54 42 22 23 5 22 2A97 2,411 1.710 651 239 142 6A 31 33 11 I 5 t1 2,363 3,211 f.8f9 830 248 196 70 61 22 15 7 7 2 15 2,182 2,705 2,390 802 336 204 70 s1
69.757
22.830/o
7234A 23.6Aq. 73,827 24.170/o 74,329 24.330/0 74,559 24,40!o 74,657 24.44% 74,108 24.45yo 74,729 24,46Vo 74,748 24.47yo 74,753 24.47yo 74,777 24.48yo 77,904 25.509/o A1,296 26.61% A3,136 27,21V. 83,890 27.46% 84,144 27.540/o
U,368
84,422
27-62r/0
21.639o
27.65yo
UA64
A4,486
27.65yo
27.66Vo
A4509 84,514
84,536
27.66yo
27-67%
87,033 28.49% 89,444 29,28% 91,154 29,84% 9r,805 30.0590 92,044 30,13Vo 92,186 30-17vo 92,254 30.20Vo 92,285 30,211o 92,318 30.2210 92,325 30.220/0 92,337 30.220/o 92,342 30.230/o 92,353 30.23% 94.716 31.00% 97,927 32.ASlo 99,746 32.65Vó 100,576 32.920/o t00.824 33,00% 101,020 33.07% 101,090 33.09%
101.151
33.11%
101,173 33.12% 101,188 33.127o 101,195 33.12V. 101,202 33.13./o 101,204 33.13c/. 101,219 33.13%
r03,40r r06,f06
108,496 109,298 109.634 109.838 109,s08 109,959
33.85% 34.73% 35.5fyo 35.78% 35.89% 35.95%
35.987o
3s.99%
4003556
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 5 of 52
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
3t7
328
341
u4
372
.
2004
2004
2004
389
429
523
.
1 1 't 1 1 1 1 1 1 1A7 65 92 114 152 z:ls 230 254 239 248 336 300 380 418 485 1,037 611 575 600 518 566 601 564 538 538 698 489 492 449 407 382 422 34'1 342 341 361 246 2U 230 198 224 187 f66 172 160 154 't32 96
249,143 249,144 249.f45 249,146 249,147
249,148 .
8',1.55%
2004 2004 2004 2004
44 44 44
44
81.55%
E1.55% 81.55yo
6 7 0
.9
8r.55%
81.55%
20M
2004
10
11
44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 45 45 45 45
2004 2004 2004 2004
540
6
7
m04
2004 2oo4 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
9
10
11
12
14
't5
t6
't7
18 19
20M
2004
2004
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
20
21
24 25
2A
2004 2004 2004
27
28
200/
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
30
3l
34
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
37
39 40
41
42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
51
.2004
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
2004 2004
52
2004 249,149 I t.5570 2004 249.150 E1.5570 249.151 8r.55% 2004 2004 249,152 8t.55% 249,339 81.610/0 2004 249.404 81 .Myo 2004 2004 249,496 81.67Vc 249,610 81.70Vo 2004 2004 249,762 A1.75% 249,9si u.a2vc 2004 250,211 8r.90% 2004 250,465 81.S8% 2004 250,704 82.06Vo 2004 250,952 82.14yo 2004 251,28A 82.254ß 2004 251,588 A235Yo 2004 20M 251,968 82.47Yo 252,386 82.610/0 20M 2004 252,871 82.77% 253,908 83.'t10/o 2004 254,519 83.31V. 2004 255,094 83.50yo 2004 255,694 83.69% 2004 256,212 83.86% 2004 256,f7A 84.05% 2004 257,379 84.25% 2004 257,943 84.430/o 2004 258,481 E/.-61% 2004 259,019 84.7Avo 2004 259,717 85.01% 2004 260,206 g5.17Vo 2004 260,698 Ass3yo 2004 2004 261,147 45.44% 26t,554 85.61vo 2004 2004 261,936 85.74% 262,358 85.88v. 2004 262,699 85.99% 200É 263,041 86.100/0 2004 263,302 86.21v. 2004 263,743 86.33% 2004 263,98S 96.41y. 2004 264,223 86,4970 2004 264,453 86.560¿ 2004 2M,651 86.63Yo mo4 264,875 86.707. 2004 265,062 86.?6% 2004 26s,228 86.Er% 2004 265,400 86.87% 2004 265,560 46.92% 2004 265,714 86.97% 2004 265,846 47.020/. 2004 265,942 87,05% 2004
12
13 14
't5
16 17 18
20
21
24 28 44
I
2
3
5 45 45 45 45
10
11
7
I
45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 46 46 46 46 46 46 46 46 46 46 46 16 46 46 46
12
't3
't4
't5
16
17
1E
196 275,847 90.29Yo 101 275,948 90.32% a3 276,úí 90.35% 34 276,065 90.36% 33 276.098 90.37% 20. 276,118 S0.38% 17 276,135 90.3so/o 276,143 90.39% I 276,'148 S0.39% 5 276,155 S0.3970 7 276.160 90.39% 5 3 276.163 90.39yo 276,167 90.4OYo 4 't 276,164 90.400/o 276,170 90.40% 2 216,171 90.4070 1 1 276,172 90.40% 1 276,1'13 90.40% 61 276,234 90.42% 150 276,384 90-470/o 330 276,714 90.67% 288 277.002 90.67vc 224 277,226 9A.74ù/o 180 277,406 90.40% 112 277,518 90.84% 63 277,541 90.860/0 59 277,ú0 90,88% 30 277,670 90.89% 22 277,692 90.49% 16 277,708 90.90% s 217,717 90.90% 12 277,729 90.910/0
7
1
19
I
4
1
20
25
27
l
1
277,736 277,741 277,747 2??,748 277,749 27?,753 277,755 277,?56 277,757
277,75A
90.510/"
90.S1%
90.91v.
90.910/o
90.91%
90.910/o
90.92% 90.92% 90.52% 90.92% 50.92y.
1 1
7
f0
11
12
13 14 15
90.940/0 58 90.9Ayo 150 227 91.0670 91.150/. 267 r87 278,U8 51.21./. 173 27A,821 S1-260,/0 81 278,902 91.29% 95 278p97 91.32% 4A 279,045 91.34% 30 279,075 91.350/0 23 279.098 91.35% 14 279,112 91.36% 10 279,122 91.36% 27S,128 9r.36% 6 279,'131 51.37% 3
277,759 277,817 277,9ø7 278,194 278,461
tAO355'?-
6J o^t\t..àl
4003568
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 6 of 52
2004 20M 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2001 2004 2004 m04 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2@4 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 200Á 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 200Á 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2404 2004
58 60 144
162
s0 69
156 168 73 85
366 62 76 80
112
83 54 77
134
47 47 47 47 48 48 48 48 49 49 49 5lI 51 s2 52 53 54 54
1 1 1 1 1 1
305,461
s9.98% 99.98% 99.98% 99.98% 99.e9% 99.99% 99.99% 99.99% s9.99% 99.99% 99.99% 99.99%
99.990¿
2004 2004 2004
2004
458 460 460 463 484 466
471
1
305,462
305.463 305,464 305,465 305,466 305,467
1
11
1
2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
18
'l
1
305,468 305,469 305,470
305,471 305,472 305,473 305,474 305,475 305,476 305,477 305,478 305,479
472 479 480 483 489
491
11
I
1 1
305,461 305,462 305,463 305,464 305.465 305,466 305,467 305,468 305,469
99.98% 99.98% 99.98% 99.98%
99.99yo
99.99% 99.99% 99.99%
99.S9yo
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004
1
305¡70
305,471
99.99% 99.99% 99.99.ß
9S.99%
z
6
11
305A72
305.473 305,474
1
1
1
499 503
511 7
99.99%
99.SS%
305,475
305,476
99.99% 99.99%
99.9S%
u1
I
1 1
99.99%
99.S9%
2004 2004
200,1
521 523 523 538 540
66
4
24
99.99%
99.9970
30s 123 96 'r45
196
'r
305.480
2004
13
118 136
126 84
391
406
8l
241 251 521 206
189
79 129 135
1't1
159
'142
168 163 207
158 193
646 2,141
56 60 60 60 61 62 62 63 64 64 64 66 66 66r 66 67 71 73 74 75 74 83 84 85 92 1r0 137 156 219 53í
'l
305.481 305,482 305.483 305.484
99.99% 99.99% 99.99% 99.99%
99.99yo
2004 2001
I
'l
542
548 559 562 571
l5
29
1 1
200/
2004 2004
2004 2004
305,477 305,478 305.479 30s,4s0 305,481 305,482 305,483
305.484 305.485 305,186 305,487
99.99%
99.997o SS.99%
99.99%
99.990/"
99,99%
99.9970
I
1 1 1 1 1
99.99% 99.99% 99.99% 99.99% 99.99%
99.99yo 99.S9%
305.485 305.486
305,487
s9.99%
99.9970
3
I
1
305,488
305.489 305,490
99.99v. 99.99% 99.99v. 99.99% 99.99%
9S.99%
2004 2004 ?004 2004 2004 2004 2004
'l
1
613 620 634 ô46
f9
305,488 305,489 305,490
I
1
.
305,491
305,492
305t93
305,494
21
219
12
305,49f 305,492 305.493 305,494
99.99%
99.9970
99.99%
S9.SS%
1 1
305¡95
30s.496
305.497 305.4S8
i00.00%
100.00%
100.0oyo 100.0070 100.0070
m04
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
2004 2004
682
694 699 724
26
7 7
1 1
I
1 1
305.499 305,500
305.501
5
100.00%
100.007c
100.000/0
7U
802
802
11
1
1 1 1
305,502 305,503
305.504
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
100.000ó 100.00yo
2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004 2004
902
1,019 1,090 1,250 1,279 1,792 2,141
1
,1
305.505 305,506
305,507
1 1 1 1 1
305.508 305.509 305,510
100.00% 100.00%
100.00yo
25
531
305,495 100.00% 305,496 r00.0070 305.497 i00.0070 305,498 t00.00yo 305.499 100.00yo 305.500 '100.00% 305,501 100.0070 305,502 100.00vo 305.503 100.00% 305,504 100.00% 305,505 100-00yo 305,506 100.00v. 305,507 100.00% 305,508 100.00"/0 305.509 r00.00yo 305,510 100.00yo
U ho39b? - lotg "^lIIeà\
4003ô20
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ Rolla, Joseph
From: Sent: To: Sub¡ect:
Enioy- I am.
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 7 of 52
Rolla, Joseph Wednesday, June 01, 2005 10:35 AM Kisliuk, Bruce FW claim fee analysis
From: ' Sntr ïo: Cc¡ Subjoct:
--.Orlginal Message--Young, Karen Wednesday, June 01,2005 9:314M Rater, Mardn; Brown, Peter loby Huntet Daniel; Rolla, Joseph; Goldberg, Howard; Bahr, Roberq young, Karen; M¡etcaretç lohn FW: claim fee analysls
Marty/Toby,
We have multiple things going on which are all using the data in various ways. l've included below the additional information Bob needs - the specific info for the number of independent claims and the large and small entity data.
