Rosetta Stone LTD v. Google Inc.
Filing
162
Objection to 141 Witness List and Plaintiff's Rule 26 Disclosures filed by Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Cobb, Stephen)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
(Alexandria Division)
ROSETTA STONE LTD.
Plaintiff,
CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:09cv736
(GBL / TCB)
v.
GOOGLE INC.
Defendant.
GOOGLE INC.’S RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO
PLAINTIFF’S PRE-TRIAL DISCLOSURES
Defendant Google Inc. (“Google”) makes the following responses and objections to
Plaintiff’s pre-trial disclosures served on April 2, 2010.
I.
OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS TO ROSETTA STONE’S
DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Pursuant to Rule 32 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Google hereby makes the
following objections and counter-designations to Plaintiff Rosetta Stone Ltd.’s (“Rosetta Stone”)
Designation of Deposition Testimony. Google reserves the right to amend, supplement, or
withdraw its objections and counter-designations.
Google hereby objects as follows to the admission into evidence of the following
deposition testimony designated by Plaintiff. Google objects generally to the introduction of any
deposition testimony without a showing by Plaintiff that the witness whose testimony they seek
to introduce is unavailable as required by Federal Rule of Evidence 804 and Federal Rule of
Civil Procedure 32.
Google also hereby submits its counter-designations, which Google requests be read with
Plaintiff’s designations for completeness purposes if Plaintiff’s designated testimony is admitted
into evidence. Accordingly, Google submits these counter-designations conditionally and
reserves the right not to introduce any and all counter-designations. If Plaintiff’s designations
are not admitted, Google intends to withdraw the counter-designations listed below.
Google reserves the right to amend or supplement these counter-designations for any
reason, including without limitation in response to Plaintiff’s disclosure of trial witnesses, trial
exhibits, deposition designations or other required disclosures. Furthermore, Google reserves its
right to object, or to not object, to the entry into evidence of any deposition exhibit on any basis,
notwithstanding any objection or counter-designation below relating to that exhibit.
Because the admissibility of testimony from a witness depends on the context, the
inclusion of testimony from a witness on Google’s own list of designations is not a waiver and
should not be construed as a waiver of the right to object to the testimony or the use of the
testimony when offered by Plaintiff. In addition, Google reserves the right to use at trial any
testimony on Plaintiff’s designations.
For those objections which are identified by an abbreviated code, the code corresponds to
an objection as set forth below:
CODE
A
AA
B
C
CC
CD
DI
DSI
IH
MT
NR
O
V
30b6
103
104a
OBJECTION
Argumentative
Asked and answered
Beyond scope of counter-designation
Cumulative
Calls for conclusion
Compound
Designation incomplete; incomprehensible
Document speaks for itself
Incomplete hypothetical
Misstates prior testimony (mischaracterization)
Non-responsive
Overbroad
Vague and ambiguous
Outside of the scope of FRCP 30b6 deposition topics
for which witness was designated
Assumes facts not in evidence
Lacks foundation
CODE
402
403
602
611c
701
702
802
901
OBJECTION
Relevance
Unduly prejudicial
Calls for speculation; speculative
Leading
Improper opinion by lay witness
Improper opinion by expert
Hearsay
Authenticity
Google hereby submits its objections and counter-designations to Rosetta Stone’s
deposition designations as follows:
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/09/2010
3/9/2010
15:8-15:16
15:20-15:25
19:9-19:14
20:14-21:13
21:25-22:7
23:12-24:25
25:9-25:18
28:9-30:6
34:16-34:22
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
34:23-35:18
35:11-35:15
35:19-35:25
36:13-38:9
39:5-35:9
50:12-51:24
103:11-103:15
111:21-112:12
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
123:10-123:15
123:16-123:19
124:21-125:13
126:15-129:10
1
colloquy.
