Humphreys & Partners Architects, L.P. v. Lessard Design, Inc. et al

Filing 346

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge T. S. Ellis, III on 9/2/14. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix)(gwalk, )

PARK CREST TWO

r-

Pi

GRANT PARK

>•

2

z

>

\ " \
\

V )| ^V,

T" -\

; 1 1 r i; I:' i-.'iu)-j,i

^ i '. '. I

I' !• i!

I'.i,';

E

f®

;r i

m

GRANT PARK

Front Elevation

m
m

m

m

m

(not cornice)

11

mnyio

PHaii

ijtjjniiyniiKVBji vif5|||M]y|j sBin eshii

i|^i:^;^ili8iilijfi^i^l!i;ai[ii' :i]«;^miiBii|:i^i!fin[!!ipM
nil iltliii iit^ It!

Front Elevation
TWO PARK CREST

imn

m.

imliii ilii m mi

gaiSBSmiEmBimlliiiaii is:|lIia::isti!Bijlii!|^M.^liiiis
fiiiHWflTsiw lUiffl liiHiiii. jHill!!iSM'ri^'jB||us| iit| iiiii

ilps^'i

!iij|3i^M!^i|pRi:Gj^iiiiiiii]iii 'fas:rmiiP!i!i;j««[|i:ii!iiife

Cornice

Roof fascia

Balustrade

Rear Elevation

GRANT PARK

(From Opus Architects' construction documents)

swislaa'i

HiliiWii

'A'

iV.

Rear Elevation
TWO PARK CREST

(f,

J,

I .? 5

Side Elevation

(From Opus Architects' construction documents')
GRANT PARK

Eli

Side Elevation
TWO PARK CREST

Trash Chute

Electrical Room

Elevator

Elevator Lobby

Fire Corridor

1

PARK CREST TWO

GRANT PARK

>

03

X

O

2!

w

•fl

Grant Piric

I

StatiweU

Elevator $l»ft

Fire t sefvlce corridor

Residential cofTldor

undercenstnictlen

TW Pirk Cmt

Lesard Onlgn Inc.

HUMPHREYS v. LESSARO EXPERT REPORT

I

LEGEND

Year occupied:

Aidiltect:

Project:

I
Oefendint

Arehfiect:
Himiphreyt &Pirtmn
Year occupied:
20(M

Plilntlff

80

«

amtfuctkn
TOwiji. ihtttAlM rwJsfrf^ff/tS/20ll, Inwdpntpi,

tonje •IVm Park Crest

Plans overlaid.
Blue • Grant Park

P«vn apartments

Grant Park; 22V

Sevenuen apartments

TVw Park Cresf 236'11"

Mumphrtft b farmtrs, A/eNttctt.

Adofittdfor /UuitrMlon from Cratt PerkAwer (ppyifsMdtpotlt <(niwln|,

$
c

✓

ridor

Stairwells adjacent to

✓

1

Unit Entry

Fire / service corridor

core

Residential elevator

Exaggerated roof overhang**

emphasis

LEGEND

✓

✓

vertical bays and vertical

Diagonal corridors (n units

Eicteriorwith alternating

✓

elevators

Barbell shape of circulation*

around elevator lobbies

Residential units arranged

✓

✓

Ttoh and utility In Arecor

Are corridor

Elevator lobbies connected by

✓

✓

High-rise
Multiple elevator cores

✓

FEATUIIES explicit In cwTptalnt

2004

Architects

Grant P«r*
Humphreys ft hrtnen.

Yev occupied:

Project:
Architect:

4I.M rrrittd WWlOlt, LetttnlOtilfi. Inc.

A*pttdfar HbMtaHen fnm Twofork Cmt <w

I ; assga

wtng»t she

3^i>a>,

ZMT.-ll

Figure 9

Elevator lobbies connected by

✓

✓

✓

LECENO

UnttEmiy

Service elevator

Fire / service ODrridor

core

Itejidentlal elevator

Btaggerated roof overhang**

emphasis

Diagonalcorridors in units
Exterior with alternating
vertical bays and vertical

✓

elevators

Barbell shape of circulation'

Stairwells adjacent to

around elevator lobbies

Residential units arranged

ridor

Ttasii and utility In Arecor

✓

✓

✓

Multipleelevator cores

✓

Are corridor

High-rise

✓

Lcssard Oe>l|n Inc.
Under construction

Architect:

"TWo l»»rk Crwt

Year occupied:

Project:

APPENDIX C: ASSERTED FEATURE 1
A HIGH-RISE RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

Dkt. 296 at 12, Lessard Reply Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. H Figure 11.