I believe you have already addressed Rolla's request in the work you sent yesterday (attached) and Joe thinks so too. He is going to double check and get back to us if he needs additional info. Thanks all. Karen
Cla¡ms Ranges
;ummary FY02-05 ..
Frpm: Sent¡ To: Subjectr
---Orj9lnal Message--Rolla, Josph Wednesday, June 01, 2005 9:15 AM Bahr, Roberq Young, Karen RÊ: dalm fee analys¡s
Also- it is needed at the Corps, TC, and workgroup level- along with the total number of claims.
From¡ SenÈ To! Cc! Subjectr
Importance:
---O.lglnal Message--Bâhr, Robert
Wednesday, June 01, 2005 9:11 AM Young, Karen Rolla, Joseph RE: claim fee analys¡s H¡gh
The independent claim ranges are not useful for our purposes. What we need is number of applications that
I
Aoluut
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
3 or fewer independent claims 4 ¡ndeoendent cla¡ms .5 indeoendent claims 6 indeDendent claims 7 independent claims I indeDendent claims I independent claims 10 or more indeDendent cla¡ms
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 8 of 52
Could we get that data for FY 2002, 2003,2004, and 2005 (to date). Also, could we get the data broken out by small entity - large entity.
Aô3 662
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 9 of 52
Cla¡¡ns Ranges Surrrmry FYO245 - 0527051 .xls
Totãl Claims Ranges - Corps Level
FY 2002
Range Count
FY 2003
Count
FY 2004
Counl
FY 2005
Counl of Cases
d
24.1% 35.3%
19.6%
ol
?2.7%
ol
21.7% 35.4%
21.O%
Ceses
C,ases
Cass
ol-10
11- 20 21- 30 3l -40
4t -50
50+
70.o07
f02,513
57,O71
æ.414 1üt,999
67.062
109.087
35.583
22.O%
355%
20.5% 9.4%
u,447
33,6,14
39.8% 20.4% 8.5% 3.9% 5.1% 100.0%
61.652
26.839 13.766
9.2% 4.7%
7.Oro 100.0%
30.44
15.186 21.544 308.375
'to.o% 4.9%
13.755 6.341
14.380
4.9V. 6.9% 100.0%
m.ß7
290.663
20293
292_602
7,0q.
100.0%
8,214
't61.984
Total
lndependeni Claims Range
lndependent Cla¡ms Ranges - Corps Level FY 2005 FY 2004 FY 2002 FY 2003
Coulll of
Câ6ês
CÆunt
of
87.2%
10.4% 1.6%
Cases
86-6%
Count ol Cases 270.595 31.206 47.7% 10.1% 1A% 0.1% o.3v.
Counl of Ceses 145.979
01-05 06-10
251.U2
31,377
255.212 30,321
90.r%
10.8%
1.7V6
f3.469
1,709 466
361
a3%
1.1%
1t-15
16-20
21+ TOTAT
4,773
1.368
4.4*
1,2æ
978 308.37s
1¡90
1.095 290.66:]
0.5% 0,4% 100.0%
0.5% 0.3% 100.0%
o.3% o.2% r00-0%
292,602
r00.0%
16r.984
o) t^
C.
(1.
(¡l
Summary - Corps ând TC Level
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 10 of 52
.¡ds
Chims Rânges Summary FY02+5 - 0527051
IFY 2002
TC
Counl of Ca6es 7.712 10,534
3,441 7.601
10 Total Cleims - by TC FY 2003
Count of Ceses
>10 Total Cleims - by TC
FY 2005
count of
Cases
FY 2004
Count of Cases
F'( 2002
TC
1600 1700 Count of Câses
FY 2003
Count of Câses
FY 2004
Counl ot Cass
FY 2005
Counl of Cases
r600
1700
21.5% 24.7% 13.2%
6.797
r0.025
20,1% 22.9%
6.582
Lgz
3,370 7,934
15.901
m.o% 2..2%
1't-6%
18-9% 23.1
2.UO
4.236
1.790
20.1
24.24n
7A-5%
2100 2600 2800 3600 3700
3,2U
6.982 15,432 10.768 13,176
m.6%
25.4%
28-4% 25.1
123% l9-1%
24.3% 26.4% 27.3%
21.6% 11.5%
18.9%
32,1ß
22.443 29.226 46.64:l
28.540
75.3% 86.8% 79.1% 74.6% 71.6% 70.9%
4.742
9.55l)
15,849 11.294 13,532
24.'l%
26.6% 25.3%
10.662
13.067
25.7
2100 2600 2800 3600
3700
26.959 3:ì,826 23.0s5 29.s33 48.176
79.9% 77-1% a7-7% 80.9% 75.7% 13.2%
72.7T0
60.0%
33.423
25,7ÊO
77.8fi
æ.4%
a1.1% 76.9% 74.3% 74,4%
11.28Ê 15.366
13.721
79-9% 7AA% 80.s% 81.1% 75.9% 73.4% 74.7%
34.117 52.990 30.790
20.3í]a 30.151 'f5.437
29.4:n
35.167
25.6q,
il:l.006
19.702
5 lndependent Claims - by TC FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004
1
Count ol
r
-
FY 2005
Count of
>5 lndependent Claims - by TC FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004
TC
Count of Cass 7.075 3.935 19.7% Counl ot Cases 19.9% Counl of Cases 6.337 3.700
5.5S2 19.3%
FY 2005
Count of Cess 2,40Ê
17.O%
Count of Cãss 80,3% s0,8% 77.3% 81.8% 84.5% 90.2%
90-8%
Co¡¡nt
of
ao.7% 91.2% 80.8%
Casês 80.1%
91.20/o
600
2ø,477
38.76'1
27,ofi
39.9r¿
20.577 30.149 56.804 36.693 43.962
26.51'l
39,185 23,534 35,247 61.696
11,720
'18.200
'13.301
83.0% 92.8% 45.8% 86.s% 91.4% 93.2% 93.0%
1600 1700
17U)
92%
2..7%
3.474
8.4% 21.7% 17,4% 'to-7% 8.8%
9.1Vo
a.8% 19,2L
16.1% 10.4qo
2r00
2600 2800 3600
20.350
30.'r 19
743%'
42.6%
2100
2600 2800 3600
5.974
6.708 7,167 3.84
83.9v.
89-6% 91.5% 91.0%
55.325 35,950 42,260
493%
91.2E 90.9%
21.695 36.435
20.111
ß-2%
11.59. 9.8% 6.804
6.768 7.195
3.5'19
1,402 2.210 .3.385
3.266 1,478 1.854
7.2% 14.2% 13.5%
a2%
6.8%
7-O%
3.*7
4,381
3700
46¡45
24.517
3700
4.274
92%
4.589
8,5% 9.0%
o (N
6\.
0r
+
Summary - Corps ånd TC Level
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 11 of 52
Total Claims Ranges by TC Group
FY 2002
TC 1600 1600
FY 2003 CaSeS
in Rãngo
FY 2004
of
cercenr or case: ln Rång6
FY 2005
Count
uroup
^
TotalclaimsR
ange
Count
of
poÉÉñt or
COUnt Of ps¡cnt of cãses Count
of
percEnt of case¡ in Rângo
CASeS
cssãs ln RångÊ
CâseS
cases
856
1
1600 1600
1600 1600 1600 1600
01-10 11-20 21-30 3t -40
1397
2064
20.7Vo
30.6yo
1335
714
388
19.8%
10.70/0
't.395 2,292 1 ,37'l 818 1,004 1,697 2,459 1,349
738
î9.0yo
31 .20/o
1,429 2,594 1,035
616
16.2Vo
15.30/o 31 .80/.
29.4% 20.4%
11.70to 7.00/0
18.6Vo 11.10/"
1,799 1,339
,402 2,115 1,193
1
1.183
630
353
,772
21.2%
11-30/0
4t-50
50+
5.8%
12.40/o
837
1888
475
6.5%
13.70/0
6.3%
15.2%
21 .60/0
787
âoô
14.'t%
21.8% 32.6%
19.9% 10.5%
4.30/.
1600
1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1ô00 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600
01-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
25.2%
31.80/0
22.5Vo
32.7To
2381 1331
695
J'J
267
243 129 53 304 632 492
203
32.60/o 18.40/o
17.80/. 9.370 5.O%
17.9% 9.8%
5.60/0
599 340 838
9.2%
5.20/o
422
814
10.9%
12.70/0
0l-10
11-20 21-30
953
2099
28.oyo
22.2Vo
12.10/0 7.60/0
862 1,021 1,757
1,577
1't.50/o 14.9o/o
12.9%
1s.10/o
25.7%
23.70/o
12.40/0 8.OYo 15.4o/o 14.OVo 27.70/0
3l-40
41-50
50+
01-10 11-20
669 907 572 1302 1384
't
849
546
853 1,445 1,174 766
463
132
10.8% 15.070
25.5% 20.7% 13.5%
8.20/o
17.Oo/o 13.80/o
31.21o
24.30/0
10.o%
7.1vo 12.40/,
16.2Vo
17.4yo
17
1.081
965
.2%
2869
35.60/o
',t6.20/o
2'l-30 3't-40
41-50
cu.l
1309
838
509
1,344
804 495 1,100 846
931
900 1,781
20.9%
12.5% 7.7%
892 1,675 1,343
811
1
251 488
615
143 853
26.00/0 20.80/0 12.60/0
28.4% 20.5%
12.1yo
7.30/0
'tO.4%
ô.30/o 14.30/o
0t-10
11-20 2t -30 31-40 4't-50
50+
155 94ô 1499 1035 549
't
17.1%
18.20/0
19.1V6
30.2lo
20.90/0
1,420
506
30.6%
20.oo/o
10.90/o
822 '1,198
835 512 290 583 1,184 3
4
3
522 ,204
81%
't8.70/o
363 2't9 469
15.6%
19.4%
2A3./.
19.70/0 12.10/0
265 518 311
190
89
16.3%
31.8%
19.1% 11.7% 5.íVo 15.8%
100.0%
0.00/o
11.1./. 6.2%
12.5./o
94.90/0
309
621
315 627
938
6.8% 13.5% 96.3%
'l -SYo
6.8%
13.8./0
257
0
01-10 11-20 .21;30 31-40 41-50
50+
1144
99.0%
0.3olo
0.30/0
3.zvo
5
I 6
0.4%
13 11
4
660
0
1.1Vo 0.4o/o
0.0v.
0.00/0
o.7%
0.57o
1600 1600 1700 't700 1700 1700 1700
1700 1700
'1700
0.3%
0.svo 0
3
1545
0.3% 0.2%
0.0%
21.Oo/o
0.4%
24.Oo/o
ol -10
11-20 2't-30 31-40
2341 1't 68
coo
36.4yo
18.2Vo
I,268 2,164
567
21.20/0 36.10/û
1,177
2,000
1,227
322
446
3s.6%
19.4Vo
10-10/0 5.40to
806
448
0 0 429
0.0% 0.0% 19.9%
20.5"/.