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
V
AA
V, AA
V, CD, AA
V, AA
V, O
104a, V
V, 30b6
104a, 602,
CD
MT, AA, V
V
104a, 602
104a, 602
DI, 104a, 602
104a, 602
402, AA
104a, 802,
901
402, 403
AA
602, V, IH
V, O
Google objects to all designations by Plaintiff that include attorney objections and
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
140:4-140:10
148:15-149:8
Aguiar, Christina
Aguiar, Christina
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
180:14-180:25
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
14:9-18
46:2-8
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
46:12-25
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
47:1-4
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
47:7-16
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
48:19-49:5
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
58:2-17
70:12-71:4
71:17-72:1
72:18-25
73:1-15
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
Alferness, Jonathan
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
3/12/2010
75:18-22
75:23-76:6
76:8-15
76:17-24
76:25-78:6
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
23:17-21
25:10-25:17
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, CD
104a, 602, A,
V
602, AA
103:4-103:10;
52:20-53:17;
112:13-114:21;
122:13-123:8;
147:18-148:14
104a, V
30b6, 402,
602
30b6, 402,
602, 104a
30b6, 104a,
402
30b6, 104a,
402, 403
30b6, 104a,
602, 402
104a, V, 402
V
402, 104a
402, 104a
402, 104a,
901, 602
AA, 104a
V, 30b6
V
V
V, 30b6
78:8-79:25;
13:7-14:7;
8:18-21;
9:20-23;
11:18-12:4;
12:7-15
DI
CD
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
33:14-33:24
37:11-38:7
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
85:16-86:2
93:2-93:12
117:21-118:14
153:19-153:23
154:22-155:3
155:4-155:12
155:13-156:6
171:13-172:1
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
172:2-172:6
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
172:7-172:11
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
181:21-182:5
182:6-11
187:24-189:21
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
189:22-191:5
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
192:23-193:17
194:1-195:15
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
196:11-197:11
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
198:18-199:6
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
208:17-209:3
Chen, Terri
Chen, Terri
2/23/2010
2/23/2010
209:4-209:10
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
13:1-13:4
13:8-13:14
14:10-14:16
18:7-18:17
19:8-19:16
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
402
402, 403, 103,
602
104a, C
104a, 103, C
104a
104a, V
MT
104a, 602
AA, 602
103, 104a,
30b6
104a, AA,
30b6, 103
103, 104a,
30b6
104a, 30b6
104a
104a, 901,
30b6, 802
901, 30b6,
802, 104a
104a, 30b6
901, 602,
104a, 402,
30b6, V
104a, 30b6,
602
30b6, 104a,
602
104a, 30b6,
V, CC
AA
24:1-11;
23:6-16; 23:22-23
V
V
V
104a, V, O
104a
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
2/24/2010
19:18-19:24
21:25-22:11
22:16-22:19
54:19-55:5
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
55:17-56:23
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
62:6-62:25
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
63:14-63:20
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
64:1-64:8
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
65:10-65:22
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
69:18-70:7
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
70:23-73:12
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
78:5-78:21
Chiang, Edward
2/24/2010
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
Datta, Sanjay
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a
V, O
104a, 602
104a, 402,
802, 901
104a, 402,
802, 901
104a, 402,
802, 901
104a, 402,
802, 901
104a, 402,
802, 902
104a, 402,
802, 901
104a, 802,
901
104a, 802,
901
104a, 802,
901
79:10-81:2;
67:1-67:8;
18:18-19:6;
20:2-20:25
16:15-16:22
27:12-27:19
27:21-28:2
34:14-34:20
35:14-35:17
35:18-35:22
36:12-36:21
39:19-39:22
40:4-40:7
41:12-41:15
41:23-42:3
42:9-42:15
42:16-43:1
45:8-45:13
104a, V
V
602, 30b6
104a
602
602
O, V
V, 104a
AA
MT
AA
IH, AA
CD, O, V
30b6
10:13-10:22;
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
DuBow, Steve2
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
15:12-20
16:15-20
17:7-10
17:16-19
19:1-3
19:22-20:7
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
20:12-14
20:17-20
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
21:10-12
21:21-5
25:13-31:2
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
31:6-9
31:16-34:22
35:7-36:6
36:12-37:21
38:2-12
38:13-17
41:11-12
63:8-64:10
64:11-20
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