••I
a:
t

00

I

II

APPENDIX D: ASSERTED FEATURE 2

TWO ELEVATOR CORES CONNECTED BY A FIRE OR SERVICE CORRIDOR

Dkt. 192-1 at 7,Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo, See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.
RIgM Elavator LoDUm:

)

Vestibule and flK door

Grant Park

Park Crest Two

Dkts. 219-2 to219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report ("Gresham Report") Ex. HFigure 7.

XI

APPENDIX E: ASSERTED FEATURE 3

DIRECT ACCESS FROM THE RESIDENTIAL UNITS TO AN ELEVATOR LOBBY

Dkt. 192-1 at 9, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3, 6-7, and 13.

Grant Park

Park Crest Two

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. HFigures 8and 9.

5

Xll

APPENDIX F: ASSERTED FEATURE 4
A BARBELL-SHAPED FLOOR PLAN

Dkt. 192-1 at 9, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo; Dktl 296 at 13, Lessard Reply Memo. See
Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.

Grant Park

Park Crest Two

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. HFigure 7,
TWo Park Crest; 236' 11"
Seventeen apartmcnto

Grant Parit: 221'

Eleven apartments

Plans overlaid.
Blue s Grant Park

Orange aTwo Park Crest

XIII

APPENDIX G: ASSERTED ELEMENT 5

A MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL ROOM SPACE AT ONE END OF THE SERVICE CORRIDOR
AND A TRASH CHUTE AT THE OTHER END

Dkt. 192-1 at 10, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.

3

Mechanlcal/Electriul

Trash Chute

•Mechanical/Electrical

Trash Chute

Service Corridor

Service Corridor

Park Crest Two

Grant Park

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. H Figure 9.

aSQB

I#

xiv

APPENDIX H: ASSERTED FEATURE 6
EXIT STAIRWELLS ADJACENT TO THE ELEVATORS

Dkt. 192-1 at 11, Lessaixl Opening NoninfHngement Memo. See Humphreys Coip. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7;ai,dlI

Grant Park

Park Crest Two

XV

APPENDIX I: ASSERTED FEATURE 7
CORNER UNITS WITH DIAGONAL ENTRY ACCESS

Dkt. 192-1 at 12, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.
balcony

Grant Park

Park Crest Two

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. H Figures 8 and 9.

F*

•"ft.!,

xvi

APPENDIX J: ASSERTED FEATURE 8
ALTERNATING VERTICAL ELEMENTS

Dkt. 192-1 at 7, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.

IP HI

Grant Park

m

Park Crest Two

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive Expert Report Ex. HFigure 10.

a'

. trt VSkHmQc' '.I •nf'- itj lE ii^

I-' li,

'11

It

1WM i

m

Ut
>i JiV'i iicJ

If s i

,0

It

ygissq rj rfiEDK" it
iVH-LC'iI B! jSulHlTfr- •
r«^;ti£i.i;
iuETv'jVi:, '1 niaara"
ct

-ii

IIBH 11 BBpiiIti
K
B

A

C

Vcftlcal tnautnj li vluially divided m thirdt. and can
read as a paucfn of five iccttom. <A BCB Aoi ASCBAI

B

C

A

i:

!1

C B

VbttKal mastinj ii vltualiy divided m (hirdi, and can
be read at a pattern of tevcn se<tlom^ (CBC A CBC.
orCBCACKl

GRANT PARK

TWO PARK CREST

XVI1

C

APPENDIX K: ASSERTED FEATURE 9

PROJECTING ELEMENTS AT THE CORNICE OF THE ROOF LINE

Dkt. 192-1 at 13, Lessard Opening Noninfringement Memo. See Humphreys Corp. Dep. Ex. Nos. 3,6-7, and 13.

P%rk Crest iwo

Grant Park

OontPark

Park Oeit Two

Dkts. 219-2 to 219-8, Gresham Responsive ExpertReport Ex. H Figure 12.
Fifur# 12

FroAt EI«vAtien

TWO FARK CREST

xvni