9.50Á
5.4o/o 7.40/0
1,092
569
37.3% 20-a%
9.3%
4.7Vo
8.1o/o 24.90/o
8.8%
5.40/0 7.3o/o
4l-50
50+
345 468
01-t0
11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
1477
1999
439
227
27.7%
37.50/0 17.2Vo
4.20/o
1700 1700 1700
919
1,359 2,065
457
1,038
240
24.9% 37.8% 19.0%
8.40/0 4.40/0
304 475 1,288 1,838 1,025
481
201
101 174 974 472
104
8.5%
24.80/0 35.40/0 19.8Vo
38.9%
18.8Yo
9.3%
8.2%
4.20/0
4,3Yo
240
4.6%
ù36ê5
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 12 of 52
TotalClaims Ranges by TG Group
croup
1700 Total0laimsR ange
50+
FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004 FY 2005 percnr ot Count of Count of prconl ol cass Count of porcont ol câs: Count of percenr ot cases CaSeS Cass ¡n Rânge câses ¡n Rânge CASeS in Rango CASeS iñ Ra¡se
¿oõ
5.00/o
302
5.SYo
r700
1700 1700 1700
1700
'1700
01-10 11-20
1256 1537
2B.4yo 34.80/o
21-30
31-40 41-50
798
412
18.1%
9.30/0
185
231
1,273 I,649 786 330
142
283
28.30/0
317 1,085 787 351
156
249
6.1yo
126
5.O% 25.00/o
25.9Yo
37.4Vo
36.670
r,569
444
732
17.5./.
7.30/0
4.Oo/o
18.4%
322
143
40.8% r8.0%
8.OYo
8.4%
3.7o/o
4.2%
5.2%
26.2V0
34.'to/o
50t
01-10
'11-20
6-3%
24.0To
34.70/o 19.00/6
5.gvo
23.90/0 35.2%o 19.20/0
58 89
752
3.zVo
5.0%
22.60/0 40.40/0 19.7Vo
8.40/0
1700 1700
1700
21-30
31-40
1938 2522 1389
682
1,843 2,67'1
1,459
731
1,833
2,696
18.8%
9.2Vo
4.80/o
1700 1700
1700
9.5vo
4.90/0
41-50
50+
379
r700
1700
'1700
0t-10
11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+ 01- 10
516 1617
7.06/o
21.50/0
2782 1556
695
37.O%
20-70/o 9.30/0
2,920
1,646 769 403
498
't
607 I,640
1,470 717 394
553
1,348 658
281
125
9.4% 5.1%
7.20/0
s.8%
5.10/0
7.9% 20.Ayo
'169
914
1,621
2,524
20.10/0 36.20/o 20.2Va
20.ÙYo
37.1%
20.90/0
1,634 433 ô't 4 1,474 2,425
1
1700
1700
346
517
LA%
5.10/.
856
10.6%
s.40/o
7
4.6y.
6.9%
23.2%
37.2Vo
19.Oo/o
1,743 1,01 1 431 210
38.1%
22.'lo/o
9.4o/o 4.60/0
1700
1700
't516
2430 1237
587
6.3%
21 -40/o
.6%
260
599
5.7%
19.80/0 37.70/o
1700 1700
1700
't
700
1't-20 2'l-30 31-40 41-50
50+
2.569
1,385 325
504
,473
21.4%
35.3ø/0
21 .Oo/o
37.3%
20.1Vo
,444
669
1,'139 668
286 150
181
22.'tqo
9.0%
4.50/o 7.10/0
s.3% 4.7%
7.30/0
9.7% 4.9%
7.60/0
9.s%
5.01o
1700 1700 1700
291 465
I
JJ'
519
6.0%
01-10 11-20
1815
1003
464
189
23.40/o
35.8Yo
19.Ao/o 9-10/0
I,169 1,949
1,076
2'1.5%
1.064
1,157 541
266
19.9% 35,2yo
21.60/o
10.10/0
35.9%
19.80/0
r.883
470
ð55
21.2./,
38.50¿ 21.8yo
1700 1700 1700
'1700
21-30 3't-40 4l -50
50+
225
380
549
300
483 'lo2
5tt5 366
10-'t%
5.5%
7.2Vo
13.0Vo 35.10/0 29.90/o
'11.16/o 5.50/o
196
'114
8.9%
4.60/0 5.10/0 14.30/0
4.4%
7.50/o
5.0%
A.10/o
2100 2100
2100
2100 2100
01-10 't1-20 21-30
31-40
289 271
125 124
389
704
13.O%
782
305
827
261
130
434
321
755
14,3% 33.6%
29.7To
13.30/0 5.4o/o 3.7o/o 12.40/û
195 133 42
38
35.1% 28.7%
12.2%
5.6Yo
5.6o/o
43.ovo
26.qVo
667 300
121
9.870 3.1yo
2.ÙVo
4l-50
50+
2100 2100
2't 00
126
566
5.4Vo 14.20/o 29-80/0
01-10
443
895 619 346
16.30/0
2100
11-20 21-30
33.0%
22.80/D
1,189
1
2100 2100
2100
3t-40 4t-50
50+
12.8%
6.7Vo
2100
2',100
0t-10 1't-20
21-30 31-40
1363
1110 587
142 227 600
523 371
260
5
,O82
27 .10/o
13.1V"
84 57 4 1,361 1,361 681
301
242
930
12.2% 40.¡Vo
25.3Yo
29.50/o
29.5Vo
14.80/0 6.50/o
585
298
12.9%
.4.4Vo
4.90to
6.5%
8.4îlo
13.80/0
93%
12.3./0 30.070
27.1ã/0 13.4Vo
2100 2100
31.3% 25.5%
13.50/0
14 't,251 1,131 558
334 't,407
1,259 675 553
7.2%
12.1o/o
30.8%
27 .50/o
1,082
661
101 '112 317
12.2% 41.7%
25.5%
11.3%
't4.80h
292
Aos6øa
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 13 of 52
TotalClaims Ranges by TC Group
TC
þfoup
^
Totâlclâ¡msR ange
FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004 FY 2005 Countof p$cenr ot Count of petÉent ol case! Count of p6rcånt of câs6s Count of pe'cenr ot cases CaSeS Cåsos ln Rang CaSeS in Rãngs cases iñ Ráñge CASeS tn Rsnge
2'loo 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100
2100 2100
41-50
50+
294
406
6.7Vo
9.30/o
252
426 257
635
7.0%
10.20/o
296
6.íyo
8.4Vo
't25
115
60
4.8%
4.40/0
01-'t0 11-20 21-30 3l -40 41-50 50r
01-10
311
758
385
2'13
11.30/0 28.Oo/o
11.7%
28.80/o 26,70/0
14.50/0
9.gvo
29.60/0 28.10/0
8.7
0/o
634
702
404
25.9"/o
14.90/o A.40/o
224
1't-20 21-30
31-40
307 408 11'12 923 543
11.3%
11.21o 30.5%
25.40/o 't4.90/o
587 320 191 212 324
785
602 347
165 t8t
16.2t/o
7.70/0
275 185 79
41
40.70/o 27.OVo
11.5%
6.070
6-10/0 11.90/o 39.20/0 26.40/0
8.7"/a
9.ô%
11.50/o 27.80/0 28.40/0 14.40/o
8.íVo
11.2% 29.81o
27.00/0
268
711
42 81
800
406
230
644
376 190 198
41-50
50+
273 382
15.8%
8.0oi6
268 180 87
31
12-7lo
4.50/0 5.3o/o
7.5%
ø.zyo
t0.5%
11.16/" 27.40/0 27.70/0
2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100 2100
2100 2100 2100
0l -'t 0
1l-20
21-30
3t-40
41-50
50+
302 742 750 395 214
274 344
926
9.7% 10-4"/"
28.OVo 24.50/o
430/o
272 833
946 513 219
234
442
36
286
9.0% 27.6% 31.4%
17 -00/o
10.20/"
1,2s9
762
278
44.70/.
27.10/0
941
.14.60/o 7.90Ã
't
501
249
15.2%
7.5o/o
s.9%
4.OVo
01-10 11-20 21-30
31-40
306 39r
806 377
226
7.3%
7 .80/o
114
117
1.3%
343
788
10.40/.
13.9%
322
't1.5%
28.10/0
9.80/o
28.7%
25.6Vo
13.40/0
719
291 532 1034
838
2100 2100
2100
41-50
50+
8.0vô
10.40/0 17.00/0
743 419 213 315
5't
26.5Vo
'ts.Oo/o 7.6ô/o
r,330 1,271
722
307
238
935 570 293 '140
4.2%
10.2%
40.'lo/o
29.6% 28.3%
16.1Vo
24.50h 12.60h
6.8%
9.40/0
6.0%
6.60/0.
1't.30/o
01-10
2100 2100 2100
2100
11-20 21-30 31-40
33.10/0
26.8D/o 11.7o/û 5.50/o
366
171
'1,314 ,152 459
1
9
13.3Vo
33.6%
29-50/0
11.7%
5.gVo
1.663 1,488 667
301
27
663
421
13.1% 32.9%
29.4o/o
328
1,168 757
155
12.1y6
43.1jlo
'13.2% 6.070
5-40/,
276
94
27.9%
10.2%
3.50/o
4l-50
50ù
0't
232
234
2100
2',100
2100 2100 2100 2100 2100
2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600
-10 1't-20
186 205
618
6'17
5.9Vo
6.0%
1't.20/o
10.1t0 30.5%
30.50/o
83 178
240
4 64 96
31
90
3.3olo
10.7%
28.50/o 33.20/o
3
13
13.0%
56.50/o 13.00/0 13.oVo
24.1Yo
32.50/o
17',1
199
31-40 41-50
50+
0l-10
11-20 21-30
3l-40 4l -50
50+
0l -'t 0
11-20 21-30
287 131 167 I 't 03 1544 998 495 325 416 777 1465 961
14.2yo
118
57
62
961
3 1
0
16.0%
7.7Vo
8.40/0
16.070
6.5% 8.2%
22.6Vo
3',l.6Yo
20.40/0
5.2%
6.1vo 22.90/õ
4.3V0
âo
o.o%
2s.50/o
20.90/o 34.A"/o
10.'l%
6.7Vo
1,601 964 442 346 810
1,156 1,827
l,033
498 251
36.3%
20.so/o
20.9%
10.50/0
696 1,016 564
235
103
37.31o
252
9.9%
5.O%
20.7% 8.6%
3.gvo
4.1Vo
8.5%
18.30/o
5.5% 7.5%
't7.20/o
34.40/,
22.60/0
1,628 1,048
2f4 889
1,679
5.4%
't8.20/o 34.40/0 23.00/o
34.6V.