85:18-86:18
110:10-13
111:6-113:3
113:4-15
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
114:9-12
114:13-16
114:17-21
116:18-22
117:4-5
117:13-14
117:16-21
117:22-118:15
2
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
45:14-45:17
103
402
V
NR
104a
402, 403, 901,
802
V
402, 403, 901,
802
103, V
V
802, 104a,
602, DSI
602
802, DSI, 901
802, DSI, 901
802, DSI, 901
802, 901
AA, NR
104a
NR
402, 104a,
NR
V, NR
104a
802, 901, DSI
104a, 802,
602
104a
104a, 802
104a
802, 901
802, 104a, V
104a
AA
104a, 802,
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
118:16-17
119:5-9
119:19-120:1
DuBow, Steve
DuBow, Steve
3/8/2010
3/8/2010
120:2-10
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
26:10-23:12
30:11-30:21
45:2-45:17
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
54:7-54:16
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
55:1-55:8
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
55:14-55:17
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
55:23-56:2
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
56:5-56:8
56:5-58:2
56:17-56:20
58:12-58:16
58:24-60:4
60:20-62:18
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
65:16-19
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
68:24-69:10
68:24-70:6
78:14-78:1
79:4-80:19
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
901, DSI
104a
104a
901, 104a,
403
A, 104a, 611c
121:13-125:6;
126:19-127:5;
128:3-18;
88:9-90:17;
94:4-98:7;
98:9-99:21,
70:6-21;
74:6-81:19;
64:21-69:14
104a
30b6, 104a
602, V, O,
104a
103,402, 602,
104a
103, 402,
602, 104a
103, 402,
602, 104a
104a, 402,
602
AA
402
AA
402
402,
402, 901, 602,
104a
V, O, 104a,
602, 402
104a
402
402
402, 104a,
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
82:17-83:21
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
84:12-84:18
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
85:4-85:9
85:9-85:17
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
85:25-86:6
86:7-86:21
91:12-92:14
92:17-93:4
93:1-93:16
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
Dulitz, Dan
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
2/26/2010
94:22-94:
99:23-100:4
107:3-108:25
118:5-119:11
139:20-141:23
142:14-143:1
143:21-145:18
153:10-156:25
155:3-155:8
156:20-156:25
Fuloria, Prashant3
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
10:16-11:3
17:17-18:5
22:4-20
3
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
602
402, 104a,
602
V, 30b6, AA,
402, 104a,
602, V
AA
AA, 402, 602,
104
104a
402
402
402
402, 104a,
602
104a, 402
V, 104a, 402
402
402, 30b6
402
402
402
402
104a
AA
143:2-143:20;
109:1-109:16;
103:10-104:7;
103:4-103:9;
100:18-100:16;
102:5-102:16;
96:6-98:1;
31:5-31:7;
30:1-30:10
402
402
402, 403,
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
23:8-18
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
23:24-24:9
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
25:23-26:23
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
28:1-29:25
31:14-33:11
34:4-25
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
35:1-36:6
36:7-37:5
37:6-9
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
37:10-12
37:13-18
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
40:9-23
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
41:20-44:11
44:12-45:3
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
45:24-46:11
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
45:12-18
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
45:19-47:1
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
47:22-48:10
49:14-50:4
51:19-52:7
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
57:1-7
77:14-78:1
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
79:6-23
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
79:24-80:16
83:6-17
85:16-86:3
Objections1
901, 104a
402, 403,
901, 104a
402, 403,
901, 104a
402, 403,
104a, 901
402, 403
402, 403, V
402, 403,
901
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403,
901
402, 403
402, 403,
901
402, 403,
901
402, 403
402, 403,
104a
402, 403,
104a
402, 403,
104a, AA
402, 403,
104a
402, 403
402, 403, C
402, 403,
MT
402, C, 104a
402, 403,
104a
402, 403,
CD
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403,
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
86:4-89:2
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
98:14-99:25
154:24-155:11
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
155:12-20
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
155:21-156:16
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
156:17-158:22
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
5/18/2006
5/18/2006
8:7-17
Fuloria, Prashant4
Fuloria, Prashant
8/9/2006
8/9/2006
195:3-7
195:8-23
Fuloria, Prashant