'l'12 580 1,296
654
19.0%
42.5Vo
21.40/6
22.3%
1,120
AÐYú1
E*
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 14 of 52
TotalClaims Ranges by TC Group
TC
þrouo
^'
TotâlolâimsR ange
FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004 FY 2005 percsnt ol Count of Countof p6rc6nt ot cas6! Count of Perca¡t ot cáso: Count of percenr ot caso: CASeS Cãsos in Rång( CâSeS ¡n RångÞ CaSeS in Rånge cases iñ Rañ
2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2ô00 2600 2ô00 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800
31-40 41-50
50+
470
¿5ó
11.O%
6.00/0 7.70/0
569
285
12.'lyo
6.10/0 7.70/0
575
257
1't.80/o
5.30/o 7.30/0
9.zyo
01-10 11-20 21-30 3l -40 41-50
50+
327 1265
2002
123
117
4.0Vo
21.40/0
33.9%
21.40/0 1't.20/o 5.00/o
363 I,115 2,OO2
355
3.8%
18.70/o
20.4o/o
1,140
2,221
18.60/0
36.70/,
22.OVo
36-2Vo
23.2Va 11.OVo 5.1Vo
5.90/0 19.60/0
1264 662
298
I,200 263
349
703
1,425
525
9.6yo
676
695
840
r,503 901
356
155 168
708
39.6%
23.8%
9.40/o 4-10/0 4.40/o 18.80/0 41.80/o 21.00/0
4.ø% 6.4%
19.8%
34.40/o 22.90/o
01-10 11-20 21-30 31-40
1206
808 381 204 215 1 163 1573 936 391 185
2ô5
417 735
7.1To
313 359
20.7% 34.0% 22.8%
10.70/0
1,219
811
JÈIO
1.2s2
374
3s.2yo
23.60/0
291 647 325
137
10.9%
4.80/0
7.1o/o
10.510
8.9%
4.70/o 4.80/0
4l-50
50+
5.7%
6.1Yo 25.4o/o 34.90/û 20.70/0 8.70/6
't71
183
2't0
5.1% 5.9%
25.30/0
01-10 '11-20
'|,10ô
1.552 435 t 98 213 770 1,845 1,549
252
72 74
24.a%
34.4o/o
21-30 31-40
959
21.5% 9.7%
4-40/.
4.80/0 13.70/" 32.9o/o 27.60/o
1,249 1,938 1.043
438
197
38.0%
20.50'/0
798 1,448 663
235
111
23.7Yo
43.0./0
19.7%
7.Oo/o
8.6% 3.9%
3.70/,
13.3Vo 32.6Vo
27 .60/0
4l-50
50r 0l -10
11-20 21-30
4.10/.
3.30/o 3.40/0 13.7Vo
5.9%
15,10/0
880
190 921
2.253
1867 1464
32.1Vo
25.20/o
3t-40
41-50
50+
772
13.3% 6.2%
ø.ovo 22.7Vo
34.80/o
720
351
12.8%
ô.3% 6.6%
1,913 887 445
114 726 2,058 't ,407
61
38.7Vo
26.5Vo
'11.5%
4.80/o
12.8Vo
1
6.4%
7.2%
257
466
37'l
01-10 11-20 21-30 3't -40 41-50
50+
816 1253 756
357
737
1,334 739 381 173
259
203%
36.80/0
500 a24
442 197 263
¿ia
4.8% 19.8%
43.Oo/o
19.0%
38.07o
22.20/o
417
s05
1,648
965
21.O% 9.S%
4.So/o
20.4lo
'1o.50/o
444
21.10/0
10.20/.
170
76
8.1% 3.6%
178 239
862
4.4%
7.10/0
't7 -30/o
0l-10
1't-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
ô.6% 20.0%
34.2%
23.20/0 10.60/0
'1474 1001 220
295 3220
780 1,619 1,137 503
230
't,o24
2,'t33 1,504 743
326
4.5% 6.1%
16.8%
35.00/0
94
4.5%
16.50/o
35.8%
25.20/0 11.10/0
5.10/0
526 1,249
a32 292 140
140
39.3% 26.2%
9.2o/o
24.7%
12.2%
5.10/o
53%
6.1%
4.4'/o
4.40/o
6.8%
22.50/o 38.7Yo 20.80/o
0l-10
11-20 21-30 31-40
5523
2975
555
1227
783
2247
8.670 3.970
4l-50
50+
5.5% 23.0% 36.7%
0t-10
11-20
3593
249 3,149 5,273 2.980 I,158 563 699 2,297 3,797
5.5%
22.AVo 38.10/6 21.60/0
8.4o/o
370
2,543
5,573
20.5% 38.9%
22.10/0
9.20/o
2,364 4,619 879
21.71o
42.4Yo 21.O%
3,176 1,317
2,251 373 364
8.1Io
3.4% 3.3%
23.3Yo
4.1%
5.10/0 22.4r)/0
583
751
4.1%
5.2%
21.1yo
37 .30/o
2,311
4,081
37.'to/o
I,089 1,931
4't.3%
Aog6bØ
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 15 of 52
TotalClaims Ranges by TC Group
TC
þfoup
^
Totalcla¡msR ange
FY 2002 psrcent ot Count of
CaSeS
Casos in Rang(
FY 2003
Count
FY 2004
Count
FY 2005
Count
of
percsñt ol cãses
in Rango
of
percen
or cases
of
pe¡canr or case:
¡n Rangs
Cases
2,252
899
CâSeS
ln Range
CâSêS
2800 2800 2800
21-30
2011
890 421 623
20.6%
9.10/0
22.O%
2,394
1,057 465
630
2'l.9vo
9.7Vo 4.3Vo
5.ao/o
3l-40
41-50
50+
8.8%
4.10/0 5.70/0
940 371
156
2Ù.1o/o
7.9%
4.30/o
6.40/o
4',t8
2800
2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800
2AOO
0l-10
't1-20 21-30 31-40
3ø27
457'1
1926
32-7%
39.170
16.50/0
695
354
351
4,797 2,096
741
3,418
585
184
3.3% 3.9%
29.OVo
44.60/0
29.1% 40.9yo
17.90/0
s.455
4,A22
28.60/0
39.9%
18.3%
7.Oo/o
2,210
847
358
2,017 3, 05 I,186
1
17.Ooh
4l-50
50+
322
5.9%
2.8%
3.Oo/o
6.370 2.8Vo
3-10/0 27.36/o
325
358
334
153 169
130
4.8%
2.2Vo
3.0%
3,zVo
26.8o/o
386
300
2.4%
28.6V0
01-10 11-20
29.3V,
3O2
424
38.6%
18.70/0
38.3%
2't,Oo/o
438
231
39.1%
20.6Vo
8.10/0
2'l-30 31-40 41-50
50+
170
233
85
190 80
38
41.910
17.6Vo
8.40/0
7.70/.
91
25
4't
2292
2.70/o 4.50/0
27 36
2,263
3,608
2.4%
3.30/0
23
38
2.1!o
3.40/o
6
10
1.370
2.20/o
01-10 11-20 21-30
25.20/o 38.60/0
24.OVo
3518
742
337
1734
441 461
482
34.20/o
19.0%
8.20/o 3.70/o 5.30/0 2'l.Oo/o
1,891
816
405 450
20.O%
8-70/ù
3t-40 4t-50
50+
2,590 4.139 2,281 981
511
23.4%
37.3Vo
20.60/0
8.4%
4.60/,
5.30/0
1,416 2,412 1,199 474
209
281
23.90/0
40.7%
20.20/0
8.0% 3.5% 3.7%
29.80/o
4-3yo
4.80/o
585
01-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
792
237
83
472
770
220
346
189
21.60/"
35.20/o
391
585 384
22.7%
33.91o
22.30/o 10.8o/o
4.80/0
36.1%
22.0V0
10.80/0
36.7%
20.oo/o
502 210
113
23.,Vo 9.6%
5.zyo
5.50/o
tJo
3.8% 6.2%
25.30/0
186 83
96
67
27
34
7.1%
2.9%
3.670
120
5.61o
01-10
3137
4346
11-20 21-30
35.0%
19.970
3l-40 4t-50
50+
2470 1103
607
8.9%
4.90/0
3,061 4,777 2,430 'I,046
551
693
421
24.4% 38.0% 19.4% 8.3%
4.40/0
3,283
5,275 2,713 1,192 660
23-4% 37.6% 19.4%
2,010 3,519
1,683 662
326 398
23.4% 40.9% 't9.6%
7.7Vo
2800 2800 2800 2800 2800
0l-10
11-20 31-40 41-50
50+
754 389 693 424 226
97
6.1Vo '19.5%
5.5%
18.86/0 33.20/o 22.80/o 11.70/0
888
468 903
594
8.5% 4.7% 6.3%
18.30/o 35.2o/o
3.8% 4.6%
19.670
39.60/0
34.8%
21.31o
11.40/0
743
510
224 452
105 37
61
23.2%
11.40/0 4.8o/o
23.010
9.zyo
3.20/o
4.9%
8.10/0
2800 2800
2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 3600
161
'0't-'t0 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
.
s
261 119 182
49
93
251
123
53%
8.1Vo 17.40/0
7.9%
183 160
396
7.10/,
f 5.60/0
53%
17.4vo
41
33
36.0% 28.9%
5.!Vo
33.070
23.40/0
11.3o/o
66
6 4
32
11
3.5%
14.4% 32.5%
3.9Yo
11.Oo/ø
01-10
1935
21
1,961
31
217 1't7 44
38.6% 21.2%
11.40/0
44
l0
10
19
40-4% 15.3%
9.2yo
9.2o/o
21
5 1,078
s2
4.3% 9.0%
29.5V6
4.6Vo
30.370
31.2%
1,9't7
Ao"6ë2
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 16 of 52
Total Claims Ranges by TC Group
FY 2002
TC
FY 2003
Count
FY 2004
Count
FY 2005
Of
Pe¡cent of Ceses
¡n Range
Grouo
Tolalcla¡msR ange
Count
of
prcnr ot
of
pârcont of cås6s
¡ñ Rng6
of
pe.cenr ol cases CoUnt
¡ñ Rång
CâSeS
cssâs ¡ñ Rang
CASes
cåses
cases
3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3ô00 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3ô00 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3ô00 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3ô00 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600
11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
2491
917
328 133 159
41.80h
15.40/0 5-SYo
2,607 '1,014 380
157
41.5%
16.1Vo
2,756 1,070
406
190
42.40/0
't6.5yo 6.zyo
2.gvo
2.40/0
6.1%
2.sVo
2.50/o
1.598 574 172
78
44.9%
16.10/0
4.6Vo 2.2Yo
2.zyo
2.7Vo
0r-10 11-20 21-30 3l -40
't019
1943 1557
160
15.3%
29.30/0 23.40/0
854
12.9%
7.50/0
1,737 1.433 788
463
838
158
13.8%
28.70/0 23.60/0
782 1,808
854 443
12.8%
59 414
963
1.7% 14.8yo
34.5o/o 24.2Vo
29.6%
25.8vo
14.Oo/o
1.573
642 2,014 2,739 1,220
511
67s
211
13.O%
7.60/0
4l-50
50+ 01- 10
496
7.30/0
1't-20 2'l-30 31-40 41-50
50+
771 1947 2512
11.6% 31.1%
40,20/o
803
1,978 2,709 1,072
431
358 1?O 1,022 1.460 620
191
12.8%
6j%
7.60/0 29.40/o 42.00/o 17.80/0
13.2% 30.0%
41.10/o 16.20/0
6.5o/o
10.50h
29.Oo/o
39.40/o
'17 .60/0
l00l
422 173
198
16.0vo
6.7Vo
2.Ao/o 3.z%o
7,40/0
5.57o
2.40/o 2.9Vo
.
0t-10
11-20
'1024 606
102 125
1
29.30/0
14'12 221
40.5%
17.4Vo
2l-30
31-40 41-50
50+
0't
6.3%
2.9o/o 3.60/o
205 202 989 1,458 633 254 110
125
3.'to/o 3.1Vo
2't8
244
3.'la/o
85
3,5Vo 26-90/o
27.7% 40.9%
17.7%
7 j%
I,046 639
330
r,535
39.5%
16.5Vo
4.50/o
102 589 906 367
53 62
27.8to
42.80/0 17.30/0
139
6.6Vo
3.'lVo
- 10
11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
't146 554
581
30.710
4't .60/0 15.50/0
1,084
1,514 700 267
3.5% 28.2%
39.4Vo
159 4j% 173 4.5Vo 925 25.1% 1,526 41.4o/o
714
19.50/0
2.5%
2.So/o
14.2%
7.O%
234
116
106
ô.3%
3.10/0 2-8o/o
130
145
3.4%
273 114
130
7.4%
3.'l1o
50t 01-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
01- 10
3.8%
3.s%
21.40/. 38.1Vo
20.70/0
10.oo/o
709
22.6Yo
1195
633 260
34.2% 20.2% 8.3% 4.3%
6.41o
1,088
644
244
638
21.4% 36.5%
21.60/0
723 1,2A7 701
338
524 758 349 137 57 64 408 758 406
171 89
27.7%
40.10/o
18.5%
7.3Vo
3.0%
3.4Vo
21.3Yo
39.6%
21.20/0
9.5%
5.4%
5.40/t 28.O%
38.70/o
8.9%
4.6Vo
11-20 21-30 3't-40 41-50
50+
135 199 2'147 2584 1231 468
246 293
162
161
2,046
151 182
1,964
4.5%
5.40/0
27.10/0
30.8%
37.10/0 17.70/o 6.7Vo
3.50/o 4.2o/o
2,826 1,258 525 290
350
17.2Vo 7.26/. 4.0Vo
2,766 1,233
579
38.1%
17 .O0/o
82 1,048 1,615 683
270
101
4.3%
27.0% 41.7%
17.60/0
7.Oo/o
8.ovo 4.3%
5.60/0
309
407
2.6Yo
4.8'/o
0t -10
11-20 21-30 31-40
1526
491
72
1367 138
57
158
669
4.1%
34.OVo 45.4Vo
37.4%
41.80/o 13.40/0
1,234 1,528
34.10h 42.2%
15.2Yo
550
170 65
74
1,291 1.526
34.90to 41.30/0
3.8%
2.O%
1.60/0
4.7%
1.8%
2.00/o
578 186
63
15.6Yo
268
80
32
852
13.6Yo
5.0%
1.7o/D
4.1Io
1.60/0
4l-50
50+
55
1.5Yo
24
1.2Vo
Ao362o
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 17 of 52
TotalClaims Ranges by TC Group
TC
^' Itfouo
Totâlcla¡msR ange 01- 10
FY 2002 FY 2003 FY 2004 FY 2005 p¡r6nt of Count of Count of Psrc6nt or caso! Count Of prcñt of cás6! Count of pe',cenr or cases CaSeS Casss in Rangr CASeS in Rångs CASeS ¡n Rânge cases in Rangê
3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700
3700
1101
1435
27.30/o
1'l-20 21-30 3l -40 41-50
cU+
35.6%
17.3Vo
696
âât
1,'t73 't,627 802
378
223 298
26.10/0
1,187 873
411
25.7%
35.3%
18.90/0
662
25.50/o
36.1%
17.80/0
8.40/0
1,629 312 3,742
4,755 2,044
7E6
1,003
524
172
38.6%
20.2Yo
6.60/o
8.2%
8.9%
4.40/0
189
282
4.7%
7.Oo/o
5.0% 6.6%
32.70/0
20s
102
1
3.9% 5.3%
31 .10/o 40.20/o 17.70/0
6.8% 31.ovo
01-10 11-20
4014
4555
34.2% 38.8% 15.3%
6.3yo 2.50/.
3,813
4,581
137 ,7 42 991 316
145
39.3%
16.10/o
39.4%
17.00/0 6.50/6
2,250
21-30 31-40
1796 739
29ô 335
1,880
708
334
6.1%
2.Solo 2.90/0 18.50/o
5.6% 2.6%
2.Ao/o 16.70/o
4l-50
50r
01- t0
337
2.8Vo
2.gvo
18.9%
't1-20
21-30 31-40
2587
1775 941
567
1580
31.0%
21.30/o
338 1,616 2,712 632
392 2.758
2,007 ,146 668
1
3.3%
16.80/o
154
1,545
3'1.1%
30.0%
21.80/0
't1.3%
6.8%
10.7Vo
1,831 s98
826 1.705
532
305
34.40/0
21.0%
11.4%
7.20/0
1,137
446 1,711 2,721
1,061
381
23.0%
10.70/0
12.40/.
4r-50 50t 01-10
'11-20 21-30 31-40
7.3%
11.8%
6.2% 9.0%
27.60/0
889 3245
4332
30.4%
40.60/0
1733
680
372
1685
16-20/,
6.40/0
.
4l-50
50+
316
1953
814
318 128 176 1907
4,575 2,038 749
942 3,107 380
'to-g./"
1,082
27.5%
4O.6./o 14.10/0
3,269 4,754 2,137
824
376
27.7% 40.3%
'18.1%
7.Oo/o
43.9%
17.10/0
7.O%
3.4Yo
6.2Va
3.O%
3.5o/o
3.20h
3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700
3700
01-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50ù
33.2%
38.570
16.00/0
ô.3%
2.5o/o
389 1,69ô 2,1't0 887 342
162
3.4%
31.5%
39.20/0
2,226
948 415
220
1 ,7
439 1,575
3.7%
28.2Vo
16.570
39.8% 't6.9lo 7.4%
3.9% 3.8V,
22.60/ø
146 174 805 1.238 514
f93
a4
2.4tÁ
2.8%
27.8Vo
42.80/0 17.80/o
6.70/0
6.4%
3.Oo/o
2.9'/o
2.'to/o
3.5%
01-
l0
28.6%
32.Oya
17 .3Vo
3700
3700
3700 3700
3700
11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50
50+
2136
1
602
344 536
¿YUÞOJ
153
181 1,771 2,243 1,274
664
351
3.4%
26.0Vo 33.070
49
2,625
9.0%
5.20/o a.oo/o
18.7% 9.0yo
5.20/o 7.30/o
1,470
33.9% 19.0% 10.1%
5.4Vo
1,5s0
859
60 927
22.4o/o 37.5VD 2O.A'/o
7A2
498
292602
420 707
308375
390
164
244
161984
9.4%
4.00/0
9.1%
6.0%
Aoz6?t
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 18 of 52
lndependent Claims
TC Count
of Cagos
Pè¡conr or
Countof
Casos
pèE6ntor
Cæ6ln Rángê
Cd66ln Rãns6
1600 1600
1610 tô10
1610
01-03 06-10
r600
1600
1600 1600 1600
1610
ll-15
t6-20
r600
1600 1600
160 1620
11-15
13.1%
1600 1600 1600
r600
1600 1600 1600 1600
1630
1.283
11-15
17.1%
154
2.10ß
r600
1600 1600 1600 1600 1600
1600 1600
1640
11-15
't
35
2.10/o
117
1.50/o
18
59.40/o
1600 1600 1600
1600
600 600 1600 1600 1600 't600
't 't
1700 1700 1700 't700
1700 1700
861
13.40/0
1710 1710 '1720 't720
11-15
21+
1700 1700 't 700
r700
1700
06-10 11-15
153
6,10/0
1700 1700 1700 1700
1730
06-10
A0367z
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 19 of 52
lndependent Claims Ranges by TC Group
TC
l-roup '
lndpndenlcl
atmsKang6 I
FY 2002 Count of P6rÈsñr or
CASS
34
Cæ6s ¡nRãrso
FY 2003
Count
FY 2004
Count
of Cass
porcs¡t of Cd3o3lñRâns6
of Cases
27
P6rcôñr or
ca!ê.
ln Rånsê
FY 2005 Count ot P6'c6nt or câ!ô. CaSeS ln Rng6
t3
0.7%
0.20/o 0.10/o
1700 1700
'1700
1730
1730
l-15
0.8%
0.20/o
27
I
0.6%
0.20/o
0.6%
0.1oÁ 0.10¿
74.OVo
16-20
21+ 01-03 04-05
1700 1700
r700
1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700
1730 1740 1740 1'140 1740 1740 1740 1750 't750 1750 1750 1750 1750 1760
1760
5,464
1,161
634
6
0.10Á
3
0.1%
73.0o/o
16.70/o 4.70/o
73.8%
't5.70/o
8.60/o
5,616
5.670
1.291
6 6
1
2.618
7E.'Vo 15.2%
1.286 84
16.4% 7.8% 0.9%
o.20/o
06-10 1't-15
16-20 21+
109
12
598
68
1E
505
180 16
5A%
0,50/o
t.sVo
't.lyo
0.3%
0,170
74.50/0
o.3vo
o.20/o
0t-03
04-05 06-10
11-15
5.554
73.90/o
1.187 650 a2
23
17
11 5,868 76
14
2't
15.S%
8.7%
1.1%
1,275 635
I
5,227
18 6,008
1.321 642
73 21 17
I 3.483
0.3% 0.2%
76.20/o 15.5Yo 7.'lYo
0.2% 74.3vo
16.30/6
16.2Vo
70s
326
38
8.r%
1.Oo/o
7.9%
0.90/o
16-20
21+
0.3% o.2%
75.20/o
O.27o
0.3%
o.20/o 75.90/0
0.1%
75.Ao/o
f700
1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 1700 2100 2100
1760 1760 1760
1760
01-03 04-05 06-10
't
4.908 529
6ô
'r,004
11
15.4%
8.10/o
1.Oo/o O.2a/o
l-ts
1,040 530
60 23
15
15.1% 7.7% 0.9%
o.30h
o.20/o
5,214 1,036 518 69
19 16
5 I 2.348
445
200
0.8% 0.1%
0.20/o
77.7%
't4.70/o
6.60/o
'l5.1To
7.5% 1.0% 0.3%
0.20/o
0.8%
16-20
1770
17fO
1770 1770
1770
0r-03
04-05 06-10
11-15 16-20
21+
I 3,783 796
403
0,1%
14.5%
15.7%
7.94/o
4,Í25
909
74.10/o 16.7Vo
3.965
890
46 27
74.2.h
16.70Á
1770 2110 2110 2110 2110 2110 2110 2120 2120 2120 2120 2120 2120 2130 2130 2130 2130 2130 2130 2140
2140
61
l6
17
1.2%
408 6?