Fuloria, Prashant
8/9/2006
8/9/2006
199:23-200:14
224:22-225:1
Fuloria, Prashant
8/9/2006
225:2-13
Fuloria, Prashant
8/9/2006
225:24-226:4
Fuloria, Prashant5
8/9/2006
194:22-195:2
Fuloria, Prashant
8/9/2006
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, 602,
802
402, 403,
104a, 602
402, 403
402, 403,
104a, 901,
602, CD
402, 403,
104a, 901,
602
402, 403,
104a, 901,
602, V, CD
402, 403,
104a, 602,
901
402
159:2-160:9;
160:11-13;
160:16-161:8;
117:18-118:14;
54:14-25
402, 403
402, 403,
104a, 602
DI, 402, 403
402, 403,
901, 104a
402, 403,
901
402, 403,
901, DI
402, 403,
104a, 602
226:5-15;
4
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
5
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
15:19-16:6
19:25-20:12
21:20-22:4
22:12-22:17
24:20-24:24
26:11-27:1
37:2-37:10
39:17-39:19
41:15-42:11
50:10-50:22
52:9-53:11
54:12-54:14
65:18-65:25
66:1-66:4
72:14-73:6
86:9-86:25
87:1-87:13
88:15-88:17
89:9-89:11
89:15-89:19
97:3-97:20
97:23-98:9
101:16-102:21
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
102:22-104:8
116:18-117:5
119:11-119:23
119:24-120:7
123:3-124:4
124:12-124:15
124:16-124:22
124:23-125:4
125:5-125:8
135:12-135:23
138:12-138:15
139:4-139:9
141:5-141:18
144:23-144:25
Objections1
V
602, V
602
104a, 602
602, V
104a, 602
104a, 602
AA
402
402
602, A
V
104a, 602, V
AA, V
104a, 602
104a
CD, V, O
602
104a
104a
CD, V
104a, 402
104a, 602,
802
104a, 602
104a, 602
501, 402
402
104a, 602
AA
V
AA
104a
104a, V, O
104a
V, O
602
602, V
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
199:21-22;
211:8-20
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
162:17-162:23
163:23-165:4
169:16-169:19
170:1-170:5
170:9-170:24
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
Gultekin, Baris
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
3/4/2010
171:11-171:16
171:17-172:6
172:9-172:11
172:12-172:22
174:13-174:15
175:7-175:15
187:13-188:13
Hagan, Rose6
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
14:12-15:12
15:19-23
2:22-26:3
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
26:14-27:2
29:19-21
31:23-33:4
46:23-47:20
62:13-63:3
66:23-67:8
74:13-75:18
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
86:21-87:3
87:11-20
92:16-93:7
6
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a
104a, 602
104a, 602, DI
104a
104a, 602,
AA
MT
104a, V
104a, V, AA
V, CD
104a, 602
103, 104a, V
104a, 602
183:1-183:9;
176:3-177:4;
172:23-173:23;
146:3-146:15;
145:8-145:18;
22:18-23:11;
89:20-89:24;
66:17-66:22;
58:1-58:25
402
402
402, CD,
104a
402
402
402
402
402, V
402, V, 104a
402, V, NR,
104a
402, V, 104a
402, V, 104a
402, DI
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
Name
Date
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
101:14-20
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
9/30/2004
115:5-16
166:16-167:1
179:4-180:3
210:20-211:11
212:24-213:1
213:6-21
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
215:10-14
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
222:12-223:5
Hagan, Rose
9/30/2004
223:8-25
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose7
8/10/2006
Objections1
9/30/2004
7
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
402, IH,
602, 701
402, C
402, C
402, V
402, 104a
DI, 402, V
402, DI, V,
802
402, DI, V,
104a
402, 104a,
V, IH, 602
V, 402, IH,
602, DI
224:2-6;
216:4-20;
213:22-214:25;
211:12-17;
165:13-166:15;
174:16-24; 176:518; 178:2-25;
189:6-190:7,
105:25-106:10;
106:21-107:6;
96:10-22; 100:717; 100:24101:13; 75:19-22,
24; 76:2-7;
33:5-12; 36:1937:7; 37:10-11;
47:21-48:1;
48:19-49:1;
27:9-12; 28:2;
28:11-13;
15:24-16:1; 17:416
136:19-23
402, DI,
104a
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Hagan, Rose
8/10/2006
137:17-138:1
Hagan, Rose
8/10/2006
167:10-168:13
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose8
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
8/10/2006
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
52:19-53:7
52:7-15
57:5-20
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
86:25-87:5
90:12-18
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
91:1-5
196:16-197:1
197:22-198:11
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
11/29/2006
11/29/2006
199:11-14
219:18-220:5
Hagan, Rose9
11/29/2006
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
402, DI,
104a
402, 602,
CC, 104a, CD
136:9-18
402, DI
402, DI
402, 403,
DI, 104a, CD
402, 104a
402, DI,
403, 802
402, DI, 403
402, 403, DI
402, 403,
DI, 104a, 802
402, DI
402, 403,
602, DI, IH
20:9-12, 14-23;
24:13-25:12;
37:6-9, 13-17, 19;
46:3-12; 47:2023; 48:13-14;
49:15-3; 52:2-6
37:9-11, 15-18;
56:2-57:3;
85:8011; 87:2488:3; 88:5-8;
88:21-24; 193:2022; 194:1-2,
223:16-22,
92:3-11; 143:819; 176:18-25;
177:2
17:9-18:2
402, 403