l5
7.5%
1.2%
410
7
7.7% 0.9%
O.5o/o
1,754 325 t't 6
'18
2
0.2%
o.',t%
79.0%
'14.6%
o.3% 0.3%
54.30/o
0t-03
04-05 0ô-10
11-15 16-20 21+
1.210
1,289
677
I
o.3% 0.1%
54.AoA
28.8ø/o
6
1
5.2% o.a% 0.3%
0.00Á
63.4Yo
0.10/0
1,262
642
56.1%
28.6Vo
13.4Vo
',l.4Yo
617
350
27.70/o
15.70/o 't.80/o
2100
2100 2100
336
40
't4.3Vo
40
Þ
1
1.7%
0.370
301 32
5
861 328 I 2 1 1.425
293 159
24.1%
11.70/0
0.6%
0.3% 0.3%
56.70,6
2r00 2r00
2100
2r00 2r00 2r00
01-03 04-05 06-10
.537 644 443
3 2.168
1.040
662
I
o.3vo
0.'t%
0.1%
0.1%
i.2%
54.7%
27
.Oo/ø
54.3%
26.1Uo
2.52s
1.245 72A 79
61.7%
23.9ø/o 12.70/0 't.OVo
23.7%
16.3þ/o
16.6%
'ls.Ach
1.7%
t1-15
56
IE
14
t6-20
2'l+
0't-03
04-05
2f00
2t00
2100
2.1% o.7% o.5%
4A.10/o
84
't9
18
2.1% o.5%
0.50¿
47.2Yo
25
l0
0.5% o.2%
50.80/o
27
23 7 I
0.3yo 0.3%
5A.A%
2,098 877
152
'1,156
47
1,969 852
144
2,324
1,525
26.5%
20.to/o
1,137
45
¿c
27.3%
20.40/o
3.50/o 1.10/0
1,259
834
't
.5%
646
8
24.9%
13.6o/o
2r00
2100
06-10
11-'t5
14.20/o 2.20/o
3.5%
't_1%
01
2.Oyo
2100 2100 2100
2100
t6-20
21+
38
0.8%
D.4o/o
0.3% 0.3% 5Ê.4%
30
0.7%
44 .60/o
0.6% 45.7%
27.50/o
2100
2140
2140 2140
2t00
2100 2100
2140 '
0't-03 04-05 06-10
1
a12 568
90
.210
1.095
605
423
5E 't1
30.070 21.O%
19.2%
2.60/0 o.50/o
1.074 628 376
47 '¡0
19
50.1%
25.3%
17.6%
2.20/o
387 174 102
16
I
25.4%
14.S%
2.so/o
D.30/o
-r5
21+
3.3%
0.70/0
t6-20
20
0.3%
0.5yo
2
10
0.4%
l0
0.5%
5
0.70/0
Ao=t?3
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 20 of 52
lndependent Cla ims Ranges
TC 2100 2100
C Group
FY 2004
Countof porconl of cás6s CaSeS lrRango
^-,,^ 2150 2150
2150
lndependentcl âtmsllange
2100
2100 2100
2
2150
2150
01-03 04-05 06-10
11-15 16-20
FY 2002 porcnl or Count of cãss c6s.s ln tun6 1,676 46.0%
FY 2003
Countof CaS9S
pE6nt ot
Câsos
ir
R6ngo
FY 2005 Count of porcorìt or cãsð, CASoS ln Rênes
1,023 769
127
1.314
46.60/o
28.1%
840
543
90
16
29.8%
19.30/0
r.r98 730
386
12
50.2Vo
389
181
57.OVo
30,6%
'16.2%
26.5%
14.60/0
21.'t%
3.5%
0.90/o 0.40/0
100
3.2%
0.670
2.2% 0.5%
0.30/o
a
3
2
12%
0,40/0 0.30/o
32
t00
2100
2150 2160
2100
2100 2100 2100 2100 2100
2r60
2160 2160
2160
2160
01-03 04-05 06-10
r
1.246
79'l 540 98
14
0.6%
46.0%
292%
19.9%
t-15
21+
16-20
01-03 04-05 06-10 1'l-15 16-20
21+
2100
2100 2100 2100
2100
2100
2170 2't70 2't70 2170 2170 2170 2f80
21AO
1,411 769
516
l8 16
3.6% 0.7% 0.6%
50.2% 27.4% 14.4% 2.7%
l.'to/o
0.30/o 54.70,/o
1,654 915 6t3 86 21
l5
50.1% 27.70h
t8_6%
2.6Vo
I r,500
900
49.7% 29.4% 14.1%
1.79o
o.30/o
1,818
313
64.6% 22.6%
11.1% 1.2./"
547
52 I I
33
0.60Ã
0.50/o 50.90/0
0.370
0.3% 0.2%
1,426
2.319
1.286
754
97 12
51.6%
2A.6% 16.8% 2.2yo
1,397
59.90/0
26.9%
25.6Vo
76
30
8
524
58
18
18.7Vô 2.'to/o
279
42 I
12.00/"
1.80/0
0.8% 0.6%
52.OVo 27.9Vo
0.6%
0.30,/o
o.4% o.30k
0l-03
04-05 06-10 r t-,15
'16-20
1.709
2100
2100
2100
2180 2180
2r80
2180
2190 2190
861 478
57
16
2,033
27.5%
r5.3%
1.8%
1,092 680
83 13 I
211
2,583 794 75
24
11
51.10/o
I,569
r.676
691
8
6r.8%
25.5Vø
31.O%
15.70Á
17.4%
2.10/0
301
30 3 12
14
11.1yo
1.1yo
0.10/0 0.40/o
1.5%
2f00
2100 2100
2100 2100
2'loo
2100
2100 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600 2600
2190 2190 2190
2190
21+ 01-03 04-05
06- t0
0.5% 0.2%
49.3%
28.70/o
0.30¿
0.20/o
0.5%
0.210
52.O%
48.ïVo 28.6Vo 1f .3Vo
4,30/o
O,1o/o
312
182
60.90/"
582 55
7
379
30.3%
15.70/o
5
4
21.7%
17.40,/o
1A.7%
2.70/o o.30/o
128
32
94
11-15 16-20 )1+
I
1.5%
0.oolo o.oo/o
1
0.0%
0.50h
2610 2610 2610
2610
0.2%
0.8%
0,0%
01-03 04-05 06-10
2610 2610 2620
2620
ll-15
16-20
21+
2,690 't,147 814
148
55.10/0 23.50/0 16.70/o
2,702 998
705 132 42
5A.70/o
3.0ô2
t.'145 680
't0l
26 25
21.7fo 't5.3% 2.5% 0.9%
0.6vo
52.90/0 23.50/o 1A,2To
60.8% 22.7%
't3.5ø/o
1.797
580 37
65.970
21.3Uo
299
4 1.894
681
r1.0%
't.10/ú o.30/o
3.0%
1-O%
0.70to
50
32
2,293
2.0%
0.5%
0.5%
57.4Vo 22.70/o
0.1Vo 62.1Vo
22.30/o
12.9o/ø
0l-03
04-05
53.9%
23.'lo/o
2620 2620 2620
2620 2630 2630
982
778
140
2189 1,104
'165
2,796
1.107
779
127
41
06-10
18.3%
3,30/6 0,80/0
16.0%
394
1t-15
16-20
21+
3,íVo 1.2% 0.7%
2.6% 0.8% 0.5%
64.10/0
2630 2630 2630 2630
2640 2640
01-03 04-05 06-10 11-15
2A 3,686 'r,293
788
35
B.7ro
56 33
3,521 I .'t 94
58 13
2.524
1.9% 0.4%
0.30/o
62.4% 21.9%
13.3%
1.70/o
64.6%
21 .90/o
3.930
r.34
414
91
12
11.3%
'l.7yo
744
88
20
r
66.6%
21.0o/o
21.9%
12.1yo
1.40/0
797 412
10.9% l.OVo o.zyo
101
t6-20
21+ 01-03 04-0s
26
14
0.4%
22
38
q
0.4%
o.20Á
63.20/o
0.3%
2,204
838
o2%
62.1% 23.6% 12.0%
t1
2.339 739
02%
6s.8%
20.gvo 11.5%
2,238
801
ll 'r,069
0.3%
69.1010
2640
06-'i0
425
22.6%
11.60/.
4't2
326
133
21.1%
8.60/o
409
Ao?ê71
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 21 of 52
lndependent Claims Ranges by TC Group
FY 2002
TC
.*,,^
2640
lndependntcl
aìmsRange
Countof
CAsOs
p6E6nror
FY 2003 p6n6¡t Count of
CaSS
FY 2004
or
FY 2005
c6!!
Counl
csæ ln Rrnso
1.Eo/o
C6êæ ln Rångê
of cases
prc6nt ol
Counl
¡n Rán96
ol Câses
p6E6nl
otcæe
ln Ransó 1.00/0
2600
2600 2600
2640 2640
2650 2650
1't-15 16-20
21+
63
10
75
't4
2
2,4O1
2.1!o
0.40/o 0.10/o
45
12 10
0.3%
0.3vo
62.30/0
1,3% 0.3% 0.3%
15
o.oo/o
o.2%
2600
2600 2600 2600
0t-03
04-05 06-10
I
2600
2600 2600
2650 2650 2650
2650
2660
2,813 975 586
102
25
12
62.8o/â 21.30/o
3,375
21.60/û
13.Oo/o
952 57s
12.9!o
2.20/o
t-15
21+
16-20
01-03 04-05 06-10 r 1-15 16-20
2.3% 0.6%
0.370
51.60/o 28.60/o
't.o27 582 80
23 I
3.632
2,31'1
20.20/o
68.6%
19.40/o
653
'l1.4yo
1.6%
0.50/r
0.20/o 52.50/o
2A.Ao/o
352 35
11
14.4%
',l.O%
14
0.5% 0.3%
53.2%
27.A%
16.'to/o
0.3%
0.20/o 57.40/o
2600 2600 2600 2600
2600 2600 2600 2600 2600
26ô0 2660 2660
2660
2,997 1,660
2.982
'1.560
900
't5
969
131 34
1.991
16.7% 0.6%
0.40/0
120
z.'tyo
0.50/o
1,107 142 30
17
16.0%
3.050 1,389 767
26.10/0
14.40/o
2.'t%
0.4% 0.2%
72 23
13
1.4%
0.4to
0.20/o
21
01-03 04-05 06-10
0.3% 60.40h
21.4o/o 14.70/0
2670 2670
2600
2600
2670 2670 2670 2670
2680
2680
2,144 78E 545
EO
59.70/6 21.90/n
15.1%
2.187 790 532
2.690 973
ll-15
16-20
27+
2.2%
o.6vo
69
29
566
78
1.9%
0.80¿
62.0% 22.4% 13.0% 1.8%
0.40/0
1,448
406 30 I
68.8%
19.30Á
206 I
9.8%
1.4Vo
20
18
0.470
t8
o.5%
59.9%
23.70/0
2600 2600 2600
2600 2600 2600 2S00 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2600 2800 2800 2800 2800 2600 2800 2E00 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800
2680 2680 2680
2680
01-03 04-05 06-10 11-'t5
16-20 21+
2.583
1.022
587
16
2,715 1 115
0.4%
60.1% 24.7% 12.9% 1.5%
0.60/o 0.20/o
'14
3.616
0.3%
59.370
25.Oo/o
0.4%
65.20/ô
2.072
698
'l.524
22.0% 10.4%
1.7%
13.670
1 A%
o.69/o 0.30/0
79
24
583 69
11
828 93
27
12
13.6% 1.5% 0.4%
0.20/o
342
2810 2810 2810 2810 2810 2810 2820
2820
14
9,839
01-03 04-05 06-10
11-15
68.9%
18.50/0 10.30/0
9,639
2,570
69.7%
18.6%
10.031
2,688
54 I 4
8,072 't,909
0.3%
0.'t%
74.10/0
1? .50/o
.