8
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
9
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
19:3-19:21
24:16-24:20
24:16-24:19
28:25-29:17
30:12-30:23
31:20-32:23
32:24-33:8
33:9-33:14
37:14-37:19
38:21-39:2
48:8-48:11
48:13-49:6
57:13-57:2
65:6-65:24
65:25-66:16
69:6-69:16
79:25-80:8
80:9-80:12
86:1-86:8
96:19-97:3
98:11-98:17
116:17-116:22
125:21-126:7
128:20-128:24
135:2-135:7
135:2-135:18
136:18-136:22
137:11-137:21
137:22-138:7
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
140:19-140:22
141:16-141:22
141:23-142:20
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
142:21-143:13
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
143:14-143:20
143:22-144:2
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
148:21-149:19
Objections1
402, 403
V
402
104a, 901
802, 104a
802, 104a
A, AA, 104a
104a
602, 104a
104a
V
306b, 104a
V
104a, 602
103, 104a
104a, 602
V
104a
104a
V
V
104a
104a
104a
104a
402
104a, 402
402, 104a
MT, 104a,
402, 403
402, 104a
402, 306b
901, 402, 802,
30b6
602, 104a,
402, 802,
30b6
30b6, 402, V
V, 104a,
30b6, 402
402, 403,
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
151:17-152:21
Hagan, Rose
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
158:21-159:4
159:21-163:25
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
164:4-164:16
Hagan, Rose
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a
402, 403,
104a
V
901, 602,
30b6, 104a,
802
901, 104a,
802
3/5/2010
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
Objections1
28:18-28:24;
40;11-41:23;
42:12-43:3;
44:19-45:24;
56:4-56:15;
56:19-57:12;
58:4-58:12;
73:2-73:25;
76:25-77:4;
80:18-81:17;
81:22-82:7;
86:13-86:20;
91:4-91:6;
91:17-92:14;
92:23-96:4;
97:11-98:17;
99:18-100:13;
117:19-117:25;
123:13-124:23;
130:23-132:14;
134:2-134:4;
147:10-148:15;
154:17-155:1;
157:22-24;
158:4-158:7;
168:13-168:21;
169:11-169:19;
170:15-171:3;
171:19-171:25
18:21-19:12
26:3-9
27:18-23
104a
AA
104a, 602
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
27:24-28:17
28:18-25
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
110:13-11:4
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
111:14-25
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
118:19-23
120:12-121:8
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
121:15-122:18
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
122:20-23
123:7-124:8
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
124:10-25
125:3-11
125:17-126:14
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
3/5/2010
126:16-20
126:22-25
127:1-15
Holden, Richard
3/5/2010
Jeffries, Deborah10
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
14:8-14:17
14:18-15:17
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
16:6-16:7
16:8-16:14
16:15-16:19
18:8-18:20
19:3-19:9
20:2-20:7
20:8-20:11
20:18-20:22
Objections1
10
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, 602
MT, 104a,
103, 602
104a, 602,
402, 901, 802
104a, 602,
402
802, 402
802, 602, 402,
CD
802, AA,
104a, CD
AA
AA, 802, 402,
602
MT, AA, A
A, AA, 402
AA, A, 402,
104a
402
802, 402
A, 802, 402,
AA
17:15-18:20;
19:13-14; 19:1820:9; 112:16113:7
403, 802
104a, 402,
403, V
103, 104a
802
104a
802, DSI
802
V
104a
104a
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
24:6-24:9
27:18-28:2
28:17-28:20
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
29:11-32:20
34:11-34:14
37:10-37:17
38:17-39:3
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
39:4-39:14
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
41:6-41:7
41:8-41:10
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
41:11-41:20
Jeffries, Deborah
Jeffries, Deborah
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
78:6-79:2
Karen, Alana
Karen, Alana
Karen, Alana
Karen, Alana
Karen, Alana
3/2/2010
3/2/2010
3/2/2010
3/2/2010
3/2/2010
14:8-16
14:24-16:6
21:11-17
23:3-11
95:3-18
Karen, Alana
3/2/2010
95:19-96:4
Karen, Alana
3/2/2010
96:5-20
Karen, Alana
3/2/2010
96:21-97
58:18-59:1
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a
104a, 602
104a, 802,
DSI
802, 901, DSI
802
104a
104a, 802,
901, DSI
104a, 402,
403, 802, 901,
DSI
402, 403
104a, 402,
403
402, 403
104a, 802,
901, DSI
402
79:22-80:19;79:379:9; 60:1277:15; 48:352:11; 46:2147:19
402, 403
402, 403
104a
V, 402, 403
901, 104a,
402, 403
402, 403,
104a
402, 403,
104a, 802
402, 403,
104a, 602,
802
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
14:1-7
15:1-3
16:5-7
17:17-23
17:25-18:8
18:9-17
27:15-20
30:14-31:25
34:10-20
34:21-25
35:7-36:20
36:21-37:20
37:22-38:5
38:7-14
38:16-24
39:12-40:5
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
44:20-45:1
45:3-12
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
47:7-11
47:12-18
47:20-48:8
50:21-51:2
51:10-15
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
51:16-22
52:10-24
55:14-24
56:2-7
57:58:25
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
59:1-21
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
60:13-25
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
61:22-62:2
62:4-8
62:13-17
62:23-63:14
Objections1
CD
AA
V
V, 104a
104a
104a, V, CD
104a
402
V, 104a
V
602, O
V, 104a
MT, 104a
MT, 104a
V
402, 403,
602
V, CD
104a, 402,
403
104a
V, 104a
V, 602, 104a
V
AA
104a
104a, V
402, 602
402
104a, 402,
403, 802
104a, 103,
402, 403,
602
104a, 402,
403
V
V
V
104a, 602
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
63:15-64:2
64:12-65:9
74:1-6
75:12-77:6
77:11-17
80:22-24
84:15-21
90:7-13
91:7-23
98:8-24
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
99:2-8
99:10-101:1
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
101:2-11
113:8-13
114:14-115:13
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
115:14-20
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
115:23-117:3
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
117:17-118:13
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
Lloyd, Bill
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
122:6-14
122:15-18
122:19-24
123:6-8
123:9-12
123:13-17
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
11:8-13
15:4-9
16:6-13
17:6-24
17:25-18:12
18:13-22:3
24:24-25:11
25:12-26:5
28:2-11
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, 602
104a, 602
104a, V, 602
104a, 602
104a, 602
V
AA
104a, V
802, 602
802, 104a,
901, 602
104a, 30b6
802, 104a,
901, 602
AA, 402
V, 104a, 402
104a, 802,
901
104a, 802,
901, MT
104a, 802,
901
104a, 103,
MT, 602
104a, 602
602
104a, 602
602
104a, 602
104a, 602
61:11; 13-16
V
V
V
V, O, 602
V, O, 602
V, O, 602
V, 602, 104a
104a, 602
CD
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
33:2-12
33:19-25
34:1-5
24:6-25
35:16-36:4
36:5-8
37:4-9
37:13-23
37:24-38:7
38:16-25
39:1-15
39:16-18
39:21-40:15
40:16-20
42:13-22
51:11-15
57:17-58:11
64:24-65:5
65:6-23
66:11-18
71:24-73:2
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
86:10-87:1
91:24-92:7
123:7-18
124:16-24
124:25-125:13
125:17-127:2
127:3-10
129:7-131:2
131:3-132:2
133:1-12
Louie, Cory
Louie, Cory
2/25/2010
2/25/2010
133:20-22
134:11-23
Louie, Cory
2/25/2010
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, 602
104a, 602
602, V, 104a
602, 104a
AA
CD
MT
602
CD, 602
602
CD, V
104a, 602
V
MT, 103
V
104a
V
V, 402
V, 402
402
V, O, 602,
AA, 402
DI, V, 104a
602
104a, 901
802
802, 104a
104a, 802
104a, 602
104a, 802
104a, 602
104a, 802,
602, DSI
V
104a, 602,
802, DSI
86:8-9;
14:25-15:3
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Page, Larry11
1/1/2007
70:13-22
Page, Larry
1/1/2007
72:8-19
Page, Larry
1/1/2007
82:17-25
Page, Larry
1/1/2007
83:1-7
Page, Larry
1/1/2007
97:19-98:4
Porter, Rita Kay12
3/10/2010
15:10-16:6
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
16:19-17:22
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
17:25-18:14
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
18:23-19:25
20:18-21:6
21:10-21:14
22:8-22:11
22:15-22:23
23:13-23:17
24:16-24:20
24:21-26:8
26:18-27:4
27:18-27:22
28:6-28:13
29:1-29:24
29:25-30:9
30:10-30:17
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
31:10-31:22
Objections1
CC, IH, 602,
701, 402, 403
CC, IH,
104a, 402,
602, 701
403, C, 104a,
602
CC, IH, 103,
104a, 402,
403, 602, 701
104a, 402,
403, 602
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
70:3-12; 99:7-23,
129:21-130:11;
131:20-132:11;
136:13-24
104a, 802,
901
104a, 602,
901
104a, 901,
CD
602, 901
602, 802
V
AA
104a, 701
104a
104a, 602
602, 802, DSI
104a
104a, DSI
402, 802, V
802, DSI
802
104a, 602,
802
602, 802
11
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: 802, Rule
26(a)(1) , 402, 403
12
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
32:20-32:22
33:1-33:2
33:18-33:20
33:23-24:15
35:2-35:14
35:23-36:5
37:18-38:2
38:10-38:18
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
38:19-38:22
39:1-39:10
40:14-40:17
40:22-41:10
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
Porter, Rita Kay
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
3/10/2010
41:25-42:3
42:6-42:7
53:2-53:11
73:8-73:14
73:15-74:6
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
17:3-17:12
20:12-18
21:1-19
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
AA
802
104a
802, 901
802
802
802
104a, 611c,
901
DSI
802
802, DI
104a, 402,
802, DSI
CD
611c
602, DI
802, 901, DI
802, 901
18:21-18:22;
27:17;
40:13;
43:22-46:3;
48:10-49:11;
43:5-43:15;
43:22-46:3;
48:10-49:11;
43:5-43:15;
78:4-78:25;
76:18-78:2;
75:9-76:15;
74:19-75:7;
73:7;
61:16-68:14;
54:14-58:25;
53:12-54:9;
53:12-54:9;
53:1; 49:14-52:15
V, DI
AA, 402, 403
402, 403