69.9%
1A.7ølo
2,638 1,472
232
58
47
1.6%
O.4!ø
1.330 197
't.126 1.916 998 150 9,116 1,771 744
46 40
9.6%
1.4%
1342
171
37 34
9.6%
1.20h
o.30/o
810 63 13
3,46't 800
7.4%
0.6%
o.zvo
16-20
21+
0.3%
6E.4% 18.5% 10.3%
2.Oolo
0.3% 0.3%
69.50/0 18.10/"
o.2%
68.5%
19.50/0
o.tyo
74.1Io
't7.10/o 7,60/,
01-03 04-05
06-'10 11-15
2A20 2820
2420 2820
6,695 1,807 1,012
194 25
7,493
147
33 25
9.7%
1.so/o O.4Yo
2,rs3 1,107
'tO.1%
1.30/o
353
42
13
0.9%
0.30/o
2830
2830
16-20 2'l+
0.50/o
0.3% o.2%
o.3yo
o.2%
77.70/o
'15.10/o
2
o.0%
81.30Á 13.2Vo
2830 2830
2830
01-03 04-05 06-10
9.005
762
80
77.O%
1,819
16
9.344
77.4%
15.4Vo
t-15 t6-20
I
15.6% 6.s% 0.7%
0.10/0 0.10/0
2830
2840
2440
27+
2840 2840
2840
01-03 04-05 06-10
11-15
683 143
73
13
68 'r9 17
97
6.3% 0.6% 0.2% 0-1%
74.40/o
1,861 767 69
24
5.659
920
340
6.4%
0.6%
0.20/o
4.5%
0.3Vo
24
11
75.1%
15.7yo
8.OVo 't.'t%o 0.00/o
824
172
t3
7'l
o.zyo
0.1./.
75.3%
10
354
0.1%
78.0% 't4.8% 7.00k o.2% 0.0% 0.0%
444
15.51o 8.8%
1.OVo
191 13
'tl.O%
6.370
67
32
1
10
0
11
1.2%
16-20
21+
2840
o.3%
0.070
1
0.1%
o.2% o.o%
36?5
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 22 of 52
lndependent Claims Ranges by TC Group
TC 2800 2400 2800 uroup 2850 2850
-
lndopendentcl
atmsKange
FY 2002 psrcént or Counl ol CaSeS Cæs6lñRân9ê
FY 2003
Count
ol Cases
6,662
p.Eènr or
c*¿s h tun86
FY 2004 Counl of p6rc6nt of câêôr CasêS ìn Rêngâ
FY 2005 Count of PEn{orcasós CaSeS ìnRongo
0t-03
04-05 06-10
2800
2800 2800 2800 2800
2850 2850
2850
6,459 1,603 8E6
97
40
70.90/"
70.6%
17.5% 1.4%
17.6%
1.649
938
7,A29 2,010
1.039 142 46
21
70.6%
14.1%
4.321
1,038 479 62
16
73.0./.
17.50/0 E.10Á
1.Oo/o
9.7%
't.10/o o.40to
9.4%
1.3Vo 0.40/o
o-2011
1r-15
16-20
21+
125
32
0.3%
0.2Vo
67.10/Þ
o.30/o
2850 2860
2860
19
1.392
0.2'/o
63.50/o 21.8Vo
0'l-03
04-05
06-10
2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800 2800
2800 2600
2860 2860 2860
2860
477
277
12.6% 1.5% 0,2% 0.4%
t1-15
16-20 2'l+
33 I
a,762
2,231
23 '1,467 42s 261
23
7
1.159
379
161
I
141 71 9 1 6.486 1,370 620
0.1%
76,50/o
67.20/r
19.4%
22.0% 9.3%
',t.3Vo
14.9Vo
7
11.9% 1.1%
0.30/o o.20/o
22 10,196
2.411
156
.50 '1,070
2A70
2470
2470 2570 2970
2A7O
2880 2880
01-03 04-05 06-10
11-15 16-20
21+
70.6%
16.0%
9,147
2,145 146
19
2 2
0.1Yo
0.1ô/o 0.oo/o
0.'t10
72.8%
17.10/.
72.A% 17.20h A.4%
1
75.404 15.9%
7.20/õ
1.160 169
67
2A
9.3%
'1.4%
1,069
't,489
443
8.5%
1.2olo
1,'t74
50 24
1.h
91
16 15
1.1%
o.20/o o.20/o
o.5%
o.20/o
2880 2880 2880
2880
0't-03 04-05 06-10 't 1-15
16-20 21+
1,271
417
250
0.3% 0.2%
66.6%
19.80/o
0.40/0
O.2o/o
63.9%
21.0o/o
1.697
535
66.2%
20.90/o
795
2't7
'I l
69.7% 19.0%
L7olo
12.6%
1.A%
35
't1
0.6% 0.3%
42.10Â
256 32 I
7
't't.A%
1.4%
0.40/o 0.30/o
273 46
7
10.7%
1.870
I
15
2
1.3%
o.2ø/o 0.1o/o
0.3%
0,20/o
4
1
79
2800 2800
2800
2890 2890
ot-03
04-05 06-10
11-15 16-20
21+
2690
2890
48 36 22 I
3
173
70 2g 6
61.3%
24.4o/o
31.6%
19.3%
714 r81
112
69.6%
17.6% 10.97o
'1.3%
0.40/a o.20/o
9.S%
2.10/o
2800
2800
3600 3600
3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600
2890 2890 3610
3610
3.5% 0.9% 2.6%
A2.20/o
3
13
4
r8 12
72.5% 16.5%
11.0yo o.ovo
0.00¿
1.1%
0.70to
0t-03
04-05 06-10 1't-15
16-20
4,902
746 276
31
2 5,218
o.o%
83.
I
o/o
't2.50h
4.6Vo
3610 3610
3610 3610
766
260
29
5.332
856
280
42.1%
13.2o/o 4.3o/o
2,991
416
'140
84.O%
12.2% 4.1% 0.5%
0.00/o
1't.7% 3.9%
0.30/0
0.5% 0.0%
24
0.4% 0.0% o.o%
11
't
o.o% 0.0%
63.40/o 22.30/o 12.zVo
6
0'l-03
04-05 06-10
0.t%
53.4!o
24.20/o
0.0%
3620 3620
3620 3620
3620
3.543 L605 74
50
3620
3630 3630
1t-15 t6-20
21+ 01-03 04-05 06-10
f,183 185 4.967
871 I 4
17.A%
3,291 1,465 1.038
111
54.3% 24.20Ã
17.10/.
3,423 1,501 s57
148
56.1% 24.6%
15.7%
2.40/o
1.770
623 340
2.4./. 1.'lyo 0.8%
79.4%
13.9ô/0
2.8%
1.Oyø
60
5,318 898 333 40
41
32
37
t3
ö
13%
0.5% 0.3%
81.5% 13.5%
4.7Vo
A.1Vo
0.6%
80.670
0.7% 0.5%
80.10lo
5,563
3630 3630
3630
13.6%
5,g1o
5.9%
0.60/o
0_
981 351
36
2.836
410
14.1ro 5.1% 0.5% 0.1% o.1%
78.20/o
163
5 5
I l-15
16-20 21+
o.6vo
10lo
3630
3640 3640
6 2,666
447
223
0.1% o.o%
0.1%
79.1Vo
3600
3600
3600
3640
01-03 04-05 06-10
2,760
474
221
a
3.034 564
7
0,1%
0.0vo 80.30/6
13.30/o 5.20/o
t3-6%
6.3%
80.4% 't2.5!o
6,20/r
1,712
242
14.51o
243
6.3%
1r0
Aö367ê
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 23 of 52
lndependent Claims
TC
by TC Group
pêrcnt or CáEos¡nRa¡go
Countol PêEonror Cas6s cæ6s¡nRárso
Count
of
CaSeS
3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600 3600
3640
11-15
3650
1í- 15
100 3660
1't-'t 5
67.1%
155
4.10/6
13
0.4Vo
414 3680
11-15
11.4%
14
0.40/.
s600 3700 3700
3700 3700 3700
37
t0
11-15
3700 3700 3700 3700
3700
3700 3700
3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700
12
0.1%
11
14
0.1vo
0.1%
3730
1,006
11-15
12,1%
3700 3700
3700 3700 3700 3700
3740 3740
06-10 I t-ls
15
0.1%
AO3êÞ77
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 24 of 52
lndependent Claims Ranges by TC Group
FY 2002
uroup
_
lndependntcl atmsxange
Counl
of CaSS
p6E6ñt or Csôs¡¡ Rorl8
3700
3750 3750
0t-03
04-05 06-10
1't- t5
'16-20
. 3700
3700 3700
3700
3750 3750 3750
3750
4,140 639 251
3'1
81.6%
12.60/0
FY 2003 prcênt ot çount of Câses C63ês lñRâñ96 4,433 82.40/0 12.O% 643
FY 2004 Count of psrcenr or caso¡ CaSeS ln Rø¡go
4,503
80.5% 13.1% 5.7%
0.670
FY 2005 Counl of psrce¡r or casos cass lñ Rángá
4.90/"
275
t9 4 4
733
317 34
5.1%
0.40/0 0.10/0
0.6v.
O.2fo
0:oo/o
t't
7
5.639
0.''t% 0.0% 72.70/. 16-8%
E.6olo
3700
3700 3700 3700 3700 3700 3700
21+
3760 3760
3760
3760
3760 3760
01-03 04-05 06-10
4.898
1.108
569
2
0:l%
72.00/û 17.50/"
73-3Vo
4.900
1.193 595
2.392 368 119 11 3 't 3,075
731
242
A2.7Vo
't2.7%
4.1%
0.4Vô
0.1%
o.Dyo
16.6%
1,302
ooc
74.3% 1f .?o/o
6.80¿
0.Ao,/o
8.5%
1.10/r
o.30/o o.20/o
A.7%
fl-15
l6-20
21+
72
17
14
86
t5
12
1.3%
o.2olo
101
29
17
1.3%
O.4lo
0.20/o
32
t3
o.2ro
5
161,984
0.3% 0.1%
290,663
292,602
308,375
No3ÉYe
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 25 of 52
Bahr. Robert
F¡om: Sent: To: Subiect:
Brown, Peter Toby Wednesday, October 19, 2005 8:12 AM Bahr, Robertì Young, Kereni Hunter, Daniel Not requested - 3rd Actions Plus by TC - 2005-10-1s.xls
llut likcl¡- \\'ill [r!'
l
reqLrestcd al sonle poilrl.
hc lst uorkshcct esplaitrs rihat lhe report shous. but in a nutshell,
\\''c look at all Oflice actiuls. but do NOT cou¡rt restrictions as O1'1ìce actions counls a¡.c. tletennitrcd. but wc festart actiou counts after an,v cPA. RCII or R129.
^ction lìcsulls arc conrpiled by'l'(1. corps and fìtllrcr an edited corps workshecl is includcd.
Onl). FY05 rvas upclatc-cl. l'he other lìYs, if upclatr,-d. r',ould havc VIìRY slight changcs ducs ttr l)Al,M lloLrblcshooting. etc.. but basicalll", o¡rce ¿ FY ends. the FY data is conrplete.
'l hanlisl
!
lìrtt¡'
3rd Actions P¡us bY
TC
- 2005-...
FO+3F?2
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 26 of 52
Logical Flow of Program
(rast updared october 15, 2oos)
All applications with office actions during FYs 02 - 05 were identified and all offìce actions from those applications were extracted. Then the actions were indexed and counted. Actions were selected from the mailing of a non-final rejection, a final rejection, an advisory action, a miscellaneous action, an independent rule 105 communication, an examiner's answer, a supplemental examiner's answer, a notlce of allowance, a letter of suspension (ML.SP only), an interference action, an ex parte Quayle action and an interference disposal. Also identified and included in the list of actions were the express abandonments for CPA, RCE or R129. When counting the Office actions, counts were restarted with any express abandonment. ln this way, same application could have multiple first actions, etc. Restrictions are not included in this analysis (i.e., they are not counted as Office actions)
>= 2). # 6+ represents all office actions numþered 6 or greater (and 2+ represents
Ao+373
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 27 of 52
OffiCe Action Analysis by TeCh Centef
Act¡on Number
1
(restrictions excluded) - updated october 15, 2o0s
Finals 77'l 9,545 1,697 589 Quayles
101
All Actions
Non-F¡nals
Allows
29,4U
24,178
3,976
1,201
5'16
4,148
7,495 3,780
1
Other 236
467
1 2'11
2
0 0 2
21,632
I
6 0 0
1
4
6+
10,420 3,987
1,582 1,323
227
Total
30,365
227
lao
13,018
149 83 46 23 26 428
116 148
91
,625
ô70 573
1
308 6
2',t5
6 0 0
1
2 n i u 3
i--
22,703 27 ,g37 1 3,739 20.243 2 1,292 10,335 3 576 3,691 t 262 1.502 s 259 e* ---------- ,4o4 66liìÏ--:-----2-8,ããi----:-r;t"f
't
525
9.366 1.807
471
4,378
o,oo.) 3,560
1
357 1,107
401
52
?-1_.
,485
236
-
578 453
75
'130
- aï:6o4
369
199
555 't 7.189 3,451 2,856 1,202
370
6 0 0
1
2 ^ u u 4 4
r 2 s ¿ s a6*
Total
1
26,534 18,868 9.175 3.350 1,400 1t?,1 ,231
1
22,453 3,793 1,263 642 276
2F,4 264
28
8'837
1,473
69
25
14
?5_
482 239
198
11
186 319 3,514 999
407
464
378 14.140
366
5.791
338
76
2
0
2
J
6 0 0
0
4
9r__
29,055 20,067 9,393 3,314 1,306
'1
24,914
3,931
1,301
428 10,292
1,717
3,404
5,403 2,787
441
233
317 3,529 989 318 338 724
124
59 32 'f6 18
,131
628 267 206
540
264 216
Total
.266
31247
325
13.513
Ao+37+
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 28 of 52
1
7 0 0
1
Office Action Analysis by Tech Center (restrictions exctuded) - updated october 15, 2oo5 Allows Ouâylês FY Action Number AllAct¡ons Non-Finals Finals 175 6,989 468 34.796 1 42.492 125 13,582 11,766 29,427 3]07 2 2 't,437 5J74 27 12,205 942 3 rì 1,741 "^ 20 377 4o2 3,640 + u 674 194 1'l 1sz 1.364 5 7 465 2 '117 1s4 e, 1oo4 6+1
Total
1
Other 64 247
4'625
1,100 333
132
40.116
14.39ô
2 0 ?
7 0 0
1
91.041
42,255
41,944 30,572 12,570 3,670 1,937 q¿Â 948
33,550 4,003 1 ,094 437 175 r33 133
39,392
34, f 16
330 12,1D5 1,576 428 176 '121 121 14,736
283
'1,355
287 141 47 18 5 13
511
7]20 14,106 5,257 1,675 662 429
57 217
4'596 1'112
3'ts
252
265
4,606
11
8'1
2
U
7 0 0
1
2 I
29,'tO2
3,646
936
4
11,504 3,164
?o5 4,565
1,007
'l,078 I
387 140
363
1 '¡OÂ
173
117
1
439
4
iril-1
79'l 87 42,259 30,333
12,407
112
39,337 37,185 5,336
1,648
too
39!_
258
6.438 93
301
27.813
4,405 9,705
1
374
202
109 22 15 6
7 0 0
2 0
2
J
ß,a82
1
,813
501
5,394
,151
0
4 5
6+
3,499
1
650
1J82
370 249
7.589
,163 732
202
143
216
127
369 208
Total
17.913
Aotzvs
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 29 of 52
Office Action Analysis by Tech Centef
FY 2
1
(restrictions exctuded) - updated october 15, 2oo5
0
rì
Number 1 2 2 3 0 4 ; 563694782309 v 2 a.
Act¡on
All
Act¡ons 16.791 9,991 3,992 1,437 414
Non-Finals 13.987 1,431 366 185 55
16,118
Finals 128 4,048 488 177 56 111 6,836 980 245 92 77 8,341
97
Quayles 156 50 19 7
Allows
Other
26 82
2,494
4,380
1,355
1,764
590
183
9,3',11
478
153 116
Totâl
î
4
5
33,261
22,478 14.699 6,430 1,909 697 438
651
238
192 65 25 5 1 1
289
4
2.619 27
83
2
1
0 0 2
1
2 0 0
I
19,317 2,475 679 307 126 58
27,690
2,831 5,240 1,796 &8 295 167
10.977 3,217 5,608
1,984
2,950 704
183
135
Total
I
2
2 3 4
31,22'l
17,965
175
69
7
1
1
42
77
2,779
772
9,432
1,107
'¡,¡1
0 0 2
1
0 0 4
8,012
2,414
959 587 61.158
438
166
168 76
4,142 843 246
183
6+
97
_--____??_o_-___-___
Total
31,942
29.914 4,385
11.21'l
198 16,143 172
12,213 3,192 6,569
57 130
2
U
2
,¡
27,290
12,173 3,210
1,.145
1,779
2,524
3 2
1
0 0
ß
729 245
180
473 226
1,O22
400
288
983 272
_?_0_9_
6+
Total
828 78.179
I
8.162
Ao*s1a
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 30 of 52
Office Action Analysis by Tech Center
Action Number
(restrictions exctuded) - updated october 1s,2005
Finals
All Act¡ons
30,101
19, r 91
Non-F¡nals
2 6 0 0
2 6
\J
I
2
24,956 3,729
1,217 601
)1)
7,530 454
193 113
Quayles 458 129
33
11
0 0 2
8,840
4
6+
3,223
1,328 906 63
222
5
5
152
30.877 28,309 4,863 1,719
Total
1
9.759
189
641
Allows 4,400 7,658 3,044 1,292 ô04 406 17 .404
Olher
145
3,309 865 304
230
4.908 44
160
34,124
23,383
10,992
¿ 0
z
J
9,572 't,690 217
610 114 39
7
4,972 8,674
3,576
1
3,968
0
4
5
3,629
I ,415
754
212
188 33,111
Ð,¿,to
,398
576
0 2 6 0 0
6+
973
139
402 788
689 9,070 3,680
10 1.498 19
Total
'I
74.516
39,347
12,U0
187
284 216 602
33
101
¿
2
25,6U
11
11,093
1,831 Þcu 304
.3
4
6+
,784
I ,718
4,051
1
0
,655 1,190
857 348
4.500 1,036
358
o
258
41.530
200
14,265 221 14,030
1,948
I
Total
478 20,689
253
ô,281
2 6 0 0
¿
ñ 0
'l 2 3 4 5 6+
Total
41 ,3O7
34,68'1
658
133 29
11
5,718
10,839
31,134 12,823 3,929
1.528 1,080
91
6,003 1,792 813 314 227
129
644
311
3.91? r,395
570
40'1
5,142
'1,066
5
200
17
328 248 6
Aoq377
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 31 of 52
Office ActiOn Analysis by Tech Center
Action Number
4
(restrictions excluded) - updated october 15, 2oo5
F¡nals
AllAct¡ons
68,075
44,441
2
Non-Finals 51,871
Ouayles
1,090
269
13,883
'1,81 't
I
0 0
2
¿ 0 0
¿
__91__
6,292
1.458
15.509 4,138
1
277 49
2',1
Allows 14,753 23,799 6.629
2,O79
691
Other 92
190
,368
493 179
81
469
198 109
1,076
14
.10
286
19't 7 92 158
786
134.317
I-9J-.!
60,374 49,950 6.867
1,883
16,739
1.461
'1,186
395 48
16,7 48
I
¿
2
8 0 0
2
n
4
c
68,194 47,O53 18,038 5,005 1,436 807
218
14,695
324
68
18
A A
1
2,314
598
187
25,009 7,667
6,106
1,224
666
2,495
733
381
182
115
326
201
't0z
18,114
47,194
6.291
.1,848
1
I
2
4
67,109 46,060 17,195 4,848
205 14,219
1,473
18,154 25,099
138 1,231
2,113
641 19
723
7,256 2,234
0 0 2
I ,660
262
144
258
118 17
343
I
2 0
Total
1
864 137.736
205
1.874
53,925 17,273 22,406 6,470 2,006 722 433
4S
7 '.t11 155
I
2
4
5
0 0
70,607 44,656 16,528 4,741 1,724
1
51,301
6,269 1,923
822
313
---19-8--
208 15,506 2,107 686
295
181 18
T otal
tt_- - _-___- ----1,-01-5-----------
1,714 322 53 22 7 4
) 122 1))
5,975 1,205 387 269
8,1
816
't0 310
Ao+zze
Case 1:07-cv-00846-JCC-TRJ
Document 174-8
Filed 12/27/2007
Page 32 of 52
Office ACtion AnalySiS by Tech Center
Action Number
(restrict¡ons exctuded) - updated october 15, 20os
F¡nals
All Actions
40,407 25,447
3 6 0 0
ó 6 0 0 ?
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