Name
Date
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
24:6-24:20
25:13-19
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
29:7-29:18
31:17-23
33:6-10
38:11-16
52:15-21
54:9-22
61:17-20
64:16-25
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
65:1-9
67:7-68:25
Sharma, Nitin
Sharma, Nitin
3/11/2010
3/11/2010
74:25-75:7
Stanley, Diana13
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
7:11-9:3
12:4-9
12:16-22
14:10-14
15:2-11
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
16:4-9
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
16:10-19
16:21-17:5
17:6-20
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
17:21-18:3
22:11-23:2
23:13-24:6
25:17-26:6
27:11-28:5
28:15-21
31:5-9
31:11-18
13
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
AA, 402, 403
30b6, DI,
104a
V
AA
AA
CD
104a, 30b6
AA
DI
602, 104a,
30b6
30b6, 104a
602, 104a,
30b6
104a, 602
25:13-25:19;
61:20
402
103, 602
802
V, 104a
901, 402, 403,
802
V, CD, 103,
104a
802, 602
CC, 602, V
901, 402, 403,
104a, 802
V, 602, 103
802, DSI, 901
802
802, 602, 901
802, 402
802, 402
802, 901, 402
802, 901, 402,
Google objects globally to all designations in this deposition as follows: , 402, 403
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
31:19-32:8
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
32:9-14
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
32:15-18
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
32:19-22
33:1-5
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
33:21-34:9
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
33:10-14
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
33:15-19
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
Stanley, Diana
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
3/9/2010
83:2-13
83:14-16
84:6-12
84:13-17
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
11:20-11:23
25:6-25:11
25:13-25:21
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
AA
802, 901, 402,
DSI
802, 901, 602,
402, 104a
802, 901, 602,
402
AA
901, 602, 802,
104a
901, 602, 402,
802
901, 602, 402,
802, 104a
901, 602, 402,
802
901, 402, 802
AA
802, A, 611c
802
5:12-13; 21:1719; 22:3-7; 35:1736:9; 38:3-4;
38:8-10; 38:1722; 39:15-18;
40:21-41:4; 41:815; 41:20-42:5;
42:9-14; 42:1843:1; 43:3-15;
45:19-46:12;
47:12-18; 48:2249:3; 53:20-54:6;
54:16-22; 62:915; 70:8-20, 22;
71:1-9; 71:1172:14; 73:9-21;
74:12-21; 74:2275:4; 75:6
104a, DI
104a, V
V, 602
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
Vij, Ashish
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
3/3/2010
27:1-27:5
27:7-27:12
27:13-27:17
27:18-28:13
51:9-51:17
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
6:17-7:13
9:16-20
11:16-25
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
15:22-16:7
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
21:6-9
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
21:10-22:11
24:9-20
24:21-25:4
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
25:5-14
37:3-7
38:15-19
38:25-39:9
50:16-51:16
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
71:3-72:1
72:15-73:19
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
78:13-79:3
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
79:4-19
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
80:2-18
83:15-84:8
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
84:13-20
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
84:22-85:10
Objections1
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, V, 402
104a, V, 402
104a, V
104a, V
V, 104a, 602
6:10-6:11; 6:186:20; 6:24-7:4;
9:1-9:14; 10:1511:18; 11:24-12:5
DI
V, O
O, V, 104a,
402
104a, 103,
402
104a, 103,
402
402
402
402, 104a,
602
402
V, O
103, 402
602, 104a
V, CD, 103,
602, IH
CD
104a, 901,
602
602, 901, V,
104a
MT, V, 901,
602, 104a
V, 104a, 602
V, 104a, 901,
602
AA, 104a,
901, 602
104a, AA
Name
Date
Rosetta Stone’s
Designated Depo
Testimony
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
121:12-122:8
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
130:2-131:3
132:22-133:10
137:14-17
143:1-144:19
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
144:20-145:13
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
146:6-12
154:14-155:6
163:6-10
164:9-21
165:1-16
201:22-202:19
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
203:11-204:5
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
204:19-205:13
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
205:25-207:1
207:2-20
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
207:21-208:7
208:8-23
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
208:25-210:4
Wojcicki, Susan
Wojcicki, Susan
3/18/2010
3/18/2010
210:5-211:6
211:7-25
Wojcicki, Susan
Objections1
3/18/2010
II.
Google’s
Counter
Designated
Testimony
104a, 901,
602
602
104a, 602
AA
901, 802,
104a, 402,
403
AA, 103,
104a, 402,
403
104a, 602
402
V, 402, 104a
CD, 802
V, 602, 402
DI, 104a, 602,
AA, 103
104a, 802,
901
104a, 802,
901
V, 104a
104a, 103,
602
V, 602, 104a
104a, 103,
602
V, A, 104a,
602
104a
104a, 103,
602
6:16; 17:9-18:13;
201:21
OBJECTIONS TO ROSETTA STONE’S TRIAL EXHIBITS
Google hereby objects to the admission into evidence of the trial exhibits identified by
Rosetta Stone in its pre-trial disclosures as indicated on Exhibit A hereto. Google reserves its
right to object, or to not object, to the entry into evidence of any exhibit on any basis,
notwithstanding any objection or non-objection in Exhibit A. Google further reserves its right to
amend and/or supplement its objections to the extent permitted by this Court’s rules, and does
not waive its right to object to documents under the attorney-client, work product, or other
applicable privileges.
Because the admissibility of an exhibit is dependent on the context, the inclusion of a trial
exhibit in Google’s own pre-trial disclosures is not a waiver and should not be construed as a
waiver of the right to object to the admission or the use of an exhibit when offered by Plaintiff.
Dated: April 9, 2010
Respectfully Submitted,
GOOGLE INC.
By counsel
/s/
Jonathan D. Frieden, Esquire (VSB No. 41452)
Stephen A. Cobb, Esquire (VSB No. 75876)
ODIN, FELDMAN & PITTLEMAN, P.C.
9302 Lee Highway, Suite 1100
Fairfax, Virginia 22031
(703) 218-2100
(703) 218-2160 (facsi e)
jonathan.frieden@ofplaw.com
stephen.cobb@ofplaw.com
Margret M. Caruso, Esquire (Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
QUINN, EMANUEL, URQUHART & SULLIVAN, LLP
555 Twin Dolphin Drive, Fifth Floor
Redwood Shores, California 94065
(650) 801-5101
(650) 801-5100 (facsi e)
margretcaruso@quinnemanuel.com
Counsel for Defendant Google Inc.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 9th day of April, 2010, I electronically filed the
foregoing with the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF system, which then sent a notification of
such filing (NEF) to the following:
Warren Thomas Allen, II, Esquire
SKADDEN ARPS SLATE MEAGHER & FLOM LLP
1440 New York Ave NW
Washington, DC 20005-2111
202-371-7126
202-661-9063 (facsimile)
wtallen@skadden.com
Counsel for Plaintiff Rosetta Stone Ltd.
/s/
Jonathan D. Frieden, Esquire (VSB No. 41452)
Stephen A. Cobb, Esquire (VSB No. 75876)
ODIN, FELDMAN & PITTLEMAN, P.C.
9302 Lee Highway, Suite 1100
Fairfax, Virginia 22031
(703) 218-2100
(703) 218-2160 (facsimile)
jonathan.frieden@ofplaw.com
stephen.cobb@ofplaw.com
Counsel for Defendant Google Inc.
#1217204v1
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?